Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Construction Under Tech -- Info Flows About this episode with Greg Lynn (@greglynnform), Gina Neff (@ginasue), Tracy Young (@Tracy_Young), and Hanne Tidnam (@omnivorousread)
Construction has been one of the industries most resistant to innovation and change over the last decades -- productivity has actually decreased there while it has risen in other industries around it. So how are new technologies (finally!) beginning to transform the most brick-and-mortar of all the (literally!) brick-and-mortar industries?
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Hi and welcome to the A16Z Podcast. I'm Hannah and this episode is part of our series on construction. This conversation includes Tracy Young, co-founder and CEO of PlanGrid, Greg Lynn, architect, professor at UCLA and co-founder at Piaggio Fast Forward, and Gina Neff, sociologist at Oxford University, who works on how new technology helps architects, engineers, and construction professionals collaborate. Given that this is one of these industries that are literally brick and mortar and has tended to be less obviously impacted right away by these new technologies, we wanted to get into what is happening, how tech is beginning to make an impact, how we think about the challenges in architecture and construction as an industry, the way information flows and coordination happens, and how technology is beginning to improve that flow.
0:43 Speaker 00 I want to start by asking you guys about the basic tools. Are they still the same?
0:49 Speaker 01 So in 2007, as a rookie engineer working on my first construction project, I was issued one of these tablet PCs. They were like ruggedized laptops. And so the innovation at the time was running Microsoft Excel through these like seven-pound tablet PCs in the field, just to track issues.
1:09 Speaker 00 To track issues that would come up as construction was going on.
1:12 Speaker 01 Yes. And a seven-pound laptop is not that easy to carry in the field for over half an hour. I remember my superintendent buying me the strap that goes around your head and attaches to the laptop so that you can just like crouch over to carry it better. So, you know, it's 10 years later and obviously the hardware has changed. And because of that, companies can be building software specific for our project manager, trying to access the information to build these projects in the field.
1:39 Speaker 02 There's been so much rapid technology change in how buildings are visualized and how these visualizations get shared. The idea behind building information modeling was to create a shared information space that architects, engineers, and builders could rapidly exchange files and they would be Interoperable. I like to make the analogy of working together on a writing project in Microsoft Word or in Google Doc as opposed to sharing locked PDFs by email. And sadly, in the construction industry, that kind of shared information space isn't developing as fast as we might see. The technology is certainly there. It's the
2:18 Speaker 02 legal, regulatory, and history of the industry that makes companies very slow to change. One of the things we noticed around 2008, 2009 is that the technology was bringing the people who plan construction and design projects closer together, but organizationally, they were still very far apart.
2:40 Hanne Tidnam? You mean like behind the scenes, you know, planning in other offices?
2:44 Speaker 02 Absolutely. So the planning for the detailed construction, especially of the mechanical, electrical plumbing systems, happens in construction trailers near or close to the site. And so there would be the ways in which these systems could come into closer coordination for planning. And general contractors are using building information modeling to coordinate the work that people do. And yet, what was happening in a day-to-day process was often those construction plans weren't being able to be shared quickly with people in the field. They couldn't quickly adapt them in those settings. They were still having to go through many layers of bureaucracy through many different companies in order to get changes made.
3:28 Hanne Tidnam? And what was the difficulty in sharing that information stemming from?
3:32 Speaker 04 If you look at a construction site with a time-lapse camera, it's the most insane organization you could ever imagine to try to turn into a vertical streamlined process.
3:46 Hanne Tidnam? You mean to actually watch a building be made
3:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
3:49 Hanne Tidnam? over time, from a pile of dirt to...
3:51 Speaker 04 Between the logistics of machines coming to the site, goods arriving just in time, everything ready to be installed. It's an incredible logistical problem, and it's not happening in a factory setting. And what happened in architecture is a lot of tools were invented by architects, tools from the aerospace industry, in particular, Revit and BIM. Were adopted to allow people to collaborate on a joint three dimensional file. So every screw, every bolt can be described not just as a form or a shape, but also what its weight is, what its cost is, where it's coming from, who's responsible to deliver it, who's responsible to install it. So what architects and engineers and everybody will do is you'll write
4:34 Speaker 04 the equivalent of a performance spec for another industry. So you'll convert everything from three dimensional files, which are very robust and very sophisticated now, into two dimensional drawings or into two dimensional documents.
4:50 Hanne Tidnam? And is that what the blueprint is essentially?
4:52 Speaker 04 It's a stock and trade, but it has nothing to do with reality. I mean, you never build off of a plan or section. Really, you use it as a performance spec to measure dimension.
5:02 Hanne Tidnam? It's simplifying it.
5:03 Speaker 01 3D model is hard to consume. It's too much information and the software just isn't in place to easily consume it in the field. For a sheet model person, all they need to know is that their duck work is a 10 inch round duck work and it's eight feet off finish floor and they're going to hang their duck work. They don't need to see a model to do their work.
5:22 Speaker 02 Although the modeling in the coordination's been very successful, right? You know, you can make a really rich visualization or a really rich model and still people are lacking the contextual information of what went into these decisions. So the sites that we observed, teams were continually going back and looking at decisions that had been made in months beforehand. But because there weren't people there in the room who could tell them why that decision was there. And so when you're looking at a drawing or a specification, you know, I think this goes almost in any industry that there's only so much that we can expect from large scale information models and databases. What I think is really interesting in the construction industry is,
6:06 Speaker 02 you know, we bring up every bolt can be modeled in 3D modeling, but you know, the killer app for building information modeling really has been coordinating your plumbing work and your heating and air conditioning work so they don't collide within the building system.
6:23 Hanne Tidnam? Matching it all up, this huge amount of data, but without context or history.
6:27 Speaker 04 What you start to see is a lot of people now modeling process, construction process and logistical processes. But when that steel beam arrives and when that... Sheet metal duct has to go through a webbing. And when the lighting comes in, and then when the sheet rock encloses the ceiling, that whole process is captured occasionally in a specification.
6:49 Hanne Tidnam? Okay.
6:49 Speaker 04 Performance spec.
6:50 Hanne Tidnam? So the flow of labor and everything coordinating.
6:53 Speaker 01 It's not even in the spec. It's in the superintendent's schedule that changes from week to week because everything is always delayed.
6:59 Hanne Tidnam? So it's basically in somebody's brain.
7:01 Speaker 01 In several people's brains. Coming into the industry in 2007, where BIM wasn't as adopted in the US, we did something called light table coordination, which is this giant light box with a piece of glass where it shines through, and you put paper over it. Then you layer on the mechanical drawings and the plumbing drawings and the structural drawings on top of it.
7:22 Hanne Tidnam? Physically, physically layering them.
7:23 Speaker 01 In a room with like 12 other people to see like, okay.
7:28 Hanne Tidnam? So how is this actually going to match up?
7:29 Speaker 01 We are going to play Tetris.
7:31 Hanne Tidnam? Yeah.
7:31 Speaker 01 Because we're going to make all these systems fit. And so it's an awful, awful process.
7:35 Hanne Tidnam? Did that work?
7:36 Speaker 01 Thousands of hours of coordination of just trying to make these systems fit together because there's so little space overhead. And so what BIM does is eliminate that entire light table process and make it fit in the model. The infuriating part with light tables is someone would always bump into those drawings, at which point everything would scatter and it's like, oh, God, here Bob goes again.
7:59 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, my gosh.
7:59 Speaker 01 And then you have to realign it.
8:00 Hanne Tidnam? That's incredible.
8:01 Speaker 01 On one of the projects I was on, the owner paid something like $14 million for us to essentially play Tetris inside the model. We went into the field and the inspectors came out and said, hey, look at my stamp, look at my signature. It's on the 2D set of drawings. It is not in this model.
8:20 Hanne Tidnam? So how are the tools in your industry being used now in the construction process?
8:24 Speaker 04 The state of the field right now is that by developing some tools and borrowing some from aerospace, the collaboration between engineers, architects, building owners and all of the constituents is fairly integrated. The ability to cost and plan and logistically scope, construction is pretty good. It's the minute you get all the entities that go into a building, which is a very flat structure, from medieval people digging holes in the ground to sophisticated robotic factories making curtain walls, and try to bring that all into a site in a timely way. It is less efficient now than it was in 1960.
9:06 Speaker 04 Because on the front end, we're very sophisticated and drawing in very detailed ways, three dimensional models.
9:13 Hanne Tidnam? So there's a real disconnect.
9:13 Speaker 04 Down to the screw. And on the job site, you've got this mix of people, some of which are using phones, some are still using drawings, some are, you know, working on 3D files on trailers. And honestly, the waste has increased and the schedules have increased.
9:27 Hanne Tidnam? Yeah, the gaps in timing and the workflow must be.
9:30 Speaker 04 Buildings are delivered later now than they were in 1960 and more over budget than they were in 1960. Because of this problem of getting those two things together.
9:38 Speaker 02 One of the things that we saw were teams of coordinators who are helping to design and plan the systems that are going into buildings. And the real ingenuity and innovation that they would have, they were really problem solvers. And the frustration they would face when they came up with a time-saving idea or a cost-saving idea, getting it through the levels of approval was so frustrating for them. Because even if they got approval from the general contractor, it would still have to go through multi-layers of engineering and architectural approval in order to get them information. So that's partly why we saw the technology more tightly coupling the work teams together,
10:22 Speaker 02 but making them organizationally really quite separate from the rest of the project.
10:26 Hanne Tidnam? And that sounds like what you were talking about, Tracy, with in terms of the inspector coming in, right? Like, then you come up against this archaic, well, is it archaic, the way that cities inspect? How does that tack on to this?
10:37 Speaker 01 So by and large, the whole world has figured out how to increase labor productivity, except for construction, as Greg touched upon. We are less productive today than we were 20 years ago, than we were 60 years ago. And it's completely unbelievable.
10:52 Hanne Tidnam? And strangely enough, it's like by, because of the innovation in a weird way.
10:56 Speaker 01 It's complicated. So the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics has written like an 84-page study on this. And then basically, the summary is, it's complicated, the data's bad, regulations are part of it, the people are part of it, because the construction involves just so many different entities. We're talking about tens of thousands of different material suppliers are part of this process. And then another 50 construction entities, from the general contractors to electricians, to the plumbers, to the drywall folks. And then on top of that, their counterparts on the engineering and design side. And when so many different parties are involved and communication needs to happen. And meanwhile, regulations changing.
11:40 Speaker 01 It's just this incredibly broken process, which requires so much managers just making sure that coordination is happening, making sure that the schedule is going to work, making sure that things are getting delivered on time, on schedule. And there hasn't been software to help with this process until very recently. There's certainly been project management software that's existed for the last 16, 30 years, but the hardware didn't exist to support the folks in the field. So any software that was used in this space until 2010, when the iPad was first introduced to the market.
12:17 Hanne Tidnam? Were on straps around their necks.
12:19 Speaker 01 Exactly. It was either on straps, which is rare, or they're in the office where most of the people are not.
12:26 Speaker 04 When it used to be 150 drawing set for a $100 million building was kind of a lot. And now you would expect 1,000 drawings. So it's like these poor builders are just drinking out of a fire hose because they're used to maybe not so much information, but the right information.
12:47 Hanne Tidnam? Very different information flow and content.
12:49 Speaker 04 And now there's just so much information that goes into a document that what to use is really difficult.
12:54 Speaker 01 It's even more than that. We're the largest digital blueprint repository in the world. On a $150 million project in the Bay Area, we have seen 15,000 sheets of blueprints. Can you imagine trying to take 15,000 sheets of blueprints into the field?
13:08 Hanne Tidnam? Is it useful information? Is it all useful, meaningful information?
13:12 Speaker 01 As builders, your job is to translate these documents and these specs into physical structure. So yes.
13:20 Hanne Tidnam? So is it all just an information management problem right now? Is that the crux of what's going on? Or are there ways in which we're starting to see that information get better managed or other tools that are coming up?
13:30 Speaker 04 I think a couple of things that are very interesting solutions. One, which is mature robotics in order to go direct to fabrication with machines.
13:40 Hanne Tidnam? Obviously, part of that might be because of the coordination and the data processing aspect of it, yes, that those that robots can understand that level of information that We're not used to drinking from the fire hose from.
13:52 Speaker 04 Certain parts of the building process, there aren't so many options or manufacturers. And so you'll see a company that's building curtain walls and they'll have some stock extrusions. Everything's always custom, but it's all coming from a easily quantified process.
14:10 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
14:10 Speaker 04 So if you introduce robots into that fabrication in a factory setting.
14:15 Hanne Tidnam? Yeah.
14:15 Speaker 04 And you get the architects and engineers to talk to those robots, then you get easy to plan, easy to cost solution.
14:22 Hanne Tidnam? And can you just describe what the robots are physically doing and where they fit into that workflow?
14:27 Speaker 04 Well, the construction industry has been an industry for a while. So there have been industrial processes where machines for welding, cutting, extruding, would have numerical control associated with them. They would tend to do the same thing over and over, but with better quality computation, you can start to get more and more fineness into that process. But it goes from steel industry, glass, wood, almost every trade. They're working now with masonry and concrete. 60% of projects built in Switzerland use robotics at some significant level in the construction process. And it's for a lot of reasons. Partially, the mortgages in Switzerland tend to be 50 to 70 years.
15:11 Speaker 04 So construction budgets are about double. So you can innovate and save more money there. But there, it's the most robotic construction industry on earth is in Switzerland per capita.
15:22 Hanne Tidnam? And what have they seen that do to jobs?
15:24 Speaker 04 Well, higher skilled robotics jobs, but more and more of the buildings are built in factories and delivered as kind of mega components. The real bottleneck is what can you get on a road or on a train or on a boat? There's an Austrian kid that just has been teaching a computer to see bathroom plans.
15:43 Speaker 04 And has been training it the same way we're training our robots to see people and bicycles. He's been training a robot to see bathroom plans. It's kind of the first job everybody gets out of graduate school is laying out bathrooms.
15:55 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, really? That's hilarious. I did not know that. Because there's not that many options in a bathroom. Is that the idea?
16:00 Speaker 04 So you just draw an 11 foot 3 by 7 foot 6 rectangle and it'll lay out a bathroom for you. It's the kind of thing you would probably want to train a robot to do. Unless you really care about the layout of your bathroom. You want to innovate in that space.
16:12 Speaker 01 Or prefabrication, right? Because it takes somewhere between 10 to 20 different subcontractors that touches a bathroom. Which is crazy, right? You only think of like, you know, maybe the plumbers. But there's the concrete subcontractor. There's a mechanical subcontractor, the electricians, the plumbers, the drywall folks, the painters, the fixture installers, et cetera. Bathrooms typically are this common room, like there's one design and then it gets repeated over and over and over in the building, which makes it the perfect thing to manufacture offsite and then bring in. And we're seeing a lot of our contractors and customers working together offsite because they can control the schedule.
16:50 Hanne Tidnam? Interesting.
16:51 Speaker 01 They can fabricate 20 of these things and then drop it into the building and then gain two weeks in the schedule versus trying to get one scope done at a time and then sequencing everyone in.
17:01 Speaker 02 You know, we don't think of them this way, but Disney builds cities. And I was able to visit their building research facility in Shanghai. And they're thinking about the ways in which, how do you understand heat generation on a block scale? How do you understand water? How do you understand waste? And what kind of systems could you build if you were not thinking of the units of analysis as individual, commercial, residential homes?
17:30 Hanne Tidnam? Because they're doing it in one fell swoop, right? It's not over two centuries. How is that vision of how we build that city changing?
17:39 Speaker 02 If we really want to take seriously the challenges facing the future of the planet, we're going to need to think both about how we reduce consumption, but also how we be really smart in the production of the future of our buildings and our cities. The construction industry is so large. It is such an enormous part of American GDP that small improvements in energy output, small improvements in efficiency end up having enormous implications. Hospitals alone are 15% of.
18:12 Speaker 02 Energy greenhouse gas production in the United States.
18:16 Hanne Tidnam? So what are some of the ways that you're starting to see that happen? Some of the cool tools that we're going to start seeing?
18:22 Speaker 01 This is why we wake up every morning. Construction accounts for 13% of global output. Literally, one out of every 10 people in the world eat, sleep, and breathe construction every single day. We're focusing on the human factors. Builders frankly spend a lot of time not building. They're trying to find information. They're duplicating work by transcribing their notes that are written on paper over to whatever they're using to track these issues. The cloud exists. Mobile devices exist. Computing power can be taken out to the field with a battery life that lasts all day on a device that's super lightweight that doesn't weigh seven pounds. And so we look at every other industry and we think about,
19:06 Speaker 01 how did the rest of the world find this massive increase in labor productivity? And one of the main reasons is they started using computing power to do their jobs better. And construction couldn't benefit from that until very recently.
19:18 Speaker 04 When you think of a robot on a construction site, you think of an autonomous bulldozer or an autonomous backhoe or a crane that's able to drop goods at a specific time, a specific place. And all those things exist. There's a finer grain with how you move there. And you move on a scooter or a bike or a motorcycle rather than a car. And that's just because you don't need two tons of steel to carry a couple of gallons of milk. You could do that on an electric bicycle. So a finer grain approach to movement and mobility is also happening, I think, on construction sites at the scale of wheelbarrows, forklifts.
20:00 Hanne Tidnam? Instead of these giant cats.
20:02 Speaker 04 Exactly. Like if you're in a factory, what drives a factory are these little things called point-of-use carts. And if you're just screwing things together with an electric screw gun, the screws just show up when you need them on these little carts.
20:16 Hanne Tidnam? Right, ready to go.
20:17 Speaker 04 If we can take that scale of construction to construction sites and have things queued outside the city that come into a site at just the right time. They're not there early, they're not there too late, and they get to the person that's doing the work. We think that scale of innovation is very ripe right now for development. We call them land drones. Anytime in a factory, you take something overhead in a gantry. You have to shut down the whole factory. When a crane is lifting heavy stuff.
20:46 Hanne Tidnam? Because you're using that airspace so much.
20:48 Speaker 04 So littler things on the ground that can help, you know, deliver things when you need them and deliver goods and help you build in an efficient way. I think it's very interesting.
20:58 Hanne Tidnam? Are we seeing that kind of scale play out in textures too? Or materials? How are we thinking about finer grained things or different ways of using materials in that part of the process?
21:07 Speaker 04 So one of the heroes of lightweight construction was Buckminster Fuller, who said that you should judge the quality of every building by how much it weighs.
21:18 Hanne Tidnam? Oh, my gosh.
21:20 Speaker 04 And it really does work. If you want to save money, if you want to save time, and if you want to build more efficiently for the environment, just weigh what you're building. In every other industry, you'd want to have lighter, faster, stronger. So if you take a tall building, the biggest load on the building is it bending in the wind. It's actually not how it's carrying a load down.
21:42 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
21:43 Speaker 04 It's how much load is up in the air. If you can take 10,000 tons of steel out of the top of a building and replace it with carbon fiber, it's better. You're saving tons and tons and tons of material and also saving a lot of time. And you can move that stuff more easily. And people can actually lift it without machines. And so.
22:04 Hanne Tidnam? So it trickles down in all sorts of ways, the cost savings.
22:07 Speaker 04 It's a very simple principle. It's just build light, like be efficient. And even use exotic materials that might not seem like they're sustainable. Because actually, if you just use a little bit of them, like plastics, and instead of throwing them away in a cup, build them into the built environment.
22:24 Hanne Tidnam? When I was in high school, I had a brief internship with Michael Graves. And I remember Michael Graves used PVC columns to make these kind of like pillar-like, you know, these Italian Renaissance-y looking things. There was PVC tubing.
22:37 Speaker 04 He was a big collector of Bakelite. We both shared a love of plastics. But no, like brick, which you think of as a natural, good material, is the worst thing you can build with because you have to fire it with all this energy. You have to truck it. It's heavy. Trying to get weighed out with the little vehicles, you want to save energy, just make them lighter. Because you don't have to move as much stuff. You know, with your batteries or with your gasoline engines, make it lighter is really the first thing to do before you do anything else. Then, things get put together faster, you can move bigger pieces. Everything gets stronger because it's consolidated. And it's happening more and more that composites and things from the 1960s,
23:19 Speaker 04 high-performance boats and airplanes are now starting to show up on job sites. It's again, a problem of getting it permitted and fireproof. And there's, there's some obstacles there. But it's a, it's a very interesting space of innovation right now.
23:33 Hanne Tidnam? So we've talked a lot about sort of coordination and information flow, and then about physical movement. But what about these visual technologies that are changing how we see things or changing how we can model and imagine them with like AR? How is that changing the workflow or the coordination or the construction or the imagination, all of it?
23:51 Speaker 02 No one thinks in 2D plans and specifications. A blueprint is not a natural language for anybody. You can put a blueprint in front of three different people and they're going to see three very different things. And when you have new kinds of visualizations, suddenly you have new kinds of clarity around what people are seeing and what the problems are. The kinds of tools that we're talking about here that, you know, are at the forefront of construction and design really offer that opportunity for more creativity at the point of the problem.
24:25 Speaker 01 Something that always gets specked into larger projects, let's say anything over $50 million or more, is the concept of a mock-up room. They'll take the most common rooms, let's say bathrooms or in a hospital exam rooms, and they'll build a physical template of it called a mock-up.
24:43 Hanne Tidnam? That you can walk into to scale.
24:44 Speaker 01 That you can walk in and what they'll do is bring the end doctors and nurses in to confirm.
24:49 Hanne Tidnam? And especially for hospitals, right? That's notoriously difficult design problem into a hospital room because there's so much.
24:56 Speaker 01 Right. There's ergonomics, there's like, everything needs to be in the right place.
25:00 Hanne Tidnam? The machines, where people move in them, yeah.
25:01 Speaker 01 And so, these mock-ups are physical and they cost a lot of money. And more often than not,
25:07 Hanne Tidnam? And time.
25:07 Speaker 01 They'll build them off of the side of the construction site. And then, once everyone approves it and signs off on it, they'll just demolish it. Wouldn't it be nice if we could just put on a headset and then see it and have the building owner or these doctors and nurses walk through it in the model, confirm, this is exactly where I want these medical equipments, and then call it a day?
25:25 Speaker 04 When for me, what underlies all of these technologies is a very simple concept that is localization. Whether it's the new iPhone or an autonomous car, what they're all doing is building a three-dimensional map and simultaneously locating that camera inside that three-dimensional space.
25:45 Hanne Tidnam? Yeah.
25:45 Speaker 04 And so it's not so much about the autonomy of a vehicle being able to get to the place. It's that there's a three-dimensional map and everything in that map has a sense of where it is.
25:54 Hanne Tidnam? Yeah.
25:55 Speaker 04 So if you put on a hollow lens, you can suddenly see that's where my duck needs to go. You get to see where something is supposed to be in space localized.
26:04 Hanne Tidnam? You know where it is.
26:05 Speaker 04 And that's huge for the construction industry. And it's also huge to know that the machines you're using are seeing the same thing in the same way that you are. So suddenly, the workers can now work with the robots where to put all the screws in the drywall. And a red dot turns to green when that's where you're supposed to put the screw in to hang the drywall. And then you record it and send it to the inspector and they know that you're the one that put those screws in on that schedule like you're supposed to in the specification. But it's a real collaboration between robotics and people in a way that you're not replacing them in a factory somewhere, but you're bringing that level of technology onto a job site that's...
26:43 Hanne Tidnam? Well, you're projecting that light table, basically, and seeing through it, right? That those layers...
26:48 Speaker 01 It's definitely the future. And construction is this industry that has to be obsessive over safety. Every single job site in all of US will have a billboard on the gates of their job site with the number of days since the last safety incident.
27:03 Hanne Tidnam? Right.
27:04 Speaker 01 And one of the challenges with these new devices that are wearable on your face is that OSHA's not okay with it.
27:10 Hanne Tidnam? What are the objections to it and how does regulation need to change?
27:14 Speaker 01 These glasses that I have, just regular old glasses, I have to have these like plastic clips that go on the side just for me to walk into a job site because they're not safety glasses. It's very bureaucratic and slow. And so most of the codes don't change for like seven to 10 years at a time. And then there's a lot of interpretation that goes on. So it's gonna be challenging. But with that said, there's easy wins, right? Like digitizing of information. There's this massive correlation between an industry's ability to digitize their information and this massive increase in labor productivity. And when you walk into a job site, even on projects that are paperless, we still see paper. It's crazy.
27:51 Speaker 04 The real question is, though, who's incentivized in all these stakeholders? If it's agriculture, that's a vertical industry now. If it's mining, that's a vertical industry now. So there's an incentive. Whereas in the construction industry, the 30% waste and the, you know, 20% of late schedule, it's baked in from the finance all the way down to the smallest subcontractor. So who in that chain is gonna go ahead and develop the AR device that's OSHA certified? And why?
28:25 Speaker 01 It's true. It's construction is an industry that there's a reason why they're slow to adopt technology because their margins are so slim. The top construction firms, the ones who employ over 10,000 field workers, hire only 5% of all builders. Whereas in services or manufacturing, the top firms, they're employing like 25% of the industry. So what that means is in construction, it is ran and built by a lot of regional, small, mom and pop contractors who are all competing against each other. So their margins for a general contractor are something like 1% to 3%. That's incredibly low. What other industries has such slim margins? Restaurant is probably the next one, and even that's like 10% to 15%.
29:09 Speaker 01 So because margins are so slim, there's not like this bankroll of cash in the bank where they can invest in technology to do their jobs better. It's easier for the industry to hire more workers. And then if things aren't going well, to fire them than to make this capital investment on new technologies.
29:29 Speaker 02 Do you think this level of consolidation is gonna change in the construction industry? I mean, here we have an industry that has a very old way of doing it. There's several very large players in the industry, you know, transnational, multi-billion dollar companies. And yet, when people want a solution, a building solution delivered,
29:54 Speaker 02 They often have to go and get multiple pieces of that. I mean, think about any other product that we want to buy. We want an automobile, an airplane. We actually don't go and contract the designer, the engineer, and the builder, the manufacturer, together, right? We ask for the thing itself. And, you know, when some of these technologies were first emerging, you know, people were talking about the fact that a large-scale manufacturing concern might really integrate and deliver integrated solutions. Do you think that's possible?
30:25 Speaker 04 In certain totalitarian countries with high labor costs, like Singapore, the Emirates, there's an incredible investment in innovation in construction. And that includes materials, like building in carbon fiber. Like, the Apple headquarters was all built in Dubai because they built a facility to build carbon fiber at the scale of buildings there. It's high labor cost and they could permit everything and make it legal because it's, you know, you just ask one person and it's all smooth. Other than that, I think it's very grassroots. And most of the action, which there's a lot of, is smaller companies that are innovating
31:06 Speaker 04 little chunks in terms of getting robots onto construction sites, making vehicles smart, solving this whole problem of a high-fidelity 3D model, delivering it to a construction site. There are a lot of small players doing things.
31:22 Speaker 01 Construction is the infrastructure of this world. And if we're unable to figure out how to solve this productivity problem, we'll be unable to deliver the infrastructure that this world needs, not in the next 15 years, in the next decade.
31:36 Speaker 02 It's really important that we get this right because the building sector in the United States accounts for 55, 0% of energy consumption in the US.
31:49 Speaker 02 And so if we can make even small improvements in the efficiency, both in the construction process and in buildings themselves, we can have a huge impact on the future of the planet. The way to do that is to bring these kinds of innovative solutions into the point of the problems that are faced in construction and allow for more creative and energy efficient design to happen at lower costs.
32:11 Speaker 04 It might be that we don't look to the biggest engineering and infrastructure companies to innovate. It might be that we look at, you know, somebody in eastern Washington state doing amazing things with timber construction that's sustainable, fast, affordable, and very high tech. And that's kind of where the action is. And I think also in scale, focusing on the little things from hand tools to
32:35 Hanne Tidnam? Wheelbarrows.
32:36 Speaker 04 to wheelbarrows is also where a lot of the action is. So I think we focused on like the big global, you know, industrial problem at big scale. And it might be in the construction industry, you've got to actually shift if you want to make an impact
32:51 Hanne Tidnam? And go small.
32:52 Speaker 04 to finer. Yeah.
32:53 Hanne Tidnam? Thank you guys so much for joining us on the A16Z podcast.
32:56 Speaker 04 Thanks.
32:56 Hanne Tidnam? Thank you.
32:57 Speaker 02 Thank you.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated October 9, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated