Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | Blockchain vs/and Bitcoin About this episode Blockchain without bitcoin? It's a debate as old as the cryptocurrency itself (which, to be honest, isn't that old). Given that bitcoin is not just a digital bearer instrument/token but is a network, a distributed ledger, a protocol, the question of separating blockchain from bitcoin isn't a moot one. Especially when you think of it analogously to voice over IP, but for financial services.
So what is the financial services industry doing with this "money over IP"? Clearly many large business players are paying attention and trying to get ahead of disruption, by asking themselves exactly what their bitcoin/blockchain strategy is. Adam Ludwin shares what's happening here from his perspective as founder of Chain, an enterprise blockchain platform that partners with financial institutions to help them apply the technology to their markets.
In this episode of the a16z Podcast, Ludwin covers what it's like merging the cultures of finance and tech; what's driving the recent bitcoin prices; why he believes in blockchain beyond bitcoin; whether there can be such a thing as private or permissioned blockchains; definitions of newer concepts like 'colored coins' and 'sidechains'; and more. Oh and what are the most interesting native apps, too.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 2 Welcome to the A16Z podcast. Sonal and I are sitting here with Adam Ludwin. Adam, welcome. Thank
0:07 Speaker 0 you.
0:07 Speaker 2 Adam is one of the co-founders of Chain. And you guys are a blockchain technology provider to large financial institutions. And right there, I think this is interesting because you're not a Bitcoin provider. You're not sort of involved in that ecosystem in the same way at least. So let's launch into blockchain and Bitcoin and where we are today and what the distinction is and how those two things are being applied in the marketplace.
0:36 Speaker 0 Sure. Well, Bitcoin was the first uh fully functioning digital asset the world has ever seen. And a digital asset is one that is minted, created uh natively at the outset as a digital token. Uh so a Bitcoin is a digital bearer token. Uh and a bearer token is something that where the ownership of that asset is defined by whoever has it in the moment. So whoever bears it. Right. So if I have a dollar bill and I hand it to Sonal, uh, there's no question of who owns that dollar. She now owns it. Uh, but with digital, uh, the way digital financial services work is that what actually we do for the most part, with whether it's credit cards or sending securities on an exchange, uh, trading securities, we actually send messages saying, I'm gonna give you my asset.
1:22 Speaker 0 And then later there's some settlement process. So if you're a merchant who takes credit cards, you know this because you don't get the money right away. You get the money right away with cash, but you don't get the money right away with a credit card. If you trade on a stock exchange as an institution, those securities don't settle right away. There's some risk that happens afterwards. It's a question of is there going to be a settlement or not? And we all pay for that. So what Bitcoin did before anyone else or any other instrument is it really created the first digital bearer token where I could just send you Bitcoin over the internet. And as soon as I hit send, uh the recipient has it. And now there's a record of that ownership of who bears that token at that moment on the network on the blockchain, which is the ledger for uh for keeping track of that.
2:15 Speaker 0 And that's a big deal. Uh it's it's as big a deal as voice over IP. Uh, I think it's a the most close uh comparable to what's happening in this area of technology. Voice over IP, of course, was uh a shift from uh an analog switch line network for moving our voice, which was very expensive and had many interlocking components and uh and of course didn't use the internet as it as the mean, the medium to uh a world where our voice traveled over the internet. Interestingly, with voiceover IP, uh the end user experience wasn't dramatically different at the beginning. You picked up the phone, you dialed grandma, you talked to her, you hung up the phone. Uh you didn't necessarily know or care that the architecture behind the scenes was completely digital.
3:02 Speaker 0 Right. But uh what you cared about was that it was cheaper, uh, that maybe the call clarity was a little bit better, uh, that you didn't have to pay more for long distance. So you get all these features as a result. And the same is now happening in financial services. So we are going to see a shift to uh and totally IP-based internet-based architecture for all sorts of financial services. Um, some like to call Bitcoin or this area of technology, you know, money over IP, which I think is a fairly good analogy. And now there to this debate, this question of is it about Bitcoin or is it about the blockchain? I actually think we could take it a level lower, which is to say, is Bitcoin going to be the only financial instrument that operates in a digital way?
3:49 Speaker 1 No.
3:49 Speaker 0 No. What about gift cards? What about airtime on your mobile phone when you're sending it from one M SMS card to uh to another, or one SIM card rather to another using SMS. What about energy credits on a smart grid? What about stock certificates? So as soon as we start to imagine the world functioning the way Bitcoin functions, but across every other asset class and across every other type of financial instrument, we we begin to think, okay, um, well, maybe we can apply this technology to other things. Um, unless you think Bitcoin is the only uh financial asset the world will ever have in the future, then you can probably start to begin to think about applying blockchain technology elsewhere.
4:30 Speaker 2 And that's it sounds that's exactly what Chain does, correct?
4:33 Speaker 0 That is what Chain does. So we we've taken inspiration from Bitcoin, and we've taken a lot of the fundamental technical architecture from Bitcoin, and we've generalized that to apply to other asset classes. Now, technically, there's a very important difference between, say, a gift card issued by Starbucks that wants to function this way and Bitcoin. And the big difference, I've already sort of pointed to it, is that Starbucks is involved. Starbucks is going to issue that, and you're gonna get it, you're gonna go redeem it at Starbucks. So it's you're not gonna have a decentralized issuance according to a fixed schedule by anonymous miners. Uh it's Starbucks saying, hey, here's a here's 500 Starbucks points, or here's five Starbucks dollars.
5:18 Speaker 0 And you can think of a gift card like a merchant-issued currency. So already we see, okay, well, Bitcoin doesn't actually fit quite well there, perfectly there, because the only way to leverage the Bitcoin network for Starbucks would be to kind of hack the network and layer a Starbucks dollar into the Bitcoin network, which is an approach uh called a colored coin. Uh and the challenge there is again, you're still dependent on the Bitcoin network. And you may not want the Bitcoin network. It's not exactly well suited from a design principle perspective for that use case. So, what might a suitable uh blockchain network look like for Starbucks and other issuers of of these uh merchant currencies or gift cards? So those are the types of starting points that we we begin with.
6:05 Speaker 0 And then our company partners with large institutions. Um, in that case, for example, we're working with first data, and first data is a huge issuer of uh gift and is interested in okay, how do we make how do we evolve the model to make it more efficient and introduce new features and better customer experience using this totally digital format? And uh, and that's what our company does. We partner with these institutions. We uh and then we deploy a network with them that is geared to that asset class. So we're really again trying to take this uh digital asset model that Bitcoin pioneered and apply it across the board.
6:43 Speaker 2 So it's it's well, it's Bitcoin without the Bitcoin. I mean, it's blockchain without the Bitcoin in some cases, or you could have both ways, I suppose, but
6:51 Speaker 0 yeah, yeah, it's not government. You don't, you you may want Bitcoin as a currency token in a particular use case. Um in many cases you you just don't. Um, the the argument that you cannot separate Bitcoin and the blockchain is absolutely both true and false. So the true version of that argument is that when it comes to Bitcoin itself, it will it doesn't work without the entire solution that includes the blockchain, includes decentralization, includes miners. That's how Bitcoin works. Those are the design principles of Bitcoin. Um but as soon as you say, how would we how might we digitize a gift card? How might we digitize a security? How might we digitize a uh a minute on a mobile network? Uh, then the question becomes okay, um, if that's the asset, then already we're not we're assuming we don't need Bitcoin as the asset.
7:42 Speaker 0 So what type of technology or what type of network do we need to deploy to facilitate the movement of those assets?
7:49 Speaker 1 Well, one part, let's pause here for a minute, though, because I do think this is a common misconception. We should spend a moment just really getting to the bottom of it because let's the whole evolution of these networks in the past. The reason a lot of decentralized efforts have never worked is because it's really tough to figure out how to allocate resources, how to get people to keep those resources going, how to actually move things, not just move things around to your point, but also just keep it going and have incentive to keep it going. And so the whole reason that I don't think we can completely disconnect the Bitcoin aspect of blockchain is that the entire system works because people are in center to mine, and those mining resources are what is keeping the entire network going. Yes. It's baked into in the past, we never had that, which is why it's never worked before.
8:35 Speaker 1 It's inherently baked in. Yes.
8:37 Speaker 0 Then Bitcoin is uh an incredibly elegant solution to uh creating a totally decentralized monetary system. And this is why I I like to tell people like Bitcoin is never going to go away. It will Bitcoin will never go away. It will live on for as long as the internet lives on. And the reason for that is as you'd pointed out, there is an economic model uh in the mining process that incentive incents those miners to keep mining. And it works, it's six years old now and it's still humming along, it's improving. Uh, there's a community of developers who are helping to scale the protocol to make it more robust and more secure. And so for those who are interested in either uh not participating in this sort of existing financial system or can't participate in the existing financial system, Bitcoin is very well suited.
9:27 Speaker 0 So take, for example, to this week. So this month, the price of Bitcoin skyrocketed 70%. We're in the middle of a big bull market, right? So it's over 400 now. It was at 200, you know, in the 200s for a long time for the last nine, nine, 10 months. And if you you look at why, the answer to why the Bitcoin price is going up or down is always the same. It's demand because the supply is fixed. So Price is always just a function of demand. So now you have a very simple question. You say, okay, well, where's the demand? And uh there's a great article on Zero Hedge, which did an analysis and and uh basically demonstrated uh very very clearly that the demand in this case is coming from the Chinese who are uh anticipating a currency devaluation, which has been uh announced and in China and are are using Bitcoin as a means to uh circumvent capital controls.
10:19 Speaker 0 So there's a great use case of wanting to be outside of a particular financial system and leverage something that's a lot like gold, but a lot more efficient. It's you don't have to ship it across borders, it's not heavy. You can just use the internet to to store value and move it anywhere else in the world and then get out. So uh Bitcoin will continue to serve those types of use cases where and many more to come, but where you, you know, you want to be essentially in uh outside of the the traditional networks. Um everything in the gray market, uh, which you know, people tend to think, oh, that means you know, Silk Road and the legal activity. Yes, that's inclusive, but everything you do in the cash economy, you could call the gray market.
11:04 Speaker 0 You know, if you if you run a little restaurant, you pay your waiters and your your bell, your uh bus boys under the table, that's gray market activity. It's cash activity. Um they have smartphones, you can do that with Bitcoin now, right? Uh so there's a huge massive cash economy. There's a huge massive number of people who want to be outside the financial system. And there's many people around the world who have smartphones who are not because they want to be, but they are because they live in certain countries outside of the financial system.
11:38 Speaker 1 They're unbanked because there isn't the financial system. Right. But shifting gears for a moment, you mentioned that the core of your business, at least the initial partnerships are with like the Nasdaq and some of the other players you have listed on your website. So what why are they like doing this? It's kind of counterintuitive, actually, because it's almost like they're willingly disrupt willingly disrupting themselves and they don't know that. I mean, they know that, but it'll be interesting to see how that plays out.
12:01 Speaker 0 So we it's a great question. Um we partner with financial institutions who view this as a strategic opportunity. They view this as the there's a market structure change on the horizon where a lot of the entities who are involved in clearing, settling, uh reconciling and uh moving funds uh are going to be disintermediated.
12:30 Speaker 2 So it's is it again that shift from you know IP phones from analog to IP phones or exactly. Okay. It's the
12:36 Speaker 0 same idea. So if money moves over IP and all assets move over IP, we don't actually need uh as uh many of the clearing and settlement functions that we currently use today. Right, because they exist for the fact that we're just you know, today we send digital messages, but then there's a settlement piece after. Well, all that settlement piece after is going away. And by the way, there are big institutions we're partnered with who run who who run networks like Visa and FiServe. They run networks. Uh NASDAQ is a very central part of the capital markets ecosystem. But the reason they've partnered with us is they've recognized that the first to deploy a network uh tends to get you know the lion's share of that opportunity.
13:23 Speaker 0 So networks are like
13:24 Speaker 1 actually saying about the early bird or something. When is it how does it go? The early birds are the
13:28 Speaker 0 early bird gets the network. Is that
13:30 Speaker 1 just saying that
13:34 Speaker 0 you know there's a notion of network effects, winner takes most. And the same is going to be true here because ultimately the solution we're talking about is substituting intermediaries with cryptographic networks. And so the first movers, most of whom are our partners have recognized that if we're going to go and do this, uh it better be our network and we better set the terms and we better bring along the partners and uh and design in a way where we have a seat at the table.
14:02 Speaker 2 So let's just like let's assume that those it's NASDAQ, for example. How do those networks start to look differently and act differently? In the case of telephone and voice, you know, at least for the user, like you say, nothing changed, although uh the the cost of use dropped dramatically, right? Um what what might me we see in this transition?
14:21 Speaker 0 What you'll see in the case of the capital markets is that uh securities and other financial products or assets uh will be issued at the outset as a digital asset, such that when I trade uh on a stock exchange with you, uh I send you I I want to sell one Apple share. You want to buy an Apple share. Uh so I uh I create a transaction on the exchange uh where I include as the output in my transaction that Apple stock. It matches me with someone who uh wants to buy. You uh send a uh a hundred and whatever dollars it it is when this this thing goes live, 115 uh in the other side of the transaction, the private keys, which control those assets, sign the transaction, and then just seconds later, the assets swap and land in our respective custodial accounts, uh again, managed by private keys.
15:18 Speaker 0 So it really looks like a real world transaction where I hold out a stock certificate and you hold out 115, and we each grab the corresponding and then we pull in the opposite direction. Uh and then we're done. Whereas today, again, uh we execute a trade, uh, you don't actually get that stock for a few days. Right. You get the promise of a stock. You get the promise. So that's what'll be different uh behind the scenes. But for the client experience, what will be different is the feature, the bullet points on the marketing brochure are just gonna say, you know, instant settlement, low cost. Uh, you know, the seven dollars for a trade, a lot of that goes to intermediaries along the value chain who are clearing and settling, right?
16:11 Speaker 0 So the the ability to go collapse that to close to zero uh and the ability to buy into more complex financial products where um there's transparency into those products, and it's not lost in all the paperwork and reconciliation that would normally go into a complex financial product will exist. So imagine or what you will see are new products and services, lower cost, uh, and ultimately a more robust and a more transparent financial system and trading platform.
16:45 Speaker 2 You're gonna imagine the same then for credit card fees, et cetera. Um, those things get squeezed in the same way.
16:52 Speaker 0 Yes. I think uh most in general, what we what we envision, you know, over time is a much smaller financial system, actually. Because many of the players in that uh in the financial ecosystem are there because they are helping to uh clear and settle, helping to uh ensure there's no fraud, ensure that identity is uh in line that all the KYCAML stuff is is uh
17:21 Speaker 1 What's the KYCML instead?
17:22 Speaker 0 Know your customer and anti-money laundering, all the all those functions which exist because there's a huge disconnect between a digital request and then the actual movement of funds. Right. Um so we will see a smaller financial market uh uh but one that's much faster, more sophisticated, better suited to customers. The the very long term, and this is sort of controversial, but I don't I don't I think some, but I don't think is, is that central governments will be minting currency this way. So we already have three different forms of a dollar bill today. We have a literally like a dollar note, uh, we have a coinage, right? And we have credit money, where there's there's uh essentially the banking system is used to create funds.
18:08 Speaker 0 Um I think there will be a fourth medium, and that fourth medium will be a digital medium where you'll be able to receive uh and have on deposit dollars that are essentially digital tokens that you can use in these systems. Um so that that's the world we're transitioning to. And uh
18:26 Speaker 1 Do you think that the players that you're working with buy into that vision? Because right now it seems like they're smartly opportunistically thinking about how to get in the game and make sure they're staying relevant in this software money over IP world, actually. But that seems like that's almost too controversial or like not controversial to us, but
18:45 Speaker 0 yeah. Our partners in every case want to run the networks, right? They want to be deploying the networks and and uh and running them. Uh then the question is what are the assets on the network? So if you're a NASDAQ, it it makes sense that you're gonna have both securities but also currencies uh that are using to used to buy these current these securities. So the other big role on every network is where the assets being issued, who's issuing them. And uh and in some cases, you know, in the case of a first data or a um uh a telecom company like Orange, you they're also the issuer. Uh but in other cases, the issuers are actually uh entities that are either governments or custodian banks or companies themselves.
19:33 Speaker 0 Um it it's not uh unforeseeable that Apple would issue its own stock, right? So applicate issue stock and uh flow stock that way uh in a in a much simpler process than the current underwriting and issuance process for stock.
19:48 Speaker 1 We'd love to hear more insights about what it's like behind the scenes of of actually doing this, because on the outside it sounds interesting and exciting. They're you know, working together and collaborating and partnering, but what does that actually look like? Because You're talking about two very different cultures, two very different technologies, two very different minds. I mean, there's so many different things coming together. Like, can you tell us a bit more about that? Sure. Yeah.
20:08 Speaker 2 And were you, were you, did they come to you or did you go to them? I'm like, are you having to do a lot of selling, or are they like, oh my God, we need what you guys have and this vision of the future.
20:17 Speaker 0 At the outset, they came to us. And the reason they came to us at the beginning was that our company chain, uh, we started two years ago and we launched a Bitcoin API for developers. So that it was very easy for software developers to build applications on the uh Bitcoin network. So uh companies like Change Tip and BitPesa, uh ChangeTip is for tipping with Bitcoin on Twitter, Bitpace is for sending Bitcoin to Africa, uh, other remittance services, wallets, exchanges. They they used our API because it made it easier to build on Bitcoin. So we were powering a huge percentage of the Bitcoin apps and services that were launched over the last couple of years. And financial institutions who were interested in the technology got in touch with us because they said, look, it looks like you guys understand the technology.
21:06 Speaker 0 So can you come explain it to us, first of all? And then second, uh what's working and why? And so we were sort of this neutral technical platform partner. And so they they first came to us. Um when we met with big financial institutions, uh, the thing we realized quite quickly was that Bitcoin was of interest, uh, and they were curious about it. But as I said earlier, they really wanted to know if they could move the asset classes that they participate in every day, uh, and and they're relevant to their business. Could they move those assets in that same format? Right. Right. So um, so that was at the outset. Now that we've become kind of the de facto blockchain infrastructure uh provider to these big FIs. Um, now we have obviously a sales process and we go out and we meet people and we go to conferences and it's kind of goes both ways.
21:57 Speaker 0 To the question of what it's like to work with, you know, we're a technology company, we're very Silicon Valley. Um for good and bad. Um, we're out here in San Francisco, and our partners are largely large institutions in places like New York and Boston and London. And, you know, it's been um it's been really interesting in terms of learning about what it's like to sell into these organizations and work with them and partner with them. The the first thing I'll say is we have we really only work with partners where the CEO's driving the agenda. In this case, it's totally necessary because this isn't like an email spam filter where an IT department can just look at the benefits and say, okay, your spam filter is better than the other spam filter and it costs this much, and we're we'll sign a deal.
22:45 Speaker 0 This is a strategic decision to go disrupt a market to try to capture a part of the market maybe you couldn't capture before or defend against the onslaught of some new thing. You know, the depending on the use case, it's a very strategic choice to deploy a blockchain network. Very strategic. So we found that when we start in the innovation lab, it never actually gets us to the point of a decision to go do this. So we found that where the CEO invited us in at the beginning, or where we were able to get to the CEO or C level executive early, we've been able to define the hypothesis and the thesis for going after and going out and building one of these things. And then we've been able to have obviously the organizational buy-in because it's coming from the top to go do it.
23:32 Speaker 0 And so that's the most important thing we've learned. Uh, and and that's how we focus our time. You know, the other thing we've learned that's that's kind of kind of interesting and and probably is not a surprise to most of your listeners, but was a surprise to us, is that uh at any given institution, it's very, very rare to find someone who actually knows how the whole thing works.
23:55 Speaker 2 How the whole institution works? Yeah, how the
23:57 Speaker 0 whole institution works. Right. All right. You go into a bank, you can talk to senior people at the bank and you say you ask them very basic questions about how does what happens when, you know, X client wants to take X action, like can you just lay out the steps? And um, you tend to need to get like a room full of people together for a day to really map it out. Uh, same is true uh, you know, in the energy markets, telecom, uh, these are large, complicated companies that have uh are often the result of acquisitions, are often the result of years of overlapping legacy systems, competing fiefdoms, different products and services. And so uh part of what is difficult and slow about working with these organizations is simply setting a baseline for what is the status quo today, and when we do it this new way, how does that how do things change?
24:49 Speaker 0 And then of course, finally the implementation, right? So the reason companies like Accenture and PwC exist and are very successful is they they're they go in and implement and re-engineer business process. And uh, and this is the same thing, right? So uh we are finding ourselves increasingly partnering with large enterprises who already sell into the IT functions of big banks uh and big financial companies uh to actually pull off the implementation. Um so, you know, the net net is, you know, as a small tech company out here, we get leverage through, you know, senior partnerships, uh, identifying people in the company that really understand how the thing works, and then partnering with integrators to actually pull it off.
25:33 Speaker 2 And and how do these things exist within these large organizations? Are they sort of like, okay, here's the Skunkworks financial, digital cryptocurrency gang, and we've got them off there in the corner in the basement, or is it sort of in the full light of day and you know, they get to come to the holiday party too.
25:50 Speaker 0 So when we started two years ago, there was no one. And maybe there's one one person who just was in, you know, they just had a hobby and they liked Bitcoin or something, right? Right. There's no official anything going on. Um we called the company chain two years ago because we had this thought that, you know, eventually people are gonna realize that it's the layer of the blockchain that is of interest. But it was kind of a bet, a gamble to call the company chain two years ago. Um then about a year ago, as you had exactly as you had said, there's a skunkworks that would get set up uh in the innovation lab. And it was kind of like, all right, you guys go figure it out and if tell us if there's anything here that's interesting. And then really in the last six months, but like in a very serious way in the last three, and this is a very real-time topic.
26:36 Speaker 0 Um, senior executives have taken this on and owned this as a part of their strategy. Right. They've decided that uh whether they're gonna take an action or not, they need to know why they're not if they're not. And if they're gonna do it, they're trying to figure out how to do it. So the notion that you don't have a blockchain strategy if you're a financial institution now is um no longer possible. You have to know what you're going to do and how, or if you don't want to do something, you better know why you're not doing something. That's the status. That's that's where we are today. So it really is a C it is really a C level agenda item now. And I by the way, I know that because uh, you know, I used to work in management consulting many years ago uh at Boston Consulting Group, you know, and I check in with them occasionally. So two years ago, I said, does anyone any of your clients asking for this?
27:25 Speaker 0 No. They're like, well, a year ago, a year ago, anyone asking, no, six months ago, anyone asking, uh, I think someone, I think Bob down the hall has talked to someone about it. Now it's can you come in and present to all of our partners because they're all getting asked about this now? So it really has changed tremendously in in the last couple quarters. To
27:44 Speaker 1 actually be able to say the same way you used to say before what's your internet strategy, what's your web strategy, what's your Bitcoin strategy? That's actually a huge shift.
27:51 Speaker 2 Let me ask this question. I don't you don't have to give an answer because I think I know what it'll be. But but but does all that interest and all this kind of come to come to see the light way of things these days? Does that mean the blockchain wins? I mean, is that then does what could happen to derail all this?
28:09 Speaker 0 I think it means that digital assets are coming. In other words, this hybrid we have now of analog assets and then databases. Um it doesn't make sense. So we're going to go to a full digital stack where the asset itself at the outset is issued in a digital format, is moved digitally over networks, is settled and held digitally using cryptography. I mean, that's that is coming. Part of what's challenging for us as a startup is there is so much noise in this market right now. And a lot of people are gonna do it wrong. You know that expression, you're doing it wrong. Like we look at a lot of initiatives people are taking, and it's clear they're doing it wrong. Right. And so what's going to happen, what we anticipate is we're at this kind of like fever pitch in the hype cycle around this technology right now.
28:57 Speaker 0 There will be a uh over the next year, year and a half, a lot of people that take half measures and they just don't get all the, they don't do it what we would consider the right way. And uh, and they won't have great results, and they'll kind of be like, ah, we tried that blockchain thing and nothing there. But then there will be a handful of networks that will be deployed by serious companies that will generate real results, and then the proof will be in the pudding. But today it's a strategic question and people are trying to learn. Uh for us, the imperative is partner with executives who are serious, who know what the why they want to do this, who will commit to it for the long haul. And let's go build those networks and change the world. Uh, and then the and then, you know, people will see the results over time.
29:47 Speaker 1 Let's actually, we don't have too much time left. Let's write lightning round a bunch of um bits and misconceptions, definitions, interesting things happening in Bitcoin and blockchain. But one to just start off, because you mentioned, you know, database and you're Discussion about assets that we have this analog stuff and then you have a database. One thing that I've heard come up a lot is this notion of private and permissioned blockchains, which feels really weird because isn't that just like a database then? So could you kind of lightning round answer
30:15 Speaker 0 that? So a blockchain is a database. So we shouldn't overthink it. But it's different from a traditional database in two critical ways. First of all, it's shared. So in other words, it's distributed to every participant who is participating in the network. And then the critical difference that uh I think most miss is that in a blockchain, the assets are controlled by the owners of the assets. Whereas in a traditional database, the assets are controlled by whoever owns the database, whoever running the database. That's the big difference. So it's a it's a system whereby the asset owners retain control uh all the time over their assets, even as we're using a data model uh in a network to uh to transact. So
31:00 Speaker 1 having defined that, what's your take on this whole move and discussion around permission and private? I think we'll
31:05 Speaker 0 have uh I think the future will be many, many uh different networks. The big Bitcoin network will be one. I think you'll have networks around prepaid and gift and loyalty. I think you'll have networks for capital markets, networks in the mobile uh market. Uh and that for the most part, uh, they will be interoperable either directly or through uh integrations. But uh I don't think every asset in the world will be wedged into the Bitcoin network
31:35 Speaker 1 into a single network.
31:36 Speaker 0 I think we'll have many networks that are designed and defined for use cases. Now, some people call those private or permissioned. I think those words connote the wrong idea. Uh what we envision is simply just many interoperable networks uh and the way in which those emerge into the world is being defined now by companies like ours and others. But regardless of path to to market, I think that's the world we're heading toward. From a regulatory perspective, it just doesn't make sense that you'd regulate like a gift card network the same way you'd regulate a capital markets network for syndicated loans and also different geographies and different there are just a lot of reasons why it's natural to to have different markets have, you know, uh cater to different or be served by different networks.
32:21 Speaker 1 Okay. So then the next lightning round question that's a logical consequence of that, which is if the entire point of having any kind of network effect is that the value increases for every user and the more people that use that network, then you increase the value for those constituents. This notion of having multiple networks, even if they are interoperable. So the interoperability takes care of some of the connection. How are we then as developers as an ecosystem going to build this in a way that it is truly giving that network effect?
32:48 Speaker 0 Sure. Well, I think uh if you look at NASDAQ, NASDAQ's a private network today with a network effect of buyers and sellers. Craigslist has a network effect. Instagram has a network effect. There are lots of services and lots of networks in the world that have network effects. So uh having multiple networks is not uh does not mean we will not have network effects within the networks that are valuable. And I think the way I think really important question, how do we make sure that we don't just end up with a bunch of different protocols and siloed off different networks?
33:19 Speaker 1 Then you have to spend more time plumbing the connections and actually getting the benefits of what the entire thing is supposed to enable. Right.
33:24 Speaker 2 And and some networks will will, like they do, will sort of accrete more power and center of gravity, right? And so then the sort of decentralized versus centralized gangs all hot and bothered.
33:36 Speaker 0 Yes. Well, you know, we already have some prior art here, which is um there was a period of time shortly after Bitcoin gained popularity in 2012 when there were what were called altcoins, many other alternative currencies that were forks of Bitcoin. And there was
33:52 Speaker 1 like a Dogecoin,
33:53 Speaker 0 Dogecoin, Litecoin, uh Dartcoin, there's a whole bunch of different ones. And um without weighing in on the value of them, because I think it's pretty clear now that they're not valuable. Oh, I don't know. I think
34:04 Speaker 1 the Dogecoin's pretty damn valuable. Dogecoin is fun, uh,
34:07 Speaker 0 but it's empirically not valuable. Uh but even though those were different networks, it was actually very easy to swap Dogecoin for Bitcoin, Litecoin for Dogecoin. It's very easy because at the root, they were all digital assets. They're all digital currencies. So even if we have a world with many different networks, it won't be hard to exchange across those networks because ultimately we're talking about uh cryptographically issued and transferred assets. So it's it's gonna be much easier than integrating two data centers uh with different database architectures and written entirely different ways and with different APIs. I mean, it'll be it'll be more straightforward than that. Um that's one part of the answer. I know it's a lightning round and it's a long answer. But
34:52 Speaker 1 it's much wow in this case.
34:54 Speaker 0 Nicely done.
34:56 Speaker 1 I was waiting to say that.
34:59 Speaker 0 Uh I didn't even see it coming. So um the other answer is uh, you know, there are many competing efforts today, uh, and some of them will just go away, right? Like not there will not be 50 different blockchain companies serving financial companies. Like there will be a few and there will be a healthy amount of competition and that's fine. I I don't think I don't think we we will have one company that will deploy all blockchain networks for all asset classes outside of Bitcoin. And
35:27 Speaker 1 nor do we want to do it. Nor do you want that? Right. Yeah, that seems like they would defeat the very purpose. You mentioned color coins. You touched upon that briefly earlier. Could you quickly pause and define that for us and talk about other colored coins initiatives? Aaron Powell
35:37 Speaker 0 A colored coin is broadly understood as uh laying an asset other than Bitcoin or a currency other than Bitcoin onto the Bitcoin network. And uh without getting into the technical uh detail of how that works, the reason it's called a colored coin conceptually is you imagine taking a piece of one of these uh coins and like marking it somehow and saying now this thing is now for from now on, this represents a dollar bill. And if I give you this, uh you can come back to me later and get a real dollar. So uh a colored coin was that was the first kind of technical attempt at uh digitizing other assets. Uh and there's there were many different approaches to doing that.
36:23 Speaker 0 Um what we're seeing is a shift away from that approach toward building networks from the ground up that are designed for a particular asset.
36:34 Speaker 1 Okay. So that brings me to the next lightning round question, which is side chains. And I think if you could spend a couple minutes on this one because it's super interesting and read this great paper on it that came out earlier this year. Could you explain what they are and why they matter?
36:47 Speaker 0 Yeah, sure. So a side the basic idea with a side chain was uh the Bitcoin network is big. There's five billion or today seven billion dollars of value transmitting on the Bitcoin network. And so we don't want to tweak the network and break it to try out new features. If we're gonna try a new feature, a new way that the Bitcoin network functions, say if it's more optimized for microtransactions or more optimized for more confidential transactions. It won't be easy to just change that on the Bitcoin network. We need some, we need like a test network to try out a new sandbox to try out a new way to architect a network, but we still want Bitcoin. We want to, we want to see how Bitcoin would function in this new type of network. So the idea with a side chain was we can uh if you imagine the Bitcoin network as a circle, we can take a smaller circle and attach it to at a tangent point to the Bitcoin network.
37:43 Speaker 0 And we can take some Bitcoin off of the main network and funnel it over and through what's called a peg into this new network. So like taking it from one country to another, it's like exchanging it over this new network and uh and see how that approach to uh a network architecture would look. So it was a way to um test new features for the Bitcoin network uh without having to create an altcoin like Litecoin. So Litecoin Dogecoin, those were new type, they had new features, but you had a new currency there. So this the idea of the sidechain is like, well, we we already have Bitcoin, we like Bitcoin. Let's continue to use the Bitcoin currency, but we can try new features by pegging it through this process. And so that was the original impetus behind creating a side chain.
38:30 Speaker 0 And um the company that is involved uh in in that solution and that uh that approach uh includes many of the original engineers and architects of the Bitcoin network. So they're really well versed and suited to innovating on the Bitcoin network and with the Bitcoin currency, where side chains uh potentially have a limitation is getting into say other asset classes because there's this really uh fundamental question is if you don't want Bitcoin currency in the particular use case or market, then why not build the network that's suited for that use case? Why try to bring over Bitcoin and like connect them somehow? So side chains, I think um are going to be very, very powerful with respect to innovating the Bitcoin network, less so with respect to uh innovating in capital markets in payments and other areas.
39:20 Speaker 0 We'll see how that plays out. But that's that seems to be where we're at today.
39:25 Speaker 1 So then last lightning round question, and then we'll wrap up. You know, you've talked a lot about the disruption of the fintech and the work that you guys are doing and a lot of these new alternatives and things that are happening, the experimentation that's happening on the blockchain. Let's talk more about some of the more interesting native apps that you're seeing, because I feel like sometimes the conversation around Bitcoin and blockchain goes so much into the infrastructural details that we sometimes forget about the most interesting apps that are being built on top of it. Yeah. What are some of from your vantage point, what are some of the more interesting native and promising native apps you're seeing? And where do you see kind of holes in the developer ecosystem that you would love people to? Address.
40:00 Speaker 0 Sure. So I'd I divide that into two categories. One is apps on the Bitcoin network. And then the other is
40:08 Speaker 1 otherwise. Essentially other
40:10 Speaker 0 asset classes. Right.
40:11 Speaker 1 Like art provenance or whatever.
40:12 Speaker 0 Right. Right. So on the Bitcoin network, uh, I think the uh can the um intersection of social media and Bitcoin is super interesting. So change tip is a really good example of that, where you can instead of just liking someone uh on a social network, you can send them a small amount of Bitcoin, which would be very hard with a credit card or another uh uh means like cash, obviously. Um also on the Bitcoin network, I think the most can continue to be one of the most powerful use cases and interesting use cases is in um essentially next generation remittances. So ways in which we can we find people with smartphones moving money out of their country to relatives or doing it, trying to do it in a secretive way. Or stashing it, yeah. Or stashing it. So taking out of we're not stashing in the mattress anymore.
41:00 Speaker 0 We're just stashing in our smartphone.
41:02 Speaker 2 Yeah.
41:03 Speaker 0 What we could speculate about the future, but today on the Bitcoin network, that is really the most compelling use case and the most the thing that is driving demand is going around capital controls, hedging against a hyperinflating currency in your home market, needing to keep uh money out of the site of corrupt officials, what whatever it is. Um and of course, illicit use cases continue to be uh driving demand for Bitcoin. So those are the those are the killer apps today. Um the uh other asset class. Right.
41:35 Speaker 1 So besides like Bitcoin. Right.
41:36 Speaker 0 So think imagine a world where you know you have a bunch of loyalty points and reward points today, sitting in programs locked up, completely isolated, you probably don't think of them as value. When you think about your net worth, you probably don't include all the gift cards and loyalty points you have, right? Yeah, freaking flyer miles. You just they kind of exist and they're kind of a nuisance almost. Well, um, what the blockchain's gonna do is unlock those and make it very fluid to move them around, to have them on your smartphone, to use them in new ways. Oh, trade them even, right? Or trade them exactly. Now, according to whatever the restrictions are that the brand has. But we we envision a world where um, you know, Bitcoin people might ask, well, why are there so many fiat currencies? There should just be like this one currency called Bitcoin. And there's something to that. There's another way to look at that, which is the the exact opposite, which is why are there so few currencies?
42:26 Speaker 0 Why doesn't every brand have a currency that that uh they give me to reward me for things? Right.
42:31 Speaker 1 I even heard our partner, new newest partner Alex Rampel at Money2020 recently talk about even like real estate, like giving out like, you know, part of your own real estate as well.
42:41 Speaker 0 Right. A fraction, a fraction of your real estate. So when it's so easy to issue and move an asset, I think what that unlocks is way more activity around that. So um imagine, for example, tweeting about Coca-Cola, uh, and then Coke pushing you, you know, uh a couple bucks worth of of Coke coupon. Yeah. And then going to McDonald's and then going to McDonald's and then paying with your smartphone and getting $2 off because you bought $2 of Coke product. Like that customer experience flow is just not possible to do today in an easy way, but it would be very possible and very easy with a blockchain.
43:20 Speaker 2 And you sit in the middle of this between not necessarily Coca-Cola, but big companies and consumers. How quickly? I mean, you you talked about how in the last year and the last couple of months things have changed quickly. But how soon do we either, you know, get to do the Coke example or even behind the scenes, securitors are moving along these digital rails that that we haven't used before.
43:42 Speaker 0 Yep. So the main uh so the the speed of at which the market has become interested in this technology has shocked us, even as a startup that moves very quickly. And that speed is that's all word of mouth, that's all talk, right? So things can change very quickly in terms of talking. And that's sort of why the Gartner hype cycle exists, because that first peak is not necessarily real things. It's it's people talking and deciding, oh, this is the next big thing. And so you get this surge of interest. But then there are just the physics of how long does it take to deploy a network and get it up and running. And so in practice, what I think you'll see, and what you know uh I can say here is you'll see the first few networks going live next year. Uh and then I think by 2017, you'll start to see some of the first uh winners.
44:31 Speaker 0 In other words, you'll see that if you if by 2017 in a particular market, if you don't have a network uh running, then you're behind. You're behind your peers. Right. And so what what we anticipate next year is a kind of a cooling off of the rhetoric, but a real investment in building. And then by 2017, the emergence of the first few networks um that will really start to change the game and change market structure. So that's that's the best guess I have based on our roadmaps that and the the sort of timelines that we're seeing with our partners.
45:05 Speaker 2 Adam, thanks for your time. Get back to work.
45:07 Speaker 0 Thank you. It was a pleasure to be here.
45:09 Speaker 1 Thanks, Adam. That was great.
45:10 Speaker 0 Thanks for having me.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated