Pod Insights a16z Podcast a16z Podcast | A Copernican Update ... In Tech, the Smartphone is the Center About this episode Given the endless time we all spend with our noses in our phones, it may not be too surprising to hear that the smartphone has taken over the tech world. But the smartphone’s dominance is so complete, says a16z’s Benedict Evans, that it’s useful to think of it as the sun, the object around which everything else in the (technology) planetary system revolves.
Technology meets astronomy, plus Android’s Stagefright bug, and why three German carmakers are getting into the software business in this segment of the a16z Podcast.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 1 Welcome to the A16Z podcast. I'm Michael Copeland. Given the endless time we all spend with our noses and our phones, it may not be too surprising to hear that the smartphone has taken over the tech world. But the smartphone's dominance is so complete, says A16Z's Benedict Evans, that it's useful to think of it as the sun. That object around which everything else in the technology planetary system revolves. And as with our own solar system, Benedict's mobile planetary model includes lesser bodies that circle around the sun, feeding off its energy and pull.
0:37 Speaker 0 You know, you might see a smart meter is Pluto, you know, it's like it's not very exciting. It hasn't got doesn't look like it's got very much to do with the mobile industry, but actually it's using smartphone components.
0:49 Speaker 1 Putting the smartphone at the center of things also elevates the mobile supply chain above the other big component stream in tech, the one serving the PC industry. So instead of the guts of PCs being mixed and matched to create new kinds of tech gadgets, it's all the processors, radios, and other bits inside smartphones that are the engine of current and future waves of technology.
1:11 Speaker 0 It's as though someone took a shipping container of Lego and dumped it on the floor. You have all these bits and we're just picking up working out what we can do with them. And so that's what's behind drones and wearables and connected TVs and connected cars and Internet of Things and all of these other things.
1:25 Speaker 1 And if mobile is the sun, the companies and geographies that best harness that energy are dominant.
1:32 Speaker 0 Now it's about Apple and Google, and it's about um ARM and Qualcomm and Media Tech, and it's about um the San Francisco Bay Area and China. And so all of those kinds of all of the places that you'd go and the companies that were important have changed. And again, that doesn't mean that Microsoft or Intel have gone away. It just means that they're not setting the agenda anymore at all.
1:55 Speaker 1 Technology meets astronomy. Plus Android stage right bug and why three German car makers are getting into the software business in this segment of the A16Z podcast. I sit here with uh Copernicus, otherwise known as Benedict Evans. Benedict, welcome. Hello. So Copernicus, you are not, but you have equated the mobile phone to the sun. Explain for us what the hell you mean.
2:22 Speaker 0 Yeah. So I thought it was just an interesting unifying metaphor for thinking about what's going on in tech. So the sort of the thing, the fundamental thing that's changed is we've exchanged a PC ecosystem for the mobile ecosystem as the dominant driver, the dominant force in the industry. So you go from one and a half billion PCs replaced every four or five years to four billion mobile phones, maybe growing to five billion mobile phones replaced every two years, and those mobile phones are converting very quickly to smartphones. There's probably two billion smartphones on Earth today, maybe two and a half billion, and the great majority of those mobile phones will convert. And so we'll end up with something like one and a half billion PCs and four to five billion smartphones and those smartphones again being replaced every two years. So just a much, much, much bigger industry.
3:10 Speaker 1 And you're not saying that the PC goes away anytime soon, and we're not arguing that, but just that that's the number of PCs we're
3:15 Speaker 0 Yeah, exactly. I mean, there's well, there's two separate things. One is just the sheer number of devices being sold reshapes the hardware ecosystem. Secondly, the fact that smartphones are now at least half of all time spent online reshapes how the internet works, which shapes how all sorts of consumer services works. In the longer term, um it seems kind of inevitable that mobile devices start replacing more and more of how PC gets used. And I've written about you know what will happen to Microsoft Office over the next five, ten years, but that's kind of kind of a separate conversation. I think the core of it is that it is now the um the mobile phone that that that's sort of that's just kind of the center of how the tech industry works. And that gets manifested in a couple of different ways. One way it gets manifested is that the supply chain um becomes extremely important for everyone else. Um that is to say, all of the or almost all of the components for smartphones are available off the shelf as commodity bits and pieces.
4:05 Speaker 0 And in addition, m almost all smartphones are made by contract manufacturers who will put those components together for you to make something else. And so it's as though someone took a shipping container of Lego and dumped it on the floor. You have all these bits and we're just picking up working out what we can do with them. And so that's what's behind drones and wearables and connected TVs and connected cars and internet of things and all of these other things. They're all basically using smartphone components, and also all being put together by smartphone manufacturers or smartphone contract manufacturers, so FoxCon and all those kinds of companies.
4:36 Speaker 1 And it and it's not to Peter Levine's point here at the firm, it's not just you know, smartphones are going into drones and things that are small and things that are like embedded in your light switch, but that the components servers as well. But into everything,
4:49 Speaker 0 right? Yeah, it turns out that you know you j we you just have a much, much, much bigger industry. And so you have much higher volume, you have much greater rate of innovation, and you have all these new kinds of components that didn't exist before. And you know, in a data center, for example, it turns out that being a low power and low temperature is actually really important in a rack, just as it's really important in a smartphone. So, you know, you have all these kind of generalizable applications. Um then that ecosystem spreads out to all the components that are used to to create all sorts of other all sorts of other things as well. Now the thing that the interesting thing that comes out of that is that it means that the center of gravity for the companies and the places that matter have changed as well. So it used to be that you would go to Microsoft or Entity Dokomo or Nokia or Intel to find out the future. And you'd go to Seattle and you'd go to um Finland and you'd go to Japan to see the future.
5:37 Speaker 1 Right.
5:38 Speaker 0 And that's not true anymore. Now it's about Apple and Google, and it's about um ARM and Qualcomm and MediaTe, and it's about um the San Francisco Bear area and um China. And so all of those kinds of all of the places that you'd go and the companies that were important have changed. And again, that doesn't mean that Microsoft or Intel have gone away. It just means that they're not setting the agenda anymore at all for what's going to happen next in all these kind of experiences.
6:05 Speaker 1 And and so if the mobile phone is the sun, and to continue the planetary analogy, w what are the rest of the planets out there and kind of how do they see it? Yeah, so
6:15 Speaker 0 this is the thing. So I actually came to this thinking about the watch, which is that you have all sorts of different planets and different orbits, and they're big and small, and they're boring or interesting or exciting, or you know, then you have kind of like messaging out as a client, uh comets, you know, that kind of spin around and
6:30 Speaker 1 explode or
6:32 Speaker 0 every now and then one of them glows in the sky.
6:34 Speaker 1 Right. Um
6:35 Speaker 0 look, it's
6:36 Speaker 1 a mere
6:36 Speaker 0 cat. Yeah, and so you know, you might see a smart meter is Pluto, you know, it's like it's not very exciting, it hasn't got doesn't look like it's got very much to do with the mobile industry, but actually it's using smartphone components. Then you might have um some other kind of product that's got like a thermostat or something that's got its own UI, it's got its own connected services. It's you know, it's a standalone thing, and yet you probably can try it from a smartphone and it again it rests on the smartphone supply chain. And then I think most interestingly you have things like um cars on the one hand or TVs on the other, where uh um in a sense you have that that the particular TVs become dumb glass. Um that they are remote screens, they're either to the extent that they're not running broadcast TV, they're remote screens for smartphone. And I think there was because we're talking about this earlier, there's kind of an irony in here that you know all of Satian Adela is reconfiguring of Microsoft.
7:25 Speaker 0 The stuff that got attention is writing down the mobile acquisition from Nokia and really signaling the end of Windows everywhere um as the kind of the driving strategic force of the company that you know you can get office on iPad, that they're neutral as to what you know it's not all about Windows and Office anymore, and those are kind of the legacy platforms, and Microsoft is trying to work out what it's going to do next. Yeah, so with the interesting but the interesting thing. And it's not clear, no. But the interest and I wrote up wrote a blog post about this, sort of talking about what productivity is going to look like in the future. But the interesting thing in this context is it's not just the death of Windows everywhere, it's also that Satya said very clearly that the Xbox isn't core anymore. Trevor Burrus,
8:04 Speaker 1 Jr. So that is fascinating to me, because the Xbox was one of those things where if you were at Microsoft and you wanted to be like on the team that mattered and the team that was going places, you often wanted to go to the Xbox team. Aaron Ross Powell
8:15 Speaker 0 Yeah, it's a bit like Google Plus at Google, you know. That's what's what the TV's they could do. So
8:19 Speaker 1 what happened? Or what is this an admission of the code? Well, there's an IRA. At least uh I don't know, acknowledgement on it.
8:24 Speaker 0 So there's an irony here. So I was chatting about this with on Twitter the other day that sort of if you look at all the predictions of what was going to happen that people were making in 1990. It all sort of presumed that there would be a small number of big companies that would build everything. And the very phrase sort of the internet superhighway kind of presupposes that it's about AT ⁇ T and Comcast and Microsoft and they sort of build it all. And if you look at what the mobile operators have thought about the mobile internet, they sort of predicted a lot of the stuff we're doing today, but they kind of thought they would be doing it. And what people didn't predict was the sort of permissionless innovation, that it's thousands of companies that are building all of these different things, and none of them depend on anybody else. This is permission to do anything. This is what Mark likes to call permissionless innovation.
9:11 Speaker 0 Now, you then come back to the TV. But a big part of the vision in 1990 was it would be on the television. It wouldn't be on these personal computers that were these ugly beige boxes on them. Even though
9:21 Speaker 1 they tried over and over to convince us of the, you know, whatever they called the entertainment center for Microsoft.
9:26 Speaker 0 Yeah, yeah, exactly. It really everyone thought it was going to be about the P it was going to be interactive television. Um this is what you know, this is why everyone in those kind of companies sneered at the web because no no no no, it has to be on the TV. And so Microsoft was putting interactivity on TV sets before when teleph telephones didn't even have screens. Right, right. And yet here we are now. And it's now painfully apparent that, you know, yes, games consoles are a thing, and yes, there's a big business there, but actually it's incredibly small relative to the size of the smartphone industry. Yes, games console games again are better than smartphone games. For now, just as entertainment arcade games were better than games console games 30 years ago. But it's a smartphone that drives everything else. And so for the vast majority of people, the TV will be dumb glass for the smartphone.
10:12 Speaker 0 Rather than so it won't be a box that's plugged into your TV that runs your whole digital experience. Right. And game consoles will
10:19 Speaker 1 be for games. Yeah,
10:20 Speaker 0 exactly. They will be like watches or thermostats or connected cars, or there'll be another planet that orbits. Right. And there will probably be games consoles indefinitely in some form, whether they end up being smartphones inside, really, which is what the original Xbox was, of course. But it will be the smartphone that everything else rotates around. And the role of the TV, yes, you may have a games console. Vastly more people if they're doing anything digital on their TV will be doing something that's fundamentally derived from the smartphone that's being controlled by the smartphone. Aaron Powell
10:48 Speaker 1 You said in in this post where you describe your your um planetary system that the smartphone or the mobile phone is the first universal device that technology has really produced. And why wasn't the TV that, for example?
11:01 Speaker 0 Um yeah, I say this and I sort of say it on Twitter every now and then, and every now and then people get extremely angry with me and they think I'm being some sort of American Silicon Valley utopian visionary, which would certainly make many of my colleagues here laugh.
11:14 Speaker 1 I don't mean to laugh, but um and so
11:16 Speaker 0 this is the thing. There are five billion p adults on Earth out of about seven billion people. And depending on what estimates you make, it there are between, say, four, three and a half to four billion and maybe four and a half to five billion, maybe as many. So there's say three and a half to four and a half billion people on Earth have a mobile phone today. Three and a half to four billion out of five billion adults. And so we are now long past the point that you could argue about you know, is an impoverished farmer in rural Africa going to have a mobile Africa going to have a mobile phone, is a fisherman in Indonesia going to have a mobile phone. The answer is yes, he will. And quite possibly someone in his village has one right now. Right. Um you look at Sub-Saharan Africa, it's already at 40% population penetration of mobile phones, and that will go up to the same 70, 80% that you have in Western Europe and of real people.
12:06 Speaker 0 Like, you know, there's always like 10 or 10% of the population doesn't get these things even in America. And so you know, these are now you know, a mobile entry price of a mobile phone now is five to ten dollars to buy the phone, and an Android phone is $30 to $40. And that's not subsidized price, that's the actual price of buying the thing. And then you get onto a whole set of challenges around, well, what do they pay for data? How do they charge their phone? What do they pay to charge their phone? Because they're probably paying someone who has power to charge their phone. Where does solar come into that? Where does Google's drones and all this stuff come into that? So you get a whole kind of gray area around the edges. But fundamentally, you get to a point that there are four or five billion people on Earth who have a smartphone. And PCs are about one and a half billion, and half of those are corporate.
12:54 Speaker 0 Right. So it's 800 million PCs or seven or eight hundred million PCs that are in someone's home. And that's yes, that's per household rather than per person. So you know it's a slightly different metric, but it's not a universal product. And television in the same sense, yes, it has very wide reach, but television in a in rural India means a television per village or two or three televisions per village. It doesn't mean two or three mobile phones per household. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
13:19 Speaker 1 Right, right. Or per pocket for that matter. Yeah. So you you mentioned Android and uh something that happened recently was this hideous Android bug. Stage freight. Yes. I'm frightened just saying it because I know that my phone is not patched.
13:33 Speaker 0 Well, I love my favorite line about this is it's the first time anyone has managed to make an app that runs reliably on 95% of Android phones.
13:41 Speaker 1 Yes, and that's the problem, right? It's backwards compatible, like nothing else is. Well,
13:45 Speaker 0 so there's so what can one say about this? There's a couple of things. So first is you know, bugs happen, bugs happen to everyone. You know, Apple's had bugs, Microsoft had bugs, Google's had bugs, it happens. Um the issue here is, and this is of course an old issue for Android, is that um you the only real way to get software updates for an Android phone is to buy a new phone still for a whole bunch of reasons that you know we are all pretty well understood at the moment. Um, the kind of the thing that I tend to say when these topics come up is that Android fragmentation and sort of Android software updates and all these kind of issues are both very overstated and very understated. So on the one hand, something like 96, 97% of all live Android phones outside China, where Google isn't present, but all the ones outside China that are therefore mostly connected to Google.
14:31 Speaker 0 Over 95% of these things have the latest player version of Google Play services, which is updated, I think, every two weeks. And so if Google push out a new messaging API or a new payment API or some new for their layer of internet services, everyone's got it. So there's no fragmentation. Right. On the other hand, there's four thousand devices out there, and they've all got different chips and different implementations of the software. And so if you want to write like a video messaging app or something, it's not 95% of the base that's on one but one version. It really is 4,000 different devices, and you just got to pick the top 20 and test. And this is kind of it's just kind of inherent in the model. Um that you know Microsoft obviously wrote down Windows Phone. Effective is another piece of capitulation. They basically now given up on Windows Phone, although they haven't quite admitted that in public, but they have.
15:19 Speaker 0 Right. Um turns out
15:20 Speaker 1 that customers gave up on it long before Microsoft.
15:23 Speaker 0 Well, exactly, yeah. But the thing is if you want to know what Android would look like if it had no fragmentation, if it had completely uniform upgrades, if all the hardware looked the same, look at Windows Phone.
15:31 Speaker 1 Right.
15:31 Speaker 0 That's what you would get. That's where it would have ended up. And the, you know, the price that you pay for having 4,000 devices is that you have 4,000 devices. You know, there's a there's a glass half half empty, glass, half full thing here. Um the challenge that Google faces is that you know they've they've gone slightly too they uh they've found themselves slightly too far down that path. Because it's one thing to say, well, there's four thousand devices, so yes, of course they don't have all have the same GPU. It's another thing to say there's four thousand devices, so it's impossible to update the software for all of them, so you've got this vulnerability living forever. Aaron Powell
16:01 Speaker 1 Well, let's let's shift gears, uh no pun intended when you hear about what this topic is. But uh Daimler, BMW and Audi teamed up to buy Nokia here, right? Or Nokia as you like to say.
16:11 Speaker 0 Daimler. So yeah, so yeah, this is a kind of a weird story. So
16:15 Speaker 1 it is mobile.
16:16 Speaker 0 It is mobile, yeah. So pre-iPhone, I think, certainly a long time ago when Nokia still ruled the world and thought it would rule the world forever. Maps were clearly very important. And so they bought I think Navtech. I forget now. Yeah, they bought Navtech for like seven or eight billion dollars. A massive amount of demand. Massive amount of money, and this was this big strategic asset, and then Google comes out with Google Maps and explodes the whole whole industry. But they bit it, but the business is still there. And they so and they kept it when they sold the phone business to Microsoft. Um and there's a story in there which is you know, a story again that's there's an interesting political story about why that happened. Um but anyway, they kept it. Um but it was clearly completely non-core because Nokia now is a network infrastructure business.
17:02 Speaker 0 Right. Um and actually quite a good network infrastructure business. Um of the handset business. Um but it was clearly no place for that inside Nokia. So it's just a question of when it was going to get bought. And maps are really interesting right now. Um Google, there is a Google platform. But anyone who isn't Google and has aspirations to an independent life does not really want to rely on Google Maps indefinitely. And so Apple has gone from the fiasca of a couple of years ago to a now sort of not bad mapping product and has now built a fleet of cars to go out and build its own maps, finally, having previously relied on trying to stitch information together from lots of other people. It looks like what they're going to try and do is basically do a carbon copy of Google Maps. Um, which is not an impossibly hard project, it just takes a lot of time and a lot of money, um, which is what which they have and which is what Google did.
17:53 Speaker 0 And we all remember the days when Google Maps was terrible too, once, which you know, it takes time and effort. Um, Apple is doing this. Um Microsoft has basically given up on maps, it shut down Bing Maps and sold the Bing Maps assets to Uber. And Uber bid against the three big German car companies for um the Nokia Maps business. And so here is an interesting challenge. Clearly, if you are in the car business, you are looking with increasing concern at what Google might be doing in the future. Right. And self-driving cars are fundamentally a routing and dispatch and control question, which means maps. So maps go from being, oh, I've got the map on my dashboard instead of having to look at a paper map to this is a fundamental enabling technology for how cars work. Right. Um they become fundamentally important. They become like oil for how self-driving cars work.
18:40 Speaker 0 Trevor Burrus, Jr.
18:41 Speaker 1 Especially if they become electric cars because the sort of engineering is far simplified, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Aaron Ross Powell,
18:46 Speaker 0 yeah, exactly. And again, we can do a whole podcast about cars. Right. You know how that changes. But the kind of this is this fundamental point that maps move from being this nice feature like I don't know, like the CD player. Oh, you've got you've got maps, you've got a CD player. Suddenly with self-driving, they become this fundamentally important strategic asset. And so it becomes terrifying for a car company to be dependent on Google for that.
19:06 Speaker 1 It's fascinating because because car companies and we we did a podcast with Peter Levine and Ash Ashatosh and that that we were talking about how every company is a data company. And this is just an even bigger example of that.
19:17 Speaker 0 But the I thought this was a really interesting thing is who is bidding against Mercedes BNW and Volkswagen, in effect. Who's bidding against them? Well, Uber. Right. Uber is hey, Uber is just a taxi company, isn't it?
19:29 Speaker 1 Well, so again. It's a transportation company.
19:33 Speaker 0 And it's a platform company. That's a bit like saying it's a bit like saying, hey, Google just does tech search. Right. Well, no, no, Google is a machine learning engine. Google is about understanding everything. And what is Uber? Well, Uber is a illiterate call it transport, call it your logistics, call it. The way that I think about maps is that maps are kind of um page rank for the real world. And so if it is your business to send stuff around or own stuff that moves around within that, then you need to own maps. But all of this again comes back to you know my kind of original point that the smartphone is a sort of the sun for all of this. Um everything revolves around mobile, everything revolves around that pocket supercomputer that you have. Now it may be that the car is doing this as well. I actually have I have this incredibly clever and very sophisticated device for integrating smartness into my 2009 car, which is it's a rubber clip that slots into the air conditioning.
20:25 Speaker 1 And I can instantly add the latest pocket supercomputer to my car. It's amazing. It's right there, huh? Yeah, exactly.
20:32 Speaker 0 Why does it and so I always feel slightly ambivalent about the idea that you should add any kind of a smartness to a car? Like why don't I just use my phone?
20:38 Speaker 1 Well it's funny. I remember having a conversation with a very large American car company uh a few years back for a story, and um I told them exactly that. I'm like, you guys, this is your domain and it's disappearing. It's going to this thing in my pocket right now. And whether they're able to reverse that, whether this purchase of Nokia's mapping business is a step forward, or if it's just another like large company buying a software company and not knowing what to do with it, we'll see, I guess.
21:02 Speaker 0 Well, so this is I mean, this is the point Ben Horowitz has made. It's a lot easier for software companies, software people to learn something else than people from another industry to learn software. And so we know we talked about the um Android vulnerability. What about the Chrysler Jeep vulnerability? Yeah, it turns out
21:20 Speaker 1 I I don't even want to mention that my car happens to be made by Chrysler Fiat. And so not only is my phone vulnerable, now my car is. So
21:27 Speaker 0 but fundamentally, you know, who is it best to who is best placed to add software to a capital good that's made every ten years by a non-software company? Is it by that non-software company hiring some software developers? Or is it best added by Google, Apple, Uber somebody else? It's a smartphone that drives it. And you know, to we talk about the Xbox, you can talk about the car again. The TV is dumb glass. And the screens in the car are dumb glass, actually, and they should be powered by the smartphone.
21:59 Speaker 1 Well, we will see what gets powered by what, and it seems like uh you so far your planetary system is and and model is holding up. Uh and when it doesn't, we'll be back and talk about that too. Benedict, thank you. Thank you.
Previous Company Building in Crypto: A Conversation between Brian Armstrong and Chris Dixon Next What's Next for Education Startups Page updated August 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated