100 Objects #8: Billy Possum

The teddy bear was a huge hit, and sparked an idea…maybe every president from then on should have their own viral stuffed animal.

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Roman Mars?

  Instagram teen accounts have automatic protections on by default. Built-in content settings for the content teens can see, contact limits for who can contact them, and time management tools like daily time limits and sleep mode. Teens are automatically placed into teen accounts, and teens under 16 will need a parent's permission to change any of these settings to be less strict. Instagram will continue adding built-in safety features to help create age-appropriate experiences. Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at instagram.com/teenaccounts.

• 0:35Roman Mars?

  If you're a small business, the right hire can be make or break. Indeed Sponsored Jobs gets you quality candidates when you need them most. Join the 3.3 million employers worldwide that use Indeed to connect with quality talent that fits their needs. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at indeed.com/podcast. That's indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. 99% Invisible is presented by Acura. Curating and designing the perfect experience takes meticulous craft, an obsession with detail, and a love for innovation.

• 1:19Roman Mars?

  Just like museum designers, Acura carefully considers every detail to curate the most engaging, exhilarating, and rewarding experience for drivers. That craft isn't always something you can see, but it's something you'll feel, that flutter in your heart, the engine roars. Every Acura is designed with deliberate intention around how people actually use the vehicles. And that is precision-crafted performance. Our story begins one day in November of 1902. Just a few months prior, President Theodore Roosevelt had become the first president to make a public appearance in a car. And now, he was off on a new adventure, this one taking him to a small town in Mississippi called Smeets.

• 2:05Speaker 01

  And he's gone down to Smeed's to do a hunt, a bear hunt.

• 2:10Roman Mars?

  That's journalist John Well.

• 2:12Speaker 01

  And he's there for a few days without seeing a single bear. And then his hunting party happens to spot one and it runs into a kind of a weedy thicket.

• 2:22Roman Mars?

  It's a good move. The hunters can't really get to the bear. But Roosevelt's guide says, hang on, you just stay right here and I'll flush it out and you can kill it.

• 2:32Speaker 01

  Roosevelt gets a little bored, though, and he goes back to have lunch.

• 2:37Roman Mars?

  So when the hunting guide finally flushes the bear out, Roosevelt is nowhere to be seen.

• 2:42Speaker 01

  So his guide jumps off his horse, whacks the bear on the top of the head with the end of his rifle, and then ties it to a tree and then starts calling the president back over so that he can do the honors.

• 2:53Roman Mars?

  When the president arrives and sees the bear, let's just say he was far from impressed.

• 2:59Speaker 01

  He takes a look at this thing and it just looks pitiable, dazed, kind of semi-conscious. Looks pretty mangy, malnourished and about half of its normal weight. And so he takes pity on it and he says, you know, it's against my code as a sportsman to shoot this pathetic thing. And he refuses.

• 3:20Speaker 01

  This moment in which he refuses to shoot the bear, it's memorialized a few days later in a cartoon in a newspaper in Washington DC.

• 3:29Roman Mars?

  The cartoon is captioned Drawing the Line in Mississippi.

• 3:33Speaker 01

  And when you look at this cartoon, you see the president there with his arm out, kind of sparing the bear's life and he's holding his rifle. And the bear is there just watching Roosevelt, wondering, you know, what's going to happen to it? He's got its fate in his hands. This bear looks really vulnerable and cute. Its eyes are huge. It's got a big, round head. And it wouldn't necessarily be familiar to you at the time in 1902, but now we understand what this thing is right away. It's a teddy bear.

• 4:10Speaker 01

  After this cartoon runs, a toy manufacturer turns the bear from that cartoon into a stuffed animal and starts selling Teddy's Bear all over the United States, and it becomes a huge hit.

• 4:25Roman Mars?

  Teddy's Bear for Theodore Roosevelt, an object that would become so ubiquitous, it would take on a life of its own outside of its namesake president. In fact, I bet you or your kid have one somewhere in your house right now. But before we get ahead of ourselves, the teddy bear is not our object for this episode. No, our object comes out of what happens next. Because what is funny about this story is that the lesson that the toy manufacturers take from this is that maybe this model can be repeated. Maybe every president from here on out will have a viral stuffed animal named after them.

• 5:00Speaker 01

  Yeah, so they're thinking, well, Roosevelt's gonna leave office in 1909. We need the next president's version of the teddy bear. Now, the next president was William Howard Taft, not nearly as charismatic of a fellow as Teddy Roosevelt. But you know, the profit motive is strong. We've got to find something to be a mascot for his presidency. And they land on something a little suspect in retrospect. It's not a bear, it's a possum. And they market it as the Billy Possum. There's a reason why you have not heard of the Billy Possum. And there's a reason why there's no Billy Possum next to your sleeping child in the other room.

• 5:46Roman Mars?

  From 99% Invisible and BBC Studios, this is A History of the United States in 100 Objects. I'm Roman Mars. We in America, land of the bald eagle, have always turned animals into symbols. They represent what we're afraid of, what we love, what we think deserves to survive.

• 6:07Roman Mars?

  Those stories are some of the most powerful tools we have for protecting the natural world. Today, the story of the Billy Possum, and how our fickle feelings about animals have shaped the history and perhaps the future of our relationship with the natural world.

• 6:35Roman Mars?

  Before we meet the Billy Possum in full, let's go back to the moment his infinitely more successful cousin, the teddy bear, was first introduced. When that cartoon showing Roosevelt refusing to shoot the cute little bear was published, it was not how people were used to seeing bears, or how most people thought about them. Because back in the early 1900s, we did not see bears as cute.

• 6:57Speaker 01

  You know, bears were monsters. Bears were a shorthand for everything that was dangerous and unruly about nature, about the Western frontier. This was part of an outlook in the United States that anything big and wild was basically a threat to us and a threat to our ability to take over the landscape.

• 7:16Roman Mars?

  Yeah, and we didn't just treat it as a threat, like this was an active response to the federal government, that we were going to eradicate bears so that people could live in the West.

• 7:23Speaker 01

  Yes, we were absolutely at war with bears. There was a department of the federal government called the Bureau for Biological Survey. One of its primary jobs was just shooting and trapping and killing animals. We had sorted nature into sort of the desirable and undesirable ones, and we were letting all the undesirable ones really have it. Coyotes, wolves, mountain lions. It's also a cultural outlook. You see this reflected in a lot of fiction of the time, especially fiction for kids. Ladies Home Journal magazine published a story in 1900 about a boy named Balzer, who was described as, quote, "the happiest boy in Indiana" because he owned a rifle and enough ammunition to kill every creature within five miles. And in this story, Balzer, he kills a bear,

• 8:08Speaker 01

  but he gets bitten by the bear in the process. And so it all culminates in this kind of feel-good ending when Balzer and his dad track down the bear's mate and then shoot her in revenge.

• 8:22Roman Mars?

  And how successful were we at this time period of taking out the bears?

• 8:27Speaker 01

  Very successful, if you want to call that success. Yeah, this is an era in which a lot of what we call mega fauna of the United States is is being driven either out of its territory or just extinct. The grizzly bear was a huge target of these efforts and it was about to be extirpated from 95% of its original range in the continental US.

• 8:52Roman Mars?

  The eradication of the grizzly bear coincided with a big shift in America. For the first time in our history, a majority of Americans were living in cities, far from nature, far from the threat of bears. And so, as more and more bears disappeared from the landscape, they started showing up differently in our imaginations and in the pages of children's books.

• 9:14Speaker 01

  There was an extremely famous writer at the time named Ernest Thompson Seton, who was leading a movement in fiction, especially stories that were read by a lot of American children, where he was writing stories with protagonists who were bears and other animals, exactly the same kind of species that the government was busy exterminating. One of his most famous books was called The Biography of a Grizzly, and it centers on a cub named Wab, who at the beginning of the book, has to watch his mother and his siblings be shot dead by a rancher. And the rest of the book is just this poor cub wandering through a wilderness where every threat to him is not a wild threat, but a man-made threat. So he's dodging traps and other people with guns.

• 9:58Speaker 01

  Even the scent of man is said to be unsettling to him. So now, these grizzlies that were once seen as ferocious competitors on the landscape, things to fear, they're now fearing us.

• 10:13Speaker 01

  And what Seton's getting at is something that you see across the culture. People are really starting to feel conflicted about all the killing going on. We hated the bear and we feared the bear, but we also suddenly sort of wanted to give the bear a hug.

• 10:30Roman Mars?

  So this is the ideological war that is going on as the teddy bear arrives at our shores. What happens after that political cartoon and the teddy bear takes off the way it does? What happens when the teddy bear hits the market?

• 10:46Speaker 01

  It kickstarts this whole craze of teddy bears where within a few years, this German company, Steef, is said to be exporting a million bears a year. Suddenly, it's to the extent that there are newspaper editorials worrying about children playing with bears instead of dolls. They're displacing human dolls. And what could this mean? You can buy clothing for your bear. You can buy winter coats for your bear, which is astonishing because this, I sort of think of this as the moment that the evolutionary trajectory of teddy bears and regular bears splits, that your teddy bear now won't be warm unless it has a winter coat.

• 11:23Roman Mars?

  So this is the point in our story where people know that Theodore Roosevelt is not going to be president that much longer, and they need to figure out what to do next. Taft gets elected. He's sort of Teddy Roosevelt's handpicked successor, and they want a new cuddly play thing to sort of mark his presidency. So let's talk about the Billy Possum story. How did they come to deciding on a possum as the thing that would represent William Howard Taft?

• 11:53Speaker 01

  Right, so, once again, we're in the South. We're in Atlanta. So Taft is going to be inaugurated. He's doing a tour of the South, and he's the guest of honor at a banquet in Atlanta for the Atlanta Chamber of Commerce. And they really, they're pulling out all the stops. And they serve him this very particular Southern delicacy, you know, really seen as an authentic piece of the South, and it's called Possum and Taters. What we have is an opossum roasted whole, head on, tail still hanging off it like a meaty noodle, and it's on a platter surrounded by sweet potatoes.

• 12:32Speaker 01

  And in many cases, it would be served with a small sweet potato crammed into the opossum's mouth. And how many teeth does an opossum have, Roman? Do you remember? 50 teeth.

• 12:46Speaker 01

  So jammed in its 50 teeth, which is just a phenomenally disgusting number of teeth, is a small sweet potato. This thing is rolled out at the middle of the banquet. The one they put on Taft's table weighs 18 pounds. He eats it. After he's done, the band starts playing and a group of Taft supporters makes a big ceremony of giving him a surprise gift. And it's a small stuffed opossum toy. Very realistic with those kind of creepy beady eyes, the naked ears, the tail. They hand this thing over with great pomp.

• 13:30Speaker 01

  This is the icon of his presidency. This is it. This is the Billy Possum.

• 13:36Roman Mars?

  Billy Possum, as in William Howard Taft's possum. I mean, they had this whole manufacturing apparatus and marketing machine ready for this moment to make this work.

• 13:52Speaker 01

  Yeah, this is the launch. This is the activation. This is the Billy Possum activation, but all the groundwork has been laid. I read news reports about how within 24 hours, this company called the Georgia Billy Possum Company, which was already set up and ready to go, within 24 hours of the banquet, they're already brokering deals to distribute the toys all over the country. The LA Times covering this wrote, "The teddy bear has been relegated to a seat in the rear and for four years, possibly eight, the children of the United States will play with Billy Possums." So I actually found an advertisement for a toy store in Brooklyn that had a promotion where kids could come in and see a actual opossum in a cage so that they would just

• 14:37Speaker 01

  get more familiar with this thing that was going to be their cuddly pal for the next four years, possibly eight. And the ad read, "Do not let it be said that any man, woman, or child in Brooklyn has not seen the cute little animal whose name is mentioned more in all parts of the world today than any other." So yeah, very bullish on Billy Possums.

• 14:56Roman Mars?

  And not just the toys themselves, but there's all kinds of other merchandise associated, right?

• 15:00Speaker 01

  Merchandising.

• 15:03Speaker 01

  Yeah, there's like attendant Billy Possum merchandise to help make the craze go even wider. There was postcards, there was pictures for cream for coffee time. Taft supporters wore Billy Possum pins at his inauguration. And then as Taft is touring around the country, people are actually meeting him at railroad stations and appearances and handing over actual opossums like bouquets of flowers. There's a moment, a brief moment, when it's sort of an icon of the man.

• 15:35Roman Mars?

  And as you mentioned, this moment is brief. What happens to the Billy Possum?

• 15:40Speaker 01

  Almost nothing happens with the Billy Possum, to answer your question. From what I could tell, it's really just only a matter of months before there's no mention of it anywhere. Everyone stops caring about it, sales, tank. And remember that this all started in January of 1909. So that means the Billy Possum didn't even make it to Christmas. It didn't even get to see a Christmas season, which is sort of a special tragedy for a toy.

• 16:12Roman Mars?

  So, I mean, there might be some obvious answers to this, but I think there might be some non-obvious answers as to why the teddy bears took off and the Billy Possums didn't. What are your thoughts on that?

• 16:21Speaker 01

  Yeah, well, the obvious answer is that, you know, opossums are really ugly. It's a really long stretch, I think, to make one seem snugly and adorable or like something you want to take care of. I just don't think there's any getting around that fact. More interestingly, though, I also think that the possum lacked a story that had any resonance with Americans, even just subconsciously. I mean, when you think about it, for all of humans' evolutionary history, the bear was this icon. You know, it was fearsome, it was independent from us, and that's what made it so impressive. It was living a parallel life as a menace to us, as a competitor to us, in some ways our superior, more powerful than us.

• 17:06Speaker 01

  And now, at the time of the teddy bear, we've beaten that creature back to such a degree that it is... At our mercy, that its survival is going to be dependent on us. And I think that stirs up some really complicated emotions, you know, both worries about the future of nature, but also worries about our place in it. This new place where we really have a kind of brutal dominion over everything. I think that's really unsettling for a lot of people. There's this oscillation that happens between demonizing an animal and then eradicating it, and then suddenly empathizing with that animal as a kind of helpless underdog and rewriting its reputation in our minds as something innocent and sweet that needs our help.

• 17:50Roman Mars?

  This, you could say, is John's teddy bear versus Billy possum theory. That the reason we love the bear is because of this compelling, complex relationship we have with it. We feared the bear, we vilified the bear, we killed the bear, and then we felt so bad about killing the bear that now we wanted to save it. Whereas the possum really had none of that resonance.

• 18:12Speaker 01

  It was hard to feel anything for the opossum, good or bad.

• 18:15Roman Mars?

  Yeah.

• 18:15Speaker 01

  It was lacking of any kind of emotional import. The story with Taft was someone served him a dead opossum and he ate it. And he really loved it, too. You know, he had a few helpings and then he just kept going. And a doctor at his table actually passed him a note saying, maybe you should slow down. And the next day, Taft was bragging to reporters about it. He said, well, I like possum. I ate very heartily of it last night, and it did not disturb in the slightest my digestion or my sleep.

• 18:43Roman Mars?

  Yeah, he just obliterated it.

• 18:51Roman Mars?

  This episode is supported by Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Every design thing began as something someone imagined. A chair, a sign, whatever device you're listening to this on. Design is imagination with a plan. Claude is an AI built to help you with both. Start with your rough idea, then work with Claude to sketch it, shape it, test it, and build it. Anthropic built Claude to help you discover more. Learn more at claude.ai/99invisible.

• 19:23Roman Mars?

  Comes from Amazon Business. When it comes to your business, procurement shouldn't be a guessing game. Whether you're running a small business or managing a large organization, Amazon Business offers smart purchasing experiences designed to meet your unique needs. Smart tech, smarter decisions. Streamline your buying process, save time and money, and gain valuable insights. Amazon Business empowers you and your team to buy with confidence. Learn more at amazonbusiness.com. Instagram teen accounts have automatic protections on by default. Built-in content settings for the content teens can see, contact limits for who can contact them, and time management tools like daily time limits and sleep mode. Teens are automatically placed into teen accounts,

• 20:07Roman Mars?

  and teens under 16 will need a parent's permission to change any of these settings to be less strict. Instagram will continue adding built-in safety features to help create age-appropriate experiences. Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at instagram.com/teenaccounts. Ready to give your home a style refresh? Article makes it easy to create a stylish, long-lasting home at an unbeatable price. They offer a curated selection of mid-century modern coastal and Scandi-inspired pieces that will make a perfect addition to your home. All Article collections are carefully curated, focusing solely on high-quality, meaningful pieces that will stand the test of time. And with Article's 30-day satisfaction guarantee, you can shop with confidence.

• 20:52Roman Mars?

  I'm trying to think of any of the Article furniture I haven't talked about at this point. I have couches. I have dining room sets. I have sideboards. I have, what do you call it? A media center? Thing that you put a TV on? Side tables, end tables, chairs. All of them are still in heavy use in my house, and all of them have held up great. Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com/99 and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com/99 for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.

• 21:30Roman Mars?

  So we laid out this pattern of oscillation between exterminating animals and then empathizing with them. That pattern repeats throughout the 20th century. And during that time, animals start to become useful symbols for fights about the environment. Take the bald eagle. It was nearly wiped out from overhunting and the use of the pesticide DDT. And then, people clocked that it was going extinct and turned it into the face of a big campaign against DDT. A big, successful campaign. The same thing happened with the spotted owl and the logging industry. But all of those environmental fights were nothing compared to the existential threat that the planet was facing in the early 2000s.

• 22:14Speaker 01

  You know, it's interesting, in 2005, I remember being in graduate school at Berkeley and watching with a class the aftermath of Katrina, Hurricane Katrina, and seeing New Orleans flooded and realizing for the first time that there was a sort of general understanding that like, oh, you know, this is, this has to do with climate change.

• 22:34Roman Mars?

  As the evidence for climate change started to stack up, climate activists and attorneys were trying to get the government to do something about it.

• 22:42Speaker 01

  And so what happens in the early 2000s is you have a group of environmental attorneys who have been struggling for years to try to get the George W. Bush administration to act on climate change, or even just to acknowledge the science around greenhouse gases.

• 22:57Roman Mars?

  But so far, all of their attempts have largely failed. What could they do to make the issue urgent enough to get the public outraged and the government to act?

• 23:08Speaker 01

  They needed some kind of emotional trigger, something that was going to not just make climate change feel real and urgent in an intellectual way, but that would cut through the kind of busyness of people's lives and make them care.

• 23:23Roman Mars?

  An emotional trigger, something people could care about, something like an animal.

• 23:30Speaker 01

  You had environmental attorneys who were just in the trenches suing the administration. And one of these groups, the Center for Biological Diversity, hit upon this pretty ingenious idea. And that was to get a species listed as endangered under the U.S. Endangered Species Act, specifically because of the threat of climate change to its survival.

• 23:52Roman Mars?

  Here's why the plan is ingenious. Because by law, if a species is listed as endangered, then the government is legally bound to look at what is threatening its survival.

• 24:01Speaker 01

  They could put that science in front of the administration. They would essentially force its hand to do what it had not wanted to do in other contexts, which was to affirm the validity of climate change.

• 24:11Roman Mars?

  No more dodging or dismissing. But to make this work, the activists feel like they have to really find the perfect animal. So basically, they start a casting process.

• 24:20Speaker 01

  And a good candidate on that front is going to be two things. It's going to have a lot of solid science backing it up to say that, yes, this thing will go extinct because of climate change. And it's going to be something that ordinary people care about. Because if there isn't the public interest, no matter how good the science is, the administration did have ways of shunting that animal off into a bureaucratic abyss and not having to deal with it.

• 24:46Roman Mars?

  In fact, hundreds and hundreds of species were sitting in a backlog, waiting to be looked at by the government. Species that the public had never even heard of.

• 24:57Speaker 01

  The Neosho muckit mussel and the Slabside pearly mussel, the Band-rumped storm petrel, the spotless crepe, the relic leopard frog. We've got a whole list of cave beetles. The Icebox cave beetle, Fowler's cave beetle, the Chyra cave beetle, the Tatum cave beetle. And at the time, in 2013, when I was looking into this, at least 24 different species had actually gone extinct while they were waiting around on the candidate list.

• 25:23Roman Mars?

  Wow.

• 25:23Speaker 01

  And essentially, no one cared about them. These things could just pass into oblivion unnoticed, even though they had been deemed worthy of protection.

• 25:34Speaker 01

  And that's what the Center for Biological Diversity was trying to avoid. That's why they needed the public behind them so that whatever they petitioned the government for wouldn't just slip away silently.

• 25:46Roman Mars?

  So they needed a good candidate, but they also needed one whose survival was really linked to climate change. And this was harder than you might think because, remember, this is the early 2000s and we're just starting to get a grasp on climate change. And there are very few actual studies that have been done about its impact on specific species.

• 26:06Speaker 01

  So they went looking for species and a lot of the candidates they came up with were way more billy possum than teddy bear. The first animal that the Center for Biological Diversity looked at was called the Glacier Bay Wolf Spider. Okay, so it's a spider. It's disgusting. Second of all, it turns out there was some uncertainty about whether it was even its own species, so that one gets tossed out. Next, they have this kind of small speckled seabird in Alaska called the Kitlitz's murelet, which is, you know, I guess it could be sold as cute, but you were working an uphill battle there. You had to first introduce people to it. It's hard to say. There was exactly one expert in the bird, as far as I could tell.

• 26:48Speaker 01

  So these two species, even if you could make a strong scientific case, they're missing that wow factor. It wasn't going to inspire the public interest and the public concern that was going to make this petition go forward.

• 27:03Roman Mars?

  So a spider wasn't going to do, a murelet wasn't going to do, no cave beetle is going to get the public upset. Where did they end up landing as their sort of animal that was going to help combat climate change?

• 27:17Speaker 01

  The polar bear.

• 27:18Roman Mars?

  It's right there in front of you the whole time.

• 27:20Speaker 01

  They got the polar bear. They got the, I mean, fortunately, in 2004, I believe it was, luckily enough, you had a really definitive first paper by a researcher named Andrew Durocher linking climate change to the near future extinction of polar bears. Polar bears survive on sea ice for most of the year. That's where they live and they hunt seals. Out on the sea ice and as the sea ice broke up earlier and earlier in certain parts of the Arctic or subarctic or just disappeared entirely from other places, you know, the entire platform where they walk around making their living was just going to be gone.

• 27:55Roman Mars?

  I mean, like, if you're trying to decide if you are a billy possum or if you're a teddy bear, let's run the polar bear through the teddy bear test, okay? So like, what are the things that it checks that make it appropriate to be the type of thing that we would rally around and love and want to make dolls of and hold?

• 28:12Speaker 01

  Yeah, I think it's operating on two levels, you know, the surface level, cute, brown face, you know, you can imagine it as a plush toy. It's no Glacier Bay wolf spider. And then on a deeper level, you have identical forces that were operating with the teddy bear story where you have a creature that was regarded as this really powerful, independent lord of the Arctic. And now it's being shown in a completely new light as helpless, as dependent on us for help, as living in this world that is literally trickling out from underneath it because of things that we've done.

• 28:49Roman Mars?

  Yeah, we have killed the polar bear off and now we need to save the polar bear.

• 28:54Speaker 01

  Yeah, I mean, you know, I would read accounts of polar bears from back in history and you would see, you know, a few hundred years ago, like Arctic explorers and they'd be writing about this thing like it was a demon, you know, stories about it's like a polar bear, I don't know if this is true, but it says something just that these stories would be recited, you know, a polar bear jumps into a guy's boat and tries to eat them all, even when he lights the bear on fire. And you've gone from that into something on the cover of time where it's this, you know, sad, thin polar bear walking on a strip of ice surrounded by water with the headline, be worried, be very worried.

• 29:31Roman Mars?

  The polar bear had the science and it had the potential to capture the public. And if the climate activists won their petition, it would be a landmark case, the first species to be protected explicitly because of climate change. And right away, the public seemed to respond.

• 29:49Speaker 01

  The day after the Center for Biological Diversity and other groups filed this petition to get the polar bear listed as endangered, it was immediately splashed on the MSNBC homepage, on CNN. It really got a kind of coverage that you had not seen endangered species and climate change getting in a while. One TV broadcast called it "A Shining White Symbol of the Green Movement."

• 30:15Roman Mars?

  And one of my favorites from this time is the Vanity Fair cover.

• 30:19Speaker 01

  Yeah, so at this time, there was a famous polar bear cub at a German zoo named Neut. He was adorable, flashy, charismatic creature, and he was paired with another flashy, charismatic creature, Leonardo DiCaprio, and photographed by Annie Leibowitz for Vanity Fair.

• 30:40Roman Mars?

  But the public didn't just care about Leonardo DiCaprio. They cared about the petition that was now on the Bush administration's desk.

• 30:47Speaker 01

  This set a record at the time for the most public comments ever sent to the government for endangered species petitions. They got a half a million letters and postcards and messages. A lot of them were from kids. You had drawings of like a polar bear. I found one of a polar bear that's drowning, and then it's also being eaten simultaneously by a lobster and a shark. You had letters saying, this fourth grader in Oakland wrote, "I really think it is not fair to the polar bears. Also, they could drown and die off. And what if they were you?" I liked another one from a kid named Fritz, who he's actually proposes a solution to climate change. She's like all in on an ethanol-based solution. He says, "I feel bad about the polar bears. I like polar bears. Everyone can use corn

• 31:32Speaker 01

  juice for cars," from Fritz.

• 31:37Roman Mars?

  Good point, Fritz.

• 31:38Speaker 01

  Yeah, Fritz was ahead of his time. You know, it's like, I grew up in the 80s. To the extent that I thought about polar bears, I did not think about polar bears the way Fritz does, or the way Juan, who wrote about the polar bears drowning. It's just a completely different creature at that point.

• 31:53Roman Mars?

  The plan was working, and the hope was that if this many people cared about the polar bear, politicians would have to care too.

• 32:01Speaker 01

  One of the attorneys for the Center for Biological Diversity, he was talking about the cultural power of the polar bear and said something like, "No politician wants to tell their constituency, 'Yes, I voted to kill the polar bear.'"

• 32:14Roman Mars?

  And how did the politicians respond to all this public pressure?

• 32:19Speaker 01

  They were really actually able to wiggle out of it. So the Bush administration, they were able to find another kind of procedural loophole. Basically, they were able to list the polar bear as a threatened species rather than an endangered species, and then they could apply something called a 4D exception to it. And basically, that was just a legalistic way of saying that these arms of the federal government that are responsible for endangered species just didn't have the power or the ability to regulate greenhouse gases. And so we can't really, we can't really welcome the polar bear in the ranks of creatures that we're going to save right now.

• 32:55Roman Mars?

  Meaning, sure, the polar bear's existence might be threatened by climate change, but the Endangered Species Act can't force the government to do what it would take to save the polar bear, which would be regulating greenhouse gases.

• 33:07Speaker 01

  The Secretary of the Interior at the time, Dirk Kempfthorin, that's who oversees the Endangered Species Program, said in a press conference that he wasn't going to let a law about animals be, quote, "abused to make global warming policies." So this set off like a slew of other lawsuits and, you know, arguing about even the difference between endangered and threatened and back and forth and back and forth for years between the Center for Biological Diversity and the Bush administration and then the Obama administration, until essentially, you know, despite the public outcry, despite the public sympathy for the polar bear, the entire issue just kind of got lost in this rabbit warren of lawsuits and counter lawsuits and semantic rebutting.

• 33:48Roman Mars?

  It is striking to me that, you know, we have this really powerful symbol of climate change, like the perfect teddy bear candidate, you know, for getting Americans to care about the relationship with nature, declare about climate change in particular, and it still gets outmaneuvered. It fails. I mean, do you think that the polar bear wasn't up for the task here, or were we asking the polar bear to do too much?

• 34:14Speaker 01

  I think it's important to go back to the original intent of that endangered species petition. You know, the original intent wasn't necessarily to birth a mascot for the climate change movement that would lead the federal government and some of the most entrenched and powerful corporate interests to suddenly change their way of doing business. The intent was simply to find a kind of a legal backdoor with that first endangered species petition. You know, it wasn't part of the plan to have it on the cover of Vanity Fair, right? With Leonardo DiCaprio. But it was like the bear was just so damn charismatic that everyone just kind of lost their minds about it.

• 34:52Roman Mars?

  Also, the teddy bear phenomenon, it really didn't ask people to do too much. Like, the people carried on with their sort of exploitation of the West and hunting. You know, maybe it wasn't done with quite such complete eradication agenda. But like, the teddy bear didn't ask much of us.

• 35:09Speaker 01

  That cartoon of Roosevelt in 1902, it takes 71 years from that moment to get the Endangered Species Act, which actually proposes a way to help that animal.

• 35:22Speaker 01

  So, you know, I'd like action on climate change to happen a lot faster. But I do think it's, we're letting a lot of powerful people off the hook if we start to wonder, you know, what was wrong with the polar bear?

• 35:37Speaker 01

  I mean, dealing with climate change, I mean, we see it much more clearly now than I think we did in the early 2000s, right? There was this feeling back then that, you know, if we just got people to accept it and care, we would just solve this thing. And I think that that's proven to be pretty naive. It's not just an environmental issue, it's, you know, a housing issue, it's a migration issue, it's an economic issue, it's a social justice issue. It's hard to just undo that, just because enough people want to. So I think it's naive to think that the polar bear could have, you know, solved climate change. And therefore, I think it's naive to say that it was a failure because it didn't.

• 36:18Roman Mars?

  One thing you can say for sure is that the polar bear got a lot of people to care about climate change who didn't before. It successfully became a symbol for an entire movement. But the problem with making any animal a symbol is that you can lose control of it. Climate change deniers started focusing on the polar bear too, using it to debunk the claims that it was in danger.

• 36:40Speaker 01

  Because there was a sense that if you could prove that polar bears were going to be okay, you were also disproving climate change. I talked to one researcher who was researching snow geese and he made an argument in his scientific paper that this one population of polar bears, if there was no ice for them to live on for longer and longer periods of time of the year, they could probably subsist by eating snow goose eggs. And this poor guy suddenly was embraced by climate deniers, which he wasn't. And other polar bear scientists were upset with him, not as far as I could tell because his science was bad, but because he was sort of giving ammunition to the other side. So the symbol in some sense became the issue.

• 37:24Roman Mars?

  Yeah.

• 37:25Speaker 01

  And we kind of lost sight of what it was all about. It's very dangerous, I think, when we start to mistake symbols for the whole reality. In a way, they're like these psychic pack animals. We just heap a lot of our feelings onto their backs and whatever we say about them, they just always have no comment.

• 38:00Roman Mars?

  Do you think there's any hope for the opossum to be something that we love the way that they wanted us to love it back in the play opossum days?

• 38:08Speaker 01

  It's not too late, I guess. Maybe as more and more creatures disappear, there will be a time in the future when people will think nostalgically about all the opossums that raided their trash cans and think of them as just, well, they were just trying to get by and now we owe it to them.

• 38:33Roman Mars?

  And that's our show. Our expert of all things Billy Possum and the polar bear was journalist John Moella. He's the author of many books, including Wild Ones, a sometimes dismaying, weirdly reassuring story about looking at people looking at animals in America.

• 39:02Roman Mars?

  A History of the United States in 100 Objects is a production of 99% Invisible and BBC Studios. It's hosted and curated by me, Roman Mars. This episode was produced by Brenna Dahl-Dorf. Our other producers are Priscilla Alabie and Ellie Lightfoot. Our associate producer is Isaac Fisher. This series was edited by Annie Brown and Courtney Harrell. Mixing by Charlie Brandon King. Fact checking by Amy Bracken. Our theme song is by Swan Real. From 99% Invisible, our executive producer is Cathy Too. From BBC Studios, our executive producers are Annie Brown and Courtney Harrell. Our production coordinator is Shan Pelé, and the production manager is Mabel Finnegan-Wright. Artwork by Stefan Lawrence.

• 39:48Roman Mars?

  99% Invisible is part of the SiriusXM Podcast family headquartered in beautiful Uptown, Oakland, California. And BBC Studios is headquartered in beautiful White City, West London. If you want to get in touch or have an object for us to consider, email us at [email protected].

• 40:35Roman Mars?

  This episode is presented by Air France. Air France Business Cabin offers comfort from start to finish. Enjoy priority check-in and boarding, followed by access to peaceful lounges. Onboard, savour menus created by renowned French chefs, paired with wines and champagne selected by a sommelier. Stay connected with free high-speed Wi-Fi. Then unwind in a fully adjustable lie-flat bed with a mattress topper developed with Sofitel My Bed, a signature touch of French hospitality. The art of travel elevated. Because Air France Business Cabin goes further in every detail to make your journey exceptional.