250 Years of Bad Decisions: SCOTUS, the Civil War, and the End of Reconstruction
Hosted by Michael Liroff and Peter Shamshiri
- 54m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This is part one of a three-part series for America's 250th birthday, in which hosts Peter Shamshiri, Rhiannon Hamam, and Michael Liroff, joined by Penn Law professor Kermit Roosevelt, examine how the Supreme Court moved the country away from its founding ideals from the pre-Civil War era through the end of Reconstruction. The episode covers five cases: Dred Scott (1857), the Slaughterhouse Cases (1873), the Civil Rights Cases (1883), Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), and Giles v. Harris (1903).
The central argument is that the Court functioned as a pressure release valve for post-Civil War political pressure on the South. Rather than upholding the Reconstruction Amendments or forcing a political confrontation, the Court was conciliatory in nearly every case—striking down the Civil Rights Act of 1875, gutting the privileges and immunities clause, and legitimizing segregation. Kermit Roosevelt argues that the Reconstruction Amendments, not the Founding, are the true source of American national values like equality, and that the Confederates should have been treated like the Loyalists after the Revolution rather than welcomed back into full political power.
The episode is notable for its specific legal analysis of how each case could have been decided differently, and for Roosevelt's argument that the Reconstruction-era Court was actually doing what courts are supposed to do—representing elite consensus—while the current Court is out of step with national majority opinion.
- The Slaughterhouse Cases effectively destroyed the privileges and immunities clause of the 14th Amendment by limiting it to access to seaports and sub-treasuries, a holding that still stands. 22:19
- The Compromise of 1877, which withdrew federal troops from the South, was the pivotal moment that broke the back of Reconstruction and allowed white supremacist paramilitaries to overthrow integrated governments. 25:41
- Kermit Roosevelt argues the Supreme Court during Reconstruction acted as a pressure release valve, relieving political pressure on the South rather than on the underclass being re-enslaved. 45:00
- The Reconstruction Amendments, not the Founding, are the true source of American national values like equality and democracy as commitments that override state preferences. 49:44
- Plessy v. Ferguson was decided 8-1, indicating that the legal elite of the era viewed racial segregation as the natural order rather than a constitutional violation. 36:48
Highlights
- 7:55
Freedom Suits as First Civil Rights Casesinsight
Rhiannon identifies the enslaved people who filed freedom suits in St. Louis over decades before the Civil War as some of the country's first civil rights litigants, a framing that reframes Dred Scott's history.
- 10:10
Dred Scott as Activist Overreachinsight
Kermit argues the core problem with Dred Scott is not just the bad constitution but Taney reaching beyond what was needed to decide, swinging for the fences on the nation's most divisive issue.
- 18:57
The Radicalism of Reconstructioninsight
Kermit explains that Congress had to wipe out ten former Confederate states and create new governments to ratify the 14th Amendment, completely inverting the Founders' assumption that states protect liberty and the national government threatens it.
- 22:19
Slaughterhouse Gutting Privileges and Immunitiesdata
The Slaughterhouse Cases reduced the privileges and immunities clause to protecting access to seaports and sub-treasuries, a holding that gives the clause nothing of practical value to this day.
- 25:41
Compromise of 1877 Ends Reconstructionstory
The deal that gave Hayes the presidency in exchange for withdrawing federal troops from the South broke the back of Reconstruction, after which Democrats swept back to power through massacres and military coups.
- 36:03
Plessy's Distinct Constitutional Flawinsight
Kermit distinguishes Plessy from Dred Scott: Plessy doesn't do violence to the Constitution's text but instead looks at a racist law and declares it reasonable, reflecting the elite consensus of the era.
- 45:00
Court Representing Elite Consensusinsight
Kermit argues the Reconstruction-era Court was doing what courts are supposed to do—representing the political coalition that appointed them—while the current Court is out of step with national majority opinion due to the appointment process.
- 51:02
Confederates Should Have Been Treated Like Loyalistsstrategy
Kermit argues that after the Revolution, the Loyalists were driven from the country and their property redistributed, but the Confederates were welcomed back with full political power, a choice that has harmed the country's ability to fulfill its equality values.
About this episode
In honor of America’s birthday, join Peter, Rhiannon, Michael and University of Pennsylvania Law Professor Kermit Roosevelt as they talk through how the Supreme Court greased the wheels for the end of Reconstruction and the rise of Jim Crow. Check out Kermit’s book The Nation That Never Was: Reconstructing America’s Story. https://smile.amazon.com/Nation-That-Never-Was-Reconstructing/dp/022681761X If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To hear this and other Premium-only episodes, access to our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support http://fivefourpod.com/support. 5 to 4 is presented by Prologue Projects. This episode was produced by Allison Rodgers. Leon Neyfakh provides editorial support. Our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations. Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On BlueSky, find Peter @notalawyer.bsky.social, Michael @fleerultra.bsky.social, and Rhiannon @aywarhiannon.bsky.social. Our Sponsors: * Check out Mint Mobile and use my code mintmobile.com/fivefour for a great deal: https://www.mintmobile.com * Check out Quince and use my code FIVEFOUR for a great deal: https://www.quince.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Transcript
9,485 words · 5 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Supreme Court History
- Reconstruction Era
- Dred Scott
- Plessy v. Ferguson
- Civil Rights
- Judicial Activism
- Constitutional Law
- Jim Crow
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated