EP 231: FLORIDA - THE CONSPIRING COWORKER: The Killing of Joleen Cummings

Mother of three Joleen Cummings would never miss a Mother’s Day with her children. When she vanished without a trace on May 12th, 2018, police instantly believed they knew what had happened: Her estranged husband had killed her. It was a tragic tale as old as time, a case they expected to have solved by lunchtime. But very quickly — things changed. As they unraveled the threads of Joleen’s vibrant life, they came face to face with a horrible reality: Sometimes, it’s the last person you suspect. And sometimes, that person isn’t at all who they say they are. - Sources:https://docs.google.com/document/d/1eTYeCoYyxm58DXXdoFbHQyWHlWbcH9iKGIefFcQToW4/edit?tab=t.y2yayotxnlcb Listen to our new show, "THE CONSPIRACY FILES"!: -Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/5IY9nWD2MYDzlSYP48nRPl -Apple Podcasts - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-conspiracy-files/id1752719844 -Amazon/Audible - https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/ab1ade99-740c-46ae-8028-b2cf41eabf58/the-conspiracy-files -Pandora - https://www.pandora.com/podcast/the-conspiracy-files/PC:1001089101 -iHeart - https://iheart.com/podcast/186907423/ -PocketCast - https://pca.st/dpdyrcca -CastBox - https://castbox.fm/channel/id6193084?country=us - Stay Connected: Join the Murder in America fam in our free Facebook Community for a behind-the-scenes look, more insights and current events in the true crime world: https://www.facebook.com/groups/4365229996855701 If you want even more Murder in America bonus content, including ad-free episodes, come join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/murderinamerica Instagram: http://instagram.com/murderinamerica/ Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/people/Murder-in-America-Podcast/100086268848682/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/MurderInAmerica TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@theparanormalfiles and https://www.tiktok.com/@courtneybrowen Feeling spooky? Follow Colin as he travels state to state (and even country to country!) investigating claims of extreme paranormal activity and visiting famous haunted locations on The Paranormal Files Official Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheParanormalFilesOfficialChannel - (c) BLOOD IN THE SINK PRODUCTIONS 2026 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  Hey Spotify listeners! When you travel with American Airlines, you'll enjoy comfort and convenience at every altitude. Before takeoff, unwind in the Admirals Club Lounge with curated self-serve offerings of hearty bites and refreshments. In-flight, stay connected with high-speed Wi-Fi, sponsored by AT&T. Your journey is designed to feel easy from the moment you check in to the moment you arrive. No matter where you're going, American gets you there. Book now at aa.com.

• 0:26Speaker 01

  Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high-fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a Berry Chantilly Cake. Ready-to-cook pizza? No antibiotics ever chicken wings. And sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.

• 0:54Speaker 02

  So good, so good, so good.

• 0:56Speaker 03

  Cashmere, outerwear, and boots are up to 60% off at Nordstrom Rack. Save on brands like Ugg, Vince, and Kohlhaan. Join the naughty club for free to unlock exclusive discounts. Great brands, great prices. That's why you rack.

• 1:12Colin Brown?

  Warning: The following podcast is not suitable for all audiences. We go into great detail with every case that we cover and do our best to bring viewers even deeper into the stories by utilizing disturbing audio and sound effects.

• 1:24Courtney Brown?

  Trigger warnings from the stories we cover may include violence, rape, murder, and offenses against children.

• 1:30Colin Brown?

  This podcast is not for everyone. You have been warned.

• 1:36Courtney Brown?

  May 13th, 2018 was supposed to be a day of celebration. Joleen Cummings wasn't just excited to spend Mother's Day with her three beautiful children. She was also thrilled to be turning 34. It was going to be a day surrounded by all of her loved ones, playing with her kids, praising her own mom for raising her so well, and taking a look with pride at the life she had created for herself. It was a day she wouldn't miss for anything in the world. So? Where was she? As the days logged on, each passing minute felt like a knife to the stomach for Jolene's loved ones. She hadn't called. She hadn't texted. Her car was nowhere to be found.

• 2:21Courtney Brown?

  It was as if overnight, she had vanished. Her disappearance was disturbing enough, but the investigation that followed would prove to be one of the most convoluted and terrifying cases that Nassau County had ever seen. It was a case twisted by violence, aliases, jealousy, and hatred, all leading to a suspect who police never expected, and one who they quickly learned wasn't at all what they seemed. This is the story of Joleen Cummings, who was above all, a loving mother, taken far too soon. I'm Courtney Brown.

• 2:58Colin Brown?

  And I'm Colin Brown.

• 3:00Courtney Brown?

  And you're listening to Murder in America.

• 4:03Colin Brown?

  It was Mother's Day, May 13th, 1984, and Ann Johnson was in a hospital in Nassau County, Florida, holding the greatest Mother's Day gift of all. Her daughter, Jolene Rebecca Jensen, gazed up at her with big, green eyes, full of wonder and determination. The hospital had been a heart-wrenching place for Ann. The last time she was in one, her son, Richard Jensen, was born sleeping. The day that she brought him into the world was the very same day she realized she was going to be burying him, which is the worst kind of pain that a mother can experience. Yet, around a year later, here was Jolene, bright-eyed, curious, beautiful, breathing peacefully and looking up at her.

• 4:46Colin Brown?

  Now, Ann was experiencing the greatest joy a mom can ever have, holding her baby in her arms and knowing that she's going to be okay. From that moment, Jolene, who came to be known as JoJo, was inseparable from her mother. The two were mirror images of one another, and their bond was something special. Jolene became her mom's everything, and she was an easy kid to love. As soon as Jolene learned to talk, she didn't stop. From the get-go, she didn't hesitate to show the world who she was and fill it with light everywhere she went. Everyone who knew her described her as social, energetic, and fun, always looking for a good time. When she was younger, the first thing she did when she woke up was rush to the beach, just down the street from her home.

• 5:30Colin Brown?

  There, she spent long hours in the sun, running around with her siblings. As the oldest child, Jolene became the ringleader, always urging her younger brother and sister towards adventures with her, and always promising to be there for them if times were tough. When she wasn't at the beach, going to cheerleading practice, or spending time with her family, she was going to church. Jolene's parents, Ann and her stepfather, Connie Johnson, were both strong in their faith, and not just in the scripture, but in truly following the love and respect that's promoted in it. Ann taught Jolene to love all people regardless of sexual identity, race, income, or struggles. Jolene had her own Bible, where she drew hearts around verses that meant the most to her.

• 6:12Colin Brown?

  One verse she circled, in particular, paints a picture of who she was and what she believed. It reads, "Love must be sincere. Hate what is evil, cling to what is good. Be devoted to one another in brotherly love. Honor one another above yourselves." It's something that Jolene seemed to carry all of her life, which is just one part of why she was surrounded by people who loved her. One of Jolene's best friends, Alma Powers, told Snapped she had a large group of friends. Everybody loved Jolene.

• 6:43Speaker 06

  Always a smile. I've never seen her cry over anything. And that was, that was an inspiration to me.

• 6:47Courtney Brown?

  And it wasn't just Alma that Jolene was an inspiration to. It seemed that she became a beacon of light for many. She believed in loyalty, justice, and above all else, love. It was widely known that whenever someone around Jolene was wronged, she was the first to stand up for them.

• 7:06Speaker 07

  She'd always be like, "Why are you letting him talk to you like that or do that to you? Like, you can't do that." So I miss that about her.

• 7:15Courtney Brown?

  In high school, Jolene worked as a waitress at a local spot called Country Cabin. She was hardworking and well-liked at her job. Unfortunately, it wasn't as easy for newcomers. When teenager Lindsay O'Quinn started working the cash register there, the environment was far from welcoming. You know what it's like when you get your very first job. You don't know what you're doing, or how to act, or how to ask for help. Dread followed Lindsay every time she walked into the building. And unfortunately, some of the waitresses sniffed out that anxiety. When Lindsay did something as simple as fumbling change, some of the daytime waitresses would scoff at her. Instantly, Lindsay would feel that shame crash over her.

• 8:00Courtney Brown?

  But then, a voice would pipe up from behind. "Back off, Lindsay's doing just fine." She turned around to see Jolene offering her a kind smile, while she gave the other waitresses a sour look, one that dared them to try to be mean to the new girl again. Jolene always stood up for the underdog, and for anyone who needed it. Lindsay, for example, was a teenage mother of three who never really had a life outside of motherhood. But according to her, Jolene helped her break out of her shell. She made her feel like she was part of a friend group. She encouraged her to speak her mind, and she even took her out for New Year since she had never been. There, the two laughed, danced all night,

• 8:43Courtney Brown?

  and made memories that still bring Lindsay a smile to this day. It was hard not to let your real self loose with Jolene. She was not judgmental, and she carried a kind, calm, and confident energy with her, one that rubbed off on anyone around her.

• 8:59Colin Brown?

  Which is part of the reason she decided to become a hairdresser. Jolene was a people person. She loved encouraging those around her and making them feel beautiful. So, in 2002, after graduating from high school, she enrolled in a cosmetology school in Jacksonville. Her dream was to open up her own salon one day, to create a safe space for anyone who entered, so she dug her heels in to accomplish that as soon as possible. But as you know, despite our best efforts, sometimes life leads us down another path. And the path that life led Jolene down as she entered her twenties, well, it was an even better path than the one she had imagined. You see, in the tail end of high school, Jolene began a relationship with a classmate named David. Like any first love, they had their ups and downs,

• 9:44Colin Brown?

  but they were both resolute about one thing: they cared about one another. Even more so, they cared about their daughter, who was born when Jolene was 24.

• 9:54Courtney Brown?

  The minute that Jolene looked into her daughter's eyes, nothing else mattered. When her relationship with David crumbled soon after her daughter was born, she knew that she would do whatever it took to give her baby girl the best life possible, just like her mother had done for her. So, Jolene hit the ground running and decided to make a name for herself as a cosmetologist. She picked up a job at Tangle's Hair Salon in Fernadina Beach, where she worked long, hard hours. Fortunately, it didn't take her long to develop a loyal client base there. In Jolene's chair, people felt comfortable telling their secrets. They would complain to her about their life's problems, and she'd always give them an ear to listen.

• 10:38Courtney Brown?

  Many of her clients referred to her as "a hairapist", because she was so talented not just at doing people's hair, but giving them advice. According to her coworkers, you'd always hear bouts of laughter echo throughout the salon from Jolene and her clients. It's just the kind of person she was. One of her clients, Donna, shared a memory of what it was like to have her, not just as a hairstylist, but a friend. Now Donna's mother had memory issues and she was her caretaker. In that week Donna was exhausted. As her mother's condition worsened, she found herself answering the same questions all day, time and time again.

• 11:20Courtney Brown?

  It was something she was used to, but not everyone is as patient with someone that has memory problems. When Donna was looking for a hair salon to bring her mother to, she was worried that the stylist might get annoyed at her mom's constant questions. But as soon as they sat down with Jolene, Donna's fears washed away. "So, how long have you been doing this?" her mom asked. Jolene smiled at her, saying, "A few years." Less than a minute later, the same question came. "So, how long have you been doing this?" Again, Jolene smiled and answered her question time and time again. Donna felt her whole body relax. It's not often, as a caretaker, that you can trust someone with your loved one, but

• 12:05Courtney Brown?

  patience and kindness just seemed to radiate off Jolene. She talked to her mother with grace and respect, and she even urged Donna to go take some time for herself. "Why don't you go to the thrift store next door and do some shopping?" she suggested. "I've got things over here, don't worry." It was a blessing that Donna didn't even know she was missing. Not only did she get a few moments to herself, but she got to see her mom respected and cared for.

• 12:33Colin Brown?

  Jolene had a long list of clients who grew to love her, and ones who also grew to love Jolene's daughter. Whenever Jolene couldn't find a babysitter, she would bring her daughter to the salon. Even as a toddler, she was well behaved and respectful. While her mom was working on clients, she would practice braiding the hair on mannequins, claiming that she wanted to be just like her mama, and proudly showing off her work to her mom and her clients. For the clients, it was just another reason to trust and love Jolene. Looking at the way her daughter adored her, it was hard not to feel the same way. Which is, actually, how Jolene stumbled upon the last thing she was looking for during this period of her life: a husband.

• 13:14Colin Brown?

  Life as a single mom is challenging, and trying to save money, Jolene decided to get a roommate. In 2012, after posting on Facebook, she learned that her childhood friend, Jason Cummings, was also looking for a roommate. Now, Jason and Jolene grew up together in the same neighborhood. He had gone to school with her all the way up through graduation. So for her, he seemed like the perfect fit. She knew his family, knew he was trustworthy, and knew that they got along. When Jason moved in, Jolene wasn't looking for a relationship, but fate had other plans.

• 13:48Courtney Brown?

  For months, Jason and Jolene got to know each other on a more personal level. He also got to see what an incredible mother she was. He watched Jolene dance around in the kitchen, singing with her daughter and encouraging her, telling her that she could be anything she wanted to be. It struck Jason. Seeing what an amazing mother she was made Jason fall head over heels with her. And soon, the feeling was mutual. He told News 4 Jacks, quote, "I moved in with her and we fell in love. The best time of my life," end quote. By late 2013, the two were married and had their first child together, a boy. Then in 2015, they completed their family with the birth of another son.

• 14:33Courtney Brown?

  For Jolene, motherhood was a blessing. She devoted all of her time to raising her three children. One of her good friends, Mariah Lorraine, told Snapped, quote, "She was so obsessed with those babies that nothing else mattered. Those kids came first," end quote. Now unfortunately, in 2017, after four years of marriage, her relationship with Jason started to sour. Wanting the best for their kids, the two mutually agreed to separate. It was a heartbreaking situation. Jolene was now a single mother of three with court proceedings, bills, and a custody arrangement on the horizon. As the divorce proceedings moved through the court, she and Jason established a temporary

• 15:17Courtney Brown?

  custody order where Jolene would have the boys for a week, and then Jason would have them for a week. According to Jolene's friends, every time she had to leave her boys, it was heartbreaking. And in the times that she did have them, she devoted everything to them. Her close friend Alma said in an interview with 50 Ways to Catch a Killer, quote, "Jolene loved her kids like it was so hard to get her away from them," end quote. Jolene's entire life revolved around her children. They were her greatest joy and her constant motivation to be the best version of herself. So, in spite of everything, she put a lot of her focus into her work so she could provide

• 16:00Courtney Brown?

  for her kids and give them a good life.

• 16:03Colin Brown?

  On the morning of May 12th, 2018, Jolene arrived at Tangle's bright and early to work a full shift. At work, all of her clients listened to Jolene excitedly tell them about her plans for the next day, which was Mother's Day. And not just that, it was Jolene's 34th birthday. The greatest gift she could ever imagine was spending the day with her kiddos. Though it was Jason's week with the boys, she was slated to pick them up the following morning so they could go to breakfast and enjoy a perfect day together. According to all of her clients, Jolene was in a cheery mood that day, and there was nothing out of the ordinary. But unbeknownst to everyone, including Jolene, once her last client walked out of the salon that day, she would never be seen again.

• 16:48Courtney Brown?

  The following morning, Jason Cummings paced in the parking lot of the Wynn Dixie in Hilliard. His heart thudded, and the annoyance that was boiling inside of him was becoming too much to bear. Not just because he was frustrated, but because, at the same time, he was scared. He glanced at his watch for the 100th time. Jolene was 30 minutes late to pick up the boys. Then 31 minutes. 32. She was never late to getting them, especially not on a day as special as today. So, with fear rising, Jason called Jolene. But, she didn't answer.

• 17:30Courtney Brown?

  He continued checking his watch, waiting on her to call him back, or to finally pull up in her car, but nothing.

• 17:39Courtney Brown?

  Again and again, he called Jolene, but the calls went straight to voicemail. Hoping that maybe, just maybe, her phone was broken. He decided to call Jolene's mother, Ann Johnson. And to his relief, she answered almost immediately. But the tone of her voice notched away any relief he was feeling in an instant. "Jason, are you with Jolene?" Jason's heart sank. Stunned, he told her, "No, I was calling to see if she was with you." The panic was palpable in both of their voices now. They wavered on the edge of hyperventilating as they discussed when they had last heard from Jolene. Ann hadn't heard from her since yesterday, despite having called and texted her.

• 18:24Courtney Brown?

  In fact, the previous night, she was so concerned by the fact that Jolene hadn't responded to her after work, that she had considered calling the police. Ann's husband, Jolene's stepfather, had calmed her down, reassuring her that Jolene was probably just busy getting ready for the joint birthday, Mother's Day celebration. But now, that possibility seemed completely out of the question. Right then, as Ann and Jason talked on the phone, they both knew, without a shadow of doubt, that Jolene would never flake on picking up her children, especially on such a special day. They both agreed that it was time to take the next step.

• 19:05Colin Brown?

  Ann tearfully called the police to report her daughter missing. And thankfully, they immediately took the report seriously. It helped that the office had a personal connection with Ann and her husband Connie. Both of them had worked at the Nassau County Sheriff's Office for years. The staff there were familiar with the family and their dynamics, and they knew the second that Ann called, that something was amiss. So, as soon as they got their report, their feet hit the pavement. They drove by the salon where Jolene worked and discovered that her car wasn't there. So maybe she was at home. From there, they raced to Jolene's trailer that had previously been known by her uncle. As they pulled up, they saw that her car wasn't parked there either. But hopefully, evidence from inside the trailer would give them some answers.

• 19:50Courtney Brown?

  As the officers walked through the threshold of Jolene's home, the state of it took their breath away. The kitchen cabinets hung at odd angles, dangling from a single hinge as if it had been ripped off. Holes marred the walls and doors of the home, each clearly from a punch. Immediately, a sobering feeling washed over the officers. It seemed very likely that they were standing in the scene of a violent altercation, one that may explain Jolene's sudden disappearance. So it's here, where detectives began looking into the people who would have had a motive to hurt her. And given the fact that Jolene was in a custody battle for her kids, it didn't take them long to have their very first suspect:

• 20:35Courtney Brown?

  her estranged husband, Jason. Thankfully, Jason agreed to speak with them. Around 8:30 a.m. on May 15th, Jason walked into the sheriff's office and sat down in the interrogation room. And what began as a discussion slowly turned into a tense argument. "Did you hurt her?" they asked. Jason was adamant that he had no involvement in Jolene's disappearance. He told them-

• 21:01Colin Brown?

  "I wouldn't threaten a woman. My dad would kick my ass all up and down this earth. And that's my kid's mom. What I do take seriously is my family."

• 21:09Courtney Brown?

  Jason went on to say that Jolene was a wonderful mother, and it was one of the many reasons he had fallen in love with her. But the police weren't so sure that he was telling the truth, especially after looking at he and Jolene's text messages. Here is one exchange they had shortly before her disappearance. "These kids have seen enough."

• 21:29Colin Brown?

  "See you in court, Jolene." With a kissy face emoji.

• 21:32Courtney Brown?

  In another exchange, Jason texted her this-

• 21:36Colin Brown?

  "I fucking hate you, and tomorrow you will hate me. I promise you that."

• 21:40Courtney Brown?

  Two detectives, these harsh words were a blazing red flag. They showed tension, rage, and above all, a motive. The two were clearly arguing over the custody of their children, and they both had strong feelings about their arrangement, which begged the question- How far would Jason go to get what he wanted?

• 22:02Colin Brown?

  But as suspicious as Jason's relationship with his estranged wife was, police eventually learned the truth. The harsh words they exchanged were just that: harsh words. The two were in pain. They loved their children, and at the time, Jason was wanting to move out of state. Something that only complicated the custody matters further. So, sure, the two were arguing, and Jason said horrible things he shouldn't have said, but that didn't mean he killed her. And he could prove it. Jason actually had an alibi for the entire day prior and the morning of Jolene's disappearance. Detectives also noted that he truly seemed distressed by her vanishing. He offered police any information he could give them, hid nothing, and, eventually, revealed to them something that wasn't widely known.

• 22:46Colin Brown?

  Jolene had recently started seeing a new man. His name was Jason "Ashley" G. And Jason Cummings was not a fan of him. He admitted to investigators, "I got text messages from other people saying he has bad news." Police didn't need an estranged husband's word on that, they had police records backing it up. Jason G., Jolene's new boyfriend, had a rap sheet in Nassau County that included drug charges and probation violations. But, the most interesting record of all included one from Thursday, May 9th. One that had been taken at Jolene's house. Five days before Cummings disappeared, her neighbor, who wants to remain anonymous, says she had to call 911 because she heard loud yelling between Cummings and her boyfriend.

• 23:30Courtney Brown?

  Something she's heard before, but she says this time, the altercation was worse. The neighbor told Action News Jack, quote, "I heard more stuff breaking than I heard him. Once I heard she was screaming at the kids to get into the room, that's when my alarm went off." End quote. And, for good reason. Because inside the trailer, absolute chaos was unfolding. That day, Jason had showed up unannounced, intending to stay the night. But Jolene had very different priorities. As soon as he walked in, she shook her head and firmly told him, "You can't stay here. You have outstanding warrants for violating your parole, and I can't let you jeopardize my custody arrangement with my children."

• 24:15Courtney Brown?

  At the end of the day, her kids came first, and because of that, Jason had to go. But Jason didn't take kindly to that demand. Jolene watched in horror as Jason stomped towards her, thrashing and knocking things off the counters in a fury. Worried for her daughter's safety, Jolene yelled over her shoulder, "Stay in your room. Just stay in your room." But the terror was rising. Jason reached up, grabbing the cabinet door, and he slammed it as hard as he could, so hard that the room shook and the door collapsed off its hinges. Jolene tried to calm him down, but at the same time, she wasn't the kind of girl to let a man talk poorly to her.

• 24:57Courtney Brown?

  She stood her ground, demanding that he go and leave her and her daughter alone. The tension was almost unbearable, until finally... As soon as the howl of police sirens pierced the air, Jason sprinted out the back door of the trailer, slamming it behind him. Jolene was scared to lose custody of her children, so when she approached the police, she told them that she didn't want to press charges. So, she didn't. But now, five days later, Jolene is missing. When the police read the report on this incident, they couldn't help but wonder if Jason was responsible. He had proven that he was violent. He had trashed her home in front of her daughter.

• 25:41Courtney Brown?

  It was clear that he wasn't in the right mind, and that made him the department's number-one new suspect in Jolene's disappearance.

• 25:49Colin Brown?

  But that, in itself, came with a new set of problems. For starters, the Nassau County Sheriff's Office couldn't find Jason G. His last-known address was a dead end, and when they tried to call the phone number they had on file for him, Jason immediately hung up when he realized it was a detective speaking to him, which is, obviously, not a great look when police are investigating you for the disappearance of your partner. This only heightened detectives' fears about Jason G, and with that fear came the realization that he was bound to run. In the days immediately following Jolene's disappearance, they spoke with relatives, friends, enemies, quite literally anyone who would have had any contact with Jason whatsoever, which brought them to a cozy home in Hillard, Florida on May 15th.

• 26:33Colin Brown?

  When Jason's aunt opened the door, police were able to barge past her. They had a warrant out for Jason's arrest, for his parole violation, and they had probable cause to believe that Jason was inside the home, meaning they didn't need a search warrant to enter. But as they raced through the home, going room by room, hearts thudding as they yelled at Jason to show himself, their concerns started to strengthen. Had they missed him? And if they hadn't, was he armed? Finally, police came to a back bedroom overflowing with trash. There was a flash of movement, and then, they spotted him. Jason G. cowering beneath a pile of cardboard boxes. Police tackled him and cuffed him, bringing him into custody. Of course, to them, he looked as guilty as ever.

• 27:16Colin Brown?

  To Jolene's family, his arrest was a relief. They hoped that Jason would be able to provide them answers as to what happened to Jolene, and they clung to the hope that she would somehow be found safe.

• 27:26Courtney Brown?

  But Jason's interrogation didn't go how anyone planned. During it, he insisted that he didn't even know Jolene was missing. He said he hadn't contacted her since the night he fled her house, five days before her disappearance. So next, the police ask him, "Why did you hang up on us when we called you the other day?" Jason said he had a parole violation. When detectives called him, he was positive that they were tracking his phone so they could try and hunt him down. Immediately after, he said he ripped the battery out of his phone so he could avoid detection, all because he didn't want to go back to jail. Now, as you can imagine, the police aren't buying a word of this.

• 28:10Courtney Brown?

  And they brought up how Jason's last interaction with Jolene had been violent. And surprisingly, Jason didn't deny that. He admitted to trashing Jolene's apartment, telling police this:

• 28:22Colin Brown?

  "I had slammed the cabinet up when we was arguing, and the one screw come out on that. Yeah, I know something about that."

• 28:29Courtney Brown?

  As for the multiple holes in the walls and doors, Jason argued that those had been from prior arguments, quote, "a long time ago," end quote. But again, detectives had an inkling that he was their guy. They kept bringing up how suspicious it was that he removed the battery from his phone. But Jason was adamant that they had it all wrong. He told them.

• 28:51Colin Brown?

  I told you the reason I was fucking hiding. I got a warrant for violation of probation. I didn't want to go to jail. I didn't have nothing to do with Jolene. I know you ain't believe in nothing I say, but I'm telling you the truth, man. I had nothing to do with Jolene being missing. I love her.

• 29:06Courtney Brown?

  Now, Jason did seem to be distressed when he learned that Jolene was missing. But even so, when the detectives walked away from this conversation, they were confident that they had their suspect. However, once again, they would soon learn that Jason had an alibi. He had been at his father's house the entire weekend, including the night that Jolene went missing. And luckily for him, his alibi checked out. After speaking with several people who were with Jason that weekend, they all provided the same consistent story, even when separated from one another. So as it turns out, as messed up and toxic as he and Jolene's relationship was, Jason was telling the truth.

• 29:48Courtney Brown?

  Just like that, police went from two seemingly great suspects to no suspects at all. But soon enough, they would get a huge break in the case.

• 30:02Colin Brown?

  As soon as Jolene's family found out she was missing, they had started tirelessly passing out flyers and spreading the word. On each flyer, a clear description and photo of Jolene and her vehicle were front and center. And thankfully, on May 15th, around 3:30 PM, it paid off. That afternoon, police got a tip that Jolene's vehicle had been spotted in the Home Depot parking lot in Yuli. Immediately, police responded to the scene, and there, abandoned in the back lot, they discovered Jolene's beige 2006 Ford Explorer, license plate number 035KBQ. When they approached the vehicle, they weren't sure what they were going to find. Carefully, they pulled at the door handle and it opened. Her car was unlocked. From there, they went to open the trunk.

• 30:48Colin Brown?

  Anytime you have a missing person and an abandoned vehicle, there's always a chance that investigators find a body back there. They all stood around as the trunk popped open. But luckily, there was no body. In fact, there wasn't much of anything inside her car, not even the keys. During their search, they found a few empty water bottles, random pieces of paper, and an old to-go coffee cup. But considering the keys weren't inside, they theorized that whoever had driven it to the Home Depot parking lot had simply stepped out and walked away.

• 31:19Courtney Brown?

  Fortunately, where the car had been abandoned, it wasn't exactly in the middle of nowhere. There were several businesses surrounding the Home Depot, so police got to work scouring the area for surveillance cameras. Right across the entrance to the Home Depot sat a credit union. And knowing how well-maintained and updated bank security systems usually are, they made that their first stop. The detectives held their breath as they looked through the hours and hours of footage, eyes locked on the screen for Jolene's car. And then finally, at 1:17 a.m., on May 13th, Mother's Day and Jolene's birthday, they spotted it.

• 32:00Courtney Brown?

  The driver, who wasn't visible, parked the car and then stepped out moments later. And although the footage was blurry, there were several things that they knew immediately. The figure that got out of Jolene's car was a woman, and it wasn't Jolene. Clad in all black, the mysterious figure walked off into the night, heading towards the only business open at that hour, a gate gas station. Following the figure, police raced to the gas station to check their cameras. And fortunately, they had several. As they watched this footage, they saw that same woman. This time, she was approaching the store and speaking with a worker who was outside on their lunch break.

• 32:45Courtney Brown?

  She talked with him at length, bought a bottle of water with her credit card, and then got into a cab where she disappeared into the night. Now thankfully, as the investigators are looking through this gas station footage, the very same worker that had spoken to the suspect was there that day, and he had quite the story to tell.

• 33:06Speaker 01

  Hey, Casey. I'm Detective Rose with the Sheriff's Office. Hello. Hello. I needed to speak to you about someone that you had contact with the other night. You're not in trouble for nothing. Oh, I was. Okay. I don't even know. Can we sit down for a second? Of course.

• 33:22Speaker 01

  Let me see.

• 33:25Speaker 01

  So. You came in contact with.

• 33:34Speaker 01

  Let's see.

• 33:40Speaker 01

  There was a female that came into the store the other night, right here.

• 33:44Speaker 02

  Yes.

• 33:44Speaker 01

  And y'all sat there and talked for a little bit on video?

• 33:47Speaker 02

  She had me, uh, call her a, uh, taxi.

• 33:51Speaker 01

  She had you call her a taxi?

• 33:52Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 33:52Speaker 01

  Can you tell me what your conversation was with her?

• 33:56Speaker 02

  Um, she said something about how she was out with a couple of friends, uh, drinking. And one of the friends, ex-boyfriends came around. There'd been some kind of problem, she didn't go into detail for it much after that. And to be honest, I don't even know how she got to the store because she hadn't even called her a taxi and then, what, ten fifteen minutes later she was gone. Uh, the taxi came and picked her up, took her, said she said somewhere to like a plant fitness.

• 34:24Speaker 01

  Okay.

• 34:24Speaker 02

  That was around us.

• 34:26Speaker 01

  Alright, um, what else did she say about them being out earlier?

• 34:31Speaker 02

  Nothing. She went into this really weird conversation about what meth does to your body. Literally, this is what most of our conversation was about.

• 34:40Speaker 01

  What meth does to your body?

• 34:41Speaker 02

  Yeah, it was really weird. Uh, they, all she said about what happened earlier that night was that they were out drinking. One of the girls, like, one of her friend's ex came around and then, you know, uh, then it just went bad from there, but she didn't give any details to me though.

• 35:01Speaker 01

  Where were they drinking at?

• 35:02Speaker 02

  She didn't tell me. I figured if she walked to us though, they were probably over at the goat. Most likely. And from the way I saw her come in from the store, she came from the, that way. I would hope she didn't walk all the way from the island.

• 35:17Speaker 01

  No, right?

• 35:20Speaker 01

  What happened when the ex came in?

• 35:22Speaker 02

  Like I said, she didn't talk about any of it to me. Nothing about what happened with her, her friends and the ex, just that something had happened and that she, uh, didn't know, um, that it wasn't good.

• 35:37Speaker 01

  She said that what?

• 35:38Speaker 02

  That it just said something had happened and they had, it wasn't good for what had, uh, happened between the friends and the ex.

• 35:44Speaker 01

  She give you?

• 35:45Speaker 07

  Any. Was there an argument or was? I I figured there was an argument, it's how she made it sound like, but she didn't give me any de- details on it. Did she say how many people were out together? Mm, all she said was just her and a couple of friends. How was she acting when you spoke to her?

• 36:06Speaker 07

  Irritable. We had called, uh, she had called the taxi company from my phone and she was very irritable with the people on the phone. Not the lady on the phone was being courteous either, but. Yeah. She was easy irritated. She just like felt like the need to keep talking, she couldn't like not talk either. Did she, was she acting different or? I've never seen her before other than this, so.

• 36:35Speaker 07

  I mean, did she? How was her, how else was her demeanor?

• 36:42Speaker 07

  Tired, I mean, I I it wasn't really anything out there that would, I would say was off. Did she, um, did you notice any marks on her? She looked like she had a red mark on her face. Okay. It was, it wasn't like much, but.

• 37:00Speaker 07

  I, it didn't look like someone had hit her, maybe it like, you know, grabbed her by the face or pushed her or something like that. But it it it didn't look like someone had hit her unless, you know, she doesn't bruise easily, but most people do bruise easily in the face, so. Did it look old or fresh? It looked fresh. It looked like it could have happened from that night or recently.

• 37:24Speaker 07

  You said the red mark looked like someone had done what? Like someone had like pushed it, it almost looked like, you know, like a finger like mark, like someone had like almost grabbed her face and pushed her out of the way or something. Or like someone had like gripped her face. It was like right there along, like on her, uh, cheekbone. Okay.

• 37:43Speaker 07

  What did she say about the details with the, with the incident and not having a ride back? I think she, she wouldn't give any details about what had happened during the night. Not that I went looking for the information about it, tried to stay out of people's business, working at a gas station.

• 38:10Speaker 07

  For our conversation, it just went around. She apparently spent all this time looking up the effects of what meth does to your body. That's what she was looking up? Oh yeah, I mean, that's what she said. She had spent a lot of time recently looking up. I'm like, why would you look up what meth does to your body?

• 38:30Speaker 07

  Well, I know, but still, it's just a little weird to me. Was there anything

• 38:38Speaker 07

  else that was, that stood out to you about her? She looked anxious, like she kinda thought something was going on. She didn't want me to leave her alone either though, so she didn't, yeah. Like when I tried to go back inside to go back to working, she got real kinda defensive and like wanted me to stay around, so figuring whatever happened, it scared her. She didn't wanna be by herself.

• 39:04Courtney Brown?

  Now, everything he said matched the footage, so it seemed like they were finally making some leeway. But there were several parts of this story that concerned detectives, like the fact that the woman was talking at length about meth. The drug aspect added a whole nother layer to this story. But from here, detectives decided to find the cab that the woman got into that night. Hopefully, if they tracked it down, they could see where the woman was dropped off and then maybe they could find her identity. Luckily, finding the cab was pretty easy. And after speaking with the driver, they learned that in the early morning hours of May thirteenth,

• 39:44Courtney Brown?

  the woman was dropped off at the place where it all began, Tangle's Hair Salon, where Jolene worked. Now, as we mentioned, there were no cameras at the salon or in the parking lot directly outside of it. But eventually, police got access to the cameras that were nearby. And that's when they saw that after the cab dropped off the woman at the salon, she got into a black Kia Soul, one that was owned by Jolene's coworker, a mysterious woman named Jennifer Seibert. Now, up until this point, police had spoken to everyone who was at the salon that day. Everyone except Jennifer, who they hadn't been able to get in contact with.

• 40:26Courtney Brown?

  And it just so happens that Jennifer and Jolene were the only people in the salon when it closed that night. So, what happened?

• 40:36Courtney Brown?

  Well, according to fellow coworkers and clients of the Tangle Salon, 50-year-old Jennifer Seibert had only been working there for a couple of months. And during that short time, she was already having problems with everyone. Apparently, she would text the owner of the salon, tattletaling on the other hairdressers. And for some reason, she seemed to be really focused on Jolene. If Jolene was running even a second late, Jennifer would text the owner to let her know. Other hairdressers said that Jolene would walk over to the thermostat to turn it down a few degrees. But as soon as she left, Jennifer would walk right over and turn it back. It was little things like this that were adding up,

• 41:20Courtney Brown?

  causing tension between Jennifer and Jolene. On another occasion, Jennifer even texted the owner saying, "I saw Jolene taking money out of the cash register." The owner would later say that they brushed it off. Jolene was the most trustworthy employee she could possibly ask for. And sure enough, when she checked the register, it was completely balanced, down to the penny. To everyone, it seemed like Jennifer had developed a strange vendetta against Jolene. And that was only intensified when, weeks before her disappearance, a baggie with a white substance in it was discovered at the salon.

• 41:58Colin Brown?

  Everyone who worked there quickly brushed it off, assuming it was something left behind by a customer. Jennifer, however, couldn't bring herself to stop talking about the baggie. In fact, she even suggested that the baggie, supposedly full of drugs, belonged to Jolene. It was a pretty serious accusation, one that had no evidence to support it. And from there, Jolene began to do all she could to distance herself from Jennifer. She felt uneasy and targeted by her. And it only got worse. Just a few days before Jolene's disappearance, Jolene was having a private conversation with her coworker Anne about her custody battle. As she poured her heart and soul out to Anne in the back of the shop, she felt like someone was watching her. And she was right.

• 42:42Colin Brown?

  Because when Jolene turned around, she caught Jennifer staring at her, very deliberately eavesdropping on the conversation. Even worse was that Jennifer didn't even flinch when Jolene looked in her direction. Annoyed, she turned back around and continued her story in a lowered voice, only to hear Jennifer's footsteps moving closer.

• 43:02Courtney Brown?

  Feeling uncomfortable, Jolene asked Anne if they could finish their conversation outside. But as soon as the door closed behind them, it opened again. Jennifer had followed them outside. And there, the tension between the two erupted into a verbal altercation. It ended with Jolene exploding, telling Jennifer, "Go away. Don't talk to me. You're crazy." But Jennifer still didn't leave. She stared at Jolene and demanded, "What do you mean? What do you mean by that?" It's here where Anne stepped between the two, telling Jennifer to just go inside. Finally, Jennifer complied and went back into the salon.

• 43:45Courtney Brown?

  But Jolene seemed really shaken by the experience. This woman had only been working here for a few months, and she was already telling on her anytime she walked in late. She was accusing her of stealing money from the register. And then she accused her of bringing drugs into their place of work. Jolene had worked here for years with no problems, but now she felt unsafe in the salon where she had built her career. At that moment, while standing outside, Jolene told Anne, "What's her last name? I'm going to look her up. There's something off about her. That woman is not who she says she is." Now later on, when Jolene's loved ones heard this, they weren't surprised.

• 44:29Courtney Brown?

  According to them, one of Jolene's defining qualities was her intuition. She always knew when someone wasn't genuine, when someone had bad intentions. And this Jennifer lady gave her this sick feeling inside. She knew something wasn't right with her, and she was determined to figure out who she was. Now, another thing Jolene's friends said about her was that when she wanted to find something out about someone, she was going to figure it out. She was known for her skill in scouring the internet for information on people. And according to the employees at Tangle Salon, that was Jolene's intention when it came to her new work feud with Jennifer Seibert.

• 45:12Colin Brown?

  As detectives are hearing this, they can't help but wonder if this tension between two coworkers was the reason Jolene went missing. Maybe there was an argument that led to something violent. So they started asking around about what was going on on the day Jolene disappeared. What was the energy like between Jolene and Jennifer? They ended up speaking with Jolene's last clients that day. According to them, Jolene was very busy that evening. She was running around juggling multiple clients at once, while Jennifer was just kind of milling about. They said she was looking out the windows and seemingly eavesdropping on their conversations. At one point, a customer came in looking for a gift card, and since Jolene had her hands full, she asked Jennifer, who wasn't doing anything, "Hey, would you mind grabbing

• 45:57Colin Brown?

  one for me? They're in the drawer in the front desk." From there, Jennifer went to the front desk, rummaged around for a few seconds, and eventually snapped at Jolene, saying, "You can deal with it. I can't fucking find it." All the customers seemed shocked by this. One of them recalled being startled because it seemed like Jennifer blew up out of nowhere. So there was clear tension between the two, tension that everyone picked up on. Are you ready to have your mind blown? I want you now to imagine that in front of you was a locked door, symbolizing all that you know, everything you've been taught in your time on Earth, the lies your government has fed you. With my podcast, The Conspiracy Files, I now give you the door's key.

• 46:37Colin Brown?

  And, once you've listened to the show, you finally unlock this door and step inside. Beyond the door is another dimension, a dimension of false narratives, a dimension of hidden evidence, a dimension of truth, lies, and murders. You're moving into a land of both shadow and substance, of deadly secrets and explosive ideas. You've just crossed over into the conspiracy zone. I'm your host, Colin Brown. Join me now on this journey into the world of secret pedophile rings, government cover-ups, and suspicious suicides on my new show, The Conspiracy Files, available now on all streaming platforms.

• 47:14Courtney Brown?

  Another concerning thing was that Jennifer and Jolene were the two employees to close the salon that day. So from what they could tell, Jennifer was the last person who saw Jolene alive. But after Jolene's disappearance, it was hard to get in touch with Jennifer. And when they did, her messages were strange. The owner of the salon, whose name is Vicky, texted her saying, quote, "Jennifer, I hate to bother you again. Jolene's mom has taken out a missing person. Do you remember what she was wearing Saturday? Jolene has been having trouble with a crazy ex. Took out an order on him Friday." End quote. Moments later, Jennifer replied, quote, "Hold on, driving."

• 47:59Courtney Brown?

  Several more minutes passed, until finally she responded, quote, "Oh my lord, I'm so sorry to hear this. For what she was wearing, I'm not sure if I remember. Um, I think dark colored pants, not remember the top. I don't pay attention. I'm not fashion forward like the other gals." End quote. Now, Vicky would later say that the interaction rubbed her the wrong way. Obviously, investigators felt the same. And they wanted to speak with Jennifer Seibert themselves. Luckily for them, as they were at the salon, speaking with the owner Vicky, she heard her phone ring. It was Jennifer who said she was on the way to the salon.

• 48:41Courtney Brown?

  Vicky responded, saying, quote, "Detective Kelly is actually here. He has a few questions he's hoping you can answer." End quote. But with that, Jennifer quickly hung up the phone. Soon after, Detective Kelly and Vicky watched as Jennifer's car took off down the road. It was clear that Jennifer was running because she had something to hide. And sadly, after she took off, they lost her. Now, later that day, Jennifer texted Vicky again, stating that she was quitting her job, and that she could mail her her last check. Which only made them more suspicious. Hoping to track her down, Detective Kelly tried calling Jennifer's cellphone, but she wouldn't answer.

• 49:26Courtney Brown?

  Until finally, they received a call back. Hi, this is Jennifer Seibert. Your detectives have been contacting me. As much as I'd like to help find Joleen Cummings, I can't. Look, I'm on the run. My ex has been tracking me for years. If he finds me, he'll kill me. I can't have my name in any reports. I can't have my name anywhere. So I'm sorry, but you'll have to talk to someone else. Now this phone call only raised more questions, and they didn't believe her claim for a second. It was clear that Jennifer Seibert wasn't running from an ex. She was running from them. Deep down, they knew that she was responsible for Joleen Cummings' disappearance.

• 50:10Courtney Brown?

  But with no evidence to prove it, they were worried that she might flee. So they decided to write up an arrest warrant for Grand Theft Auto, since she was seen driving Jolene's car.

• 50:22Colin Brown?

  As the authorities worked on getting their arrest warrant, they knew that they needed to find Jennifer before she skipped town. They used her employment paperwork to find her home address, which was listed as 915 Citrona Drive. Along the way there, they saw that Citrona Drive was a peaceful street close to the beach. It was lined with ranch homes and white picket fences. But as they looked around for the house at 915 Citrona Drive, they were confused. As it turns out, there were no homes on the 900 block of Citrona. Detective Douglas doubled back, scanning the street to see if he had somehow made a mistake. But he hadn't. The closest address to 915 Citrona Drive at the time was 435 Citrona Drive.

• 51:06Colin Brown?

  In other words, the address she listed didn't exist. It was a completely fake one that, on paper, even for locals, could very easily have been mistaken for a real one. But the one thing they knew for sure was that Jennifer was fleeing, and they had to find her fast before they lost her completely. Luckily, they were able to track Jennifer's cellphone through nearby towers. They knew Jennifer would likely be sleeping in her car, somewhere she felt safe, somewhere where a transient person wouldn't ring any alarm bells. So when her phone pinged off I-95 in St. John's County, they scoured nearby truck stops. And there, late into the night of Thursday, May 16, a detective found exactly what they were looking for: a black Kia Soul that seemed to be trying to hide.

• 51:51Colin Brown?

  The car was wedged between two parked semi trucks, obstructing it from view unless he were specifically looking for it. And thankfully, detectives were. Detective Harrington approached Jennifer's vehicle with caution, unsure how she would react to being cornered. And as he drew closer, he realized that the front of the vehicle was empty. He swept his flashlight around to the back of the car, and there, in the shadows of the backseat, he saw a flicker of movement. In his own words, Jennifer slithered from the back of the car through the center console, slipping into the front seat. Detective Harrington then ordered her out of the car with her hands up.

• 52:30Courtney Brown?

  Slowly, Jennifer emerged from the car. There was an eerie calm about her as she stared blankly at the detectives, as if she didn't care or couldn't bother to learn why he was there. But something they immediately noticed was that her face was covered in bruises and Band-Aids. Peeking out from behind one of the Band-Aids was what appeared to be a long, deep scratch, the kind you'd get from a human fingernail. When detectives asked where Jennifer got the scratches on her face, she scoffed, saying, "I was riding my bike and got hit by a branch." "What's going on?" Detective Harrington promptly cut her off, telling her that she was under arrest for grand theft auto.

• 53:13Courtney Brown?

  Jennifer claimed over and over that she had never even been in Jolene's car, that she had no idea what the detectives were talking about. But of course, the proof was in the surveillance footage. It was also written all over Jennifer's face.

• 53:28Colin Brown?

  From there, Jennifer was booked into St. John's County Jail for the night, where detectives got a first look at the attitude that they were in for for months to come. Now, what's interesting is that Jennifer was initially interviewed by two female detectives. And as you'll see, her behavior with them is completely different from her behavior with Detective Steve Harrington the following day. At St. John's County, the detectives' main concern was maintaining any DNA evidence they could related to the case, something that Jennifer complied with, but rolled her eyes about the entire time, especially when detectives had to take fingernail clippings.

• 54:16Colin Brown?

  Oh, you're doing it till I bleed. Good for you.

• 54:18Speaker 02

  No, I'm not.

• 54:19Colin Brown?

  Yeah, huh, because there's blood coming underneath my nail. See it? It wasn't there before. That's all right. You want blood, you got it. Now, these officers didn't ask Jennifer any questions regarding the crimes she committed. They were primarily focused on making small talk and collecting the samples needed before Jennifer had a chance to wash her hands or rid herself of any evidence. However, when she was transferred to Nassau County the next morning, the focus was entirely different.

• 54:48Speaker 07

  Do you know why you're here?

• 54:51Speaker 02

  Um, yes, I'm being accused. You accused me the other night of, uh, you're like, "Where's Jolene at?"

• 54:58Speaker 07

  Where is she? It's, you know, she had been reported missing. They said, you know, "There's no way that she's not gonna be with her kids." And so I probably come across harsh when I talked to you the other day. And for that, you know, I didn't mean anything by it, but like I said, I wanna know, I wanna be able to find her and I wanna be able to get her back with her little boys. Just like, you need to go and be with them and she needs to be with her kids, okay? Um, so again, if I come across, uh, you know,

• 55:28Speaker 02

  You're just doing your job.

• 55:29Speaker 07

  No, no, it's more, it is my job, but at the same time, I try not to let your, you know, in my job, you try not to let your emotions get involved, but sometimes even, I've been doing it for 21 years. Sometimes I let things get to me that I shouldn't let, you know, let get to me, and at least until later on when I'm not trying to have a conversation with somebody.

• 55:51Speaker 02

  No.

• 55:52Speaker 07

  You kind of put those things to the side and you worry about them later. And maybe I didn't do a good job of that when I started talking to you.

• 55:58Speaker 02

  You're fine. And feelings are just kind of a funny thing. Because I was raised by kind of South German people. They're like, "Suck it up, you know, shed feelings. I'll beat you until you stop crying." So we're like, we finally learned. It only took a couple of beats. We're like, "Okay, we got this under control." But feelings are like a funny thing because you gotta somehow deal with them. And I've never really quite figured that one out. Like, where do you stuff them? Well, I stuff them in different places. Then I end up stuffing my face because I'm gonna do something wrong to like, try to quit. We all have, you know, feelings that are positive. Not everyone's happy. I mean, we all have things in our life, you know? So, and I stuff it with food, which is not good. A lot of people do it with drugs and alcohol or whatever. The right way to do it is like going to the gym.

• 56:42Speaker 07

  I like to go camp or hike and it's like if I can, I say it all like, I like to be along for short periods. I couldn't do it for 25 years, but to me, nothing's better than a three day in the woods right by myself, me and nothing but a campfire and a canoe or something like that.

• 56:58Speaker 02

  Frogs and birds and, yeah, critters.

• 57:01Speaker 07

  Is there, you know, and again, you know, can we, I don't think we talked much about it the other night because like I said, I probably didn't handle it as professionally as I should have. But can we just go through when you work with her on that Saturday so I can, is there anything you can tell me that, did she ever talk to you about a boyfriend? I know she's had a husband. I know she had a boyfriend. Did she ever talk about anybody she was scared of? Did she ever say anything that would, that she wanted to run away and get away from it all? I mean, you know?

• 57:29Speaker 02

  I don't remember hearing anything. She would have different conversations sometimes with different clients because different clients, you don't tell every client, you know what I mean? Like, but the one client that, oh, the one, I don't, the one, I told you, who was it? She,

• 57:48Speaker 02

  she was saying CPS came to her house. She was telling one client that. I caught a little blip of it in between listening to YouTube and the phone ringing. And, and she, I remember hearing her say she thought her, her ex-husband or her husband was doing it to get out of paying child support. That's all I heard. And I don't remember ever hearing about a boyfriend ever. But then again, I don't always really pay attention. And as I told you before, Ms. Ann, she really like talked to Ms. Ann, like her and Ms. Ann would go out back and they'd smoke cigarettes. And they'd sit out back sometimes for a while and they would even forget that their clients were in. I'd have to go in the back and be like, hey, your clients are here. Cause they would get so involved in talking. So I don't know as much as, you know, maybe Ms. Ann.

• 58:27Speaker 02

  And honestly, whenever I first started, she would tell me, you know, I don't even remember when she started to tell me some things and I would be like, I am not the person to ask. I can't give you any good counsel. Hanging around with or was she in anything that maybe she shouldn't have been She was just saying to me like, you know, the time or two that she'd say, I'm just going home and having a quiet night at home, or like, I don't have the kids tonight, or, you know, whatever, I'm just gonna enjoy this. And I'd be like, you're young, why don't you go out? She's like, no, I don't need a man in my life. But here she had a boyfriend, I didn't even know that. Was she involved in any bad habits or anything that could get her in trouble? Um, I, I can't say that it, that she did, but I did find a bag that I believe had

• 59:09Speaker 02

  crystal meth in it, just a little bit in the bottom, a tiny baggie back by the back door. Um, at first I thought, well, maybe it's Val, uh, Vicky's daughter, uh, whatever her name is, Whitney, you know, because I heard she had a drug habit, but hers is opiate and that's not crystal meth. So, and I didn't even know what it was at first. And it was actually Jolene who said, that's a drug baggie. And I'm like, really? She said, yeah, that's drugs. She goes, you know what kind of drugs it was? I'm like, I don't know, I don't know, it could be bath salts, looked kinda like crystals. And, um, she, I ended up looking up on the internet, I believe it was crystal meth. How much was it? Just a little bit in the bottom.

• 59:45Colin Brown?

  Clearly she was trying to deflect suspicion from herself, even attempting to create the impression that Jolene was a drug addict. But the detectives were determined to get to the bottom of two questions. First, obviously, what happened to Jolene Cummings? And second, who the hell was Jennifer, really? Because the more they looked into her past, the less clear answers they received. And as soon as Jennifer sat down with them, it became clear why

• 1:00:11Speaker 00

  Hey Spotify listeners, when you travel with American Airlines, you'll enjoy comfort and convenience at every altitude. Before takeoff, unwind in the Admiral's Club Lounge with curated self-serve offerings of hearty bites and refreshments. In flight, stay connected with high-speed Wi-Fi, sponsored by AT&T. Your journey is designed to feel easy from the moment you check in to the moment you arrive. No matter where you're going, American gets you there. Book now at aa.com.

• 1:00:36Speaker 01

  Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies, made without that spooky high fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a Berry Chantilly Cake. Ready to cook pizza? No antibiotics ever chicken wings. And sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.

• 1:01:07Speaker 03

  Stay cozy and look cool with up to 60% off cold weather gear at Nordstrom Rack. Save on cashmere, outerwear, boots, and more from brands like Ugg, Vince, Kohan, and Hunter. Join the Nordy Club for free to unlock exclusive discounts, shop clearance and new arrivals first, and more. Plus, buy online and pick up at your favorite Rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you Rack.

• 1:01:33Colin Brown?

  Tracing her history had been such a challenge.

• 1:01:38Speaker 07

  What name do you want me to call you? Because I've talked to the detective that drove you up and he said I might have been called me by the wrong name.

• 1:01:45Speaker 02

  It's funny, the St. John's didn't tell you. When you run my fingerprints through, they come up as Kimberly Lee Kessler. I was born in May of 1968, May 9th. I am 50 years old. I've been running from the FBI for over 25 years. I've been living under this particular alias since 1999, so not quite 1999. This is 18, yeah, about 19 years. And that's about it. So I would prefer to be called Kim.

• 1:02:16Speaker 07

  Okay, I just want to make sure that I'm calling you by your right name.

• 1:02:20Speaker 02

  But if you run them through, I mean, the last time I got picked up was back in 1999 and I bonded out. And it took them, I don't remember, it was a couple of weeks. I don't know if it was two and a half weeks or three and a half weeks before they actually, you know, matched them up.

• 1:02:34Speaker 07

  Matched them up?

• 1:02:34Speaker 02

  Yeah, it didn't like, but that was 1999, so maybe it was a little bit slower then. But I don't know, there's like lots of people on the face of the planet, so maybe it still takes time. I'm not sure.

• 1:02:44Speaker 07

  And it may be too that you, since you've had this alias for so long, you know, it probably, you've probably done a lot of stuff since that time. And so you've actually kind of got a, you know, you've got a history under that name, so it probably shows up in. Different databases and stuff like that. And that's just a guess, and maybe that's why it's happening like that.

• 1:03:05Speaker 02

  Oh, no, fingerprints are fingerprints.

• 1:03:07Speaker 07

  Fingerprints are fingerprints, and I agree.

• 1:03:09Speaker 02

  I didn't erase them with acid, so they are the same. Just saying.

• 1:03:14Speaker 07

  And I agree with you, but I had a run your fingerprints. And if St. John's did, they failed to notify us that, you know, of the different names. So I probably.

• 1:03:23Speaker 02

  Perhaps they just thought I was a, you know, a nut job, so they ignored me. But it will eventually come out.

• 1:03:30Courtney Brown?

  As it turns out, Jennifer Seibert wasn't Jennifer Seibert at all. She was actually Kimberly Kessler. For the first part of her interrogation, she brags repeatedly about how she's been able to successfully hide from the FBI for over 25 years. Over and over again, she encourages detectives to look her up. And when they finally do, they don't exactly find what she's been claiming.

• 1:03:57Speaker 07

  Well, Kim, they're doing.

• 1:03:59Speaker 02

  I didn't lie.

• 1:04:01Speaker 07

  Well, she's still working on stuff, but she found this right away. Is that you?

• 1:04:05Speaker 02

  Yeah, that's me. I was a lot younger then. Stop taking back and squinting my eyes. You know what? She wanted me to open my eyes there in Tennessee because they wanted to scan them, and I wouldn't open them. See how squinty my eyes are? The woman kept saying, "Open your eyes." "Open your eyes." No, this one. "Open your eyes."

• 1:04:23Speaker 07

  I was gonna say, your eyes looked that way.

• 1:04:24Speaker 02

  "Open your eyes."

• 1:04:25Speaker 07

  Is that a driver's license photo?

• 1:04:26Speaker 02

  Yep. "Open my eyes." I wouldn't do it. I was like, I was squinting until she finally gave in and took the picture. Because I didn't want my eye scanned.

• 1:04:34Speaker 07

  It's not, um.

• 1:04:35Speaker 02

  That's me with short hair.

• 1:04:36Speaker 07

  It's not short hair that you wanted, though. It's just saying that you're a missing person. Why wouldn't you be wanted?

• 1:04:41Speaker 02

  No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I have aliases. I have IDs. I was Christina Brooke whenever I had my son Evan Brooke. I was Melissa Marney.

• 1:04:51Courtney Brown?

  Kimberly Kessler did indeed have several aliases, including Jennifer Seibert. But to find out how she arrived at that name and all of the names in between, we have to look at who she really is, the person that she never wanted anyone to see. So let's go back and look at Kimberly's life and everything that led up to Mother's Day of 2018.

• 1:05:14Colin Brown?

  Kim was born Kimberly Lee Kessler on May 9, 1968. The parents, Constance Connie Kessler and Robert C. Kessler, in the small town of Butler, Pennsylvania. Growing up, Kim, along with her siblings, Robert Jr. and Sarah, never really wanted for anything. Their family came from a long line of successful businessmen, with her father's parents owning Kessler Auction Barn, a large event space where weekly auctions and estate sales were held. In addition, the family was involved in horse racing, which was, and still is, wildly popular in the area. Throughout her childhood and teens, Kim was what you would call one of the "popular girls." Her freshman and sophomore year, she was a cheerleader who dated one of the most popular boys in school.

• 1:05:58Colin Brown?

  From the outside, she really seemed to be the "all-American beauty queen," but those who knew her closely, even from a young age, knew that something wasn't right. According to several childhood friends and high school boyfriends, Kim had an undercurrent of anger, instability, and hatred about her. She often spoke at length about how much she hated her brother, Bob, and her mother, telling people that she constantly fought with them. The summer heading into her senior year, 1985, it seems that something happened to Kimberly. There was a drastic shift in her personality, almost as if all the hidden parts of herself came to the surface. One high school friend told detectives, "Everybody was afraid of her. I tried to stay off Kim's radar because, quite honestly, she was a scary individual

• 1:06:43Colin Brown?

  once she did this major change in personality." Another mirrored these sentiments, saying, "It was just like one day something snapped. It seemed to be maybe over a summer break, if I remember correctly, because it was like one school year was great, and then the next one, she was just this different person." Now, what happened to cause this change, we may never know. We searched arrest records in local newspapers to see if there were any arrests or disturbances related to her home life, and the first sign of turmoil was an accident in 1987. Her older brother Bob was in a horrific motorcycle accident where he ran off the road crashing into a tree. Tragically, the friend who was riding with him died of his injuries.

• 1:07:25Colin Brown?

  For unknown reasons following the accident, rumors began to swirl that Kimberly had allegedly run her own brother off the road. Of course, these are just small-town rumors, but the fact that this was a rumor in the first place is enough to raise an eyebrow. And what happened soon after that accident does the same.

• 1:07:43Courtney Brown?

  At one point after graduating high school, her brother Bob was fast asleep in his childhood bedroom. And there was a creak of a door. Bob didn't stir. He was at home, safe, or so he thought. As he hovered between dreams and reality, a blinding pain shot through his face. He awakened to the throb of agony radiating through his jaw and head. And with it, a gush of warm blood filled his mouth. He bolted upright, bracing his mouth with his hand, and he watched in horror as his front teeth tumbled out into his palm. With a torrent of blood, his teeth had been smashed out of his gums at the root.

• 1:08:27Courtney Brown?

  And his sister Kimberly stood beside his bed with a baseball bat, smiling at him. The two had gotten into an argument earlier that day, and evidently, this was her choice of revenge. Now the two stopped speaking shortly after this, but Kimberly told anyone who would listen about what she had done to her brother. She seemed sickly proud of the pain she had caused him, even laughing about it at times. And unfortunately, that tendency towards violence didn't stop with her brother. In the early 90s, when Kim was entering her twenties, she dated a man named Tim. Initially, Tim was head over heels for Kim, but soon enough, her instability drove him away.

• 1:09:13Courtney Brown?

  In one incident, the two got into an argument while at a cookout. In a rage, Kim ran at him and plunged a butter knife into his chest, leaving him with a scar that he still has to this day. In another instance, when Kim came at Tim, his father stepped in between them, restraining Kim and trying to calm her down. But in response, Kim latched her teeth into her boyfriend's father's calf, biting his leg as hard as she could. Now after this altercation, Kim essentially disappeared from Tim's life. He came home one day to see that all of her belongings were gone, and sadly, his cat Malcolm was also missing. Tim was especially devastated about the cat.

• 1:09:58Courtney Brown?

  He loved him, but he hoped that Kim was giving him a good life. For about a year, Tim didn't hear from Kim. But then one day, he saw her at a bar. By then, the pain of their breakup had subsided, and they struck up a conversation. During it, he asked her about his cat. But in response, Kim shrugged while smiling and told him, "No, I had to get rid of him. My new apartment didn't allow cats." Tim was heartbroken. If Kim had to give his cat away, the least she could have done was give it back to him, the rightful owner. So he asked her who she gave him to. Again, Kim looked into his eyes with a sick look he knew all too well.

• 1:10:43Courtney Brown?

  She then said, "Oh, I didn't give him to anyone. I killed him out back with a shotgun."

• 1:10:49Colin Brown?

  Now it's around this time in the early 1990s when Kimberly decided that she didn't want to live as Kimberly Kessler anymore. She wanted a new identity. On one occasion, she begged her boyfriend to go to the cemetery to visit her dad's grave, who died when she was just 21 years old. At first, the boyfriend was flattered, thinking that Kim wanted to share a special piece of her life with him. Instead, as the two entered the cemetery, Kim began to walk headstone by headstone, staring at the names and birth dates intently. Despite claiming she wanted to show him her dad's headstone, she had no flowers, and didn't seem to be in a rush to see her dad's grave. Instead, she seemed much more focused on finding tombstones of girls who would have been around the same age as her, were they still alive.

• 1:11:34Colin Brown?

  At the time, the boyfriend never imagined that this was for a nefarious purpose. But as you'll see later, Kimberly used names of young girls from this very cemetery throughout her life. Now, anytime you're creating different identities for yourself, there is clearly something going on there, and her family noticed this change in her.

• 1:11:54Courtney Brown?

  At some point in 1998, Kim gave birth to a son named Evan. Now Evan's father was named Tim, but I'm not sure if it's the same Tim we mentioned earlier. Regardless, by the time Kimberly gave birth to her son, she was using the name Christina Brooke. And I think "using" isn't even the right word. Kimberly had essentially become Christina Brooke. She somehow got a license and passport under this name as well. Her son's birth certificate listed her as Christina Brooke. And for the next 14 months, Kimberly created a whole new life for herself using this identity. But in August of 1999, her new life began to crumble.

• 1:12:38Colin Brown?

  It was August 3rd, 1999, a blazing summer day in Virginia Beach, Virginia, when a woman heard an odd sound just outside her bedroom window. It was the tiny, earthy sound of someone shoveling just beyond her yard. She assumed that maybe her neighbor was planting trees or doing some yard work, but when she looked outside, her heart stopped. There, just a few feet from her house, stood her neighbor, who she knew as Christina Brooke. Christina's real name, of course, was Kimberly Kessler, but she had a license, passport, and had even signed her son's name as Christina Brooke. To everyone around her, that's who she was. And in the past few weeks, following her separation from the baby's father, Tim Edwards,

• 1:13:23Colin Brown?

  her behavior had become increasingly erratic. There, standing in the yard, Kimberly dug a hole with her fourteen-month-old son, Evan, peering out one end of it. Tears welled in his big eyes. He wasn't playing a game or goofing around. He was clearly in distress. The neighbor raced out to ask Kimberly what she was doing, and Kim rambled nonsensically before telling the neighbor something that chilled her to the bone.

• 1:13:48Courtney Brown?

  I'm digging a grave.

• 1:13:50Colin Brown?

  Terrified for Evan's safety, the woman called CPS, who immediately took Evan out of Kim's custody. From this point on, Kimberly was enraged. A few days following her son being taken from her, she stormed into the CPS headquarters, demanding to see her son. Security called police, who swiftly arrived to escort Kimberly out of the building. As they did, however, Kimberly fought back, flashing the contents of her purse. And inside, clear as day, they saw a Smith & Wesson 357 Magnum, a taser, and a brand-new roll of duct tape. In the aftermath, the officers believed that she was going to kidnap her son that day. They referred to the items in her purse as "a kidnapping kit."

• 1:14:34Colin Brown?

  But from there, she was taken into custody for carrying a concealed weapon. Kim, or rather Christina, as she was known then, immediately posted bond and swiftly disappeared, leaving all of her earthly belongings behind.

• 1:14:47Courtney Brown?

  After Kim disappeared, the courts terminated her parental rights, and Tim, Evan's father, was awarded sole custody. And from that day on, they never heard from her again. Tim would later say that Kimberly was a very violent person, and he's thankful that his son Evan never got to see that firsthand. But after this whole ordeal, Kimberly moved to Arizona, beginning a new life under the alias Melissa McKernan. And for the next decade or so, Kimberly continued to wreak havoc all over the United States. Here is what she told detectives about this period of her life.

• 1:15:25Speaker 02

  You can wait tables or whatever. I have driven a tractor and trailer, which I did in Virginia Beach, Virginia. Did I mention I'm one in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Arizona? I also have a real estate license in Arizona. It goes on and on. I didn't really sell anything, though. Here's the thing, it's just, I guess it requires like, I just thought that, okay, so my grandparents on my father's side of the family made a lot of money.

• 1:15:50Speaker 07

  In real estate, or?

• 1:15:52Speaker 02

  No.

• 1:15:54Speaker 02

  No, um, actually estate sales.

• 1:15:57Speaker 07

  Uh huh.

• 1:15:58Speaker 02

  Lots and lots and lots of money, like unbelievable now. So I just thought to myself, I'm gonna make money. Well, no, it requires like a special blessing from God. It also requires help. What I noticed in the last 25 years of being on my own, I, especially after my son was taken, I didn't let anybody get really too close to me. I did get into abusive relationships, that was bullish. And then I really kept everybody at arm's length, but never really let too many people get close to me. It is virtually impossible to take care of oneself by yourself. You can't do it.

• 1:16:31Speaker 07

  It's funny because.

• 1:16:32Speaker 02

  You gotta have somebody, you gotta have a wife, or you gotta have people. You can't do it by yourself, so.

• 1:16:37Speaker 07

  It's amazing though that you, you know, for 20, I mean, it's amazing to me that, you know, because you always hear about people going, oh my gosh, you know, I just wanna start over. I just wanna, you know, I just wanna be somebody else. I just wanna have a whole new identity.

• 1:16:51Speaker 02

  No.

• 1:16:52Speaker 07

  But then if you ever really look into it, I mean, it's, it's complicated, it's complicated.

• 1:16:56Speaker 02

  It's very complicated, it's very complicated.

• 1:16:58Colin Brown?

  Complicated doesn't even begin to explain Kimberly's life or timeline of events. Throughout her life, she went by 18 different names. Kimberly Kessler, Christina Melissa Brooke, Christina Young, Pamela Kleber, Melissa McKernan, Melissa Lozey, Mia Stone, Jennifer Marie Seibert, Jen Lee Seibert Allen, Jennifer Sebring, Jennifer Marie Allen, Marie Seibert Stone, Krista Brooks, Pamela Cleaver, Pam Cleaver, Pamela Jean Kleber, and Jen Seiver Allen. And with those identities, she lived in over 33 cities and in 15 states, including Arkansas, Arizona, Kansas, Virginia, Tennessee,

• 1:17:40Colin Brown?

  North Carolina, Vermont, Florida, Texas, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Missouri, Colorado, and Alaska. Of all her aliases, she had passports for at least two of the names and licenses for five. And what she was doing during that time, we may never know.

• 1:18:01Courtney Brown?

  Now, something important to note is that after 2004, Kimberly cut off all contact with her family. But by 2012, after eight years of not hearing from her, her mother decided to report Kimberly missing. However, she never got answers as to what happened. And that's because by then, Kimberly Kessler ceased to exist. She hadn't used her real name in 14 years. So, her family moved on. The next thing we know about Kimberly's life is that around 2013, she decided to become a hairdresser. She began training at the Jacksonville Hair Academy. And during that time, her fellow trainees described her behavior as strange.

• 1:18:46Courtney Brown?

  She was reserved, quiet, and she didn't associate with anyone. She often carried around a notebook and scribbled down everything that was said during lectures. One of the instructors who wanted to remain anonymous told the first coast news, "She wouldn't let anyone touch her hair. When I told her that she needed to learn certain things, she told me she was only there. Even though it was a cosmetology school, she told me she was only there to barber." But it was after this when her truly odd behavior began. At one point, Kimberly crawled inside a cabinet. And when asked what she was doing, she casually replied that she, "Wanted to see if she could fit."

• 1:19:30Courtney Brown?

  Another time, a student had a bad sunburn where her skin was peeling off. And Kimberly asked if she could keep her peeled-off skin. Her behavior was so alarming that many of the students wanted to figure out who she was. And they even began researching her background. But unfortunately, due to her many aliases, they weren't able to find much.

• 1:19:53Colin Brown?

  In 2014, Kimberly officially graduated from the Hair Academy and started looking for work at different salons. For years, she bounced around to different salons, not able to stay at one location for very long. At some point, she worked at Great Clips and used the alias Mia Seabird. Co-workers described her as being paranoid and said that she often wore wigs to work claiming that she was running from an abusive ex-boyfriend. I was very surprised to hear it, but... only in the sense that, wow, you know, I mean...

• 1:20:24Speaker 06

  That's a horrible thing to hear, but I knew something was odd with her anyway, because she always seemed to be hiding from something when she was here. A little bit of an odd feeling when I would get off at night and she would still be sitting in her car out in the parking lot and kind of watch you go to your car. And I was, that kind of always gave me an uneasy feeling.

• 1:20:45Colin Brown?

  In fact, everyone at the salon had that same feeling. Coworkers stated that sometimes Kimberly would be a ball of energy who was fun, kind and funny, but at the flip of the switch, she would go into fits of rage. At one point, when a customer wasn't pleased with her haircut, one of the coworkers glanced over to see Kimberly white knuckling the back of the chair, as if it was the only thing keeping her from attacking the woman. As her fits of rage and odd behavior increased, her manager looked for excuses to fire her because it reached a point where everyone was begging not to work the same hours as her. When they did finally fire Kimberly, she allegedly threw her keys at the owner before she stormed out.

• 1:21:25Colin Brown?

  This was just one of many jobs Kimberly switched between until finally, in early 2018, she answered a Craigslist ad, leading her right to Tangle Salon.

• 1:21:35Courtney Brown?

  The women at Tangle's Hair Salon knew Kimberly as Jennifer Seibert. Interestingly, Jennifer Seibert was a young girl who died in Kimberly's hometown in 1987. Somehow, she had even been able to get her social security number and everything. But as soon as Jennifer started working at the Tangle Salon, everyone did their best to welcome her. However, it wouldn't take long for her to start causing problems. Thirty-four-year-old Joleen Cummings could sense that something was wrong with this woman. Her feelings about Jennifer were so strong that in one of her last texts to the Tangle's owner, Vicky Simmons, Jolene said, quote, "There is something a little off about her.

• 1:22:19Courtney Brown?

  I can't put my finger on it," end quote. Another message to Vicky read, quote, "She's been real negative, trying to avoid her," end quote. And now, here we are. In May of 2018, Joleen Cummings wound up missing after working a shift with Jennifer Seibert, or, as we now know her, Kimberly Kessler. And thankfully, it didn't take them long to place her under arrest.

• 1:22:45Colin Brown?

  Now, while Kimberly was in custody, she decided to reconnect with her mother. As we mentioned earlier, Kimberly had completely cut off contact with her family in 2004. And now, 14 years later, she wanted her mother to bail her out.

• 1:23:00Speaker 06

  He told me that you, he, he thought you were involved, they think you're involved in

• 1:23:07Speaker 06

  a missing person there. If you can, or if you want to, please, you know, bail me out.

• 1:23:15Colin Brown?

  She also asked her mom to remove her stuff from her storage unit before the police went through it.

• 1:23:20Speaker 06

  You've gotta get that stuff before Wednesday, because Before Wednesday? They confiscated it. They confiscated it next week. Okay, next week. Yeah, they confiscated it and it becomes theirs.

• 1:23:34Colin Brown?

  Now, we'll go over what was found in her storage unit here in a minute. But throughout Kimberly's interrogations with the police, it became clear that she was not going to come clean about what happened.

• 1:23:45Speaker 07

  Hey, I think Jolene's dead, and I think you know where Jolene is. And I wanna, I'm gonna go tell her, her, her ex. You know, I know that she didn't have a great relationship with her ex, but I know she loved those two boys. I don't wanna, uh, them to, I, I dread the, the point that it's gonna happen. I'm gonna have to tell them that their mom is gone, okay? And we need to know where she is. But I need to, I need to at least let them be able to give them, give her a proper. She, she's out there somewhere, her body's out there somewhere. Let us get her buried properly, or whatever, whatever final arrangements they need to take care of. I, you know, I, I just want you to think about it for a minute.

• 1:24:24Speaker 07

  We're, we're gonna find out what happened. I don't mean that in a threat, I don't mean that in a bad way. Um, I've been here for four days, almost, you know, 16, 18 hours a day, cuz I'm gonna find out where the, those little boys' mom is. I promise you I'm gonna do that. You can help me do that. And you're the one that can make it happen right now.

• 1:24:40Speaker 06

  No, I cannot, and I'm not, again...

• 1:24:43Speaker 02

  Whatever fury may come, I

• 1:24:45Speaker 07

  How much blood is on your shoes?

• 1:24:49Speaker 02

  So let me reply it this way, and you may not like the answer. I would like legal counsel. I haven't been able to call anybody. I haven't been able to call my mom, and I see how that works. And that may still continue to go on. I may not be able to call anybody. You know, stick me in jail, and I'll sit there, and I can't call anybody, and on and on we go. That's fine.

• 1:25:03Speaker 07

  I can't speak for what, you know, when you were held.

• 1:25:06Speaker 02

  I couldn't call anybody. I couldn't call my mom, I couldn't call anybody.

• 1:25:09Speaker 07

  I can assure you, when you get to our facility, we will uphold the letter of laws, as far as whatever the policy is, and whatever legal and rights you have, those will be upheld.

• 1:25:17Speaker 02

  Well, they weren't so far, so I don't really even expect them to be. That's what I saw down there. They didn't pay attention to me. That's fine. I just, I'm expecting that that's what'll... I heard that southern jails, that's what happens. So I'm like, I'm perfectly expecting it to be really bad.

• 1:25:29Speaker 07

  That's not, that's not gonna happen here, I promise you that.

• 1:25:31Colin Brown?

  With Kimberly now asking for an attorney, the interrogation was stopped. But by this point, investigators had already uncovered some pretty damning evidence against Kimberly Kessler.

• 1:25:42Courtney Brown?

  Now, as we mentioned, the Tangle Salon didn't have surveillance footage, but the businesses around them did. And one bit of footage confirmed their worst fears. The clock in the corner of the surveillance screen ticked 8:09 PM on May 12th. It was three hours and nine minutes after closing time at Tangle's. Three hours and nine minutes since the door had been locked, and no one saw Jolene alive again. There, well after she should have gone home, Kimberly stumbled onto the screen. Weighed down by a massive garbage bag in her arms, she heaved the bag into the dumpster, then, breathless, went off-screen,

• 1:26:24Courtney Brown?

  only to return seconds later, throwing yet another bag into the dumpster. This horrible dance continued on for several minutes, until Kimberly had disposed of multiple large trash bags into the dumpster. So, what was she throwing away? What was she doing inside the salon during those three hours? So it's here, where the detectives knew that they needed to take a closer look at the Tangle Salon. After Kimberly's arrest, crime scene investigators descended upon the salon. And almost immediately, they found exactly what they were looking for. On the bottom of the reception desk, there were tiny specks of blood spatter.

• 1:27:05Courtney Brown?

  There were also tiny spots of blood on the mat by the front desk, on one of the drawers, and on the desktop calendar. The more they looked, the worse it got. As it turns out, there wasn't just blood around the reception desk. There was evidence of blood on the complete other end of the salon, on a set of cabinets, and in the center of the floor several feet away. They quickly learned that this wasn't just a small, isolated incident. This painted a picture of a room that had been drenched in blood. Detectives painstakingly covered the room with luminol, a special chemical that reveals traces of blood not visible to the naked eye.

• 1:27:47Courtney Brown?

  And when they did, they were left with a disturbing discovery. One of the detectives told Fifty Ways to Catch a Killer that after luminol was sprayed, the entire salon "lit up like a Christmas tree." There were large amounts of blood on the floor, spattered across the walls, on the chairs and the sink, on the cabinets, and even traces of blood on the salon's mop.

• 1:28:12Colin Brown?

  Based on the amount of blood found, investigators knew that Joleen Cummings was dead. Surveillance footage from outside also showed that Kimberly was likely throwing away key evidence, and possibly even parts of Jolene. But sadly, when investigators searched the dumpster, they discovered that it had already been emptied. Their next course of action was to track down where the trash had been taken. But first, it was time to alert Jolene's family and the public that this was likely no longer a missing persons case. It was now a homicide investigation.

• 1:28:46Speaker 06

  Through our investigation, we have obtained evidence. Which we are not releasing at this time, which leads us to believe Jolene is not alive. We have subsequently found out that Cybert's real name is Kimberly Kessler, K-E-S-S-L-E-R. Date of birth, May 9th, 1968. And she is from Butler, Pennsylvania. She had also been using a fake social security number.

• 1:29:14Speaker 06

  She has since been charged by the FBI with a federal offense of possession of a counterfeit passport.

• 1:29:21Speaker 06

  Kessler is a suspect in the disappearance of Joleen Cummings. We are working to obtain all and gather all evidence we possibly can related to this incident, and additional charges are forthcoming. We continue to follow up on all leads and gather additional information and evidence as to Kessler's location and dealings before and after May the 12th, until the time of her arrest. We know she frequented Inferno Marina Beach, Uly, the Bartram Park area of Jacksonville, as well as St. John's County. We are working closely with our state attorney's office, the St. John's County Sheriff's Office, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and the FBI. We will continue to search for Jolene, but she could be anywhere.

• 1:30:05Speaker 06

  We have searched for her utilizing all of our resources, including canines, horses, and boats. We are asking if anyone has seen or had any contact with Kessler, who is also known as Jennifer Cybert, or her vehicle, or has any information that would help us in our investigation, to please contact the NCSO at 904-548-4005, or contact First Coast Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS, or 8477.

• 1:30:37Colin Brown?

  Joleen Cummings, who had been in the prime of her life, had been taken from everyone who loved her. Following Sheriff Bill Leaper's statement, Jolene's mother, Ann Johnson, said a few words, pleading for help finding her daughter.

• 1:30:53Speaker 00

  Thank you to the press. Thank you for keeping her name out there. But I also ask that you give us some privacy. This has been a very difficult time. The majority of you have been very cordial and very helpful. Thank you. As we grow, as we draw close to day nine, that I reported my daughter missing, Sunday was a special day, not only for Mother's Day, but it was her birthday. She was born on Mother's Day. God gave me this special blessing after my first born infant, son, Richard, was buried.

• 1:31:36Speaker 00

  We are all heartbroken. Jolene's three children, her stepdad, her sisters, her brother, several aunts, uncles, cousins, myself, and all the extended family and friends. I want to sincerely thank Sheriff Bill Lieber and Director Henderson and the rest of the staff at the CID unit and Donna Thurston and members of NCSO, who have been working night and day to bring my daughter home, who unfortunately still has not been located.

• 1:32:18Speaker 00

  My daughter was a loving mother to her children. Her children were her life. I need you, the news, the public, to help assist the law enforcement agencies, to be their ears, to be their eyes. Someone out there, someone out there knows something. I beg you, I beg you as a mother, to please keep coming forward with any information that you have, no matter how small.

• 1:33:01Speaker 00

  Help with any possible leads that could help locate my daughter. For my three grandchildren who miss her so much, we want closure.

• 1:33:17Colin Brown?

  Thank you. Later that same day, a vigil for Jolene was held at the Journey Church in Fernandina Beach. Dozens of friends and family members gathered to pray for and remember her. After Sheriff Leeper's public statement, everyone was reeling with the shocking news that investigators did not believe Jolene was still alive. Maria Lorraine told Action News Jax, "The news today from Sheriff Leeper was a little devastating, but we can't say we didn't see it coming after 10 days of her being missing." But everyone, including Jolene's mother Anne and stepfather Connie, clung to the hope that Jolene would be found and returned home for a proper burial. However, finding Jolene's body would prove to be an impossible task.

• 1:34:00Colin Brown?

  The dumpster that police believed her body had been thrown into was taken to a massive landfill in South Georgia. That summer, in an effort to find Jolene, investigators geared up in body suits, masks, safety goggles, and steel-toed boots to begin sifting through the 6.6 million pounds of trash. The search went on for days in temperatures that reached up to 116 degrees. Medical personnel even had to treat some searchers for heat exhaustion. But day after day, there was no sign of Joleen Cummings.

• 1:34:33Speaker 06

  Now to the search for missing Nassau County Mom Joleen Cummings. In one hour from now, the almost week-long hunt for clues at a South Georgia landfill will end. Today, investigators announced that they found what they described only as items of interest related to Cummings' disappearance in Yule more than 60 days ago. News 4 Jax reporter Elizabeth Campbell shows us what this week has been like for members of law enforcement in that landfill and what's next.

• 1:34:59Speaker 03

  Brutal. That is the way Nassau County Sheriff Bill Leeper described the conditions more than 200 investigators have been working in this week here in Charlton County at the Chester Island landfill. Both he and the FBI say they are very proud of these men and women. New photos we received today from the FBI of investigators sifting through trash on the seventh and final day of the Chester Island landfill search. The FBI originally said they would go through 2,700 tons of trash, but they went through 3,300, which is more than 6.6

• 1:35:34Speaker 03

  Million pounds. Sheriff Bill Leeper says Kimberly Kessler is the only person who knows where her coworker Jolene is and that she's not talking. Whether the items of interest turn out to be relevant or not, he says the investigation will continue.

• 1:35:48Speaker 06

  We'll continue to follow any leads, credible leads that we receive. We have not received any credible in a while. So we'll continue with our criminal case, criminal investigation there to put a rock solid case together to make sure that this will never happen again.

• 1:36:07Speaker 03

  Ann Johnson, Jolene's mom, hugged law enforcement after the update today and thanked them and the community. She is asking for a favor from everyone tonight.

• 1:36:16Speaker 00

  At 7 o'clock tonight, I ask that everyone, everyone, join us in prayer. Prayer for my daughter to be found, for more evidence, and most of all, for justice to be served. Thank you, God bless.

• 1:36:31Speaker 03

  She says she's confident this case will not grow old and she'll get the answers she's looking for. Sheriff Leeper says those items will be sent to a lab with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. It could be several weeks before they get those results back. Reporting from Charlton County, Georgia, Elizabeth Campbell, Channel 4, the local station.

• 1:36:50Courtney Brown?

  Sadly, the items of interest that the police discovered were not definitively linked to Jolene. But luckily, even though they had no murder weapon and no body, the DA still believed that they had enough evidence to charge Kimberly Kessler with first degree murder. And on September 7th, 2018, those charges were finally handed down. That's when the media coverage of this case really took off. The world was shocked that this woman was able to drift through the country, using all of these different names and living all of these different lives. And soon enough, people started coming forward with stories about Kimberly Kessler, or whatever name they knew her as.

• 1:37:34Courtney Brown?

  Surprisingly, a childhood friend of hers, whose name was also Kimberly, said, quote, "We rode horses all over the countryside together, and we would do things like go skating. There was nothing that I could think of that was off or strange about her," end quote. But other people painted a very different picture. Kim's ex-husband, the father of her child, said that Kimberly was a very violent person. He said at one point she had even stabbed him with a pair of scissors. But the most recent bizarre story came from a man in Texas. According to this guy, in March of 2018, just months before Jolene's disappearance, Kimberly sent him a friend request on Facebook.

• 1:38:18Courtney Brown?

  Except, her name wasn't Kimberly Kessler, it was Mia Stone. After he accepted her request, the two started chatting back and forth. And eventually, Kimberly decided that she was going to go meet this guy. Without even telling him, she drove all the way from Florida to Texas. Once she arrived, she messaged him and asked if he wanted to meet her at a local Whataburger. The guy agreed, not thinking much of it. But as soon as he sat down with her, he realized he made a big mistake. You see, apparently he was going through some custody issues. And Kimberly had a solution to his problem. "Let's get married," she told him.

• 1:39:00Courtney Brown?

  "If the courts see that you have a wife, that'll help your custody case." The man said that he was completely thrown off. He barely even knew this woman, and she was asking him to marry her. He was so taken aback by her intensity, he actually cut the date short and left. But afterwards, he couldn't shake the feeling that he knew her from somewhere. She looked really familiar. And that's because he did know her. In fact, he had grown up with her in Butler, Pennsylvania. When he was a teenager, Kimberly was friends with his younger sister. He said she had developed an obsessive childhood crush on him, one that evidently followed her until she was 50.

• 1:39:43Courtney Brown?

  All those years later, Kimberly tried to start up a relationship with him, under a different name.

• 1:39:50Colin Brown?

  As all the stories started coming out, Kimberly told her mother in a jailhouse phone call that the reason she was getting this harsh media coverage was because Joleen Cummings' family was in the Illuminati.

• 1:40:02Speaker 00

  That there is nothing going on in the world? I say it's because it's the Illuminati. I think that, um... Her people definitely are seriously involved in it, so that's just what is happening.

• 1:40:16Colin Brown?

  In other phone calls that Kimberly made to her mother, she talked about how much she enjoyed being in jail. Here is a part of that call.

• 1:40:23Speaker 00

  It's kind of funny. They keep me in solitary confinement like it's a bad thing. It's heaven, girl. I love it.

• 1:40:31Colin Brown?

  For Jolene's family, this time of their life was incredibly difficult. They were in the thick of their grief after losing her. Her three children had to go on without their mother, and her loved ones had to come to terms with the fact that Jolene's body was likely buried under tons of trash in a landfill. Then, to add insult to injury, the woman responsible was just about the worst human on earth, and her behavior while she awaited trial was truly unbelievable. As we mentioned earlier, Jolene's family had close ties to the Nassau County Sheriff's Department. In fact, her stepfather had previously been the director of the Nassau County Jail. And when Kimberly learned of this, she was angry.

• 1:41:12Colin Brown?

  She demanded to be transferred to a different county, but they refused. So, in response, she went on a hunger strike. She claimed that the jail was poisoning her food. She also bizarrely stated that Hitler himself was involved in her poisoning. During her several hunger strikes, she dropped from 196 pounds down to just 74 pounds. Kimberly also went on violent tirades, yelling, screaming, and cussing uncontrollably. She would make obscene gestures and comments to the jail staff. As a result, there were multiple competency hearings to determine whether Kimberly was mentally fit to stand trial. Of course, these hearings continued to delay her trial. And ultimately, on July 3, 2019, Judge James

• 1:41:57Colin Brown?

  Daniel declared her mentally incompetent. From there, she was sent to a Florida State Hospital in Chattahoochee for mental health treatment. For Jolene's family, every trial delay only intensified the pain they were feeling. Here is Jolene's mother.

• 1:42:12Speaker 01

  Will she ever tell us the answers? I don't know. I pray for that. But we're not giving up. We are in a storm, and this storm isn't over with. We don't want this to go 25 years or never at being able to find her. She will be found competent. I arrest you. She will. She'll be found competent. You gotta believe in the judicial system.

• 1:42:36Colin Brown?

  You know, she may be intelligent. You got a higher power. We got people that are fighting, fighting to and working very diligently for this case. Jolene's mother, Ann Johnson, was right. After eight months in the Florida State Hospital, Kimberly was reevaluated. And in March 2020, Judge James Daniel reversed his finding and declared her competent to stand trial. He determined that Kimberly was not delusional, but rather manipulative and psychopathic. And as if to prove his point, Kimberly responded by going on yet another hunger strike in an attempt to get out of serving her punishment. Meanwhile, women who interacted with Kimberly at the Nassau County Jail admitted that she

• 1:43:20Colin Brown?

  always walked around with a Bible and enjoyed eavesdropping on other inmates' conversations. Her roommate stated that Kimberly often talked about her mother, whom she referred to as "mommy dearest," stating that when she was a little girl, her mother sold her to men. Kimberly also repeatedly claimed that she believed her mother kept a voodoo doll of her, which was made out of her own hair, that she used to punish her. This, of course, isn't true and has been disputed by all of Kimberly's siblings, aunts, and cousins, who, for the most part, have refused to communicate with Kimberly whatsoever. But Kimberly's erratic behavior didn't stop there. Seven months after Judge James Daniel found Kimberly mentally competent to stand trial,

• 1:44:02Colin Brown?

  she went on yet another bizarre tirade in the courtroom and in her jail cell. This time, she claimed that her public defender, Jordan Beard, was a cousin of Joleen Cummings. Once again, this wasn't true whatsoever. Yet, for most of Kimberly's hearings, she interrupted proceedings with these claims. Here are all the different instances when she screamed out in court.

• 1:44:28Speaker 06

  We may want to put her on mute while we finish this, Judge. It's fine.

• 1:44:33Speaker 02

  Let's just put me back on my cell.

• 1:44:37Speaker 02

  I want to get rid of the public defender's office. Yeah, exactly. Jordan Beard is Johnson's nephew. Jordan Beard is Jolene's cousin. Jordan Beard is Johnson's nephew. Jordan Beard is Joleen Cummings' cousin. Jordan Beard is Jolene's cousin. Jordan Beard is Jolene's cousin. Jordan Beard is Joleen Cummings' cousin. Jordan Beard is Jolene's cousin. And I refuse this assigned counsel. I refuse the public defender's office. I refuse it. I have refused it. I refuse the public defender's office.

• 1:45:17Speaker 02

  They appointed Jordan Beard, Joleen Cummings' cousin, as my public defender.

• 1:45:23Speaker 07

  You ready to begin today?

• 1:45:25Speaker 02

  No.

• 1:45:27Speaker 07

  Ms. Castle, today appears that today will be the last day that the state will be presenting evidence, and the defense will be afforded the opportunity to present evidence today. So I want to make sure you're aware of that. You want to stay here in the court, it's in your right. I want you to be able to do that.

• 1:45:46Speaker 02

  Sure, I can stay up here and I'm going to say what I want, when I want, how I want, which you silenced me for years. You have silenced me for years. So let everyone know, this is just the tip of the iceberg. Jordan Beard, public defender, is Joleen Cummings' cousin. Along with his brother Josh. Yeah. He squatted under the rug for three and a half years. Along with her father, her stepdad, who runs the jail, who recently retired. He still comes in.

• 1:46:16Colin Brown?

  Back in the county jail, Kimberly's behavior didn't improve. She destroyed a fire extinguisher, smeared feces all over her cell, and even threw feces at two police officers. According to First Coast News, in April 2021, Kimberly apparently stripped off her jail clothing and told the officers, "Okay, we can do this today." Then she grabbed several styrofoam cups filled with feces and started spreading it all over her body, on the walls, and throwing it at the officers. Even after being sprayed with mace, she continued to throw feces at them. Ultimately, officers were forced to use their taser to subdue her and remove her from the cell.

• 1:46:57Colin Brown?

  For this, Kimberly was charged with two counts of battery on a law enforcement officer. After this incident, she refused to leave her cell for court appearances and stopped checking in with her doctor regarding her mental health. For Jolene's family and friends, Kimberly's behavior only made their never-ending nightmare worse. On the three-year anniversary of her death, Jolene's mother, Ann Johnson, issued a statement to First Coast News that read, "What has happened in the past three years? Delays over competency. Here we go again. Enough is enough. The judicial process is confusing, frustrating, and overwhelming." It's now been three years since Jolene was murdered, and her remains have not been found. "The month of May is a very difficult time for our family. We have no closure.

• 1:47:42Colin Brown?

  Jolene's children are without a mother, and their world has been turned upside down. Nothing in life prepares survivors for the reality that someone you love has died of violent death. As survivors, we are grieving not only the death, but how Jolene died. A life has been cut short through an act of cruelty. The disregard for human life adds overwhelming feelings of turmoil, distrust, injustice, and helplessness to the normal sense of loss and sorrow. The world no longer feels as safe as it once did. When your child is murdered, grief is only the beginning." What a true statement. "Not only for my family, but especially for Jolene's three children. The hardest part of grieving is waiting for justice, waiting for Jolene's remains to be found.

• 1:48:27Colin Brown?

  The children are surrounded by Jolene's pictures. While I know Jolene's soul is in heaven, I feel her spirit is here, watching over her children. Sometimes I hear her say, 'Mom, do this or do that. Kiss and hug the kids for me.' It brings a smile to my face and tears to my eyes." I want to leave you with one last note. When we face times of delay, we can become frustrated, discouraged, and even angry. All of this combined together can become a breeding ground for the enemy to tempt you to quit and give up. Jesus said in Luke 18:1 that men ought to always pray and not faint. “We will not give up; pray without seizing for Jolene’s remains to be found; pray without seizing for justice to be served for Jolene’s children.”

• 1:49:11Courtney Brown?

  Finally, in December of 2021, three and a half years after Jolene’s murder, it was time for Kimberly Kessler’s trial. As Jolene’s family members entered the courtroom, it marked a long-awaited step towards justice. But everyone knew there was a lot at stake here. Without a body and without a murder weapon, the prosecution would be forced to convince a jury of eight women and four men, using mostly circumstantial evidence. Around 8:30 a.m., Kimberly Kessler was wheeled into the courtroom, where she went on another tirade about her attorney, Jordan Beard. Ultimately, she was removed, and from there, opening statements began. And based on the prosecution’s findings, we are going to walk you through what happened

• 1:49:56Courtney Brown?

  on that fateful day in May of 2018. But before we do that, we have to talk about what happened in the weeks before. As we mentioned, Jolene had been having some problems with Kimberly, who everyone knew as Jennifer Seibert. After weeks of tension, Jolene started telling her coworkers that something was off with this woman. Jolene even voiced that she planned on looking into this woman’s past. But during this time, it seems that Kimberly Kessler started making plans of her own. Twelve days before Jolene disappeared, Kimberly went to Google, coworker guilty of murder, missing person’s body not found.

• 1:50:37Courtney Brown?

  She also Googled, man with hunting humans DVD charged with murder, after coworker’s remains found in yard. So Kimberly was looking up cases where people had murdered their coworkers. In the days before Jolene’s disappearance, she also Googled female murderers. In the state of Florida, and the phrase "no body, no crime", to the prosecution, this showed that Kimberly was hatching a plan to kill Jolene. Then, on May 5th, Kimberly went to a store called West Marine, located right next to the salon, and while there, she bought a set of heavy-duty zip ties. Then disturbingly, she walked over to the salon's appointment book,

• 1:51:22Courtney Brown?

  and she took a picture of Jolene's appointments, which showed exactly when Jolene would be at the salon.

• 1:51:29Colin Brown?

  Meanwhile, Joleen Cummings continued on with her life. Despite the growing tension she experienced with her new coworker, her focus was on her work and her children. In the days before May 12th, 2018, Jolene's two sons had spent the week with their father per their custody agreement. It was hard for her to be apart from her children, and she was counting down the days until they would be reunited, which was Sunday, May 13th, 2018. It was supposed to be a special day for many reasons. Not only would she be with her kids, but it was also Mother's Day and Jolene's 34th birthday. She was so excited about it. All she had to do was get through the weekend, which included a shift at the salon on Saturday, May 12th.

• 1:52:10Colin Brown?

  That morning, I'm sure Jolene was annoyed to see that Jennifer was also on the schedule. Even worse was the fact that they were working the closing shift together. And the tension between the two women was palpable. Clients that were at the salon that day said that Kimberly was snapping at Jolene over small things like salon gift cards. As the clock ticked by, Jolene was looking forward to going home. Around 5:00 PM, her final client walked out of the front doors, meaning all she had to do was clean up and then she could go. However, she would never get the chance.

• 1:52:44Courtney Brown?

  Now what exactly happened next, we will never know. Perhaps the two got into an argument, or maybe there was no argument at all. It's believed that Kimberly had been planning to murder her. And Jolene was actively trying to discover who Kimberly was. Kimberly wasn't going to let that happen. So, once that client walked out of the door, Kimberly began her demented plan. The prosecution believes that she started by grabbing a pair of scissors used to cut clients hair. Then she approached Jolene and lunged at her. When Jolene realized that Kimberly had stabbed her, she was flooded with terror. She tried to get away to run to the front door, but before she could make it outside,

• 1:53:28Courtney Brown?

  Kimberly followed behind, stabbing her again and spattering blood across the room. I'm sure at that moment, Jolene's thoughts were with her children. She knew that she needed to fight back if she wanted to see them again. But she didn't have a weapon. She could only fight back with every bit of strength she could muster. So, within that salon, as Kimberly chased her around the room stabbing her, Jolene thrashed, kicked, and pulled, yanking out a chunk of Kimberly's hair. But Kimberly would not let up. They continued to struggle around the salon, breaking pieces of furniture, knocking over plants, and leaving trails of blood all over.

• 1:54:10Courtney Brown?

  At some point, Jolene sunk her teeth into Kimberly's thumb, slicing it open and crushing the bone. But Kimberly continued stabbing. Throughout the entire ordeal, Jolene screamed out for help. But sadly, no one could hear her. I'm sure she even tried to reason with Kimberly, begging her to stop. But Kimberly had already made up her mind. Weak and bleeding out from her wounds, Jolene watched as Kimberly towered over her. As she continued delivering more stabs, Jolene reached up and raked her fingernails over Kimberly's face, catching her left eye and leaving a trail of blood down her cheek. But sadly, she was overpowered.

• 1:54:54Courtney Brown?

  Kimberly was much bigger than her, and she had cowardly prepared for this moment. And it was here, on the floor of the salon, where she had spent her entire life making people's days so much better, Joleen Cummings took her final breath. The struggle likely lasted only a few minutes, but what came next took hours.

• 1:55:15Courtney Brown?

  Kimberly quickly cleaned herself off in one of the shampoo bowls, watching as her and Jolene's blood spiraled down the drain. As she looked around the room, it was a complete bloodbath. She knew that before the salon opened the following morning, she not only had to clean everything up, but she also had to get rid of Jolene's body. So it's here where she decided to make a trip to Walmart. Surveillance footage shows Kimberly wearing all black, walking through the aisles and grabbing a number of items, including gloves, trash bags, ammonia, and most concerning of all, an electrical carving knife. After purchasing her items, she made her way back to Tangle Salon. By now, it was dark.

• 1:56:00Courtney Brown?

  All of the businesses in the shopping center where the salon was located had closed. And as Kimberly Kessler stepped back inside, she immediately got to work. The prosecution believes that she used the electrical carving knife to dismember Jolene on the floor of the salon. As she put her body into trash bags, the clock ticked into the early morning hours of May 13th, Jolene's 34th birthday. Just hours earlier, Jolene was planning out how she was going to spend the day with her children. And now, she was in pieces at her place of work. Once the dismemberment was over, Kimberly went to work cleaning up the salon.

• 1:56:43Courtney Brown?

  After everything, it was completely covered in blood. And she cleaned up most of it, at least what she could see. Unbeknownst to her, there were still small amounts of blood spatter all around the room. There were still remnants of blood in the places she did clean that would later be revealed with luminol. But for now, as Kimberly threw everything into trash bags, she was pleased with her cleanup. The blood was gone, the body was dismembered. All of the chairs that had been knocked over in the struggle were in their original positions. The cleaning products were all put away. All she had left to do was get rid of the trash bags.

• 1:57:25Courtney Brown?

  Surveillance footage from nearby businesses show Kimberly walking back and forth, throwing a number of heavy trash bags into the dumpster behind the store. It was risky throwing a body in the trash like that, but Kimberly was willing to take that risk. When she walked back to the salon, she had one more thing to complete before she was finished. Joleen Cummings' car was still parked out front. If she left it there, her family and the police would realize that Jolene never left work the previous day. From there, they would want to talk to all the people she was working with. Or worse, they might check the dumpsters out back. So from there, Kimberly got into Jolene's car and drove it to a Home Depot.

• 1:58:10Courtney Brown?

  Surveillance footage captured her abandoning the vehicle and walking to that nearby gas station. While there, she chatted with the employee and used their phone to call herself a cab. That cab then brought her back to her own vehicle that was still in the Tangle Salon parking lot.

• 1:58:27Colin Brown?

  It's believed that during Kimberly's planning to murder Jolene, she truly thought she would get away with it. The Tangle Salon didn't have cameras. The parking lot directly outside didn't have them either. And in a stroke of luck for her, the dumpster where she dumped all the evidence was emptied and taken to a landfill without anyone noticing what was inside. As of now, it seemed like Kimberly was in the clear. But in the days after Jolene's disappearance, as police were looking into other suspects like Jolene's ex-husband and boyfriend, Kimberly Kessler's Google searches prove she was spiraling. Shockingly, she searched Joleen Cummings' name 457 times. She looked for information regarding autopsies, cadavers, meth addiction,

• 1:59:11Colin Brown?

  dismembering a body, and plastination, which is a way to preserve a body.

• 1:59:16Courtney Brown?

  Just by looking at Kimberly's Google searches, you can tell she was nervous. And she had every right to be. Because soon enough, police learned from several people at Tangle Salon that Jolene and Jennifer had been having problems. Obviously, they wanted to speak with her. But as soon as they tried, Kimberly tried to flee. When investigators eventually tracked her down and arrested her for grand theft auto, they found a pair of Kimberly's socks and boots that had Jolene's blood on them. They also found a pair of scissors with her blood on them as well, but I guess they were never able to prove that it was the murder weapon. Now, at some point, they also came across some footage of Kimberly dumping a blue tote bag

• 1:59:59Courtney Brown?

  into the woods behind a restaurant in town. And inside the bag, they found Jolene's fingernail. So even though they never found Jolene's body, they had plenty of evidence to prove that Kimberly Kessler was responsible for her murder.

• 2:00:15Colin Brown?

  But of course, at trial, Kimberly's defense disagreed. They argued that due to Jolene's body never being found, there was absolutely no proof that Kimberly murdered her. They told the jury, no body, no murder weapon, no crime. Now, as for the injuries that Kimberly had on her face directly after Jolene's disappearance, they argued that it's possible Jolene and Kimberly got into a fight that day. But that still didn't mean she killed her. As for the bizarre internet searches found on Kimberly's phone, they stated that there was no way to know for sure who conducted the searches or why. Clearly, their defense was pretty weak. But finally, after an agonizing trial on December 9, 2021,

• 2:00:58Colin Brown?

  after only one hour of deliberation, the jury found Kimberly Kessler guilty of first degree murder and grand theft auto. After the verdict was read, Jolene's family members and friends hugged each other in the courtroom. After three and a half long painful years, justice had finally been served. Kimberly Kessler was sentenced in January 2022. Before Judge James Daniel announced her punishment, he allowed Jolene's family members to deliver their victim impact statements to the court. Jolene's sister, Justine, delivered her statement first, using her uncle to read it aloud on her behalf.

• 2:01:36Speaker 07

  My name is Justine Brown. And Jolene was my older sister by six years.

• 2:01:43Speaker 07

  I wanted to specify Ray Tippin because she always wanted to let everyone know I was her baby sister. Even as adults, Jolene had the funniest laugh and a personality to match. She had the prettiest green eyes and loved to make people laugh. She ate the weirdest food and loved watching you Ashlyn, she got from when she did so. Jolene was the rock of our family. She was the strongest person I've ever known. I knew that no matter what, she'd always have my back.

• 2:02:25Speaker 07

  Jolene loved her three kids more than anything in the world. She was a wonderful mother. She was the hardest worker I've ever seen and she lost her life working to provide, to make the best life possible for her children. The last day I saw my sister was May 5th, 2013. It was my wedding day, the day that is supposed to be cherished, that's one of the best days of my life. Instead, when I reflect back on that day, I only remember how I should have hugged

• 2:03:05Speaker 07

  her, my sister, goodbye and told her I loved her. I will never be able to forget today, share a tribute to us and told, because my sister's gone. The pain I felt inside me and the hurt that I could barely feel, my heart was unimaginable. It has been almost four years and still the same way I felt that day and I know that it's something that I'll feel for the rest of my life. My sister was exposed to what she was trash.

• 2:03:48Speaker 07

  As a result, we don't get a piece of my nerd to rest as she deserves. The items that were used in this horrible detail, but my sister does unbearable. Simply every day I No longer just items to me anymore. I can't go to the store and not think about what happened because there are reminders all around me. Remember my sister's brutal murder.

• 2:04:26Speaker 07

  People always ask me how I am doing and I always reply, "I'm good." I can never really put into words how devastated I really am. I've experienced pain and loss, but nothing compares to the suffering and sadness that I feel in the reality that I'll never be able to see or talk to my sister again. I know how I feel, but I can never even fathom what my sister's children feel or the hurt my mom must feel having her child taken away from her. I have watched Jolene's children, lives be torn apart.

• 2:05:08Speaker 07

  The struggle that they have endured. The nightmares they've experienced. And the reality that her mother, their mother, is no longer here anymore. And never will be.

• 2:05:25Speaker 07

  How to explain to her children that they can't go to heaven to see their mom? This is just an example of the question one of the children asked.

• 2:05:36Speaker 07

  They will grow up and won't have their mother there to comfort them when they are sick. She won't be there when they graduate from school, go to college, or even get married. For Jolene's children, this is only the beginning for them. They have the rest of their lives ahead of them and they have to do it without their mom.

• 2:06:00Speaker 07

  Jolene still had her whole world ahead of her. She had dreams that will never be fulfilled and goals that will never be met. She had a family that she loved so much in the life of her children. Have been taken forever, have been forever changed and nothing will ever be able to take away the hurt that has suffered me feel. Well, children and family don't deserve for her to be taken away by the conscious decision of another. Jolene's life mattered and she will never be forgotten.

• 2:06:41Speaker 07

  We will make sure her children never question how their mother loved them and how happy they may have feel. Even though my sister is no longer here, I will always have her back, you know, will forever be her, always.

• 2:06:59Colin Brown?

  Ultimately, Kimberly Kessler was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Before sentencing, Kimberly was once again wheeled into the courtroom and shortly thereafter, escorted out due to another outburst. For Nassau County Sheriff Bill Leeper, the outcome was a celebration. Throughout the entirety of the case, he was outspoken on his beliefs that he did not think that Jolene was Kimberly's only victim.

• 2:07:25Speaker 00

  It's been for you as well, three, three and a half years. To hear that verdict in the courtroom for you all and go through this trial, what was that like?

• 2:07:33Speaker 06

  Well, you're right, it has been a long three and a half years. When we initially got the call of a missing person and started investigating, things we were finding out was just, to me, it was shocking that something like this would happen in our community. I can't thank the state attorney enough, Melissa Nelson, Donna, Ashley, for what y'all did. Our NCOS investigators are the best. They are the best. They worked day and night, for months, no sleep, trying to find out what happened to Jolene.

• 2:08:18Speaker 06

  But one person solved this case, and that was Jolene. Jolene left her blood, and she left her DNA, and that's what got her. That's what helped us close this case out. I don't for one second believe that Kimberly Kessler, or whatever her name she's going by today, I don't believe this is her first murder. I don't at all. She's evil, she's evil in the flesh. And as soon as she's sentenced, I want her behind, out of our jail, because we are fed up with her crap. It's the state's problem from now on. So we're glad the verdict came about, it was a just verdict, the jury came to the right conclusion.

• 2:09:01Speaker 06

  Our hark goes out to Jolene, her family, her children, her mother, her sister, but nothing's going to bring her back. And we're not going to rest until we find her. And hopefully one day, she will turn up somewhere. And we pray for that day.

• 2:09:16Speaker 00

  And we know she wasn't found in the landfill. Could she be anywhere else that you know of?

• 2:09:21Speaker 06

  She could be anywhere from Nassau County to St. John's County in between, we don't know. Uh, we have no clue. But hopefully one day she'll talk. I doubt it, but hopefully she will. But by God, we're going to keep looking. If we get clues, we'll keep looking. But she's being held accountable for what she did to Jolene, and that's what we're proud of today. So, thank you.

• 2:09:44Colin Brown?

  When she was transferred out of the Nassau County Jail and taken to the Lowell Correctional Institution in Ocala, Florida, jail staff celebrated with a party that included cake and ice cream. The cake read, "In incarceration relocation celebration." No longer would they have to deal with her tantrums and violent outbursts. And ultimately, her outbursts cost taxpayers a total of around $215,000 over the course of three years.

• 2:10:12Courtney Brown?

  Kimberly Kessler, leaving the Nassau County Jail in this white van, called for a cake and ice cream celebration. A deputy was seen doing a rock on hand gesture before her departure Friday morning.

• 2:10:24Speaker 06

  Her new home, for the rest of her life. And until she takes her last breath, it's gonna be Florida State prison.

• 2:10:31Courtney Brown?

  Kessler is beginning her life sentence for the 2018 murder of Joleen Cummings. Sadly, to this day, Joleen Cummings' remains have not been found. And Kimberly Kessler has refused to speak about what really happened that night. But for the people familiar with this case, there's a collective feeling of relief knowing she's never getting out of prison. That's right where she belongs. For years, this woman floated around the United States, using 18 different aliases. And there is no telling what she was up to throughout that time. For nearly everyone that's had the misfortune of knowing her, they've claimed that Kimberly is an incredibly violent and dangerous woman.

• 2:11:14Courtney Brown?

  Many people, including those in law enforcement, believe that she might have more victims out there. And that's not just based on a gut feeling. In fact, when investigators went through Kimberly's phone, they found a list of over 60 names with bizarre descriptions beside them, like "witch," "satanist," "evil murderous gang." And apparently, some of the names on her list are of people who have died over the years. But from what we can tell, investigators have never been able to connect Kimberly to their deaths, or even figure out why they were on her list. And Kimberly definitely isn't going to answer those questions, so we may never know.

• 2:11:55Colin Brown?

  In the years following Jolene's murder and her killer's trial, her family has done the best to keep her memory alive. Every birthday, they try to celebrate despite the horrible memories surrounding that day. But it's been a hard journey. Her three young children have had no choice but to go through life without their mother. Because of their young age, they luckily don't know the horrible details surrounding her death, but they find comfort knowing she's in heaven. According to their father, Jason, they think she's their guardian angel. One of Jolene's friends, Brooke Harley, stated that Jolene's son spent the night with her, and one of them admitted that he wanted to purchase a train ticket to heaven so he could see her again.

• 2:12:36Courtney Brown?

  Sadly, unlike many people who have lost a loved one, her family doesn't have a place to go when they want to visit her. Because Jolene's body was never found, the only place where they could connect with her was a bench at Buchanan Park in Hillard, Florida. For years, that's where her ex-husband Jason would take the kids anytime they wanted to see their mom.

• 2:12:58Speaker 06

  This is where we come visit her.

• 2:13:00Speaker 00

  It's not the typical place you go to grieve a loved one, but it's all Jason Cummings has. Does it hurt knowing that to have that moment with her, you have to come see a bench?

• 2:13:13Speaker 06

  All the time.

• 2:13:16Speaker 06

  Especially for the kids, you know, they don't have a grave site to go visit. This is the only thing they have to remind their mother and mama.

• 2:13:25Courtney Brown?

  In 2023, a plot and headstone were purchased at Jones Cemetery in Callahan, Florida. It helped provide a permanent resting place for Joleen Cummings. And although it hurts that she isn't there, it's given her family a place where they can remember and honor her. Jolene's mother and stepfather have even purchased the plot next to her so they can all be together one day, even if Jolene isn't physically there. But they're still holding on to hope. They believe deep within them that one day Jolene will be found. And when that day comes, they can finally be reunited.

• 2:14:03Colin Brown?

  For today's episode, we will be making a donation to Texas EquiSearch, a nonprofit organization that provides search and recovery services to families of missing persons and law enforcement.

• 2:14:16Colin Brown?

  Hey everybody. Thank you so much for joining us for this week's episode of Murder in America. Wow, this story is just incredibly heartbreaking, like every story that we cover here on the show. It never gets easier, but it's important that we keep talking about these people and raising awareness that evil can really strike anywhere. If you want to help support what we do here on the show, please consider joining us on Patreon. On our Patreon, you can get access to early ad-free episodes of Murder in America. So if you like the show and you don't like the ads, consider joining us on there. And if you run out of episodes, on Patreon, we post bonus episodes, two bonus episodes every single month.

• 2:14:57Colin Brown?

  These are full-length episodes of Murder in America, exactly like the episodes that you hear on all of our main feeds. But they are exclusive to Patreon and they will only ever live on Patreon. So we have, I don't even know at this point, 130, 150 bonus episodes, full-length bonus episodes on the Patreon. So if you want more Murder in America, you can help support the show there. Also, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @murderinamerica to see photos and videos from every single case that we cover here on the show. And as a reminder, please leave us a five-star review wherever you listen to the show. It's incredibly important, whether that's Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or really whatever platform you use. We love hearing from you guys. We love seeing the love and we appreciate y'all so very much.

• 2:15:42Colin Brown?

  Anyways, guys, we will be back next week with another episode of the show. Thank you for spending your morning, afternoon, or evening with us. And yeah, I'll catch y'all next week.

• 2:16:00Colin Brown?

  Hey, Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now, I don't know if you've heard, but Mint's premium wireless is $15 a month. But I'd like to offer one other perk.

• 2:16:09Speaker 00

  We have no stores. That means no small talk. Crazy weather we're having. No, it's not. It's just weather. It is an introvert's dream. Give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan. $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.

• 2:16:30Speaker 03

  Does checking your bank statements feel like digging through a dusty attic full of forgotten subscriptions and old free trials?

• 2:16:39Speaker 03

  Experian can help take the pain out of canceling by handling it for you. Think of it as Operation Get Your Sanity Back. Over 200 subscriptions are cancelable. So get started in the Experian app and see how much you could save. Results will vary. Not all subscriptions eligible. Savings not guaranteed. Paid membership with connected payment account required. See experian.com for details.

• 2:17:02Speaker 00

  Fall never arrives all at once. First the air, then the light. And slowly, the things you love begin to find each other. A jacket meets a dress. A hoodie slips beneath a blazer. An old cap finds a new scarf. Because you don't simply step into the season. You create it, layer by layer, until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.