The Hype and Skepticism of Finding Life on Exoplanet K2-18b

Brian Keating explores the buzz around a possible sign of alien life on exoplanet K2-18 b, discussing the detection of dimethyl sulfide—a molecule that on Earth is linked only to biology. He urges caution, explaining that while the findings are exciting and headline-grabbing, the evidence is not yet conclusive and scientific skepticism is essential. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  In the world of expense management, SAP Concur is here to help. From cost control slipping to travel chaos, SAP Concur has an integrated travel and expense solution to help you overcome problems like overburdened teams, decisions looming. When travel, expense, and AP are connected with a single AI-supported solution, SAP Concur keeps you ahead of problems. Visit concur.com to learn more.

• 0:30Speaker 01

  Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.

• 0:42Brian Keating?

  Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing. Hey, everybody. Life just may have slid into our DMS. And that's based on a discovery around the star known as K2-18b, the exoplanet, actually. And it's perhaps a discovery for all time, or perhaps it could be sort of another twisting turn in the long road to finding extraterrestrial life. So we may have heard a whisper. We may have heard a roar. We may have heard nothing. And that's why I want to present this short video. My friends and family are asking me about it. So I figured I'd make a short video about it. So what is the signal? The signal is sort of a hint, a molecular signal. It's not from extraterrestrial intelligence

• 1:26Brian Keating?

  or technology, but it is a whisper, perhaps of life, a signal faint and suggestive from a planet over 124 light years away. The name of the planet is the Winsome K2-18b. And according to a new paper by Dr. Niku Madhusidun and his team using the James Webb Space Telescope, they may have detected a chemical called dimethyl sulfide. Now, dimethyl sulfide, DMS, so slide into my DMS, in this alien world's atmosphere could be a harbinger of life. Not like us, but life nonetheless. And that would be one of the greatest discoveries of all time. On Earth, the DMS has just one source: life.

• 2:10Brian Keating?

  Predominantly, some argue about that. Specifically, microbes in the ocean produce it. So naturally headlines exploded. Possible signs of life discovered on a habitable planet. Revolutionary moment in the search for aliens. Disclosure is here. Even Dr. Mahusadon himself told the New York Times, this is a revolutionary moment. The first time humanity has seen potential biosignatures on a habitable planet. Now, I don't fault them for being so excited. I'm excited about this too. And I study cosmology. But it's a big claim and it requires big evidence. So let's not just book a ride to this planet anytime soon. We have to talk about what real proof might mean or might look like. First, let's understand what the signal actually is.

• 2:53Brian Keating?

  Now, this is detected in the atmosphere of the planet. And it was actually detected, this type of molecule, DMS, dimethyl sulfide was detected over a year and a half ago, I think, by James Webb Space Telescope. At that time, the significance was much lower, so called one sigma versus a three sigma or beyond that's required for scientists to accept it as a true hint or suggestion, even a detection. Now, K218B is not Earth 2.0. It's actually a planet about the size of Neptune, about 2.6 times Earth's radius and about 8.6 times its mass with a hydrogen-rich atmosphere and temperatures hovering just above freezing. This picture behind me from the New York Times depicts what's called the Hyacinth World,

• 3:35Brian Keating?

  a theoretical class of exoplanets with hydrogen ocean, Hyacinth Ocean, Hydrogen Ocean, under hydrogen skies. It's strange, exotic and unfamiliar, and that's part of the problem. When the Webb telescope looked at K218B, it wasn't snapping a photo. It was actually analyzing the spectrum of light filtered through the atmosphere. That means interpreting complex absorption lines buried in infrared noise. That's really challenging to do, and only the Webb can really do it for us. And while the team did find hints of methane and carbon dioxide, both previously expected and signs of life themselves in many cases, it's the possible detection of dimethyl sulfide, DMS, that slid into our DMs and caused us to raise eyebrows. And caution is advised.

• 4:17Brian Keating?

  According to their own paper, DMS detection is at low confidence. The signal's weak, it's very challenging, and the statistical significance around three sigma, which is below the usual threshold of about five or more required for a claim of detection in, say, particle physics or cosmology. Now, this is just one molecule inferred from one set of JWST transits using atmospheric models that depend on dozens of parameters. Temperature gradients, cloud layers, planetary mass, stellar activity, tiny changes in those assumptions, well, they shift the outcome completely. Also worth noting is that DMS isn't as exclusive to biology as we once thought.

• 5:02Brian Keating?

  A recent paper from last year, which I'll put a link to in the description below, along with a gift to you, the article from the New York Times from my friend Carl, shows DMS can arise from abiotic processes, nonliving processes, especially in comet-like collisions, or conditions, rather, or prebiotic chemistry that we don't fully understand. So, no, this isn't a smoking gun yet. It's a sort of chemical nudge. And the history of astronomy, especially these that involve chemistry on exoplanets, or even planets in our own solar system like Venus, remember phosphine on Venus? Remember the 1976 Viking mission and its positive life detection on Mars?

• 5:43Brian Keating?

  Remember the meteorite fragment found in Antarctica that had microbial life, elements of microbial life found on it? Featured in the movie Contact? Well, those all went away to some degree or another. So, this is where I think it gets interesting to my audience of cosmologists, physicists, and philosophers, and that's how to think scientifically also balanced with sociological thinking. Because the story about life tells us something about how science is communicated, and the interpretation has ramifications both in philosophy and even in theology. And so, when faced with these career-defining moments, scientists sometimes phrase ambiguous results with a dramatic tension. This revolutionary moment, as Dr.

• 6:26Brian Keating?

  Mahdi Ashen said, could be true, or it could be an example of scientific overreach. And it's not just the scientists that are eager to do this, the media too are eager to capture the public's imagination, and they lean hard into speculation, burying the caveats and glossing over the uncertainties.

• 6:49Brian Keating?

  But here's the thing, for me, when I think about this, the search for alien life is not going to end in a Hollywood moment. Most Hollywood moments aren't real Hollywood moments, they're often terrifying. There won't be a clear voice ringing out, "Take me to your leader."

• 7:05Brian Keating?

  No, it's gonna be slow, messy, frustrating, and filled with false starts, and often twists and turns, and full stops. And that's not a flaw. That's the way good, real, true science works. Discovery in the scientific process isn't a race, it's not a sprint, it's a crawl. It's agonizing. Sometimes when readers, and listeners, and viewers get burned by premature excitement, they become skeptical. Not in a healthy way, but in a somewhat dismissive way. So, we should all, as active citizens, and the media, and so forth, demand better from reporters, but from scientists too. We have an obligation, a moral obligation, as I often say, not to overstate our case. We don't want to hurt the credibility of

• 7:47Brian Keating?

  individual scientists, or the credibility of science itself. I'm not saying or accusing anyone of that in this case, I'm just saying, we should be advised to have caution not to overthrow the paradigm that we are no longer solely inhabiting this beautiful cosmos. So we live on this amazing time, amazing moment, when these technologies, these tools, funded by taxpayer dollars in the US and Europe, may have found life, we may have found life, but we also have to learn how we can recognize when we haven't found it, and know when we could be wrong. It's a story worth telling, and it's an incredible reminder of what Richard Feynman once said, as the first principle of science is that you must not fool yourself. And the second principle is that you are the easiest person to fool.

• 8:32Brian Keating?

  So we didn't find aliens, not yet. We may have found some evidence of the byproducts of life, that's very clear, we need to make that very clear. So it's a reminder of something else. Science isn't about belief. I always say, I don't believe in gravity. It's about having evidence, and it requires doubting precisely, rigorously, and beautifully yourself, most of all. Next time we'll talk about what real evidence might look like if aliens were discovered. And in fact, this coming weekend, I'm gonna have an interview with one of the pioneers in the search for planets beyond the orbit of Neptune in our own solar system. That's Dr. Mike Brown, who's also known as a killer, not just for his amazing scientific

• 9:13Brian Keating?

  abilities, but also for his killing of Pluto. So stay tuned for that. That's coming soon, Sunday, on my channel, Dr. Brian Keating on YouTube. So thanks very much for this short little update. Hope you enjoyed it, and we should have more data, evidence, and skepticism for now. Try not to be too excited for now. Okay.

• 9:36Speaker 01

  Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5, only at McDonald's for a limited time.

• 9:48Speaker 03

  Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.

• 9:51Speaker 04

  They're running a cover two defense. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go-to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats. Order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.