Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode follows beer writer and educator Mandy Neglich as she prepares for and takes the Master Cicerone exam, widely considered the hardest beer test in the world. The host catches up with Mandy at a New York City bottle shop to test her knowledge of beer styles and off-flavors, exploring her journey from winning a national homebrewing competition to becoming one of the top female beer experts in a male-dominated industry. After spending thousands of dollars of her own money and studying intensively, Mandy travels to Chicago for the grueling two-day test. Although she misses the passing score by just two points, she ultimately decides to channel her extensive knowledge into writing books about flavor and sensory science rather than retaking the exam.
The episode opens with a brief introduction and a short advertisement segment.
Dan challenges listeners to pair foods with beers, showcasing quick beer knowledge.
Dan introduces Mandy Neglich, her background in homebrewing, and her ambition to become a Master Cicerone.
Explanation of the Cicerone levels, Mandy’s progress, and the challenges she faced as a woman in the beer industry.
Dan and Mandy practice beer tasting, style identification, and off‑flavor recognition in a realistic setting.
Mandy takes the exam, receives her score, and reflects on the outcome and its impact on her career.
Discussion of Mandy’s next steps, her book, and the broader context of women in the Cicerone program.
The host welcomes listeners and sets the stage for the episode.
Teddy Swims promotes his music and encourages listeners to enjoy life and music.
The episode introduces the Cicerone program levels, noting that out of thousands in the industry, only 19 people in the world held the Master Cicerone certification when Mandy attempted the test.
Homebrewing Gold and Scrutinystory
Mandy reflects on winning a gold medal at the National Homebrewing Competition against 3,000 other brewers, only to face immediate skepticism and hostile questioning about her recipe from male peers at the awards ceremony.
Proving Credentials Against Skepticsstory
Mandy describes taking the online Certified Beer Server test alongside male acquaintances who doubted her expertise, ultimately scoring the highest among them.
Failing the First Attemptstory
Mandy recounts her first Master Cicerone exam attempt in 2019, where she walked into an active brewery to troubleshoot broken draft lines and realized she scored a 73 out of 100, falling short of the 85 required to pass.
Blind Tasting Study Sessionstrategy
During a simulated study session at Carmine Street Beers, Mandy tastes a flight of four complex beers and correctly identifies a Rausch beer by its distinct smoked malt flavor.
Pinpointing Off-Flavorsinsight
Mandy correctly identifies two spiked off-flavors in a blind test using tiny additive pills, naming four-vinyl guaiacol and hydrogen sulfide before even tasting the samples.
After flying to Chicago for the two-day exam and waiting six weeks for results, Mandy receives a score of 83, narrowly missing the 85 passing threshold and deciding not to retake the expensive test.
“I mean, there's no bad glass of wine and no bad meal.”
“The big development in Mandy's career since we last met up is that, as I said, she's trying to become the 20th Master Cicerone in the world.”
“I think having a Master Cicerone who's a little outside the industry, who can speak to consumers a little more directly and maybe speaking their language a little bit more is a really important move, not just for Cicerone, but for the beer industry.”
“The Master Cicerone Test is two full days and it's only given once a year, in person, in Chicago.”
“I got an eighty-three. Um, so no, uh, it's eighty-five to pass, so.”
“I think if I would have been able to take it in 2020, I probably would have taken it again in 2021. But it's just like waiting two years and like thinking about waiting another year. It's like, it just feels like I'm like staying in the same phase of my life.”
Mandy Naglich is an award-winning home brewer who also writes and teaches about beer. Now she wants to become a Master Cicerone — basically the beer equivalent of a master sommelier.
9,181 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated