The Fifth Annual “My Guy” Fantasy Football Draft With Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck
Hosted by Bill Simmons
- 2h 2m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Bill Simmons and the Ringer Fantasy Football crew of Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck sit down for their fifth annual My Guy fantasy draft, examining this season's lack of variance, injury concerns across top skill players, and the over-availability of preseason information. The discussion covers the biggest upside picks, true love candidates, late-round strategies, and players to completely avoid.
The hosts debate specific players and situations, from Brock Bowers' elite ceiling to AJ Brown's potential resurgence in New England, while also highlighting sleeper running backs and quarterbacks who could provide league-winning value without high draft capital. The episode balances deep fantasy analysis with plenty of football debate, team preview talk, and comedic tangents about coaching hires and player personalities.
- Targeting elite tight ends early, such as Brock Bowers, can provide a massive positional advantage when the rest of the tight end tier is stagnant. 12:28
- Target players with high target shares and elite route participation even if their previous situation was chaotic or frustrating. 19:40
- Leverage mobile quarterbacks in late rounds to take advantage of rushing floor value that outscores traditional pocket passers. 1:15:47
- Avoid drafting players with chronic injury concerns or unstable team situations unless they fall significantly past their ADP. 1:06:05
Chapters
- 0:00PayPal and NFL Sunday Ticket Sponsorships
Bill Simmons opens the episode with two ad spots, first for PayPal and then for NFL Sunday Ticket, setting the tone for the show.
- 1:59Introduction to the Fifth Annual My Guy Draft
Bill explains the history of the My Guy Fantasy Draft and introduces the guests Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck.
- 2:37Draft Prep and the Lack of Variance
The panel discusses the current fantasy prep season, noting a perceived lack of variance and sleeper prospects compared to previous years.
- 7:30Joint Practices vs. Preseason Games
Bill and the panel weigh the value of joint practices over preseason games for evaluating player performance and injury risk.
- 12:09My One True Love Category Begins
The draft kicks off with the first category, where each guest shares their top fantasy player of the season.
- 31:16Red Flags and Player Health Concerns
The conversation shifts to discussing red flags, injuries, and the reliability of players like A.J. Brown and Kenneth Walker.
- 34:22Closing and Poll Results
Bill wraps up the episode, shares poll results for the My Guy Draft, and signs off with a final note on the show’s future.
- 40:21Parker Washington Debate
The hosts discuss Parker Washington’s fantasy value, comparing him to other receivers and debating whether hype has pushed him too high.
- 43:10Jalen Waddle Evaluation
Danny and the crew analyze Jalen Waddle’s role on the Broncos, his potential upside, and the impact of a new quarterback on his fantasy production.
- 47:38Rashi Rice and Running Back Strategy
The conversation turns to Rashi Rice, other Chiefs running backs, and the broader strategy for selecting reliable, low‑cost RBs in fantasy drafts.
- 58:29Veal Chop Guy Debate
The hosts argue over the concept of a “veal chop” player, debating who fits that risky, high‑reward profile in the upcoming draft.
- 1:05:18D&D (Do Not Draft) List
Each guest lists players they avoid drafting, citing injury history, inconsistent performance, or questionable upside.
- 1:11:00Quarterback Loophole Analysis
The discussion focuses on quarterbacks who gain significant rushing yards, exploring how this can create a fantasy loophole for point production.
- 1:11:39Smart & Steady Draft Picks
A segment sponsored by PNC Bank highlights conservative, dependable players the hosts would rely on week‑to‑week in their fantasy lineups.
- 1:14:33Sponsored Segment: Duke Cannon Pucks of Soap
A playful ad segment promoting a soap product with fantasy football analogies.
Highlights
- 2:59
Too Much Information in Preseasoninsight
The hosts discuss how modern social media has eliminated true fantasy sleepers because every practice clip and hype video goes viral instantly, creating a lack of draft variance.
- 12:23
Brock Bowers as One True Lovestrategy
Danny Heifetz argues that Raiders tight end Brock Bowers is a premier target because of his historic rookie reception volume and new offensive system principles.
- 14:58
Kenneth Walker on the Chiefsinsight
Danny Kelly explains his love for Kenneth Walker, comparing his move to the Chiefs to Saquon Barkley joining the Eagles for an explosive offensive boost.
- 26:21
AJ Brown's New England Resurgencedebate
Bill Simmons and Danny Heifetz make the aggressive case for AJ Brown, arguing that a change of scenery and a better deep-passing quarterback will unlock massive production.
- 47:38
Rashee Rice Fantasy Valueinsight
Craig Horlbeck advocates for Rashee Rice despite off-field concerns, emphasizing his elite efficiency and top-five weekly production whenever he is on the field.
Quotes
“I think it's a better way to assess. I'm still auctioned for the other league I'm in, but but I think that's right because”
Bill Simmons · 14:31 “I think Kenneth Walker is perfect for that.”
Unnamed speaker · 15:17 “Lawrence loved this guy. He threw him all the time. He was always open. I actually feel like he can sustain that for the whole year.”
Bill Simmons · 41:03 “The way that Cohen talks about Parker Washington is like, he's his favorite player on the team, like, first guy in, last guy out.”
Unnamed speaker · 42:06 “I'm always, one of my weaknesses with fantasy is I overrate concussion guys.”
Bill Simmons · 47:04 “I think he will get the most points. All the stuff that happened last year.”
Bill Simmons · 57:06 “It's gonna be those two and running back by committee, but I think, I think Coker is gonna be a thousand yard guy. That's my most random dumb prediction of the, of the pod.”
Bill Simmons · 1:24:31 “McCaffrey has literally in the last seven years been maybe the most important player to have on your team in four of the years.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:26:50 “Laporta red flag next to him basically for the last two years, even though we all love him.”
Bill Simmons · 1:34:29 “Uh, yeah, I guess the Brown, the Brown shouldn't count.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:52:57
Sponsored segments
- PayPal 0:00–0:25
- NFL Sunday Ticket 0:39–1:30
- ChatGPT 33:15–34:13
- PNC Bank Fantasy Football 1:11:39–1:14:00
- Kansas Star Casino 2:02:03–2:02:31
About this episode
The Ringer’s Bill Simmons is joined by Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck LIVE on Netflix for their annual “My Guy” Fantasy Football Draft. (0:00) Intro (1:26) NFL fantasy prep discussion (11:36) “My Guy” Fantasy Football Draft Host: Bill Simmons Guests: Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck Producers: Chia Hao Tat, Eduardo Ocampo, Chris Wohlers, and Trevor Rabone Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at https://ChatGPT.com by selecting Work mode. Available on Plus and Pro plans The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit https://fanduel.com/playwithaplan to learn more about the resources and helplines Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
27,795 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Ringer
- Netflix
- YouTube TV
- Ringer Fantasy Football Show
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated