Pod Insights Murder With My Husband 257. The Blue Eyed Butcher - The Murder of Jeff Wright About this episode On this episode, Payton and Garrett dive into the case of Susan Wright, a woman who stabbed her husband and buried him in the backyard.
Links:
NEW MERCH LINK: https://mwmhshop.com
Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/themwmh
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murderwithmyhusband/
Discount Codes: https://mailchi.mp/c6f48670aeac/oh-no-media-discount-codes
Watch on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@murderwithmyhusband
Listen on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-dark/id1662304327
Listen on spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/36SDVKB2MEWpFGVs9kRgQ7?si=f5224c9fd99542a7
Case Sources:
ABC13.com - https://abc13.com/susan-wright-murder-trial-jeff-stabbed-husband-193-times/9184616/
Oxygen.com - https://www.oxygen.com/prosecuting-evil-with-kelly-siegler/crime-news/trial-blue-eyed-butcher-susan-jeff-wright-murder-texas
Case-Law.com - https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/wright-v-state-no-891659943
Yahoo.com - https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/where-susan-wright-now-061348614.html
Click2Houston.com - https://www.click2houston.com/news/investigates/2023/06/07/the-evidence-room-episode-16-193/
Kiro7.com - https://www.kiro7.com/news/trending/blue-eyed-butcher-texas-woman-who-stabbed-husband-193-times-2003-released-parole/GMR2DZYQLVEIBCYYT7DPOB6IW4/
NBCNews.com - https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna33510199
Abc7News.com - https://abc7news.com/archive/7736279/
TexasMonthly.com - https://www.texasmonthly.com/true-crime/susan-wright-193/
Wikipedia.com - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Wright_(murderer)#:~:text=Susan%20Lucille%20Wright%20(born%20April,his%20body%20in%20their%20backyard.
CBSNews.com - https://www.cbsnews.com/news/woman-stabs-husband-193-times-self-defense/
Chron.com - https://www.chron.com/neighborhood/article/Body-found-in-White-Oak-Bend-backyard-homicide-9734075.php
ABCNews.go.com- https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/story?id=127997&page=1
Hubpages.com - https://discover.hubpages.com/politics/Susan-Wright
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Everyone talks about how challenging it is to raise kids, but what about protecting them? Outlet covers, kitchen cabinet locks, baby gates? Where do you even start? Well, protecting your home and auto is a great place to start. Progressive offers customized coverage options, so you can be sure you have the right coverage. They're basically the baby gates of insurance. Get a quote at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Not available in all states.
0:29 Speaker 01 You know that feeling. Too many updates, too many meetings, too many things falling through the cracks. Monday.com was built for that gap. The AI work platform designed from the ground up for people and agents to work side by side and deliver more together. Drafting the brief, flagging risks, running a competitive scan, your agent can do it all. And the best part, anyone can build one, even you. Try it. Create your first Monday agent today at monday.com.
1:00 Payton Moreland? You're listening to an Ono Media Podcast. Hey, everyone, and welcome back to the podcast. This is Murder with my husband. I'm Payton Moreland.
1:07 Garrett Moreland? And I'm Garrett Moreland.
1:08 Payton Moreland? And he's the husband.
1:08 Garrett Moreland? And I'm the husband.
1:09 Payton Moreland? Again, if you are on YouTube right now, you will notice that we are definitely in a different set. If you're on audio, maybe we sound different, maybe not. There's no pop filter on this one, so I hope I'm not popping peas the whole time.
1:22 Garrett Moreland? No, I'm sure you're good.
1:23 Payton Moreland? But Garrett's probably going to use why we're at a different set for his 10 seconds. But before we jump into that, I actually dropped new Into the Dark merch, which is my solo show, if you didn't know. And I'm pretty sure there's a few left over. So if you were listening and missed it, go over to Into the Dark, the links are everywhere, and snag the little last bit of that merch. But yeah, I don't want to bore everyone with it. So let's jump into your 10 seconds.
1:49 Garrett Moreland? That's kind of all we got going on here. We are not home, as you can tell. We have been swimming with Daisy. So she's been living it up the last couple of days.
1:59 Payton Moreland? Yeah.
2:00 Garrett Moreland? Best day of her life. She's been crying 24/7 because all she wants to do is swim 24/7.
2:07 Payton Moreland? She literally, the second she wakes up, runs to the door.
2:11 Garrett Moreland? It's getting out of hand.
2:12 Payton Moreland? Yeah, I don't know what we're gonna do.
2:13 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, we have a monster in our hands. But yeah, for 10 seconds, I have been getting a lot of questions about...
2:22 Garrett Moreland? I've been getting a lot of questions about my hair transplant.
2:24 Payton Moreland? Oh, yeah.
2:25 Garrett Moreland? Cause Peyton posted some stories.
2:27 Payton Moreland? I actually posted the picture of his eyes super swollen.
2:29 Garrett Moreland? Like swollen shut. It's a process. A lot of people, a lot of people have been asking me, messaging me about it. Basically, right now, it's like a shedding phase. So for the next like a month and a half, my hair just kind of sheds, doesn't look great. It's called like the ugly duckling phase and then it'll kind of all come back in and everything will be good. But the first like two to three months is kind of just, I keep a hat on and just suck it up for the most part.
2:57 Payton Moreland? I will say I have followed a lot of hair transplant like journeys as Garrett was prepping to get his. And yours is looking good.
3:06 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, no, it's looking good.
3:06 Payton Moreland? I would say yours is above average.
3:08 Garrett Moreland? I think because I've had a lot of hair already.
3:09 Payton Moreland? Yeah.
3:10 Garrett Moreland? I mean, just like it was like the fronts that I kind of got touched up and thickened. Anyways, that's my 10 seconds. If you have any more questions, feel free to shoot me a message. Again, a lot of people asked about it. And again, I went somewhere in Salt Lake City. I did not go out of the country. Yeah, that's kind of all I got. Also, um, we'll kind of, we'll tag below where we're recording at. If you're ever in St. George, Utah and need somewhere to record and go check it out. But on that note, let's hop into today's podcast.
3:37 Payton Moreland? Our sources for this episode are abc13.com, oxygen.com, case-law.com, yahoo.com, click2houston.com, kiro7.com, abc7news.com, texasmonthly.com, cbsnews.com, chron.com, abcnews.go.com and hubpages.com.
3:53 Garrett Moreland? A lot of sources.
3:53 Payton Moreland? A lot. Okay, so no matter how big or small a case, how violent or discreet it all may have been, in the end, the entire investigation typically amounts to one big finale, and that is the courtroom hearing. A trial is supposed to be the most critical part in the justice system machine. But at the same time, It's theater, right? And you hear Garrett talk about this all the time and how annoying
4:27 Garrett Moreland? All the time, all the time.
4:28 Payton Moreland? A good performance by either the accused, a witness, an expert, or more importantly, the counsel can make or break a juror's opinion of the case. Was their lawyer convincing? Whose story was stronger, that of the prosecution or the defense? These are all things the jury has to keep in mind when they choose the fate sometimes of someone's life. But the problem with courtroom theatrics is they aren't always an accurate interpretation of the truth. They're a best guess. And sometimes all it takes is an Oscar-worthy reenactment to convince a jury of guilt, wrongfully or otherwise.
5:12 Garrett Moreland? It's actually funny because just the other day, I think I asked you, why sometimes they're a judge and sometimes there is a jury? And you were saying-
5:20 Payton Moreland? You said, if I was going to trial, would I pick a judge-only trial or would I let it go to a jury?
5:26 Garrett Moreland? And I would, and I said 100% I'd pick a jury.
5:29 Payton Moreland? And I said it would depend on the crime.
5:31 Garrett Moreland? Yes.
5:31 Payton Moreland? Because, and the, literally the reason I say that is because, is the exact thing I'm talking about. You can manipulate a jury way easier than you can manipulate a judge.
5:40 Garrett Moreland? Especially someone who's a prominent figure like a judge, right?
5:43 Payton Moreland? You gotta rely on your stupid peers.
5:45 Garrett Moreland? Yes.
5:46 Payton Moreland? Not your very smart judge who does this all day, every day. So today, we are headed to Houston, Texas, where Susan Wyche is born on April 24th, 1976. Susan and her two siblings were brought up in an upper-middle-class household. Their mother was the textbook definition of a homemaker. She watched the kids every day, made everyone freshly cooked meals, and tended to the home while Susan's father would head off to work each morning. And Susan's father was a mechanical engineer by day and then a husband with a temper by night.
6:26 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
6:27 Payton Moreland? When he wasn't laying a hand on Susan's mother, he was taking his rage out on his three children. As you can imagine, Susan and her siblings sort of had to learn how to walk on eggshells around him, as they put it. When he got mad, they learned to scatter and hide. But for Susan-
6:47 Payton Moreland? She grew up kind of thinking that this is what a normal marriage looked like. That everyone fell in love, got married, had kids, and then started hitting each other.
6:56 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
6:57 Payton Moreland? It was just another step on the path of life. Still, every day when Susan and her siblings left the house, they put on their smiles and went about their business, pretending that nothing was abnormal at their home. And of course, the weight of it all did end up taking a toll on Susan's grades. But as you probably know where this is going, the relationship with her father and how he acted at home most affected the way she sought attention from other guys. So Susan said she craved male attention and was willing to do whatever it took to get and maintain it. So when a boyfriend of hers made some snide remarks about her looks,
7:38 Payton Moreland? instead of breaking up with him, Susan dropped nineteen pounds to try and please him. And then during her senior year of high school, she realized she could actually make money this way by seeking attention of men, especially because she likes it. And so this is when she actually got a job as a dancer.
7:57 Garrett Moreland? What year were you in again?
7:58 Payton Moreland? Um, she was born in nineteen seventy-six and now we're around her just graduating high school life.
8:06 Garrett Moreland? I figured you said that. I just wasn't sure if this was going like OnlyFans route or like.
8:09 Payton Moreland? No, no. This is going dancer route and not the type of dancers that we were talking about at UDA college competition.
8:16 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
8:16 Payton Moreland? Okay. This was temporary for Susan, just a quick means to an end. Also, I didn't mean to make that sound like I don't support dancing as well because I support everything.
8:26 Garrett Moreland? Get your bag, man.
8:26 Payton Moreland? I support everything. So this, though, was temporary for Susan. It was just a quick means to an end. For the eight weeks she worked as an exotic dancer, she stashed away her cash because she wanted to go to nursing school.
8:39 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
8:40 Payton Moreland? Now eventually Susan had enough to begin her education and juggled that with her new job of working in a hair salon. So she danced just enough to rake in some dough and then was like, I'll get a job at a hair salon and I'll start going to school.
8:52 Garrett Moreland? So she was just doing it to save up money.
8:55 Payton Moreland? She's on the grind.
8:55 Garrett Moreland? Cash away and try to, okay.
8:57 Payton Moreland? But those dreams of becoming a nurse were too time consuming and expensive for Susan to stay committed to. So she ended up just quitting and working at the salon full time.
9:08 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
9:09 Payton Moreland? And then in April of nineteen ninety seven, the twenty year old Susan went on a trip with one of her girlfriends to Galveston, Texas. And it was during that little vacation that Susan locked eyes with a twenty nine year old man named Jeff Wright. Now remember Susan is twenty, she's still very young.
9:28 Garrett Moreland? And he's twenty nine.
9:30 Payton Moreland? And he's twenty nine.
9:31 Garrett Moreland? Okay, look, I don't know, doesn't bother me.
9:34 Payton Moreland? Okay.
9:35 Garrett Moreland? I'm just, okay, I'm just saying.
9:36 Payton Moreland? Maybe when you're, maybe when you're the type of girl who's trying to please a guy even at your own expense.
9:40 Garrett Moreland? We've had stories where it's like nineteen and like fifty, so I'm saying.
9:43 Payton Moreland? I know, I know, I know.
9:44 Garrett Moreland? We're gonna compare.
9:46 Payton Moreland? This isn't as bad.
9:47 Garrett Moreland? Correct.
9:48 Payton Moreland? And I'm not even saying it's always bad. It's not always bad, but with the wrong personalities, this could be harmful.
9:53 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
9:54 Payton Moreland? Right away, the two became inseparable. Jeff appeared to be everything Susan wanted in a partner. He was kind, he was caring. He bought her flowers, he took her to expensive restaurants, and only a few weeks in, he was already telling Susan he loved her. I know that love can move fast, but sometimes, again, with the wrong personalities, this could be called love bombing.
10:14 Garrett Moreland? What did the Peyton?
10:15 Payton Moreland? Yeah. No, I had to pull it out of him.
10:19 Garrett Moreland? Kinda true.
10:19 Payton Moreland? So when she took him home to meet her parents, they actually loved him too. He talked about his dreams for the future, how he hoped to start his own carpeting and flooring business. He would provide for their daughter, he would care for her, and Susan was smitten. So when Susan found out just a few months into their relationship that she was already pregnant, she wasn't panicking. She honestly was like, I love him, he's great, he treats me well. The pieces are kind of falling into place. But when she told Jeff, hey, I'm pregnant. He honestly seemed indifferent about the matter. He told her, I'll be fine if you want to terminate the pregnancy. I don't care. Now, this wasn't an option for Susan. She told Jeff
11:01 Payton Moreland? she was keeping the baby. And in October of 1998, when Susan was just a month shy of delivering, the two were married in a tiny little ceremony right outside of Houston. But after their son, Bradley, was born, Susan says she saw something change in Jeff. Keep in mind, the two had only been together for about a year by the time they got married. So you're still learning things about people at that point, right? And now you have a baby and you're married, but you're still going to learn things. But what she was uncovering now, post-marriage and baby, it wasn't just like, oh, I learned that he leaves the sink on while he brushes his teeth. It wasn't good.
11:44 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
11:45 Payton Moreland? Suddenly Jeff began getting nasty with Susan. He often called her names and criticized her weight after she gained a few pounds from her pregnancy. And when she was suffering from postpartum depression with their son, Jeff refused to let Susan take the medications that her doctor had prescribed to her. He said, quote, "Suck it up and do your job." So from there, he supposedly only got more and more controlling over Susan. It was kind of this downward spiral. Susan said she could only leave the house to make quick trips to the grocery or drugstore or to visit her mother. But if she was ever gone for more than two hours, she would not hear the end of it.
12:26 Garrett Moreland? Interesting.
12:27 Payton Moreland? When she told Jeff she wanted to start taking college courses again, he was like, absolutely not. So Susan snuck away one night to the college campus to see if there was like an online course that she could take from home. But when Jeff found out that she had done this, he began accusing her of cheating on him, calling her horrible names. And there were also things about Jeff's past that were now coming to the surface in this new marriage, like the fact that just a year before she met Jeff, he had pleaded guilty to felony drug possession. Now, according to some sources, this wasn't a, well, it wasn't a one-off event. Apparently, he didn't tell her, but Jeff had had a pretty rocky past when it came to drugs and alcohol, particularly in his high school years.
13:13 Payton Moreland? And apparently Jeff's past was back to haunt them both because not only was Jeff smoking marijuana almost every single day, which I know a lot of people do. So, but on top of that, Susan said, as she's trying to raise this baby and suffering with postpartum depression and he's super controlling, he would go out drinking and doing harder drugs.
13:34 Garrett Moreland? That's what you're saying.
13:35 Payton Moreland? Um, all at night and then would come home angry because the drugs were making him angry.
13:40 Garrett Moreland? And she doesn't really have any family she can go to, like escape, correct?
13:45 Payton Moreland? Well, yeah, I mean, it's like living with her father all over again. This is what her whole life looked like. Susan also claimed that when Jeff was in this state, he began physically abusing her. This was something that got even worse when they moved into a new home by the year of 1999. That's when Susan said every little thing, like every little thing began to set Jeff off. If there was a problem with a client or if the utility bills were too high or if dinner wasn't cooked exactly how he liked it, he would fly off the handles and the abuse never let up. He was kicking, punching, throwing her up against walls and windows. On one road trip to see his parents, Susan, yeah, Susan said Jeff slammed her head into the dashboard
14:29 Payton Moreland? while they were driving and the child was in the backseat. And Susan kept all of this to herself. This is what she'd always said. I mean, you have to realize she grew up in this environment and kept it a secret as well.
14:40 Garrett Moreland? We talk about DV a lot. I feel like a lot of our cases involve DV. I mean, we, we kind of say it every time. It's, it's so hard.
14:48 Payton Moreland? To pipeline.
14:49 Garrett Moreland? To get out of.
14:49 Payton Moreland? Yes.
14:50 Garrett Moreland? Like you obviously want to tell the person to get out of it and they know it, they know. But it's just a, the trauma and the manipulation and just everything, everything that involves it is wild.
15:02 Payton Moreland? Garrett and I were just talking about this last night.
15:05 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
15:05 Payton Moreland? Domestic violence really is one of those things that you should not be judging until you're living that experience because we truly, we can't put our mind where, where.
15:16 Garrett Moreland? And it's hard. I would say probably before we started this podcast, I would just look at, I mean, usually, I mean males too, but usually it's a female in the DV situation.
15:25 Payton Moreland? Hmm.
15:26 Garrett Moreland? Um, I would just look and be like. What are they doing? Just leave?
15:30 Payton Moreland? Yeah.
15:30 Garrett Moreland? Just go somewhere. Just get out. And yeah, I mean, obviously, it's easy to say that. But there's, there's.
15:36 Payton Moreland? You realize how even more complex.
15:38 Garrett Moreland? There's just layers to it. There's a lot to it.
15:41 Garrett Moreland? P S. If you are watching on YouTube and you see me itching my head. It's been a very common occurrence the last few weeks.
15:48 Payton Moreland? I told them today in public, I said, stop itching your head. People are gonna think you have life.
15:51 Garrett Moreland? I said, I don't even care.
15:54 Payton Moreland? Um, okay, so. Yeah, I think I think domestic violence is just a very complicated and complex thing that you truly can't wrap your head around it until you've been through it.
16:03 Speaker 04 The mighty dollar. Once upon a time, it had a whole menu named after it. Now, no more. But $1 a day lets you add Progressive Renters Insurance to your auto insurance. Definitely something your younger self would roll their eyes at, but your current adulting self appreciates. Learn more at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Average premium cost based on Progressive Home data from 2025. Product and prices may vary by state.
16:30 Payton Moreland? All right, guys, we're jumping into an ad. And if you are like me. Protecting the people inside your home is a top priority. I have Daisy at home. I'm about to have a baby at home and Garrett and me. And there are a lot of times where I've thought about our safety, but that is where Simply Safe comes in and has had my back, honestly, for years. Unlike traditional security systems that only alert you after a break in is already underway. Simply Safe is built to stop it before it starts, which is exactly what I'm looking for. I don't even want someone in my home. I want it stopped before the alarm has even gone off.
17:09 Payton Moreland? Smart AI-powered cameras watch for potential threats and alert a live US-based security specialist. Ready to intervene. The agent intervenes in under 30 seconds, speaking through the camera to stop an intruder in their tracks, calling for urgent 911 dispatch when it's needed most. And we've partnered with Simply Safe to offer our listeners their biggest savings of the year. 70% off your new system with professional monitoring. If you've been thinking about a security system. It is now 70% off, guys, when you visit simplysafe.com/husband. That is simplysafe.com/husband. And when you order, just write in murder with my husband at checkout. Tells them we sent you, really helps the show.
17:53 Payton Moreland? Simply Safe, ahead of crime in real time. And now, as an adult, she still kept this abuse from her friends and now her family. She painted the picture of a happy wife in a happy marriage. If things weren't good, she just didn't leave the house. Which may be why so many people thought Jeff and Susan honestly had a perfect little life. But in the summer of 1999, Susan had reached a breaking point. After another beating from her husband, Susan called her sister Cindy for help while Jeff was at work one afternoon. You have to, you probably, you have to imagine how mind blowing this was for Cindy, who knew nothing was going, who didn't know anything was going on in this marriage.
18:36 Payton Moreland? So she tells Cindy about the abuse and Cindy and her husband arrived hours later in a U-Haul and they helped Susan pack all of her and Bradley's things and she got them out of there. But the following morning, Jeff called her, threatening her. He said he was sending a moving van back over and if she didn't pack it all up and come home, he was going to kill her and Bradley.
18:58 Garrett Moreland? So cops, what happens?
19:00 Payton Moreland? No, she feels like she has no choice and things only get more complicated because Susan got pregnant.
19:08 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
19:08 Payton Moreland? Um, but then had a miscarriage when Jeff was beating her in the stomach and she lost the baby. And, but it's just this toxic cycle of being scared, you know, just your, your, what you can usually see. So then in December of 2001, she gets pregnant again, this time with a little girl they named Kaylee. And now Susan has three lives to protect hers and her two kids. This is all while Jeff lived his life doing whatever he wanted, including dating women. Like he would just cheat all the time. He gave Susan an STI that he had gotten from one of the women he was sleeping with. It's really so much for Susan or anyone to bear.
19:51 Payton Moreland? And with Jeff literally threatening to kill her if she tries to leave again. That's when Susan realized, and this is Garrett literally just said this on last week's episode. But Susan comes to the realization, he'll never let me leave peacefully. I will die.
20:08 Garrett Moreland? Yep.
20:09 Payton Moreland? So it's either
20:10 Garrett Moreland? Kill or be killed, man.
20:13 Payton Moreland? So on the night of January 13th, 2003, that decision would be made. So that evening Jeff came home from his weekly boxing lesson with a look in his eye. Susan knew it all too well. Jeff was high on cocaine. And that's when he started taunting the now four year old Bradley, trying to get him to box with him. Jeff began taking jabs at the little boy's face, eventually hitting him pretty hard on the cheek. And the more Bradley tried to run away and resist the fighting, the more Jeff was badgering him, calling him a sissy.
20:45 Garrett Moreland? He was four?
20:47 Payton Moreland? Yes. So Susan removed the children from the situation, putting them on the bed. But at this point she was like, I can't. I, I cannot do this anymore. I can't. Susan, at her breaking point, went to the bedroom and confronted Jeff. She said, it is time for you to find other ways to deal with your rage. You need to get help for your addiction. You need to go to therapy.
21:10 Garrett Moreland? Oh, I'm sure that went over amazing.
21:12 Payton Moreland? No, Jeff does not appreciate it. He throws her against their bedroom wall, tells her not to give him any ultimatums. Then he pushed Susan to the bed and began sexually assaulting her.
21:24 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
21:24 Payton Moreland? Susan closed her eyes.
21:26 Garrett Moreland? Insane dude.
21:27 Payton Moreland? She was scared of what was coming next because this was a really, really bad fight. And when she opened her eyes, according to her, Jeff is holding a knife above her. This has escalated to that point. So Susan did the only thing she could think to do at that moment, which she hadn't really done. She fought back. She kicked Jeff. She actually managed to grab the knife from his hands and she just began stabbing him in the bedroom while her kids are in the other room.
21:54 Garrett Moreland? I didn't see this going this way.
21:56 Payton Moreland? So as soon as she gets the knife, she's stabbing him over and over again. She stabs him in his chest, his neck, his stomach, his legs, his genitals.
22:02 Garrett Moreland? Holy crap.
22:03 Payton Moreland? Everywhere on his body.
22:06 Garrett Moreland? How many times?
22:07 Payton Moreland? Well, a hundred and ninety-three wounds on his body.
22:13 Garrett Moreland? So a hundred and ninety-three stabs or a hundred and ninety-three wounds?
22:17 Payton Moreland? Stabs altogether.
22:18 Garrett Moreland? Okay, so even if we take fifty percent of that, let's go, let's just say ninety-ish stabs. I mean, Peyton and I talk about this on the podcast a lot. I'm trying to figure out how to say it. I mean, she obviously is angry and we talk about how intimate. When someone kills one with a knife, it's anger, it's it's other things that are involved.
22:36 Payton Moreland? It's rage.
22:37 Garrett Moreland? It's rage, right? Uh, keep going.
22:39 Payton Moreland? According to Susan, she like fully admits, no, something came over me and I couldn't stop. Like, once I started, I did not stop.
22:45 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
22:46 Payton Moreland? Um.
22:46 Garrett Moreland? I mean, I don't blame her. I don't know.
22:47 Payton Moreland? And you have to like, uh, this story is just like.
22:51 Garrett Moreland? Wait, was her kid in the room?
22:52 Payton Moreland? In the room, in the next room.
22:54 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
22:55 Payton Moreland? The reason that Susan stopped stabbing is because she hears a little knock on the door.
22:58 Garrett Moreland? Got it.
22:59 Payton Moreland? And Bradley is asking if everything's, are you okay? Now Jeff is already dead, but Susan wasn't convinced, so she hid the knife. She wiped the blood off herself. She walked Bradley back to the bed. She tucked him in. She said, everything's fine. But in the back of her head, she's like, what if he's alive? Like, what if he's alive? What if he's gonna get up, you know, on the movies? So as soon as the kids are back tucked in, she goes back to the kitchen. She grabs a brand new knife. She goes back to the bedroom and stabs him several more times.
23:29 Garrett Moreland? That part's, that part's kind of wild.
23:31 Payton Moreland? So this comes to a grand total of one hundred and ninety-three wounds. And this is why I opened this.
23:35 Garrett Moreland? I didn't expect this part.
23:36 Payton Moreland? Because this case is complicated and you now understand why trial is gonna be probably the biggest part of this case. Because you do have. A woman who was threatened, who was be, who probably did feel like she was, well, she was fighting for her life.
23:50 Garrett Moreland? Oh, for sure.
23:51 Payton Moreland? But is this self-defense is 193 wounds? Can you argue self-defense?
23:55 Garrett Moreland? Does it matter? Like, does it matter if it's self-defense? I mean,
23:58 Payton Moreland? Well, that's why you're not on the jury.
23:59 Garrett Moreland? I mean, does it matter if it's a mix between self-defense and also being angry? Like, you know what I'm saying?
24:05 Payton Moreland? That's up to the jury.
24:06 Garrett Moreland? I know it's up to the jury. Okay, let's hear what they say.
24:08 Payton Moreland? So after this,
24:10 Garrett Moreland? Sorry, we talked about it, I think, a couple of weeks ago. Put me on the jury.
24:14 Payton Moreland? No.
24:15 Garrett Moreland? They never will. I'll never be on a jury because of the podcast. You know, I might squeak through.
24:20 Payton Moreland? When you say kill or be killed, you will never be a part of it.
24:22 Garrett Moreland? I think as soon as they look into the, what we do for a living, they'll be like, nope, not happening. Cause I will leak out. No, I'm just kidding.
24:29 Payton Moreland? So Susan is done now. And she's like, oh.
24:35 Garrett Moreland? What do I do?
24:35 Payton Moreland? Now what?
24:36 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
24:37 Payton Moreland? How is she gonna clean up this mess? Get her husband out of the house without anyone knowing? Um, the only thing she could think of was a dolly that they had outside. So she goes out.
24:47 Garrett Moreland? She didn't call the police?
24:49 Payton Moreland? I told you this case is gonna be complicated.
24:52 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
24:53 Payton Moreland? She, I'm trying to just give you the facts, as is, I'm trying to give you Susan's history and background and the reality of her life, but also give you how horrific this murder was.
25:03 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
25:04 Payton Moreland? How she had thought about killing him before, does that make it premeditated? Even though it was self-defense, it is so complicated. So she brings the dolly into the bedroom, she pushes Jeff off the bed and onto the cart and she wheels him into the backyard. Conveniently, Jeff had dug his own grave just a few months earlier. There was a hole in the backyard that he had dug because he was planning to install a fountain. But he hadn't done it yet.
25:29 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
25:29 Payton Moreland? So Susan dragged him off the dolly, put him in the hole, and then covered it with dirt. But even as the 26-year-old Susan, so young, caught her breath, the reality of the situation hadn't sunk in yet. She said even at this point, she was worried that Jeff wasn't dead.
25:50 Payton Moreland? And I think that this is coming from her, her lawyer trying to argue the amount of
25:55 Garrett Moreland? The psychology behind it.
25:58 Payton Moreland? Yeah, like the amount of fear she had and how that proves that this is self-defense.
26:04 Garrett Moreland? I understand it to an extent, right? She starts having all this PTSD and I'm not saying I don't believe her. Like I totally, it totally makes sense that that can't happen.
26:13 Payton Moreland? I mean, she's not sitting here panicking going, oh shoot, how do I get out of this? She's sitting here panicking going, oh shoot, what if he's alive and gets out of this?
26:19 Garrett Moreland? Think about last week's case, he had to remember, he had to pretend he was dead.
26:24 Payton Moreland? Yeah.
26:24 Garrett Moreland? Like the cops set up a whole stint. He had to pretend that he was dead. So I mean, this happens.
26:29 Payton Moreland? Yeah. So she actually goes back inside. She sits on the couch. She stays up all night. A knife in her hand staring at the door.
26:37 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
26:38 Payton Moreland? Just to make sure that he doesn't get up and come back in again, according to her story and her lawyer. For the next few days, Susan says she remained in a hazy fog, just on autopilot. But Jeff's parents obviously knew something was wrong. So on the afternoon of January 14th, Jeff's parents called Susan worried. They said they were expecting to hear from Jeff last night, the night she, that she killed him, but he never called. Is everything okay? Did he come home? Susan was like, yeah, uh, but we got into a terrible argument. She said Jeff got so mad at her that he actually poured a bottle of bleach all over their bedroom, which in her mind, she's trying to now cover up what she's done. So she's like, if I tell his parents that there was bleach in the bathroom or in the bedroom,
27:22 Payton Moreland? then if police find the bleach, they're not going to think it was me.
27:25 Garrett Moreland? Why not just call the cops? She's just too scared?
27:28 Payton Moreland? I think she's just in.
27:30 Garrett Moreland? Like is she having a mental breakdown?
27:32 Payton Moreland? Yeah. I mean, I don't know if I'd go that far, but it's like, what do you do?
27:36 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
27:36 Payton Moreland? So, I mean, 190 wounds, how are you going to explain that to the cops?
27:41 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, I get that.
27:42 Payton Moreland? So to the rights, his parents, this just doesn't make sense. They're like, Susan's acting weird. Why would he have poured bleach? This is not right.
27:50 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
27:51 Payton Moreland? And Susan actually told this same story to Jeff's boss when he called later that day looking for him. And then also to a neighbor who called to check in. And after hearing the story, the neighbor told Susan she should file a report with the police because the entire situation sounds like domestic abuse. Like she's like, well, if Jeff really did that, you should go file a police report. Which was actually something Susan took them up on the following afternoon. So January 15th. So this is two days after cleaning up the crime scene and emptying the joint bank account she shared with Jeff. Susan walked into the Harris County Constable's office. There she told them the same story she had shared with the others, including the fact that he had hit their son on the night of the 13th.
28:35 Payton Moreland? She also showed them pictures on her phone of cuts and bruises that she had. She told police she wanted a restraining order from her husband for both her and her kids. And she officially filed a domestic violence complaint.
28:50 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
28:51 Payton Moreland? Now, obviously, we know her husband is deceased in the backyard at this point.
28:56 Garrett Moreland? And she still hasn't told them that, obviously.
28:57 Payton Moreland? No.
28:58 Garrett Moreland? So by January- Can you imagine calling and filing a DV complaint, but then being like, my husband's dead because I killed him?
29:04 Payton Moreland? Yeah. So by January 18th, the pressure was too much for Susan. Everyone's calling, everyone's asking, where's Jeff? Where's Jeff? And it was only a matter of time before someone would come to the house and notice things are wrong. And that evening presented another huge hiccup for Susan because their dog had been in the backyard digging at the grave. And he had allegedly exposed a part of Jeff's head. He had also chewed-
29:31 Garrett Moreland? Wild.
29:32 Payton Moreland? Well, he had also chewed off Jeff's hand and she found the dog gnawing at it on their patio.
29:38 Garrett Moreland? This is wild.
29:39 Payton Moreland? So that's when Susan was like, I've got to get out of here. So she grabbed the kids, she threw them in the car and she went to stay with her mother. When she got there, Susan's mother finally confronted her about it. She's like, where's Jeff? Did you do something to him? And Susan confesses to her mother that she murdered him. Now, I can only imagine what it was like for Susan's mother. I'm sure she's in panic. She tells Susan, go send the kids to stay with Cindy. That's their aunt, her sister, and we are going to find an attorney. So-
30:10 Garrett Moreland? Oh, and that's-
30:11 Payton Moreland? She's like, you're turning yourself in.
30:13 Garrett Moreland? Well, no, it's like the first time I've heard someone say, I'm getting an attorney before the cops start questioning me.
30:18 Payton Moreland? Yes. Well, I mean, as the mom, you're like, listen, you're not going to hide. You're going to admit to the murder, but we're going to find you an attorney first. So- They lock in on a guy named Neil Davis and before going to the police, she tells her attorney everything, which
30:34 Garrett Moreland? We talked, okay.
30:35 Payton Moreland? Yeah, I know.
30:36 Garrett Moreland? I've talked about this with you guys many times, all of you attorneys and lawyers who have
30:42 Payton Moreland? But we don't want a murderer
30:44 Garrett Moreland? Sent me DMs.
30:45 Payton Moreland? Getting an attorney before, but you also a victim, you do want getting an attorney before.
30:53 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, I don't know.
30:53 Payton Moreland? And so it's this weird thing because it two statements can be true at once. She can be a murderer and also a victim.
30:59 Garrett Moreland? That's true. I guess I was referring to something different when I asked them about attorneys lying and
31:06 Payton Moreland? Oh, the attorney's not gonna lie.
31:07 Garrett Moreland? No, no, but I'm saying I guess it's a different situation.
31:10 Payton Moreland? Yes.
31:10 Garrett Moreland? Because it's who we think is probably the quote unquote good guy in this story, even though she killed someone, she's technically the
31:19 Payton Moreland? It's a twisted story.
31:20 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
31:21 Payton Moreland? So Neil Davis, she tells him everything. She's like, listen, like, I don't know what to tell you. Not only did I kill him, I stabbed him a hundred and ninety seven times. I snapped. She's like, I snapped. Enough was enough. I could not take it anymore. She said, I thought he was gonna kill me and the kids if I didn't kill him first. So only hours after confessing everything to her mother and attorney, Neil Davis was walking into the Harris County District Attorney's Office and he said, if you go to the address, you will find a dead body in the backyard. Now, when the police pushed for more details, Neil said, nope, attorney client privilege.
32:03 Payton Moreland? But hey, when a lawyer says there's a dead body somewhere, the police are gonna go. She's like, I'm not telling you any details, but I'm just letting you know, this is our us officially turning in that a crime has been committed.
32:14 Garrett Moreland? So smart that
32:14 Payton Moreland? But he doesn't make her go in.
32:16 Garrett Moreland? So smart.
32:17 Payton Moreland? The police do. They sent a team down to the home and sure enough, after barely scanning the backyard, they found him partially buried. His head, his arm and shoulder at this point were exposed. He's also completely naked aside from the neckties around his wrists and a sash from a bathrobe that was tied around his ankles. It doesn't take much for them to realize, okay, this is obviously the homeowner. I mean, they looked up the home before they went, thirty four year old Jeff Wright. But of course, they know that Jeff has a wife and kids and they're missing. So the police let themselves into the home because it's empty. They let themselves in to investigate. And when they get to the primary bedroom, it looks like a tornado has hit. There is stuff
32:57 Payton Moreland? everywhere. There's fresh paint, bleach, a giant piece of carpet has been cut out from the floor. Like, it looks like someone was trying to take every piece of evidence they could find, but didn't do a very good job. There's still blood on the curtains, the nightstand, the walls, and even more damning detectives locate a receipt for two gallons of bleach, obviously for afterward, and a hunting knife in a pot outside that looked like it had been tried to be hidden, but it was obviously the murder weapon.
33:25 Garrett Moreland? I'm so curious to see what the jury says, like what conclusion they come to, because I know what conclusion I think I come to, but I could see the jury being swayed both ways, to be honest.
33:38 Payton Moreland? Think about how wild it is that we work and then we wait and then get paid. That's just the deal we accept. Meanwhile, we can literally get anything else instantly. Earnin has been changing that for over a decade. You can get up to $150 a day of money you've already earned, up to $1,000 between paychecks. Tips are optional and standard transfers take one to two business days with no mandatory fees. Expedited transfers start at $3.99 and cap at $5.99. And 5 million people have already made the switch. At this point, the old way is starting to look like a weird option. There's been times in my life where
34:19 Payton Moreland? I am waiting paycheck to paycheck and Earnin would have been so nice for me to get access to the money I've already worked for and earned in between those pay periods.
34:31 Garrett Moreland? Download Earnin on the App Store or Google Play. Spell it like earning, money without the G. Type in Murder With My Husband on your podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show. Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank. Access limits are based on your earnings and risk factors. Standard cash outs take one to two business days with no mandatory fees. Expedited transfers available for a fee. Tips are voluntary and don't affect the service. Available in select states. Terms and restrictions apply. Visit earnin.com for full details. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Peyton and I are both big advocates for therapy. We love therapy. We think everyone should do therapy if you want, get to talk
35:12 Garrett Moreland? to somebody. I think sometimes we have thoughts and experiences that we want to, you know, remove. Or delete from our brain. And sometimes that's just not how it works. I think therapy is a great place to help process those thoughts. So yeah, if you're interested in therapy, you really should give BetterHelp a try.
35:32 Payton Moreland? And BetterHelp insurance options may now be available nationwide. With insurance, many members pay $15 or less, some even pay $0. And BetterHelp therapists are licensed, experienced professionals such as psychologists, marriage and family therapists, social workers, and counselors. They have at least three years and 1,000 hours of hands-on experience and have the required education, training, exams, and practice.
35:58 Garrett Moreland? BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many copays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the US, you can still get 20% off your first month. Sign up and get 20% off at betterhelp.com/husband. That's better H E L P dot com slash husband.
36:18 Payton Moreland? So this whole thing's a disaster, should be a pretty open and shut case when you consider the evidence, like they have enough evidence. And naturally-
36:28 Garrett Moreland? For murder, yes, but I mean, obviously they're gonna-
36:30 Payton Moreland? It's not a question.
36:31 Garrett Moreland? So it's a completely different.
36:32 Payton Moreland? They have a giant hunch about who's done it, obviously. So they call the lawyer back, and they say, any chance your client Susan Wright, right? And he's like, yep. And he says, she will not be speaking to police, though, because she's been checked into a psychiatric ward at the hospital. The mental break that she has suffered and originally started on the night of the murder has not subsided. She's still not convinced that he's fully dead, and she still believes that he could come for her any moment.
37:03 Garrett Moreland? Holy crap. Okay.
37:05 Payton Moreland? So-
37:06 Garrett Moreland? This is wild.
37:07 Payton Moreland? The police are like, oh, gosh, is this a lie? This is the pros of getting a lawyer before you turn yourself in. Because whether it's a lie or not-
37:15 Garrett Moreland? Well, then also now the DA has to be like, where do I go with this?
37:19 Payton Moreland? Yeah.
37:19 Garrett Moreland? Like, where do I go with this case?
37:20 Payton Moreland? She's in a mental hospital.
37:21 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
37:22 Payton Moreland? Because she's, she still thinks her husband's gonna kill her.
37:24 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
37:25 Payton Moreland? So the police are like, ah, okay, we get what you're saying. And we get that this is obviously gonna, she's not denying the murder. So this is gonna be a self-defense murder case. And also, they discovered the injuries were so violent that the tip of the knife had actually snapped off and was still lodged inside Jeff's head. So she was stabbing his head.
37:44 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
37:45 Payton Moreland? But they find something else in-
37:49 Payton Moreland? The autopsy that's going to throw a wrench into her case. It's actually going to be a huge part of the debate. They find red candle wax on his thigh and around his genitals, which doesn't match any part of the story that Susan has told so far, right?
38:10 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
38:10 Payton Moreland? So Neil Davis, at this point, released a statement on Susan's behalf stating that she had been abused by her husband Jeff for upwards of four years, leading up to his death. But murder is murder and Susan knew there was no getting herself out of this one. So on January 24th, 11 days after stabbing her husband, Susan Wright turned herself into police with every intention of pleading not guilty.
38:37 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
38:37 Payton Moreland? And letting the court know exactly what she went through to be pushed to this point. And she's going to argue that anyone who went through what she went through would snap.
38:46 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
38:47 Payton Moreland? An opportunity that finally came for Susan a little more than a year later in February of 2004.
38:53 Garrett Moreland? So during this year, she's not in prison?
38:56 Payton Moreland? No, she's prepping for trial. And when Susan took the stand, it was obvious that for a year she had been prepping very hard with her lawyer for this trial. She does not miss a beat. She offers up the same exact story I told you earlier. That is the story she tells. How Jeff had come home that night from a boxing match, high on cocaine, how he was hitting their son. How later that evening in the bedroom, Jeff came at her with a knife in the middle of their attack. And she fought back thinking it's either him or me. And that the reason she didn't go to the police right after was because she was having a mental break and still literally confused, thinking that her husband was going to be able to get to her and her kids at some point.
39:38 Payton Moreland? The prosecution sees holes in Susan's story, holes that would convince them that Susan wasn't being totally honest with how that night actually went down. There might be pieces of truth. But there were definitely pieces missing according to the prosecution.
39:54 Garrett Moreland? Okay, like?
39:55 Payton Moreland? This hinged on two giant things found on Jeff after he died. Number one, he had ties on his wrists and feet. If a body is already dead, why would you tie the feet and wrists up? You would tie feet and wrists up on a person who's alive to keep them from moving.
40:16 Garrett Moreland? Was it tied with what they were saying earlier, um, the?
40:20 Payton Moreland? Neckties and bathrobe.
40:21 Garrett Moreland? In the bathrobe?
40:22 Payton Moreland? Yes.
40:23 Garrett Moreland? Okay. I mean.
40:25 Payton Moreland? You're thinking maybe just to move him?
40:26 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, just to move the body. That would be my initial thought, a hundred percent.
40:30 Payton Moreland? Number two, the wax near his groin that does not come up at all in her story.
40:35 Garrett Moreland? I don't even know if I want to know. That's weird.
40:37 Payton Moreland? She thinks this doesn't look like a situation where someone fought back from self-defense. She thinks Susan decided a couple of days earlier, it's me or him. He's gonna kill me if I don't kill him. So she lured Jeff into the bedroom, seduced him with what he thought was gonna be maybe.
40:55 Garrett Moreland? And then started killing him.
40:56 Payton Moreland? Tied him up.
40:58 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
40:59 Payton Moreland? And then started killing him.
41:00 Garrett Moreland? I mean, I guess I could see what they're saying just because.
41:04 Payton Moreland? That she had tied him up, that she had poured the wax on him, that it was a whole thing. And then got the knife and stabbed him.
41:12 Garrett Moreland? Also, the chances, I'm not saying this doesn't happen, but he's going to stab her and then she somehow gets the knife from him? You know what I'm saying? Like, he sounds like he was.
41:22 Payton Moreland? Yes, but it does happen.
41:23 Garrett Moreland? I know, but he's high on cocaine.
41:25 Payton Moreland? Yeah. And apparently over top of her, which is an even harder place.
41:29 Garrett Moreland? Like, it's, it's, it's possible. It's just.
41:32 Payton Moreland? Unlikely in your mind?
41:34 Garrett Moreland? In my mind, unlikely.
41:35 Payton Moreland? So if you're sitting on this jury, you're thinking, hmm, that's a little unlikely.
41:38 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, I would, I would start to raise some red flags.
41:41 Payton Moreland? Okay. So this is where the prosecution comes in. They said, yep, we agree that she murdered him. We're not even really arguing that she wasn't abused by him. What we're arguing is that this was not self-defense, this was premeditated murder.
41:55 Garrett Moreland? First degree premeditated murder.
41:57 Payton Moreland? They said it had nothing to do with protecting her children. They actually said, and they brought her past of dancing.
42:05 Payton Moreland? Into the trial, like trying to smear her reputation, you know, make the the jury think different of her. They said, also Jeff had a $200,000 life insurance policy. And what was she gonna do? How was she gonna provide for her kids? Which the prosecution even called a witness to support. Kevin Conboy was a coworker of Jeff's and he recounted a time just a week or so before Jeff's death, where Susan called the office. He said he could hear Susan screaming over the phone at Jeff, asking him whether or not he completed the insurance policy paperwork. So a week before she murders him,
42:44 Garrett Moreland? Damn.
42:44 Payton Moreland? A coworker is coming forward, saying she called him at work complaining about the insurance policy. That's a $200,000 payout.
42:53 Garrett Moreland? Did he? I don't know, it would be so hard to be on the jury because this is where the reasonable doubt starts inching away at your mind, right?
43:00 Payton Moreland? So Kevin says Jeff even ended the call, saying, if I die, like as a joke, saying, if I die, you'll be a very rich woman. So Jeff's brother in law.
43:10 Garrett Moreland? Very rich, I mean.
43:12 Payton Moreland? Yes, but I mean, how many times do you joke about insurance?
43:15 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, I get that, I get that.
43:16 Payton Moreland? So Jeff's brother in law, Brian Roberts, also testified against Susan. He said there was one occasion where he was at their house for dinner and Susan and Jeff got into an argument. He then said Susan, who was using a knife, turned and pointed it at Jeff in a threatening matter, which doesn't really mean Susan's lying, but also Brian claimed he never once saw or heard any abuse from Jeff towards his wife or kids.
43:39 Garrett Moreland? I would say that majority of people don't ever see the DV actually happening in relationships. So I take that with a grain of salt.
43:46 Payton Moreland? And the prosecution sort of takes that and runs with it. They say, this, this relationship could have been toxic, okay? But is this domestic abuse?
43:56 Garrett Moreland? Or murder.
43:57 Payton Moreland? Is no, is this domestic abuse defense exaggerated?
44:01 Garrett Moreland? Oh.
44:01 Payton Moreland? Like, was this like something that was conjured up after the murder that was made to be even worse? That she created this huge lie about the history of their relationship. And because Susan didn't file a police report until after Jeff was dead, there's really no evidence like of her going to the police and filing domestic violence report or cops coming. You know how sometimes you have that evidence?
44:24 Garrett Moreland? But again,
44:25 Payton Moreland? doesn't mean it's not happening.
44:27 Garrett Moreland? With the grain of salt, because the amount of DV cases where people are actually filing police reports, it's a very small percentage.
44:34 Payton Moreland? Well, so people come to Susan's defense. A neighbor testifies and says, no, I saw Jeff angrily, physically grabbed Susan a few times. A few friends testified that she had shown up with black eyes to places claiming, oh, it was just a fall or kid accidentally hit me. Others said she was completely terrified of Jeff. Like they said, no, Susan was terrified. Though her best friend claimed there was one instance where she confided in her that Jeff had hit her after an argument on his birthday. So there are times before this murder happened that she was telling people. So this whole idea that the abuse was something Susan conjured up after the fact, it doesn't really land after the jury hears testimony from other witnesses saying, no,
45:15 Payton Moreland? there were little clues here and there. But it's all he said, she said. Though when it came to the real hard evidence, like the wax and the ties, Susan said, there's not a simple explanation for it. She says the wax from the candle came from when she pulled Jeff off the bed that night after killing him, that his shoulder had hit the nightstand and the candle fell over and poured wax on him. She also said the neckties and bathrobes, she never used them to secure Jeff to the bedpost or tie him up. She said, those are what I was using to secure his body to the dolly while moving him.
45:52 Garrett Moreland? I mean, they both got good points, man.
45:53 Payton Moreland? Still, the prosecution had one more trick up their sleeve at trial. One more attempt at proving Susan wasn't telling the truth about what went down that night. And to pull it off, it required them to bring the right's actual bed to the courtroom. And this is where I was saying theatrics and theater. We see this with the OJ Simpson trial.
46:17 Payton Moreland? It's big. Okay. So on the most shocking day of the trial prosecutor Kelly Siegler had the Wright's blood stained mattress and bed set rolled into the courtroom. Then she asked another young male prosecutor from her team to step up and lie down on the mattress. And then she climbed on top of him to show a reenactment.
46:40 Garrett Moreland? What the freak?
46:41 Payton Moreland? She tied both of his hands to the bedposts, took the actual knife from evidence and began recreating her own version of what happened that night, the prosecution's theory.
46:54 Payton Moreland? To give the jury a visual stimulant of like, this could happen. This could be real.
47:00 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
47:01 Payton Moreland? She said afterwards that the reason she did this was you have to make it come alive. This is a quote, "You can't just sit in your chair and talk to the witness in the stand and discuss it theoretically." She said, "I chose to take it to the next level, offering an Oscar worthy performance, one that seemed convincing enough for the jury."
47:21 Garrett Moreland? No way.
47:23 Payton Moreland? Some people call it genius. Some people call it completely inappropriate, but the jurors called it the truth. After five hours of deliberation, they came back with a verdict. They found Susan Wright guilty of murder in the first degree. She was sentenced to 25 years in prison. Susan has said that her defense kind of failed her at trial. They had a lot of regrets about how it was handled. For example, they failed to call to the stand, the psychologist who treated Susan after her arrest.
47:56 Garrett Moreland? To, yeah.
47:57 Payton Moreland? I mean, that psychologist says she was in a dissociative state. She was suffering from PTSD. They never had him testify. They also weren't aware of a sworn statement given by one of Jeff's ex-girlfriends 10 months before the trial. Her name was Misty Michaels. She was working as an exotic dancer when she met Jeff and she said he was abusive towards her as well, that he hit her across the face, threw her down a flight of stairs. So they could have had her testify.
48:24 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
48:25 Payton Moreland? At trial. She even filed a police report. So there was evidence to back it. Jeff was actually arrested and spent the night in jail for beating up his girlfriend. She said he was controlling. She basically mirrored her story. He's controlling. He monitored my every move. The jury never got to hear a word of it. They didn't get to hear from domestic abuse experts. So people are like she could have had a better defense. So in November of 2004, Susan and her new lawyer, Brian, began filing appeals stating that her lawyers were inexperienced and ineffective. There was evidence that should have been given at trial. He also argued that Kelly Siegler's courtroom reenactment was should not have been allowed, that that is made for TV nonsense.
49:07 Payton Moreland? And the whole thing was just confusing. And how can you separate acting and dramatizations from what actually happened?
49:16 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
49:16 Payton Moreland? It took nearly five years, but after a judge also heard Misty Michael's testimony, this is the ex-girlfriend, they granted a new sentencing hearing for Susan Wright. In 2009, a court ruled that Susan's counsel was in fact ineffective. They shaved five years off her sentence.
49:31 Garrett Moreland? Okay.
49:31 Payton Moreland? So in 2020, after being denied parole twice, Susan Wright was released from prison.
49:36 Garrett Moreland? And so she's out?
49:37 Payton Moreland? Yes. Up until 2024, Susan was on intensive supervision. She was required to wear GPS monitor, had to attend anger management classes, but now she's a free woman. We may never know for sure what happened in the Wright's home behind closed doors on that night, but Susan said even jail was better than the way she was living before. And she put it to reporters saying, isn't it strange that I had to come to prison to finally feel safe? And that is the case of Susan Wright.
50:09 Garrett Moreland? I think that, I mean, you're probably not going to express your opinion, but I'll express mine because it's what the listeners want.
50:16 Payton Moreland? Oh my.
50:17 Garrett Moreland? I kind of think Susan's innocent.
50:18 Payton Moreland? You wouldn't have had her served any time.
50:20 Garrett Moreland? Okay. I know this is probably a, I think this is
50:23 Payton Moreland? Don't you think that's blurring the lines a little too much?
50:25 Garrett Moreland? It's hard. I'm pretty drastic as far as like, Here are my thoughts. If you're abusing someone, what would you expect, man?
50:33 Payton Moreland? To not be killed, Gary.
50:35 Garrett Moreland? You shouldn't be abusing someone.
50:36 Payton Moreland? I agree.
50:37 Garrett Moreland? It's the same reason like you shouldn't steal, you shouldn't abuse someone. Like there's things we just don't do in life and guess what?
50:44 Payton Moreland? This is if the self-defense thing is taken out. If it, if, if he was on top of her with a knife, then that's self-defense.
50:51 Garrett Moreland? So you're saying you take that out? Did he deserve it? I don't know. If you're hitting girls and you're hitting your wife?
50:57 Payton Moreland? And also.
50:57 Garrett Moreland? I'm not gonna say he deserved to die, but maybe.
51:00 Payton Moreland? Women in cases who are being abused, who don't kill their husbands and end up dead.
51:06 Garrett Moreland? And they get killed. It's like, what do you like? What do you expect?
51:10 Payton Moreland? It's a very complicated topic and it's a very complicated thing to go to trial for. When a woman fights back to what I think is provable that he was abusive. People saw it. His ex-girlfriend came forward and basically shadowed her statement. So I think it's pretty safe to say.
51:25 Garrett Moreland? Yeah.
51:26 Payton Moreland? No doubt that he was abusive, but you also.
51:31 Payton Moreland? I mean, did she plan a murder?
51:33 Garrett Moreland? Yeah, I don't know.
51:34 Payton Moreland? You can't just plan a murder and get away with it. It's just a complicated case, you guys. Obviously. I don't think that either of us are like a hundred percent right or wrong. I think that this is one of those cases that is so far in the gray. It just depended on what jury she had. You know what I mean? But let us know in the comments what you think about it and we will see you next time with another episode. I love it.
51:57 Garrett Moreland? And I hate it.
51:57 Payton Moreland? Goodbye.
52:05 Speaker 06 Great meeting. Who took notes? Anyone?
52:09 Speaker 07 With Monday Note Taker, nobody has to take notes again. It joins your call, transcribes it, and turns the whole conversation into a clear plan. Action items, owners, deadlines, all right there on your monday.com board, ready for the team. So the meeting ends and the plan already exists. Meetings aren't just talk anymore. Go to monday.com, the AI workspace platform.
Previous 256. Lulu's Hitman - The Shocking Case of Ramon Sosa Next 258. The Killer Cadets - The Murder of Adrienne Jessica Jones Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated