Pod Insights The Big Picture The 25 Best Movies of the Century: No. 14 - ‘Moneyball’ About this episode Sean and Amanda return to continue their yearlong project of listing the 25 best movies of the 21st century so far. Today they discuss one of the greatest sports movies of all time: Bennett Miller's ‘Moneyball’—starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill. They explore the film’s very curious production history with director Steven Soderbergh, share why they think this was the best performance of Pitt’s career, and examine what the movie’s legacy is considering Miller’s lack of work following its release.
Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins
Producer: Jack Sanders
THIS EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY THE STARBUCKS COFFEE COMPANY. ORDER NOW | STARBUCKS. COM/MENU
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Sean Fennessey? This episode of The Big Picture is presented by Starbucks. We are big Starbucks Frappuccino fans over here. So when we heard about the new Strato Frappuccino blended beverage, we had to try it. It's a crave-worthy iced blended beverage topped with cold foam, making for delicious layers of flavor.
0:15 Amanda Dobbins? I love how Starbucks leans into the seasons, especially summer. From vibrant refreshers to cold blended beverages, there's always something exciting to sip on.
0:24 Sean Fennessey? Available now for a limited time only, your Strato Frappuccino blended beverage is ready at Starbucks.
0:40 Sean Fennessey? I'm Sean Fantasy.
0:41 Amanda Dobbins? I'm Amanda Dobbins.
0:42 Sean Fennessey? And this is 25 for 25, a big picture special conversation show about Moneyball. And how can you not be romantic about baseball?
0:58 Sean Fennessey? We are here live at the Music Box Theater. We've just watched this wonderful movie. And let's talk about it briefly. I'll give some details for the audience, even though they've just sat here and watched the movie and watched the credits and they know everything I'm about to say. Hang with me. Directed by Bennett Miller, written by Stephen Zalian and Aaron Sorkin, originally to be directed by Amanda's beloved Steven Soderbergh. We will get into that. Starring Brad Pitt, Jonah Hill. Who else is in this movie? Chris Pratt, Robin Wright, Spike Jones.
1:29 Amanda Dobbins? PSH, thank you. Philip Seymour Hoffman, of course.
1:33 Sean Fennessey? God bless the dead. And this movie was, I'm serious.
1:40 Sean Fennessey? This is an Academy Award nominated film, considered one of the best movies of the century by many people, including us. It's been an object of affection and fascination on the show for years. Why did we pick this one?
1:51 Amanda Dobbins? This is a passion project. And I just got to say, it did warm my heart. We did not announce what movie we would be screening before it started here in the Music Box Theater tonight. So you did not know. Did anyone guess? Raising your hands. Okay, yeah, all right. I would say that's like 5% of the room, which is good. Congratulations. You should feel good about yourself, but.
2:13 Sean Fennessey? Everyone wanted it to be The Dark Knight.
2:14 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I think.
2:16 Sean Fennessey? Sorry, bros.
2:20 Amanda Dobbins? Listen, I tried, but also I didn't try. Anyway, it really warmed my heart to hear a large room of people cheering, even if you were just being nice, when you realized that it was Moneyball. Because this is, it is one of my favorite movies, certainly of the decade. And I do understand why it hits a lot of soft spots for me. But the best sports movie of the decade, one of the, for my money, the best performance by one of the great movie stars of our generation, written, or at least half-written by one of the great screenwriters of my life, when he is being interpreted by other directors. Thank you so much. Please put a note in that.
3:04 Amanda Dobbins? And, you know.
3:06 Sean Fennessey? What about being the Ricardos?
3:10 Amanda Dobbins? Remember when I literally put off my birth of my child for one day to see whether being the Ricardos got nominated? It didn't. That's okay. And just, at some point, it is like the line in the movie, like, how can you not be romantic about this movie? Which is a lot of things that are not romantic. It's about math. It is about, like, a lot of math. And there are just a lot of numbers at screen all the time. Everybody in it's pretty angry and a little touchy. And no one is wearing flattering pants. And it's just, I mean, it's really, really tough. And there is, and it is, there's a lot of archival, there are a lot of, it's very PC. And I think the score is really magical,
3:55 Amanda Dobbins? but it's not really swooning until it is. So it doesn't immediately jump out as a sentimental, just irresistible classical sports movie, but to me it is.
4:07 Sean Fennessey? This episode is brought to you by State Farm. There's nothing better than having friends who support whatever you're into, like re-watching a director's entire catalog in the lead-up to their latest release. And like those friends, State Farm is there to help you feel supported by helping you choose the coverage you need. With so many coverage options, it's nice knowing you have help finding what fits for you. So you can check coverage off the list and spend more time debating movie rankings. Go online at statefarm.com or use the easily accessible app to get help from one of their local agents. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. It's a weird movie. It's based on a nonfiction book by Michael Lewis, which was a wild bestseller. I don't know if I've ever asked you, have you read the book Moneyball?
4:43 Amanda Dobbins? No, of course not.
4:44 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
4:46 Sean Fennessey? Any Moneyball fans of the book? Yeah.
4:48 Amanda Dobbins? You read it? Has anyone read Bill James? Yeah, crickets. Okay. All right, we got one shaking his hand.
4:56 Sean Fennessey? I mean, Bill James was a great thinker about baseball. Other stuff? He's pretty weird. He's got a lot of feelings about who killed JFK. I don't know if people know that.
5:03 Amanda Dobbins? Don't we all? Chris Ryan is in the room tonight.
5:05 Sean Fennessey? CR is here.
5:08 Sean Fennessey? And he is currently going through the deleted files to figure out who killed JFK. So he won't be with us tonight. He will be here tomorrow.
5:16 Amanda Dobbins? Literally yesterday, I was like, so what you do is you just Ctrl F for things you're interested in. This was what we talked about at dinner. Anyway.
5:21 Sean Fennessey? And that's what a lot of baseball general managers started doing with Bill James when he was exploring sabermetrics in baseball. The book itself is fantastic. It's like a genuine page turner. It kind of reads like a thriller, even though it's covering sports events that most people who were reading the book already knew occurred. The other thing about the movie and the book is that it's largely chronicling a kind of modest success at best, but basically it's another story about a loser. We just did Inside Lewin Davis in this series, which was a story about somebody who doesn't quite fulfill his promise and become as famous as he hopes to become. Billy Beane still has not won a World Series. He's no longer the general manager or executive president of the A's. In fact, the A's don't even play in Oakland anymore.
6:04 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
6:05 Sean Fennessey? And weirdly, this movie still has this incredible sentimental hold on us, even though like, I don't care about the A's.
6:11 Amanda Dobbins? No.
6:11 Sean Fennessey? Like at all.
6:12 Amanda Dobbins? But, you know, I think part of, we like it because it is a baseball movie and you are a baseball psychotic. I do love baseball not as much as Sean, but it is even beyond a baseball movie at this point. It is just sort of a pop cultural phenomenon. Like I, you know, I sat and watched the Hatterberg homerun because I really wanted to see that with a crowd of people. And then the Brad Pitt head swoop up is like, it's a meme now at this point, right? You know, and it is, and, and now I think like the Moneyball of something, or they're Moneyballing this as shorthand for whatever. So it is, it's pretty weird that a nonfiction math and business text.
6:56 Amanda Dobbins? Became like a very, a movie that was nominated for many Oscars and that is now pop cultural shorthand for, you know, whenever anyone's feeling misunderstood in the workplace. And he's just, yeah, you want me to talk? Yeah. When I point at you, yeah.
7:13 Sean Fennessey? Do you relate more to Billy or more to Peter Brand?
7:16 Amanda Dobbins? Oh.
7:16 Sean Fennessey? Jonah Hill's character, who is based on the real life figure Paul DePodesta, but slightly changed.
7:21 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I know you relate to Billy, but I'm, I'm, I do you? Or do you feel, do you feel more like a Peter?
7:28 Sean Fennessey? To hear you say that.
7:30 Amanda Dobbins? Well, yeah, I mean.
7:30 Sean Fennessey? I was never drafted by the Mets, like Billy, though I wish I was.
7:33 Amanda Dobbins? In many ways, the Mets let you down every year. So, um,
7:38 Amanda Dobbins? thank you.
7:38 Sean Fennessey? It's just mean.
7:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, sorry. If you're, if you're listening at home, I'm wearing a Cubs jersey right now, which was extra immune to Sean. Um, yeah, go Cubs. Uh, sorry again about today.
7:49 Sean Fennessey? Amanda has allegiance to like nine baseball teams.
7:51 Amanda Dobbins? I have renounced the Braves, okay? It's not worth it. Um, yeah, but also, you know, when you're angry, you don't really speak and.
8:04 Sean Fennessey? That's true.
8:05 Amanda Dobbins? You snack a lot.
8:06 Sean Fennessey? I do love to snack.
8:07 Amanda Dobbins? So in that sense, you seem pretty Billy, you know?
8:11 Sean Fennessey? I have a young daughter.
8:12 Amanda Dobbins? There you go. Yeah. You want to, you want to talk about it?
8:15 Sean Fennessey? Well, you know, I don't think I really thought about the movie in that way when I saw it back when it was released 15 years ago. And now I watch this and this is a movie about like a dad who's kind of fucked up, you know? And he's not really coming to grips with what's actually important in his life. And he thinks that winning is everything and he thinks that success and, you know, it's a character study about a guy who thought he was the prince who was promised and has spent his adult life reckoning with the fact that he was not. And so he's constantly trying to rebuild the promise that he thought he was going to achieve. And he can't, and he doesn't realize really that the promise is in his family and the, you know, the daughter that he, he is a father to. And it's a very beautiful movie. If you see it in that very specific respect, if you peel away the memes and he gets on base and, you know,
9:00 Sean Fennessey? Jonah Hill mugging while reading statistics off, like if you peel all that stuff away, you can tell that the people who were drawn to this movie, Bennett Miller is not a. Sports movie hero. He's made two sports movies, but he's interested in people and characters. And that's obviously what drew Pitt to it. And it's just a very affecting story about the very unique relationship between dads and daughters. You have a very strong relationship with your dad as well.
9:23 Amanda Dobbins? I did. I went to a lot of baseball games with him growing up. And I do think he likes this movie. He has, we've had mixed results with him on 25 for 25 so far.
9:31 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
9:32 Amanda Dobbins? But I do, I'm hoping that this gets a thumbs up.
9:35 Sean Fennessey? So he's been saying like, the handmaiden, you guys suck. Has he been going on Reddit?
9:42 Amanda Dobbins? Wouldn't that be incredible? I don't think he knows. Actually, maybe he does. Let's not go there. Yeah.
9:51 Sean Fennessey? The other thing that's interesting about it as a sports movie is the big game is just like a winning streak game in the middle of the season.
9:59 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
10:00 Sean Fennessey? There's no dramatic playoff moment where they're in the World Series. They don't even make it to the World Series, you know? And there are sports movies and baseball movies that have done that before, like, you know, Major League famously doesn't end with winning the World Series. But the movie almost doesn't care if you don't get that. It's not really ultimately interested in that idea of success. It's about the idea, it's about the, whether the success of the idea happens. The idea of like changing the way that people think about something that feels like dogmatic and systematic and breaking that down too, which is pretty heady for a mainstream September release starring Brad Pitt. I give them an incredible amount of credit for-
10:38 Amanda Dobbins? To quote Billy Bean, it has to mean something. But in terms of the actual baseball, you really, you only see the moments of failure throughout the movie with the, with the exception of the Hatterberg home run. But even, even that streak, I guess, you know, they recreate and kind of put together some archival of, of certain wins or victories or, you know, signs in the stands. But you don't see the 11 runs that they score. You don't see those first three innings. You only, you sit through the like very punishing at like error after error after error. And the movie really is more interested in the failure, in the not quite getting there, or, you know, what is, what are we trying
11:20 Amanda Dobbins? to get out of this? Or how, how can we punish you? It is like, people are very mad in this movie, most of the time.
11:26 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I think there's something to the idea of being obsessed with your job. And thinking that there is an inherent moral value in the work that you're doing, even if you're, what you're doing is kind of bullshit entertainment. I don't relate to this at all.
11:44 Sean Fennessey? I, it's amazing. I can even enjoy this movie with that as one of its core ideas, but like you can tell, there are many shots of Brad Pitt looking into the middle distance, pondering his lost fate.
11:59 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
12:00 Sean Fennessey? Which sounds really boring.
12:02 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
12:02 Sean Fennessey? And so is it, why do you think that's, it effectively works?
12:06 Amanda Dobbins? Well, it's, it's a good face, you know, and I, well, let's be real. I, I slandered the pants, but everything else is working well. But I, understatement. Um, I think it's his best performance. And I think that some of it is it does not ask him to speak as much as some other movies do. And he is very good at reacting, or he's very good at looking pissed, or looking like regretful, or looking just like he would like to be somewhere else, unless he's eating a Twinkie. Um, and you know, we talk about all the time that like movie star thing that you can't, that he holds the frame. But this
12:51 Amanda Dobbins? movie opens with a bunch of footage, old footage from the playoffs, and then him sitting alone in a stadium, just turning a radio on and on. And it is riveting. And it's just because he can, he can hold the frame. And he also, I think, found the right role in this of someone who is emotionally repressed, has a lot of things that he would like to change about his life. And, um, and, and it's also pretty physical. Like it's, he doesn't have to play baseball in this, but it is very athletic. He is throwing stuff around a lot in it. And that is a good match for Pitt as well. And a good match for the movie.
13:33 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. That Gatorade cooler takes a beating in that scene.
13:36 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, the desk.
13:37 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. Incredible supporting cast in this movie. Some of you may recall Jonah Hill was not a dramatic actor as far as we knew before this movie, easily best known as kind of an apetow player off the huge success of Superbad. And he was Academy Award nominated for this role. He's a very unlikely person to be cast in this role, in part because if you've ever seen Paul DePodesta, you know, he's like a very tall, skinny guy. And in the version that Steven Soderbergh was going to make, Dimitri Martin, the comedian, was going to play the Peter Brand character. So Jonah is a really like a pretty hard pivot away from what they were doing there. But I think his comic timing, mixed with a kind of like glazed over sincerity that
14:21 Sean Fennessey? he applies to this, it's like, really helps the movie because Pitt really needs a foil. Because he's so restrained in his performance, except when he's throwing things, that he needs somebody who can like, give him comic timing, give him something to bounce off of constantly.
14:36 Amanda Dobbins? And, and they're well matched. They respond to each other. And, and you can watch Pitt. I don't know whether he's just like being entertained by Jonah, or whether, you know, that is just really good acting. He's a pretty good actor. But you can see in the moment that, I mean, the movie is a little bit about them figuring out, you know, their little, their relationship and their mission together, as well as whatever it is with his daughter. So they, yeah, they play off each other. And he's just also very funny.
15:03 Sean Fennessey? So Philip Seymour Hoffman, who plays Art Howe, who also managed the Mets, by the way, and he sucked. He, Hoffman had, had acted in Capote, Bennett Miller's first narrative feature film, and won an Academy Award for Best Actor for that role. And this is kind of a small role, kind of a nothing part on the page, if you're not Philip Seymour Hoffman. And he brings a tremendous amount of gravitas, and he looks like a baseball manager. There are a lot of baseball managers with that physique, and that posture, and that kind of glower that he brings to the table. And he's also really good because Philip Seymour Hoffman is not afraid of Brad Pitt. Like, he is not intimidated by him. And there are a lot of scenes where they really have to openly have, share contempt for one another.
15:48 Amanda Dobbins? You are outside your mind.
15:52 Sean Fennessey? And I love the series of confrontations that are written for them because Pitt is playing a version of himself, an overconfident movie star and how is a overweight manager and the cheapest team in the Major League Baseball. And they have like an unusual anti-chemistry that I think is like one of the rare aspects of tension in the movie. There's actually not a lot of ultimate tension that isn't internal, that isn't born of like, can Billy do it? There has to be some sort of foil for him going through the movie and, you know, Rudy Giuliani and the Yankees aside, like, there's not a lot presented there.
16:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, you forgot Grady and we can't forget Grady and the rest of the scouts.
16:31 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, those guys.
16:32 Amanda Dobbins? Which is another, just one of the great scenes of the 21st century.
16:37 Sean Fennessey? Um, do you, do you know kind of where we stand with baseball right now in this debate? Like, have you followed this? Have you been reading the sabermetricians?
16:46 Amanda Dobbins? No, I haven't been reading the sabermetricians. So what I know is because I see you all of the time and I see Chris all the time and I live with one of your friends who's also sports obsessed. Um, so it gets filtered. So I know that the, so Moneyball went for all the other sports for a while, right? And so like the stats wave went through and now in football, you're always supposed to go for fourth down or you're never supposed to go for fourth down, right? You're always supposed to, but Bill doesn't like that, right?
17:15 Sean Fennessey? Who's Bill?
17:16 Amanda Dobbins? Because our boss, Bill.
17:21 Amanda Dobbins? That's good. You got me. Um, so yeah, so there were stats and then people are like, we've gone too far with the stats and then what are we, so, but I don't know where we are right now.
17:31 Sean Fennessey? I would say we're somewhere in the middle.
17:32 Amanda Dobbins? Right, there we go.
17:33 Sean Fennessey? You know, the eye test still matters. And it's interesting thing about this movie, Grady Fuson, who is portrayed in the movie as the head scout of the Oakland A's, who is unceremoniously fired for saying fuck you to Billy in the movie, was a longtime scout and minor league coach with the Oakland Athletics. And according to him and some others, was very supportive in real life of the revolution that Billy was trying to push with Paul DePodesta. But for the purposes of the movie, they needed like, they took some dramatic license with that story. Notably, Grady Fuson, where everywhere he went after this, he kind of flamed out every time, trying to hold on to some of the old ways. But that is the other theme of the movie is can you introduce new ways of thinking into these worlds? But not lose your soul.
18:18 Sean Fennessey? You know, what Grady Fuson represents is unusual. That's usually what the hero of a movie is trying to stand for. That we are about something and we can't, you know, get rid of it in favor of data and metrics and a kind of soulless approach. And weirdly, Billy represents something that I think like today.
18:38 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
18:39 Sean Fennessey? We're pretty skeptical of, we're pretty dubious of having our lives dominated by
18:43 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
18:43 Sean Fennessey? A data center, if you've seen Eddington.
18:46 Amanda Dobbins? God, yeah, it was playing earlier today here at the Music Box.
18:49 Sean Fennessey? Playing here at the Music Box.
18:50 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, yeah, adapt or die, coming from literally anyone else right now. We, uh, we are allergic to, but I think, you know, the movie wisely softens it because it invents the, the Hattler character written, uh, played by Chris Pratt in one of his best movie roles, I feel confident in saying in public.
19:10 Sean Fennessey? So it's number one, Electric State. Number two, Jurassic World Dominion.
19:15 Amanda Dobbins? I saw that, so yeah.
19:16 Sean Fennessey? Number three is, uh.
19:19 Amanda Dobbins? Guardians three, my favorite of Guardians movies.
19:21 Sean Fennessey? Guardians three.
19:22 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, yeah.
19:23 Sean Fennessey? The Tomorrow War is four.
19:24 Amanda Dobbins? Right. Don't forget Passengers.
19:26 Sean Fennessey? Passengers five. Let's keep going.
19:31 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, you know, I never saw Garfield.
19:34 Sean Fennessey? Movie six.
19:34 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, he wasn't bad in that.
19:36 Sean Fennessey? Garfield seven.
19:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
19:39 Sean Fennessey? Jurassic World eight.
19:43 Sean Fennessey? Help me out here, folks.
19:44 Amanda Dobbins? Someone yelled, some, Bike Wars, what?
19:48 Sean Fennessey? Bride Wars nine, thank you.
19:50 Amanda Dobbins? He's one of the husbands. Guys, we gotta talk about Bride Wars. I don't, I like, I, I don't, I, you know, I understand we need that kind of representation, but also do we, you know?
20:02 Sean Fennessey? You know, I'm really excited to announce that, uh, we're gonna wrap this episode up because we're about to show number 13 on our list, Bride Wars.
20:10 Sean Fennessey? A great film about the bride industrial complex. What's it about? I haven't seen it.
20:16 Amanda Dobbins? They, it's two best friends and they're getting married like close to the same time or is it the same day? Same day. I mean, that's not realistic.
20:22 Sean Fennessey? Dob mob.
20:23 Amanda Dobbins? Um, thank you, guys. And it's, and it's Anne Hathaway and, um, Kate Hudson, right?
20:27 Sean Fennessey? Anne Hathaway, isn't that movie?
20:29 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. And then, and Chris Pratt, and then who's, wait, who's the other husband?
20:36 Amanda Dobbins? Who? Okay, all right.
20:38 Sean Fennessey? Guys, this is being recorded for a podcast. I need you to have your phones out with information quickly for us. This episode of The Big Picture is brought to you by Amazon Prime. What pairs with a good comedy? The cozy blanket arriving with Prime. What pairs with a nail biting thriller? Snacks arriving with Prime. What pairs with the big game on Prime Video? That new couch arriving with Prime. Whatever feeling you're after, Prime helps bring it to life with great entertainment and fast shipping that delivers what the moment calls for. From streaming to fast shipping, it's on Prime. This episode is brought to you by LinkedIn Ads. Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first, but didn't live up to the hype? Marketers know that feeling. They optimize for the numbers that look great, impressions, reach and reacts.
21:20 Sean Fennessey? But when they don't show revenue, well, that's a not so great conversation with the CFO. LinkedIn has a word for that, bull spend. Instead, why not invest in what looks good to your CFO? LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title and more. So, cut the bull spend, advertise on LinkedIn, the network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. That's LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. Terms and conditions apply.
21:57 Speaker 02 Ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease symptoms? Don't pause for the moments that matter. That's why understanding your treatment options matters. Discover what's possible with Trinphaya. Guselkamap. Trinphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms or need a vaccine. Talk to your doctor and explore what's possible or call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more about Trinphaya and visit trinphyradio.com.
22:42 Amanda Dobbins? Anyway, Chris Pratt, Hattieburg, is also, it's, he is both, I guess, this representation of the stats and also-
22:50 Sean Fennessey? He's a real person, though.
22:51 Amanda Dobbins? But he's a real person and he is also a second chance and, you know, he also has one daughter who, you know, comes out in the crucial scene at the home and is like, "Hey daddy, I love you." So, you know, it's like, the themes are alive. She's very cute. I hope she had a great Christmas.
23:09 Amanda Dobbins? You know, so the movie is very smart in how it's constructed and in order to soften, what, you're right, is a lot of numbers. And it shows like a lot of numbers, just a lot of spreadsheets. This is, must be why you love this movie.
23:25 Sean Fennessey? I relate to some of it. It has a very curious production history, which I think is worth, isn't necessarily always worth talking about for these conversations, but for this one it is. It was optioned shortly after publication and Stan Shervin was hired to write the screenplay. He very quickly moved on. They hired Stephen Zalian, writer of Schindler's List, you know, the knight of the recent Ripley series on Netflix, like literally one of the, considered one of the most skilled screenwriters in Hollywood for the last 40 years. And Stephen Soderbergh was going to direct that movie.
23:57 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
23:58 Sean Fennessey? And Soderbergh's vision for the movie was really interesting. It was kind of like if you made Reds as a baseball movie, where he was going to use into-camera testimony and real-life people performing from the film. So Scott Hattieburg would have acted in this movie. Chad Bradford would have acted in this movie. A number of figures. I don't know, I think Brad Pitt was still going to play Billy Bean.
24:18 Amanda Dobbins? Was David Justice going to be in it?
24:20 Sean Fennessey? But I'm sure David Justice would have been in it. And it was a very audacious movie that was still going to be an expensive studio movie. And reportedly, Soderbergh, three or four days before production, added a lot of things to the script that included adding a lot more stuff about statistics. And Amy Pascal, who was running Sony at the time, said, "What the fuck is this? This is unintelligible to regular, normal moviegoers." And right before production, she put the movie in turnaround and paused it completely. Soderbergh walked away. He went off to, on his journey of making nine movies a year. And she hired Aaron Sorkin.
25:00 Sean Fennessey? And there is so much Sorkinian stuff
25:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
25:02 Sean Fennessey? in this movie that I have to assume is not there. And I'm sure that the dad-daughter stuff is a part of that. And I'm sure a lot of that, kind of the nobility of the work, which is so common in all Sorkin's TV shows and movies, the idea of like, just doing the thing in an honest and decent way.
25:16 Amanda Dobbins? Sure, and also you find yourself at work.
25:18 Sean Fennessey? Right.
25:18 Amanda Dobbins? And you find your people at work and your work is your... Yeah, it is very Sorkinian.
25:21 Sean Fennessey? Again, I can't relate to the movie.
25:23 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, not that that's not Soderbergh quoted either, at least in my understanding of him. You were describing the Soderbergh scripts to me yesterday while we were waiting for our flight at the airport. And, you know, the movie that we saw is not unlike what you described in that, I mean, it certainly still has a lot of math. Instead of people talking directly to the camera, it uses a lot of talk radio, but it does use a lot of archival of the real people. You know, there is a recreated collage feeling and like, a good amount of math. No equations, I guess. But, you know, as devoted as I am to the Steven Soderbergh project, I am happy that we got the movie that we got.
26:07 Sean Fennessey? The thing that's fascinating about it is that Bennett Miller is hired after Sorkin completes a draft. And Bennett Miller, to that point, had made a documentary called The Cruise. How many people have seen The Cruise? Are you familiar with that movie? Speed Levitch, who was featured in Richard Linklater movies, it follows him. And then he made Capote, which was written by his friend Dan Futterman. And then he gets hired to make this movie six years later with relatively little interest in baseball, as far as I can tell, but understands the character aspect of this beautifully. Makes this great film. He makes Fox Catcher, four years later, a movie that no longer exists. And, which I kind of liked, honestly, but it's a little self-serious. And then he has not done anything since. And I wonder if like, the legacy of this movie is dimmed at all
26:52 Sean Fennessey? because Bennett Miller hasn't made a movie in over 10 years.
26:56 Amanda Dobbins? Well, on our list, it's one of the rare movies that is not like, oh, this is the, this director's slot. Like, Fox Catcher was not in consideration. There is so much wrestling in that movie. And, and some other stuff.
27:11 Sean Fennessey? Like what?
27:17 Amanda Dobbins? You know, but everyone else, it was like, okay, well, this will be, this will be our Nolan. That's why you didn't get Dark Knight. And I mean, that's, it's long, you know, you guys have seen it, you live here. And this will be our-
27:32 Sean Fennessey? Are you suggesting that the Dark Knight is a documentary about Chicago?
27:37 Amanda Dobbins? That's, I'm going on a boat tour tomorrow and that's what I'm expecting, so.
27:41 Sean Fennessey? I'll be playing the Joker during that boat tour.
27:47 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, this, so I guess in some ways, if you want to be rude, this is taking the, there are, there are many celebrated directors who we are, we devote whole episodes to, aren't going to be on this list.
28:00 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
28:00 Amanda Dobbins? And, and this is-
28:01 Sean Fennessey? Sorry, Taylor Sheridan.
28:05 Amanda Dobbins? But I, for me, it was a no brainer.
28:09 Sean Fennessey? Six Academy Award nominations. Picture, actor, supporting actor, adapted screenplay, film editing and sound mixing.
28:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
28:19 Sean Fennessey? No director. Do you remember who Brad Pitt lost to?
28:23 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I do because you put it in the doc. This is very upsetting. Does anyone else here, does anyone remember? Yep.
28:29 Sean Fennessey? Jean Du Jardin for the artist.
28:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, that's the groaning. I hope the mics picked that up.
28:35 Sean Fennessey? You know, some people like the artist, I don't.
28:39 Sean Fennessey? And I don't like, I don't dislike that performance. I just don't, I don't, I literally don't understand what happened there. I do understand what happened there. Harvey Weinstein happened. That's what happened. But, and that's terrible and we hate that. But, you know, Pitt, of course, eight years later will eventually win best supporting actor for Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.
28:56 Amanda Dobbins? Which he's very good in, but-
28:58 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, he's very good in, but like so many before him and so many after him, very rarely winning for the right role. And that is an interesting sliding doors because if he wins in 11 and somebody else wins in 19, you know, maybe our friend Tracy Letts for Ford versus Ferrari could have gotten in there, you know?
29:18 Sean Fennessey? It's tough. It's too bad that didn't happen.
29:19 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
29:20 Sean Fennessey? Fucking idiots at the Academy.
29:24 Amanda Dobbins? Once again, our streak on this list of just no Oscars means, no Oscar wins.
29:31 Sean Fennessey? Means it's an all time classic.
29:32 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
29:32 Sean Fennessey? What about Oppenheimer?
29:33 Amanda Dobbins? Like you're out. Well, once again, you know how I felt about that episode.
29:39 Sean Fennessey? Usually when Roger Ebert and Manola Darkus are like, this movie is crack.
29:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
29:44 Sean Fennessey? Then it's crack. And that, this was a case, four stars from Ebert.
29:47 Amanda Dobbins? It's like, I was really nervous something else was coming.
29:50 Sean Fennessey? Roger Ebert said zero stars, this movie. No, he loved it. And Manola wrote at length about the kind of use of Pitt's power.
29:58 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
29:58 Sean Fennessey? And what he kind of brings as a movie star type and him kind of like filtering in your Robert Redford types, the kind of like strong, silent figures. And it's like incredibly well regarded, a very adult movie that did very good business at the box office, you know, $120 million is like a 50 or 60 million dollar movie.
30:18 Sean Fennessey? And we did used to say a lot in the last five years, they don't make them like they used to anymore. You know, certainly a book based on, you know, nonfiction adaptation seems unusual, but I'm, I'm, I'm feeling, I'm going the other way.
30:31 Amanda Dobbins? You're optimistic?
30:31 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. And the year of Minecraft.
30:33 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
30:33 Sean Fennessey? I feel like we're back.
30:34 Amanda Dobbins? Good. So Moneyball and then Minecraft, that's, that's the direct line.
30:38 Sean Fennessey? They're both IP.
30:39 Amanda Dobbins? They are. They are. Would this have been eligible in the IP franchise category in whatever draft we did? I guess so. Sure.
30:46 Sean Fennessey? When they make a sequel.
30:47 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
30:47 Sean Fennessey? About whatever the hell they're doing to the A's right now and.
30:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
30:50 Sean Fennessey? Sending them to Las Vegas. You following that?
30:52 Amanda Dobbins? What would the Mets version of Moneyball be?
30:55 Sean Fennessey? It'd be like Dog Day Afternoon.
30:59 Sean Fennessey? We're all being held hostage. They won't let us out. The bank robbers don't know what they're doing. Cops are screaming in the streets. It's 100 degrees out. We can't get out of New York. They won't let us free.
31:11 Amanda Dobbins? That's good. Good job.
31:12 Sean Fennessey? Thanks.
31:15 Sean Fennessey? Is this movie standing in for anything else? Was this in competition with anything else? Even if there wasn't another Bennett Miller movie? Is there anything you can think of from what we are examining?
31:26 Amanda Dobbins? So definitely sports movie. But I don't even know what would have been in contention besides this.
31:34 Sean Fennessey? Leatherheads?
31:38 Sean Fennessey? What sports movies should we have done?
31:42 Sean Fennessey? Speed Racer?
31:43 Amanda Dobbins? Speed Racer, okay.
31:44 Sean Fennessey? I like that.
31:46 Amanda Dobbins? Challengers, thank you guys.
31:48 Sean Fennessey? Challengers.
31:48 Amanda Dobbins? Sure, okay.
31:49 Sean Fennessey? Interesting.
31:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
31:52 Amanda Dobbins? But play that tape out, right? Because that's Luca Guadagnino. So then you've got five movies or six, so.
32:01 Sean Fennessey? So Challengers isn't on the list?
32:03 Amanda Dobbins? Challengers is not on the list. This is our sports movie, I'm sorry to say. I know, well, you know, next year I'll do my own list.
32:10 Sean Fennessey? On what show?
32:16 Amanda Dobbins? But I can't think of anything, any other sports movies that are also on the, you know, the quote unquote prestige level, for lack of a better word. But really, any others that we both have a connection to. It's come up on the show a lot. I thought that more people were going to guess that this movie was Moneyball because we have talked about how every time we're asked to host any sort of rev screening, we're like, how about Moneyball? And then.
32:40 Sean Fennessey? You said no four times. So we did this.
32:43 Amanda Dobbins? Thank you so much, Music Box Theater.
32:44 Sean Fennessey? To record the record.
32:45 Amanda Dobbins? And thank you all.
32:48 Amanda Dobbins? Was anyone like tempted to leave? You're all still here. I don't see any empty seats. Maybe keep it to yourself. But yeah, we love this movie.
32:56 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. So recommended if you like is something we talk about at the end of all of these conversations. There are a couple of sports business movies that I think could have stood in for this. Most of them are fairly recent. Air comes to mind. Air is sort of a similar movie to this in terms of ideas and the relationship between commerce and finance and decision making around sports.
33:19 Amanda Dobbins? And some movie stars in questionable pants.
33:22 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
33:22 Amanda Dobbins? But we love them anyway.
33:24 Sean Fennessey? Hustle, the recent Adam Sandler movie about a basketball scout, player personnel person. F1?
33:32 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, F1 is very Moneyball coded.
33:34 Sean Fennessey? Very Moneyball. And I, maybe we didn't talk about that when we talked about F1, but I think a lot of what Pitt is doing is
33:39 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
33:40 Sean Fennessey? just channeling Billy, you know, like the guy who never really made it. He's done this before. Kind of a demerit for F1, to be honest with you. Anyway, uh, speaking of air, though, I thought a lot about Good Will Hunting, watching this movie a second time. You know, like the wizard who just kind of needs to tap into everything and all the math and all the like, we're just waiting for you to really have the big moment, buddy. We're all rooting for you. Hope you don't, you're not at your door when we pick you up in the morning.
34:04 Amanda Dobbins? Boston plays a pivotal moment.
34:06 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
34:06 Amanda Dobbins? And then someone has to go on their way.
34:08 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. Are you hoping one day I'm just not in the chair under recording? I've taken off.
34:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. Well, you know, we've got, we've got a couple of people in, in the room who, who are ready, need be. So I know who to call now.
34:18 Sean Fennessey? Chair attendees?
34:19 Amanda Dobbins? Just, you know, no one in particular.
34:21 Sean Fennessey? We'll put them to a vote tomorrow.
34:22 Amanda Dobbins? I thought a lot about Friday Night Lights, really more the show than the, the movie, but the movie too, but especially the, the score and, and the music and, and, and people just doing their best.
34:34 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. And you love progressive rock, right?
34:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
34:37 Sean Fennessey? That's the genre that you're interested in.
34:38 Amanda Dobbins? I actually played on the score. Yeah, it was in the sessions.
34:41 Sean Fennessey? Wow. What, what instrument? Timpani?
34:44 Amanda Dobbins? That was me. Yeah.
34:44 Sean Fennessey? Okay, really impressive. I also wrote All the President's Men.
34:49 Amanda Dobbins? Sure, procedural.
34:49 Sean Fennessey? Procedural, process movie, trying to figure out the right way to do thing. And also taking you inside of a world that you don't totally understand and showing you literally how people do things, literally how people talk about things, which is one of the best things you can do in a movie.
35:03 Sean Fennessey? I mean, that's more or less it. What else do you want to say about Moneyball?
35:06 Amanda Dobbins? We didn't talk enough about Spike Jonze. One, just, just one of the, one of the great cameos.
35:12 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
35:12 Amanda Dobbins? And the sandals.
35:13 Sean Fennessey? And up this year.
35:13 Amanda Dobbins? Things are really peaceful here. I just, I, I mean, I.
35:17 Sean Fennessey? I think I owned those sandals when I was like 15. And at the time I was like, this is a great idea. I'm going to wear these in March to high school on Long Island.
35:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:28 Sean Fennessey? And it was a bad idea.
35:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:30 Sean Fennessey? I regret it, but he's pulling them off.
35:32 Amanda Dobbins? Well, in the context of that beautiful, peaceful living room, it is, it is a very nice living room.
35:37 Sean Fennessey? Do you think Spike should act more?
35:40 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I think he should do whatever he wants.
35:41 Sean Fennessey? He's another guy who hasn't made a movie in 10 years.
35:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. A lot of, a lot of her on the New York Times Movies of the Year list.
35:49 Sean Fennessey? People like the film Her.
35:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I mean, I like it too.
35:51 Sean Fennessey? Because they love AI.
35:54 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
35:56 Sean Fennessey? I think that's where we're gonna wrap.
35:56 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
36:00 Sean Fennessey? This has been really, really special for us.
36:01 Amanda Dobbins? Thank you so much for coming out. And also.
36:08 Sean Fennessey? We are eternally grateful that people care about movies and listen to the show and would come out for something like this. So, thank you so much. Thank you to the Music Box Theater, which is a very special place.
36:19 Amanda Dobbins? Thank you.
36:22 Amanda Dobbins? Which, and, and they let us keep this movie a secret, which is an amazing thing. And thanks to all of you for just coming to see a movie without knowing what it was. That's, that's genuinely cool and very nice that you would trust us.
36:35 Sean Fennessey? For those of you who are disappointed by this pick, Chris will be hosting a screening of Cruising in the Alley out back.
36:43 Sean Fennessey? Which sounds really fun. I do want to say thank you to Elizabeth Feirman and our whole events team. Thank you to Jack Sanders for his work on this episode.
36:51 Amanda Dobbins? He's in the house.
36:52 Sean Fennessey? Shout out Jack, who's been rolling with us all day. Thank you to Jack Wilson, who's here, who runs video at The Ringer. He's here with us today. We are gonna be at the Steppenwolf Theater tomorrow night.
37:03 Amanda Dobbins? We are.
37:04 Sean Fennessey? I hope some of you will be there. We will be drafting Chicago movies.
37:15 Sean Fennessey? Thanks for being here. Thanks for listening. We'll see you soon.
37:17 Amanda Dobbins? Thank you all so much.
38:06 Speaker 03 The holidays sound a little different when we show up for one another. And for families facing hunger, your generosity could mean one less difficult choice. Across the Feeding America network, your donation fulfills the promise of connecting families to nourishing food and greater stability. When you give this holiday season, you help ensure more neighbors can gather around a meal. This Thanksgiving, give at feedingamerica.org/holiday.
Previous ‘The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ Is Here. Plus: Our Fall Film Festival Preview. Next The 1990s Horror Movie Canon and ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer.’ Plus: The ‘KPop Demon Hunters’ Revolution. Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated