99% Invisible
Hosted by Roman Mars
A single diagonal step on a map sparks a legal war with huge consequences.
7,376 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Instagram teen accounts have automatic protections on by default. Built-in content settings for the content teens can see, contact limits for who can contact them, and time management tools like daily time limits and sleep mode. Teens are automatically placed into teen accounts, and teens under 16 will need a parent's permission to change any of these settings to be less strict. Instagram will continue adding built-in safety features to help create age-appropriate experiences. Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at instagram.com/teenaccounts. This episode is presented by Air France. Air France Business Cabin offers comfort from start to finish. Enjoy priority check-in and boarding, followed by access to peaceful lounges.
Onboard, savor menus created by renowned French chefs paired with wines and champagne selected by Smollet. Stay connected with free high-speed Wi-Fi. Then unwind in a fully adjustable lie-flat bed with a mattress topper developed with Sofitel My Bed, a signature touch of French hospitality. The art of travel elevated because Air France Business Cabin goes further in every detail to make your journey exceptional. 99% Invisible is presented by Acura. Curating and designing the perfect experience takes meticulous craft, an obsession with detail, and a love for innovation. Just like museum designers, Acura carefully considers every detail
to curate the most engaging, exhilarating, and rewarding experience for drivers. That craft isn't always something you can see, but it's something you'll feel, that flutter in your heart, the engine roars. Every Acura is designed with deliberate intention around how people actually use the vehicles. And that is precision-crafted performance.
This is 99% Invisible. I'm Roman Mars.
In 2019, two hunters were scouting for elk in Wyoming when they came across a peculiar feature in the landscape. The hunters had first noticed it while poring over maps of the area. Now, they were driving out to see it for themselves, a kind of break in the terrain near the state's southeast corner.
So it's open country. It's open ranch country, sagebrush country, and then there's this big mountain sticking up right there in the middle of it that's just the only mountain.
Brad Cape is a fencing contractor from central Missouri. Brad has been hunting since he was old enough to walk. So when he and his hunting partner saw the lone mountain with its dark timber and the arid, empty land around it, he knew what it meant.
It is a very unique place, and you can see on a map that it's a very unique place. But whenever you drive around it, it really comes to life. It is a rocky mountain that sits out by itself. You know, it might as well have a big bullseye on it that says there's elk here.
And it's true. The mountain basically screamed, "Good hunting."
That's Montana-based journalist Nick Mott.
I'm a hunter too, so I get how Brad felt when he found this spot. Poring over land boundaries and topographic lines, trying to figure out where animals are and other hunters aren't, finding that perfect area is often nearly as exciting as the hunt itself. And this time, all the pieces of the puzzle were fitting into place. The area had everything big game needed: forage, water, cover. On the map, the peak was named Elk Mountain.
Which, you know, was probably another big clue.
And so, we were driving around it. We're just seeing how close we could get to this mountain. And this sweet old gal pulls up there and rolls down her window and asks if she can help us, you know? And we said, "Well, we're just looking for a way to that mountain. Is there a way to get up there? We'd like to... We're thinking about hunting it." And she's like, "There's no way up there. A billionaire bought it, and he don't let nobody in."
And we said, oh, okay, you know, well, is there, is there any elk around here, deer around here?
That's when this sweet old gal told them there were so many elk in the area, they'd actually become a nuisance, eating the hay meant for cattle.
And we just kind of looked at each other and said, yes, ma'am, thank you for your time, you know, and we were excited from that moment on that we were going to find a way in there.
But finding a way in there wasn't going to be easy. Brad and his fellow hunters would end up trying to access Elk Mountain again, and again, and again, until eventually it wasn't even about hunting elk anymore, but something way bigger than that. And whether they succeeded or not would end up having lasting consequences for the future of land use everywhere in the US.
Because the single largest obstacle preventing the hunters from making it onto Elk Mountain wasn't the elevation or the topography. It was how the mountain itself had been divided up into public and private land.
When you look at that place on a map, it looks like a bunch of these little bitty squares. And when you start looking at it, you see that it is, it's a checkerboard.
The checkerboard, as it's commonly known, is a phenomenon unique to the American West, a pattern of land ownership, which is found in huge areas from New Mexico all the way up to Washington.
On a map, these particular areas look a lot like, well, a checkerboard, or perhaps checkered linoleum tiles. But instead of alternating black and white squares, checkerboarded land alternates between single square mile parcels of public land and square mile parcels of private land. So every public square borders a private square, which borders a public square, which borders a private square, which borders a public square, which borders a, well, you get the idea.
If you look out of an airplane window while flying over a checkerboarded area, it's not uncommon to see one square with a private housing development on it while the next sits relatively untouched. Or perhaps every other square features dense forest on public land while those private squares in between are logged. Again, just think of those alternating tiles.
An image which Brad finds himself invoking all the time.
Still, to this day, if I have someone ask me about this in the grocery store, I can't explain it unless I'm standing on a tile floor. Because here in the Midwest and the rest of the country, they just don't get it.
There's a catch, though, when it comes to hunting or doing anything really on the checkerboarded area. In the US, there's no legal way to pass through private property without the land owner's permission. That's trespassing.
So, public land in the checkerboard is often very difficult to access. After all, any public square in a checkerboard is surrounded on all sides by private property. It's only ever catty-corner to other public squares.
It doesn't matter that the public land belongs to us, the public. The reality is, it's only the owners of the adjacent private squares who have an easy way in. These inaccessible public lands are what's called "cornerlocked."
So, it's a big deal out West because you have the layout of public land out there, but you're just trying to keep the access to yourself.
And when it came to hunting in the checkerboard on Elk Mountain, it was no different. The private half of the checkerboard belonged to a ranch, and the ranch wasn't allowing strangers to cross their land.
But to Brad, that just made the public land all the more tantalizing, because it meant that it had the one thing that any good hunter was looking for: no other hunters.
So, the next year, in 2020, Brad and his friends, they decided to try something that, in hunting circles, is called "corner crossing."
Because something where nobody else would be, that's where I want to be. And in order to do that, we had to cross these corners.
To understand corner crossing, think about a literal checkerboard. In a checkers game, a piece that starts on black needs to stay on black, so the pieces move diagonally, crossing catty-corner from the corner of one square to another.
Moving through checkerboarded land works in the same way. To avoid the ranch's property, all Brad and his friends had to do was move around like a checkers piece. They'd start on public land and then make sure to stay on public land by only crossing into new squares diagonally at the corners where all those public squares touch.
Tell me about, you know, you, I mean, so the way it works in this area, like you set up camp and your camp is in the first like square that is publicly accessible and then you cross from there? Like, how did that work?
Yeah, that's exactly what it was.
That's Phil Yeomans. Phil is also from Missouri and he's been hunting with Brad for about a decade. Phil explained that this time, they all hiked from a public road towards the checkerboard's nearest approachable corner. When they got there, in the middle of this empty field, there was a little government survey marker about the size of a Coke can. There were also two no trespassing signs, along with a couple of posts called T-posts with a chain strung between them.
Which was ironic, considering it was obstructing the one spot where they could legally cross.
So, um, we just grabbed hold of the top of that T-post and swung our feet around, you know, kind of doing a little ballerina around the T-post so that we didn't touch the private property.
Yeah, we weren't, we weren't nonchalant about it. We were very specific, you know, as in, we planted our foot exactly.
From that point on, they made sure to stay entirely on public land their whole time inside the checkerboard. They corner crossed from one public square to another as they hunted for elk on Elk Mountain.
And from the start, the mountain proved true to its name.
Man, that first morning, the bulls were bugling. We could hear them from the county road.
And once we got up to the place, we decided we were gonna camp. We saw a big old herd coming, walking down the side hill. And we just stood there and watched them. It was like, this is gonna be good.
But we were up the mountain, up the mountain, up the mountain. And we ended up so far up that mountain, we drank water out of an elk track seeping out of the hill that day. And this elk's bugling just as far away as you can hear, you know?
They would go on to harvest three big bull elk. And I can tell you, this is a big deal. Most elk hunts lead to nothing, mine included. And these guys got a haul.
But things weren't all sunshine and roses and big bugling bulls. Because just as they were field dressing a bull elk, a man appeared in the distance.
And he makes the walk over to us, which took quite a while. We just kept working, you know, because they're half a mile, you know, from us.
As the man walked over, Brad's friend Zach thought something felt wrong and started recording on his phone.
So he just walks up to us and asks us what we're doing there. You know, and was a little snotty about it. Hey, how we doing?
Good. How are you?
Worn out.
Yeah? How'd you get in here?
It was the ranch's manager, a man named Steve Grindy. The hunters told Grindy they got here by crossing from a public section of land to another public section at a corner.
So on that first corner with the signs on it, how'd you get through that?
Grabbed the deep posts to follow around it.
Got a chain on it, so you can't go between them. But it's also on private property. Anytime you touch that thing, it's criminal trespassing. That's why they're there.
But the hunters had done their research. They pointed out that Wyoming Fish and Game, and even the state attorney general, had said that crossing at corners was legal. But Grindy countered.
You can't corner jump in Carvin County.
Period.
I believe everything we read says we can.
Well.
Just gonna have to go to the court and have them decide.
Right.
So.
That's fine.
Okay.
As uncomfortable as the encounter was, it wasn't out of the ordinary. Spats over corner crossings happen between hunters and landowners all the time. Ultimately, it's all part of a much larger war over public and private land and the checkerboard that began over a century and a half earlier.
The US government has been in the business of dividing up government-owned land into squares since 1785. The system was the brainchild of Thomas Jefferson, who dreamed of selling all those squares to a nation of small yeoman farmers. But the actual checkerboarding of the land began at the tail end of the Civil War, when policymakers in Washington wanted American settlers to move west.
Because, as anyone who's ever played Oregon Trail knows, moving out west was hard. Beyond the 100th meridian, most settlers struggled to access the necessary supplies to get their homesteads up and running, or their goods to market. So, in the mid-1800s, the US government turned to the railroads to move those supplies for them.
Only, it turned out that the railroads also needed help.
The railroads aren't gonna build by themselves. The reason they're not gonna build by themselves is there's nobody out there and no traffic. You don't build a railroad into the middle of nowhere. This isn't Field of Dreams, you just hope they'll come if you build it.
Richard White is professor emeritus of history at Stanford and the author of the book Railroad It: The Transcontinental's in the Making of Modern America.
So what you're gonna do is you're gonna have to get aid in building the railroad. The federal government says, "We are going to prime the pump."
White says the United States was cash poor, but land-rich. So the government gave the railroad companies long corridors of land, up to 80 miles wide, on which to build new rail lines. The railroads could then sell or lease that land to whomever they could lure west. But the government only granted the railroads every other square mile of land, hence the checkerboard.
With the checkerboard, the government could keep all the undeveloped sections in between and wait for them to go up in value before turning around and selling them to more developers. The new railways would also transport the soldiers needed to push Native Americans off the land the US had promised them and onto reservations.
So this becomes a means of conquest. And once it's there, once Indian lands can be sold to build the railroads, then the railroads can become the agency for conquering any remaining Indian resistance. So this is how the whole system works. And in this way, it does become an agent of colonization.
Under this system, a lot of land changed hands. In all, over 130 million acres went to the railroads.
And to put that in perspective, if all the federal grants to railroads were combined into one state, if you called it railroadiana, it would be the third-largest state in the United States, behind Texas and Alaska.
One company alone, the Northern Pacific Railroad, received an amount of land roughly the size of New England.
And almost all of it was given away in alternating one-square-mile sections.
So the checkerboard, on paper, this is a system is ideal. What can possibly go wrong? It seems to be foolproof, but like most systems that seem to be foolproof, they're usually designed by fools, and that's what's going to happen here.
When the railroads sold their land, it went to timber companies, it went to miners, it went to developers, but especially ranchers, who saw a sort of two-for-one bargain on all that checkerboarded property. All you had to do was buy the private squares and then fence off all the adjacent public squares, and they would effectively be yours for the keeping, too.
By the 1880s, big cattle barons had fenced in millions of acres of land they didn't own. But homesteaders and smaller-scale ranchers and farmers weren't happy about all that fence.
The fences block settlers because settlers have to be able to drive their wagons, get to railroad depots, and they're blocked by fences.
The tension between settlers and ranchers quickly grew ugly. There were standoffs, shootouts, murders. Later on, dime novels, radio programs, and television shows like Gunsmoke would dramatize this era, known as the range wars.
Those cattlemen built this country, man. A few more years now, they'll have us fenced out. Times change, Ben.
In 1885, in an effort to curtail the power of the big ranchers, Congress finally stepped in and passed the Unlawful Enclosures Act, which guaranteed public access to public land.
You can still build fences around your own land. You can control access if there hasn't been a right of way established across your own land, but you cannot enclose public land, and you cannot enclose land that you do not own.
Today, the Unlawful Enclosures Act is still on the books. But the act never did much to break up the ranches and other big properties of the Western U.S. And those large landowners never stopped looking for ways to secure their property, including in the checkerboard. That part never seems to change.
So Jefferson's dream of this whole thing ending up as being small farms, that is just simply not the case. The West ends up as a place of very, very large landholdings.
And it still very much was when Brad and the hunters stepped from corner to corner of public land in 2020.
After that first hunting trip, they could easily have left and just never come back. Why risk another awkward run-in? But in the end, the hunting was just too good. Plus, they'd spoken with law enforcement, who told them they were good to go. After all, the Unlawful Enclosures Act was still in force. So the following year, they went back to hunt Elk Mountain.
But this time, just to be on the safe side, they made one small adjustment to their corner-crossing strategy.
The only thing that we had that, that the ranch complained about was that we touched their T-post, you know, so we just had to get past that T-post without touching it. And then there was nothing that they could say. So that's where the whole ladder idea came in.
If they shouldn't touch the T-posts, then why not find a way to climb right over them?
What, what did you build? Like, how did you build the ladder? This, you know, I, this wouldn't be the, uh, my solution necessarily. I wouldn't think about building a ladder. Like, what goes into it?
Well, I guess maybe if you were a pole vault-er, you would take a pole vault with you. Um, I was a fence guy, you know, so I had, I had access to a lot of pipe and a welder. So just went back there in the shop and welded some pipe together.
Brad fashioned together a ladder that unfolded to a specific height, length, and width. The dimensions allowed it to go right over the T-posts and across the corner, all without ever touching the ranch's property.
And when the hunters crossed using Brad's ladder, just like the time before, other than those T-posts, there were no fences, no gates, no other infrastructure. The hunters designed, built, set up, and climbed a specialized ladder to cross through empty airspace in an empty field. Just so they could say that this time, they were following the very letter of the law.
Carbon County Sheriff's Office.
Hi, this is Stephen Grindy with Elk Mountain Ranch. Again, um, calling. We had an issue with some trespassers, um, out here, uh, off Rattlesnake Pass in the canvas tent.
Not too long after the hunters got there, that same ranch manager from earlier, Steve Grindy, recognized their truck from the previous year. He called local law enforcement agencies repeatedly. Eventually, a sheriff's deputy and fish and game officer both showed up.
How's it going? Chris.
Steve. Here's the body cam footage. Have you seen him pointed past? Yeah, we just watched. I just watched.
Next post it, I have signs right there too. Jump this corner right here. What they have is a ladder that they put down and go over.
Grundy's efforts to keep the hunters out of the public land went beyond phone calls to police. At one point during the trip, Grundy poked his head in the hunters' tent and got escorted away by an officer. Another time, he tracked the hunters down in his truck, cursed them out, and tailed them while they were hiking on a road that passes through public land.
And as the law enforcement officers giggled about the ladder in that body cam footage, a frustrated Grundy let this slip.
Do they realize how much money my boss has?
The ranch was owned by a pharmaceutical executive from North Carolina named Fred Eschelman. I reached out to Eschelman and his lawyers for an interview. Neither got back to me. But we know Eschelman told the ranch manager to keep talking to the authorities until they could get the hunters prosecuted. And eventually, Eschelman's strategy worked.
The county attorney charged Brad, Phil, and their hunting partners, John Slawinski and Zachary Smith, with criminal trespass and sent a sheriff's deputy to their campsite.
Again, here's the body cam footage.
All right, so just so it's not a surprise, you guys are all gonna get cited for criminal trespass. Not a surprise.
But we see on the look in your face, we still don't understand why.
With this citation, the hunters were facing up to six months in jail, plus a big fine.
So in Wyoming, it's, if you go past the private boundary or a marked area, it is considered trespass. So Elk Mountain Ranch is marked, is no trespassing. So that's what they're gonna use, is you guys went beyond the boundaries of the Elk Mountain Ranch.
But if I never touch Elk Mountain Ranch, you know, if I never touch the ranch, how did I trespass?
So it's, this has been a point of contention in Wyoming for a long time.
So especially, so it's 20 miles north and south of the railroad is the checkerboard.
And it's been this way for a long time, so hopefully you guys can come back and fight it.
When we come back, Brad and the other hunters do just that. Stay with us.
Support for this episode comes from Amazon Business. When it comes to your business, procurement shouldn't be a guessing game. Whether you're running a small business or managing a large organization, Amazon Business offers smart purchasing experiences designed to meet your unique needs. Smart tech, smarter decisions. Streamline your buying process, save time and money, and gain valuable insights. Amazon Business empowers you and your team to buy with confidence. Learn more at amazonbusiness.com. Instagram teen accounts have automatic protections on by default. Built-in content settings for the content teens can see, contact limits for who can contact them, and time management tools like daily time limits and sleep mode.
Teens are automatically placed into teen accounts, and teens under 16 will need a parent's permission to change any of these settings to be less strict. Instagram will continue adding built-in safety features to help create age-appropriate experiences. Learn more about teen accounts and Instagram's ongoing work to protect teens online at instagram.com/teenaccounts. Ready to give your home a style refresh? Article makes it easy to create a stylish, long-lasting home at an unbeatable price. They offer a curated selection of mid-century modern coastal and Scandi-inspired pieces that will make a perfect addition to your home. All Article collections are carefully curated, focusing solely on high-quality, meaningful pieces that will stand the test of time. And with Article's 30-day satisfaction guarantee,
you can shop with confidence. I'm trying to think of any of the Article furniture I haven't talked about at this point. I have couches, I have dining room sets, I have sideboards, I have, what do you call it, a media center? A thing that you put a TV on? Side tables, end tables, chairs. All of them are still in heavy use in my house, and all of them have held up great. Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com/99 and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com/99 for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.
To the millions of small business owners out there, we appreciate you. We see your early mornings, late nights, and all the hard work in between. And with the US Bank Business Essentials Card, you don't have to go it alone. With unlimited 2% And cash back on every purchase because we know your communities count on you to be here, there, everywhere. So yeah, we don't just appreciate you, we support you. The creditor and issuer of this card is US Bank National Association pursuant to a license from VC USA Inc. Some restrictions may apply.
And we're back with the story of America's public lands and whose checkerboard it really is.
When the Wyoming Sheriff's Office charged the hunters with criminal trespassing on Fred Eschman's land, things might very easily have just ended there. After all, at that point, it really was just a matter of corner crossing in this one area on this one ranch. There were plenty of other places in the country they could go hunt elk.
You know, we went back and forth contemplating whether we were going to just plead guilty, pay the $750 or what it might be. None of us were too concerned about the six-month in jail type thing.
But although the stakes for Brad and Phil and the other hunters personally were low, the principal involved seemed like part of something bigger, starting with their belief that corner crossing to access public land, which again is something hunters and other people do all the time, is legal.
It's such a simple concept. I got a six-year-old grandson. I could point this to him very simply and he would easily end up on the right side of this. This is just smoke and mirrors to try and steal the public's land.
So they decided to lawyer up. To win, they would need someone with experience representing both hunters and ranchers, someone who knew the laws, both spoken and unspoken of the Mountain West, someone who knew the difference between a mock scrape and a rub line. They needed, when it came down to it, a guy like them. They got Ryan.
My name is Ryan Semirad. I am an attorney in Casper. Were you in tune with, I mean, were you a hunter, an angler? Were you in tune with sort of public land issues in this case? No, I have never hunted.
I think I have caught a fish once.
Ryan is originally from New York, not Wyoming, but his wife is from the area. And when they wanted to have kids, they decided to move closer to her family.
And that's what brought us back to Wyoming, and that is the only reason that I am here.
At first, Ryan had no idea what to make of the case.
They described it as a corner hopping case. I assumed, and I was wrong, but I assumed that must have meant something really weird and rural, like a cow tipping case or something, or you, you know, left your neighbor's gate open. I don't really know.
But Ryan talked to some local friends. They told him this is a big deal here, and it has been for a long time. They sent him a study, and he learned that although a lot of the original checkerboarded area had been bought up and consolidated into these single land holdings, today, more than 8 million acres of public land across the Western US remain corner locked.
That's an area of public land only slightly smaller than Switzerland, completely inaccessible to anyone except for landowners like Eschelmann.
That's when it kind of dawned on me that this was maybe a bigger issue than just this one case.
So Ryan agreed to represent one of the hunters in the criminal trial, but he ended up representing all of them in civil court when he got notice that Fred Eschelmann, the owner of the ranch, had decided to sue the hunters too.
Eschelmann argued that he had bought the ranch with an understanding that corner crossing was illegal. Suddenly allowing it now would mean an influx of hunters and recreationists regularly trespassing on his private property. The chaos, as he saw it, would effectively devalue the land. The exact dollar amount he was suing for changed over time, but he put the total cost as high as $9 million.
What is the reaction you're hearing from, from Phil and Brad and the others when they, when they hear that?
Yeah, well, I, I will tell you, that was a pretty tough moment. When you tell anybody, hey, you know, you have this.
Exposure and especially these guys, I mean, these are not pharmaceutical executives, but they are not billionaires. Nine million dollars, you know, that's financial apocalypse.
Although for two people facing financial apocalypse, Brad and Phil seemed pretty stoic about it.
Yeah. So I told you I'm a, I'm a truck mechanic. Like buddy, I don't know. I guess my biggest concern was, you know, I want to make sure my wife, we still have a home, but I guess if he wants my 2013 Silverado, I guess he can take it.
If anything, Eschelman had sued them for too much money for it to have the desired effect. Phil thought nine million was laughable, Brad too.
That dollar amount was so outrageous. If he would have said a couple hundred thousand, that would have scared me. But in the millions, you know, it just wasn't a realistic number.
But Eschelman wasn't deterred. He just kept applying more pressure.
I've never seen this happen before. It kind of shocks me is while we were waiting for that criminal trial to begin, for the jury selection to begin, jurors are filing in, court staff are filing in. My guys are all sitting there and a sheriff's deputy walks up to each of them and issues them one more citation in front of the jury.
So another ticket, another criminal charge, this time for that first crossing back in 2020, a whole year before the ordeal they thought they were being tried for.
So yeah, that's, that's when we first learned about that. And I kind of handed the, I kind of looked at Ryan. I said, well, what do you want? What do I do with this? He said, throw it in the trash.
All right, court's back in session. The matter before the court is the state of Wyoming versus Bradley Keith, John Slawinski, Philip Yeoman, and Zachary Smith.
In the criminal trial, the state's lawyers argued that even if the hunters didn't set foot on private land when they ballerined over the tea posts in 2020 or climbed over them in 2021, they passed through air itself that's owned by the ranch.
Being a property owner has value. It matters. So do boundaries. And in Wyoming, the law is you don't just own the ground, you don't own the earth, you own the airspace. How many of you knew that before you came here?
Ryan's defense consisted of a few different points, but basically, it came down to this idea that the hunters never physically trespassed. Plus, they had air and land rights, too. Only in their case, it was the right of access to public land.
Government can't take away your land without compensating you to take it. But just so, private landowners can't take the public land. It's not theirs. It's all of ours.
And as the trial wore on, something else was happening. All sorts of other people started to take notice, including hunters and environmentalists who have been struggling with checkerboard enclosures for years, but also hikers, bicyclists, and fishermen who, thanks to new GPS mapping apps, could now see the full extent of the checkerboard and all that inaccessible public land. Journalists got interested, too.
Even before the trials had ended, The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal all ran features about the four hunters from Missouri, their little ladder, and corner crossings.
Hunting and public lands advocacy groups rallied members, raising money for the defense. And for those paying attention, the case became about something larger than just this one little square in Wyoming. It was about public access to public land all over the country.
The significance of it, the millions of acres, you know, the corner locked land, it's just, it's public land. That's what it is. It belongs to the public, yeah. It belongs to everybody, and it shouldn't be monopolized.
I live in Montana, where there's a lot of public land and also lots of checkerboarded country. Even here, more than 500 miles from where Brad and Phil crossed, their case made waves. I ran into a guy in a yoga class not too long ago, wearing a "corner crossing is not a crime" t-shirt.
So you get to a point where you can't back out. It's a moral thing. It's all of that, right? And that's why it became bigger than us.
And while the social status of the case got bigger, the legal stakes climbed too. The hunters won at both trials, but the civil case ended up before the US 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. The 10th Circuit is based in Denver and oversees six western states. This wasn't a small one-off case any longer, or even a case just setting the precedent in Wyoming.
The circuit court had the power to settle whether corner crossing was legal in all six of those states. The outcome would decide who got effective access to a huge amount of public land. And it was Eschelman's side, now backed up by a bunch of other landowners that had appealed to the 10th Circuit. They were the ones who wanted to go big. Ryan told me what he thought that meant. They have this kind of imperial intent that it's our lands, the lands they bought, and all of these public lands too. That's really what this case is about. They are going to shut out the public from the public lands. So May 2024, you're in Denver. Have you made arguments in front of a circuit court before?
Um, no, that's their very first time.
Looks like everybody's ready to go. With that, let's call the first case, which is 23-8043, Ironmark Holdings versus... You may proceed.
Good morning, Your Honors. May please the court.
The morning of the 10th Circuit hearing, an armada of well-respected attorneys showed up representing Eschelman. And since Eschelman's side brought the suit, they went first.
Some of the arguments had more or less stayed the same from the criminal trial, but now things got more nuanced. Eschelman's team argued that private property is a building block of society. Property lines have sharp edges because of the consequences...
So there's practical implications of this case that I want to address.
The gist of their argument was what Eschelman had maintained all along. That whatever high ideals we might have about public lands, the on the ground reality was that legalizing corner crossing would be an invitation for chaos.
In places without government survey markers, and there often aren't any, people would start to accidentally trespass all the time if corner crossing was legalized. But also, there was no need to permit corner crossing. The government already had better tools at its disposal to resolve the problems created by the checkerboard.
All of this can be fixed by the government tomorrow. If the government wants to create access, just as they had gone from 150 million acres of originally locked land, today, less than nine million remains. They are making progress.
And that's true. Although those last nine million acres have proven tricky to eradicate, there are various mechanisms for erasing the private squares in the checkerboard or just letting the public pass through. Eschelman's side argued there's no need to override all that policy for the sake of some elk-hungry hunters. If anything, this is a question for the legislature and local agencies, not the courts.
Meanwhile, Brad and Phil and the other hunters were streaming the proceedings from Missouri. They didn't attend the oral arguments in person.
When you watched it, did you guys like get together? Did you watch it separately?
No, we watched it separate. We all work.
May I please the court? Ryan Semer for the police.
When it was Ryan's turn to speak, Brad and Phil could both tell as they listened in that Ryan's core arguments were also much the same as in that first trial.
You can't exploit the interlocking land pattern to deny everybody else the benefits while you reap them all.
But this one moment toward the end of the hearing stood out to them both.
For me, it was when, and I don't remember the judge's name, he said, yeah, I don't believe our Congress intended when they wrote the laws and this checkerboard pattern was first made, they didn't intend it to block the public.
Congress said, "We want to give the railroads half the land and the public half the land."
"Did Congress really intend," the judge asked, "for the public to have no real right to the land from their half of the deal?"
If somebody had just posed the question that way to Congress, I have no doubt how they would have answered that question.
This past March, nearly a year after the oral arguments in Denver, the U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals issued its opinion on the case of Iron Bar Holdings versus Cape. That day, Ryan was in court in Wyoming. So I try to rush back to the office and I print off the opinion and I sit down to read it and just, what is it, what am I about to read? And as I read it, it was just, it was perfect. In many ways, the opinion was everything Ryan and Brad and the other hunters had argued for since the very beginning. The court laid out the history of the West, the railroads, the checkerboard grants, the enclosures, the range wars. It explained how the land is supposed to work.
The opinion said, "These public lands in the West, they're for everyone, and that's who they were always for."
So, we win. Corner crossing is not a trespass in all six states. The 10th Circuit's decision won't bring total closure. After Echelmann's team appealed again, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to take up the case, which means that, for now at least, the status of corner crossing and public land access in the other 44 states remains murky.
The last time I met up with Brad and Phil, they were passing through where I live, on their way to their big annual Western hunting trip, this time in Montana. Here, we're in the Ninth Circuit, along with other Western states with lots of checkerboarded land like Idaho, Oregon, and Washington. Montana's Fish and Game Agency has said, "Corner crossing remains unlawful here, so don't do it." But other authorities in the state disagree, and the issue remains as unclear as ever. It's unlikely Brad and Phil will be involved in whatever comes next. The whole saga has already taken up four years of their lives, and that, they said, was enough. But talking with them, I could tell they're a little bit bummed the Supreme Court didn't take up the case.
The way they see it, there's still more locked up land that needs to be freed.
You could never dream in a million years that you would end up here over something so simple as making one step.
Yeah, you know, we didn't set out to... To do this, you know, we just wanted to, we just wanted to go hunt elk.
Would you guys ever corner cross again?
Absolutely, absolutely. We, we put in, we've put in now every year since, I believe, for Elk Mountain. Yes, we're going back. We don't know when, but we're going back.
Why do you want to go back so bad?
I think because we can.
99% Invisible was reported this week by Nick Mott and edited by Joe Rosenberg. Mixed by Martin Gonzalez, music by Swan Real, fact checking by Graham Heishen. Special thanks this week to Savannah Tate-Wright, Ayla Kuziz, and Melody Star Edwards. Kathy Turow is our executive producer. Kurt Collet is the digital director. Delaney Hall is our senior editor. The rest of the team includes Chris Berube, Jason DeLeon, Emmett Fitzgerald, Christopher Johnson, Vivian Le, Laish Madon, Kelly Prime, Jacob Medina Gleason, Talon and Rain Stradly, and me, Roman Mars. The 99% Invisible logo was created by Stefan Lawrence. We are part of the SiriusXM Podcast family, now headquartered six blocks north
in the Pandora Building in beautiful Uptown Oakland, California. You can find us on all the usual social media sites as well as our own Discord server. There's a link to that as well as every past episode of 99PI at 99pi.org.
This podcast is supported by Nurtec ODT, Remedipant. We know you.
Didn't ask for an interruption. But migraine doesn't wait for the right moment to interrupt either. It just barges in, takes your time, and throws everything off. So when migraine takes your time, take Nurtac. It's for the acute treatment of migraine with or without aura in adults. Nurtac can provide pain relief in two hours, which can last up to two days. Ask your healthcare provider if Nurtac is right for you, because your time is for you, not migraine. Don't take if allergic to Nurtac ODT. Allergic reactions can occur even days after use. Get help right away for trouble breathing, rash, swelling of face, mouth, tongue, or throat. High blood pressure and Raynaud's syndrome can occur. Get help for high blood pressure, numbness, coolness, pain, or color changes in fingers and toes. Common side effect is nausea.
For full prescribing information, call 1-833-4-NUR-TAC or visit Nurtac.com. All right, back to your podcast, playlist, or whatever's keeping you going today. Time for a quick break to talk about McDonald's. It's the tangiest time of the year. For a limited time, head to McDonald's and get a McRib sandwich. Make it a meal by adding a medium fries and a soft drink like an ice cold Diet Dr. Pepper. So grab a McRib sandwich and embrace the tang. Save time by ordering ahead on the app. Participate at McDonald's for a limited time. Dr. Pepper is a registered trademark of Dr. Pepper, 7-Up, Inc.
Vehicle safety starts underneath. That's why the pros choose NAPA for undercar solutions that stop safety issues before they become costly problems. Go further with complete repairs that restore stopping, steering, and stability. Then grow your business through trust and repeat visits. With premium rotors, pads, struts, and wheel hub assemblies, NAPA has everything you need to keep undercar under control. That's NAPA Know-How.
Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated
