A failed galaxy could solve the dark matter mystery

Cloud 9 is a failed galaxy. It’s a clump of dark matter, called a dark matter halo, that never formed stars. But this failure could be the key to a mystery almost as old as the universe itself: dark matter. Scientists don’t know what dark matter is, but Cloud 9 could offer new clues. Three researchers weigh in on this new discovery and why it could be a missing piece to the story on how the universe formed. Check out our episode with astrophysicist Jorge Moreno on the mysterious Great Attractor https://www.npr.org/2024/05/01/1198909922/great-attractor-universe-laniakea-milky-way-galaxy and our summer series on space https://www.npr.org/series/g-s1-3299/short-wave-space-camp. Have a scientific question you want us to answer? Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected]. See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences. NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  This message comes from the Southern Environmental Law Center. No one voted for dirty air and water. That's why S E L C is fighting back to defend the healthy environment everyone depends on, because it's not political, it's fundamental. Learn more at S E L C dot org.

• 0:18Speaker 00

  You're listening to Short Wave from NPR.

• 0:23Regina Barber?

  The universe that you and I see with our eyes, things that make up matter like galaxies, stars, planets, grass, that's only 15% of the universe's total mass. The rest is called dark matter. This is mass in the universe that doesn't interact with light. Astronomers know that dark matter is there, but they don't know what it's made out of.

• 0:48Speaker 02

  So we don't know what dark matter is, but we know what it's not. So when you think of a galaxy like our Milky Way, it has three main components. It has stars, it has gas, but most of it is dark matter.

• 1:00Regina Barber?

  That's Jorge Moreno, a computational astrophysicist, cosmologist, and professor at Pomona College in California. Like many scientists out there, he would love to find out what exactly dark matter is. And a new clue just dropped. It's called Cloud Nine.

• 1:18Speaker 02

  Cloud Nine, I like to think of it as a bit of an underachiever. It actually had all the resources it needed to make a galaxy. It had the fuel, it had all the conditions, but it just chose not to.

• 1:30Regina Barber?

  Cloud Nine is a failed galaxy. It's a dark matter halo with a cloud of gas devoid of stars. It's on the outskirts of a beautiful spiral galaxy, M94. But what's a dark matter halo?

• 1:44Speaker 02

  A clump of dark matter.

• 1:46Regina Barber?

  And while it may be an underachiever, Cloud Nine is a big deal. The current model of our universe predicts this kind of dark matter halo exists, one that didn't help make a galaxy or stars. But this is the first time astronomers have observed one.

• 2:02Speaker 02

  It not only teaches us about the nature of galaxy formation, but also the nature of dark matter itself.

• 2:11Regina Barber?

  Today on the show, why this failed galaxy could be the key to finding out one of astronomy's biggest mysteries. Answering, what is dark matter? I'm Regina Barber, and you're listening to Short Wave, the science podcast from NPR.

• 2:44Speaker 03

  Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from International Medical Corps. When crises strike, every second matters. And that's why International Medical Corps moves fast. From the flooding in Nepal to earthquakes in Venezuela, they deliver lifesaving medical care and supplies around the world, while training local health workers to ensure care continues long after the emergency ends. This giving season, your generosity saves lives and builds resilience for tomorrow. Learn more or donate today at internationalmedicalcorps.org/NPR. This message comes from Google Workspace with Gemini.

• 3:24Speaker 03

  Ever notice how every new AI tool asks you to explain your business to it all over again? Google Workspace with Gemini skips that. You get Google's AI built right into the premium versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Sheets, and more. No new tools, no extra logins, just one subscription that gives you personalized AI right inside your actual workflow. Try Google Workspace with Gemini at g o o dot g l e slash workspace with Gemini. This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you.

• 4:05Regina Barber?

  I'm talking with Andrew Fox and Gagan Deep Anand, two astronomers from the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore, Maryland, and you two were on the team that found this dark matter halo. First of all, Andy, how did you feel when you realized what you found?

• 4:19Speaker 04

  We were excited because we've been studying this cloud near the galaxy M94. This cloud's been known for a few years, but we pointed the Hubble Space Telescope at this cloud expecting to find some stars. And if we'd seen stars, that would have confirmed that this cloud is really a small galaxy, something like many other galaxies that are out there. But what we found was that there are no stars, even though we pointed at this object for a very long time with the Hubble telescope. And that told us that it's a different type of object, an object that is gas-rich but that is almost completely starless. And so we were excited because, in a way, that was a surprise. We didn't find the stars we

• 5:02Speaker 04

  were expecting to see. We found just a blank piece of sky, a completely empty cloud. And that's a really interesting clue about what the nature of this object is.

• 5:12Regina Barber?

  And Deep, can you help our listeners to understand, what is a dark matter halo? Why is this such a big deal?

• 5:19Speaker 05

  Yeah, so galaxies form inside dark matter halos. So the dark matter is the prevailing structure, actually, even though we can't see it. And then all of the matter that makes up the things we know, like stars and planets, normal matter or baryonic matter, that's the stuff that we know and love and that you see in the pictures. But the prevailing model of our universe, what's called Lambda CDM, or the model that describes dark energy and dark matter, it predicts that you should have dark matter halos that are actually not massive enough to form stars in the centers. And so this has been a prediction of the

• 6:01Speaker 05

  theory. And with the discovery of this relic object, Cloud Nine, it's a confirmation that you actually do indeed have dark matter halos that are not massive enough to form stars, just like the simulations predict.

• 6:15Regina Barber?

  Okay, so Andy, can you help explain this Lambda CDM model and how it really tells us how galaxies are being put together?

• 6:24Speaker 04

  Yeah, it's a great question because as as Deep mentioned, most of the matter in the universe is not thought to be in atoms and molecules, the regular matter we can see around us on Earth and in our solar system. Most of the matter is thought to be dark, which means it doesn't emit any light. We can only infer it by seeing on its effects on the matter around it. For example, the gravity that the dark matter can provide. Now, this Lambda CDM model, it's accepted as the prevailing, the commonly accepted model of where the matter is in the universe and and the matter condenses into galaxies. And those live in what we call halos because the the matter is concentrated into different patches. We call those halos. Most massive halos have galaxies in them.

• 7:09Speaker 04

  So when we look out into the night sky, we see those galaxies. But the cool thing about this model is that it predicts there are smaller halos, smaller halos that are beneath the scale that can form a galaxy, essentially failed galaxies, things that didn't quite have enough mass to form a galaxy, emit light, and become like any other galaxy we can see. Those smaller halos are called relics. That's a technical term, but you can think of it as a relic, a leftover from this time when galaxies formed. But there were some leftover clouds that were not massive enough to form galaxies. And this is part of this this this theory, the CDM theory.

• 7:45Regina Barber?

  How big are we talking about? Like, if you can kind of compare it to our galaxy and things maybe around it, when we're talking about these relics, how big are they?

• 7:54Speaker 04

  So this relic we've been studying called Cloud Nine is about a kiloparsec across. That's the unit astronomers use. That's about 3,000 light years. The Milky Way would be, I don't know, maybe 50 kiloparsecs or 150,000 light years across. So this object is much smaller than the Milky Way. It's small and it's dense with with no stars in it. But so we think of these relics as the leftover clouds that didn't quite make it to become galaxies. And they've just been hanging out there in the universe, but they're very hard to observe. And that's why we had to look really to very deep levels, look with very sensitive imaging with the Hubble telescope to actually confirm this thing and show that it had no stars in it.

• 8:38Speaker 04

  And that's really the side of this story we're most excited about, is that these objects have been predicted by theory. They come out of this Landau-Czernian theory. But with Cloud Nine, we finally have a chance to observe one and see what its real properties are like.

• 8:51Regina Barber?

  And Deep, I think this is a good time to like, take a step back for people, you know, who aren't astronomers. How do galaxies form? Like, what is the consensus, you know, in the astronomy community?

• 9:04Speaker 05

  Yeah, so before, you know, if you go back way in time, before galaxies formed, you have the universe and you have certain parts of the universe that are just slightly more dense than other parts. And those are the regions that become galaxies. And so we think that galaxies form in halos, or roughly spherical regions of dark matter. And so these halos trap gas, and that gas collapses and then forms galaxies. But our models predict that you have to have a halo that is above a critical mass to actually collapse and form a galaxy. And so, as Andy was saying earlier, you also have, you should also have dark matter halos

• 9:48Speaker 05

  that are just below this critical mass threshold that remain starless, basically. Adding on to what Andy was saying earlier, too, relics live in the sweet spot where they're not massive enough to collapse and form galaxies, but they are just massive enough to hold on to some of the gas still. And that's the key part, is that since they're able to hold on to the neutral hydrogen gas, we can actually go with radio telescopes and look for the glow of that neutral hydrogen. And we see it in the radio observations. And that's how the Chinese team that detected Cloud Nine in the first place, that's how they were able to find it.

• 10:28Regina Barber?

  And Andy, before this discovery, there was that gap in the theory, right? We hadn't seen any of these dark matter halos this size. I remember there might have been other candidates, so have there been other possibilities before you found this dark matter halo?

• 10:44Speaker 04

  Yeah, that's right. There have been other candidates. There's been cases where people have seen these gas clouds without any obvious stars. But we've never found one quite like Cloud Nine before, the new one in our latest research. And in particular, we've never pointed just so long with the Hubble telescope at one of these clouds. In other words, we were really taking a very deep, long exposure to see if there's anything there. So we wouldn't really have expected that it would be so empty. That was the great surprise and the great finding here is that even with the Hubble, with some of the sharpest eyes we have in space, we still couldn't find any stars. And that tells you that there really is very little stellar content, very little stars in this thing at all.

• 11:26Regina Barber?

  So Deep, what does this discovery mean? Now we've finally filled in this gap of theory. What does this mean for theory? What does this mean for astronomy going forward?

• 11:36Speaker 05

  Yeah, so first of all, it's a big win for the theory. It's a big prediction of the model that these objects should exist. And just by finding one, you know you're on the right track. The other thing is that these things are really useful, right? And so if you look at normal galaxies like the Milky Way, yes, they have dark matter halos, but they also have a lot of other stuff going on. There's stars, there's gas, there's dust. And so the idea is if you look at the distribution of mass in Cloud Nine in more detail, we'd be able to sort of put more constrict constraints on what dark matter actually is. And so by mapping out Cloud Nine in higher resolution in the future, we might have a

• 12:19Speaker 05

  better hold on what the dark matter particle, or if it's not a particle, whatever else it is really is.

• 12:25Regina Barber?

  Yeah, Andy, do you have anything to add to that? Because this is a big deal. We might be able to find what dark matter is?

• 12:30Speaker 04

  I think it's a very promising direction. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, these clouds, you can think of them as a window into a dark matter-dominated cloud, a window into the dark universe. We don't have many places we can look without stars because the stars are so bright, they take your attention, they make it harder to see what's happening underneath. With Cloud Nine, the lack of stars, we can turn that to our advantage.

• 12:54Speaker 04

  Where we found Cloud Nine is not close to M94. It's way out in the outer halo, in the outskirts of that system. And we think that's really important because if it had been found much closer in, nearby to the galaxy, there's all sorts of processes that could have destroyed it by now. But it's quite happy sitting where it is in the outer halo and giving us this great chance to study it and to look at what the cloud is actually made of in terms of its dark matter content. Getting the first one is always the hardest thing, but we want to look for more of a population of clouds with similar properties. That's certainly going to be helpful for following up on this.

• 13:33Regina Barber?

  Yeah, Andy, Deep, thank you so much for talking to me about Cloud Nine.

• 13:38Speaker 05

  Yeah, thank you. Thank you very much for this opportunity.

• 13:41Speaker 04

  Thank you. It's been our pleasure.

• 13:47Regina Barber?

  If you liked this episode, follow us on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Also, you may want to check out our episode with astrophysicist Jorge on the mysterious Great Attractor, or our whole summer series on space. We'll link to them in our show notes. I'm Regina Barber. Thank you for listening to Short Wave from NPR.

• 14:25Speaker 03

  Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.