Pod Insights You're Dead to Me History of Broadway (Radio Edit) About this episode Greg Jenner is joined in 20th-century New York by Dr Hannah Thuraisingam Robbins and comedian Desiree Burch to learn about the history of Broadway.
Most of us are familiar with at least one Broadway musical, from classics like My Fair Lady and the Sound of Music to new favourites Hamilton and Wicked. In the last couple of decades, high-profile film adaptations of shows like Chicago, Cats and Les Misérables have brought musical theatre to a bigger audience than ever before. But whether or not you know your Rodgers & Hammerstein from your Lloyd Webber, the history of Broadway is perhaps more of a mystery.
This episode explores all aspects of musical theatre, from its origins in the early years of the 20th century, to the ‘Golden Age’ in the 50s and the rise of the megamusical in the 80s. Along the way, Greg and his guests learn about the racial and class dynamics of Broadway, uncover musical flops and triumphs, and find out exactly what ‘cheating out’ is.
This is a radio edit of the original podcast episode. For the full-length version, please look further back in the feed.
Hosted by: Greg Jenner
Research by: Hannah Campbell Hewson, Annabel Storr and Anna McCully Stewart
Written by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner
Produced by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner
Audio Producer: Steve Hankey
Production Coordinator: Ben Hollands
Senior Producer: Emma Nagouse
Executive Editor: James Cook
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Greg Jenner? This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:05 Speaker 01 Hosts Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavours with the quality you want, only at Whole Foods Market.
0:35 Speaker 02 We all have routines. I'm Gibran, and with diabetes, mine was finger sticks. Sometimes, I skip them because they hurt. The Freestyle Libre 3CGM changed that. It gives me glucose insights without finger sticks. Learn more at freestylelibre.us.
0:50 Speaker 03 Finger sticks are required if your glucose alarms or readings do not match symptoms, or when you see check blood glucose symbol for the first 12 hours. The views expressed should not be used for medical diagnosis or treatment as a substitute for professional medical advice. Individual circumstances may vary. For prescription only. Safety info found at freestylelibre.us.
1:08 Speaker 04 BBC Sounds, music, radio, podcasts.
1:13 Greg Jenner? Hello and welcome to You're Dead to Me, the Radio 4 comedy podcast that takes history seriously. My name is Greg Jenner, I'm a public historian, author and broadcaster. And today, we are collecting our costumes and can-canning into the chorus line as we learn all about the history of Broadway. And to help us, we have two very special theatrical stars. In history corner, they're an associate professor in popular music and the director of the Black Studies Department at the University of Nottingham. They're an expert on musical theatre and research race and gender identity in popular culture. They've published on everything from The Wizard of Oz to Hamilton and, my favourite, Frozen. No, you let it go. It's Dr Hannah Taurisingham-Robins, welcome.
1:50 Speaker 05 Hello, thank you for having me.
1:52 Greg Jenner? Delighted to have you here. And in comedy corner, she needs no introduction on this show, but I do still have to do one, so she's a comedian, actor, writer, you'll have seen her on all the telly, Taskmaster, Frankie Boyle's New World Order, The Horn Section TV Show, Netflix's Too Hot to Handle, and you'll know her from our many, many episodes of this very podcast, including- ...recent highlights, the Colombian exchange and Pythagoras. It's your Dead to Me's leading lady, Desiree Birch. Welcome back, Desiree.
2:16 Speaker 05 What a dude. You said you had to do one. Do I get to host the podcast now?
2:20 Greg Jenner? I think you've done enough episodes now that maybe...
2:22 Speaker 05 I've learned my British slang. I'm doing well, guys. Is this under the test?
2:26 Greg Jenner? Are you a fan of musical theatre? Do you go to Broadway when you're maybe back home and to the West End?
2:33 Speaker 05 Okay.
2:35 Greg Jenner? Are we about to hear something?
2:36 Speaker 05 No. I mean, look, I love theatre. I love seeing incredible acting. For me, it is always about the acting above everything else. For musical theatre, it really does need to be, for the most part, singing first if you're going to enjoy it. It feels like it needs to be singing, then acting, and then movement. And I wish it were two and one were inverted. Although I've seen musicals on Broadway where they couldn't sing or act. And I was just like, well, what are we doing here except for a jukebox revival? But yeah, I mean, every so often it is done really well, but there's always a point in a musical where you're like, I get it, fall in love. Like, I want, I need to catch a train. Like, make it end.
3:18 Greg Jenner? So, what do you know?
3:25 Greg Jenner? This is where I have a go at guessing what you, our lovely listener, might know about today's subjects. And we've all watched a musical, haven't we? Whether it's a classic like West Side Story or My Fair Lady, a Lloyd Webber wonderpiece like Phantom of the Opera, a modern smash like Wicked or Hamilton. Most of us have seen a stage musical at some point, plus there are the film adaptations as well. Catherine C. Jones in Chicago, you might have swooned over Hugh Jackman in Les Mis. What about the history of the mega-popular art form that we call Broadway? How have Broadway shows changed over the years? And just who was Imogen the Cow? Let's find out. But I'm going to start with the basic question. What is a Broadway musical?
4:01 Speaker 06 So like, for me, I guess a musical is a combination of singing and drama and spectacle. Sometimes there'll be lots of exciting sets, sometimes there'll be costumes, sometimes there'll be amazing lighting, you know, lots of additional theatre craft. But I think particularly going backwards, it's this really interesting like hybrid of influences, smushes. Into one performance form. And I guess the way to tell if you're engaging with a musical is that the singing uses different storytelling and also kind of a different vocal style than we might expect if we're listening to popular music, the mashup of genres and the emphasis of like communicating the content of a song rather than communicating through song, which is opera, are the clues that we're listening to a track from a musical and not
4:43 Speaker 06 a song from something else. The Commercial Theatre District in Manhattan sort of runs roughly between Forty Second and Forty Sixth and Seventh Avenue. So it's kind of a hotchpotch of different theatres, but it's also places where you can eat. So they built a lot of theatres sort of at the end of the eighteen hundreds, eighteen eighties. But by the time we hit the early nineteen hundreds, we've got about thirty theatres.
5:05 Greg Jenner? Is the West End just Broadway but in London? Or is that a different thing?
5:09 Speaker 06 Oh, controversial.
5:12 Speaker 06 We look at Broadway as kind of the geographic home and the spiritual home of the musical, even though it's actually genuinely a global phenomenon at this point and belongs to lots of places. But the thing that I think we can't debate is that it is originally an American art form. There is a little bit of that creeping into the discourse at the moment that musicals are not American. And that's one of those that I won't stand for.
5:33 Greg Jenner? Oh, push down moment. Okay. This American theatrical tradition, there are words I want to chuck at you, vaudeville, burlesque, theatre, musical, minstrel shows. Are those all the same thing?
5:46 Speaker 06 Vaudeville was lots of often sketches. It could be songs. It might be comedy. It might be dance sequences. But one of the sort of defining factors of vaudeville is that it took place in places that sold alcohol. And so you could tap in and out of the entertainment while it was taking place.
6:04 Greg Jenner? Quite literally tap in and out, yeah.
6:05 Speaker 06 Literally. Pun. Burlesque is interesting because in the nineteenth century, it was actually more of a satire form. It was the striptease component actually comes in much later.
6:19 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
6:19 Speaker 06 Alongside this, minstrelsy sort of solidifies itself mid eighteen hundreds, has a sort of a peak and a trough, and then another peak and a trough in the early twentieth century. That is a performance form that generally involved white men or white presenting men wearing black makeup and doing comedy skits and songs, comedy in inverted commas there, but based on racist principles.
6:43 Greg Jenner? Let's get to 1902, when Broadway gets going, I think, Desiree, and one of the first productions was The Wizard of Oz.
6:49 Speaker 05 Nice.
6:50 Greg Jenner? Quite an unusual musical, do you know why?
6:52 Speaker 05 I mean, there's so many versions of it that I've seen, The Wiz and Wicked and all these other versions of that. What's weird about it?
6:59 Greg Jenner? No songs.
7:00 Speaker 05 Okay, yeah.
7:00 Greg Jenner? No music? I mean, or some music, but not a score?
7:04 Speaker 06 So some music, but not a score. So this is like an interesting example of a work deliberately blending lots of different things together. So this was kind of burlesque, it was pantomime, as we would understand it in the UK, and also like lots of fantasy elements were immersed into this version of The Wizard of Oz. But in terms of the score, what happened, and this still happens in musicals, lots of people aren't aware, is that there were optional songs and you could switch them in and out.
7:28 Speaker 05 It's a real comedy set where you're like, oh, they're not warm enough for that one yet. Let's take that one out and do a couple.
7:33 Greg Jenner? We won't do that bit, yeah.
7:34 Speaker 05 Yeah, kind of.
7:36 Greg Jenner? The production also changed a couple of other things about The Wizard of Oz, Desiree. They changed a major character from the book and the later film. Do you want to guess which character did not appear in 1902's?
7:46 Speaker 05 Dorothy?
7:47 Greg Jenner? That'd be amazing. It's just some bloke called Rob. Just like, hello.
7:51 Speaker 05 And they were like, ah, let's get a gal in there. We need to sell these tickets.
7:54 Greg Jenner? No, Toto the Dog was replaced by Imogen the Cow.
7:59 Speaker 05 Oh, there we go.
8:00 Greg Jenner? There we go. Let's talk about the development of increased visibility of these black performers, you said. Minstrel C, obviously racist and an unfortunate problematic history, but it created perhaps a culture whereby black performers could get work.
8:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, for sure. And I think one of the things that we don't necessarily know so much about the early days of Broadway is that there were lots of black creatives, writing work, producing work, touring work at the sort of the turn of the 20th century. So we're talking the early 1900s. Perhaps the most famous example of that is the musical Into Homie, which was a musical mainly set in Florida. It was written by two African American performers who were already an established double act called Williams. Walker. It's a particularly famous one because it was very successful in America and it had a big touring life. But it also came to the UK and was one of the first times that a Black authored production, particularly a Black authored musical, had been played in lots of London and British theatres.
8:58 Greg Jenner? Because this is nineteen oh three.
8:59 Speaker 06 Yes, this is nineteen oh three, so it's really early.
9:02 Speaker 05 Were black people able to see this in segregated places or who was witnessing this work?
9:08 Speaker 06 So there's a balance of the two. I think Indehomi is complicated because it does have elements of minstrelsy in it. There were no white performers. All of the cast were black.
9:17 Greg Jenner? Right.
9:18 Speaker 06 But there were black actors using blackface and using anti-black stereotypes that were derived from minstrelsy.
9:24 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
9:25 Speaker 06 That formed kind of the first two halves, the sort of smash hit musical people like to turn to, which is Shuffle Along, which opened in nineteen twenty one. And Shuffle Along changed the game because it ran for an extraordinary amount of performances for the time, around five hundred performances. The audiences flocking in were so excited to see it that they actually had to make, I think it's sixty third street, a one-way thoroughfare because it was impossible for the police to manage the traffic.
9:53 Speaker 05 It was the Hamilton of its time.
9:54 Speaker 06 Yeah, it was the Hamilton of its time.
9:55 Greg Jenner? They blocked traffic. We've got to fly through the twentieth century, so.
10:00 Speaker 05 Best way to deal with it.
10:01 Greg Jenner? Yeah. In the nineteen twenties, there was a new entertainment phenomenon that showed up. Desiree, what happened in Hollywood in nineteen twenty seven that had a major impact on Broadway?
10:11 Speaker 05 All I can think of is racism and men technicolor. There's definitely something in between.
10:17 Greg Jenner? There's a third thing in the middle.
10:18 Speaker 05 In the middle to triangulate that. What happened in actual sound? Like, because.
10:23 Greg Jenner? That's it. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. You've got the coming of the talkies.
10:26 Speaker 05 Yes.
10:27 Greg Jenner? And it's the Jazz Singer, which is the first talkie, which actually really brings us back to Broadway, doesn't it? It's a musical. And this hurt the popularity of theatre simply because, I guess, cinema was offering a brand new experience, right? You could go for a much cheaper ticket to go and listen to songs, listen to dialogue. You don't need to go to the theatre.
10:44 Speaker 06 Initially, there was some concern. Some people were actually frightened of the talkies and the notion of people being able to speak through. The initial peak wasn't as extreme as we might have expected, but after that, the number of new theatre productions of all kinds drops across America. And this does coincide, it's important to say, with the Great Depression. But so you have a sort of a decline from maybe 200 new productions a season to somewhere nearer 100 new productions a season.
11:09 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
11:10 Speaker 06 It's important to say that Broadway was perhaps one of the less hard hit industries during the Great Depression. But there was a significant drop off. And that's also one of the reasons that musicals become in lots of ways, the popular music. Because shows lived or died by covers of songs from musicals becoming the popular music.
11:28 Greg Jenner? Yeah. So the 1940s is where American, the American economy is sort of supercharged by World War Two. And by the 50s, you obviously it becomes the kind of dominant superpower. And that's also where we get the golden age, inverted commas, of the Broadway musical. Desiree, do you know who the famous writing duo were who kind of dominated that decade?
11:46 Speaker 05 Is it Rodgers and Hammerstein?
11:48 Greg Jenner? It is, yeah, very good, yeah.
11:49 Speaker 06 One of the bits Rodgers and Hammerstein's story that gets missed is that they were already influential figures in Broadway by the time they came together. And they come together to produce this musical no one's ever heard of called Oklahoma. This is, this is 1943 and Oklahoma becomes this overnight sensation after Shuffle Along and Showboat. It's the next sort of major landmark. It expanded the sort of creative understanding of what a musical could be because it combined plot, songs, dance and music sort of seamlessly. It's what's sometimes referred to as an integrated musical, which as a critical race scholar, I think is hilarious.
12:30 Speaker 06 Actually, we're first to the dramatic elements of the show. Oklahoma ran for about 2,000 performances, so over five years. When you consider that the longest running musical in the 1930s ran for about 500 performances, that gives you a sense of the sort of impact.
12:48 Greg Jenner? And Oklahoma, I mean, 43, middle of the war, America, you know, it's sort of feel good.
12:53 Speaker 05 It's like, America's great, guys, remember?
12:55 Greg Jenner? Yeah, oh, what a beautiful morning. Yeah. This is where we're getting the character sing. Their feelings.
13:01 Speaker 06 Yeah, a little bit. It's about the songs needing to progress the plot in some way or give us a sense of place. Or they become about expressions of internal thought and feeling.
13:14 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
13:14 Speaker 06 Oklahoma is really deemed to be the first example where you can't just chop and change songs. They're really significant to where they fall.
13:22 Greg Jenner? Driving the actual plot.
13:23 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely.
13:24 Greg Jenner? I want song or whatever.
13:25 Speaker 06 Yeah.
13:25 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
13:25 Speaker 06 Absolutely. The the softness we might have expected in the 40s and 30s comes in musicals in the 50s. Once the form is a little bit more settled and Rodgers and Hammerstein are, you know, this dominant force. But at the same time, you have things like Guys and Dolls, which opens in 1950. You have West Side Story. West Side Story was actually overshadowed by The Music Man, that's recently been on Broadway. And right up to Fiddler on the Roof, see, which is the first musical to pass 3,000 performances. So if you think in the the 20s, we're overwhelmed by something that runs 400 performances. By the sort of mid 60s, we're at 3,000 performances. Phantom of the Opera has run 14,000.
14:06 Greg Jenner? They must be so bored of it by now. Surely. Yeah. And My Fair Lady is another one to shout out, which is Lerner and Low, isn't it? So we've got, we've got other double acts coming in. We've got other creative teams. West Side Story is Bernstein and Sonheim.
14:17 Speaker 06 Yep.
14:18 Greg Jenner? Who are both giants.
14:19 Speaker 06 Yes.
14:20 Greg Jenner? Let's talk about the actual sound being made because we get the arrival of microphones and amplification. But prior to the mics, how are these performers getting through a two hour show and hitting the back rows with their vocal techniques?
14:34 Speaker 05 And how many shows a week are they able to?
14:36 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
14:36 Speaker 06 Yeah. So I mean, we we are in the sort of five to seven shows a week. Amplification comes into musicals really slowly, so they are starting to dabble with it towards the end of the 1930s. The beginning of Oklahoma, Oh, What a Beautiful Morning, the person singing offstage is actually using a microphone in 1943.
14:53 Greg Jenner? Interesting.
14:53 Speaker 06 But there aren't mics on stage. If we listen to musical theatre performers, really from the pre 60s, we are listening to a much rounder, broader sound in general. Often we're listening to operatically trained performers or a balance of singers. We also have techniques which I'm sure you'll be able Aware of the zero of cheating front. So you don't actually look at a performer because the directionality of where your voice is going is really important.
15:18 Greg Jenner? So you're standing at the front of the stage singing to the audience, even though you're talking to your colleague on stage who stood to your side. In the sixties, firstly, we get electrified instruments, so guitars and drums, that's it. But that also means that kids are listening to rock and roll now. They don't want to go to the theatre, they want to listen to the Stones. So does the theatre change again?
15:36 Speaker 06 Yeah, the sixties is kind of a watershed. Musical theatre ceases to be the popular music. It becomes old fashioned in comparison to what's happening, both in popular music and in film. Part of this is sort of triggered by Elvis Presley's film musicals and his transition from his sort of more quote unquote clean identity into his rock star figures. But there are also shortcomings, I guess, to what this leads to. Not everybody was able to write a successful rock musical because actually lots of rock songs were not intended to tell stories. Jesus Christ Superstar is an outlier in someone doing it very successfully early and hair would be another.
16:17 Greg Jenner? There are some duds, Hannah.
16:19 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah. Nice. I want to hear about these.
16:22 Greg Jenner? Desiree, if I say to you, nineteen seventy two's classic Via Galactica.
16:27 Speaker 05 Oh, my gosh, that sounds amazing.
16:29 Greg Jenner? What do you think happens in that?
16:30 Speaker 05 I'm at vehicle. I don't know. It sounds like space lasers and, you know. I mean, because I'm trying hard not to think of things that were that thing like Xanadu, which is just, or is it, or is Xanadu? One of them. No, I'm thinking of Starlight Express. That's all on roller skates. Yeah. What else could it be on? All on snowboards or something like? With laser guns, doing aliens.
16:53 Greg Jenner? You're doing really, Hannah, do you want to tell Desiree what the technology was?
16:57 Speaker 06 Well, so they wanted to mimic zero gravity.
17:01 Speaker 05 Yes.
17:02 Speaker 06 So all of them.
17:05 Speaker 06 All of their actors bouncing on trampolines for the entire musical.
17:09 Greg Jenner? Bring it back, that's what I say.
17:11 Speaker 05 It's not really anti-gravity, it's like very gravity.
17:14 Greg Jenner? Yes, you can really feel the gravity, like bang, bang.
17:18 Speaker 05 Yes.
17:18 Greg Jenner? Saying that, I would love to, if anyone would like to produce the Van Halen musical, jump with me. I know where to get some trampolines, let's do this. The 1970s was a time of a bit of crisis in New York. It's not great, so there were sort of big campaigns to try and get New York up and running again, bring Broadway back. But also, you then get the arrival of Andrew Lloyd Webber and the mega musical. What do you think of this as a mega musical in your head?
17:41 Speaker 05 I just imagine a lot of people and I guess a chandelier crashing. I mean, a lot of people and spectacle, I mean, in my head, musicals are pretty mega, like as far as my modern understanding of them, it's like, oh, someone's getting hoisted up and like, you know, someone's flying out over the audience or you've got to have like something like that.
18:03 Greg Jenner? So wire work, stunts.
18:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, stunts and like huge, you know, and an entire army of people coming onto stage or like a helicopter lands in before the act breaks.
18:12 Greg Jenner? So obviously you've got Les Mis, Miss Saigon, Starlight Express, Cats, we get Lloyd Webber coming in and fixing the show. Nothing changes, you can perform it a thousand times in every city in the world, it's never going to be different.
18:24 Speaker 06 The seeds of this are sown in the 70s with Grease and Chicago and The Rocky Horror Show and The Wiz. And A Chorus Line, which is another sort of massive hit. But what Lloyd Webber does is he combines technology, a score, musical choices, lighting, production components, all together to create a product that could be recreated in lots of different spaces. And what that means is that these musicals, specifically mega musicals, become destination performances. You go to Broadway to see The Phantom of the Opera on Broadway. It allows considerable special effects, so we have extensive revolving stages and extra complicated folding scenery like in Les Mis.
19:07 Speaker 06 We have a helicopter seeming to land in the middle of a scene in Miss Saigon. And the standardization is really important because it means that if you've seen one of these Shows in theory in one place in the world and you go to see it somewhere else, you actually know what you're getting and that was very different.
19:22 Speaker 05 It's so weird that we had a British person come in to do that because it's a very American thing.
19:26 Greg Jenner? It is, isn't it? It is quite an American tradition. Well, I mean, I don't want to, you know, speak on behalf of America.
19:31 Speaker 05 A bit to like standardize something to make it highly commercial.
19:34 Greg Jenner? Exactly.
19:34 Speaker 05 He's the reason why my suburban friends fly halfway around the world, you know, once a year to be like, we're going to the Broadway to see this show.
19:44 Greg Jenner? Yeah, exactly. And I mean, it's called show business, right? And I mean, ticket prices soar in this time, don't they?
19:50 Speaker 05 They shoot up. He's the reason they're all 400.
19:52 Greg Jenner? Yeah, yeah, so.
19:53 Speaker 06 I mean, I wouldn't want to blame him entirely. And the reason I wouldn't want to blame him entirely is that one of the tensions in musicals, the whole way through is the balance of the shows that sell an amazing amount and the shows that are critically acclaimed but don't sell a massive amount. So this is a tension, for example, between all the classics on time shows that we know and love now that weren't particularly commercially successful when they originally opened.
20:14 Greg Jenner? The 90s obviously is where we get the Disney Corporation saying, well, we've got some musicals, let's, let's.
20:19 Speaker 05 We like money. Let's see what we can do here. Spectacle, you got it.
20:23 Greg Jenner? You've got your huge hits, Beauty and the Beast and The Lion King, obviously mega smashes again. But then, of course, you know, the 20th, 21st century, rather, the millennium brings the horrors of 9/11, of course, but also kind of a different era. Again, how is Broadway adapting to that 20 years ago or so?
20:39 Speaker 06 Yeah, we have this really interesting balance of excitement that the musical is kind of having a revival. The Disney animated musicals have been a massive hit. The Broadway versions have then been a massive hit. We then have Moulin Rouge in Chicago that come out pretty close together in the cinema, which had massive box office success. And at the same time, we also have jukebox musicals having a new resurgence. I mean, jukebox musicals have been part of musical theatre since the 1930s.
21:03 Greg Jenner? That's really interesting because I think people often assume they're kind of very cynical, modern cash cows for musical artists like Abba or whatever, where you're just cashing in on your back catalogue.
21:11 Speaker 06 Yeah, they were musical cynical cash cows when you had in-house writers.
21:18 Speaker 05 Remember Amber Jen.
21:19 Speaker 06 It's kind of an interesting thing because if you already owned the rights to the songs from a musical you already produced, why would Do not reuse them again. But what's important about that is that it brings people who are maybe not excited by what they think of as musical theatre and music into musicals. But we have a real diversity of material. We have things like Spring Awakening, Le Man Miranda's first musical in the heights, which was a surprise success.
21:41 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
21:42 Speaker 06 And an interesting example of theatre that was subsidised in the States where most theatre is commercially funded. Things like The Book of Mormon and Avenue Q pressing the boundaries of what is irreverent and what isn't. But we also have this massive wind of films that did not have musical theatre elements becoming musicals. So Billy Elliot is the obvious example for the UK audience, but Legally Blonde, Mean Girls.
22:04 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
22:05 Speaker 06 There's a lot, um, the American Psycho is an interesting outlier. But so there's, there's lots of this.
22:09 Greg Jenner? I've not even heard of that.
22:11 Speaker 06 Groundhog Day.
22:13 Greg Jenner? And then obviously Wicked is a massive hit as well.
22:16 Speaker 06 Yes, absolutely. So Wicked, I think it's fascinating that The Wizard of Oz is peppered the whole way through musical theatre history.
22:22 Greg Jenner? I was gonna say, nineteen oh two we started.
22:23 Speaker 06 We started in nineteen oh two. We then have the, the switch to Technicolor, which leads to Disney then making Snow White and kicks off all of our animated musicals. We have The Wiz, which is a really significant landmark in black authored musicals post civil rights. And the film becomes really significant. And then we move forwards into Wicked. And interestingly, then Andrew Lloyd Webber's reality TV shows where we hunt for Dorothy.
22:48 Greg Jenner? Yeah.
22:48 Speaker 06 So there is this sort of massive.
22:50 Speaker 05 I missed that.
22:51 Greg Jenner? Not, not hunting her like literally.
22:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, like, oh, yeah.
22:55 Greg Jenner? That'd be amazing, like The Running Man, but with Dorothy.
22:59 Speaker 06 The musical theatre X factor.
23:04 Speaker 06 But it's very interesting. So Wicked, but Wicked is a great example of taking what was an adult book and pitching it for teenagers. There was a definite attempt, a bit like in the sixties, to bring in new young family audiences back in the success of the Disney musical to other musicals. So we have Wicked, which is very traditional in lots of ways. And that prefaces the success of something like Hamilton. And Hamilton takes this kind of full circle as a musical that not only transcends sort of the social political context. Text of musicals, but also goes back into popular music. And, you know, becomes the first cast album to reach number one on the Billboard rap chart.
23:43 Greg Jenner? So Desiree, final thoughts. You send your regards to Broadway. Have we convinced you of the joys of singing?
23:48 Speaker 05 Yes, please remember me to Harold Square.
23:52 Speaker 05 Particularly that Macy's. This has been amazing. Thank you so much for teaching me about stuff that I now miss. Because I didn't understand it the first time. And now letting me know I can't whinge about a jukebox musical because they are basically the backbone of musicals throughout the entire commercial practice.
24:11 Greg Jenner? Yeah, there's, there's nothing new under the sun. Often on this show, we're always like, yeah, history is, we've done it before. The nuance window.
24:24 Greg Jenner? Okay, well, it's time now for the nuance window. This is where Desiree and I enjoy our intermission ice creams and Dr. Hannah gets two minutes onstage to sing us something we need to know. Take it away, Dr. Hannah.
24:34 Speaker 06 Okay, something I think we haven't covered is musicals rely on communicating plot and character really quickly, so they work in shortcuts. And because of the number of elements that most musicals contain, musical theatre creators have kind of developed a vocabulary to tell us what we need to know simply and succinctly. So the company might pause onstage and a spotlight actor will appear in a contrasting colour, probably covered in sequins. The action is paused. We know that this is our main character and we don't have to process where they fit into the story any further. On the same basis, we have things like dance sequences that reveal dreams and introspections.
25:11 Speaker 06 But in musicals from Brigadoon in the 1940s through to like The Lion King, choreography also covers action that's really hard to stage and chase scenes. We have types of song. You mentioned earlier the I want song, the love duet, and these tell us about the character's emotions and motivations. We also have these establishing numbers that explain the musical's location and their plot. And they prevent us from having to think about specifics while we're enjoying all the other things musicals have to offer. Wicked and Hamilton are really interesting examples because they begin by telling you how the story ends and then they also introduce key. Characters and narrative. So we are kind of wrapped up in comfort five minutes in. We know who the characters are. We know what the key content is. We can just enjoy what
25:56 Speaker 06 we are consuming. All of that makes musicals really exceptionally accessible to a broad audience. And that is one of the things that musical theatre has in comparison to other art forms. It accesses all walks of life. It also means that musicals that are successful tend to be written by people who are in musicals in other parts of their career, are connected to musical theatre history and know this vocabulary before they get into the process of writing. The complexity of this vocabulary then is that the amalgamation of ideas leads to musicals trading in stereotypes. And it can also allow us to have a limited imagination about how we stage things and what musicals might sound like. The challenge,
26:39 Speaker 06 I suppose, then is that the creative efforts of lots of people over decades and centuries who've made the musical what it is can become invisible in this product that we think is a very simple thing to make.
26:51 Greg Jenner? Lovely. Thank you so much. Desiree, any thoughts on that?
26:54 Speaker 05 There's something really amazing about this because there is a microcosm for like how things could work, where it's like in theatre, the bottom line is that the show need must go on. Everyone's got to find the most creative, cost effective way to make the thing come together and happen. But also hearing your argument about you do need to do it quickly economically also means that the things that get cut are often some of the most sort of like damaging things that we probably needed to explore in the first place. It is a really great metaphor for how we could sort of do life and capitalism, but then it does involve a lot of nepotism.
27:33 Greg Jenner? Listener, for more musical chat with Desiree, check out our episodes on Paul Robeson, Josephine Baker, and also Pythagoras, because we talked briefly about-
27:40 Speaker 05 Oh, it was fantastic.
27:41 Greg Jenner? We talked about his octave stuff.
27:42 Speaker 05 Yes.
27:42 Greg Jenner? For a rousing encore on Black American culture, we've got a lovely episode on the Harlem Renaissance, which I really enjoyed. And remember, if you've enjoyed the podcast, please leave us a review, share the show with your friends, subscribe to Your Dead to Me on BBC Sounds so you never miss an episode. But I'd just like to say a huge thank you to our guests in history corner. We have the wonderful Dr Hannah T. Risingham Robbins from the University of Nottingham. Thank you, Hannah.
28:02 Speaker 06 Thanks so much for having me.
28:04 Greg Jenner? And in Comedy Corner, we had the brilliant Desiree Birch. Thank you, Desiree.
28:07 Speaker 05 Surely you should ask your listeners to leave you a musical review if they like this episode.
28:11 Greg Jenner? Hey, if people want to sing their reviews, I'm open to it. And to you, lovely listener, join me next time as we stage revival of another forgotten historical masterpiece. But for now, I'm off to go and perform a one-man version of Frozen in My Garden Shirt until the Disney lawyer shut me down. Bye.
28:35 Speaker 07 Hello, I'm Robin Ince. And I'm Brian Cox. And this is the Infinite Monkey Hedgerow. He was unable to write a funny joke for the introduction. That's amazing. The new series of The Infinite Monkey Cage. Science with funny bits. Science with bits. Funny science plus bits. So the reason that the Neanderthals died out, you're claiming, is because they weren't astronomers?
29:01 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly. That's why. This is how we investigate cybercrime. We look for the yachts.
29:07 Speaker 07 The new series of The Infinite Monkey Cage. From BBC Radio 4, listen now on BBC Sounds.
29:17 Speaker 02 It was the first dinosaur ever to be scientifically named.
29:21 Speaker 05 And he came up with an animal that was about 40 foot long.
29:24 Speaker 02 A profound discovery that led to paleontology as we know it today.
29:29 Speaker 05 Impossible monsters, these giant, weird reptilian creatures. This was like a thunderbolts.
29:36 Speaker 02 Join me, Misha Glennie, and my three guests for In Our Time. On this episode, Megalosaurus. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Leif Erikson (Radio Edit) Next Happy Christmas from Greg and the team! Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated