UNSOLVED: The Murder of Roberta "Bobbie" Miller (New Hampshire)

In the fall of 2010, Roberta “Bobbie” Miller was starting over. She had a new home in Gilford, New Hampshire, she was back in school, and she was making plans for the life ahead of her. Then, on Halloween weekend, Bobbie and her dog, Sport, were shot and killed inside that home. There were circumstances that seemed to point suspicion in one direction. But as the years passed, some members of Bobbie’s own family began looking somewhere else entirely.

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:01Kylie Low?

  There's something about being out in nature that makes the world feel a little quieter. But sometimes even the most peaceful places have stories that refuse to stay hidden. That's what my friend Delia Diambra explores on Park Predators. Each week, she investigates true crime cases set against the world's most beautiful landscapes. Going beyond the headlines, Delia speaks with loved ones, digs through records, and sometimes visits the places where the stories unfolded. If you're ready to uncover the mysteries that linger beneath breathtaking scenery, listen to Park Predators every Tuesday wherever you get your podcasts.

• 0:40Kylie Low?

  In the fall of 2010, Roberta Bobbie Miller was starting over. She had a new home in Guilford, New Hampshire. She was back in school, and she was making plans for the life ahead of her. Then, on Halloween weekend, Bobbie and her dog, Sport, were shot and killed inside that home. There were circumstances that seemed to point suspicion in one direction. But as the years passed, some members of Bobbie's own family began looking somewhere else entirely. No one has ever been charged with Bobby's murder. When I spoke with her brother for the first time in 2024, he made it clear how deeply frustrated the family had become

• 1:24Kylie Low?

  by the lack of attention and resources devoted to her case. But now, nearly 16 years later, New Hampshire's expanded cold case unit has an investigator specifically assigned to it. And Bobby's family is offering a new $56,000 reward for information that finally leads them to the truth. I'm Kylie Low, and this is the case of Roberta Bobbie Miller on Dark Down East.

• 2:03Kylie Low?

  Roberta Dionne Miller, or Bobby to everyone who knew and loved her, was born and raised in the Manchester suburb of Bedford, New Hampshire. She was one of six children, five girls and a boy. Bobby's brother Ken told me that growing up in a house of girls meant the rules were pretty strict. But Bobby knew how to fly under the radar.

• 2:25Speaker 01

  My father was very strict and had strict rules. And if he said be home by 10 o'clock at night, that meant be home by five minutes of 10, but not five past 10. And so Bobby was real good about that. She was always home on time. And as a result, scored some brownie points with my father. But what my parents didn't know is that after they went to bed, Bobby would then sneak out the window and go back out. And we all got a big chuckle out of this because the window she would sneak out was the bathroom window that was right next to my parents' room. And I don't know how she did it. She never got caught, and my parents never knew it.

• 3:07Speaker 01

  Until years later, we were having a family gathering, and we were talking about some of the stuff we did. And one of us said something about Bobby sneaking out the window. And my parents were quite surprised to find that their little angel was doing something like that.

• 3:27Kylie Low?

  She was a creative soul and an adventurous spirit. When Bobby wasn't hiking with her rescue dog, a yellow lab named Sport, she was creating beautiful works of stained glass art. She was also a loving mother to her son Jonathan and daughter Jennifer. Although they were all grown up and out of the house, Bobby would do anything for those kids. Bobby had spent much of her life as a stay-at-home mom, while her husband Gary Miller started up a few successful car dealerships in New Hampshire and Maine. She supported Gary through the ups and downs of owning a business and even worked at the dealerships alongside him on occasion. They were a team.

• 4:09Kylie Low?

  However, around their 25th anniversary, Gary and Bobby's marriage began to crumble. They filed for divorce in 2007.

• 4:19Speaker 01

  Well, it was a very bitter divorce. They were pretty well off financially. And of course, that just causes problems when you're trying to split things up, I would say.

• 4:32Kylie Low?

  It would be a tumultuous, multi-year process. But the final divorce decree in August of 2010 was like a reset button for Bobby.

• 4:42Speaker 01

  They had been divorced for a couple of months, and she seemed to be moving on pretty well. She had moved out of the house that they had lived in. They were selling. The house was for sale. But she had bought a new home in Guilford and was settling in, seemed to be very happy there, and was ready to move on with the next chapter of her life.

• 5:04Kylie Low?

  Separating from Gary unraveled the only life she'd known. Now, she was single again at 54 years old, but Bobby was finding her footing. She'd lived in Wolfboro, New Hampshire with Gary and the kids for nearly as long as they'd been married. But soon after the divorce was finalized, Bobby bought herself a house in Guilford, about 35 minutes away. It was a modest, single-story ranch-style home with a garage that faced the Pheasant Ridge Country Club on a quiet rural road. In the early fall of 2010, she started taking classes at Granite State College in pursuit of her business degree. And she was slowly turning her new house into a true home,

• 5:47Kylie Low?

  with plans to convert the garage into a studio for her stained glass projects. Bea Lewis reports for The Concord Monitor that Bobby's daughter Jennifer talked to her mother sometime over the weekend of October 30, 2010. During that phone call, Bobby was all abuzz about another house project. She wanted to build flower boxes to hang on the front of the house under the living room window. She thought it would brighten the whole place up. On Sunday that weekend, Bobbie talked to her mother Madeline on the phone, and she said she was heading to the store to get everything she needed for the window box project that afternoon. According to reporting by Todd Feathers for the Union Leader,

• 6:28Kylie Low?

  Bobby was last seen that day buying building supplies at a nearby hardware store. But Bobby would never get the chance to finish her project. That same night, the home where she was building her new life would soon become the scene of Bobby's death.

• 6:48Kylie Low?

  On the afternoon of Monday, November 1, 2010, a 911 call requested help at 123 Country Club Road in Guilford. Police responded to the address by 4:30 PM, and soon the whole road was shut down. Inside the house, they found Bobbie Miller's lifeless body on the kitchen floor. Investigators quickly realized that they were dealing with a homicide.

• 7:14Speaker 01

  Early on, they really didn't say anything to us. They were very tight-lipped. They did tell me the circumstances of how Bobby was killed. She was in her kitchen, and she had been working on some... She was actually building some window boxes. So she was going in and out of the house to her garage, doing some stuff. And it was Halloween evening, and she was shot twice. She was wearing a hoodie, and she was shot in the face and throat area the first time. And I was told that the hood captured some of the blast.

• 7:56Speaker 01

  And then she fell on the floor and was shot again in the back of the head.

• 8:01Kylie Low?

  Bobby's dog, Sport, was found dead in the house, too, also a victim of apparent gunshot wounds. There's little information about what police learned in those first few days after Bobby and Sport were discovered. We know that Bobby and her dog were shot inside her home, and there were no signs of forced entry. And it had been a little ambiguous at first, but Paula Tracy reports in the Union Leader that investigators narrowed down the time of the murder to between 4:00 PM on October 31, 2010, and 5:00 PM on November 1, around the time she was found. Investigators were in the process of obtaining Bobby's phone records

• 8:43Kylie Low?

  and expected results from forensic testing on evidence pulled from her house. But what that evidence was, I don't know. Many of Bobby's friends and family were questioned over the course of a week, but Assistant Attorney General Benjamin Agadi wouldn't say if investigators had uncovered any clue as to who might be responsible for Bobby's murder yet. He told Catherine Marchak of the Union Leader, "I can't say we have some specific suspects or persons of interest. We have a lot of people we need to talk to." But it doesn't take a seasoned detective to guess at who was at the top of the list for questioning. You know the old true crime trope, "The husband did it,"

• 9:26Kylie Low?

  or, in this case, "the ex-husband." Bobby and Gary Miller's volatile divorce was a big, bright red flag. In fact, Bobby and Gary were due back in court on yet another divorce-related issue the very same week she was killed.

• 9:45Kylie Low?

  So let's talk about the ex-husband. Gary Miller was a car dealer and once owned a number of dealerships, including Miller Chevrolet in Wolfboro and Miller Ford in Sanford, Maine. According to reporting by Harrison Haas in the New Hampshire Union Leader, Bobby and Gary filed for divorce on September 19, 2007, citing irreconcilable differences, which I'll get to later. But the divorce was not granted until three years later, on August 13, 2010. And even though it was finalized, Gary and Bobby were still in court over Bobby's alleged failure to comply with the divorce order. Roger Amstyn reports for the Union Leader that, as part of the divorce decree,

• 10:30Kylie Low?

  Bobby was ordered to pay close to $75,000 in her share of taxes due, but Gary alleged that she failed to pay up. In addition to the 75 grand in taxes, Gary wanted Bobby to pay for roughly $6,100 in legal fees that were, as he argued, the direct result of Bobby's litigation tactics. Basically, if she hadn't dragged this out, he wouldn't have to pay a lawyer, and so now it's on her to cover the costs. The week of her murder, that Thursday, November 4, Bobby was due to face a contempt of court hearing in Carroll County Superior Court, and she intended to represent herself for the proceedings.

• 11:13Kylie Low?

  She'd filed a response to the motion a few weeks earlier, claiming that she didn't pay her share of the taxes because she simply didn't have the money. But Gary's attorney, James Ogerchuck, challenged that claim, alleging in another filing that Bobby had somehow squandered upwards of $1 million as the divorce dragged on. Gary's attorney argued that Bobby was intentionally dragging out the proceedings, running up Gary's legal fees, and trying to put Gary through an emotional and financial wringer. Gary's attorney wrote in the contempt of court motion, quote, "Of the $928,051 that she has received over the course of this divorce,

• 11:54Kylie Low?

  she has refused to itemize anything more than $100,000 in legal fees and $110,000 in personal taxes, totaling $210,000. This leaves over $718,000 left unaccounted for by Ms. Miller," end quote. But in her response to the motion, Bobby wrote, quote, "The funds Mr. Ogerchuck refers to in his contempt motion are assets distributed to both Gary and I over the last three and a half years. Gary's funds, I am sure, have gone to the same place mine has: taxes due to his Sanford Ford dealership business, over $100,000 in lawyer fees, over $110,000 in personal taxes on these funds,

• 12:37Kylie Low?

  mortgages, real estate taxes, college tuition for my son and I, lawsuits on marital home from the town of Wolfboro, two tractor repairs to maintain marital home and other properties, car payments, health insurance and bills, along with living expenses while I have been unemployed for almost a year. Yes, I have no counsel. I have spent over $100,000 on this divorce to date, which is overwhelming. I have no more funds to pay outrageous costs to lawyers who prolong this agreed-upon settlement. I am unemployed with no income, no alimony, no support, 54 years old with a high school education, now attending college full-time to try and support myself. I am living on $500 a month

• 13:21Kylie Low?

  in the most disastrous economic times in decades," end quote. These filings are just a glimpse into what the three years of their divorce must have been like: the back and forth over money and assets and real estate, racking up billable hours with expensive attorneys, and separating two lives that had been interwoven for almost three decades. An acrimonious divorce sure sounds like the foundation of a convincing motive, right? Well, there's something else I haven't even told you about yet, something that happened a few days before Bobby was killed. Depending on what you think is true, it might make the motive even stronger.

• 14:05Kylie Low?

  Gary and Bobby had once owned a camp together just over the New Hampshire border in Acton, Maine. It was a cozy three-season cottage on Great East Lake, and Gary had bought out Bobby's interest in the property as part of the divorce settlement. Just two days before Bobby's murder, that cottage in Maine burned to the ground. According to reporting in the Laconia Daily Sun, the Acton Fire Department received a call of an active fire at 111 Katy Lane around 9:30 on Friday, October 29. It took nearly five hours to extinguish the blaze, but when it was finally out at 2:30 a.m., the one-story cottage was a total loss.

• 14:48Kylie Low?

  When the Maine State Fire Marshal's Office began their full investigation in the morning, they found that a flammable liquid had been poured on to the exterior of the cottage. It was an act of arson. Let me run you through a theory, if you haven't already assembled a similar one in your head. Hypothetically speaking, is it possible that Bobby, bitter about the divorce and frustrated by the ongoing financial and emotional toll it was taking on her, went to the cabin she once shared with her ex-husband, doused it with some sort of accelerant, and watched as the match she tossed ignited the entire thing into a destructive blaze? And then, hypothetically,

• 15:31Kylie Low?

  when Gary finds his lakeside cabin in smoldering rubble, he goes to find his ex-wife and kills her in retaliation, putting an end to their drawn-out legal battles?

• 15:43Kylie Low?

  Hypothetically, that whole scenario is possible. It's a theory, though not necessarily one the investigation was considering. Police hadn't said either way. According to Harrison Haas's reporting for the Concord Monitor, Assistant AG Benjamin Agati said that authorities hadn't conclusively determined whether the fire at the cottage in Acton and Bobby's murder were connected, but they hadn't ruled it out either. The arson case was ongoing in Maine as the homicide probe continued in New Hampshire. Ken and the rest of Bobby's immediate family remained hopeful that investigators would be able to solve this case quickly. But an entire year passed, and no arrests were made.

• 16:28Speaker 01

  Now, in the beginning, of course, I mean, we'd never been through anything like this. We were all in shock. They deposed all of the family members, and they asked us a bunch of questions about Bobby and her children and her ex-husband and whatnot. But of course, we figured that they were going to get to the bottom of this. I mean, you watch these TV shows, you know, it's a joke. It's not like television at all.

• 16:52Kylie Low?

  After a year, the confidence that Ken and Bobby's family once had in investigators was waning.

• 17:00Speaker 01

  I mean, we were probably a year into it when we realized that, you know, there were problems. We would meet with the detectives, and we would have a whole list of questions. We would email these questions to the detective, and they'd set up a meeting with the AG so that we could go in and speak with them and see what kind of questions they could answer. And basically, they never answered any questions. It was always, "We can't tell you that, we can't tell you that, we can't tell you that." It was like a broken record. We basically didn't get any answers.

• 17:33Kylie Low?

  The only recourse Bobby's family felt like they had at the time was to keep her case in the public eye. They held a press conference ahead of the one-year anniversary in 2011. Ken, their mother Madeline, and Bobby's daughter Jennifer gathered with other family members at Mount Major State Park in Alton. It was one of Bobby's favorite places for a hike with sport, and where her family had scattered both of their ashes a year earlier. During the press conference, Jennifer announced that their family was offering a $50,000 reward for information, leading to the arrest and prosecution of the person or people responsible for her mother's murder. They also announced the launch of Bobby's Soup.com,

• 18:18Kylie Low?

  a website once dedicated to raising awareness and sharing information about Bobby and her case. The site got its name from Bobby's favorite spinach soup that she asked her mother to make every year for her birthday. There were scans of the handwritten recipe for the soup on the website. Though the website is no longer active, I was able to access it through the Internet Archive, so I'll share the scans with you at darkdowneast.com. But beyond the soup recipe, the website also included a statement from Bobby's family. It reads in part, quote, "This violent act, which we believe was both personal and planned, remains unsolved with minimal leads. Although the local and state police are working to solve her murder,

• 19:03Kylie Low?

  resources dedicated specifically to Bobby's case are extremely limited." It continues, "Without enough manpower devoted to her case, it's unlikely her killer will be brought to justice without our help, and yours," end quote. Bobby's family urged those with information to come forward, especially anyone who may have spoken to Bobby between 4:00 p.m. that Sunday, October 31, and 5:00 o'clock on Monday, November 1, 2010. The press conference concluded with bowls of Bobby's favorite spinach soup handed out to reporters and other attendees. I asked Ken what he was thinking at that point, what theories he was weighing in his head at the time.

• 19:46Kylie Low?

  Because when investigators aren't answering your questions, you're gonna try to fill in the blanks and guess at possible scenarios yourself, right? Even a year in, and with no confirmation one way or another, every time Bobby's murder is mentioned in the media, there comes with it a summary of her messy divorce from Gary Miller. So was Ken thinking what everyone else was thinking?

• 20:10Speaker 01

  As human beings, you know, if two people were fighting and one of them got hurt, well, of course, you're gonna think it was the person they were fighting with that did it. That's a natural knee-jerk reaction, and of course, we thought that. You know, in the beginning, we were all in shock. Of course, we thought that. But as time goes on and you digest things and you learn a little bit more, all of a sudden, you realize, wait a minute, you know, that's not what happened at all.

• 20:40Kylie Low?

  We're about to flip this entire case on its head.

• 20:50Speaker 02

  The real cost of a break-in isn't your valuables. It's the feeling that your home stopped being safe. SimpliSafe keeps danger away from your family with three layers of protection. One, smart AI cameras and live US-based agents help stop intruders before they break in. Two, we sound the alarm at points of entry. Three, our agents request emergency response. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 60% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com/truecrime. Outdoor deterrence plans start at $49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com/licenses for alarm license information.

• 21:20Kylie Low?

  Every small town has a local legend. The house no one drives past after dark? Or the woods that hold secrets? Every October, I like to add something a little more spooky to my playlist. Stories that blur the line between what's imagined and what might be waiting in the dark. Full Body Chills returns with more strange coincidences, unsettling confessions, and stories where danger may be closer than it seems. Listen to Full Body Chills all October long, wherever you get your podcasts.

• 21:59Speaker 01

  Of course, in the beginning, you know, the family, you know, of course you look at the ex-husband, that's, it's just normal. That's what you do. But it didn't take us too long to figure out it, it wasn't Gary. He had nothing to do with it. He was very, very cooperative with the police. Has really worked hard with me and my family trying to solve this since that day.

• 22:24Kylie Low?

  Gary Miller has never been publicly named a suspect in Bobby's murder. Investigators also haven't said in so many words that Gary isn't a suspect. But as far as Ken is concerned, Gary has proven to him and other members of Bobby's family that he is just as shocked and shaken by Bobby's murder as anyone else. And as Ken said, Gary has cooperated with the investigation since day one, as far as he knows. But there was someone else that Ken claims wasn't as helpful when police came knocking.

• 22:57Speaker 01

  Let's talk about her son for a minute.

• 23:01Kylie Low?

  Bobby's son, Jonathan Miller.

• 23:04Speaker 01

  Bobby and John were very, very close. It's like they never cut the umbilical cord.

• 23:11Kylie Low?

  Bobby would do anything for either of her children. But Ken tells me she was especially protective of Jonathan, even when he was getting himself into trouble. According to reporting by the Laconia Daily Sun, Jonathan had several run-ins with the law in his late teens and early twenties. In 2005, when he was 18 years old, Jonathan was indicted on two Class B felony counts of burglary for breaking into a sandwich shop and a paint store in Wolfboro. In 2007, he pleaded guilty to four counts of burglary. I can't tell the length of his sentence or how much time Jonathan actually served on those charges. There's just a one-off line in a Laconia Daily Sun article about how his sentences

• 23:55Kylie Low?

  were deferred for a period of time. Jonathan also had multiple traffic violations, a reckless driving conviction, and he had been incarcerated with the Carroll County Department of Corrections on three separate occasions at the time. One while awaiting trial for the burglary charges, one for disobeying a police officer, and a five-day stint for a probation violation and simple assault.

• 24:20Speaker 01

  John was constantly in trouble. From the time he was eight years old, he was always in trouble. And I think that Bobby and Gary did not agree on parenting. And I think that's what led to the divorce.

• 24:33Kylie Low?

  Ken believes it's possible that the irreconcilable differences cited in their divorce included a difference in opinion on what to do about Jonathan.

• 24:43Speaker 01

  With Bobby, you know, we, as the family, we, we never said anything bad about John. We knew that if we said anything about John, we are crossing a line. She would protect him to the very end.

• 24:57Kylie Low?

  Jonathan was 23 years old when his mother was murdered. He lived nearby in a house that he bought with money Bobby had loaned him. And though it wouldn't be reported until years later, it was Jonathan who found Bobby dead in her kitchen that day and called 911. Ken claims that Jonathan hasn't participated in the family's efforts to find answers in Bobby's death. Notably, he did not attend the press conference on the one-year anniversary of her murder. It turns out that a few weeks before that gathering in his mother's honor, Jonathan was arrested on charges of being a felon in possession of a firearm.

• 25:41Kylie Low?

  The Laconia Daily Sun reports that Guilford Police and a New Hampshire state trooper obtained a search warrant for Jonathan's home and vehicles following a tip that he was in possession of a firearm. During the search, police recovered a 45-caliber semi-automatic pistol with magazines and ammunition. Since he had a felony conviction to his name, Jonathan wasn't legally permitted to have a gun, and so Guilford Police arrested him on September 1st, 2011. Police quickly squashed the speculation that Jonathan's firearm possession was somehow connected to his mother's murder. A statement by Guilford Police following his arrest reads in part, quote, "This investigation

• 26:24Kylie Low?

  is separate from any other incident that the Guilford Police has been involved with up to this point," end quote. At the time, investigators hadn't released any details about the kind of firearm used in Bobby's murder. But more details about how and when Jonathan obtained the gun more or less cleared up that it wasn't the murder weapon. According to court filings obtained by the Laconia Daily Sun, Jonathan bought the 45-caliber Glock handgun on or about August 11th, 2011, from a former Gilmanton police sergeant named Dennis Rector. Dennis had never met Jonathan before, and he didn't know anything about him until a

• 27:06Kylie Low?

  friend told Dennis that Jonathan's mother had been murdered the previous year, and he might be a felon. So Dennis called Guilford Police to report the gun sale, and a few days later, Jonathan was arrested. Before Jonathan went to trial on those possession charges the following year, Assistant County Attorney Stacy Kalin wanted any details about Bobby's murder excluded from the testimony. She believed it would risk unfair prejudice and possibly mislead or confuse the jury. But Jonathan's lawyer actually wanted the jury to hear about Bobby's murder. Jonathan's defense appeared to be that since his mother was killed, he was in fear for his life, and he bought the gun to protect himself.

• 27:51Kylie Low?

  Attorney Daniel Deutsch argued in response to the motion, quote, "While the defendant's purpose in acquiring a firearm for protection is not in itself a defense to the felon in possession charge, testimony concerning that purpose is appropriate in this case," end quote. Before it ever got to the point of testimony, though, Jonathan agreed to a capped plea deal of one to three years with possible work release. Now, there was one line from the Assistant County Attorney's motion that really sticks out to me. Kalin writes, quote, "The murder remains unsolved.

• 28:31Kylie Low?

  Upon information and belief, the defendant Jonathan Miller may have been, at least at one time, a suspect in the murder investigation," end quote. "Upon information and belief" is a legal turn of phrase that basically means it's not a known fact, but they either heard the information somewhere or suspect it to be true. And to be clear, investigators have never said if Jonathan is a person of interest or suspect in his mother's murder. Yes, Jonathan had a criminal history. He was convicted of that firearm possession charge.

• 29:11Kylie Low?

  But what could possibly be the motive for Jonathan to kill the woman who birthed him and who would do anything for him? In Ken's view, the murder was about money, but not Gary and Bobby's fights over finances in divorce court. He thinks Jonathan had a lot to gain from his mother's death.

• 29:33Speaker 01

  Well, he got his house paid off, free and clear. Bobby had just bought him a house, and upon her death, he got paid off for that. So he got that free and clear. We believe there was a bunch of cash missing from her house. And also, Bobby and Gary had annuity funds that came to fruition shortly after her death. Her share was $750,000, and John got to split that with his sister. Sounds like motive to me. Of course, that's just one man's opinion.

• 30:02Kylie Low?

  Around the same time as Jonathan's conviction in July of 2012, the new owners of Bobby's home in Guilford were out doing yard work when they came across a spent shotgun shell. Bea Lewis reports in The Concord Monitor that the homeowner called police to report the finding, and investigators came out to photograph and collect the plastic shell. With permission from the owners, police then continued searching the property around the house. Despite the discovery, Ken Dion said at the time that he hadn't heard of any updates in the case, and it was unclear whether the shell casing was determined to be related to Bobby's murder. Again, police didn't say either way. At that point, it had been almost two years

• 30:46Kylie Low?

  since Bobby and Sport were murdered by an unknown killer. Though investigators still hadn't made any arrests, Assistant AG Benjamin Agati insisted that it was not a cold case, and the investigation was following a number of possible leads. According to reporting by Dan Dufort in The Union Leader, when asked if Gary Miller was a suspect, Agati responded, "I can't specifically say anyone is a suspect at this point in the investigation. We're hoping that with the passage of time and with relationships changing, someone will feel that now they can come forward with more information." Meanwhile,

• 31:30Kylie Low?

  Bobby's family was able to increase the reward for information to $53,000 thanks to donations, and they were planning another memorial hike up Mount Major on November 3, 2012. Dogs and their humans were invited to join. Ken and Bobby's family waited for these public awareness efforts to pay off, for police to get a tip that put an end to their waiting, and for investigators to answer their questions. But none of it happened. Two more years passed, and in 2014, investigators released more information about Bobby's murder, including details of the murder weapon and something they found in Bobby's house that day.

• 32:14Kylie Low?

  As the fourth anniversary approached in 2014, Bobby's death certificate revealed previously undisclosed details about her murder. It lists her date of death as October 31, and states that she died almost instantaneously from a shotgun blast to her head and neck with perforations to her skull, brain, carotid artery, and lungs. The Laconia Daily Sun reports that police confirmed the same shotgun was used to kill her dog. It was the first time any details about the murder weapon were made public, so it makes those shells found by the new homeowners seem extremely relevant now.

• 32:57Kylie Low?

  The AG's office also disclosed that investigators had found $26,000 in cash in an undisclosed location, presumably at Bobby's house, but said that the cash did not appear to be related to the murder.

• 33:12Speaker 01

  We know she had a lot of cash in the house. We know what they found for cash. We don't know what they didn't find.

• 33:21Kylie Low?

  In other words, if Bobby had 26 grand in her house, it's possible she actually had even more than that. But how would anyone know it was missing? The new public information generated a few blips of media coverage, but it didn't change anything. There were still no arrests or answers. By 2015, a whole five years since they'd lost their mother, sister, and daughter, Bobby's family decided to try a new approach to generate attention and information in her still unsolved case.

• 34:00Kylie Low?

  Every small town has a local legend. The house no one drives past after dark? Or the woods that hold secrets? Every October, I like to add something a little more spooky to my playlist. Stories that blur the line between what's imagined and what might be waiting in the dark. Full Body Chills returns with more strange coincidences, unsettling confessions, and stories where danger may be closer than it seems. Listen to Full Body Chills all October long, wherever you get your podcasts.

• 34:39Kylie Low?

  The large billboard posted at the corner of Hatch Corner Road and Route 104 in Meredith, New Hampshire, was unmissable. The headline text seemed to shout at passing motorists. It read, "Who Killed My Daughter?" Below it was a color photo of Bobby posing with Sport at the summit of a mountain with the $53,000 reward for information printed in bold, black text against a bright yellow background. Ken spoke to Bea Lewis of The Concord Monitor at the time of the billboard's unveiling and said that he knew investigators were still actively working on her case, but they could only do so much with limited resources. Ken felt the only hope for his sister's case reaching a conclusion

• 35:24Kylie Low?

  was with the help of the public and their family's efforts to keep her name out there. The billboard stood in place with the same message for years. But in the summer of 2018, it was replaced with a mysterious new sign.

• 35:40Speaker 01

  I'm gonna say a controversial billboard showed up for a few days. And that billboard basically said I was murdered. It had a picture of my sister on it. Said I was murdered. Why won't my son take a polygraph with the New Hampshire State Police? That billboard was up for a few days, and I received a phone call from the billboard company telling me that that billboard had to come down. They asked me if I put that billboard up. I said I have no idea how that billboard got there, but I liked it. And they were upset. They said, "You gotta take that billboard down because we got a phone call from the police, and John Miller is complaining, and that billboard has to come down."

• 36:21Kylie Low?

  The apparently unauthorized sign was swiftly removed and replaced with the original billboard. According to Todd Feathers reporting in The Union Leader, no one would claim responsibility for the accusatory signage, but Jonathan Miller had an idea who did it. Jonathan said his uncle Ken had been pointing the finger at him for Bobby's death for years. He said in the previous year, he'd even sent Ken a cease and desist letter demanding he stop accusing him of the murder. He mentioned a possible lawsuit against Ken for the billboard, but he couldn't prove his uncle did it. Ken would not confirm for me how the billboard got there either. The billboard claimed

• 37:04Kylie Low?

  that Jonathan hasn't taken a polygraph test as part of the investigation, but Jonathan has said he did take one at his lawyer's office at some point and didn't think it was necessary to take one at the police station. So I'll say it once again. Jonathan Miller has never been identified as a suspect in Bobbie Miller's murder, nor has he been charged with any crimes in relation to her death. No one has. Her case remains unsolved to this day. Over the years, Bobby's case was shuffled from detective to detective and eventually transferred to the New Hampshire Cold Case Unit. Though Ken and his family had meetings with investigators throughout the years, when I first spoke with him in 2024,

• 37:49Kylie Low?

  he felt like they were being brushed aside and that cold cases weren't receiving the funding, staffing, or attention they needed to reach a point of closure. We had an eye-opening conversation about the issues he and other surviving family members were dealing with when it came to getting answers for their loved ones' cases in New Hampshire. Ken had become a voice not only for Bobby, but for other New Hampshire families too. In 2019, he supported Senate Bill 130, a proposal that would have added two attorneys and two state troopers dedicated to cold casework. According to the New Hampshire General Court's legislative history, the measure ultimately failed to become law and died on the table later that year.

• 38:32Speaker 01

  The gloves are off. I'm very frustrated with the state of New Hampshire. All the other cold case families, victims' families out there, they all feel the same way that my family does. It's all smoke and mirrors. They tell you and the public that you're doing certain things, but they are not. And the bottom line is there's no funding. There's no manpower. There's no funding.

• 38:55Kylie Low?

  Several families of New Hampshire's unsolved case victims, including Ken, gathered in Concord during the summer of 2023 to push for more attention, better communication, and greater resources for cold cases. They had asked to meet with Attorney General John Formella. He did not attend the gathering, but his office responded that the state was continuing to communicate privately with affected families and that Formella remained open to meeting with them individually or in smaller groups. For Ken, though, that didn't change how he viewed the situation.

• 39:30Speaker 01

  My sister's case, even though we've been told many times it's a solvable case, it will never be solved. You can't solve it if you don't work on it. There is nobody working on her case, and they're not working on anybody else's case.

• 39:46Kylie Low?

  When this episode first aired in 2024, that was essentially where things stood. Since then, New Hampshire has put more resources into its cold cases. Pat Grossmith reported for Manchester Inklink in August 2025 that new funding allowed the cold case unit to move to two full-time investigators. Todd Flanagan, a longtime Department of Justice investigator, began working cold cases full-time alongside Bruce Foramney, who had previously divided his time between cold cases and other responsibilities. By September 2026, Bob Martin of the Laconia Daily Sun reported that the unit was responsible for 128 cold cases statewide.

• 40:31Kylie Low?

  Each case had been paired with an investigator and a victim advocate, and six cases had been resolved since the funding increase in 2025. Bobby's case is among those receiving that dedicated attention. Deputy Chief Investigator Todd Flanagan is the investigator assigned to her case. Now, that doesn't mean investigators have announced a new break. No one has been arrested, and authorities have not publicly disclosed new forensic findings or named a suspect. But it is a different situation from the one Ken described when I spoke with him in 2024. On the 15th anniversary of Bobby's death in November 2025, her family stood alongside

• 41:13Kylie Low?

  members of the New Hampshire Cold Case Unit and once again asked the public for help. Rachel Watchman reported for the Concord Monitor that Bobby's daughter Jennifer, her sister Miki Moore, and her mother Madeline Blake attended the press conference. Bobby's former husband, Gary Miller, was there as well. Gary told reporters that he still wanted answers about what happened to Bobby, both for himself and for the family they shared. He also addressed their difficult divorce, saying that although their marriage ended badly, their relationship had not been physically violent. Cold Case Unit Chief R. Christopher Knowles also made clear that the investigation remains open.

• 41:57Kylie Low?

  According to Watchman's reporting, investigators are still hoping to hear from anyone who saw Bobby or had contact with her between 4:00 PM on October 31st and 5:00 PM on November 1st, 2010. The family has now also increased the reward. Up to $56,000 is now being offered for information that results in an arrest and prosecution. 16 years after Bobby and Sport were killed, there are still no answers about who walked into that house and took their lives. But there is now something Ken spent years asking for: dedicated resources to keep looking for them.

• 42:38Kylie Low?

  With an unsolved homicide, the unknowns far outweigh the facts. We're left guessing at some reasonable explanation for such a vicious and senseless crime. We sit here speculating on means, motive, and opportunity with only fuzzy circumstances to work with. In the case of Bobbie Miller, there's the long-running theory that we've talked about: the ex-husband did it. It goes something like, Gary and Bobby's marriage ended in a nasty divorce, so Gary put an end to their drawn-out legal battles and shot Bobby and her dog. And then, add in the fire at Gary's cottage in Maine—the arson is still under investigation, by the way.

• 43:19Kylie Low?

  And if you believe Bobby could have been the one to light the fire, that's even more motive for Gary. Could it be that simple? If there's one thing I've learned in this line of work, it's that nothing is ever really that simple. Ken insists Gary Miller had nothing to do with Bobby's murder. Ken and Gary remain in contact, and they've even teamed up to get answers themselves.

• 43:46Speaker 01

  Yeah, we talk constantly. We talk very, very often. We're always strategizing about how to solve this. We're always coming up with new questions for the detectives, which we never get answers to. And we're always looking for new leads, trying to interview people ourselves. And we've worked very hard on this, and we'll continue to do so.

• 44:09Kylie Low?

  As far as Ken's suggestion that Jonathan Miller could have killed his own mother, there's no publicly disclosed evidence that Jonathan had anything to do with her death. If Jonathan really did get that gun back in 2011 because he was in fear for his life while his mother's killer was still out there somewhere, the possibility remains that the person continues to walk free even now. I was unable to reach Jonathan for this episode myself, but Todd Feathers reports for the New Hampshire Union Leader that when asked if he killed his mom, Jonathan responded, "No," and then added, quote, "I was always a mama's boy, and I always will be," end quote.

• 44:53Kylie Low?

  If you have information about the 2010 unsolved homicide of Roberta Bobbie Miller, please contact the New Hampshire Cold Case Unit at 603-271-2663, or email [email protected]. You can also leave a tip via the link in the show description.

• 45:29Kylie Low?

  Thank you for listening to Dark Down East. You can find all source material for this case at darkdowneast.com. Be sure to follow the show on Instagram, @darkdowneast. This platform is for the families and friends who have lost their loved ones and for those who are still searching for answers. I'm not about to let those names or their stories get lost with time. I'm Kylie Low, and this is Dark Down East. Dark Down East is a production of Kylie Media and AudioChuck. I think Chuck would approve.

• 46:12Speaker 03

  If anyone wanted to commit a murder, up here would be the greatest place in the world to hide the body, but soon they'll find it.

• 46:20Speaker 04

  He acted friendly. He talked friendly. He sounded friendly. They all knew that I did the scary boogie stuff, and they said, "Maybe she'll find

• 46:30Speaker 05

  out where this girl is." I saw him, I backhanded her, pow! Listen to The Devil's Quarry, Season 2, in the Bone Valley feed, on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.