India Between Empires (Radio Edit)

Greg Jenner is joined in early modern India by historian Dr Jagjeet Lally and comedian Nish Kumar to learn all about the subcontinent’s dynamic 18th century. From the 16th century, the dominant power in India was the Mughal Empire. According to the traditional narrative, when the Mughals began to decline in the 18th century, the subcontinent descended into political chaos, and European trading powers – most notably the British East India Company – swooped in to take advantage and (in their words) restore order. But can we trust this story? In this episode, we look at India’s long 18th century not as a period of chaos, but one of dynamic transformation and exciting developments. Taking in the rise of new powers including the Marathas, the Rajputs and the Sikh Empire, and looking at changes in the economy, global trade, artistic patronage and gender relations, we explore what India was really like at this time. This is a radio edit of the original podcast episode. For the full-length version, please look further back in the feed. Hosted by: Greg Jenner Research by: Clara Chamberlain Written by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner Produced by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner Audio Producer: Steve Hankey Production Coordinator: Gill Huggett Senior Producer: Emma Nagouse Executive Editor: Philip Sellars

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

• 0:06Speaker 01

  Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake. Ready to cook pizza? No antibiotics ever chicken wings. And sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.

• 0:34Speaker 02

  Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.

• 1:09Greg Jenner?

  Hello and welcome to You're Dead to Me, the Radio 4 comedy podcast that takes history seriously. My name is Greg Jenner. I'm a public historian, author and broadcaster. And today we are joining a trading caravan and trekking all the way back to the 18th century to learn about Indian political and cultural life in this particular period. And to help us, we have two very special guests in history corner. He's Associate Professor of the History of Early Modern and Colonial India at UCL. He's a historian of economic and material life in early modern India with a special interest in trade. You might have read one of his wonderful books, India and the Silk Roads, or India and the Early Modern World. It's Dr Jagmeet Lali. Welcome Jagmeet. Hi Greg. Delighted to have you here and in comedy corner. He's a comedian, presenter and podcaster.

• 1:52Greg Jenner?

  You'll have seen him all over the TV, on The Mash Report, QI, Mock the Week, Live at the Apollo, the best ever series of Taskmaster, no arguments. He's also the co-host of Pod Save the UK and a frequent guest on the Bugle podcast and Radio 4's News Quiz. He's very busy. And you might have seen one of his award-winning stand-up shows, including his most recent Nish Don't Kill My Vibe. It's Nish Kumar. Welcome, Nish.

• 2:10Speaker 04

  Genuinely, I'm so excited. I will say, I've put myself in a bit of a difficult position here because I did study history to an undergraduate level. So like, there's a lot of pressure on me to at least loosely sound like I know what I'm talking about. And I am feeling the genuine hot flush of panic. Just for the benefit of listeners, there's a circular seating arrangement and it is genuinely giving me flashbacks to feeling underprepared in history seminars.

• 2:42Greg Jenner?

  How are you on 18th century India?

• 2:44Speaker 04

  Basically, I've got some awareness of 1857. The uprisings and how that is.

• 2:49Speaker 05

  That's not the 18th century.

• 2:50Speaker 04

  Oh my god, I've got it wrong immediately.

• 2:53Greg Jenner?

  Get out, Nish.

• 2:54Speaker 05

  This is gonna be fun.

• 2:55Speaker 04

  This is gonna be an absolute disaster. I've got almost no knowledge of the 18th century in India. I know the white man turned up and was up to his usual malarkey.

• 3:06Greg Jenner?

  Guilty, yeah.

• 3:08Speaker 04

  The only bit of it that I, this specific Indian history I studied, we did a bit of Moghul stuff because, you know, the British.

• 3:14Speaker 05

  Warmer, you're getting warmer.

• 3:15Speaker 04

  In the British state education curriculum, we like to do stuff before the British turned up, just to set the scene that it was bad. And we didn't make things that much worse in the grand scheme of things. And then I did a lot of stuff about the partition of India.

• 3:30Greg Jenner?

  Okay, yeah. So, what do you know?

• 3:37Greg Jenner?

  This brings us to the first segment of the podcast, it's called the So What Do You Know? This is where I have a go at guessing what you, our lovely listener, will know about today's subject. This one might be a bit of an unfamiliar topic. 18th century India usually only comes up for British audiences through TV dramas, about the East India Company specifically, like the Tom Hardy show Taboo, or the recent one, Nautilus. If you're a fan of Indian cinema, maybe you've seen the films Panipat, about the 1761 battle between the Maratha and the Afghan army, or there's Bajirao Mastani, a tragic love story set at the Maratha court, or there's Karila Varma Pasashi Rajah, featuring the king of Khatam and his fight against the East India Company. I don't know if I'm murdering these lovely words, but I'm trying my best. But what was really going on in India in this period?

• 4:19Greg Jenner?

  How big a role did the British actually play, as Nish has alluded to? Let's find out. Right, Jagjit, can we start with some basics? When exactly are we talking about and why is this such an exciting moment in Indian history?

• 4:32Speaker 05

  Well, I love the 18th century so much that I like to think of a really long 18th century, so longer than just 1700 to 1790. I really want everyone to get their value for money. So for me, the long 18th century probably started around the 1680s, when the Mughals are expanding their empire into the south, into the Indian peninsula. We can say it probably ended around about the 1820s, maybe even the 1840s, when the last of those great post-Mughal kingdoms were conquered by the East India Company. And in between that, there's a whole lot of stuff going on. It's a really exciting time of economic and cultural change and political change. I suppose another reason why I'm interested in a long 18th century is because we think of that kind of time period when we think about British history.

• 5:18Speaker 05

  So Britain from the Glorious Revolution through to the Industrial Revolution or Queen Victoria's reign, and I think that's quite a useful framing for comparison to what's going on in India. And one final reason why I like this long 18th century is because we associate that period with the Enlightenment, with coffee houses, all kinds of new material culture, and a lot of that stuff is going on in India, too. It helps to think about all of that, I think.

• 5:45Greg Jenner?

  Okay, so we've got our sort of frame of reference. We've done a Mughals episode before, and if you want to listen to that, you can. It's a good one. But by the 1700s, they were in trouble, Chekji.

• 5:55Speaker 05

  Yeah, it's definitely a bit of a turning point compared to what came before. So a bit of a recap, since you need to fit in some of the blanks. The founder of the Mughal Empire, he's born in Central Asia, and he's a descendant of both Genghis Khan and Timur, or Tamilnay, as some people might know him, these two great world conquerors. His name is Barber, and he defeats the Sultan's of Delhi to establish what we call the Mughal Empire in North India in 1526. The empire basically grows in fits and starts through to about the end of the 17th, early 18th century, to the death of the sixth Emperor Aurangzeb. We used to talk about decline quite a lot, and what historians have really tried to

• 6:38Speaker 05

  emphasise is that there's a process of change and transformation that occurs after the empire starts to retreat territorially. The Emperor Aurangzeb, he dies, and there's a period of factionalism at court, there's a lack of clear leadership, and that's when I think the imperial centre starts to lose a grip over some of the outlying provinces.

• 7:01Greg Jenner?

  So we've got Various independent states throughout India, because as the Mughals sort of retrench, not necessarily decline, but as they, you know, their territories reduce perhaps. So we've got independent states in Bengal, we've got Awad, we've got Hyderabad, we've got Sikhs in Punjab. Let's talk about one of the rising powers then. This would be the Maratha in the Deccan Peninsula. That's in a sort of centre of the Indian subcontinent. They've got a leader by the name of Shivaji.

• 7:25Speaker 05

  Shivaji, like many people of many different faiths in this period, serves masters of other faiths. These kinds of distinctions of between different religious groups are being made in this period, but they're maybe not as hard as and rigid as they've become today.

• 7:45Greg Jenner?

  Yeah, right.

• 7:46Speaker 05

  So we can kind of look back and we can sort of over determine these kinds of religious conflicts. That's not to say that there aren't religious conflicts, but they are really, these religious boundaries are becoming ossified in this period. When the Mughals start moving into the south, into the Deccan, they start trying to expand their empire into the peninsula. Shivaji thinks this might be a good moment for him, so he tries to sort of broker an agreement with the Mughals. But I don't think the Mughals take him perhaps as seriously as they should have taken him.

• 8:13Greg Jenner?

  Ah.

• 8:14Speaker 05

  And I think that's where one of the falling outs happens. Wouldn't be the first time that the Mughals think of outsiders in this manner. I mean, they write about Afghans in this way, they write about various groups who, over the 18th century, are coming to power in and around Delhi. They see them as sort of people who are outside of the Mughal order, who people are uncivilized or a bit rough around the edges. In the end, it doesn't really matter, because what Shivaji does is he has himself coronated as a king. And in 1674, he assembles a group of Brahmin priests who perform all the necessary rituals in order to have him crowned as a chaturpati, a lord of the umbrella, which is kind of like a kind of lordly title.

• 8:56Speaker 05

  The empire is expanding, and I think the Marathas really seize the moment after Aurangzeb's death and the political instability in the imperial court, as well as the lack of clear leadership, to expand in the south.

• 9:08Greg Jenner?

  Let's talk about the Rajput Empire as well, because this is another power rising and suddenly having a good time. Where is this in the geography of India? Are we in the north?

• 9:17Speaker 05

  The Rajputs, that most people think about when they think about the Rajputs, I'm sure lots of people are thinking about the Rajputs a lot of the time. It's like the Roman Empire for Brahmin. Yeah.

• 9:28Speaker 05

  The ruling houses.

• 9:29Speaker 04

  I just thought about them again.

• 9:30Speaker 05

  Oh, my goodness. How many times today?

• 9:32Speaker 04

  Oh, five times at least.

• 9:33Speaker 05

  Wow. It's a slow day today.

• 9:37Speaker 05

  So the grandest of all the Rajput royal houses are the ones that are in what's today Rajasthan. One of the preeminent Rajput kingdoms is Merwar or Udehpur, which was ruled by the Sisodia dynasty. Incidentally, Udehpur is where the James Bond film Octopussy was filmed.

• 9:52Speaker 04

  Oh.

• 9:52Speaker 05

  If you go there, you can pretty much see it on loop every single night.

• 9:56Speaker 04

  One of the boldest casting choices in human history. They needed to cast an Indian, who did they go to? One of the actors from the second biggest film industry in the world, I think at the time? No, tennis player. The, the, the main Indian guy in Octopussy is Vijay Amritraj. He's a tennis player.

• 10:14Speaker 05

  As well as the Udehpur Rajput court, at Marwar, there are the rotars with their capital at Jodhpur. And then the kathoahs in neighbouring Jaipur. The, you know, Udehpur and Jaipur and Jodhpur, these are the places that lots of people go to on holiday. They're on countless documentaries. They give us that image of royal India, sort of castles and palaces and elephants. So they are the Rajput sort of dynasties that we think of.

• 10:40Speaker 04

  Let's add another empire into our catalogue of empires, the Sikh empire, which I guess is almost into Afghanistan as well. We're in north west India now.

• 10:49Speaker 05

  The Sikh empire does abut Ahmed Shah's and his descendants' kingdom. At its height, the Sikh empire reaches towards what is now called the North West Frontier. But the Sikh empire is one that's formed quite late in the 18th century. In fact, right at the end of the century, which is why I like the idea of a long 18th century. What's happening beforehand is also, I suppose, really important. So if you don't know, the Sikhs are followers of the teachings of Gurnanak and his descendants. Gurnanak was actually alive at the time that the first Mughal emperor came to, marched down to North India and, and conquered India from the Delhi sultans in 5026. And after his death, the Sikhs are led by a succession of other gurus.

• 11:35Speaker 05

  And some of them choose to militarise the Sikhs. The Sikhs are in conflict with the Mughals, but also other powers, and sometimes amongst themselves in the early 18th century. The Sikh rulers form a number of different kingdoms of their own, based around their military units or missiles. And then it's in 1799 that these missiles are united by Ranjit Singh into the Sikh Empire.

• 11:57Greg Jenner?

  So it's 12 missiles that combine into an empire.

• 11:59Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 11:59Greg Jenner?

  So Maharaja Ranjit Singh captured Lahore in 1799. That's your big year that you wanted to sneak into the long 18th century, right?

• 12:07Speaker 05

  Yes, and he is alive until...

• 12:09Greg Jenner?

  Wait, what year was snuck in? 1799, which, you know, is right at the tail end, but then...

• 12:13Speaker 04

  No, come on, that's in the century. It's like when a movie comes out in 1989, you're like, it's an 80s movie. It's an 80s movie.

• 12:20Greg Jenner?

  Sure, but he keeps ruling for ages, right?

• 12:22Speaker 05

  Yeah, he dies in 1839, and his descendants are also on the throne for a couple more years, but that's when the East India Company sort of swoops in.

• 12:34Greg Jenner?

  We'll get to that bit later, Jackie. But yeah, he's, he's sort of ruled for almost four decades. He's kind of parallel to, I guess, almost the beginning of Queen Victoria, isn't he? He really sort of sees a huge amount of history there. And now it's time to introduce the cameo that we've all been waiting for into the story. Who am I talking about, Nish?

• 12:52Speaker 04

  The East India Company.

• 12:53Greg Jenner?

  Yes.

• 12:54Speaker 04

  The whites are here.

• 12:56Greg Jenner?

  It wasn't just actually the British.

• 12:58Speaker 04

  There was the Dutch as well, right?

• 12:59Greg Jenner?

  Oh, good knowledge. Yeah.

• 13:01Speaker 04

  Yeah, there was a Dutch East India Company as well, right?

• 13:04Greg Jenner?

  Yeah, yeah.

• 13:05Speaker 04

  Why didn't none of these people have their own names?

• 13:09Greg Jenner?

  There's actually several European nations who are elbowing their way in. They're not invited in, right? So, I mean, could you sort of run us through some of them?

• 13:17Speaker 05

  It all began, of course, with Vasco de Gama's famous voyage to Asia. He gets to India in 1498, and a year later, he's already back in Portugal. And in the decades that follow for much of the 16th century, the Portuguese are exploiting this new knowledge of how to get to Asia. They're creating trading enterprise that runs between Portugal and Asia, not just India, other places too. And other Europeans want to get in on the act. So that's when a group of English merchants get together and form the East India Company in 1600. And then in the Netherlands, the Dutch East India Company is created in 1602. And then there's a whole bunch of others as well. Some of them are private enterprises, some of them are state-run enterprises, and sometimes there are things in between.

• 14:01Greg Jenner?

  One country we haven't mentioned, actually. Nish, do you want to guess another, another European power?

• 14:07Speaker 04

  Whenever you talk about European colonizers, the Belgians are always acting up.

• 14:11Greg Jenner?

  Oh, good, good, good.

• 14:12Speaker 04

  The Belgians are always acting up. They're always gifting countries to their stupid kings.

• 14:19Speaker 04

  But I don't think there's any Belgian, I don't believe there's any Belgians that turn up in India, but obviously I could be.

• 14:24Speaker 05

  Well, it's not Belgium and isn't the Netherlands.

• 14:26Speaker 04

  The French?

• 14:27Greg Jenner?

  There we go, easily. Yeah, it's the French, the French are in India too, which is not just, it's not well known here in the UK.

• 14:34Speaker 04

  Oh, that's why they're pondicherry?

• 14:35Greg Jenner?

  Yeah.

• 14:36Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 14:36Speaker 04

  Yeah, right, right, right. I've been to Pondicherry and you're like, why is this stuff in French? And you're like, why? Let's not start asking those questions because, you know, I've got a British passport, I'm in trouble if we start pulling at the thread of why are there European influence in different parts of India?

• 14:49Greg Jenner?

  There's also another European country that pops up, quite a surprising one.

• 14:52Speaker 04

  My god, these people. No offence.

• 14:56Greg Jenner?

  You've already guessed Belgium, which I thought was a pretty slightly outlandish guess, but do you want to go even more unexpected?

• 15:03Speaker 04

  The Spanish?

• 15:04Greg Jenner?

  I mean, that's, that's too sensible, I guess, arguably.

• 15:06Speaker 04

  Yeah, yeah. Oh, it's weirder than that.

• 15:08Greg Jenner?

  I think so.

• 15:08Speaker 04

  What, does Luxembourg turn up for a dust up?

• 15:11Greg Jenner?

  Charmingly. No, Denmark.

• 15:17Speaker 04

  How does Denmark even get there?

• 15:19Greg Jenner?

  I mean, I'd love to know. It's a, it's a long old commute, isn't it?

• 15:22Speaker 04

  Yeah.

• 15:23Greg Jenner?

  All the way around. Yeah, Denmark show up and their plan, which is quite, quite a charming one in some ways, they took advantage of the Anglo-French wars and rivalry.

• 15:30Speaker 04

  Yeah.

• 15:31Greg Jenner?

  And they offered merchants the ability to fly, what, the ability to sail under the neutral flag of Denmark, so they wouldn't be attacked by either side. They were basically a maritime VPN service. But the important thing to stress, and I think you want to stress, you're a historian of trade, aren't you? I mean, the Mughal Empire was already plugged into global trade networks. It's not that European powers showed up and said, oh, let's do trade.

• 15:55Speaker 05

  Yeah, it's happening before the 18th century and it's happening before the Europeans show up. So India is really plugged into trade networks in every direction. So there's the caravan routes, which I've worked on a bit between India and Central Asia, Iran, parts of Russia, so towards the north. And then going towards the west, there are all the ports in Arab. Peninsula, the Red Sea region and East Africa. And then, of course, there's Siam and the Spice Islands to the east. And these are just some of the places where you either find Indian goods or you find Indian merchants. There's trade between England and India, direct trade, once the East India Company is formed.

• 16:36Speaker 05

  There's lots of really exciting new research, which has been not just about trade between Asia and Europe, but trade at a more global level. And the Spanish are moving goods between Asia and the New World. And what we're starting to kind of realise is that the reach of some of these goods are really global. So it's not just the rich in England who are decorating their country houses with fine Chinese wallpapers and Indian textiles and so on. It's also this, you know, it's the kinds of cloth that are used in the transatlantic slave trade between Africa and the Americas.

• 17:18Speaker 05

  And Indian cloth is a medium of exchange in the transatlantic slave trade. But there are also fairly ordinary Mexicans who are buying Indian and Chinese goods.

• 17:27Greg Jenner?

  Amazing. Indigo's a big one, isn't it? That's, is that going global, indigo? Because that's a

• 17:31Speaker 05

  Oh, I've got a good story about indigo.

• 17:32Greg Jenner?

  Oh, go on then. Yeah, give us, give us your

• 17:34Speaker 05

  I don't know if it's a good story.

• 17:36Greg Jenner?

  No, you've got to deliver now.

• 17:37Speaker 05

  Oh, I know. So indigo, it's called indigo because it comes from India.

• 17:43Speaker 04

  You've got to go India to get it.

• 17:45Speaker 05

  There is an airline in India called Indigo.

• 17:50Speaker 04

  You want indigo, you've got to go Indy.

• 17:56Speaker 05

  So the Europeans

• 17:57Speaker 04

  For listeners, I'm considered to be an intelligent comedian. So that tells you what the intellectual capacity is for the rest of my profession.

• 18:04Greg Jenner?

  Okay, so indigo, yes.

• 18:07Speaker 05

  Europeans are buying indigo from India in the 17th century. It's all going great. And then they decide to transplant indigo production to the Americas. So to the Carolinas, to the Caribbean. And there they quote unquote improve how the dye is produced. So you have to grow a plant and then you have to turn the plant into a dye. And that combined with other factors puts lots of indigo production and indigo producers in India out of business. There's also like a terrible famine in the 17th century and all kinds of other factors. But that doesn't mean that people who are using indigo dye within Asia stop needing indigo dye.

• 18:46Speaker 05

  And one of the things that happens in this period is that new places start to produce indigo dye in this period. So in parts of Punjab near Afghanistan, there are relatively new, in fact, probably entirely new indigo fields, fields planted with indigo and dye that's being produced there for the caravan trade to Afghanistan and Iran and Central Asia.

• 19:10Greg Jenner?

  And the interesting thing that, I mean, I'm going to have to use the dreaded C word now, capitalism.

• 19:16Greg Jenner?

  The 18th century is the era in which people would often say capitalism is invented, some would say slightly earlier. What does capitalism mean and how is it arriving into India or has it been there all along?

• 19:26Speaker 05

  Well, we think of capitalism as this uniquely European invention, that it's something that emerges in Europe. You know, these Tuscan bankers are creating banks and that's the kind of master narrative. But one of the things we've known for quite a while now is that there are similar developments in banking and finance and trade and the market that are happening fairly simultaneously across Europe, but also the Middle East and parts of Asia, including India. And this is not a new development in the 18th century. This is something that has been unfurling for a long time, for, you know, at least two centuries by the 18th century. But I think it comes to a kind of crescendo in the 18th century.

• 20:09Greg Jenner?

  Okay.

• 20:09Speaker 05

  Two things stand out. One is that the market has really encroached people's lives much more by the 18th century. People's awareness of the value of real estate and their assets, for example, has intensified by this period. People are really fighting over them and they're getting bits of paper signed and notarized because they know what the market for property is like, for example, and that's just one example.

• 20:31Greg Jenner?

  Wow.

• 20:31Speaker 05

  The second thing that comes to mind is the growing power of merchants and bankers. And they don't form a bourgeoisie like they do in Europe, but they are becoming more important and their relationship to the state is becoming much closer. And that's partly because of what's happening in India in the 18th century. So you have these new rulers, and some old rulers too, rulers of these states who are building up their kingdoms. And what do they need? They need money. And how are they going to get money? They're going to get money by having a bureaucracy that doesn't leak money and by increasing the amount of production and trade that's happening within their kingdom. So they bring land

• 21:12Speaker 05

  under cultivation, they try and attract new kinds of cultivation there that maybe didn't happen previously, try and create new trade routes, maybe have new kinds of manufacturing. And merchants and bankers are financing that. And they're also, sometimes their family members are part of that bureaucracy too.

• 21:33Greg Jenner?

  And as well as banking, as well as merchants, as well as insurance firms and so on, that sort of thing. We also get another profession beginning with M, an important profession, a beloved profession. Do you want to guess what they would be, Nish?

• 21:44Speaker 04

  Mmm, mirth makers. The first comedians emerge.

• 21:50Speaker 05

  There are lots of those actually in the 18th century.

• 21:52Greg Jenner?

  Really?

• 21:52Speaker 05

  Yeah.

• 21:53Greg Jenner?

  Fantastic.

• 21:53Speaker 05

  I don't know if there are more, but they're definitely more prominent.

• 21:55Greg Jenner?

  Wow. No, I said beloved, so.

• 22:00Greg Jenner?

  No, mercenaries.

• 22:03Speaker 04

  Here we go.

• 22:03Greg Jenner?

  We get the mercenary class who show up. Nish, have you ever heard of Amir Khan?

• 22:09Speaker 04

  Amir Khan?

• 22:10Greg Jenner?

  Yeah.

• 22:11Speaker 04

  What, you mean the incredibly famous actor?

• 22:13Greg Jenner?

  Not that one from La Guerre. And not the boxer either.

• 22:18Speaker 04

  Have I heard of Amir Khan? Of course I've heard of Amir Khan.

• 22:21Greg Jenner?

  No, this is the third most famous Amir Khan, after the pugilist as well. Jagjit, who was Amir Khan, the Afghan mercenary? He's a big deal, right?

• 22:30Speaker 05

  Yeah, he began his rise by serving the Marathas, who gave him a royal title. And they gave him some land that he formed into a kind of principality. He then joined the Maharaja of Jodhpur's service, Jodhpur again. But his scheming got him into trouble, which is unsurprising, given that he was implicated in poisoning one of the king's favourites. And so he's expelled from Jodhpur in 1815. But he wasn't unusual. I mean, there are lots of mercenaries. There's what I've called a whole market for violence, which already exists by the 18th century. But in the 18th century, when there is all this competition over land to fashion your own kingdom and make your own state, when so much is at stake, those kinds of actors are becoming more powerful, more important.

• 23:15Speaker 05

  And it's not uncommon for some of them to be given land in return for their loyal service and to form principalities of their own, making this even more complicated, this whole patchwork of different states.

• 23:25Greg Jenner?

  I mean, in the end, it doesn't work out for him, right?

• 23:28Speaker 05

  I think he sort of just like goes to Tonk, which is his principality, and he just retreats and has a nice retirement.

• 23:34Greg Jenner?

  Oh, really? Okay.

• 23:35Speaker 04

  Does he really?

• 23:36Speaker 05

  I don't know.

• 23:36Speaker 04

  Right, yeah. It's just with, you don't associate mercenaries with like winding down.

• 23:41Speaker 05

  He doesn't.

• 23:42Speaker 04

  When you hear mercenary, you don't think gentle retirement, getting into gardening.

• 23:46Speaker 05

  And if you do, they're after something.

• 23:47Speaker 04

  Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. You sort of feel with mercenaries, it's probably going to end quite badly.

• 23:53Greg Jenner?

  The nuance window!

• 24:00Greg Jenner?

  Well, it's time now for the nuance window. This is the part of the show where Nish and I pull out our paintbrushes and poetry books for two minutes while Dr Jagmeet takes centre stage to tell us something we need to know about India in the 18th century. My stopwatch is ready, so take it away, Dr Jagmeet.

• 24:15Speaker 05

  Well, I think what has become clear by now is that the 18th century was a really exciting, really dynamic time. It's full of lots of opportunities, some hazards too. But this isn't how we've always seen the 18th century. And to grasp just how much our understanding has changed, I think it pays to go back to the period itself. Now, from the point of view of Mughal writers, anyone who rocked the boat was tarred as a rebel and often seen as being a ruffian from outside the Mughal order. Another important set of source materials we have on the 18th century are those histories that are written by men working for the East India Company after the colonial conquest had begun. And these writers had a vested interest in helping the company legitimate its new spoils.

• 24:59Speaker 05

  And so they portrayed the company as the font of order and peace and prosperity. That conquest would help Indians out of the chaos that supposedly reigned supreme. So these two very different groups of writers, some writing in Persian in and around the Mughal court, those writing in English on behalf of the company, gave us a very similar and very negative picture of the century. And that picture more or less persisted until around about the late 1970s, when historians started to turn their attention to all these new regional courts that we've been talking about. Now, the first part of this work was really about state building, it's about revenue management and so on. And it showed that these new rulers and their collaborators, like merchants and bankers,

• 25:41Speaker 05

  were creating a political order and islands of economic prosperity at a very regional level. More recent work in the wake of the cultural turn has focused on court culture, art, poetry, music, intellectual life, and it's shown us just how vibrant these regional centres were. What's maybe been missed in some of this is detail about the lives of fairly ordinary people and how that was changing. That kind of social history is something I've been fascinated by ever since I wrote my first book, and I'm sure the archives can tell us much more.

• 26:11Greg Jenner?

  Wonderful. Two minutes on the dot. Well done. Wow. That was bang on.

• 26:17Speaker 05

  Yeah. Give a lot of lectures.

• 26:19Greg Jenner?

  Two-minute ones.

• 26:22Greg Jenner?

  Nish, final thoughts on 18th century India?

• 26:25Speaker 04

  This has been great. Like, this is, you know... We should do it more often. Yeah. This is really filling in like a total gap in my historical knowledge.

• 26:35Greg Jenner?

  Mine too.

• 26:36Speaker 04

  And really like reframing the way I think about the sort of East India Company. And even what I was saying, I think one of the things that I think is interesting about this idea of this independence or capitalism springing up is that even in kind of what you would identify as politically progressive history of the region, we still talk about it as, we still have this like victim narrative around it, that Western capitalism in cohorts with Western governments took over these countries and we only focus on them as conquered lands essentially, even when we're trying to write positive histories about them. And actually, it really benefits to understand that there was a whole independent culture

• 27:19Speaker 04

  and country that was evolving and to look at it through a non-European lens, even when the European lens is trying to be progressive and post-colonial and anti-capitalist.

• 27:31Greg Jenner?

  Thank you so much, Nish. Thank you so much, Jagjit. And listener, if you want more Indian history, check out our episodes on the Mughal Empire or on the history of Bollywood cinema, that was a fun one. And if you want a different perspective on the 18th century, why not listen to our episode on black people in Georgian England? And remember, if you've enjoyed the podcast, please share the show with your friends. Subscribe to You're Dead to Me on BBC Sounds. But I'd just like to say a huge thank you to our guests in History Corner. We had the incredible Dr Jagjit Lali from UCL. Thank you, Jagjit.

• 27:57Speaker 04

  Thanks, Greg.

• 27:58Greg Jenner?

  It's been an absolute hoot. And in Comedy Corner, we have the fantastic Nish Kumar. Thank you, Nish.

• 28:02Speaker 04

  Thank you very much for having me. It was very educational. I hope to remember some of it.

• 28:06Greg Jenner?

  And to you lovely listener, join me next time as we shine new light on historical periods. But for now, I'm off to go and make my fortune by investing in Indigo. Hopefully, I'm not hundreds of years too late. Bye.

• 28:20Greg Jenner?

  You're Dead to Me is a BBC Studios audio production for BBC Radio 4.

• 28:37Speaker 06

  It gave me as an actress just what I was craving.

• 28:41Speaker 07

  They were both very mature as filmmakers. This was a film that spoke to a red state, blue state divide.

• 28:47Speaker 06

  I'm Mark Kermode.

• 28:48Speaker 08

  And I'm Melanie Jones and we'll direct you through the intertwined worlds of film, television and streaming.

• 28:55Speaker 06

  In the new series, we'll look at Studio Ghibli and summer blockbusters and start with cinema's fascination with doppelgangers.

• 29:02Speaker 08

  Helped by the one and only Richard Iwari.

• 29:05Speaker 00

  I'd quite like to meet more Norwegian Nigerians. In fact, if there's a meeting, I'll happily attend.

• 29:11Speaker 06

  Screenshot from BBC Radio 4.

• 29:14Speaker 08

  Listen now on BBC Sounds.

• 29:25Speaker 09

  Welcome to The Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.