#352 – Omar Suleiman: Islam

Imam Omar Suleiman is the Founder and President of the Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research and a professor of Islamic Studies at Southern Methodist University. Please support this podcast by checking out our sponsors: – NetSuite: http://netsuite.com/lex to get free product tour – House of Macadamias: https://houseofmacadamias.com/lex and use code LEX to get 20% off your first order – ExpressVPN: https://expressvpn.com/lexpod to get 3 months free EPISODE LINKS: Omar’s Instagram: https://instagram.com/imamomarsuleiman Omar’s Twitter: https://twitter.com/omarsuleiman504 Omar’s Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/imamomarsuleiman Yaqeen Institute’s YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@yaqeeninstituteofficial Yaqeen Institute’s Website: https://yaqeeninstitute.org PODCAST INFO: Podcast website: https://lexfridman.com/podcast Apple Podcasts: https://apple.co/2lwqZIr Spotify: https://spoti.fi/2nEwCF8 RSS: https://lexfridman.com/feed/podcast/ YouTube Full Episodes: https://youtube.com/lexfridman YouTube Clips: https://youtube.com/lexclips SUPPORT & CONNECT: – Check out the sponsors above, it’s the best way to support this podcast – Support on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lexfridman – Twitter: https://twitter.com/lexfridman – Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lexfridman – LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lexfridman – Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lexfridman – Medium: https://medium.com/@lexfridman OUTLINE: Here’s the timestamps for the episode. On some podcast players you should be able to click the timestamp to jump to that time. (00:00) – Introduction (08:39) – God (16:25) – Loss (25:14) – Life after death (26:53) – Why God allows suffering (40:18) – Seeking the truth (47:58) – Islamophobia (1:12:55) – Muslim ban (1:20:24) – Meaning of prayer (1:34:01) – Mecca (1:39:12) – Malcolm X (1:42:23) – Muhammad Ali (1:47:09) – Khabib Nurmagomedov (1:53:19) – Prophets (1:59:31) – Quran (2:05:17) – Ramadan (2:12:21) – Future of Islam (2:15:30) – Colleyville synagogue hostage crisis (2:23:37) – War and religion (2:33:29) – Israel and Palestine (2:59:13) – Hope for the future (3:03:56) – Prayer

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Lex Fridman?

  The following is a conversation with Imam Dr. Omar Suleiman. He's a Muslim scholar, civil rights leader, founder and president of the Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research, and he's a professor of Islamic Studies at Southern Methodist University. He's one of the most influential Muslims in the world and is a fearless, kind-hearted human being who I'm now proud to call a friend.

• 0:25Lex Fridman?

  As a side note, allow me to say a few words about Israel and Palestine. While this conversation with Omar Suleiman was mostly exploring the history and beauty of Islam and the Muslim community, we did delve briefly into the topic of Israel and Palestine. This topic is an extremely challenging one and an extremely important one. It has deep roots and implications in US politics, in global geopolitics, in military and religious conflicts, wars and atrocities, and basic struggle of all human beings to survive, to protect their loved ones, and to flourish as individuals and as communities. I did not want to cover this topic in a solely scholarly fashion.

• 1:09Lex Fridman?

  Much like with the war in Ukraine, it is not simply a story of history, politics, religion, and national identity. It is also a deeply human story. To cover this topic in the way that my gut and my heart says to do it, I have to talk to everyone, to leaders and people on all sides, Muslim and Jewish, Israeli and Palestinian, from refugees to soldiers, from scholars to extremists. I'm not sure if that's possible or wise, but like Forrest Gump said, "I'm not a smart man." And maybe you know how the rest of that goes. I just like to follow my heart to whatever place it leads. I ask the Muslim and the Jewish communities for your patience and support as I explore

• 1:54Lex Fridman?

  this topic. I will make many mistakes, and I'll be listening to all voices so I can learn and do better. I've become distinctly aware that my approach of talking to people from all walks of life with empathy and compassion, but with backbone can create enemies on all sides. I don't quite yet understand why this is, but I'm learning to accept it as the reality of the world. Hopefully, in the end, whatever happens, whatever silly thing I do, has a chance of adding a bit of love to the world. Thanks for going along with me on this journey. And now, a quick few second mention of each sponsor. Check them out in the description.

• 2:37Lex Fridman?

  It's the best way to support this podcast. We've got NetSuite for business management, Howl and Academius for a satiating delicious snack, and ExpressVPN for privacy and security. Choose wisely, my friends. And now, onto the full ad reads. As always, no ads in the middle. I try to make these interesting, but if you skip them, please still check out our sponsors. I enjoy their stuff. Maybe you will too. This show is brought to you by NetSuite, an all-in-one cloud business management system. They manage financials, human resources, inventory, e-commerce, and many business-related details. There's so much stuff involved in running a business.

• 3:19Lex Fridman?

  This is something I think a lot about. Because of me wanting to work for a company, or me wanting to start a business, you know, like a legit tech company that builds products, that delivers products into the hands of people, and hopefully brings joy to their life, hopefully adds a bit of love to the world. To do that, it's not just about the design and the engineering and the scaling of the computer infrastructure, and even the hiring, the hiring decisions, all that kind of stuff. There's a bunch of stuff in the middle that's just very difficult to take care of, and so you should use the best tools for the job.

• 4:00Lex Fridman?

  And, you know, I have to be honest, there's a bunch of aspects of that that I don't understand as deeply as I should. I think a lot of that you can catch up by reading books, but there's just no replacement for experience. Like I said, you should work with the best people, but you should also use the best tools for the job. You could do that if you go to netsuite.com/lex to access their one-of-a-kind financing program.

• 4:27Lex Fridman?

  This show is also brought to you by a sponsor that brings a smile to my face every time I think about them because they're delicious. Not the sponsor, but the thing they make. It's a Hossam Akademias. They ship delicious, high-quality and healthy macadamia nuts directly to your door. They have bars, whole nuts, whole nuts mixed with a bunch of different stuff that makes it all super delicious. I mean, I try not to consume all the snacks that I get from them, that I purchase from them, because I'm trying to actually have like a snack thing for guests when they come over. If they're sort of hungry or they need a little bit more energy for the longer conversations, I'm trying to get the Hossam Akademia nut snacks there because they're small portions, super

• 5:12Lex Fridman?

  delicious, very healthy, you know, all of, all of the, and there's a lot of variety and there's no way you can go wrong with any of the options. And so I like to be a professional adult, responsible kind of human being that, you know, cares about the joy and the wellbeing of the guests that come over. Yeah. So Hossam Akademia's nuts doesn't just make me happy. They provide the possibility, the infinite possibility of joyous snackage for the guests that come over. So I think last time, C. Grimes was over, somebody that I've gotten to know more over the past few months. She's a brilliant,

• 5:55Lex Fridman?

  brilliant artist, but just a fascinating human being. And one of the things she kind of inspires me to do is to take care of the studio environment, of the place that people come to, to have a conversation, you know, to really create an experience. And that's something I really haven't really invested on. And so Hossam Akademias is my first step into creating a delicious, joyous experience for the amazing folks that come over for a podcast. Go to hossamakademias.com/lex to get 20% off your first order.

• 6:31Lex Fridman?

  This show is also brought to you by ExpressVPN. I've used them for many, many, many, many years. You know, it's been, I mean, I don't know what the number is. I wonder when it gets to 10 years because I think it's been like seven, eight years I've been using them.

• 6:46Lex Fridman?

  A VPN is obviously really important, or maybe if it's not obvious to you, if you don't use a VPN, I think you should really be using a VPN for many activities you do. Protects your privacy. There's a bunch of features that allows you to do, like if you watch Netflix and you want to get access to a geographically restricted content, it allows you to do that. But it's just a good tool to have in your toolbox if you're on the internet. And my favorite VPN by far, the one I always recommend is ExpressVPN. I've used it for many, many years. Makes me super happy. It works on any operating system. It's super fast. Click a button, pick a location, it just works. It does one thing and it does it extremely well, which is what I love from, from software

• 7:30Lex Fridman?

  and from, I don't know, from anybody. I love meeting people that just are extremely competent and passionate about one thing. And they do that thing better than anybody I've ever seen. And that sort of fills me with joy, just admiring their excellence. And even more than that, just admiring their joy at the thing they're doing, their lifelong passion manifested in, in this one very specific activity. I don't know. It's beautiful to see. And so ExpressVPN is in some way represents that for me. Go to expressvpn.com/lexpod for an extra three months free.

• 8:14Lex Fridman?

  This is the Lex Fugman Podcast. To support it, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now, dear friends, here's Omar Saliman.

• 8:39Lex Fridman?

  Assalamualaikum Omar. We've been trying to do this a long time. It's, uh, the world tried to prevent it through the, the funny ways that the world does. But, uh, here we are. I'm a huge fan of yours. It's a huge honor to talk to you. I appreciate it. Thank you for making the sacrifice and coming down, or coming up, I guess, to Dallas. I appreciate it. It's a short flight, but a long journey. Let's start with the biggest question. Who is God according to Islam?

• 9:04Speaker 01

  God is the most compassionate, the most merciful, the creator of the heavens and the earth. He is one God. He begets not, nor is he begotten. He is unique. He is omnipotent. He is beyond the limitations of man. He is beyond the constructs of our imagination, but he is ever accessible through sincere supplication. When you call upon him alone, one God, he is closer to you than your jugular vein, the Quran tells us. He's known by many names and attributes, but his essence is

• 9:43Speaker 01

  one. He's one God. No human likeness, no human imperfection can be attributed to him. No partners, no image of him can be constructed. And that is God.

• 9:58Lex Fridman?

  So God represents, he is a feeling of closeness that is accessible to every human being?

• 10:04Speaker 01

  Well, God's not a feeling. God is known by names and attributes. We call upon God, but there is certainly a feeling of closeness when you access him. And so I think the beauty of Islam is that as perfect as God is described, he's also so accessible to the imperfect. And so the idea of sincere supplication and connection to him, we worship him alone, we call upon him alone. There's no clergy, there's no barrier between God and us. And that encourages a sincere devotion and commitment to him alone. And so he is certainly described supreme. And God speaks

• 10:48Speaker 01

  to us through the Quran, and we speak to him through sincere supplication. And his attributes are the furthest from us in terms of their perfection, but he is ever close to us through our supplication, through our prayers and through our connection to him.

• 11:05Lex Fridman?

  To open the door to that connection, to have a connection with God, how difficult is that process? How difficult was it for you? How difficult is it for the people that, for the many, many, many Muslims that you've interacted with?

• 11:18Speaker 01

  Well, I think that there are different layers of difficulty, right? There is the personal difficulty submitting yourself to God. You know, Islam requires a complete submission to Him. And one of the things that happens is that if we project some of our bad experiences with authority onto our relationship with God, then we immediately perceive Him in a certain way that might not allow us to gain a closeness to Him, because maybe we didn't have the best relationship with our parents growing up. Maybe we didn't have the best relationship with authority figures in our lives. And so this idea of an ultimate authority to whom you submit yourself can be very difficult.

• 12:00Speaker 01

  You know, Malcolm X, who was one of the most prominent converts to Islam in American history, talked about the difficulty of prostration for the very first time. Putting your head on the ground, putting your face on the ground and praying to God is a very humbling thing. Submitting all of your affairs to Him is very humbling. And ultimately, you have to relinquish control. And you can't relinquish control without trust. So you have to learn to trust God. To trust God, you have to know Him. And to know Him is to love Him. And so for me personally, you know, growing up, going through certain difficulties,

• 12:39Speaker 01

  having a sick parent who struggled in her life with cancer and with strokes, dealing with racism in South Louisiana, growing up. It was important for me to learn about God through my difficulties, for example, rather than let those difficulties turn me away from Him. Many times, people put a barrier between them and God because they can't make sense of the things that are happening in their own lives. And so they project anger towards God and at the same time, deny their own belief in Him and do away with this natural disposition that every one of us has to believe in Him. So there are intellectual barriers, certainly. There are experiential barriers.

• 13:25Speaker 01

  But I think that one of the beautiful things about Islam is clarity. There is an explanation for his existence, there is an explanation for our existence, there's an explanation for the existence of difficulties in trial, and explanation for the existence of desires and distractions. And it all comes together so beautifully and coherently in Islam. And so I think that for many of us, we want to be our own gods, you know, and ultimately we create and fashion gods in ways that allow us to still be the ultimate determiners of our own fates, of our own story.

• 14:07Speaker 01

  And that's very unfulfilling when you fail at your own plan. But when you realize that there is one who is all-knowing, that there is one who is all-wise, you actually find peace in submitting yourself to Him. And so submitting your will to Him, submitting your desires, submitting your own fate to Him, becomes actually an experience of liberation, because you trust the one that you're submitting to. You trust His knowledge over yours, you trust His wisdom over yours, and that gives you a lot of peace. And then you have direct access to Him. You pray to Him, you call upon Him, you supplicate. And everything in your life suddenly has meaning. You know, in our faith, everything is about intention.

• 14:52Speaker 01

  And there's an intentionality even behind the most, seemingly most mundane actions. A morsel of food in the mouth of your spouse, your family, is looked at as a great charity. The way that you enter into a place and exit out of a place, what foot you step in, what foot you step out with, there's an intentionality. There's a word of remembrance that's spoken. There's a word of praise before and after you engage in any action. There are things that you say before you eat, before you sleep. There is meaning even to your sleep. One of the great companions of the Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, said that I seek the reward for my sleep, just as I seek the reward for my prayer.

• 15:33Speaker 01

  Because you sleep to refresh yourself so that you can once again do great things. And the intentionality behind that allows even the sleep to be rewardable. You eat to nourish yourself so that you can do great things. You seek to be in a position of independence and of being sustained, so that you can sustain others. So the Prophet, peace be upon him, says, for example, that the upper hand is better than the lower hand. The upper hand is the giving hand, the lower hand is the receiving hand. So to seek a position where you can help other people, everything becomes intentional. And there's no such thing as, you know, something that is meaningless and without purpose. So every pursuit is ultimately a pursuit of God. And when you pursue God sincerely,

• 16:18Speaker 01

  then he rewards you, not just with paradise and the afterlife, but he rewards you with a great sense of serenity and self-satisfaction here.

• 16:25Lex Fridman?

  You mentioned part of the struggle growing up was having a parent, your mom, who was sick. What do you remember about your mom? What are some happy, pleasant memories?

• 16:37Speaker 01

  So my parents were, well, my father, thank God, is still alive. My mother was a pious woman, a beautiful woman, a righteous woman, a woman who was known for treating everyone with a great deal of love and respect. She was a poet. She used to write poetry about oppressed peoples around the world. From her homeland in Palestine to the genocide in Bosnia, she followed every conflict before social media and poured her heart into it. She was a woman of great charity. So when I think back to my mom growing up, she was known for her smile. My mom was always smiling. And in fact, every picture of her, she's smiling.

• 17:20Speaker 01

  And at her funeral, you know, people talked about her smile, that she would smile at everyone, and that was kind of her thing. So if you were left out of a gathering, she was smiling at you, and she'd kind of welcome you in. I remember my mom to be content. She was a woman of prayer and a woman of contentment. So I used to see her in her prayer clothes all the time. In fact, when I think back to her growing up, I think of her more in her prayer clothes than in her normal clothes, because that's how often she was engaged in prayer. And I think of her making sure that everyone was included in a conversation. So she was very interesting in that she had several strokes. And each one of those strokes impaired one of her senses to some extent.

• 18:04Speaker 01

  So she was partially deaf because of one stroke. And she'd be sitting in a gathering and she'd be pretty quiet with a big smile on her face, very serene. And she would tell me, you know, alhamdulillah, which means thank, thank God, all praise be to God, that I can't hear because I can tell when people are gossiping, when people are saying negative things around me about other people, because she says even the look on people's faces changes. So it's, it was really interesting because she was that spiritually rooted and, and deep that she said, like, you could see on the looks on people's faces when they started to speak ill about other people, that their faces would change, that their demeanor would change. And she said, I would actually praise the Lord that I couldn't engage in those conversations

• 18:48Speaker 01

  and that I wasn't sinful for hearing them. And what she would do is what, what people said at her funeral, which was really beautiful to me and was very comforting to me, and I took it as a life mission, that if you were new to a place or if you were kind of in the corner and not, not known to other people in the community and you felt left out, she was the one that literally would look around the room and she'd see who was standing in the corner and who was new to the community or new to whatever place. And she'd go and try to include that person in the gathering. So even when she had impaired speech and impaired hearing, with her smile and with her warmth, she was able to welcome people wherever that was. And so the amount of people that came to her funeral and the stories that I continue to hear

• 19:29Speaker 01

  till this day, 15 years later, after her passing away, of people that said, you know, no one ever treated me the way your mother treated me. And she connected that to God. So that was actually part of my faith journey. When I think of great people, when I think of people of faith, she's the first person that comes to my mind because.

• 19:50Speaker 01

  Despite her challenges, she was always the greatest person that you would meet. Anyone that met her and that knew her would say, "I've never, I've never met anyone that kind." That was her reputation. And she was deeply empathetic. She would shed tears over people that she had no connection to. This is again, before social media, before, you know, the, the heavy exposure that we have to people in conflict zones. She had to engage every single human being in her life in a deep and profound way, because she had a profound connection to God, and she believed that that was her calling. And none of her challenges made her bitter. In fact, they only made her more connected to God, and they only made her a better person until the last breath that she took.

• 20:35Speaker 01

  Do you miss her?

• 20:38Speaker 01

  Yeah. There, I mean, yes, absolutely. But I, I feel like everything I do is an extension of her. So you try to carry what she stood for? Absolutely. As part of yourself? The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, said that when a person passes away, there are only three things that continue to benefit them, that continue to extend them. A continuous charity, or a piece of knowledge that continues to benefit people, or a righteous child that prays for them. And I want to be that child that prays for her, but also does charity in her name, extends her charity, extends what she taught me by being the person that she was to everyone around me.

• 21:22Speaker 01

  And there are some times where I don't feel like getting out of bed, sometimes where I don't feel like doing for myself, but I actually feel like doing for her. So everything in my life that I try to do, I try to make it an extension of her. And that's been my calling. And, you know, I believe I'll meet her again. I believe I'll be with her again. I believe that everything I do that is good will be of benefit to her. And I believe that it would make her proud. And so as much as I miss her, as much as I am... Fueled to do for her. And so I continued that. And that's kind of become part of my life.

• 22:07Speaker 01

  It's been my life story. As a child and as an adult, it's been sort of the centerpiece of my life. To do things that extend her. And ultimately, in the process, hopefully benefit me because I, I believe that she's a woman who I pray is destined for paradise. And I want to do the things that would get me there, too.

• 22:30Lex Fridman?

  What did you learn about death? About life from losing her?

• 22:38Speaker 01

  Well, I feel like the facade of the material world was made evident to me at a very young age. You know, most children grow up and their parents want to protect them from everything. And, and I felt that too. You know, my, my mother wanted to downplay her own tragedy so that me and my brother could live a fruitful and fulfilling life. My father wanted to protect us from the hardship of her life. So that we could live fulfilling lives. He was, he'd often be the only father on a field trip, even though he was a distinguished professor. I mean, he was a busy man. He, he was a very busy man, but he tried to show up at a field trip and tried to make

• 23:22Speaker 01

  our lives as normal as possible. But in the process, we always understood that there was more to life than what other children were seeing it as. And now I know that as an adult, there's more to life than what other adults see it as. The material world disappointed early on so that we could see beyond it. And I, and I often tell people that, you know,

• 23:44Speaker 01

  there are many that grow up in tragedy, orphaned children, refugees that

• 23:52Speaker 01

  grow up and do incredible things because they immediately see past the

• 23:58Speaker 01

  Facade. They see through all of the material promises of this world, the deception of it. And that you can choose to be bitter as a result of that, or you can choose to be better. And I think that for me, I had to consciously make that decision that I was going to live a life of prayer, I was going to live a life of charity, I was going to live a life of commitment. And in that process, invest in something that's greater, invest in something that doesn't disappoint. And so I believe in God, I believe in the hereafter, and I believe that God will not

• 24:38Speaker 01

  let any trial or effort in this life go to waste without it being repaid in the hereafter. And so I worked towards that. And so life and death, I understood existence to be transcendent early on, that if I believed that there was nothing to life except for life, I would be a very bitter person. But because I know that there is more to it than this, I'm able to exist in it without being depressed by it.

• 25:09Lex Fridman?

  Existence is transcendence. What happens after we die? After the material instantiation fades away?

• 25:29Speaker 01

  So the Quran tells us that God brought us from the darkness of the womb into this life. You were nothing but a dirty drop of fluid, and you became this fully proportioned human being from the darkness of the womb. You come into this life, you experience it, and then you go to the darkness of the grave only to be resurrected once again. And that we are souls with bodies, not bodies with souls. And there's a huge difference between those two things. This is the vehicle that contains us here. This is the material world that we encounter here.

• 26:12Speaker 01

  But we are not this, and this is not our entire existence. And so the soul continues. This is a life in which we seek to worship Him and seek to live in accordance with the purpose that He has set out for us. And after we pass away, our soul continues onwards, either to reward, or to punishment, or to a mixture of both. But it's a realm of accountability. And hopefully, it's a realm of reward, should we exist in a way that He wants us to exist.

• 26:53Lex Fridman?

  So you said that you can look to God for wisdom to make sense of the world. There's a lot of stuff to us humans that's difficult to make sense of. Like you losing your mother. There's a lot of cruelty in the world. There's a lot of suffering in the world. What wisdom have you been able to find from God about why there is suffering in the world, why there's cruelty?

• 27:24Speaker 01

  You know, there's a saying that I wanted to ask God about why He allows hunger and war and poverty. But I was afraid He might ask me the same question. God has certainly given us enough food. There is enough food in the world for everyone to have a 3,200 calorie diet a day. God has certainly given us enough guidance for us to not inflict on each other the cruelty that we inflict. When we look to the world around us, first and foremost, we have to have a sense of accountability. We are accountable for our own actions. We don't blame God for the evil of man. That's one.

• 28:04Speaker 01

  But at the same time, we understand that God and His wisdom allows for certain outcomes that we cannot encompass with our own. And that to isolate these incidents and to try to make sense of them is no different than a baby in the womb that doesn't understand the world that it's coming into and trying to explain to that baby that hasn't yet developed its own senses and its own perception of this world, what is happening to it, right? You know, I often think of the example of a child and, you know, having been at this point now through the experience of parenthood, I'm still learning.

• 28:47Speaker 01

  I'm just going into having a teenager, but three kids and being a softie for my kids, you know, when you have to tell your child that they can't have something that they really, really want. And that child thinks you hate them at some point, you know, because why are you stopping me from putting this toy in my mouth and choking myself? They don't get it, right? But at the same time, you prevent them out of love. They're not in a position to understand that you're preventing them out of love. And to isolate these incidents with God and to say, the wisdom, what's the wisdom?

• 29:29Speaker 01

  You're trying to make sense of a pixel when you can't see the bigger picture. Your mind is not at a place where you can make sense of the bigger picture. You haven't seen the bigger picture. And so for Him to even explain to us every incident would completely defeat the purpose of putting your trust in Him. So we believe in a God that is all encompassing in His knowledge and wisdom that gives us, and Islam is very, you know, specific, by the way, that there is what God tells us to do and there's what God allows to happen. So what God tells us to do in terms of the roadmap towards good and then what God allows to happen in His divine wisdom, that no outcome can escape Him, but at the same time, we

• 30:14Speaker 01

  are accountable for our own actions and our own deeds. So when you come to someone and you say, you know, why did God allow this to happen to this person? I can't rationalize that for you because my understanding is relegated to the immediate experience in front of me. But if I know God, and if I learn about God, then I don't have to make sense of the plan, but I can tell you that I trust the planner. And I think that that's where peace is found. You know, a lot of times you look for the light at the end of the tunnel. What's the light at the end of the tunnel? In Islam, there's emphasis on God and the hereafter.

• 30:55Speaker 01

  Because to try to make sense of divine decree and why certain things happen in this world without the existence of a God or without the existence of a hereafter will always fail you. So the existence of a God that is all-knowing what we don't know, I know what you don't know, that understands what we don't understand, the existence of a God who is not subject to our constrictions, and the existence of a hereafter, where all things find recourse, where there's divine recourse, allows for this world to be situated within the existence of something greater and not treated in isolation. So when you're trying to treat

• 31:40Speaker 01

  an incident of this world in isolation, you're going to fail. And when you try to treat existence in this world and of this world in isolation, you're also going to fail. And so the emphasis is the belief in God, a God that is not limited like you are, and a belief in the hereafter that is not limited like this life. And so everything continues onwards. And there's divine recourse for everything, each and everything. You know, the Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, mentions that on the day of judgment, a person who lived the most difficult of lives will be dipped into paradise one time and will be told, "Have you ever seen any sadness, any hardship?" Now, when you think about the most difficult life,

• 32:24Speaker 01

  some of the commentators in Islam, they said that this is perhaps referring to the Prophet Job, Ayub, peace be upon him, because Job lived, obviously, a life of great difficulty. But that a person who lived a very hard life would be dipped into paradise one time. And just with a dip, be asked, "Have you ever seen any hardship? Have you ever seen any misery?" And that person would say, "What is sadness? What is hardship? What is misery?" Now, if you don't believe in the hereafter, if you don't believe in anything beyond this life, then the recourse has to happen in this life. And because we see so many people pass through this life... Without recourse of cruelty, without recourse of suffering, then we're forced to try to make sense of it.

• 33:07Speaker 01

  And if you are someone who believes that this entire world came into existence through randomness, that we're just an existence of random atoms that collide with each other and that all of this comes together out of nothing, then how can you put your trust in anything that is greater? So, you know, you asked me, as a child of a parent who suffered, I believe that every moment that my mother suffered, that she will be rewarded, that she will be elevated, that all of that made her or contributed to the beautiful person that she was and will contribute to the beautiful reward that she receives.

• 33:49Speaker 01

  And the recourse is certain to me as a believer in that.

• 33:54Lex Fridman?

  So the right approach to making sense of the world, especially making sense of suffering and cruelty, is that of humility that we as humans cannot possibly understand fully.

• 34:07Speaker 01

  Absolutely. In fact, in the Quran, it's very interesting. When God creates Adam, the angels say to God, "Are you going to create a race or a species that will spill blood and cause corruption?" And God says to the angels in response to that question, "I know that which you don't know." So even the angels have to humble themselves for a moment. The angels who adore God, who love God, who worship Him, who obey Him unconditionally, they are told by God, "I know that which you don't know." And what we extract from that, what many of the early interpretations extract from that is that God knows that there are human beings

• 34:50Speaker 01

  that will come out of this enterprise of humanity that make the entire existence of it worth it. And so just as, yes, there will be criminals and corrupt ones, there will be prophets and beautiful people that come out of this and sages and saints that come out of this that show that a human being...

• 35:13Speaker 01

  Who unlike an angel who has no choice but to worship God, an angel has no sense of will, no sense of choice. An angel is created to worship and has no desires. A human being who has the choice of desire and worship, the choice of righteousness and wickedness, that there are human beings who will choose worship and righteousness, that will choose charity over cruelty, that will choose service and choose dedication and devotion over death and destruction, that there are human beings that will in fact ascend the angels in rank because they will live lives where they choose that capacity, that part of themselves. And they lean into that and worship God lovingly and obey him.

• 35:57Speaker 01

  You see, and some of the sages in Islam, scholars, they describe this as saying that the human being has the capacity to be anywhere from an animal to an angel, or even worse, to be a devil, you know, to an angel, not in the sense that we ever actually become angels or become animals, but that an animal, you know, for the most part, seeks its desires over everything, doesn't really think about, you know, many of the things that we are supposed to calculate as human beings, doesn't think about which territory it's infringing upon, or, you know, how much of its appetite it should fulfill. It simply exists to fulfill its appetite, and that many human beings simply exist to fulfill their appetite, and they choose that over worship or reason or anything that is greater.

• 36:41Speaker 01

  Just, they, they literally take themselves as gods in that sense, and their selves have no limitation on appetite, so they just keep filling that appetite, and filling that appetite, and filling that appetite, whereas a human being can also go to the extent of choosing something greater and disciplining their desires, disciplining themselves, because they're seeking a greater reward. You know, we know many people that achieve great things in the worldly sense because they choose to study over sleep, for example. They choose to exert themselves towards their careers, towards their education, because they believe that ultimately the outcome of those pursuits are more rewarding than the immediate fulfillment of their desires.

• 37:26Speaker 01

  So as believers, we choose that love of God and we choose that outcome that we seek. And we discipline ourselves to where we can even ascend past the angels in rank. Now, of course, I said we can go as low as an animal or even as low as a devil. And we have tyrants, past and present and future as well, that can become satanic in their nature because they allow their desires to take such control over them that they not only worship them, but that every other existing being around them simply becomes a piece of their own puzzle in pursuit of their own lordship and their own satisfaction, and they will kill, they will discard.

• 38:10Speaker 01

  Not because, you know, and I always say this, it's not that tyrants necessarily like killing people, it's that people's lives pose somewhat of an indifference to them. They're indifferent to people's existence. And so you become either an object for or against me. And so they're willing to discard. Children discard people, discard the rights of others because they ultimately have chosen that the greatest pursuit of themselves is the maximum position of power and a place to where they can fulfill what they want to of themselves without any limits.

• 38:53Speaker 01

  And everyone else becomes either a threat or an opportunity in that regard. So we can be devils, we can be angelic-like, we can be animals. We're somewhere on that spectrum. And every moment contains a set of choices you can make. Absolutely. Every single moment contains a set of choices. And that's where the intentionality comes in, right? So the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, says that I saw a person strolling in paradise because he removed something harmful from the road. He tells us about a woman that lived the life in prostitution, but that repented to God when she was thirsty one day, and she saw a dog that was also thirsty. And she said that I was thirsty and God gave me water.

• 39:37Speaker 01

  So I'm going to choose to give water to that thirsty dog. And God enters her into paradise as a result of that. Sometimes the small moments with a small sincere deed can have a huge impact on a person's trajectory. So every moment is a moment of choices. And when we choose belief, righteousness, a pursuit of something greater, then we find ways to turn things that are otherwise mundane into miraculous acts, right? Where we can, we can choose God over ourselves and in the process, choose a better fate for ourselves.

• 40:18Lex Fridman?

  How difficult is the process of knowing, understanding what is the righteous action? Of knowing what it means to be a good man? Or a good woman?

• 40:32Speaker 01

  Well, the truth has consequences. So don't seek out the truth unless you're willing to abide by what you find. So a lot of people want to mold their journey in accordance with a predetermined pursuit that they already have. And so when they approach religion, they approach it like another product. You know, there was a, an article that was actually written by a rabbi. I've spoken about this in several sermons. It was called "The Allure of Narcissistic Spirituality", "The Allure of Narcissistic Spirituality", where he talks about, you know, how religion becomes just another product of your own self-adoration and worship, to where you only approach religion to the extent that it gives you...

• 41:14Speaker 01

  More happiness in the worldly sense. You only approach of it what is therapeutic. So it becomes just as secular in its nature as any other practice of meditation or whatever it may be, or some other product. And he kind of mentions, you know, how he took that from a person that is praying in a temple. And a guy walks into the temple and bumps into him, and then he curses the guy out. So he didn't see his behavior towards that person as part of his trajectory of worship. He just saw his being godly as the worship that he was engaged in. The truth has consequences.

• 41:55Speaker 01

  The truth has circumstances that are required of you, actions that are required of you that may be somewhat inconvenient. So you have to be willing to engage in a sincere pursuit of truth and look for truth for what it is, and not simply look for comfort and convenience. And when you engage in that journey of wanting to know, you have to engage it thoroughly and sincerely and try your best to remove any bias. I think that's what makes the religion of Islam such a phenomenon for people that with all the Islamophobia and the bigotry towards it, it's still the fastest growing religion in the United States and the fastest growing religion in the world. And no, that's not all birth rate. Yeah, we have a lot of kids.

• 42:40Speaker 01

  But many people, you know, you met someone just before we started this interview. Many people, in fact, in a post 9/11 world, saw what they saw of Islam in the media. And they actually, you know, went and checked out copies of the Quran and started to read about the religion. And in their sincere pursuit of truth, ended up embracing a religion that they believed was the greatest source of destruction in the world. And now it's the greatest source of peace for them in their own existence, in their own lives. And so you have to be willing to engage in a sincere pursuit of wanting to know. And then be willing to engage in sincere commitment after you know. Otherwise, the heart rusts.

• 43:23Speaker 01

  And so there's a process in the Quran talks about this of making the heart like fertile soil towards truth. So you have a sincere pursuit, but then at some point, if you come to know and then you ignore what you come to know, then the heart rusts and it becomes harder to recognize it the second time around and the third time around. And so when people come to me and they say, you know, I'm looking for something, I'm looking for, I'm looking for God, I'm looking for my purpose. The first thing I tell them is I say, listen, what you need to do is if you're really looking for God and you're, and you believe in God, and there are often people that say, I believe in God, but I don't know where to go with this, right? I know that there's something greater. And in Islam, we call that the fitrah, a natural disposition towards the belief in

• 44:08Speaker 01

  the existence of God. But where do I go from here, you know? What do I do now? And I say, the first thing you need to do is you need to sincerely say, oh, God, guide me to the truth. Call upon God sincerely, say, I'm calling upon you alone and I'm asking you to guide me to the truth. Show me what it is, right? And that's the heart function. Then you need to actually investigate and try to suspend bias, right? Investigate the world's religions, investigate the claims to truth, investigate, use, you know, rational inquiry to the extent that the heart becomes satisfied and suspend bias and you'll be surprised.

• 44:52Speaker 01

  And so for a lot of people, they come to me and they say, you know, this, this, this about Islam, I'm like, look, I'm, if you're just going to talk to me about what you've seen of Islam in the media, if you were serious about it, you know, if you're serious about it, then you're not simply going to be satisfied with the highly edited images and distorted facts that come towards you about this religion, right? What are you looking for, right? Are you, are you looking for a scapegoat? Islam poses a threat to many people, right? Are you looking for a scapegoat? Are you looking for the big, bad, scary foreign enemy? Or are you looking at?

• 45:35Speaker 01

  A religion that one-fourth of the world adheres to. And if one-fourth of us were that, the world would not exist. Right? So are you looking towards this religion that one-fourth of the world adheres to? Are you going to read about the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him? Are you going to read the Quran yourself? Are you going to investigate for yourself? What it is that this faith has to offer? And find in it a great sense of wisdom, a great sense of beauty, a great sense of truth? And I think that for a lot of people, you know, they find that Islam has such a beautiful combination of the intellectual proofs, as well as the spiritual experiences that often combine what people seek in the Western and the Eastern religions.

• 46:19Speaker 01

  So I had an interesting two weeks, two weeks in a row. This was August, two weeks in a row. I had someone who converted to Islam that went from being, that started off as a Methodist, went from being a Methodist to being a Buddhist, to being a Muslim. So two weeks in a row, I had a Methodist turned Buddhist turned Muslim. Great journey. Yeah, I called my Methodist friends. I have a lot of Methodist pastors in the city that I work with. And I said, what's going on here, man? Sending people on to this interesting journey of Buddhism and then Islam. But both of them had a very similar story, which is that they had sought in Buddhism, for example, the, you know, some of the meditative practices that are found that really

• 47:02Speaker 01

  Western religion, which has been dominated by capitalism and dominated by very material things and can be very unfulfilling. They found that in some of the Eastern philosophies and the meditative practices. And then they came to Islam and it combines, you know, their belief in sort of the Abrahamic way. It merged their belief in one God and the prophets like Abraham and Moses and Jesus, peace be upon them, all with a deep tradition of meditative practices, of consciousness, of connection to God on a regular basis. And they found that to be very fulfilling, both intellectually and spiritually. And so I was like, that's interesting, you know, two people in two weeks that went through that journey.

• 47:45Speaker 01

  So I think Islam is very wholesome, comprehensive when people actually approach it with humility and appreciate what it has to offer.

• 47:58Lex Fridman?

  As you mentioned, in the minds of some Americans, after 9/11, the religion of Islam was associated with, maybe you could say evil in the world, maybe you can say terrorism. How can you respond to this association? How does it make you feel, first of all, as a devout Muslim yourself? And how can you overcome it personally? How can you overcome it as a community and as a religious leader?

• 48:28Speaker 01

  It's interesting, because 9/11 now, we're talking over 21 years ago.

• 48:34Lex Fridman?

  You know, there's people born after 9/11.

• 48:36Speaker 01

  It's crazy.

• 48:37Lex Fridman?

  And you get to talk to them all the time.

• 48:39Speaker 01

  Yeah, so when I'm talking to young Muslims, I'm talking about post 9/11, post 9/11, they're like, I was born in 2005. What are you talking about, post 9/11? I'm like, well, I remember being a teenager. I remember being in high school when this happened, right? So a lot of us that experienced 9/11 as high schoolers or as college students and remember distinctly what it was like to be a Muslim pre 9/11 and post 9/11, we can relate to that experience and we could identify that juncture, you know, very clearly and talk about it and speak to the change in the perceptions of Islam that happened here in the United States and around the world. But a lot of young people are born into that reality and are experiencing the aftermath of it.

• 49:23Speaker 01

  And, you know, unfortunately, have to deal with the bigotry that has not just, you know, taken greater shape in media constructions of Islam, but also policies, right? A lot of the civil liberties of the Muslim community were taken away from us. You read about the Patriot Act. You read about the securitization of the Muslim community and some of the unfair practices that have been engaged by the Bush administration, the Obama administration, the Trump administration, and continue into the Biden administration. International Islamophobia. And so... The hatred of Muslims and the bigotry that is wielded against Muslims on the basis

• 50:06Speaker 01

  of this idea that we are a barbaric people, not ascribed to a religion of hate and violence, has had immediate consequences for us, no matter where we are in terms of our age and in terms of our experience. We have dealt with that in different ways. Now, the association of Islam to terrorism is a lazy association. It's one that ignores both the history of violence, as well as its everyday occurrence. You know, we're good for how many mass shootings a year? When's the last time you heard of a Muslim carrying out a mass shooting in

• 50:48Speaker 01

  America? Right? How many of those mass shootings, if you were to scrub the social media, what, 400, 500 mass shootings a year? If you were to scrub the social media of some of those that carried out those shootings, you know, we're good for one or two idiots a year, right? It's unfortunate that you're gonna have people that, that carry out despicable acts of violence. But when we as Muslims hear someone in the media say terrorism has been ruled out as a possibility, while the blood is still on the floor of that Walmart, we already know that the police chief just said that that wasn't a Muslim. Don't worry. You know, that wasn't Al Qaeda guy or an ISIS guy. It was, it was one of our own,

• 51:30Speaker 01

  right? And so it's, it's become frankly ridiculous because the association of violence with Islam is one that is used to actually carry out acts of violence against Muslims worldwide. It justifies bad policy towards Muslims worldwide and then in the United States. And it's just factually so lazy. There was a study just about how the media gives more attention to acts of violence done by Muslims and immediately stamps it with Islam, up to 300% more than it will with another act of violence carried out in the name of anything else. So you don't hear about the acts of violence that are carried out by others.

• 52:14Speaker 01

  You don't hear about the religion of the perpetrators. You don't associate terrorism with actions frankly of state terrorism. You know, when governments launch chemical attacks or drone weddings and do so while explicitly dehumanizing the people. Just because they do so with the government apparatus doesn't make it any less terroristic than if it's a lone person that goes out and commits an act of violence trying to achieve a political goal. So the association is lazy, historically speaking. The crusades, I grew up in Louisiana, I saw Klan rallies, Ku Klux Klan rallies my whole life and people said, well, that's a thing of the past. Well, guess what?

• 52:57Speaker 01

  You know, we see many semblances, many acts that are carried out with the same vitriol that was generated by the Ku Klux Klan. We have people standing in front of our mosques that belong to right wing hate militias carrying AR-15s, talking about wanting to inflict harm on Muslims. I have been to Christchurch, New Zealand and buried the victims of a white supremacist terrorist who was inspired by the political rhetoric here in the United States, in his own words, in his manifesto, to go and kill 50 innocent people in Christchurch, New Zealand, one of the most peaceful cities in the world. And by the way, Lex, I mean, it's really interesting, like with Christchurch.

• 53:41Speaker 01

  You know, the man wanted, and I won't even say his name, but his next target after the two mosques, had he not been stopped, was to go to a Muslim daycare. So what drives someone to dehumanize people to that extent that he was willing to go to a daycare and murder a bunch of kids because he saw them as a demographic threat to civilization? So Muslims are terrorized because they are falsely depicted as terrorists. Muslims suffer domestically and globally because of this false association. It's a lazy association. And when someone comes around and says, well, um, fine, not all Muslims are terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslims. I say that, you clearly don't read statistics.

• 54:28Speaker 01

  Whether we're talking about the 20th century, and I'm a student of history and I believe you are as well. All the isms, World War I, World War II, had nothing to do with religion, certainly had nothing to do with Islam. Fascism, Soviet atheism, right? Many of these systems where people were murdered in the millions, Nazism, the Holocaust, Rwanda, Cambodia. I can go on and on. The Rohingya today, the greatest atrocity towards the Uyghurs. Where is Islam fit in all of this? People do horrible things. They stamp it with religion at times. But the only group of people that seem to suffer after an act of violence is committed are Muslims. Because any act of violence that is committed by a Muslim

• 55:13Speaker 01

  will immediately be blamed on Islam. And 2 billion people will have to carry the burden of the act of a single perpetrator.

• 55:24Lex Fridman?

  And just to reiterate, in case the numbers are not known, you mentioned Christchurch. Those are two mosque shootings with 51 people killed and 40 were injured in New Zealand.

• 55:37Speaker 01

  Yeah.

• 55:39Lex Fridman?

  So it's hate manifesting itself and then actual human suffering and destruction.

• 55:49Speaker 01

  Absolutely.

• 55:51Lex Fridman?

  Is there similarities between antisemitism and anti-Muslim hate? So is there something deeper to say about hate in general here? That is beyond just particularly hate towards Muslims?

• 56:07Speaker 01

  Absolutely. Look, in Pittsburgh, the synagogue shooting, the perpetrator particularly targeted that synagogue because...

• 56:17Lex Fridman?

  Tree of Life synagogue.

• 56:18Speaker 01

  Tree of Life synagogue.

• 56:19Lex Fridman?

  11 killed, 6 wounded in 2018.

• 56:22Speaker 01

  Because he believed that they were taking in Syrian refugees or supporting Syrian Muslim refugees. You think about that. The San Diego synagogue shooting that took place shortly after. He went to a mosque and then he went to a synagogue.

• 56:41Speaker 01

  Look, the idea of... Scapegoating minority populations and attributing to them a disproportionate sense of power and a nefarious element where they can't be trusted. And unless we wipe them out, then they're going to wipe us out. Underlies many of the bigotries that exist. I mean, look, after Trump announced his Muslim ban, there was a shooting in Canada, an attack in Canada on a mosque in Quebec, where six people were killed. The shooter explicitly said that the reason why he went to that mosque in Quebec

• 57:22Speaker 01

  and shot dead six Muslim worshippers was because he was afraid that because of the ban on Syrian refugees in the United States, they would come to Canada, and he didn't want them to feel welcomed in Canada. So there is a connection. And I think it's when you are able to dehumanize large groups of people and attribute a nefarious element to them, then unfortunately, in a world that's becoming more and more polarized, where people are able to construct their entire worldviews based on an algorithm that their social media caters to, you're going to have some of these attacks happen.

• 58:05Speaker 01

  And there's going to be an unfortunate connection between them. So what I tell people is that, you know, I think with all of these people that shoot up synagogues and shoot up mosques, and even before that, actually, the Charleston, South Carolina, shooting at an AME church. You know, when he went there, he actually said that before he murdered nine worshippers in that church.

• 58:35Speaker 01

  He was taken aback by how nice they were to him. He sat there for two hours before he turned a gun on many people who were over the age of 80 years old and murdered them in cold blood. So this is what I talk about when I say that as human beings, we have the propensity, unfortunately, to become worse than devils, or we can choose to be angelic when we choose worship and righteousness over ourselves. So that's a spiritual crisis as well, and a crisis of meaning and emptiness where I think people are willing to inflict great pain on others when they can't make sense of their pain in their own lives.

• 59:19Lex Fridman?

  I'd like to try to figure out together with you sort of a way out to try to decrease the amount of hate in the world, but maybe it's useful to talk about the BBC documentary that, it's kind of interesting that people should check out. It's called United States of Hate: Muslims Under Attack. And you appear in that, you have conversations with people who are anti-Muslim, and it's, I believe, most of it takes place here in Dallas.

• 59:51Speaker 01

  Yeah.

• 59:52Lex Fridman?

  And can you just tell me about this little documentary about that time, what it was like to interact? What was the group in the documentary and what was it like to interact with them?

• 1:00:01Speaker 01

  You know, in the very beginning of the rise of, at that time, actually Ted Cruz, Donald Trump, like when Islamophobia was at the center of many of the presidential candidates' campaigns at the time.

• 1:00:16Lex Fridman?

  So this must have been 2015?

• 1:00:18Speaker 01

  Yes, 2015. The mayor of Irving at the time, Beth Van Dyne, who is now a congresswoman, had put out the idea that Muslims were operating a Sharia court in Irving, Texas.

• 1:00:37Speaker 01

  And suddenly, there was hysteria. Because again, there's the idea that Muslims are here to dominate. Muslims are here to overthrow everything that you have in the United States. There was hysteria here. And it was unfortunate because what it unleashed, you know, especially with the national discourse at the time, again, the presidential campaign. You know, Donald Trump says, I think Islam hates us. When he uses those words, I think Islam hates us. When Ted Cruz suggests that Muslim neighborhoods could be patrolled or should be patrolled. And then you have the Irving mayor saying that one of the most populated cities with Muslims in America,

• 1:01:18Speaker 01

  they're operating under an alternative legal, an alternate legal system. And funny enough, the year before that, she'd come to the mosque and she praised the diversity of Irving. And she was talking about how welcome she felt in the mosque. And the next thing we know, you have these crazy white supremacist groups, openly white supremacists that affiliate themselves with the Klan and others protesting regularly in front of our mosques with their AR-15s. And telling people to go back home. And I'm like, I'm from New Orleans. I'm not planning to move back to New Orleans. I'm home. We're home. We're good. You know, we're staying put and we refuse to be intimidated.

• 1:01:59Speaker 01

  But then when the Syrian refugee crisis is unfolding as well, Dallas has been one of the more popular destinations, if you will. I'm not talking about it like a vacation destination, but where a lot of refugees have come to just because of the infrastructure that we have set up here to receive refugees. And so that hysteria was an unfortunate, perfect combustion of the national discourse with the local discourse with the incoming refugees. And we would do all sorts of welcome refugee events. And we do that, you know, and we don't only do that for Muslim refugees. By the way, there are refugees from other parts of the world as well. But we would host events at our mosques, you know, to welcome refugees,

• 1:02:44Speaker 01

  to help integrate them into the community, to do things for them. So you have these armed protests happening, right? And Horrible because I think about the trauma to the children that are hearing about Tree of Life and hearing about some of these other incidents that are unfolding. And really, one of the first communities that was targeted was the Sikh community in Madison. That was one of the first shootings, and then the AME Church Charleston. And then you just had tons of places of worship being targeted, right? So they're seeing this unfold, and they're seeing these guns in front of their mosques. And the result to many is, well, I just don't want to get shot. I don't want to go to the mosque. I don't want to have this happen to me. So, you know, when BBC reached out and said, we want to do a documentary

• 1:03:27Speaker 01

  about this. Unfortunately, Dallas was the only place in America where you had regular armed groups in front of our mosques. It was happening around the country infrequently, but here it was happening every week. So the BBC reached out and said, we want to interview you. And I said, we've got this idea. We want to put you, we want to take you to a park and have you meet one of the protesters who's been wielding his gun outside your mosque and talk to him. And it was really interesting because they'd interviewed him before meeting me. And the things that he was able to utter before meeting me and before meeting Syrian refugees was just awful. I mean, the most dehumanizing rhetoric

• 1:04:08Speaker 01

  that you can imagine. But then, at the park, he meets me, talks to me, he meets a Syrian refugee family, one of the girls whose leg had been blown off in an airstrike. And he said, I feel like an idiot. I mean, he expressed all sorts of regret and was teary-eyed, that he could dehumanize people the way that he was. And so my whole thing was, and is, come inside the mosque, put your gun down, disarm yourself, and learn. And you'll be surprised what you'll walk away with. And I only took one meeting with him to completely

• 1:04:52Speaker 01

  shift his worldview at the time, which was made up of heroes and villains, the Muslims, unfortunately, being the villains that had to be wiped off the face of the earth so that the earth could continue. So that was a, that was an interesting documentary, and it was an interesting social experiment.

• 1:05:09Lex Fridman?

  What's it feel like to have all these people that hate you and others in the community, people you love?

• 1:05:22Lex Fridman?

  With guns, threatening violence, basically that don't want you here in this country on this earth.

• 1:05:33Speaker 01

  Um, it's not nice. It's not great. I mean, it's um, it's definitely a challenge, but look, there are challenges that we face as Muslims, being in the United States, being in a hostile climate. There are different types of challenges and I think what we've had to do as a Muslim community is see beyond both the guns and the roses and think about who we are first. Because frankly, Islamophobia exists in different forms and from different sides. And we try to use this as an opportunity to instill in our young people, not just a sense of belonging, but a sense of purpose.

• 1:06:20Speaker 01

  Do not be intimidated and in fact, show them the best of your Islam. Live your life because at the end of the day, the goal that is sought through intimidation is silence. And so we have to carry ourselves as proud American Muslims. We don't have to impress anyone. And we don't need to relinquish an iota of our faith to coexist with anyone. We are satisfied with who we are. We don't, we don't see a contradiction

• 1:06:56Speaker 01

  between our place of residence and our religion, our nationality, our religion. We don't see that as a problem, right? So that's a, that's something for them to work out, not for you to work out. That's what I would tell young Muslims that continue to live your faith fully. And demonstrate the beauty of it and do not let the ugliness of the world consume you.

• 1:07:22Lex Fridman?

  But for those young Muslims, what would you say how they should feel towards the people that hate them? The natural human, there's a desire still to have anger, to have resentment, to have hate back at the people that hate you.

• 1:07:37Speaker 01

  The Quran says, "Respond to that which is evil with that which is better." And you will find that sometimes your enemy will become your close friend. So respond with that which is better. Doesn't mean be passive. Sometimes there needs to be a demonstration of strength. Sometimes there needs to be a demonstration of ignoring a people altogether. But ultimately, you can't let the way people treat you shape who you're going to be in the world. And so that's why I say we have to look beyond the guns and the roses. We have to look beyond the hostility of our enemies and the temporary and opportunistic

• 1:08:21Speaker 01

  embrace of some of those who claim to be our allies. And be us. And treat the world and treat the people of this world in accordance with your standards, not with theirs. So don't teach them, you know, or don't let them teach you bad character. You teach them good character. So live your life and live your faith beautifully. And let people see the beauty of it through your, through your being. And do not let their ugliness consume you. But at the same time, sometimes you got to give people room to express frustration, to to say that this is unacceptable, to have demonstrations of strength.

• 1:09:03Speaker 01

  And I think that those things don't have to all contradict each other.

• 1:09:07Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, what do you think about, these kinds of protests are not allowed in many parts of the world. What do you think about? One of the most, you directly, personally painful manifestations of the First Amendment, of the people's right to freedom of speech and to protest, to say hateful things. You've been at the receiving end of the worst of it. What do you feel about this particular freedom that's at the core of the founding of this country?

• 1:09:41Speaker 01

  Look, I think that you have to take it away from the text and look at it within reality. Let's be real, would Muslims be able to protest in front of churches with guns on a weekly basis in this country? I don't think so.

• 1:09:54Lex Fridman?

  So that's a deep, pragmatically speaking, there's a hypocrisy to what's allowed.

• 1:09:59Speaker 01

  Major hypocrisy, major hypocrisy. See, free speech is an ideal that is weaponized against the Muslim community and against other communities in such a hypocritical way. You know, you take, for example, some countries in Europe, you know, let's kind of move away from this and look at the hypocrisy of a place like France, where the caricaturing and the portrayal of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, in derogatory ways will be used as the hallmark of free speech. But Muslims that will caricature Macron or challenge some of the values of France,

• 1:10:41Speaker 01

  the supposed and trined values of France, will end up in prison and end up deported. And so here in the United States, there's a great hypocrisy. I don't think that places of worship should have armed protesters in front of them. I think that that poses a security risk. I think that it's not okay. And I think that free speech is weaponized against the Muslim community and often is held up as this great value, but really to attain very lowly things and is often to our detriment.

• 1:11:16Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, just even watching that documentary.

• 1:11:22Lex Fridman?

  It's hard to put into words, but somehow that does not capture what maybe the founders intended. What I would see is the great ideal of the freedom of speech.

• 1:11:39Lex Fridman?

  I don't know what the solution to that is. I think taking it outside of words, maybe that requires a community, a cultural pressure to be better.

• 1:11:51Lex Fridman?

  It's not about the law, it's more about just the cultural pressure, what is and isn't okay. Because there's something deeply wrong about that kind of hate.

• 1:12:00Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, because it was dehumanizing other people that are here in America, that they're Americans.

• 1:12:07Speaker 01

  Yeah, I mean, it's, we have to interrogate the foundations of our country when our country is in such turmoil and such chaos. No country in the world has the mass shootings that we have. No country in the world has some of the polarization that we have. We have to interrogate that and say what it is that we're doing wrong that's leading to that. And I think, again, that it's reaching a point where it's unsustainable.

• 1:12:39Speaker 01

  If we don't do better and try to solve some of the rifts right now that exist in our society, then we're going to end up in, you know, in a place where we may not be able to climb out of this.

• 1:12:55Lex Fridman?

  What do you think about, you mentioned the Muslim ban, what do you think about executive order 13769 titled Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States? Often referred to as the Muslim ban or the Trump travel ban. It was an executive order by President Trump that was in effect from January 27, 2017, for just a few months until March 6, 2017.

• 1:13:23Lex Fridman?

  What was this executive order and what was its effect on your life and on the life of the Muslim community and just the life of Americans?

• 1:13:34Speaker 01

  Well, it was disgraceful. It was a tactic that was used, you know, at the time, very similar to the whole build the wall rhetoric to play to a particular political sloganeering and carrying out those types of acts against the Muslim community. You're not going to face much opposition typically in any meaningful way that would be politically costly. When he rolled it out at the time, there were people in flight on their way to the United States that were held in airports around the country.

• 1:14:16Speaker 01

  Children, elderly people that were held in these small rooms and treated awfully before being put back on a plane and sent to where they were. There were families that had medical needs that were never able to come together. He specifically targeted Muslim countries to play to that idea of a complete ban of Muslims, which he knew was not feasible at the time. Now, personally, you know, Dallas had the largest amount, the largest number of detainees in the airport. We have one of the largest airports in America and we took to the airport and we stayed

• 1:15:00Speaker 01

  there for a few days, stayed overnight. It was one of the New York Times pictures of the year when we did our prayer because when we had to do our prayer, it wasn't just Muslims that came to the airport. It was many people that came to the airport of different faiths that were outraged by what they had seen. So when we do our prayer, there was a protest chant that you pray, we stay. And so the airport had to make room for us because there were like a thousand people that needed to have our five daily prayers. So we would do our prayers in the airport. We waited. We continued until the detainees were freed, at least temporarily. Unfortunately, some elements of that legislation remained,

• 1:15:43Speaker 01

  and it was it was an ongoing struggle. But look, what I'll say is that those are some of the more obvious manifestations of anti-Muslim bigotry. But again, there is hypocrisy on all sides of the political aisle here in the United States. There is Islamophobia of different flavors. I think even the term Islamophobia can become contentious because there are people that attack us in different ways, and that might not be as overtly bigoted, but nonetheless are infringing on our rights to be full American Muslims. And Muslims find themselves in a very strange political place, where you've got one side that seemingly wants to annihilate

• 1:16:27Speaker 01

  you, and another side that only accepts you if you're willing to assimilate, but no one really allows you to be a full-on American Muslim. And so Muslims find themselves in a very strange place right now, with all of the political sides, with the political parties.

• 1:16:45Lex Fridman?

  Where do Muslims sit politically? Are they politically engaged in the function of the United States? Where do they find themselves politically as a community?

• 1:16:54Speaker 01

  So Muslims find themselves in an awkward place politically. That's the best way to put it. We are a religious community, and so we don't find ourselves welcomed by the left, which has a hostility towards religion and most left spaces and most liberal spaces.

• 1:17:14Lex Fridman?

  In general, because it's a kind of religion has many conservative elements.

• 1:17:19Speaker 01

  Right. So the Muslim community is in its nature conservative, for what that's worth, right? It's a conservative community. It's a community that has certain orthodoxies and practices that would make it disagreeable in its nature and its practice to many on the left. And many on the right just see us as a group of foreigners and a threat in that regard. So we find ourselves in this awkward place. There's also the Presence of sort of the pro-Israel dominance of both parties. The foreign policy of both parties is detrimental to Muslims globally. The securitization of the Muslim community in the name of countering Ba'ath extremism.

• 1:18:03Speaker 01

  Unfortunately, the Muslim community has had both Republican and Democratic administrations just run over its rights. So we find ourselves kind of in this awkward space, right? We are a religious community that's also a minority. The racialization of the Muslim community sort of robs us of who we are and how we get to engage then with different platforms and different peoples around us. So we find ourselves in a very awkward place.

• 1:18:32Lex Fridman?

  Is there in general a lack of representation in places of power in politics?

• 1:18:40Speaker 01

  I don't think representation is everything. I think that representation can actually be detrimental sometimes because you can have people that represent you, but that don't actually represent your priorities as a community, as a faith community. So we don't want to be tokenized as a community, right? We want to be engaged and engage fully as Muslims and be respected as American Muslims. You know, I wrote something at the time, actually, of Muslim Ban. I wrote an article for CNN called "I am not your American Muslim." "I am not your American Muslim." Because we are not a tool of liberals against conservatives, nor are we simply to be made out to be your villain or your victim.

• 1:19:23Speaker 01

  We're a people of faith. We're people that have values. We're people that want to see our places of worship thrive. We're people that have something to offer to this country, to the people around us of good. But ultimately, we want to engage and be engaged with on the basis of who we actually are, not who you need us to be right now. And that's been the problem that we've had. So it's not a lack of representation as much as a lack of authentic engagement.

• 1:19:58Lex Fridman?

  You mentioned...

• 1:20:01Lex Fridman?

  Daily prayer. And if I may, looking at the time, this might be time. And if it's okay, I would love it if you allow me to follow along, at least in movement as you pray.

• 1:20:18Speaker 01

  Sure, absolutely.

• 1:20:20Lex Fridman?

  Thank you for allowing me to join you in that. Can you maybe describe? What?

• 1:20:30Lex Fridman?

  What does the prayer represent? What is the actual practice of prayer like? What is the process like?

• 1:20:36Speaker 01

  Sure, so prayer is the central pillar, if you will, of Islam. It is the life of the believer encapsulated into a very specific act of devotion that's done at least five times a day. So there are different types of prayer. There's prayer, there's supplication. So the five daily prayers are called Salaah, which is the obligatory prayers. And then beyond that, there are voluntary prayers that are done throughout the day as well. So you can pray before and after the obligatory prayers. And then there are other times of the day that you can pray also. And the best prayer, voluntary prayer is at night, in the middle of the night, because it's the time that you're closest to God.

• 1:21:21Speaker 01

  Sincere, away from the eyes of people, just in the still of the night. And you'd pray in a similar way with the standing and the bowing and the prostration, reciting the Quran. And then you have supplication and words of remembrance that you are to do throughout the day. Between all of that. So when people say, do you pray five times a day? I say at least five times a day.

• 1:21:43Lex Fridman?

  What are the words of supplication? Do they come from the Quran? Or do they come from your own heart? Or do they, where do they come from?

• 1:21:48Speaker 01

  So basically, you say, Allahu Akbar, which means I'm going to kill you, right?

• 1:21:55Speaker 01

  Or so they say, right?

• 1:21:58Speaker 01

  God is greater. You start off with that in expression of God's greatness. And then you recite the opening chapter of the Quran, which is known as Al Fatihah. It's the first chapter of the Quran. In the name of God, the most compassionate, the most merciful. All praises be to God, the Lord of all the worlds, most compassionate, most merciful, master of the day of judgment. You alone we worship, and from you alone we seek help. Guide us to the straight path, the path of those who have earned your favor, not those who have earned your wrath, nor those who have gone astray. So that's a translation of the first chapter, the opening chapter of the Quran, which is known as Ad Fatihah. So we recite that in every one of the units of prayer. And then after that, we recite something else from the Quran. So some other portion of the Quran.

• 1:22:41Speaker 01

  And then we say, Allah Akbar, once again. God is greater. We go into bowing. And in bowing, we say, Subhanallah, Rabbi Al Azeem, Subhanallah, Rabbi Al Azeem, Subhanallah, Rabbi Al Azeem, which means glory be to God, the Almighty. Glory be to God, the Almighty. Glory be to God, the Almighty. And then you come back up and you say, Sami Allah, the one who has praised him. And then the response is, Rabbana, wa lakal hamd. And to you, oh Lord, belongs all praise. And then we go into prostration. And prostration is at the heart of the prayer. And it is the most beautiful portion of the prayer.

• 1:23:22Speaker 01

  And it is the most beloved position for a servant of God and that which is most pleasing to God. It's when you say at that point, Subhanallah, Rabbi Al A'la. All glory be to God, the most high. All glory be to God, the most high. So while you put yourself in the lowest position, you acknowledge God being the most high. And the prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said that the closest that a person is to God is when they are in prostration. That is the time that your supplications are most precious and beloved. That is the time that you can cry your heart out. That is the time that you really feel a sense of great closeness and devotion to God.

• 1:24:04Speaker 01

  And as I was telling you earlier, it's a time that your, your mind is under your heart for a change, right? The only position, physical position, that your mind is actually under your heart. And you really have a chance to pour your emotions out and to connect deeply to God. It's the prayer. Of all of the prophets, uh, Jesus, peace be upon him, is described even biblically as falling on his face in prayer. And so it really is, uh, I think the most intimate moment that you get with God. And the deepest part of the prayer, the word masjid, which is mosque in Arabic, means place of sujood, place of prostration. So think of the rest of prayer as an introduction to that particular part of the prayer where you really immerse yourself.

• 1:24:47Speaker 01

  Not that you shouldn't be immersed in your prayer throughout, but when you're in sujood, when you're in prostration, uh, that's where you're really closest and most connected to God. So we do that. And so some prayers, uh, are, uh, two units. Well, the first prayer of the day, which is before sunrise, the earliest prayer is two units. The second prayer, which is around noon, is four units. And then afternoon, another four units. And then the sunset prayer is three units, and then the evening prayer is four units. So each prayer has a different number of units to it and some voluntary prayers that surround it.

• 1:25:27Speaker 01

  Uh, when you come back up, um, you express also a form of greeting towards God and channeling your prayers and your blessings towards God. You reiterate the shahada, which is the first pillar of Islam. I testify that there is only one God and that Muhammad is his servant and messenger. And then you read what's called Salaah Ibrahimiyah, which is the Abrahamic prayer. So you send peace and blessings upon Muhammad and his family and Abraham and his family. Abraham, peace be upon him, is really at the core of this religion. And so at the prayer, at the end of the prayer, you, you send peace and blessings and prayers upon, again, both Muhammad and his family and Abraham and his family. And then you have another chance to make some of your own personal prayers. And then you say, assalamualaikum warahmatullah.

• 1:26:13Speaker 01

  Peace be on to you and the mercy of God to your right. Peace be on to you and the mercy of God to your left. And that means everything and everyone to your right. Everyone and everything to your left. So you imagine a congregation. Uh, when you're in worship, right, you're, you're sending that to the angels and the human beings next to you, your fellow worshippers next to you. And you'll even say you'll seek forgiveness from God afterwards. There's supplications that surround the prayer. And you will say, Allahumma Antas Salam, Aminkas Salam. That, Oh Allah, Oh God, you are peace, and from you is peace. And to you belongs all glory and all praise. Almost to say that you received something in this prayer.

• 1:26:55Speaker 01

  That you receive a great sense of inner peace, and now you're spreading that, right? So as it really comes into you, then you can give, you can give to the world around you what you generate in your own heart. And in prayer, you generate a great sense of tranquility, a great sense of peace. The Quran says, verily, "In the remembrance of God do hearts find contentment." And prayer is an exercise in the remembrance of God. That is, again, obligatory five times a day, no matter where you are.

• 1:27:26Lex Fridman?

  And you are in the world, anywhere you find yourself in your life, in different life circumstances, anywhere.

• 1:27:34Speaker 01

  Yeah, so outside a coffee shop in the grass, outside of the coffee shop.

• 1:27:38Lex Fridman?

  As it did a few days ago. So anywhere at all, and that means.

• 1:27:44Speaker 01

  Airports included.

• 1:27:45Lex Fridman?

  Given the context of our previous conversation of hatred towards people of Muslim faith, that means you probably, through the practice of prayer, it attracts people that hate.

• 1:27:59Speaker 01

  I've attracted curiosity, I've attracted hate. I've had people walk up to me like, hey, man, you OK? You know, in the airport.

• 1:28:04Lex Fridman?

  So everything, so most probably it's conversations of curiosity and the opportunity to actually talk about the values that you're upset.

• 1:28:13Speaker 01

  And I try to make it a point to tell people, if I'm about to pray in front of them. So like, you know, in the airport, let's say, for example, I'll go to the corner next to a gate. And if there are people sitting there like, hey, I'm about to engage in a prayer, I hope you don't mind, they'll really appreciate the courtesy most of the time. But no, I mean, when those five times come in, and they're kind of windows, right? We have to pray. And that means at work, that means at school, that means when you're traveling. Although there are some concessions that allow you to combine prayers at certain times when you're traveling, for example. But even then, you're gonna have to pray. And I think that what that does to.

• 1:29:00Speaker 01

  Bring you back to God, no matter what you're doing. It's actually, you know, you think of it this way, you're in a meeting, you're engaged in something, you're really stressed out, and you also have the ablution before the prayer, where you wash up, wash your face, wash your limbs, and engage in prayer. What it does for you in anchoring you in something more meaningful, when you are in the turmoil of a lot of times what's not so meaningful, is incredible. And so it's a gift from God. And it is an obligation, it's something that we have to do as Muslims.

• 1:29:40Speaker 01

  But if you actually learn its essence, then it can feel more like a joy than it is an obligation. And then you're called to at night, especially, again, the night prayer is a big part of who we are as Muslims, waking up in the last part of the night. The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, said that the best prayer and the best fasting was of that of David, peace be upon him. So we think of David, Prophet David, he's a prophet in Islam as well. I'm sure you'll ask me about the whole concept of prophethood. You're hearing Abraham and David and others, right? So David, peace be upon him, he said that David used to fast every other day, and he used to pray the last third of the night. He'd stand up and pray in the last third of the night.

• 1:30:21Speaker 01

  So fasting is a big part of who we are, and praying in the last third of the night, meaning before that early morning prayer, you know, waking up if you can at 4:00 a.m., 4:30 a.m., 5:00 a.m., and praying even for a few minutes. There's something in the serenity of the night that can unlock in you a sense of inner joy and peace that nothing else in the world can give you.

• 1:30:50Lex Fridman?

  And again, that pulls you away from all the turmoil of day to day life. If it's little things, or if it's big things, it just pulls it, pulls you out of it to remember what is more important in life.

• 1:31:03Speaker 01

  So when we think about access, in the last third of the night, we're taught that God says, is there anyone seeking forgiveness that I may forgive them? Is there anyone seeking refuge that I may grant it to them? Is there anyone asking for anything that I may give it to them? So whatever you're calling upon him with at that time, he's responding to you in a way that befits him. And so it's closeness as well. And you would think that you sleep less, so you're probably more cranky, but the happiest people in the world are the people that stand up in that last third of the night and pray.

• 1:31:41Lex Fridman?

  I mean, there's a deeply meditative, contemplative aspect to it that I, that I think probably strengthens your sleep if anything else, once you return to it.

• 1:31:53Speaker 01

  There you go. See, people underestimate that. There's a great sage in Islam. He was asked, he said, how come the people who pray at night are the most beautiful of people and they're, they're fresh in the day? It doesn't make sense. And he said, because they secluded themselves with the most merciful, and he dressed them in his light. And so there's a, there's a, there's a beauty that it generates. And that's why we're to aspire to that really, as, as believers, that's kind of your highest thing. Like, don't just pray the five prayers. If you can pray at night, pray at night and connect at that time.

• 1:32:25Lex Fridman?

  Well, a good friend of mine, Andrew Huberman, who's a neuroscientist from Stanford, he's a big, he's a, he has an amazing podcast called Huberman Lab, but he's also a scholar of sleep, among many other things. And so I would love him to, he probably knows the science on this too. There's probably good science that actually studies practicing Muslims to see what

• 1:32:49Lex Fridman?

  the benefits of sleep. I would love to actually see what that says.

• 1:32:52Speaker 01

  We have amazing, I don't want to cut you off, but we have amazing hygiene because of how much we have to wash up for prayer. And it's great for our limbs as well, right? You know, and that's one of the added benefits, right? It's good for us. Worship that we do is not torturous. It's actually good for us. However, the core objective of worship has to remain that it's something you do out of worship and something you do out of a sense of obligation gratitude to God, not because of those things. Like, I'm not going to fast because it's good for my health, but I know it's good for my health to fast. But it's pretty cool when you walk into, I'll share this with you. There was a man, he was a scholar from Turkey, an Islamic scholar from Turkey, and he had visited us in Dallas, and he was

• 1:33:35Speaker 01

  108 years old, and he could still pray bowing and prostrating, I mean, his limbs. And you think about that, like, someone at that age still being able to do that. So I'm sure it's good for your limbs, it's good for your health, good for your gut, good for your sleep, good for your mind.

• 1:33:49Lex Fridman?

  I think the mind one is the really one we've been talking about, and that's really, really, the really the big one. And in the in the small day to day psychological sense and in the big philosophical sense of what it means to be a human being. We should also mention that during the prayer, as you've explained, you should face Mecca. So what is Mecca? And what's the experience of visiting Mecca like?

• 1:34:16Speaker 01

  So Mecca is the home that Abraham, peace be upon him, built along with his son Ishmael, peace be upon him. And it gives the Muslims a unified direction of prayer. It's sort of at the center geographically of who we are. And when we pray towards it,

• 1:34:41Speaker 01

  It's not that, it's not that that's the only place that you can supplicate turn towards, but it gives us a unified sense of direction. It gives us a unified sense of prayer. So Mecca is our qibla. It's our place of direction when we are alive and when we are dead. So actually, we pray facing towards it. When we die, we are also faced towards it in our graves. And it kind of gives us that unifying spirit. So this is the Valley of Bekah. Also, in the Bible, spoken about the Valley of Bekah. And where other biblical scholars would also mention Mount Paran.

• 1:35:19Speaker 01

  And it is the place that Adam, in the Quran, Adam, peace be upon him, first had a place constructed there as a place of worship from the angels towards God. And then when Abraham settles Hagar and Ishmael in Mecca, they build this house of worship. And that is where the gushing springs of Zamzam are mentioned, where God sends an angel to give a miracle to Hagar and Ishmael that they can sustain themselves from, as they're not left in the desert. So Ishmael, being the firstborn son of Abraham, is given a place.

• 1:36:01Speaker 01

  And there's a story and a history that's going to unfold from that place of Mecca. And then Isaac is born, peace be upon him, 13 years later. And there's a story and a history that comes from that. But ultimately, Mecca is the center. Mecca is where we turn towards for prayer. Mecca is where we perform the pilgrimage, the Hajj pilgrimage. Once in our lives, at least if we can physically and financially, if we find ourselves capable, we at least perform the Hajj pilgrimage once in our lifetimes. But there are other pilgrimages throughout the year. You can go at any time of the day, any time of the year, you will

• 1:36:40Speaker 01

  find people that will be performing the pilgrimage, an iteration of the pilgrimage in Mecca. And it's an incredible practice. It really is a place where...

• 1:36:55Speaker 01

  You feel like you're no longer in this world. I mean, it's incredible. So we all go there, donning what's known as the Ihram garb. So the men will wear just these white garments, which are resembling, or they resemble the garments that we will be buried in. And whether you're a king, or a prince, or a peasant, and you know, in classical terms, whoever you are, whatever distinction you have, you're all the same. And the women will wear a simple garment as well. So you go there, you relinquish all of the pretensions, and concerns, and superficial barriers and distinctions

• 1:37:40Speaker 01

  that exist in this life. And we do what's called Tawaf, circle around the Kaaba, symbolically putting God at the center of our lives. We do seven rounds between Safa and Marwa, the two mountains, where Hagar, when she once ran between those two mountains with her baby Ishmael, looking for water, trusting God, was provided for. We too go between the two mountains of Safa and Marwa to express that trust in God and to follow in that way. And these are ultimately, these are the rituals that Abraham himself engaged in, in our tradition, and the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, engaged in. And so we engage in the exact same rituals. And there are divine wisdoms to them

• 1:38:25Speaker 01

  that we may not even be able to unpack and reflect upon. But it really is in that place where you find the most beautiful global expression of Islam. You see people from all over the world, people that don't speak the same languages, people from all sorts of backgrounds, and they're all doing the exact same thing. And in a matter of seconds, when the call of prayer comes, in a matter of seconds, two, three million people get arranged in perfect rows for prayer, right? And it just, it looks like this perfect optical, you know, vision of just beauty when you see people.

• 1:39:05Speaker 01

  In unison, standing, bowing, prostrating. And you don't know who the person next to you is. And that's where, you know, you, you know, Malcolm X, you read about the history of Malcolm X. When he went to Hajj, that's where his entire worldview shifts. Not just his previous baggage, but the dream that he then had, the possibilities that he saw for people to be able to overcome some of the false distinctions that we have. Race and class. And to see God as one and to come together. And worship Him alone and also seeing each other, equal participants in that worship.

• 1:39:50Lex Fridman?

  If you could just linger on it a little bit.

• 1:39:54Lex Fridman?

  I think you've mentioned that Malcolm X has been in part misunderstood. What are some aspects of him that are misunderstood?

• 1:40:02Speaker 01

  I think reading his autobiography is

• 1:40:06Speaker 01

  extremely important for anyone that wants to understand him, right? So you read him, his own words. Malcolm lived the tragedy of being a young disenfranchised black man in America who went through all of the difficulties that were posed in a 1950s America towards him. I mean, he went through the system and it was awful for him. And he had to pull himself out of that and make himself into an incredible orator, an incredible leader. That suddenly had a pretty empowering vision and a calm and, and, and nonetheless courageous, but a calm presence to him.

• 1:40:48Speaker 01

  And was able to bring together people, especially uplift black people in America to believe in themselves. Young, young men in America, in, in prisons in particular, will read the autobiography of Malcolm X and see hope for themselves to come out of the darkness of, you know, being imprisoned, not just by the bars in front of them, but also by what they thought to be their own worth prior to that moment. And so Malcolm climbs out of that and he goes through multiple phases. So Malcolm dies as an Orthodox Muslim.

• 1:41:28Speaker 01

  Who does not believe in the superiority of one race over the other, finds great tranquility in the practice of the Hajj, great clarity. And I think you read his letters from Mecca, and he talks about his change, his transformation in particular. And it was a process. It's a process for him. But he inspires the likes of Muhammad Ali to become the person that he becomes, and inspires many other people till today to really see themselves and see the world differently in light of that understanding of monotheism.

• 1:42:07Lex Fridman?

  So he was deeply a man of faith. And throughout his life, the nature of that faith has changed as he grew, as he interacted with, I would say, a cruel society that he was living through.

• 1:42:22Speaker 01

  Right, right.

• 1:42:24Lex Fridman?

  You mentioned he inspired Muhammad Ali, who I don't think is an overstatement to say is probably the most, quite possibly, the most famous American Muslim from America. Could you maybe make a few comments as an athlete yourself? What impact did Islam have on Muhammad Ali's life? And what, and vice versa? What impact did he have as a leader, as a religious figure, on the Muslim community?

• 1:42:57Speaker 01

  I think Muhammad Ali, his quotes on Islam are precious because he talks about how he sought the wealth of this world and he found it in Islam. He found a greater meaning and he attributes everything that he became to his faith, his sense of strength and commitment, the willingness to take a stand for the truth when it was extremely unpopular, on the basis of his faith and on the basis of his integrity. I think that he inspired people with his confidence and...

• 1:43:38Speaker 01

  His coherence, I mean, he was incredibly eloquent. I mean poetic. And just unwavering. Seemed unbreakable. So as relentless as he was in the ring, he was even more so outside of the ring. The man could not be broken. And everything was stacked up against him. But he perseveres and he does so then through Parkinson's. And chooses to live a life of of giving, a life of service, a life of using his platform. To bring up issues of importance and to champion the rights of others. So he wasn't satisfied at any point in his life with simply being a boxing great, a boxing champion. He uses it for so much more.

• 1:44:24Speaker 01

  And so he goes down as one of the most famous Americans period of the 20th century, one of the most transformative Americans period of the 20th century, not just American Muslims. And a lot of people that loved him when he died would not have loved him if they were around in the 1960s and the 1970s. You know, they said they loved him when he couldn't speak anymore. You know, many of those who celebrated him at the time of his death would have been his greatest opponents at the peak of his career. And when he was taking the stance that he was taking.

• 1:44:54Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, he was fearless and part of this, his faith was helping him take the fearless stance. But throughout all of it, given the strength, I think he's also a symbol of compassion. Through all the, through all the fun, kind of. Yeah, the poetic nature of who he was and the fearless nature of who he was, there's always like a, like a deep love for, for the sport and for humanity.

• 1:45:19Speaker 01

  Absolutely. And that's the thing, right? It was so obvious that despite everything that had happened to him.

• 1:45:26Speaker 01

  He never loses himself, neither to the fame nor to the fear.

• 1:45:31Lex Fridman?

  Yeah.

• 1:45:32Speaker 01

  He, he always. Stays himself. He's authentic. And you know, and I went to his funeral and it was one of the most beautiful things I'd ever seen because everyone in Louisville, Kentucky, had a story with Muhammad Ali, right? The guy that he saves from committing suicide. The school kids, the hotel shuttle driver, the gas station worker. Everyone has a story of Muhammad Ali in Louisville, Kentucky. And when he when he passes away, everybody comes out and stands in front of their homes and they take the casket and they drive around the streets of Louisville.

• 1:46:14Speaker 01

  And he had this dream, I'm very close to some of his, some of his children. Incredible people, by the way, just incredible human beings. And he had this dream that he shared with them that he was jogging around the streets of Louisville, Kentucky. And everyone had come out to wave to him. And so he's running around jogging and waving to everybody in the streets of Louisville, Kentucky. Then he gets to the cemetery and he says he flies into the heavens. So his, his dream, and he had this dream years ago. And if you look at his funeral, it's such a beautiful. You can't make it up. It's such a beautiful

• 1:46:55Speaker 01

  moment where it seems to come to reality because everybody in Louisville just comes out and just waves by to his casket. And then when he gets to the cemetery, the gates close and he goes off to be with his Lord and we pray that it's a good place for him.

• 1:47:10Lex Fridman?

  So Muhammad Ali is probably one of the great 20th century representatives of Islam. For me personally, at least, hope I'm not showing my bias. One of the great modern representatives is Khabib Nurmagomedov, who's a great fighter and a great human being. So you've gotten a chance to meet him. I should also say you're friends, you're good friends with a lot of really interesting Muslim people. I mean, it's such a widespread religion. There's just so much variety of different people that are practicing Muslims. So what

• 1:47:44Lex Fridman?

  does Khabib represent? What do you like about him as a Muslim? What do you like about him as a person, as representative of the religion?

• 1:47:51Speaker 01

  I think, I think Habib.

• 1:47:54Speaker 01

  First of all, he is a great person, you know, humble person. He's shown, and now Islam as well, kind of following in that. They're really showing the beauty of faith in their lives, their culture, their values. Everything from the way that he carried himself in a principled way. You know, like, like every Muslim kid grew up in a public school cafeteria before Islamic schools were a thing in the United States, not eating pork, for example, and kind of being the odd person out. So when you got a fighter in the UFC scene and doesn't drink alcohol, kind of maintains

• 1:48:34Speaker 01

  like a very consistent, principled, you know, attachment to his religion. It really is inspiring. Growing up, we had Hakeem Olajuwon in the 1990s, basketball, who was fasting in the NBA. I think Habib was, is that for a lot of people, a lot of young people today and people in general. And I think beyond that, the values, how he honored his father and how he honors his mother and how he continues to put family first. That's a beautiful part of Islam. That's a beautiful part of our value system. We have a lot of emphasis on family. Family is central to Islam. And his honoring of his father was so beautiful.

• 1:49:19Speaker 01

  And again, what he's willing to do for his mother, you know, it's just so beautiful. And I think that we saw it frankly, even with Morocco in the World Cup. You know, there was a lot of Islamophobia in this recent World Cup episode. You know, a lot of the criticism of Qatar, while no government is beyond reproach, certainly no government is beyond reproach, but had very obvious blatant Islamophobic undertones. And then with Morocco rising, being the first African Muslim Arab team, you know, to get that far in the World Cup, what did you see? Beyond the consistent honoring of Palestine, you also saw the honoring of the mothers. Every single time the game would end, they go into a prostration of gratitude.

• 1:50:04Speaker 01

  So just like we prostrate in prayer, a prostration of gratitude. And then they go and they kiss their mothers' foreheads, dance with their mothers on the field, hug their moms and honor their moms. That's Islam for you. Habib, after his fight, what does he do? He prostrates. He points up to the heavens. It's God. And then he prostrates.

• 1:50:24Speaker 01

  The whole Moroccan team beautifully prostrates. Even when they lost, they prostrated out of gratitude. They honored their mothers. So I think sometimes athletes are able to demonstrate some of these beautiful values of Islam in a way that the world can maybe see them in a different light.

• 1:50:41Lex Fridman?

  Values of humility and the values of love. Love broadly, but love for family.

• 1:50:47Speaker 01

  And look how everyone around Habib talks about him. Right? No one ever, no one ever says he's a jerk. No one ever says he's mistreated them. They've all got stories, right? And that's what a beautiful Muslim does. Beautiful human being. You treat the people in such a way that all these stories come out later of how good you were to everyone that came into contact with you. And Habib was that person. He is that person. He does a great job of treating people with a lot of respect. Obviously, no one is perfect, right? I mean, imperfections are for everybody, but

• 1:51:24Speaker 01

  I definitely think that he did a beautiful job representing his faith in those moments.

• 1:51:31Speaker 01

  You know, beyond punching people in the face. That's kind of a different subject. Smashing faces. Not the smashing faces part, the prostration part and the humility. I tell you, man, he's not humble in the ring, right? He's a, he would maul his opponents, right? But

• 1:51:48Lex Fridman?

  I mean, as a practitioner, as a fan of the sport, of all grappling sports, for me, there's also a beauty to the art of grappling and the fighting sports. But yes.

• 1:52:00Lex Fridman?

  I think his, again, humility, his honor outside the cage is exemplary. And the money, the fame, the power hasn't changed the man.

• 1:52:12Speaker 01

  No, not at all. And that's, that's actually, I think, the most beautiful part. When I met him, I found him to be as humble as he is on screen. And that's always very endearing. And all of the stories of the people that have been around him for a much longer time. Very humble man. I pray for him, honestly. I pray for Islam. I pray for that family. That God keeps them grounded, protected, and together. And that they maintain that beautiful spirit. Because even if you if you just watch the lead up of to the last the last fight with Islam, just the way they carry themselves their day to day. You know, they never relinquish their prayers.

• 1:52:51Speaker 01

  They never relinquish their family ties, the things that make them who they are to be better fighters. Because they don't see that. They have to let go of those things. In fact, they attribute all of their worldly success to that that faith. And so beautiful examples. And I think that it's good for young Muslims to see themselves in that. And it's good for other people to see Islam through that as well.

• 1:53:19Lex Fridman?

  When you mention the prophets, you often say peace and blessings be upon them.

• 1:53:25Speaker 01

  Yes.

• 1:53:27Lex Fridman?

  What does that phrase mean? Is why do you say it? Is it to celebrate the people? Is it is a constant reminder that these are figures that should be celebrated?

• 1:53:38Speaker 01

  Absolutely. So it's part of our tradition that when we say the name of a prophet, at least the first time in the conversation, we say peace be upon him. And then afterwards, it's still praiseworthy to say peace be upon him. So if you're reading an Islamic article and you see in parentheses, P B U H. Peace be on to him or peace be upon him. When I was in high school, I often tell the story. I wrote an article about Jesus, peace be upon him in Islam and Christianity. And my teacher comes up to me and she says, you can't do that. And I said, what? And she like slams the paper on on the desk. She says, you can't say Jesus.

• 1:54:16Speaker 01

  And I said, no, no. P B U H, peace be upon him. So that's what it means and something that we reserve for the prophets of God and we honor them with.

• 1:54:27Lex Fridman?

  So who is Muhammad?

• 1:54:30Speaker 01

  So the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, is the descendant of Abraham, peace be upon him, through Ishmael. God promises Hagar and Ishmael that he will make of him a great nation. And so there are prophets that are descended from Isaac. And then from the brothers of Isaac comes the Prophet Muhammad. And he is the final prophet of a long line of prophets. And we do not distinguish between the prophets in regards to their role. And so Islam has a very accessible theology. It's something that resonates with a professor at an Ivy League university and, you know, a person who may be even illiterate.

• 1:55:14Speaker 01

  This idea of one God that sent many prophets and all of the prophets had a singular message, worship one God and respond to the messages of that one God through his messengers. So Adam, through Muhammad, you have many of the prophets that are mentioned in the Old Testament. Moses, peace be upon him, being the most spoken about prophet in the Quran. In fact, Abraham, Jesus, peace be upon him, many of these prophets that are familiar to people, all of them are considered prophets. In Islam, the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, being the last of them. He comes at a time where there was still a lot of confusion about what the world had

• 1:55:57Speaker 01

  just encountered in Christ, in Jesus Christ, peace be upon him. So you got to think about it this way, that this is still, you know, he's born in the sixth century. There is still great debate about who Jesus was. The Council of Nicaea happens in the fourth century, where you kind of have a standardizing of Western Christianity. But then you have Eastern Christians that are still maintaining very different theologies and very different conceptions of Christ. There is no Arabic Bible at the time. And he kind of brings together the message and the mission of all of those prophets,

• 1:56:38Speaker 01

  and it fits perfectly into a singular string of thought where you don't have to reject Jesus, peace be upon him, but Islam also is staunchly opposed to the idea of a trinity, the idea of a begotten son of God. That all the conceptions of the Messiah, and there were many claimants of the Messiah, prior to Christ, peace be upon him. None of them included an idea of Trinity, or of him actually being a part of God Himself, a begotten Son of God, but rather a great and mighty prophet that would restore glory on earth. So he really captures theologically, or rather, we would say God captures through him theologically,

• 1:57:23Speaker 01

  a coherence and a unifying message of all of the prophets, that there's only one God, and that that God has sent messages and scriptures to ultimately guide people back towards Him. And that all of the prophets are equal in the sight of God. There's no distinction between them. And that we are to live our lives in accordance with the message as best manifested by the messenger. And so the prophets are exemplary human beings. And this is where we kind of sometimes maybe have a difference. You know, someone will say, well, you know, Noah did this, and David did this. As Muslims, we don't believe, we don't hold many of the stories that have been attributed

• 1:58:08Speaker 01

  to these prophets to be true. We don't believe that the prophets are capable of major sins. We believe they're exemplary human beings. And that they kind of give us a manifestation of the scriptures that they were sent with, of how to live noble lives. And the most documented human being in history is the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. We know everything about him, his family life, his day to day, the way he would greet you, the way he'd look at you, everything about his physical appearance. It's documented in immaculate detail. And Muslims have a standard that they then seek to live up to with how to treat your family, how to be in your community, how to be in your worship, how to be in your social interactions, how to care yourself with your neighbors.

• 1:58:52Speaker 01

  It's a full, complete guidebook through his example, where we have the Quran, which is the word of God. And then you have the biography of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, which is a living manifestation of that word that has been documented for us to live by until the end of time.

• 1:59:14Lex Fridman?

  So Muhammad, if I may, peace be upon him.

• 1:59:20Lex Fridman?

  Is really the, like you said, the manifestation, the thing to be, the example of a good man?

• 1:59:27Speaker 01

  Yes, example of a good human being.

• 1:59:31Lex Fridman?

  Is the Quran the word of God?

• 1:59:33Speaker 01

  So the Quran, and this is what distinguishes the Quran in many ways from other scriptures. So as Muslims, we do believe that God has sent divine revelation prior. We believe that the original scriptures, prior to the multiple versions and the changes and revisions throughout history, the original scriptures that were given to the prophets, whether it was the Torah to Moses or the Gospels, were all original divine revelations. But they've been changed over time. The Quran is the word of God with a promise that he will guard it for all of time. And it's probably one of the greatest miracles because in 1400 years,

• 2:00:16Speaker 01

  we have the Quran preserved through oral transmission and through written transmission. And there are almost 2 billion Muslims in the world and they all recite this book the exact same way. And there's only one version of it. And so when I'm reciting the Quran, if I say "u" or "i" or "a" differently, an Ethiopian Muslim, a Chinese Muslim, a Yemeni Muslim can correct me. An eight-year-old kid in any one of those countries can correct me because they will know that this is not how it's memorized. And so it was memorized from the start, committed to memory in the time of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him,

• 2:00:54Speaker 01

  and preserved in writing and passed down and memorized by millions and millions of people around the world. And it's 600 pages. And you can't go to a city in America, a city in the United States of America, and not find at least one person or a group of people that memorize it, that have committed it to memory. And so there's an emphasis on committing it to memory as well as understanding it and applying it and practicing it as much as we can.

• 2:01:27Lex Fridman?

  What are some maybe deep or insightful differences between the Quran, the Torah, and the Bible?

• 2:01:38Speaker 01

  Well, like I said, so you've got the original revelations of those scriptures, but there are so many versions of those scriptures, and there are times throughout history where there have been changes, just from an objective perspective, right? What is the original scripture that was given to Moses, peace be upon him? And what was initially communicated to Jesus, peace be upon him? Those things have changed over time. However, there's still some truth that remains even in those scriptures. And so there are still things that line up, especially with the Old Testament and Islam. There are still many things that line up between the two.

• 2:02:21Speaker 01

  The Bible as well, the New Testament. Now, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, it's different because these are not original scriptures. These are testimonies that were obviously collected around the entire phenomenon of the coming of Christ. But the authors themselves, the biographies, the documentation even of those original testimonies and gospels, what made the cut in terms of being included within the gospels and what didn't, because there were many gospels at the time in that sense, is different from what we believe was scripture communicated to Jesus, peace be upon him. The Quran is different in several ways, but it confirms what came before it.

• 2:03:04Speaker 01

  But it's the documented and preserved word of God to be recited throughout time. So it confirms much of what came before it, and it resides amongst us and within us for the rest of time. And through it, we honor those revelations that came through the prophets of old, because the essence, the core of what came through those revelations is preserved in the Quran and with us. And I tell people this all the time, that the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, introduced Uh, Jesus, peace be upon him. And even Moses, peace be upon him, to much of the world.

• 2:03:47Speaker 01

  There are Muslims around the world that are named Isa, that are named Jesus. There are Muslims around the world that are named Ibrahim, Muslims around the world named Musa. And they learned of these figures through the revelation that came to the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. Nooh, Noah, Maryam, one of the most popular names in Islam, Mary. Peace be upon her, a whole chapter in the Quran named after Maryam, which is actually what I was reciting in the prayer was the chapter of Maryam, the chapter of the story of Mary, peace be upon her. So the Quran contains the stories, it contains legislation and law, but primarily it was revealed over 23 years.

• 2:04:28Speaker 01

  So it actually was coming in accordance with some of the events that were unfolding in the life of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. The first 13 years of that was primarily belief in God, belief in the hereafter, and things that surrounded the core creed of Islam. And then legislation, law, stories of the prophets came down in accordance with the unfolding events, as well as prophesizing some of the things that were to come. And speaking about some of the things that had just happened. And it is completed in the lifetime of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, memorized, and then communicated to generation after generation after generation, so that we have it in its pristine fashion.

• 2:05:07Lex Fridman?

  Now billions of people, just all across the world, all the different cultures, all memorizing the same words. One of the pillars, or maybe I should say, one of the central practices is the month of Ramadan. What is the importance of this month? What does the process of it entail also?

• 2:05:31Speaker 01

  So Islam has, I think it'd be good to maybe lay this out for people. The Articles of Faith and the Pillars of Islam. So the Articles of Faith, there are six Articles of Faith, and this kind of lays the foundation for the creed of Islam. So belief in God, belief in the angels, belief in the messages, belief in the messengers, okay? Belief in the Day of Judgment and belief in divine decree. So these are the six Articles of Faith. Belief in God, belief in the angels, belief in the messages being the scriptures, belief in the messengers being the prophets, belief in the day of judgment and belief in divine decree.

• 2:06:10Speaker 01

  That's what you have to believe to be a Muslim. You have to believe in those six things, right? And then you go to the pillars of faith, the five pillars of faith are sort of, or they make up the structure of those articles of faith, the practice of the Muslim. So to be a Muslim, you testify that there's only one God worthy of worship and unconditional obedience. And then you testify that Muhammad is the final messenger of God. That's the first pillar. It's the actual testimony entering into Islam. Then it's the five daily prayers, practicing the five daily prayers, at least as a bare minimum obligation. The mandatory charity, which is called the zakat, that Muslims have to give at least 2.5%

• 2:06:56Speaker 01

  of their retained earnings to specific categories of charity. Then it is the fasting of the month of Ramadan, the mandatory fasting of the month of Ramadan. And then it's the Hajj, if you can do so, the pilgrimage, if you can do so once in your lifetime. So those are the five pillars of Islam. So Ramadan is a month in which Muslims engage in this incredible spiritual boot camp. Now fasting can mean different things to different people. When we fast, we fast from before sunrise to sunset for an entire month. And there's no food or water, period, and no intimacy as well. So you would abstain from intimacy with your spouse as well in that time.

• 2:07:40Speaker 01

  No food or water, no bread, no nothing. You don't eat or drink, even if you live in Texas, where you get these long, hot days in the summer. And of course, Islam is on a lunar calendar, so it moves every year, about 10 days earlier.

• 2:07:56Speaker 01

  During that time, you restrict the intake to the body so that you can focus on the intake of the soul. So instead of being focused on consumption, constant consumption, you are consuming words of remembrance, words of prayer. You're to be hyper-conscious of not doing anything that would spiritually validate your fast, just as you would physically. So just like you won't eat or drink, you certainly won't engage in sin, though you shouldn't engage in sins throughout the year, but you know, you're not going to speak words of evil, you're not going to gossip or slander. You try to fast with your eyes, not look at things that are not praiseworthy.

• 2:08:36Speaker 01

  So you try to engage in a wholesome act of disciplining yourself with a consciousness of God, but then channel that into engaging the soul instead, exercising the soul instead. And what you'll find with Muslims and this act of God consciousness, where they reduce the consumption is they become far more grateful for the blessings of God, because throughout our lives, we just take sips of water, we eat what we can, we snack. When you're abstaining from that, you become so much more grateful for that sip of water, so much more grateful for that bite of food, so much more aware of the one who provided those blessings to you, so much more aware of those that don't have the same access to those blessings that you have.

• 2:09:18Speaker 01

  So you also develop a sense of empathy for the poor that don't have access to those blessings on a regular basis, that can't help but fast. And on top of that, again, spiritually, you are engaged in extra reading. At that time, people are listening to more lectures, people are engaged in extra acts of devotion, extra acts of charity. Muslims are most charitable in the month of Ramadan. So you just feel great. And it's hard to explain to someone that doesn't do it, because it sounds like torture to people, right? What in the world are you doing, you know, four o'clock on a hot Texas day, not eating or drinking? You're probably dehydrated and cranky, have a caffeine headache, and you probably can't wait for this month to be over.

• 2:10:01Speaker 01

  But in reality, you talk to Muslims, their favorite time of the year is Ramadan. You feel amazing, you feel absolutely incredible, because you taste a different type of consumption. You feed your soul for a change. And in that process, you connect with God in a way.

• 2:10:19Speaker 01

  That you simply could not without the distractions of the day to day throughout the year. Now, it's good that it's one month of the year because it's honestly physically taxing, right? So it gives you a chance to experience it for that one month, but then you're encouraged to fast a few days of the year as well outside of the month of Ramadan to keep that connection.

• 2:10:39Lex Fridman?

  What are the hardest parts that maybe for people outside of the Muslim faith? Yeah, we'll be curious about.

• 2:10:51Speaker 01

  Well, I think the hardest part is physically.

• 2:10:57Lex Fridman?

  Is it physical or is it the spiritual?

• 2:10:58Speaker 01

  I mean. So as Ramadan goes on, your acts of worship increase. So in the last 10 nights of Ramadan, there is an intense period of prayer throughout the night. So every night in Ramadan, we have something called the Tathawich prayers. The Tathawich prayers are about an hour, hour and a half of prayer outside of the five daily prayers. So the mosques are packed every night in Ramadan. The last 10 nights of Ramadan, people will engage in prayer throughout the entire night. So the only sleep that you're probably getting is actually a couple of hours in the morning before you go to work. So it's everything sort of put together, the disruption of schedule, the disruption

• 2:11:40Speaker 01

  of diet, the physically exerting yourself. But the way you feel is unmatched. I mean, you feel so fulfilled through that deprivation. And it's actually the point, you know, it all ties back together when you talk about even tests and trials, that God does not deprive us of anything except that He gives us something greater in return. And you do not deprive yourself of anything for the sake of God, except that He gives you something greater in return. And so fasting is an exercise in patience that unlocks an infinite sense of gratitude and a greater connection to God.

• 2:12:22Lex Fridman?

  Many people predict that Islam will surpass Christianity as the largest religion by the end of the century, by the number of its adherents and practitioners. What responsibility does that place on people like you, who is a religious leader, who is somebody who teaches, who grows, who cares for the community, for the Muslim community, but actually for all people?

• 2:12:43Speaker 01

  Well, I think what that means is that we have a responsibility to teach and live our faith in the most beautiful of ways, that its values and ideals are not just expressed by you, but experienced by everyone around you. And so what I often teach my community is that, look at the Muslims in the area, what are they, what are your neighbors experiencing of you? What are people experiencing of you? You know, and there's, there are statistics to Muslims being the most charitable communities in America, where a community of great service, a community of volunteer, a community that greatly enriches the world around us.

• 2:13:24Speaker 01

  I think that oftentimes, people forget the history of Muslims, you know, being at the forefront of contributing in the areas of medicine and science and all sorts of ways, education, really changing the world through their commitment to faith. But on a deeply personal level, you know, it's important for us to be representatives of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, in a way that makes Islamophobia impossible. I, you know, I tell people this, that it's very hard, you know, you mentioned the United States of Hate, the documentary, and the one man, the protester who met me and sort of changed his worldview.

• 2:14:09Speaker 01

  It's very hard for people to believe what they hear about Islam if they see you live it. Now, that does not excuse bigotry. That doesn't excuse the prejudice against Muslims. But it's important for us to sort of take it as a responsibility as Muslims to channel our faith in the most beautiful of ways. God describes faith in the Quran, in the chapter of Abraham, peace be upon him, as "a tree with firm foundations." The firm foundation being the testimony of faith, the oneness of God. So the tree of monotheism with firm foundations, and then branches high in the sky, providing shade to everything and everyone around you, and producing fruit at all times.

• 2:14:53Speaker 01

  The tree of faith of a Muslim is not seasonal. So you should be producing with your faith at all times, good works and things that people can can actually experience. And I think that Muslims have historically contributed to the world around them. And I think that Muslims today are still contributing to the world around them. But I think that we can never do enough of holding ourselves accountable to the message that we hold dear to our hearts, and trying to be the best representatives of that message and of that messenger to the world around us.

• 2:15:30Lex Fridman?

  So not only are you a religious leader in the Muslim community, but you have a lot of friends who are from different religions. You have a lot of Jewish friends, as we've talked about a lot offline. And we'll probably, hopefully, get a chance to talk to as well here. But on that topic, let me bring up another tragic event that was just a little bit less than a year ago. In this very community here in Dallas, there was a synagogue hostage crisis. Can you describe what happened? And what was your experience like through it and afterwards? And what were the bad things you saw? And what are the good things you saw in the community?

• 2:16:17Speaker 01

  The Colleyville synagogue situation, it's kind of surreal that we're coming up on a year of that. But I'll actually tell you exactly what happened that morning. I was out with the family. And that morning, I kid you not, that very morning, I was telling my kids the story of Muhammad Ali talking that man out of committing suicide off the roof. And I showed them the YouTube video. My wife pulled it up on her phone. Kids were sitting in the backseat. We talked about that, that video and talked about that importance of helping people. We also went to visit a loved one in the cemetery that day. And we went to breakfast. So we're out as a family that day, right? And there's a lot of meaning that's sort of coming together.

• 2:17:01Speaker 01

  For us and a lot of discussion, deep discussion we're having as a family. And then some of our community groups, we get this message that there is a synagogue that's been taken hostage. A rabbi and his congregation taken as hostages and go to this Facebook link and it was the feed of the synagogue. And you could hear the gunman shouting. And it became apparent

• 2:17:30Speaker 01

  very early on that it was a man that was claiming to be Muslim that was holding them hostage. Now, all these synagogue massacres, all these places of worship, were not attacked by Muslims, right? This is

• 2:17:44Speaker 01

  a different type of situation, but

• 2:17:49Speaker 01

  my first instinct was like all that happened this morning was not random. So I told my wife and I told my kids, I'm gonna go down there. It's a Colleyville.

• 2:18:04Speaker 01

  She was very supportive. Obviously, there was a moment of shock. And my kids were like, wait, what? And I said, look, remember what we talked about this morning?

• 2:18:15Speaker 01

  We can't be indifferent to the stuff. We still go back and revisit that day. You know, like, it's crazy how it was all falling into place. It's not an accident, right? So I dropped them off at home and I started to drive to Colleyville. I called the Irving Police Department and I asked them to call the Colleyville Police Department so that they could kind of know that I'm coming down there. I called some of the faith leaders in the community to see if they could put me in touch with those on the ground so that I wouldn't get shot when I showed up there. And eventually I had to wait out outside until I got clearance to come through and to just offer whatever support I could, pastoral support,

• 2:19:00Speaker 01

  support with trying to free the hostages of the synagogue. At the time, it was operating out of a church right across the street from the synagogue.

• 2:19:11Speaker 01

  A day long, just wondering, you know, what was going to happen? Looking at the family of the rabbi at the time, wondering what was going to happen? And trying to just be as supportive as I possibly could at that time. Thankfully, they all got out in the evening. And I think that, you know, looking back on that day,

• 2:19:41Speaker 01

  like, my wife actually asked me, she said, would you have done it differently? And I said, no, I really wouldn't, because I think that that things happen sometimes, you've got to act on your good instincts sometimes, right? We talk about like being calculated. I think sometimes we're calculated when we shouldn't be, and that's when that good instinct comes in, where you're called to do something else, so.

• 2:20:03Lex Fridman?

  What did it feel like to be a Muslim in a situation like that? I mean, did you, was there, were you a human being? Were you a religious?

• 2:20:12Speaker 01

  Yeah, I don't.

• 2:20:13Lex Fridman?

  Practitioner?

• 2:20:14Speaker 01

  I don't, I don't, see, I can't, I can't separate anything about myself in that situation, right? So when I had to pray, I had to pray to help people out, to give people words of comfort, to try to appeal to the senses of whoever I could at the time. I didn't see myself as like a guy trying to.

• 2:20:39Speaker 01

  Trying to show a particular part of Islam there. I just saw myself as someone that was trying to help a family get their their husband and father back, right? And so it was more of just like that part of me was was there. You know, you can you can kind of see yourself, right? And this is the irony of it. When Christchurch, New Zealand happened, that was kind of our worst nightmare as Texas Muslims, because we've had armed groups in front of our mosques threatening to do what that men did in Christchurch. And so when you see a wife and kids, um, wondering if they're going to get their their dad back, you kind of see yourself there. And so I just saw myself in that situation. What would I want people to be doing for me in that moment? What would I want people to be telling my family in that moment?

• 2:21:24Speaker 01

  So that's really where I went to, and that's really where where I dug into. And I prayed a lot that day, a lot, a lot for the right words, for the right actions, what I could do to just help.

• 2:21:38Lex Fridman?

  What are the lessons now, a year later, that you take away from that day? And the days?

• 2:21:44Speaker 01

  So many lessons, just don't be indifferent. Don't be indifferent to the suffering around you, even that's distant from you, because it's somehow related to you. So just don't be indifferent.

• 2:21:58Lex Fridman?

  So you you're proud that you stepped up and you went there and then?

• 2:22:02Speaker 01

  Yeah, look, I don't I don't think um, I don't think I did much. I'm being really honest. This is not me trying to be humble here. I don't think I did much. I think I did what I was what I was called to do. I wish that it never happened, right, as a whole, but I'm glad that the relationships that have been built over time came into being in that day, right? We could call upon people that we knew, call upon each other, and as a community really come together, you know? Dallas has been through a lot, a lot of pain, but we've come together through a lot of pain as well. So it's it's kind of one of those things where we're united in our pain.

• 2:22:44Speaker 01

  You know, when you suffer together, you build you build certain bonds together. So Dallas has been through a lot as a community, but we've we've come together through a lot as a community.

• 2:22:56Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, the thing about violence and war, it destroys, it causes so much suffering, but it also sort of brings out some of the best aspects of human nature and unites people. It's a, it's an interesting way how our human civilization functions.

• 2:23:11Speaker 01

  Well, that's the beauty that you don't just want to see, but you also want to be. You know, we're living in a climate where there's a lot of that, right? So how do you, how do you actually get through that and actually not allow yourself to succumb to that? And be another voice in that polarization?

• 2:23:38Lex Fridman?

  It seems that throughout history and still in the world today, religion has been a source of some of the, of a lot of polarization, a lot of conflict, even war. Why do you think that is?

• 2:23:53Speaker 01

  Listen, I think at the essence of it is always some sort of political instability that leaves behind a brutalized population and vulnerabilities that can be exploited. As I said, in the 20th century, with the bloodiest century that we've had to date, where does religion fall in any of that? Where does religion fall in the isms? Where does religion fall in the world wars? Where does religion fall in, in much of that? Even when we talk about things like the Crusades, remove the Islamic framing, the Crusades, the Crusades, were they really about religion? The Mongols and the destruction of the Mongols,

• 2:24:37Speaker 01

  was it about religion? Myanmar and the Rohingya today, is it about Buddhism? So I think that these are essentially political issues, political causes, where you have people that rise up and that use religion to disguise things that are far, far, far from religion. And if you want to manipulate a religious scripture, you could turn any book, any scripture, into a violent scripture if you have a violent aim. So I think that that's where you find people manipulating versus manipulating religion to justify sick ideologies that are based

• 2:25:20Speaker 01

  And thrive in political instability.

• 2:25:23Lex Fridman?

  So these are fundamentally political geopolitical conflicts, not religious conflicts.

• 2:25:28Speaker 01

  Absolutely. Look, when you talk about a group like ISIS. Islam has been in Iraq for a very, very long time.

• 2:25:37Speaker 01

  Iraq has been bombed by now five consecutive presidents, or four. It's been bombed into the Stone Ages. There is no political infrastructure. It's devastation and destruction and desperation as a result of that. Many of the old Saddam loyalists and Saddam's regime was was a secularist regime. Are now heads of ISIS, right? It just moved into that. When you create that type of chaos, you generate an environment where groups like ISIS are bound to rise out of. And so Islam did not, you know, cause this. People didn't wake up in Iraq one day and say, hey, let's create a group called ISIS. Because Islam tells us to, right?

• 2:26:22Speaker 01

  Iraq was bombed into this place. And we have to not just free religion from the responsibility, from having to bear the responsibility of much of the hatred and violence. But we have to interrogate the political instability that was caused. Were we justified?

• 2:26:49Speaker 01

  As Americans, these are our taxpayer dollars. Were we justified with what was done in Iraq? Do we even know what was done in Iraq and Afghanistan? These drones that drop using our tax dollars under democratic and republican regimes? And kill thousands of innocent people in weddings in Yemen and Somalia. Are these justified? And when you think about dehumanization.

• 2:27:19Speaker 01

  Can the average American name a single victim of the Iraq war?

• 2:27:24Speaker 01

  Is there a picture that comes to your mind? Is there a person? Absolutely not, because that's the dehumanization. Now, I often talk about Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., his progression as a faith leader in America, as a political leader in America. Dr. King was deeply unpopular when he took his stand on Vietnam. And he mentions how first, he had to see Vietnam through the lens of the soldiers, because many of the soldiers that were lost, American soldiers. Right? And that was, that was a crime that they were sent to fight a war that they should not have been sent to fight. And there was an injustice that was done towards them. He said, but things really changed when he started to see it from the other side of the bullet.

• 2:28:06Speaker 01

  When he started to see the world through Vietnam, through the Vietnamese child. And that's where he resorted to breaking the silence. That's where he changed his tune. Because we dehumanize our victims so much that they're not even relevant to our discourse until they become able villains to our story. And then now they're attacking us because they hate us. Now they're blowing us up because they hate us. Their religion tells them to do this to us. What have we allowed to be done to them using our tax dollars in our name? Right? So I think that we have to interrogate the political chaos that was caused,

• 2:28:47Speaker 01

  not just, not just free religion from the groups that were created, but what was done to those countries and what continues to be done in many of these places?

• 2:28:58Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, when the, the pride that people had about America, where everybody came together after 9/11 and there was all the American flags.

• 2:29:10Lex Fridman?

  That was beautiful to see, but then you have to transfer that. And I wish all of us Americans could go and see the daughters that would lose their parents, the parents that would lose their daughters and sons because bombs dropped. The thousands, the tens of thousands of civilians that died

• 2:29:32Lex Fridman?

  in Afghanistan and Iraq because of the decisions made in the name of politics. Like if we just met those families and if you, if we, if we empathize with them and just put ourselves in their place, it's impossible not to feel hate for America, for everybody. I mean, I, I visited Ukraine and spoke to a lot of Ukrainians and they said, you know, there's, there's loved ones that are Russians before the war, but now all they have is hate. And if you ask many of them, will they ever forgive? Not, not, not the regime, not the soldiers, will they ever forgive Russians? They, many of them say never.

• 2:30:17Lex Fridman?

  And that never feels like it's a generational never.

• 2:30:22Speaker 01

  Hmm. I mean, look,

• 2:30:26Speaker 01

  you think about this, you know, if your grandparents were wiped out in a drone attack, your parents, your brothers, your sisters, all of your loved ones, and you're missing a leg and an eye.

• 2:30:37Speaker 01

  And the world does not take you into consideration. You'll never be seen or considered in the halls of Congress or discussed. What are you going to grow up with? Right? But the thing is, is that we should not be speaking about this only from the standpoint of, oh, shoot, they're going to grow up and hate us.

• 2:30:55Speaker 01

  We should be thinking about what was done to them and hate that, despise that, that it's ugly. You see, when people carry out a terrorist attack, they're not considering the lives of the civilians in these places. So those that perpetrate the nine 11 attacks are not seeing the thousands of people that they killed, the human beings, the lives, many of whom were Muslim, by the way, actually, no. One of them was a very active Muslim in Islamic Circle of North America. I mean, they didn't see those stories, right? When you drop a bomb on this many people, when you drone people and you say, oops, collateral damage, we were looking for one person, killed 40 people, and there's no

• 2:31:39Speaker 01

  count, no names, nothing that can be recalled in the American memory. That's a problem, a fundamental issue with how we treat the rest of the world. Right? So I'm an American. I think that I'm responsible to the extent that I have to critique these policies and I have to try to, you know, challenge America to deal with the world differently. And when I go overseas, when I'm around Muslims in the Muslim world, right? In the Middle East and in the Muslim world, you know, I have to, I'm speaking as a Palestinian American Muslim who grew up in South Louisiana.

• 2:32:23Speaker 01

  I've got a complex background here, right? A lot of experiences here that I'm grateful for because they all contribute to who I, who I am and who, what I know and what I've been, I think they're all enriching. I wouldn't relinquish the Palestinian part. I wouldn't relinquish the American part and I certainly wouldn't relinquish the Muslim part. But it's helping people consider what they're not seeing. And when you can dehumanize entire groups of people to where you can reduce them to chalk casualty counts and not be able to recall a single story, then you have to take a step back and ask yourself, what are we becoming?

• 2:33:08Speaker 01

  Right? What are we becoming? Not a single victim of Afghanistan or Iraq. Millions of people, not a single person can the average American conjure in their head.

• 2:33:21Lex Fridman?

  If you apply this to a very difficult topic of Israel and Palestine.

• 2:33:27Speaker 01

  Speaking of which, right?

• 2:33:29Lex Fridman?

  You have been critical of the policies of the state of Israel, but as we've mentioned, very supportive of Jewish people. You have a lot of friends, rabbis and Jews in general here in Dallas and across the world. What is the difference to you in that part of the world between politics and religion? So in this case, Zionism and Judaism, both terms broadly defined.

• 2:33:58Speaker 01

  Both terms broadly defined.

• 2:33:59Lex Fridman?

  So I say that because those terms, there's technical definitions and there's how they're popularly used. And so you have to be kind of, just like we said with Islamophobia, these terms are, they become politicized. So just generally speaking, I think Zionism has to do with, with, with politics and Judaism has to do with religion.

• 2:34:24Speaker 01

  Yeah, it's the great complexity like to a lot of people, like, wait a minute. Right? And you got to take a step back and wonder why there are so many Zionist anti-Semites in America. And there are so many anti-Zionists who are far from being anti-Semites, anti-Zionism that are opposed to the ideology, that are opposed to the implications of it. Look, I think that it's fundamentally secular. When you think about it, there is an ethno-supremacism. There is, I am the child of Palestinians that were forcibly displaced from their land. I've never been able to go to where my parents, my grandparents are from. I've never been able to see that land. I've never been able to access that. I have cousins that I'll

• 2:35:09Speaker 01

  never be, well, I shouldn't say never. Inshallah, God willing, I will meet them. But that I've only been able to speak through a phone, FaceTime, Zoom.

• 2:35:22Speaker 01

  I think that it's important for us to separate criticism of Israel's policies from antisemitism. In fact, it's an injustice. It cheapens antisemitism when you throw every person who is opposed to Zionism or opposed to Israel's policies in the bucket of being antisemites. It's wrong. It cheapens it. It doesn't do justice to it. And I think it's important for us to have a meaningful conversation about America's support for Israel. Listen, there are terms that are important here, so I'm gonna throw out these, these big terms, right?

• 2:36:05Speaker 01

  Apartheid, occupation, ethnic cleansing. These are terms that are legal terms. There are objective thresholds here for apartheid, occupation, ethnic cleansing. The threshold of apartheid has been crossed according to multiple, the most respectable human rights organizations in the world. These are the organizations that you will champion and that you will use in every single other conflict to justify your own policies. But that threshold of apartheid has been passed. According to Human Rights Watch, according to Amnesty International, according to the Harvard Law Review, the threshold of apartheid has been crossed. There's a legal terminology there.

• 2:36:49Speaker 01

  Two sets of laws for two separate people. You have a displaced people that are forcibly being removed, that are being treated differently, that are stateless, that are undergoing daily humiliation, that live behind an apartheid wall, that live under a different set of policies, that are routinely bombarded, that have lost their ability to free movement, that have lost their ability to access to basic necessities of human life. There are legal definitions here. I don't see how any objective human being can read those reports on apartheid and the threshold crossed for apartheid and walk away from that and say that this is just Jews and Muslims that don't like each other. There's a legal definition here. Occupation.

• 2:37:35Speaker 01

  When Israel was created in 1948, you will find many Jews who are opposed to Zionism. And I think this is important, you know, to talk to Jews who are opposed to Zionism, and they are many, that will say that we were told that it was a land without a people, for a people without a land. The problem with that was, there were people there, our ancestors, 750,000 Palestinians expelled in the Nakba, and many Palestinians that have been removed and harassed, and that are treated in horrific ways. And the occupation is expanding. It is an illegal occupation. The settlements are still expanding. And the United States

• 2:38:19Speaker 01

  enables that occupation with its funding, with its unconditional support, unwavering support of Israel. And it does so in a way that completely undermines any of its claims to being a beacon of freedom in the world. Because it is in plain sight now that the world can see what is happening in Sheikh Jarrah, what is happening in Jerusalem, what is happening with these expanding settlements. Everything that flies in the face of any claim to wanting a peaceful solution. The children in Gaza, when I talk about dehumanization, the children that were on the face of The New York Times, which is historically one of the most anti-Palestinian newspapers in America,

• 2:39:01Speaker 01

  the faces of the children of Gaza. America and many parts of the world are now seeing it. We have been saying for a very long time, this is apartheid. This is an occupation. This is an injustice. The world needs to check it, hold it accountable. South Africa, which experienced apartheid, Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu, all of those that fought apartheid in South Africa, said that Palestinians are living under apartheid, and that the same strategies that check apartheid in South Africa need to be used to hold Israel accountable for apartheid with the Palestinians.

• 2:39:41Speaker 01

  It's impossible for us as Palestinians to simply say that we should give up on this cause because all the odds are stacked against us. But when you have, you know, videos coming out of the Israeli armies, you know, spewing skunk water, skunk water, sewage water on worshippers leaving Al-Aqsa. Far-right leaders now taking the government and the so-called only democracy in the Middle East prohibiting a Palestinian flag being raised anywhere around. American reporter, Shirin Abu Akla, Palestinian-American Christian reporter, Palestinian-American

• 2:40:26Speaker 01

  Christian reporter, one of the most prominent journalists in the Middle East, shot in the face, plain sight, and all America could say was, all the American government could say was, if it turns out that it's indeed Israel, that Israel is responsible for the death of an American journalist, then we will hold them accountable. Nothing, not a peep. It was a shame to see that happen and it just solidified to us that whether it's a democratic president or a republican president, unfortunately, the support for Israel is enabling it to continue to wipe out the Palestinian population from its historic land.

• 2:41:09Speaker 01

  And so we see that happening and I'll say this as well. People ask me about the Abraham Accords. They say, you know, you are talking about faith between, or you're talking about peace between communities of faith and protecting communities of faith. Why are you opposed to the Abraham Accords? I think that the name of Abraham should not be used. And I wrote an article called Why I Opposed the Abraham Accords. The name of Abraham should not be used to justify arms deals that only further disenfranchise the abused population of the Palestinians. Where, you know, you have quote-unquote Muslim regimes making peace with Israel and that's being used against the Palestinian people who are only further disenfranchised from

• 2:41:53Speaker 01

  having a voice in their own fate. For the sake of American arms deals and security and economic benefits. It's despicable, it's repulsive. Talk to the people, speak to people on the ground there, see what's happening with your own two eyes, and think about the injustice where our taxpayer dollars are being used to suppress the people and what legally meets the definition by every objective standard of apartheid, of occupation, of ethnic cleansing. And it's ongoing and it's happening in real time and it's becoming more blatant with a regime now that's unapologetic of even expressing what the policies have already done.

• 2:42:38Speaker 01

  And that is the removal of a people, forcible removal of a people because the government knows that the United States' support is unconditional.

• 2:42:48Lex Fridman?

  Do you have hope that Jews, Muslims, and Christians in this land will live in peace one day, together, have a basic respect for each other's humanity?

• 2:43:01Speaker 01

  Look, this isn't a religious conflict. I think that's fundamentally one of the problems.

• 2:43:08Lex Fridman?

  So even the question is not the correct question?

• 2:43:10Speaker 01

  It's not the correct question. This is not a religious conflict. Yes, religion is invoked. Yes, there are religious elements, but there are many Jews that are opposed to what is happening right now towards the Palestinians, many. And I would recommend, you know, a serious discussion with even people whose perspectives have grown. Peter Beinert being an example, Rabbi Simone Zimmerman, who started If Not Now, Beis Ha Simi, an Israeli human rights organization that also classed it as apartheid recently. There are many Jews that are opposed to what is happening right now. Palestinians are also not exclusively a Muslim population. Shereen Al Maraklo was Christian.

• 2:43:54Speaker 01

  There are many Palestinian Christians that are also being denied entry into their historic churches and that are completely bewildered or absolutely lost in regards to why...

• 2:44:08Speaker 01

  American evangelicals have this ironclad support for the occupation and have ignored the plight of Palestinian Christians. Of course, I believe Muslims, Christians, and Jews can coexist.

• 2:44:22Speaker 01

  Of course, I have hope, because I have to have hope as a person of faith. But as much hope as I have, I think there's a great sense of urgency for people to open their eyes, learn what's actually happening on the ground, read the reports. Stop letting these commentators and these companies that are able to generate propaganda own the narrative. There are objective standards here. There are objective measures of oppression that need to be considered here. What's happening to Gaza is one of the greatest atrocities of our time. Learn about it, right? I'd tell people to just watch the Vice documentaries, for example, the mini documentaries. I'd send them to you as well.

• 2:45:07Speaker 01

  Inside the Battle for Jerusalem. I mean, think about it. A guy from Long Island, New York can fly to Israel, right? Fly into Tel Aviv and walk into a home that's been occupied by families for generations and throw the people out under the full protection of the military there and spit on them. Historic homes. And when people come up to me and say, "We're opposed to Islamophobia. We're opposed to Islamophobia," but they support that? I tell you, you're not opposed to Islamophobia. How can you be opposed to Islamophobia when you traffic in the same framings and dehumanization

• 2:45:48Speaker 01

  that enables the viciousness towards Muslims here and Palestinians over there that they do not deserve to be treated like equal human beings, like full human beings? And that based on historic claims, a guy can fly from New York into a historic neighborhood in Jerusalem and kick out generational families with military guns next to them? What does that sound like? How is that, how is that normal, right? And so I think that if people take the time to read, people take the time to investigate. Then they come to this conclusion themselves that this is unacceptable. And that you can't put, and this is one of the problems with the framing of Israel Palestine, is that you're equating occupier and occupied.

• 2:46:31Speaker 01

  You're equating the two sides of the conflict. And it's not a conflict, it's an occupation. There is such a disparity of power here that you cannot equate the two sides. How, you know, you can, you know, Malcolm X would say, you clip the bird's wing and then fly, and then blame it for not flying as high as you do. You can't, you can't do that to a people and just equate them with their occupier. It's an atrocity. It requires us to challenge it. And I'm hopeful at the current movement of Muslims, Christians and Jews and people of all faiths that are saying enough is enough, that thresholds have been crossed here, that this, this is an atrocity that cannot continue. You know,

• 2:47:16Speaker 01

  this is very personal to me because this is happening now.

• 2:47:22Speaker 01

  What I anticipate, and this is what America did, this is what Nelson Mandela actually predicted with the United States. What I anticipate is that 10 years from now, 20 years from now, every American will say, how could we have supported this? And this was terrible. And will pay symbolic, you know, homage to the Palestinian cause.

• 2:47:43Speaker 01

  But there are people now that are clinging on for dear life, access to their places of worship, access to their generational homes. Right now, at this very, there, there are children that are in detention. And there's a bill in Congress to just stop, I mean, wherever you stand on this issue, child detainment, child detainment, child detention should be a red line, right? Congresswoman Betty McCullum has put this bill on the floor of Congress. She can't even get that passed, right? Just to, just to at least censure child detainment by the IDF. So. People need to look into this deeper.

• 2:48:24Speaker 01

  They need to consider the human element of this and consider the urgency of it as well. With this new regime, it's only going to unfortunately get much worse in the immediate term, and so we have to do something about it.

• 2:48:39Lex Fridman?

  If I may ask you for some advice, for a reason I'll explain maybe in a little bit, or maybe I should just explain now, which is, I think, because you've talked about Islamophobia, because you've been at the center of so many catastrophic events, because you sort of jump into the fire to try to help people, you've been attacked a lot, just in general, you've been under stress, it's just, you're not immune to stress. So a part of me wants to ask, just how psychologically difficult it's been and where you draw strength, and would you advise, if the opportunity is there, for a person like me, for a silly

• 2:49:24Lex Fridman?

  kid in a suit, to go to that part of the world and take seriously conversations? I would divide it into two categories, there's leaders and there's people. The leaders are sort of these political entities that have their interests, but they also have power, and they want to hold on to power. And then people are just regular people that have families, that just want to have basic rights and freedoms and continue to love their families, to pursue different jobs and careers and lives that they can flourish and so on. Those are very kind of different dynamics at play.

• 2:50:05Lex Fridman?

  And if given the opportunity to speak to leaders, for me, would you advise I do it or not? And when I say leaders, I mean leaders that would make the case, the pro-Zionist case?

• 2:50:22Lex Fridman?

  And the anti Zionist case, and in both cases, I would make it a very challenging conversations for both of them. Unlike today, our conversation today, you're an inspiring, incredible person. I'm a huge fan of yours. You spread so much love to the Muslim community here, to the Jewish community, just everybody loves you. But

• 2:50:43Speaker 01

  Not everybody.

• 2:50:44Lex Fridman?

  Not. Yes, that's true.

• 2:50:46Speaker 01

  Not everybody.

• 2:50:48Lex Fridman?

  That's true. But a lot, a lot of people love you. Yes. But this was kind of inspiring and a positive conversation. It wasn't very challenging. Although we did touch challenging topics, and you did exceptionally well there. But I would do very challenging conversation with those leaders in that part of the world. Is that a bad idea?

• 2:51:08Speaker 01

  All right. Well, let me tell you from now, first and foremost, the first part, because I don't want to lose the first part of your, your conversation. Is it psychologically stressful? Very, very.

• 2:51:23Speaker 01

  But when you're

• 2:51:27Speaker 01

  when you're a person of faith, and you believe that

• 2:51:33Speaker 01

  good work will always be rewarded, and that doing the right thing will always be rewarded eventually, you're able to weather that storm

• 2:51:44Speaker 01

  quite a bit.

• 2:51:45Lex Fridman?

  So your wife told you

• 2:51:48Speaker 01

  Well, that's the second thing.

• 2:51:48Lex Fridman?

  The college bill was okay, right?

• 2:51:49Speaker 01

  That's the second thing I was going to mention is honestly supportive, a supportive family. You know, my dad's 80 man, and he's been through a lot. He was born in 1943 before his, five years before Israel was even created. He was born in Palestine. He's suffered displacement. He has been around the world and somehow built himself up to be a distinguished professor of chemistry, an author, an inventor. You know, grew up taking on some of the most difficult challenges and was just always a man of principle. I always admired my dad being a man of principle. And like, he just tells me, man, stay the course, stay the course. Don't be afraid. Don't back down. I have a supportive family. I have a supportive wife. I've got supportive kids. So I have

• 2:52:31Speaker 01

  amazing people around me that keep me grounded for sure. And ultimately, obviously, faith.

• 2:52:38Speaker 01

  And also, I'll say this slander doesn't stand.

• 2:52:41Lex Fridman?

  What do you mean by that?

• 2:52:42Speaker 01

  When people slander you, and it kind of comes with the territory of a public figure, it's not going to stand throughout time because eventually any sincere person will find the truth. And the only people that will regurgitate that will continue to do so. So when I get portrayed as an anti Semite because of my strong takes on Israel and challenging Israel, and I will continue to do so, it takes just people in doubt, like, we know him, what are you talking about? You know? So slander doesn't stand, at least with the people that are important to you. It might reside on the internet, it might have great rankings and social media bots that give it traction.

• 2:53:22Lex Fridman?

  But is that psychologically difficult to you to have that?

• 2:53:25Speaker 01

  Of course, yes, it is difficult. It's very difficult and it's hurtful, especially when it comes from corridors that you would hope that it doesn't come from. But, you know, you take a step back, you reevaluate, you lean into your faith and you lean on the people that are closest to you and then you keep going. You learn the lessons. Could I be doing something better? Could I be doing something different? Could I be saying something better? Could I be saying something different? Are the noble causes that I want to achieve, am I doing justice by those causes? How do I grow out of this? Right? You become wiser through these things as well. Second part of your question, though, about what you should do.

• 2:54:08Speaker 01

  If you're going to talk to people, talk to people from a place of inquiry. I would say, talk to people more so than leaders and especially some of those who have been erased from the media commentary. Benjamin Netanyahu gets a lot of airtime, you know, here in the United States. He's well spoken, you know, he speaks perfect English, he's an American as well.

• 2:54:33Speaker 01

  I would challenge him, you know, on some of the things that he has said and done. He has an ongoing corruption case. I think that, I think he's a fascist. I think that he's a person who has done much evil. I think that he has a lot of blood on his hands and I think that one day he will be prosecuted for that. But I'd say, talk to people on the ground. And people that have been erased, talk to the families that are being displaced. Sheikh Jarrah, I don't care about the political leadership. I'd much rather you talk to the people on the ground in East Jerusalem that have been displaced. The families, talk to Palestinian Christians, talk to the sister of Shereen Abu Akhla, Lina Abu Akhla,

• 2:55:13Speaker 01

  who has been, who was extremely disappointed and let down when Joe Biden went to the region and did not take her calls, did not meet her, which was an absolutely disgraceful move. He should have met with her. She's the sister of an American journalist who was murdered in cold blood. Talk to Lina Abu Akhla, talk to Mitri Rahib. Mitri, interesting person, for example, he's a Lutheran, he's the head of the Lutheran church in Palestine. He comes to Dallas sometimes and talks about the plight of Palestinian Christians. I think if you're talking to people in leadership, you know, obviously there are some that'll be able to represent themselves in English, you know, Hanan Ashrawi is a very eloquent person, for example.

• 2:55:56Speaker 01

  I don't know if you're gonna have any luck getting into Gaza, but I'll pray for you if you do. But obviously, you know, if you want to talk to everybody, you gotta talk to everybody, man, so.

• 2:56:04Lex Fridman?

  Well, and I also want to say, this is very important when you say whitewashing, because I've heard this a lot, so also with Ukraine and Russia. There's an interesting line between whitewashing, which is something you definitely should not do, and a deep empathy for a large number of human beings. It's a, it's a really tricky line to walk. And I also disagree with you about, well, I think, I don't know if it's a disagreement, but I think I disagree about leaders. I think I agree a hundred percent that the most important people are the people on the ground.

• 2:56:40Speaker 01

  Okay.

• 2:56:40Lex Fridman?

  But I think those are extremely important people to understand, not just as leaders, but as human beings too. And in many cases, to have a challenging conversation, but from a place of empathy, from understanding a human being.

• 2:56:57Speaker 01

  So if you plan to talk to right wing, the current leadership of Israel, my only request to you is talk to the victims themselves, not the Palestinian Authority, talk to the victim. I know you want to, right? So I, and I appreciate it.

• 2:57:12Lex Fridman?

  But the victims, yes, the victims.

• 2:57:13Speaker 01

  Talk to the victims themselves. Talk to those people that are being thrown out of their homes and subjected to the daily humiliation. Go to a checkpoint and walk through the checkpoint the way that a Palestinian walks through a checkpoint and tell me that's not apartheid. Walk through that checkpoint, crammed in in cages, and tell me it's not apartheid. So I think you're a very sincere person. I think you're gonna, you're gonna do your best. I'll be praying for you.

• 2:57:37Lex Fridman?

  Some of these things are harder than others, but yes, I feel like we're in the middle of a negotiation and we've come to a point where we both agree.

• 2:57:45Speaker 01

  Everyone deserves to be, everyone, not everyone deserves to be, but I think there's a great value and benefit. Let me say I agree with you and hearing people, even tyrants, hearing them so that you can properly deconstruct and decipher what you're hearing. But just think of the voices that don't get heard. And a lot of times what's been done to the Muslim world is, and what's being done right now in the name of the Abraham Accords, what's wrong with the Palestinians? The other Arabs are making peace with them. Let me tell you something, those regimes that are signing on to the Abraham Accords, the people are not happy, but they're terrified of challenging those regimes. So if you go talk to the leaders of some of these countries that have signed on to the Abraham Accords,

• 2:58:28Speaker 01

  and that are, you know, in some twisted way, making this about religion and peace, you can greatly skew the narrative to where Palestinians are just an inherently disagreeable people that don't want peace. They just want to live in their homes. They just want to live as full, equal human beings. They want the things that everybody, everybody wants. And they're only being further disenfranchised in the name of peace now, because voices are being amplified in the name of peace that are suffocating voices for justice.

• 2:59:13Lex Fridman?

  You said, "Hope." As a man of faith, you have hope.

• 2:59:17Speaker 01

  Yes.

• 2:59:17Lex Fridman?

  What gives you hope about this part of the world and our world in general? When you look across and see so much conflict, so much division happening? What gives you hope?

• 2:59:31Speaker 01

  I think that if you look through history, we have been through points as a world where we almost were not going to exist anymore. If you lived in the time of the Crusades, if you lived in some of these darker moments of history, World War I, World War II, you probably thought you weren't going to come out of this as a world. I have hope in God. And I have hope that godly people, people that are devoted to God and people of righteousness, can shift things with His help.

• 3:00:12Speaker 01

  I also believe that younger people, I hope they'll be different. I think younger people, hopefully, or using the word "hope" a lot, you know, you might hear "Insha Allah," God willing, will see the path that we're heading and will seek to disrupt this bleak trajectory and bring it back to something else. So here's the thing, we live in a time of hyperexposure. That hyperexposure could paralyze you or it could empower you. It could make you completely shut down and say, "What's the point of even trying to help these people out?

• 3:00:57Speaker 01

  Why even talk about the Palestinians? You've got these people here, the Uyghurs, the Rohingya. You've got what's happening in Honduras, Guatemala, El Salvador, Brazil, South America, Africa, Ethiopia, Somalia. It's so much and it's, it's, it can be overwhelming to a person who cares. But you ultimately realize that the difference that you can make can become a much greater difference, even if it's after your lifetime. And I'll tell you actually a story that, I remember the first time, it's Syria, Syrian refugee camps. And you deal with people.

• 3:01:38Speaker 01

  In this deeply human way, for me, the most clarifying parts of the world are the refugee camps. It's where I feel the most clarity in life about what I'm supposed to be doing in life. You go to the refugee camps and then after interacting with these people and, you know, maybe giving a few people some trailer homes and some food and something to sustain themselves, some coats and blankets, you drive out of the refugee camps, back to where you're staying. And the camps get bigger and bigger and bigger and bigger, and the people get smaller and smaller and smaller and smaller. But then you realize that it might be that that small section that I touched is going to be the change that affects all of them.

• 3:02:22Speaker 01

  What's going to happen to that 12-year-old boy that has seen the horrors of this world? And that is absolutely committed to uplifting his people and bringing about a change, being responsible for the plight of his people. And so when I look at any section of devastation in the world, you never know which part of it that you're going to touch that's going to change everything, by the grace of God, by the help of God. So you keep trying to do your part. You know, the prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, said that the most beloved of deeds to God are the consistent ones, even if they're small. That small act of charity, that small smile, that small act of kindness,

• 3:03:04Speaker 01

  that small prayer, might go a long way if he blesses it. So keep chipping away, chipping away, chipping away.

• 3:03:13Lex Fridman?

  So do not be paralyzed by the scale of the division. Just chip away at it.

• 3:03:19Speaker 01

  Chip away.

• 3:03:20Lex Fridman?

  Small step at a time. And that's like, I suppose all of us can do that. Young people can do that. Just one person at a time, try to help.

• 3:03:27Speaker 01

  Yes, absolutely, absolutely.

• 3:03:30Lex Fridman?

  Omar, you're an incredible person. You're an inspiration. You know, I think you mentioned you came to Dallas for a podcast and instead you got a friend. So it's a, it's an honor to be your new friend.

• 3:03:44Speaker 01

  Appreciate it.

• 3:03:44Lex Fridman?

  And I think it's time we go pray.

• 3:03:46Speaker 01

  Absolutely.

• 3:03:47Lex Fridman?

  I hope it's okay that I join you in, at least in movement and prayer.

• 3:03:52Speaker 01

  Thank you so much. I appreciate you coming down. It's been an absolute pleasure.

• 3:03:56Speaker 02

  وَلَأَنِّي عَبْدُ اللَّهِ أَتَى لِيَ مِنْ كِتَابٍ وَجَعَلَنِي نَبِيًّا وَجَعَلَنِي مُبَارَكًا هَيْنَمَا كُنْت وَأَوْصَعَنِي بِالصَّلَةِ وَالزَّكَاتِ مَادُوْتُ حَيًّا وَبَرَّاً بِوَالِدَتِي وَلَمْ يَجْعَلْنِي جَبَّارًا شَخِيًّا وَالسَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللَّهِ اللَّه

• 3:04:39Speaker 02

  اللَّه

• 3:04:44Speaker 02

  اللَّه

• 3:04:50Speaker 02

  السلام عليكم و رحمة الله

• 3:06:29Speaker 02

  So much.

• 3:06:35Speaker 01

  Sure you don't want to come back? Do a round two?

• 3:06:37Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 3:06:38Speaker 01

  Thank you, man. Great talking to you.

• 3:06:43Lex Fridman?

  Thanks for listening to this conversation with Omar Saliman. To support this podcast, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now, let me leave you with some words from Muhammad Ali. "Impossible is just a big word thrown around by small men who find it easier to live in a world they've been given than to explore the power they have to change it. Impossible is not a fact, it's an opinion. Impossible is not a declaration, it's a dare." Thank you for listening and hope to see you next time.