Skip to content

The art of influence: The single most important skill left that AI can’t replace | Jessica Fain

Lenny's Podcast

Hosted by Lenny Rachitsky

1h 33m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Jessica Fain, a product leader at Box, Slack, and now Webflow, breaks down the art of influencing executives. She argues that product managers forget their core skills of curiosity and empathy the moment they're talking to a leader, and that the single most important shift is treating your executive as your key user. She describes an executive's calendar as a strobe light—context-switching from finance to legal to product reviews without time to center your problem—and recommends spending 30 seconds at the top of every meeting to re-establish context.

Fain offers specific tactics: ask "what led you to believe that?" to disarm and extract reasoning; present three options rather than one to show you've considered alternatives; use the "Stuart plus two more" approach (do what they asked plus two of your own versions); and align your pitch to their specific incentives, like board pressure or OKRs. She also argues that killing and deprioritizing projects is one of the strongest trust-building moves, and that shrinking the change (from the book Switch) makes risky ideas palatable.

The conversation extends to how AI is reshaping influence: as execution complexity plummets, the leverage shifts from being the best synthesizer to deciding what survives and getting buy-in. Fain calls it a golden age of product management, where the 10x skill is stakeholder management and learning, not Gantt charts or note-taking.

  • Spend 30–60 seconds at the start of every exec meeting stating what you're here to discuss, what happened last time, and today's goals, then stop talking. 44:02
  • Use the phrase "That's so interesting. What led you to believe that?" to disarm an executive and extract the reasoning behind their position. 17:37
  • Present three options rather than one, with the Goldilocks option in the middle, to demonstrate you've considered alternatives and aren't missing something. 23:35
  • Killing and deprioritizing projects is one of the strongest trust-building moves because it shows aligned incentives with the executive. 1:00:53
  • Ask your executive what the board is pushing them on, rather than the generic "what's top of mind for you?" which has lost its firepower. 30:03

Highlights

  • 0:20

    Executive Calendar as Strobe Lightinsight

    Fain describes an executive's calendar as a strobe light going off: they jump from finance to legal to product reviews without time to center your problem. The PM has been prepping for weeks, but the exec hasn't thought about you since the last meeting.

  • 5:59

    Pitching April Underwood While Pregnantstory

    Eight months pregnant, Fain approached newly-minted CPO April Underwood at Slack and asked to be her chief of staff. She got the role and later served Tamar Yehoshua, learning firsthand how executives actually make decisions.

  • 17:37

    The Disarming Question for Execsstrategy

    When an executive says something that contradicts your data, respond with "That's so interesting. What led you to believe that?" It's curious, not confrontational, and co-creates the answer with them.

  • 25:45

    Stuart Plus Two Morestrategy

    After a design review with Stuart, the team would implement exactly what he asked for plus two other versions they felt good about, creating a forum to debate the merits of each approach.

  • 29:21

    Against the Top of Mind Questioninsight

    Fain calls "what's top of mind for you?" a lost trope. Instead, ask spicier questions like "tell me what the board is pushing you on" or "what's the most urgent priority you're scared about messing up?"

  • 34:02

    Slack's Customer Love Sprintstory

    Fain's team at Slack stopped all work for two weeks to fix rough edges. Engineers picked what to work on, the only rule was shipping something good for users. They shipped 65 improvements and executives ran a judging competition.

  • 1:00:53

    Killing Things Builds Trustinsight

    Fain argues that one of the biggest things you can do to build trust is kill things and deprioritize. It's a very senior way of thinking that shows you have the same aligned incentives as the executive.

  • 1:09:51

    Golden Age of Product Managementinsight

    As AI plummets execution complexity, the leverage shifts from being the best synthesizer or note-taker to deciding what work survives and getting buy-in. Fain calls the act of influence and stakeholder management the 10x skill.

About this episode

Jessica Fain is a product leader at Webflow and former Chief of Staff to the CPO at Slack, where she worked alongside April Underwood and many past podcast guests including Stewart Butterfield, Annie Pearl, Tamar Yehoshua, and Noah Weiss. She’s spent her career learning how executives actually make decisions—and why most people completely misunderstand the process. *We discuss:* 1. Why great ideas often don’t get buy-in 2. Why executive calendars are “like strobe lights” and why the first 30 seconds of a meeting matter so much 3. Why executives are usually optimizing for a global maximum while you are often optimizing locally 4. The best question Jessica uses when a leader says something that seems wrong: “That’s so interesting. What led you to believe that?” 5. Why you should go in to learn, not to convince 6. Why showing only one option is a mistake 7. Why AI will make influence more important, not less *Brought to you by:* Omni—AI analytics your customers can trust: https://omni.co/lenny Lovable—Build apps by simply chatting with AI: https://lovable.dev/ Vanta—Automate compliance, manage risk, and accelerate trust with AI: https://vanta.com/lenny *Episode transcript:* https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/the-art-of-influence-jessica-fain *Archive of all Lenny's Podcast transcripts:* https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/yxi4s2w998p1gvtpu4193/AMdNPR8AOw0lMklwtnC0TrQ?rlkey=j06x0nipoti519e0xgm23zsn9&st=ahz0fj11&dl=0 *Where to find Jessica Fain:* • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jessica-fain-79b8989 *Where to find Lenny:* • Newsletter: https://www.lennysnewsletter.com • X: https://twitter.com/lennysan • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lennyrachitsky/ *In this episode, we cover:* (00:00) Introduction to Jessica Fain (03:53) Why influence is the highest-leverage skill in product (04:47) Why great ideas fail without executive buy-in (06:00) How executives actually think (09:05) The fundamentals: context-setting, communication, and empathy (10:22) Stop pitching for approval—start co-creating with execs (12:59) Influence vs. politics (and why people get it wrong) (15:44) How to disagree with execs without losing trust (17:20) Going in to learn, not to convince (19:08) How to present ideas (26:05) The Minto-style approach and tailoring your communication to each exec (28:22) Why Jessica doesn’t like the question “What’s top of mind for you?” (30:24) Understanding incentives to unlock buy-in (32:10) Aligning product work with company strategy (35:10) Quick summary (37:31) Disarming the executive (40:49) Speed matters: why fast follow-up builds momentum (43:32) How to run high-impact meetings (the 60-second rule) (47:00) Why influencing execs is part of your job (49:15) Asking for more resources and thinking in 10x bets (52:23) What to do when your idea gets rejected (54:18) Clarifying information (56:50) How to build trust and make ideas stick (58:30) Shrinking big ideas into experiments (01:02:27) Common mistakes people make when influencing leaders (01:06:00) How to grow into your next role (01:09:32) How AI is changing influence and product work (01:17:55) Using AI to simulate exec feedback and improve pitches (01:21:15) Protecting our brains from overwhelm (01:22:44) Lightning round and final thoughts *Referenced:* • Box: https://www.box.com • Slack: https://slack.com • Brightwheel: https://mybrightwheel.com • Webflow: https://webflow.com • April Underwood on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/aprilunderwood • Lessons in product leadership and AI strategy from Glean, Google, Amazon, and Slack | Tamar Yehoshua (Product at Glean, ex-Google and Slack): https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/you-dont-need-to-be-a-well-run-company-to-win-tamar-yehoshua • Atlassian: https://www.atlassian.com • Behind the scenes of Calendly’s rapid growth | Annie Pearl (CPO): https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/behind-the-scenes-of-calendlys-rapid • Calendly: https://calendly.com • Glassdoor: https://www.glassdoor.co.in/index.htm • The 10 traits of great PMs, how AI will impact your product, and Slack’s product development process | Noah Weiss (Slack, Foursquare, Google): https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/the-10-traits-of-great-pms-how-ai • Ethan Eismann on X: https://x.com/eeismann • Slack founder: Mental models for building products people love ft. Stewart Butterfield: https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/slack-founder-stewart-butterfield • Ilan Frank on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ilanfrank • Checkr: https://checkr.com • Ali Rayl on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/alirayl • Rachel Wolan on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rachelwolan ... References continued at: https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/the-art-of-influence-jessica-fain _Production and marketing by https://penname.co/._ _For inquiries about sponsoring the podcast, email [email protected]._ Lenny may be an investor in the companies discussed.

Transcript

0:00
1:33:32

16,974 words · 2 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Executive Influence
  • Product Leadership
  • Stakeholder Management
  • AI and Product
  • Decision Making
  • Career Growth
  • Trust Building
  • Strategy Clarity

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated