#297 – Jonathan Reisman: The Human Body – From Sex & Sperm to Hands & Heart

Jonathan Reisman is a physician and author of The Unseen Body who has practiced medicine in some of the most remote places in the world. Please support this podcast by checking out our sponsors: – Lambda: https://lambdalabs.com/lex – InsideTracker: https://insidetracker.com/lex to get 20% off – Fundrise: https://fundrise.com/lex – Onnit: https://lexfridman.com/onnit to get up to 10% off – NetSuite: http://netsuite.com/lex to get free product tour EPISODE LINKS: Jonathan’s Twitter: https://twitter.com/jonreismanMD Jonathan’s Instagram: https://instagram.com/jonreismanmd Jonathan’s Website: http://jonathanreisman.com The Unseen Body (book): https://amzn.to/3Fyycw0 PODCAST INFO: Podcast website: https://lexfridman.com/podcast Apple Podcasts: https://apple.co/2lwqZIr Spotify: https://spoti.fi/2nEwCF8 RSS: https://lexfridman.com/feed/podcast/ YouTube Full Episodes: https://youtube.com/lexfridman YouTube Clips: https://youtube.com/lexclips SUPPORT & CONNECT: – Check out the sponsors above, it’s the best way to support this podcast – Support on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lexfridman – Twitter: https://twitter.com/lexfridman – Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lexfridman – LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lexfridman – Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lexfridman – Medium: https://medium.com/@lexfridman OUTLINE: Here’s the timestamps for the episode. On some podcast players you should be able to click the timestamp to jump to that time. (00:00) – Introduction (07:01) – Hands (16:15) – Sex (25:56) – Future of medicine (35:03) – Throat (45:26) – Heart and blood (53:28) – Genitals (1:05:57) – Poop (1:10:12) – Emergency room (1:18:03) – Sperm (1:23:09) – Liver (1:28:38) – Living in the Far North (1:47:21) – War and medicine (1:52:07) – Antarctica (2:05:03) – Artificial organs (2:13:39) – History of medicine (2:22:40) – Paul Farmer (2:27:05) – Advice for young people (2:34:03) – Struggle (2:40:07) – Mortality (2:45:44) – Meaning of life

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Lex Fridman?

  The following is a conversation with Jonathan Reisman, a physician and writer of The Unseen Body, A Doctor's Journey Through the Hidden Wonders of Human Anatomy. He has practiced medicine in some of the world's most remote places, including the Alaskan and Russian Arctic, Antarctica, and the Himalayan Mountains of Nepal.

• 0:23Lex Fridman?

  And now, a quick use second mention of each sponsor. Check them out in the description. It's the best way to support this podcast. We've got Lambda for deep learning, Insight Tracker for longevity, Fundrise for investing, Onnit for supplements, and NetSuite for efficiency. Choose wisely, my friends. And now, onto the full ad reads. As always, no ads in the middle. I try to make this interesting, but if you skip them, please still check out our sponsors. I enjoy their stuff. Maybe you will too. This show is brought to you by Lambda, computers, workstations, laptops, servers, cloud compute, all for deep learning. They're great both for individual researchers and huge companies. I consider myself an individual researcher, but I'm also part of a group of researchers,

• 1:08Lex Fridman?

  or I've been for most of my life. And perhaps one day I'll run a huge company. It's a dream. And all of those will involve a very large amount of deep learning. And there's no company that does this as well as Lambda. They have desktops, they have laptops. I have their laptop. It's freaking amazing. I love it. But it's already set up for you. It's plug and play access to very powerful computation. They have Linux and a Windows version. I don't know why you would want a Windows version. If you're legit like me, oh, this is just me talking trash. You're going to be using the Linux version. They got PyTorch, TensorFlow, all the drivers. Everything's already set up for you. Super fast, super stable, just works great and looks sexy too.

• 1:52Lex Fridman?

  I should mention that. That's very important. Probably the most important thing. You can check all of this out at lambdalabs.com/lex.

• 2:02Lex Fridman?

  This show is also brought to you by InsideTracker, a service I use to track biological data. They have a bunch of plans, most of which include blood tests that give you a lot of information that you can use to make decisions about your health. They have algorithms that analyze your blood data, DNA data, and fitness tracker data to provide you with a clear picture of what's going on inside you and to offer you science-backed recommendations for positive diet and lifestyle changes. It's kind of funny that I just did an ad read for Lambda, which I love, which is the compute machine learning system that runs whatever machine learning algorithms. And now we're talking about InsideTracker, which uses said machine learning algorithms to analyze the data that comes from your body. This is the future.

• 2:45Lex Fridman?

  You should not be making lifestyle changes based on generic population data. Anyway, lifestyle decisions and probably the future of medicine should really be reliant on data that comes from your own body and not from a single measurement, but from a measurement across time. And that's what InsideTracker is about. So you can go to insidetracker.com/lex and for a limited time, you get special savings for being a listener of this very podcast. This episode is also brought to you by Fundrise, spelled F-U-N-D-R-I-S-E. It's a platform that allows you to invest in private real estate. If you're looking to diversify your investment portfolio, this is a good choice.

• 3:27Lex Fridman?

  The economy, friends, in 2022 is a giant chaotic mess. I have no idea what's going on. I don't know if anyone has any idea what's going on, but I think one thing is for sure, diversification in this madness that's going on is a really good idea for your investment portfolio. And I think Fundrise is a great way to add diversity into your investment. I just love it when there's a whole class of things you can invest on that are made super easily accessible to you through a service like Fundrise. That's exactly what they do. Make it super easy that there's not some complex thing. We have to talk to a lot of people. No, it's a super easy to use service that allows you to diversify your portfolio.

• 4:12Lex Fridman?

  Over 100,000 investors use it. Check out Fundrise. It takes just a few minutes to get started at fundrise.com/lex.

• 4:22Lex Fridman?

  This episode is also brought to you by Onnit, a nutrition supplement and fitness company. They make AlphaBrain, which is a nootropic that helps support memory, mental speed, and focus. I use it as a super boost rocket launcher for the mind when I need it. I don't use it every day. I only use it when I'm feeling pretty sort of exhausted and really need to go through a difficult thinking session, like a deep work session where I have to keep my mind focused on one task and stay there in the pocket for one, two, three, four hours. For example, right now, I'm feeling incredible because I drank

• 5:05Lex Fridman?

  a couple of cups of coffee, so I don't need AlphaBrain. But if I wasn't feeling the way I'm feeling now, AlphaBrain would be part of the toolkit that I would be using. I love it. Anyway, as a listener, you can get a special discount on AlphaBrain at lexfridman.com/onnit.

• 5:26Lex Fridman?

  This show is also brought to you by NetSuite. NetSuite allows you to manage financials, human resources, inventory, e-commerce, and many more business-related details all in one place. Running a company is very difficult. See, to me, the thing I love is the idea generation, the brainstorming, the design, the engineering, maybe the small details like the grinding on the factory floor, the specific tasks that require skill that you develop over time. It becomes craftsmanship that you can achieve or strive towards excellence in that craftsmanship. That's what I love. But that's not enough. To run a business, you have to do everything. Like I said, financials, human resources,

• 6:12Lex Fridman?

  inventory, if you're doing e-commerce stuff, e-commerce, I mean, all of that, even just thinking about it is giving me a headache. So you have to use the best tools for the job to make that aspect of running a business easy. You have to hire the best people and use the best tools for the job. Anyway, right now, you can get special financing if you head to netsuite.com/lex.

• 6:35Lex Fridman?

  This is the Lex Fridman Podcast. To support it, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now to your friends, here's Jonathan Reisman.

• 7:01Lex Fridman?

  You wrote a book called Unseen Body, all about the human body, the messy, the weird, the beautiful, and the fascinating details. So from an evolutionary perspective, are most parts of the human body a feature or a bug? Is it like the optimal solution or just a duct taped solution?

• 7:20Speaker 01

  Great question. I think that most of the time, the way the body works is the best solution. I haven't seen many alternatives, so it's hard to compare. But I think, you know, there's some parts of the body that make more sense than others. You know, the way our hands work, for instance, you know, the muscles are up in the forearm and then the tendons kind of come down like strings on a puppet. And just the dexterity it gives our hands is just really amazing. And it's hard to imagine a better, a better tool than the human hand to do everything from, you know, hold things to play piano and do a million other daily activities that we do. One thing I talk about in the book, there's some other body parts that seem to be lacking that kind of brilliant design, such as the

• 8:05Speaker 01

  throat, you know, where the food, drink are swallowed and air is inhaled and they kind of those two paths come within millimeters of each other. And you slip up once, you laugh while eating, or you speak while trying to swallow and you die from choking. So it seems less than optimal, though I'm not sure it could be better from the way we're kind of formed in the womb as a beginning as this tiny little tube. I don't think it could have been done any better, or there's any other way to do it. But it is an unfortunate thing that, you know, does lead to some problems.

• 8:37Lex Fridman?

  So the hand, if I could just linger on that for a second, you talk about the wisdom of a design. In the book, what are the important things about the hand? It seems like very useful for many things and it seems to be quite effective. A lot of people think the thumb is foundational to, um, to the human civilization. Is there any truth to that?

• 9:01Speaker 01

  I think that is true. Actually, one of the ways in which the importance of individual fingers comes to attention is when people have severe injuries to their fingers. For instance, um, I have a story in the book about a guy whose thumb is nearly ripped off by his dog's leash. And, you know, when we, when plastic surgeons, who are often the ones to repair that, sometimes it's orthopedic surgeons, they will debate, you know, how important is it to save this finger? Or how important is it to save, you know, let's say the kind of tip, uh, the one third, the tip one third of one of your fingers, you know, depends on the length that you'll lose, it depends on which finger. And so the thumb really is the most crucial, um, just, you know, for your occupation in

• 9:44Speaker 01

  most cases to just daily life, um, and your ability to get around, take care of yourself and others. So, you know, the, they'll be more, they're willing to go further, do more surgeries, more aggressive therapy to save a thumb, let's say, um, than, you know, the tip of your pinky finger. So in that way, I do think the thumb, you know, does seem like the most important in many ways.

• 10:04Lex Fridman?

  It's nice that there's backups. I wonder if that's part of the future or is it just the symmetry that nature produces? You think, you think the two hands is like, is it about the symmetry or is it about backup?

• 10:16Speaker 01

  We'd be much less formidable hunters, gatherers, uh, survivors in any way if we only had one hand. So I think that is important to have two, so we can, you know, even everything from kind of, uh, spearing an animal to firing a bow and arrow to butchering an animal. You really need two hands to do it very effectively.

• 10:34Lex Fridman?

  But can you do a better job with three?

• 10:37Speaker 01

  Great question.

• 10:39Lex Fridman?

  And we'll never know perhaps.

• 10:43Lex Fridman?

  You tweeted, now I'm gonna analyze your tweets like it's Shakespeare sometimes. You tweeted that quote, millions of years of sex and death designed the human body. It's like poetry. Are those two basic activities basically summarize everything that resulted in humans on Earth? So like, is that a good summary of the evolutionary process that led to this conscious, intelligent being? Is death and sex?

• 11:13Speaker 01

  In a way, yeah. So sex is how more of us get made, obviously. And death is how we get weeded out, or the gene pool gets weeded out and certain genes survive and others don't. And, you know, the age at which we die, whether it's before we've, you know, had sex and reproduced ourselves, is a big factor. And who survives, who doesn't, who passes on their genes and what the future of the body looks like, you know, who lived and who died before they were able to be at reproductive age a million years ago was pretty important in what we look like now. And perhaps how we have sex and die now will determine what we're shaped like, unless technology has an even bigger role in that, you know, a million years from now.

• 11:56Lex Fridman?

  Do you think that's fundamental to like if there's alien civilizations out there that have the same order of magnitude of intelligence or greater? Do you think that we will see something like sex and something like death? So the reproducing and this selection process plus the weeding out of the old to make room for the new? Is that kind of foundational to life?

• 12:20Speaker 01

  I would think so. I mean, it sure seems to be on Earth, you know, perhaps in some distant future when medicine is nearing, you know, perfection and people can live a really long time. Maybe we won't even need to reproduce as much or something like that, you know? It's hard to even know what what life will be like in the distant future. But I would guess that any alien civilization will have the same dependence on who has sex and who dies.

• 12:44Lex Fridman?

  Well, that's the problem with immortality. How are we going to clear out the old to make room for the new, which is kind of a... It's like a framework of adaptability to changing environments. So as long as the environment is changing, and it seems to always be, because the entirety of the Earth system is a complex system. It seems like you have to adapt, and to adapt, you have to kill off the stubborn old ideas. And unless there's a way to like not become stubborn and old, but it feels like the nature of wisdom is stubborn and old. Like, that's what wisdom is.

• 13:26Lex Fridman?

  It's like the lessons of life, the lessons of experience solidified. And the solidification is the thing that actually prevents you from reinventing yourself to adapt to the new changing conditions. But then again, why not have that, both those modes? Like, have two minds in one person, one immortal person that, like, in the morning, they act like a teenager. In the evening, they act like an old wise man. That's possible. So you can imagine, within one mind, both modes. But those are required. You have to have, you have to have the ability to completely reinvent yourself,

• 14:08Lex Fridman?

  which is what death does in an ugly way. Or a beautiful way, depending on your perspective, depending whether you take the human perspective or the nature's perspective. And then you have to have the selection, so competition, so sexual selection. It's an interesting, interesting little planet we got. What's the weirdest part, function, concept, idea about the human body to you? We'll talk about fascinating details, but what's, you, I should say, for people that should read your book, they will come face to face with the fact that you do not shy away from the weird and the wonderful of the human body. It's like, it's fun, but it's honest.

• 14:53Lex Fridman?

  So given that, sorry to make you pick one of your children, but what's the weirdest one, would you say? The weirdest body part? Or concept, or function? So the chapters, you divide it up, kind of into parts, but there could be a thread that connects all of them, the weirdness, maybe, or maybe the texture of the substance, could be the liquids, the solids, I don't know.

• 15:21Speaker 01

  Definitely every body part and bodily fluid has their own kind of both gross and fascinating aspects. That's probably why I'm a generalist as a doctor and couldn't just, as you said, pick one of my children, become a specialist because I like them all. I feel like one of the strangest concepts about the human body is that kind of the aspects of it that are the most universal, that we all do, are the most taboo socially. I wouldn't have expected that if I had, you know, just looked from the outside, like what we do in the bathroom, what we do in the bedroom, what we do to our own genitals, what we do to our, you know, quote unquote, private parts, they're private, even though it's sort of the thing

• 16:03Speaker 01

  that we have all have in common is the most we try to hide from other people and don't talk about in polite company. I mean, it makes sense as a human living in this society, but from the outside, it sort of might be surprising.

• 16:14Lex Fridman?

  How do you make sense of that if you put on your Sigmund Freud hat? The thing we all do, why do we make that a taboo thing? Is it because we like taboos? Maybe we get off, or maybe our, our, our kinks as humans is to have taboos and it's kind of efficient to have taboos about the things that everybody does. Like you can make walking taboo or something, I don't know. But just, maybe that's what we love. That's what's exciting to us is the, is the forbidden.

• 16:46Speaker 01

  I think, yes, society loves rules for sure. They loves, some societies more than others, you know, they love controlling how you think and what you do in public versus in private. You know, there's a lot of societies where, for instance, parents have sex in front of children. Not, you know, for instance, like in a traditional Inupiat Eskimo societies, that was sort of normal. I mean, but what are you going to do? Go outside in the middle of the winter in the Arctic and do it out there? Of course not. So, you know, there's different, different taboos in different societies. Some taboos make perfect sense. Some taboos are. Even public health measures, you know, like as I talk in the book about in in India, where they, you know, the hands are symmetric, as you said, but in Indian culture and the

• 17:31Speaker 01

  left hand is taboo and the right hand is what you use for shaking hands, for eating, for other things. And the left hand is the dirty hand that you use for wiping your own bottom. You know, that's the toilet paper is your left hand. So while the body is anatomically symmetric, the taboo creates this pretty intense asymmetry. But for a good reason, you know, yet you probably shouldn't be shaking hands with other people with the same hand that you use to kind of clean your bottom. So in that sense, it makes sense.

• 18:00Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, maybe the roots of it makes sense, but the way it propagates, especially as the times change, might not, because you can wash your hands. But the taboo remains.

• 18:10Speaker 01

  Right. Society is very slow to change.

• 18:13Lex Fridman?

  What is the most fascinating part, function or concept in the human body? So,

• 18:21Lex Fridman?

  you know, something that fills you with awe.

• 18:24Speaker 01

  I guess the most obvious one is the brain, partly because it's so, you know, sort of poorly understood, though we understand more than we ever have in the past. There's still so much that we don't understand about how the lump of matter in our skulls kind of creates this subjective experience that we all kind of understand quite viscerally. That's an easy one. I would say the kidneys are an underappreciated organ. They, the way they tinker with the bloodstream, raise levels of this, lower levels of that, kind of our entire lives from inside the womb until we die is just really incredible. And when you look at how much energy different organs consume, the brain and the kidneys

• 19:06Speaker 01

  are two of the biggest ones, because the brain, obviously, in us is always active and controlling parts of the body. But the kidneys are just consuming a ton of energy to do what they do. They're kind of the unsung hero of the body relegated to the back of the abdomen, like some forgotten organ. But they're, they are great. I did consider being a nephrologist, which is a kidney specialist, because I was so taken with the kidneys, but, you know, decided I like all the organs, so couldn't pick just one.

• 19:32Lex Fridman?

  So your book is ordered in a particular way. It's throat, heart, feces, genitals, liver, pineal gland, brain, skin, urine, fat, lungs, eyes, mucus, fingers and toes, and blood. All right. First of all, great, great chapter titles. Is there a reason for this ordering or is it all madness?

• 20:01Speaker 01

  There's a few different reasons that went into it. I did want to start with the throat for the reason that it kind of presents the topic of death, which is sort of obviously very important in the training of a physician, in the career of physician. It's a big part of what I deal with. You know, on the first day of medical school, we started the dissection of a cadaver in the class called anatomy lab. And so in a way, we were kind of thrown right in there in the beginning, like this is the end of the human story, you know, and understand this. And then we sort of backed up to the beginning with embryology and reproduction and stuff. So it's kind of like we got, and I got thrown into that right, right away, right in the beginning, kind of like, here's a dead body.

• 20:44Speaker 01

  Now start cutting it apart and learn the name and function of absolutely every bit of flesh.

• 20:49Lex Fridman?

  How did that change you, that first experience with the cold honesty of human biology?

• 20:56Speaker 01

  Right, that's exactly what it was, is cold honesty about the kind of the story of, of each individual human body. It has an end and that's it. I think that, well, actually before the end of that first day, so what we did on that first day was study the superficial muscles of the back, like the lats or latissimus torsi and some other muscles, you know, we cut through the skin of the back. My cadaver was lying face down on this metal gurney. We pulled back the kind of plastic sheets that would keep him moist for the next four months as we dissected him, cut through the skin on his back and then started dissecting through the superficial muscles of the back. And that was really all we saw that first day. We didn't get any deeper, didn't enter the abdominal or, or chest cavity to see internal organs, but I was so fascinated with this sort of behind the scenes look at how things

• 21:41Speaker 01

  work in the body, how you move your arms, how you arch your back, you know, these are the muscles that do it, that I decided I wanted to donate my own body for the same purpose. So I made that decision literally before the end of that first day of class and I, I'm still sticking to it.

• 21:57Lex Fridman?

  So someday there'll be a medical student. They can watch and listen to this podcast while dissecting your body.

• 22:05Speaker 01

  It could happen. They might not know that that person they're listening to on the podcast will be the carcass in front of them. But like, we don't, we never learn.

• 22:13Lex Fridman?

  The universe will know.

• 22:14Speaker 01

  The universe will know.

• 22:15Lex Fridman?

  And they will acknowledge the irony or the humor, the absurdity of that.

• 22:20Speaker 01

  The universe will chuckle, but the medical student won't know because they never, as I did not, learn any, you know, personal information about the person, only what I could glean from looking inside him, which actually tells you quite a bit. I knew he was a smoker. I knew he had coronary artery disease. You know, you, you get a, a window into, I knew he was overweight. You get a window into people's lives just by looking in their, in their bodies after death. Other, other cadavers in the lab, not my own, or I shared one with three other students, but other cadavers, some had, you know, metal joints, like a knee replacement, some had a kidney missing. So they probably, and we could tell it was surgically removed, not that he was born with one. And we could tell that he probably had a kidney tumor or cancer that was removed.

• 23:04Speaker 01

  So you, you do get an insight into people's lives from, you know, picking them apart after they're dead, but you don't know their name or what podcast they've been on.

• 23:14Lex Fridman?

  So the, as the book title says, Unseen Body, so it tells some kind of story of your life. So it does capture the decisions you've made in your life, the things you've done that might be kind of secret to, to that person and maybe to a few others that knew him or her well. That's so fascinating. So what kind of things can it reveal? Like, what kind of choices in terms of the injuries, the, the catastrophic events, the lifestyle choices of smoking and diet and all those kinds of things? What, what, what, what can you see? What kind of history can you see about the human before you?

• 23:57Speaker 01

  So all those things you mentioned are things you can see. You can, you know, take the skin, for example, right? Most things that happen to us leave a mark. As I say, a kind of a story written in the language of scar where it tells you injuries you've had. And same thing with animals. You know, I've seen deer hides that have marks that look like they're made by maybe a barbed wire fence, something like that. You can tell, sometimes it's conjecture, but you can sort of imagine what might have happened to cause that. Perhaps, you know, two bucks were fighting and one got injured with an antler. And the same with humans. You know, I have scars on my body. And when I notice them, I remember what happened. You know, I got a big cut on my hand when I was 13 and it's

• 24:39Speaker 01

  still there. And I remember what happened, you know, every time I look at it. And so in that way, only I might know that story, but other people, you know, when they dissect me and notice the same scars, they can kind of, it can fire their imagination as my cadaver, you know, did for me.

• 24:54Lex Fridman?

  They know that there is a story there. That's such an interesting way that the skin does tell a story, both tattoos and scars.

• 25:04Speaker 01

  Right.

• 25:05Lex Fridman?

  Some of the fun you've had and some of the damage you've done.

• 25:08Speaker 01

  Right. And even when I, when I evaluate a patient, I can use scars to help me make medical decisions. So for instance, someone that comes in with abdominal pain into the emergency room, you can see scars on their abdomen that tell you about, you know, the past kind of activities of a surgeon, perhaps. I know, I recognize the scars that are left when someone has their gallbladder removed, the scars when someone has their appendix removed, when maybe when someone's had a hysterectomy. And that can tell you what it might be or what it isn't. You know, if someone doesn't have an appendix, their abdominal pain is not appendicitis, end of story. So in that way, I'm sort of looking at these, the tracks of a footprints of past surgeries to tell me what, what might and might not be the cause of this patient's abdominal pain, which is kind of my main job in the

• 25:52Speaker 01

  ER is figuring out what's causing it and to help them.

• 25:56Lex Fridman?

  Is there ways to get more data about the human body as we look into the future of medicine biology that will be helpful to fill in some of the gaps of the story? So, you know, you have, you have companies, you have research that looks at, you know, a collection of blood over long periods of time to see sort of, you know, paint the picture of what's happening in your body, mostly to help with lifestyle decisions, but, but also to, you know, to anticipate things that can go wrong and all that kind of stuff. Is there, can you just speak to a greater digital world that we're stepping in, how that can help tell a richer story?

• 26:39Speaker 01

  I certainly think that we have more data than we know what to do with right now, especially with kind of direct to consumer medical devices, you know, smartwatches, et cetera, that are just collecting these reams of data. I have not seen them put to, I think, the eventual use that they will. I think that the potential is sort of just, you know, unimaginable. And I hope we're heading into a new age where, you know, you can determine, for instance, is a, is a person going to have more of the dangerous side effects to a drug based on their genetics? Or are they going to tolerate one drug better than the other, you know, based on, on their genetics? And we are slowly moving into that

• 27:21Speaker 01

  age, and especially the age of kind of completely synthesizing drugs in a lab, you know, much like, for instance, some of the COVID vaccines, actually, like Moderna never had a, the virus in their lab. They made that vaccine completely without ever having the virus themselves, just by having the genome, which is sort of astounding. And there's a lot of potential going forward, you know, based on that technology and some others.

• 27:45Lex Fridman?

  I didn't know that. So they, basically, it's all in the computers, computational.

• 27:49Speaker 01

  Right. You have the genetic code. You have tremendous power, even if you don't have the organism itself.

• 27:54Lex Fridman?

  What do you make of Elizabeth Holmes and efforts like that? First of all, I'm a

• 28:05Lex Fridman?

  Curious, I'm drawn to the darkness in human nature because that somehow reveals the full spectrum of what humans could be. So there's a lot of sort of controversial thoughts about who she is and her efforts and so on. I think you may have even tweeted about it, but I've read a lot of your tweets, so I'm not forgetting. But what do you make of her and those, both those efforts and the charlatans, that sort of snake oil salesman that's promised those efforts to do more than they currently can?

• 28:45Speaker 01

  I think that her, you know, that goal that she had, that she created Theranos to try to achieve, to use less blood in tests, is a very worthy goal and a huge frontier that we have not achieved and that I hope we will achieve. So I understand why, you know, someone describes what a huge step forward that would be, and it would be indeed. I understand why people put a ton of money behind it.

• 29:10Lex Fridman?

  Can you describe what was the promise? What, what are we even talking about? What's Theranos? What, just for people who don't know?

• 29:16Speaker 01

  So Theranos is a company that was basically started to revolutionize the way medical blood tests are done, both to use a whole lot less blood in doing it. You know, if anyone's ever been to the doctor and had five to 10 tubes of blood removed from them, it can be quite surprising how much they take out. And, and it's, you know, that's the limitation of our technology that we need those volumes of blood to run all the tests that we want to. And so the promise of Theranos was that perhaps with a single drop of blood, we would be able to know as much about the person's, the condition of their, their body without drawing all that blood. And thereby, you know, there would be these devices she was going to create that would sort of do it. You put a drop of blood in and spits out everything you ever wanted to know about what's in your

• 30:01Speaker 01

  bloodstream. And in a way that would make it so much easier, you know, it could be, you could have one in your home theoretically and you, I don't know why you'd wonder what your potassium level is on any given day, but you could check if you wanted to. And so that that goal is very worthy, you know, I put that goal up there with the frontier of making painkillers that are as good as opioids without the addictive quality, you know, that would be such a huge revolution if we did have that in medicine. But particularly for me, because I trained in both pediatrics and internal medicine. So I learned to care for both children and adults. In children, we do draw much less blood. They have a much lower blood volume and we use these tiny little tubes to draw their blood. And we seemingly get equivalent information out of the larger tubes we draw

• 30:45Speaker 01

  from adults. And I'm still unclear, to be honest, why we can't draw that little amount of blood from adults. It seems technically possible. I don't know what the barriers are. I'm sure there are, or else we'd be doing it. But I do think that that is a very important goal. And if Theranos had done it, they would have really revolutionized the practice of medicine.

• 31:03Lex Fridman?

  So to return to that cadaver, that first day when you got to meet with a with a dead, with a human body that's no longer living. So how quickly did it take for you to get used to sort of, you said, looking at the surface muscles of the back? I mean, that can be overwhelming as a thought and people listening to this that have never dissected anything might be overwhelmed by that thought. So like, how quickly were you able to get used to the brutal honesty of the biology before you?

• 31:43Speaker 01

  For me, it did not take long at all. I guess I've not never been a squeamish person. So for me, it was kind of riveting and fascinating right from the first moment. But I do know some of my fellow classmates did have some trouble with it. Some of them I heard had nightmares in the first few weeks of anatomy lab. And but then everyone, as far as I know, got used to it. And that was also actually a big lesson for me that it's pretty amazing what people can get used to in their daily lives. And I kind of extrapolated that to people living through war and through, you know, just terrible situations and living under, you know, oppressive regimes. And it really is amazing what people can get used to. Almost anything.

• 32:25Lex Fridman?

  But you know, in war, people often come back and they have nightmares. They suffer through it. There's PTSD. There's a, there's a lot of complicated feelings with that.

• 32:38Lex Fridman?

  Are echoes of those same complicated feelings possible in the case of training to be and becoming a doctor?

• 32:46Speaker 01

  It's a good point. Yeah, I think, you know, sometimes just as, you know, a barbed wire fence can leave a scar on your skin, you know, emotional, psychological experiences can leave a mark on your brain or your memory. And I think that that definitely could be, could be a problem in medical training. You do see a lot of things that are very shocking, very repulsive, things that you'd never forget. I know one of those students that had nightmares initially went on to be a surgeon. So I imagine she's not having the PTSD of kind of seeing inside in her first dead body because she sees inside them all day, every day now. But I'm sure it could, you know, we go on to see so many kind of grosser or more shocking

• 33:30Speaker 01

  things in medical training through medical school and then by working with actual living patients, not just dead and embalmed bodies. So I do think that things can leave a mark, but I don't think that initial cadaver would be the most traumatic.

• 33:46Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, but maybe some of that trauma, the demons make you a better surgeon, just like some of your own psychological trauma might make you a better psychiatrist. Returning to the ordering, is it order or is it chaos? The ordering of the chapters from throat and heart and feces and genitals, all the way to fingers and toes and blood?

• 34:11Speaker 01

  So I did mention that, you know, throat was the first one because I kind of wanted to throw the reader right into the brutal honesty of death. And I followed it up with feces as the third chapter, and in a way, partly to also throw them right into the deep end of how I like discussing parts of the body and revealing their gross and fascinating aspects. So I didn't want to hide anything, you know, when you train to be a doctor, everything is on the table, literally in the cadaver lab, but also just, you know, you deal with blood and piss and vomit and feces, and that's kind of the medium of your craft and.

• 34:47Lex Fridman?

  Yes, the medium of the craft. That's right.

• 34:49Speaker 01

  Right.

• 34:49Lex Fridman?

  Like if you're a painter, this is the paint that you're wearing.

• 34:54Speaker 01

  Exactly.

• 34:55Lex Fridman?

  And then you have to create a masterpiece with it. Uh, like, almost like a dance, because there's multiple painters. One of the painters is the biology. So let's return to throat. You mentioned it's a weird one. So first of all, a friend of mine said, I just see humans as a, like, a bunch of holes that just walk, walk around.

• 35:18Speaker 01

  Not untrue.

• 35:20Lex Fridman?

  Funny way to look at humans. So we have ears, we have nose, we have mouth, we have the sexual holes, vagina, penis, and then, uh, you know, what's the medical term for your asshole?

• 35:37Speaker 01

  Anus.

• 35:37Lex Fridman?

  Anus, thank you.

• 35:40Lex Fridman?

  This is a very technical discussion.

• 35:41Speaker 01

  The rectum's further in, don't confuse the two.

• 35:44Lex Fridman?

  Oh, that's very important. What, what, is there a difference between throat and mouth? By the way, so when you say throat, are we talking about when that hole actually became, becomes tubular?

• 35:55Speaker 01

  The throat, I would count as just sort of the very back of the, of the, you know, the back of the mouth, where the nose also comes down and meets it, where the tonsils are and the uvula. But you're right that, you know, we are a bunch of holes, but more accurately, we're a tube, right? We start in the womb as kind of this microscopic little disc, almost like a, you know, a flatbread, and then we're, we roll, almost like a burrito, into this tube. And we're a simple microscopic tube, and from there, we grow into this bigger and bigger tube, and we become more complicated. And each end of the tube does split into various holes. So all the holes you mentioned at the front end of the tube, the front end of our body, right? It splits into the nose, the mouth, the ears, the sinuses, the, the tube to the lungs,

• 36:39Speaker 01

  which is the windpipe, the tube down to the stomach, which is the esophagus. And then the other end of the tube splits as well. You know, men end up with two holes, and women end up with three holes. You know, the urethra, the vagina, and the anus, and men just, you know, the urethra and kind of the reproductive system, they share a hole.

• 36:57Lex Fridman?

  So I'm learning a lot today. It really is incredible that you start from sperm and an egg, and you have some DNA information, and from that, the building project begins. And then what that leads to is like a, like a pizza dough, and then you roll it into a tube, and that tube then...

• 37:21Lex Fridman?

  Eventually, sort of becomes more and more complicated and gets eyes and a brain, and then can create a Twitter account. So from, it's really incredible that we're just a fancy tube.

• 37:38Speaker 01

  Right, we are. And we sprout eyes and a brain and a sense of smell and taste, pretty much to regulate what comes in the front of the tube. You know, we don't want to eat anything dangerous or poisonous. You know, we want to choose what we eat, even choose who we kiss.

• 37:52Lex Fridman?

  Well, we seem to be motivated by what comes out of the tube as well, in part. That's not just output. It's a feedback mechanism, seemingly. Like, we're also monitoring the functioning of the output. We're not just obsessed about the input.

• 38:08Speaker 01

  We're very obsessed with the output. You're absolutely right about that. People, you know, have medical complaints about their output very often that are, you know, I'm never, I never cease to be surprised by a new kind of complaint or observation about the output.

• 38:22Lex Fridman?

  I think people have gone to wars over the output and maybe sometimes the lack of the output, or the desire for output with the particular other humans that you fancy. The brain and the eyes that sprouted somehow convinced the rest of the body that this one particular other tube is fanciful. So you're going to go to major wars and lead global suffering because of the fancy and the desire for additional output with the other tube. Okay, so that's, so on the throat, that part of the tube, is it, you said the

• 39:06Lex Fridman?

  design is not, you could have thought of maybe a little bit better options because it's too multifunctional. Is that, can you sort of elaborate on the multifunctional nature of this part? Are a lot of parts of the human body multifunctional? Or do you find that it's more specialization?

• 39:24Lex Fridman?

  Is going to get the job done better.

• 39:26Speaker 01

  There is a lot of organs, for instance, do have multiple functions. You know, the pancreas is has two, is like two organs in one. One, you know, secretes hormones like insulin into the bloodstream. And the other aspect of it secretes digestive enzymes into the gut to help you digest and absorb food. The liver is like 15 organs in one. It's just amazing how many different things it does. But the throat, you know, so basically the problem with the throat is, as I said, we have two tubes that are right next to each other in the throat. One is for food, drink, saliva, mucus, snot, whatever you're going to swallow. All of that stuff must go down the esophagus, the food tube, and end up in the stomach. And right next to the esophagus, millimeters away, is the windpipe or the trachea,

• 40:10Speaker 01

  which goes down to the lungs. And your, your throat does these daily gymnastics to keep everything but air out of the windpipe because, you know, you slip up once and you can die. You can choke, you know, you laugh or speak while eating and, and it's curtains, unfortunately. So it seems like, you know, every aspect of the body, when I was learning about it in med school, seems so brilliant and so perfectly designed by evolution, or whoever you might think designed it, to, you know, favor survival, to enhance life.

• 40:46Speaker 01

  But the throat seemed the opposite. It seemed set up almost for failure. And, you know, we developed all these mechanisms as a compensation, right? We have the gag reflex whenever food or something is headed towards your air pipe, your windpipe or down to your lungs. Your throat has this sort of like rejection of it. It pushes it away in a gag reflex. At the same time, we have a cough, which is something our body does when something inappropriate does get down the windpipe. You know, when we get a little food down the wrong pipe, we end up coughing and the coughing does. Usually flush it out and get rid of it. We even have something called the mucus elevator in our lungs, which is this constant flow of mucus up the airways, up to the trachea,

• 41:30Speaker 01

  dragging with it all kinds of particulates that we've inhaled and perhaps some food that went down the wrong pipe and drags it up into the throat and we swallow it kind of unconsciously all day, every day is the truth. Even the mechanism of swallowing is super complicated. You know, it uses a number of cranial nerves. It's uses over 15 different muscles. It's this coordinated act to keep food out of the airway. You know, you can see someone's Adam's apple in their neck kind of jump upward when they swallow, which helps lift the airway up against this kind of the epiglottis, which plugs it closed and allows food or swallowed drink to kind of skirt just past it. But every time we swallow, those things do come within millimeters of going down the wrong pipe. And it's just

• 42:14Speaker 01

  thanks to these kind of compensations, these adaptations we have to the danger of the throat that that keeps us alive.

• 42:21Lex Fridman?

  As I actually took a sip of water, it's kind of, it makes you appreciate the wonderful machinery of it all. By the way, we have pulled up your Instagram that people should follow. You have a post about the throat and then just showing so many different components from the tongue to the trachea, the esophagus, just the entire machinery of it all. The teeth for the chewing. It's so interesting. And so a lot of the structure of this, the anatomy and the physiology, does it echo other mammals? Are we, so are we just basically borrowing

• 43:05Lex Fridman?

  a lot of stuff from evolution and maybe making small adjustments, maybe due to the fact that we're not using our mouth to murder things as other predators might?

• 43:16Lex Fridman?

  We use our thumbs.

• 43:18Speaker 01

  Exactly. We have hands. We don't need to bite them. Yeah, there's a lot of overlap between different animals, which I find very comforting and fascinating. You know, someone asked me, is there any animal in which the throat is better designed? And I, my first thought was whales, because the blowhole is kind of up on the top of their head. So I was thinking, oh, maybe, maybe they are set more separate. But when I looked into it, actually, no, you know, the paths do come very close, just like in us. And I saw a paper about some new discovered organ that actually helps keep food and drink out of the airway in whales that they hadn't ever noticed before. So it's a different mechanism, but the same kind of basic problem is that, you know, we're tubes and the air tube and food tube are right next to each other.

• 44:01Lex Fridman?

  How well do we understand, so just even lingering on this little part, is there still mysteries about the complexity of the system? Because you mentioned, just even for swallowing, all these parts in the brain that are responsible and all, all the different things that have to, like an orchestra play together. Do we have a good sense from both a medical perspective and a biology perspective? Or is there still mysteries?

• 44:23Speaker 01

  There's definitely still mysteries. We understand a lot about, for instance, how the swallowing mechanism, you know, is coordinated. It's in the brain stem, sometimes using some higher levels of the brain. But it is a very thoughtless thing, as you mentioned, when you drank the water. You know, it's not something we have to think about, thankfully, or we'd be thinking about it all day. There's a lot we don't understand about the basic mechanisms, perhaps about how the nerves fire and how they kind of, you know, coordinate on the, on the microscopic level, how ions rush into and out of nerve cells to kind of create that electrical signal. But we sure understand a heck of a lot, and it's very fascinating.

• 45:02Lex Fridman?

  So moving on to chapter two, we'll jump around. And you actually said the liver does a lot of things. I also saw you retweet something.

• 45:15Lex Fridman?

  Where it said, you know, showing that the liver is bigger than the heart, which is the body or the universe's way of saying you should drink more and care less. This is a good line. So you give props, like you said, to the kidney, to the liver, to the maybe, to the organs, to the parts that don't often get as much credit as they deserve. But let us go for time to the human heart.

• 45:44Lex Fridman?

  We get chest pain. We talk about it when we talk about love for some reason. Why do we talk about the heart when we talk about love?

• 45:53Speaker 01

  There sometimes can actually be some chest pain involved in love. I remember when I was a med student, I was very smitten with another medical student. It was totally brilliant and beautiful. And it actually does cause this kind of burning in your chest. I don't know what that is. I don't think it's from the heart itself. I don't know if it was like acid reflux because I was so nervous. I'm not really sure, but I definitely felt something in my chest whenever I saw her. I don't know what that is, but you could see why someone might think, oh, you know, maybe it is your heart. That's kind of the most prominent organ in your chest. When people come to the ER with chest pain, you know, the big question is, is it my heart? And that's my main job is figuring out if it is or not. So I could see why, you know, the way ancients saw the functions of different organs is fascinating,

• 46:37Speaker 01

  but often hard to explain.

• 46:40Lex Fridman?

  Would it be fair to say that if you look at the entirety of human history, the way most people die has to do with the heart?

• 46:49Speaker 01

  Well, like in America today, cardiovascular disease and coronary artery disease is one of the most common, perhaps the most common cause of death. You know, 100 years ago, 200 years ago, it was probably not. People were not living as long and people were dying of infections that we tend to die less of these days.

• 47:08Lex Fridman?

  Sure. That's true. But in terms of things to stab. So I'm trying to sort of introspect like, why, why talk about the heart and love?

• 47:20Lex Fridman?

  My thought would be that is because the heart was seen as the most important organism. It would be like the origin of life comes from the heart. The originator of life and the way you figure that out from sort of an ancient perspective is when you stab things. What is likely to lead to issues? It's like, it's possible to imagine that the brain is not as special as we might think from when you don't understand modern biology or physiology or neuroscience, all those kinds of things, especially because pain, you know, is painless too. If you stab it, the brain, I mean.

• 48:02Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, anyway, so that's, that's really interesting. I'm sure there's a, there's a kind of a poetic answer to maybe the way people wrote about it. But what to you is the wisdom in the design of the heart?

• 48:15Speaker 01

  I mean, the main function of the heart basically is to push blood through the cardiovascular system, through the branching blood vessels to feed every cell in the body. You know, when I, I believe our ancestors started off as single celled organisms floating in some ancient brew. And they were surrounded by the medium that would bring them all the nutrients they needed. So there's no issues there. And then once you start getting multicellular organisms, the kind of that are thicker and the ones on the inside aren't in contact with that sort of nutritious brew that they're growing in. You kind of need a way to distribute those nutrients to every cell. And so that's what the heart and the branching vascular tree do. So the heart, you know, it's the most, the biggest disconnect between how the organs talked about in poetry and through history

• 49:00Speaker 01

  versus his actual function is probably the heart. Cause we ascribe all these things like love and passion and life itself sometimes to the heart. But actually it's just a simple mechanical pump. You know, that's all it is. I don't want to downplay it. It's amazing, but um, you know, it just pushes. It fills with blood and then squeezes it, fills a button, squeezes it. And just that squeezing, that pushing creates the blood pressure that you need to get blood to every cell in your body, especially when you're standing upright to get blood to your brain. You need a certain amount of pressure to get it up there.

• 49:30Lex Fridman?

  Isn't it amazing to you how much volume of blood just gets pushed through by this, by this pump?

• 49:37Speaker 01

  Absolutely. They say every red blood cell takes about five minutes to circulate and come back to the heart. And that circulation kind of, you know, starts in the womb and continues and kind of until the moment that we die. But the volume is tremendous and it can never, you know, take a break, basically.

• 49:54Lex Fridman?

  And it's sort of propagating all kinds of stuff throughout the body. It's a delivery mechanism, blood for all kinds of good stuff and bad stuff, nutrition, drugs, all that.

• 50:08Speaker 01

  Right. Medications too.

• 50:09Lex Fridman?

  Medications. Such a fascinating design.

• 50:13Speaker 01

  And it also takes the waste away. You know, it kind of brings the nutritious stuff, brings the nutrients, especially oxygen, but many other things. And then it also, as it passes the cell, takes the cell's waste. So it's sort of the freshwater and the sewage system in one.

• 50:27Lex Fridman?

  So about blood, what do you use fascinating about blood? So we talk about the pump that spreads the blood, but the blood itself.

• 50:37Speaker 01

  Right. So the blood itself is sort of, I mean, it's the most important bodily fluid, of course. It, you know, from moment to moment, every cell in the body needs a flow of blood to bring it, most importantly, oxygen, but also, again, all the other nutrients and to take away waste. And if that stops for even a few moments, you can be in big trouble. So blood is sort of, you know, the most important medium. It's also, doctors use it to kind of evaluate the body. It does have this kind of all seeing quality to it where, you know, we can evaluate organs through the blood. I can tell you about your liver, your heart, your kidney, just by taking a sample of your blood. So it's sort of like this crystal ball in a way, and we use it kind of all the time, you know, to assess someone's health, to assess their disease.

• 51:23Lex Fridman?

  Is it also the attack vector for diseases, for bacteria, for viruses and all that kind of stuff? So viruses seem to attack you through the throat. Maybe you can correct me, but they seem to attack different parts of the body, depending on how easy it is to access and how easy it is to get in deep, depending on what you prefer. If you want to do a little bit of hard work, but you get in deep, or you don't want to do the hard work, but you don't get in deep. Those are the choices viruses have. But is blood one of the sort of attack vectors? What's like, if you were trying to break into the human body? Like a parasite, a virus, a bacteria. How would you do it?

• 52:07Lex Fridman?

  Like, what would you, what would be the attack vectors you would explore?

• 52:10Speaker 01

  Right, so you got to look for the body's weaknesses, of course. You know, we have inherent weaknesses, for instance, like our respiratory tract. We have to breathe. We have to get air in from the outside. And so that's one of the entries into the body. And so, you know, when we inhale, let's say, a poisonous gas, you know, it's, it's an easy way in. You have to breathe, can't hold your, your breath very long. But, you know, air in our lungs is still kind of contiguous with the out, external atmosphere. It's not really inside the body until it does cross, across the lining of the alveoli into the blood. As you said, that's when it really gets inside. And the other, besides the respiratory tract, the gastrointestinal tract is another way, kind of a chink in the armor. You know, we have to eat, we have to drink, and therefore we're taking the external world into ourselves,

• 52:54Speaker 01

  into our gut, in order to extract from it what we need and let the rest kind of flow out. So those two, the gastrointestinal and respiratory tract, you know, there's a reason that, you know, respiratory tract infections and gastrointestinal infections are kind of the most common that afflict us because those are the ways in to the body. So I would definitely pick one of those. Not just be a lazy cold in the nose, but really a more aggressive pneumonia down deep in the lungs and get across that barrier into the blood.

• 53:21Lex Fridman?

  But also the whole sex thing that humans do. So, speaking of which, let us go for time to the genitals chapter. So, what are genitals? I think I've heard of those. I think I've read about a penis and a vagina. Can you explain to me how those work? Just asking for a friend. But also, what is fascinating about it? And maybe what's misunderstood or little known about them?

• 53:54Speaker 01

  Sure. So they're very unique organs, I would say. One of the things that I like to point out is that, you know, while every organ from moment to moment keeps us alive and ensures our survival, the genitals are, in a way, the opposite. You know, we don't need them from moment to moment. You don't even have to use them at all. And in fact, they often make us do stupid things that are the opposite of kind of enhancing survival. So, and they, you know, they've affected the brain and you can become sort of focused and nuts based on those desires that kind of stem from the genitals. So they can be dangerous organs, too. But, you know, I mean, sexual dimorphism helps with genetic variability, as it does in so many other organisms. You know, you take two people and mix them together,

• 54:38Speaker 01

  their genetics, you just get a lot more variation and more opportunities to try different genetic codes and see what'll enhance survival, as we talked about sex and death. I talk about in the book, a lot of, for instance, the female genital tract, how the uterus is very unusual because, you know, it doesn't even sort of wake up and start doing its thing until the second decade of life. You know, it's, even though babies, female babies are born with all of the eggs they'll ever have in their ovaries already, they're just sort of in this stasis until they start waking up kind of once a month. And it's this, this cycle, you know, there's so much in our bodies that are cyclical and rhythmic, the heartbeat,

• 55:18Speaker 01

  the breathing. But menstruation is kind of a very strange rhythm that takes over a decade to start and only, you know, the rhythm beats once a month, which is very slow compared to every other rhythm of the body. The other unusual thing is, you know, in medicine, when rhythms of the body cease, when they stop, those are emergencies, right? When your heart stops, that's a cardiac arrest. You need CPR, maybe an electric shock to restart it. When your breathing stops, you know, you need a breathing machine to breathe for you or something to reverse whatever might be causing the suppression of your breathing. But when menstruation stops, it's the point of menstruation in the first place.

• 55:58Speaker 01

  The whole reason that the uterus grows a lining and sheds it each month is to one day, you know, get fertil, the ovum to get fertilized and for it to implant in the lining. And then the rhythm ceases and that's obviously not a medical emergency, unlike most other rhythms, you know, cessations. It's the point of the whole thing in the first place.

• 56:16Lex Fridman?

  So these particular penis and vagina are that whole thing, the uterus, whatever. Am I not using the wrong terms? I don't know. I'll just keep saying.

• 56:25Speaker 01

  We use those terms. There's more technical, there's parts, various, various parts. In medical school, you learn every bump and, you know, every little part of every little organ and including the genitals, so.

• 56:38Lex Fridman?

  I never really thought of it this way, as you said, is that most organs are kind of full-time employees, like 24/7, they're doing something. And then there's some organs, penis or vagina being representative of this, they're not functioning all the time. They're only functioning every once in a while and then get us to do stupid stuff or awesome stuff and all that kind of stuff. But they're not essential for human survival on a second by second basis. And the whole cyclical nature of the human body, how many other cycles are on a monthly basis? Like that far apart? That's a, that's a fascinating design that the human body would do that and wouldn't start

• 57:23Lex Fridman?

  until the second decade, decade of life. It's almost like, um, what do I want to say? There's some kind of meta-planning going on. Like this is the optimal solution for the sexual selection mechanism among like somewhat intelligent species. Like it's useful to, after the brain has developed sufficiently long, to now be making sexual selection decisions. Like you need time for this computer, this really powerful computer to load in the info.

• 58:00Lex Fridman?

  Interesting.

• 58:01Speaker 01

  You also need the body to develop, you know, a child simply isn't big enough to be pregnant and deliver a, you know, another baby.

• 58:08Lex Fridman?

  I wonder if there's animals in which this happens at a much more accelerated pace in different stages.

• 58:13Speaker 01

  Definitely, especially, you know, certain kinds of insects, you know, like Trusophila, a lot of the fruit fly, a lot of experiments are done on because their life cycle is so rapid, you know, a lot of kind of insects and other creatures are almost ready to mate as soon as they're born.

• 58:29Speaker 01

  Not us.

• 58:30Lex Fridman?

  Not us. Is there any improvements to the design? So a lot of people are very interested in these particular body parts. If you were to sort of step back as a geneticist, biological designer, or maybe a computer scientist, computer engineer, trying to build human 2.0, or maybe a robot, how would you improve the penis and the vagina?

• 58:59Speaker 01

  Well, the penis, for starters, I mean, let's also discuss the testicles, you know, they're very important, too. I mean.

• 59:05Lex Fridman?

  Okay, so they're, yes.

• 59:07Speaker 01

  Right, so they're fragile and they're important, and yet they're hanging off the body in danger, basically. So, um, does that make sense? You know, they begin in the womb, they begin inside the abdomen, and they slowly descend, and sometimes before birth, sometimes in the first year of life, sometimes never, they pop out of the body and end up hanging in the scrotum. There's a reason, because the chemical reactions that create sperm function best at a few degrees cooler than body temperature. And so that's why you might notice in the warm weather, they might hang further down, and in the cold weather, they scrunch themselves up to get closer to the body to maintain that ideal temperature, a few degrees cooler.

• 59:49Speaker 01

  So it's hard, you know, if you could create a sperm production mechanism that did not rely on that lower temperature, that would be great, keep them inside the body protected like the ovaries are.

• 59:58Lex Fridman?

  But oh, then you wouldn't rely on lower temperature. I thought you meant create some kind of weird internal cooling mechanism.

• 1:00:06Speaker 01

  No, well, now I guess that would be one solution, but just maybe a different type of chemical reaction or, you know, would not be reliant on the lower temperature. Let's say, um, you know, it'd be great to design spermatogenesis or sperm production process that would function best at body temperature. And then we can keep those delicate organs inside the body and not have them hanging out in danger.

• 1:00:29Lex Fridman?

  Or maybe the argument for this design is, uh, maybe it's nice to put them in danger. So you are constantly concerned about it.

• 1:00:40Speaker 01

  Could be, maybe that's beneficial for male psychology. I'm not really sure.

• 1:00:44Lex Fridman?

  There's a psychological element here about the evolution that could be. So that's testicles, uh, penis.

• 1:00:52Speaker 01

  Um, a better way to do it, you know, I mean, it's pretty good as it is, you know, it kind of, when it's time for it to work, it, it grows and stiffens. And when it's time for it not to work, it, it kind of shrinks and hangs out.

• 1:01:07Lex Fridman?

  Saw this on a Seinfeld episode, so I know how it works.

• 1:01:11Speaker 01

  Shrinkage.

• 1:01:12Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, that was a good one.

• 1:01:13Speaker 01

  But, you know, that's, that's also a bit unique. I suppose that, you know, the way it's, it has this erectile tissue. Actually, they're similar. In the mouth of certain baleen whales, there's a certain similar kind of erectile tissue that helps, um, cool, cool them off. Um, because they have so much blubber and creates so much heat and moving around and feeding that they have actually a similar, similar to the penis organ in their mouth that helps cool their bodies because it's a big problem. They have to store all that blubber for fuel, but it makes them too hot. So as a compensation, they have this kind of erectile organ in their mouth.

• 1:01:49Lex Fridman?

  Okay. What about vagina?

• 1:01:53Speaker 01

  You know, the fact that miscarriages sometimes happen because of sexually transmitted diseases, because of trauma, you know, it'd be great if the uterus where the growing fetus is is sort of even more protected from those things.

• 1:02:10Speaker 01

  You know, I guess that's, it's a side effect of the fact that people still have sex when they're pregnant, are still, you know, exposed to injury. If there was a way to make it more protected, perhaps that would be even better. I did see an article recently about the artificial wombs, which are rapidly becoming a reality. And in, in animal studies, they're able to prolong the gestation of a fetus by a month in an artificial womb.

• 1:02:35Lex Fridman?

  Can you explain the artificial aspect of the artificial womb?

• 1:02:38Speaker 01

  Sure. It's, um, I believe it, it acts almost like a, a heart lung bypass machine. So when someone's getting like bypass surgery, their heart is stopped. Literally they throw ice in the chest and they, um, give a potassium infusion through the blood, which stops the heart. But the blood is run through a machine that basically does what the work of the heart and lungs together, gets oxygen into the blood and then pushes it in back into the body. So it's, I believe it's a sort of similar mechanism to keep blood and nutrition flowing to this fetus. And so it's just not inside the body of a parent. It's in some kind of other device, but I think that science is going to rapidly improve.

• 1:03:21Speaker 01

  One benefit is, you know, babies are born premature and while, you know, neonatology is able to continuously kind of lower the age of viability through better technology and understanding how, what you can, medicines and other things you can do to, to premature babies when they're born, you know? Ideally, if let's say premature labor begins, you can't stop it. That baby's coming out one way or the other. If you could just then stick it into an artificial womb where it can continue its development, that would save a whole host of problems off. And those babies born very early suffer from damage to various organs, including the brain, you know, for the rest of their life. So that could be a very important technology.

• 1:03:59Lex Fridman?

  So some aspects of the human body, we can develop technologies that outsource them, sort of a...

• 1:04:07Lex Fridman?

  Offload some of the stress and the workload from the human body to do it elsewhere.

• 1:04:14Speaker 01

  Like dialysis does that for kidneys. You know, people can live decades without kidneys as long as they get dialysis, which does the work for them. Not every organ can do that. For instance, the liver, there's no dialysis version for the liver. Like if your liver fails, you need a liver transplant and that's the only thing that's gonna do it for you.

• 1:04:35Lex Fridman?

  So that's the world's first artificial womb for humans. And we're looking at a picture of what looks like gigantic balloons.

• 1:04:44Speaker 01

  Matrix, here we come.

• 1:04:46Lex Fridman?

  This is very matrix-y. How are they floating? What are we even looking at? There's giant red spheres. This really looks like the Matrix. I wonder where it's from. So there seems to be a paper on this, too.

• 1:05:02Speaker 01

  I don't know too much about it, but I did see that there it's advancing very rapidly.

• 1:05:07Lex Fridman?

  The world's first artificial womb for humans. Scientists in the Netherlands say there within 10 years of developing an artificial womb that could save the lives of premature babies. Premature birth before 37 weeks is globally the biggest cause of death among newborns, but the development also raises ethical questions about the future of baby making, and so on and so forth. Wow. We're going to be facing a lot of ethical questions as we start to mess with human biology. In an effort to help human biology, we might start to mess with it. And it's gonna be very interesting as we take steps

• 1:05:49Lex Fridman?

  towards, towards the Matrix.

• 1:05:55Lex Fridman?

  All right. What about the neighbors? Poop, feces? There seems to be a lot of interesting stories in that particular output as well.

• 1:06:11Lex Fridman?

  What to you is fascinating? What?

• 1:06:18Lex Fridman?

  What to you maybe is misunderstood or little known about poop?

• 1:06:25Speaker 01

  Well, it's hilarious, for one thing.

• 1:06:27Lex Fridman?

  Yeah.

• 1:06:27Speaker 01

  That we do it.

• 1:06:28Lex Fridman?

  Fun to say it. Oh, okay.

• 1:06:29Speaker 01

  The word is great as well.

• 1:06:30Lex Fridman?

  Yes.

• 1:06:31Speaker 01

  There's so many different words. I do, you know, when I'm talking to the parents of pediatric patients, I use the word poop. I don't often, when I'm talking to adult patients, try to choose a more mature word. But poop is amazing. I mean, I guess it's, you know, it's sort of the most, the dirtiest, the most vile, the most hated aspect of our bodies. It's the grossest. We don't want to think about it, talk about it, have it anywhere near our, you know, food or in social interactions. With good reason, you know, I mentioned gastrointestinal infections are one of the most common infections the human body suffers from. And, you know, what we call, the way they spread from person to person, grossly enough, is referred to

• 1:07:13Speaker 01

  as the feco-oral route, which is, means a bit of someone's stool is getting into your, you're swallowing it, you know, through the water supply. For instance, diarrhea is actually quite a brilliant mechanism of these microbes, right? If you, let's say you're in the intestine of one person, your goal is to get into the intestines of another person. Brilliant to just trick their intestines into secreting all this fluid into, into the intestines to increase the volume of stool and its runniness, so that when they do poop, it gets into the water supply and then everyone else kind of ends up getting infected as well.

• 1:07:47Lex Fridman?

  Wow, that's brilliant.

• 1:07:48Speaker 01

  Just the same way like, you know, tuberculosis or coronavirus kind of infects your lungs and makes you cough, and you send it out into the air and it ends up in other people's lungs.

• 1:07:57Lex Fridman?

  And that's all evolution.

• 1:07:59Speaker 01

  Yeah, it's brilliant. So diarrhea is intelligent. Is a big takeaway lesson.

• 1:08:05Lex Fridman?

  It's one of the most intelligent things we can do as an entirety of an organism, not just the particular cognitive organism, but there's, there's, you know, we're, we're made up of bacteria and viruses and there's a lot of visitors and so on. As the entirety of the system, diarrhea is one of our better accomplishments. It's fascinating. Well, I wonder, why is poop funny?

• 1:08:29Speaker 01

  I think a lot of that is socially constructed, just how it's sort of supposed to be hidden away, yet something we always do, something, you know, we chuckle about as children. And but even in healthcare, you know, it becomes this big topic of conversation because you end up talking about it constantly. Like in the ER, people come in, I, they're complete strangers, sometimes like a nice old lady who resembles my grandmother. And all of a sudden I have to ask her all about what's happening in the bathroom. Like, is she straining? What color is it? What, what, you know, what's the consistency? Does it float on top of the water more than it should? Is it hard to flush? I mean, there's a million different questions you learn as a, as a medical student and you're like this poop detective when people come in with issues.

• 1:09:13Speaker 01

  And so it's, it's funny, I guess, you know, in the exam room with the doctor-patient relationship, there's sort of no barriers, you know, you talk about everything and you're talking about the most intimate details of a person's life, even though you just met them a second ago. It's so different than normal social interactions, yet there is this social aspect. A lot of what I do is social, you know, it seems like doctors, what they do is mostly scientific. But actually, it's just relating to another person and you have to maintain, you know, your professional demeanor and this normal human level interaction, even though you're talking about poop. And that's a skill, that's an art and a science.

• 1:09:51Lex Fridman?

  Well, okay, actually, I want to linger on that because I'm a fan of just diving into conversations right away with strangers, just getting no small talk. And this is like the ultimate, I don't know if it's the ultimate, but it's one version of no small talk. You get right to the point. I, that's really powerful from a psychology perspective. You're a kind of therapist or you have the power to be a therapist. And I don't mean just about the medical condition of the body, but the psychological. There's so much fear connected to this concern, also self doubt.

• 1:10:34Lex Fridman?

  Insecurities, even sort of existential thoughts about your mortality, all of those things are right there in the room. So I think one way doctors deal with that is they kind of have this cold way about them. They almost have that dual mode. One is like, I'm going to be friendly on the surface and cold about the brutal honesty of the biology. But I wonder if there's like a skillful middle ground, this dangerous place where you can help people deal with their psychological insecurities, concerns, fears, all those kinds of things. Is that just really tough to do?

• 1:11:17Speaker 01

  Yeah, it's a huge part of being a doctor is dealing with the psychological aspects of whatever's going on with a patient's body. I mean, in the ER, you deal with psychiatric emergencies kind of left and right more than ever these days. And, you know, that's a huge issue, not to mention sort of drug use, alcohol related stuff, you know, that gets into sort of psychology and the human love of intoxicants and changing the brain's chemistry. And, you know, and habit, of course, we're creatures of habit and that plays in as well. I mean, a big part of, for instance, pediatrics is reassuring parents and kind of convincing them, giving them the confidence that what's going on with their child is not serious, will go away on its own, does not need any particular intervention. And

• 1:12:01Speaker 01

  but adults too, you know, reassurance is a huge part of the game. Yeah, you know, in the ER, you see humanity at its most raw. I feel like you get this tremendous insight into people, how they live, what they worry about, what they think about, how their body works, and also how their mind works that you almost don't see anywhere else. It's a really interesting place to work. And also, the way our society is shaped, the ER is where people go for almost everything. When they're suicidal, they come to the ER. When they're too high on drugs to walk, they come to the ER. You know, children who have been abused, sexually abused, physically abused, come to the ER for us to investigate. It's sort of like the all purpose waste bin for the dregs of society, what people do to themselves

• 1:12:45Speaker 01

  and what they do to other people. You know, you mentioned you're interested in the darkness of humanity. It made me think of the ER where you really see what human life is like in the ER.

• 1:12:56Lex Fridman?

  Okay, you've, you tweet about, you write about, you think about the emergency room, ER. That's really fascinating. Just the little window you give to that world is fascinating. What lessons about humanity do you draw from this place where you're so near to death? There's so much chaos. There's so much variety of what's wrong, so little information. Or the urgent nature of the information inflows such that you can't really reason sort of thoroughly and deeply and collect all the data, all those kinds of things. You have to act fast and then everybody's freaking out.

• 1:13:40Lex Fridman?

  Can you just speak to the human condition? That you get a glimpse at through the ER experience?

• 1:13:49Speaker 01

  Yeah, I think you do see all those things. I think on one end of the spectrum, it is this very unique place where you get all these unique insights. On the other end, it can become a ho-hum workplace, just like any other, which is sort of surprising. As I mentioned before, humans seem to be able to get used to almost anything. And doctors can get ho-hum used to, oh, dying of a heart attack. Oh, actively in labor and the baby's half out. Oh, you know, just ho-hum. I know what to do, going about my job and go home and have dinner with my family and not think too much about it. That's amazing. I do, I do try to maintain, you know, both my fascination, you know, as I think writers in general tend to think more about what they see, write more about what they see,

• 1:14:32Speaker 01

  maybe draw connections with what they see to other things. So I do think that writer's perspective does help me kind of maintain my fascination and my kind of more of an insightful perspective than just a ho-hum water cooler conversation. But you do see a lot, you know. In a way, medical problems are sort of the great equalizer, right? Class, race, culture, background, you know, the failings of the human body, the way it fails and what we can do to help in those situations is almost universal. I always liked this quote from, you know, Chekhov was a doctor and a writer and he saw, treated a lot of. Of peasants, very low class, and also treated a lot of aristocrats.

• 1:15:15Speaker 01

  And he, he wrote that they all have the same ugly bodies, basically, which I think is really right on. And, you know, it's sort of, you can see people underneath a superficial layer of clothing, maybe it's the most expensive clothing bought from the fanciest places, but underneath their bodies still failing in the same way. And they still have the same anxieties, the same worry about mortality, the same concerns about why their poop turned green today. All these things that they bring to the table. So in a way, it is this great equalizer where, where people are kind of all the same in some ways.

• 1:15:48Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, I feel like people sometimes, class, money, fame, power, makes you for a time forget that you're just a meat vehicle. And, and just as good and just as bad as the other meat vehicles all around you. In that sense, there's this question sometimes raised, are some people better than others? And I usually answer no to that question because of that. Yeah, some people might be better at math, some people might be better at music. But at the end, we're just meatbags.

• 1:16:27Lex Fridman?

  Beautiful as we are, there's a poem that just, a small tangent I want to take. I just saw it, "Just Acting",

• 1:16:39Lex Fridman?

  that you have written. I have to, would you classify it as a poem?

• 1:16:44Speaker 01

  Yeah.

• 1:16:45Lex Fridman?

  At first, if I may read it, "At first, you enter the clinic, shoulders weighed down by white coat pockets, bookstuffed, timid. You act out a role. Your white coat, a costume. Your questions, a script. Your demeanor, a rehearsed act. No one is going to buy this. But then, as you play the role again and again, repeating the lines and the motions, the script slowly dissolves and the interaction becomes thoughtless. And the rehearsed act slowly fades into a profession. You suddenly find yourself unable to tell if you're still acting or if you're doing it for real. And now, you're a doctor.

• 1:17:28Lex Fridman?

  Jonathan Reisman, M.D., Harvard, Massachusetts General Hospital Medicine and Pediatrics Department." Beautiful. So that is...

• 1:17:37Lex Fridman?

  What it is to be a doctor, you're just acting. Fake it till you make it.

• 1:17:40Speaker 01

  Exactly, fake it till you make it. And I think, I imagine every medical student has this feeling when they first go into a room. Like I talked about asking this nice old lady about the color of her poop for the first time. And you're just like, what am I doing here? Like, does she believe I'm a doctor? You know, this just feels absurd. But then it's, again, ho hum becomes normal.

• 1:18:03Lex Fridman?

  Now, there's not a sperm chapter in your book. This, you mentioned offline that this is the second and the third book that you're working on all about sperm. No, I'm just kidding. But, or maybe I'm not. Humor tends to make way for reality.

• 1:18:23Lex Fridman?

  So the tweet was that a human, an average human male produces 500 billion sperm, I believe, which is about four to five times more than the number of people who have ever lived. And each of those sperm is genetically unique. So you can think of them, you can kind of imagine the possible humans they could have created. And they're all different. They have similarities, of course, but they have peculiarities that make them different. And you can think of all the different trajectories, all the Einsteins, the Feynmans, the Hitlers, and all the people who have died, who would have died during childbirth, who would have died early in their years, given the different diseases. It's fascinating to think about an average human.

• 1:19:09Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, we're all winners of a very competitive race. So the people who make it were winners. Hashtag winning. Is there something that you find fascinating, interesting, beautiful, ugly, surprising about sperm?

• 1:19:33Speaker 01

  I think sperm is, um, yes, it is a very interesting bodily fluid. Maybe I'll write about it in a second or third book, we'll see. But, uh, you know, I guess sperm is interesting because it's kind of the only projectile bodily fluid, um, from the body. Um, you know, vomit can be projectile. Usually that's a diseased state. That's not the expected kind of normal, healthy state. Oh, sneezing, would you classify that or no? True, I guess that it's, yeah, there's some particles in the air. I guess it's not a fluid. I mean, not a liquid. Um, but true. I mean, cough, in addition to sneeze, right? Sneeze is how our nose gets rid of something that shouldn't be there. Cough is how our lungs get rid of something that shouldn't be there. Vomiting is sometimes how our stomachs get rid of something that shouldn't be there.

• 1:20:17Speaker 01

  All projectiles, sometimes in their own way. Sperm is sort of interesting. It's created with the food for its journey. Sperm mostly feed off of fructose, a kind of sugar. Um, you know, for the few days that they live inside the female genital tract. But it's sort of, I like comparing our genitals to the genitals of the plant world, which is flowers. And in the same way that, uh, you know, a touch me not, uh, for instance, the kind of flower where when you brush up against it, it sort of launches seeds into the distance to try to, um, survive in a way, kind of the sperm is doing something similar, launched into the female genital tract and then all, all trying to find this, uh, competing against each other to find this egg. It's really amazing. And when you learn about it from the biological perspective, the most amazing thing is how

• 1:21:01Speaker 01

  many things can go wrong. Um, you know, just in the sperm not surviving long enough for it, making it to the egg and then some genetic, um, abnormality causing a miscarriage. It's sort of astounding that it works as often as it does. And I think the lesson there is just that people have a lot of sex. And so statistics just favor it's going to work out a good number of times.

• 1:21:23Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, and there might be intelligence in the design of just the sheer number of sperm. Maybe that's yet another way to inject variety into the system.

• 1:21:33Speaker 01

  And redundancy, I guess, you know, we have two kidneys, we have two hands. If we lose one, we can still go on. We have, you know, however, however, many millions of sperm get sort of launched in every ejaculation is, you know, if a bunch fail or don't make it inside.

• 1:21:48Lex Fridman?

  There's papers on this, by the way, that I read for some reason, not read, but skimmed for some reason, which is talking about which sperm usually wins, like, what are the characteristics of sperms that are winning? And it's not the fastest. So apparently there's some kind of slaughter that happens early on. People will correct me, but it's not the fastest. It's, there is an aspect of it's the luckiest. It really is like the body tries to make it a random selection. It tries to make it fair in making it as random as possible. Interesting, and also interesting that they're fueled by fructose. I didn't really think about that. So they're a, they're a carb loaded athlete.

• 1:22:31Speaker 01

  Right, with food for the journey.

• 1:22:33Lex Fridman?

  Food for the journey, because I'm somebody that actually does a lot of running on, I guess you would call me a fat adapted athlete. So I do sort of meat heavy diet. And so you could do a lot of endurance kind of stuff when you don't eat any carbs, any glucose, any of that kind of stuff. And you're very low. It's interesting to think that sperm are like, nope, they're total bros. Let's go to the gym, sprint, performance, short term performance is everything. All right, well, that sperm returning to the liver, the place that deals with all our poor decisions. No.

• 1:23:16Speaker 01

  Many of them.

• 1:23:16Lex Fridman?

  Many of our poor decisions. Is there? You said that the liver does quite a few things. What do you is fascinating, beautiful about the liver?

• 1:23:27Speaker 01

  I'd say its primary function seems to be as the sort of gatekeeper for what we eat and absorb. You know, the entire gastrointestinal tract from the esophagus to the rectum. The blood flows from it, not back to the heart, but to the liver where it's first examined. Kind of things are evaluated, packaged, you know, processed, detoxified perhaps. And it's kind of this great overseer of what we digest and absorb. And so it kind of keeps, keeps track of what's coming in, you know, the outside world that comes in and become, will become part of us.

• 1:24:06Speaker 01

  You know, why that's why partly the liver suffers sometimes the injury from certain, certain toxins like alcohol. But beyond that, the liver is also the place, as I said, it metabolizes things too. So metabolizes alcohol and why it can be injured by alcohol and metabolizes drugs like Tylenol, which is why Tylenol is a, can be very toxic to the liver when taken as an overdose. So the liver, you know, even beyond that, the liver produces a lot of different, you know, things that float in the bloodstream. It packages cholesterol and fats and sends them to where they're needed. It deals with protein in the blood. It deals with clotting factors in the blood, helping the blood clot.

• 1:24:48Speaker 01

  You know, processes things like Billy Rubin and other things that really, as I mentioned, is like 15 organs wrapped into one. Maybe that's why it's sort of the biggest internal organ. Skin's bigger, but it's not an internal organ.

• 1:25:00Lex Fridman?

  Right. The biggest organ in the human body is the skin.

• 1:25:04Speaker 01

  Right. But the liver is the biggest internal organ and it really is a powerhouse and, and does a lot, which is why when people suffer from liver failure, kind of everything goes wrong in a way.

• 1:25:15Lex Fridman?

  And in terms of replacing organs, what what are organs that are easily replaceable, which are not, like on the list of things that are hard to replace and not, where would you put it number one? Where would you put it like at the bottom?

• 1:25:31Speaker 01

  Well, I'd say the kidneys are, you know, nothing's easy, but kidneys are easiest in a way. Partly, I mean, maybe a big factor there is that other people have two of them and can give one to you. So you don't have to wait for people to die, which is the case with hearts and livers. Sometimes you can take a part of a liver from someone who's alive. And the liver does have this kind of mythological ability to regenerate itself. In the myth of Prometheus, Prometheus, he's, you know, chained to a rock and the bird eats his liver every day and it grows back every day. And that's actually biologically accurate. It does not that he can completely get rid of it and it'll appear again. But when pieces of it are removed or injured, it does regenerate itself pretty amazingly. So I'd say the kidneys,

• 1:26:14Speaker 01

  the fact that there are more around. Also, it's, you know, the kidney is a smaller organ. It's often just, you don't have to put a transplanted kidney where the kidney should be in the back of the abdomen. You can just kind of stuff it into the pelvis there because it's a smaller organ. The liver would be hard because it's huge. And I guess we just have the most experience with kidney transplants because they are the most common.

• 1:26:36Lex Fridman?

  And the heart and the brain are probably quite difficult.

• 1:26:40Speaker 01

  Brain, as far as I know, hasn't been successfully done. The heart is is done. And definitely, I've evaluated a lot of patients with a heart transplant. It does work pretty well. The mechanical heart substitutes are also advancing quite rapidly these days. For a failing heart, there's certain kinds of devices they can surgically implant, like when a failing heart isn't able to push hard enough, you know, that's the heart's job is pushing blood with sufficient pressure to create blood pressure. When it fails, there are actually these devices you can strap on to the heart to help it pump harder. Those are rapidly advancing. Many of those were not available even 10 years ago when I was a got out of med school and now they're commonly used. So maybe heart transplant won't be as

• 1:27:25Speaker 01

  necessary in the future if those mechanical things do advance. And as I said, the heart is basically a mechanical pump. So perhaps it would be the easiest organ to replace with some mechanical device.

• 1:27:36Lex Fridman?

  Now for something completely different, returning to testicles for a time. You posted Instagram posts of testicles as food.

• 1:27:45Lex Fridman?

  Perhaps eating them doesn't help libido because ingested testosterone is totally metabolized in the liver, returning to our liver, leaving none to reach the bloodstream. That is why testosterone only comes as injection or topical foam, not as pills. On the other hand, estrogen and progesterone can be absorbed orally, hence the pill. But testosterone is mostly responsible for libido in women, too. I was not expecting for this biology lesson when I was looking at an Instagram picture of, are we looking at testicles?

• 1:28:24Speaker 01

  Yeah.

• 1:28:25Lex Fridman?

  Are these like, which species?

• 1:28:28Speaker 01

  I believe all those are from cows.

• 1:28:30Lex Fridman?

  From cows.

• 1:28:31Speaker 01

  Cows technically, females, so bulls.

• 1:28:34Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, well, speaking of which, just we'll jump around a bit, but you've also traveled the world quite a bit. What have you, what is the craziest food you've eaten across the world? What have you learned about the extremes of the culinary arts by traveling the world?

• 1:28:58Speaker 01

  I would say, I guess I've always been extra fascinated with the diets of natives of the far north. I spent some time there in Russia and in Alaska and always loved their diet. So when I worked in Alaska in emergency room and did some other travels in Arctic Alaska. And, you know, they eat a lot of fat traditionally before contact, you know, more than half of all calories in the Inupiat Eskimo diet came from blubber, marine mammal fat, or, you know, also fat from fish, fat from ducks and other, other birds that go up there to mate in the summer. So things like raw whale blubber was especially interesting for me and very exciting.

• 1:29:42Speaker 01

  You know, I had some beluga whale chowder, things like that. There's just all these very unusual dishes. You know, they, there's a dish called mikyuk, which is whale meat fermented in whale blood.

• 1:29:57Speaker 01

  Which is quite delicious, actually.

• 1:29:59Lex Fridman?

  So is it cooked? Is it eaten raw? Is it what? How do they like their fat like in, in, uh, and, and same up north in Russia, as you mentioned?

• 1:30:09Speaker 01

  So they often eat it raw. So the raw whale blubber is called mukhtuk. And it's often just sliced thin and it's like, it's sort of cold, but not frozen when often when they eat it and they slice it thin. And a lot of people assume it would be very chewy, but it's not that chewy. It's quite pleasant, actually, and has this kind of sea smell to it as you're eating it. I quite like it.

• 1:30:32Lex Fridman?

  And what's the culinary culture like? Meaning, is it just source of energy or is it art?

• 1:30:40Speaker 01

  Well, there's, you know, traditionally, there's not a lot of cooking in, you know, in the, in the Arctic. A lot of things are eaten raw, partly because there's not a lot of fuel for making fires. So they will, you know, some, in some of the big rivers in Russia, for instance, that flow north, they will bring trees, you know, dead trees and logs up to the north and they can get some wood that way. And same thing in some of the rivers kind of flowing northward from the Brooks Range of Alaska. You do get some trees, but just not enough to really produce a culinary art that requires cooking with heat. You know, they do have traditionally blubber lamps where the blubbers of seals and whales are used to create a little flame.

• 1:31:22Speaker 01

  Often that's for light and for a little bit of heat and, and less for cooking. But eating things raw is definitely a huge part of the culture there. And while I was, I, I went on a whale hunting trip out on the spring ice in the Arctic Ocean by Barrow, Alaska. And two of the guys, the Inupiat guys who had invited me were kind of talking about how eating things raw is sort of the most essential characteristic of Inupiat culture. And the one guy who's half white, half Inupiat said, people often doubt his ethnicity because he looks like a white guy. So he'll, you know, bite the head off of a, a raw bird to show them that he is truly an Inupiat, is what he said.

• 1:32:01Lex Fridman?

  That's how you prove you're legit. We're looking at Instagram pic. As a doctor, I was used to knowing fat as the most maligned of all body parts and the culprit in an obesity epidemic. But in Arctic Alaska, fat has always meant health and survival. In fact, the entire story of life in the Arctic, especially human life, is basically a tale of fat. And in Barrow, what's AK?

• 1:32:28Speaker 01

  Alaska.

• 1:32:28Lex Fridman?

  Alaska, okay. A lawn covered with whale blubber is still equivalent of a plush green lawn in temperature suburbia swelling in its owner with pride. And that's what we're looking at is a lawn full of whale blubber.

• 1:32:48Lex Fridman?

  Beautiful. So this is, I mean, there's a lot of calories there.

• 1:32:51Speaker 01

  Oh, yeah.

• 1:32:51Lex Fridman?

  And this can feed a lot of people, a lot of energy, a lot of warmth.

• 1:32:55Speaker 01

  Absolutely. And it's delicious. This was like, I was a kid in a candy store, basically. I rounded a corner in Barrow. So when people do get a whale during the spring whaling season, they raise a flag or the whaling captain raises a flag over his house and everyone in town is welcome to come try some. And so before I went inside to try some, I was kind of playing around with blubber. And I saw the, this is a bowhead whale. I saw its heart, which was huge, like the size of a yoga ball. And that was for me just like amazing. I spent probably the next 45 minutes just looking at all aspects of it. The stump of aorta that was attached to it was the size of my thigh. That was really fascinating.

• 1:33:38Lex Fridman?

  It's similar, Alaska and northern Russia, like Siberian out there. So where were you?

• 1:33:45Lex Fridman?

  I think you have some pics from that time. Where were you in Russia?

• 1:33:50Speaker 01

  So I spent a lot of time in kind of western Russia as well, but I did take two trips to Kamchatka, including northern Kamchatka. I didn't go far enough nor, I didn't go to Chikotka, for instance, until more recently, when I was a ship doctor on a wildlife cruise that sailed from Anadier, Russia up to, through the Bering Strait. Straight into Rangel Island. And we stopped in some villages in Chukotka and I got a chance to to try some some whale and stuff like that. Northern Kamchatka, where it's more the Korjak or the indigenous people. They do a lot of seal hunting, so I had a lot of seal blubber, but they I don't believe they do any whale hunting quite there.

• 1:34:30Speaker 01

  But the Chukchi in a way are sort of, you know, similar to the Nupiat in their diet and their life ways. Of course, everyone's diet, all these people's diet has changed dramatically in the last hundred years. As it has for actually everyone living in kind of modern societies. But for them, perhaps more than anyone else, since their diet was the most extreme, I think, of any human culture on earth.

• 1:34:52Lex Fridman?

  Just to stay on the wild travel you did, and I should say I'm using the word travel, but it really. You were a doctor there.

• 1:35:05Lex Fridman?

  Well, first of all, can you just comment on the decision to go to such places? And to help people to be a doctor there. What was the motivation? What was the thinking behind it?

• 1:35:15Speaker 01

  Well, I think I got the travel bug before I ever went to medical school and even wanted to be a doctor. So right after college, I kind of wasn't very into college, didn't enjoy things, kind of wanted to get out there and see the world. Get out of New York City where I was a student at at NYU. The first thing I did after finishing college was I was invited to be an intern at a research center in St. Petersburg, Russia. I spent six months there my first trip and went back four more times to Russia, traveled all over, including to Kamchatka twice. And other parts of the country I had never heard of cities like Petrozavodsk and Siktivkar and Skov.

• 1:35:57Speaker 01

  I didn't even know a word could start with P S K, like the city of Skov, but it can. And I was sort of fascinated. I was actually studying. The international environmental movement and how it came to Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union. And how organizations like Greenpeace and World Wildlife Fund. And the World Bank are trying to kind of push the timber industry, which is huge in Russia, toward a more sustainable path. And so I was sort of evaluating how is it working? If not, why not? And that seems like such a little niche, such a small detail about Russian society. But in a way, researching that in depth was almost this window into the entire country and the history in a place I knew nothing about. And I learned

• 1:36:41Speaker 01

  the language, traveled all over the country, you know, got to know the food, the history, the literature. It's just an immersive and amazing and life-changing experience that made me want to see every, every spot on the globe, basically, and learn about every culture. So I took that desire with me to medical school. I decided I would, I would go to medical school. And from the very beginning, I was intent on traveling around the world. So a lot of my career has been fashioned so that I'm practicing medicine in a place with an interesting geographic context, an interesting place with an interesting cultural context. And that just makes it more interesting, I find. Not only are medical

• 1:37:22Speaker 01

  services often more needed in these remote and rural parts of the country and world. So I feel like I'm, you know, taking my knowledge and education experience to places where it's needed. But also, for me, it's just such an enlightening experience, the way culture, history, geography, climate affects medical disease, but just getting to know the people, getting to know their culture, being a very useful traveler by, you know, providing medical services in that place. And that's taken me to Arctic Alaska, to Pine Ridge Reservation, South Dakota. I currently work in a few different parts of Pennsylvania, Appalachia, which, you know, for me is a unique geography and culture that I didn't grow up with, wasn't familiar with. So in some ways, it's, it's exotic for me as well.

• 1:38:06Speaker 01

  And I worked in other places too, like Calcutta, India, Nepal. Just, I think my love of travel has shaped my medical career. And, and being a doctor does give you these opportunities to go to places and travel in a unique way, you know, through the medical profession.

• 1:38:24Lex Fridman?

  You know, there's a documentary Happy People, you're in the Taiga or something like that. I think Warner Herzog voices it. It tells a story of a simple life of survival in the Taiga. And I think they're trapping for food. And there's a lot, there's an alcoholism problem too as well. There's like a very basic life of survival, of loneliness, of desperation. But also, there's a, I think the underlying claim of the documentary is that that simple

• 1:39:05Lex Fridman?

  life actually has a kind of simple happiness to it. Hence the name Happy People. Is there, can you speak to the life that people live in, in those places when it may be simpler than you would in sort of big city life?

• 1:39:26Speaker 01

  It's definitely very different, for sure. You know, I guess I found like in some of the remote villages of Kamchatka, I was actually surprised how similar they were in that, you know, there was, I saw the same family strife, the same fights, the same, you know, kind of pairing of relationships and bickering and politics. And, you know, in a way, I'm from the New Jersey suburbs and yet being, being in this remote, you know, village of northern Kamchatka, I remember writing an email to my friend about how it just, it seemed so similar, even though on the surface, it was this exotic other world.

• 1:40:07Speaker 01

  The incredible material know-how they must have to get their food from the land, you know, that, the number of animal species, plant species, the behaviors of the animals, seasons, how to live that way. In a way, it's more complicated in a way that I find fascinating, how people live on the land and the knowledge and experience it takes to do it well and survive. You know, obviously, other aspects of modern life in a city are, are much more complicated than they would be there. But I guess it's, that was something that struck me too, that it's simpler in some ways, but more complicated in other ways.

• 1:40:40Lex Fridman?

  So some of the complexity that happens in life is from, originated from humans, not from the technology or the, all that kind of stuff around us.

• 1:40:50Speaker 01

  You can take the human out of modernity, but they're still human.

• 1:40:52Lex Fridman?

  They're still human, and they fill the empty space with their own human complexities. Are there people that just stand out, memorable people, memorable experiences from those places?

• 1:41:08Lex Fridman?

  Some people that maybe made you smile, made you cry, changed who you are as a man, changed who you are as a doctor? Anything jumps to mind?

• 1:41:18Speaker 01

  I think, you know, when I was, it's interesting, when I was in Russia, I found that most of the people I hung out with were old women. I'm not sure why. I mean, there, actually, I didn't meet a lot of old men in Russia, which might speak to kind of life expectancy there for men in particular. But I found women, older Russian women, including, you know, Russian from St. Petersburg, or some of the elderly women in Kamchatka, who were, you know, some were Koryaks, some were half Koryak, half Russian, some were Chukchi. I just found them to have, to be so enlightening, the way they talked about history, about people, so insightful about humanity, you know, all they've lived through in the last 50 years in some of these parts of Russia.

• 1:42:02Speaker 01

  Like the upheaval, societal upheaval, the destruction, the building up. It's just something I could not even imagine. And I think their insights were just very, I'm not thinking of anything in particular, but I just remember I could listen to some of these elderly women talk about their lives for hours and hours. I remember there was this older, elderly, blind, Koryak woman, who you would have thought was the, you know, most country bumpkin of country bumpkin, and yet she couldn't stop talking about how much she loved reading Dostoevsky and Tolstoy, and which might also speak to the Soviet education system. And it's just sort of surprising and fascinating, and just those stories and perspectives on life really stayed with me.

• 1:42:43Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, with Babushki,

• 1:42:48Lex Fridman?

  there's a, there's a wisdom, there's a kindness.

• 1:42:53Lex Fridman?

  I mean, I suppose that's true for older people in general. But there's something about, it's not just Russia, it's Eastern Europe. It's like this kind of look of wisdom and not just like sort of middle class wisdom or something like that. It's like, I have seen some shit wisdom. I've seen it all. And on the other side, I'm left here with a pragmatism and a compassion and also an ability to cook really well.

• 1:43:34Speaker 01

  That's for sure. Absolutely.

• 1:43:36Lex Fridman?

  There's, there's just this balance of just deep intelligence and deep kindness. And yeah, I mean, I part, much of who I am is because of the relationship I had with my grandmother, who was a Russian Ukrainian born Russian grandmother. Did you learn the Russian language?

• 1:43:58Speaker 01

  I did. It's quite rusty at this point, but I did, one of the, one of these wonderful elderly Russians in, in St. Petersburg sort of adopted me. I think that was another thing that a lot of these elderly women on every side of the country kind of adopted me or saw me as this real curiosity, you know, sort of just not, I mean, this was around 2002, 2003. It just wasn't common for this sort of strange American to suddenly show up in the middle of Kamchatka or even St. Petersburg and just care, absolutely ravenously curious about everything they had to say. So I often got adopted and one of them taught me Russian and how to ride a horse. So same, same babushka taught me both of those things.

• 1:44:41Lex Fridman?

  And like you said, also, I should mention that there's something about the Soviet education system where, yeah, everybody reads Tolstoy, Dostoevsky.

• 1:44:49Lex Fridman?

  It's exceptionally well read, no matter where life has taken you, no matter where you come from, the literature, the mathematics, the sciences, they're all like extremely well educated and that creates a fascinating populace. Like then you take that education, that excellent early education, and you throw a bunch of hardship at those people. And then they kind of cook in that hardship and come out really fascinating people on the other end.

• 1:45:23Speaker 01

  It makes me surprised sort of that, for instance, like Russian medical science is not, doesn't, you don't see a lot of sort of studies, medical studies, advancing of medical science come out of Russia. It's just sort of, I'm surprised, sort of, I wish that it would. You know, I visited Akademy Gorodok outside Novosibirsk, which is an entire city the Soviets created just for the study of science. And it's like, there's the geology building, and there's the biology building, and there's the chemistry building. And I just feel like Russia has this potential to be a science powerhouse, or even in the medical sciences. But I guess you just, I don't see it. I'm not sure why.

• 1:46:01Lex Fridman?

  I mean, you can certainly guess as to why. And I, I see the same thing in the other, in the sciences, I hold the dearest, or in computer science, in engineering fields. I kind of long held this desire, by long, I mean, last couple of years, because a bunch of people reached out to me from Yandex and Moscow State to give lectures there, to sort of connect, you know, why, why so little science is coming out of there? Why so little that we hear about? And it feels like we should be able to bridge the scientific community.

• 1:46:39Lex Fridman?

  Like, science, let's even say, even in turmoil of geopolitics, even in global conflict, I feel like science should be bigger than that. But why do we not hear from the scientists? Is because of the limitations on human freedoms, on scientific freedoms. I feel like in China, in Russia, in any regime of its sort.

• 1:47:07Lex Fridman?

  You should give freedom to scientists to flourish and to interact with others. And you can only grow from that and you shouldn't suppress that. The sort of Cold War ideas, we should put those aside. As somebody who spent time in Russia, as somebody who learned Russian,

• 1:47:30Lex Fridman?

  do you have some thoughts that you want to say about the war in Ukraine currently?

• 1:47:36Speaker 01

  It's tragic, of course.

• 1:47:39Speaker 01

  Seemingly pointless to watch the destruction of a country in real time.

• 1:47:46Speaker 01

  I guess it's, you know, when you read Russian history and Ukrainian history, I guess it just, it's sort of, you know, destruction is a big part of it. The populace being beaten down is a big part of it, you know, from the Mongolian hordes through the Tsar and the Soviets and Putin, I guess. You know, it's just in science, in particular, medical science, it feels like this sort of unrealized potential. You know, the, the culture is so beautiful, the people are so smart and well educated.

• 1:48:15Lex Fridman?

  I think the word unrealized potential is kind of how I feel. That's why I wanted to celebrate that part of the world is there's so many beautiful people, so many brilliant people. And I just happen to know the language, so I'm able to appreciate the beauty of those people. I'm sure the same is true in China. I'm sure that that's one of the things that makes me sad is there's all these cultures that I don't know about, I can't fully appreciate their brilliance. Even Japan and places like that, that are sort of, there's channels of communication wide open and there's a lot of interaction is still not knowing the language. I feel like I miss some of the culture or Portuguese and, you know, looking at South America and all that kind of stuff.

• 1:48:59Lex Fridman?

  But anyway, in Russia, there's, there certainly is that unrealized potential. In Ukraine, so many brilliant scientists, engineers came from Ukraine, from Russia. And I hope, I hope they get to flourish soon. And I hope we put this.

• 1:49:17Lex Fridman?

  I hope we stop this war because all war is hell.

• 1:49:23Lex Fridman?

  Is there something to comment about the biology of war? Is there echoes of the emergency room experience? Do you have you have you dealt with with patients that have been touched by wartime?

• 1:49:44Speaker 01

  Definitely war and medicine has a very intricate and complex relationship. I don't know if it was Walt Whitman who said it, though he was a nurse during the Civil War, that war is the best medical school, but some people have said that. And, you know, even advancements in medicine are come from war. You know, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have, in some ways, really revolutionized certain aspects of the way we treat trauma patients in the civilian world as well. The importance of tourniquets, the importance of transfusing whole blood instead of, you know, red blood cells isolated from serum and platelets, et cetera. The importance of pain control in the battlefield, that's changed dramatically.

• 1:50:25Speaker 01

  Everything from ketamine injections to fentanyl lollipops in the battlefield. So war has really improved medicine in many ways. In another way, you know, the Department of Defense spends a lot of money on medical research and kind of really pushes the envelope. You know, DARPA is a one aspect of the military budget that really funds these moonshot experiments that are really fascinating and to really push the frontiers more than seemingly most, you know, kind of universities doing it, doctors and researchers doing their research. So in a way, you know, the space program, which sort of was military initially, then became civilian under NASA, also has led to a lot of advances and understandings of

• 1:51:08Speaker 01

  of health, you know, on earth and in space. So the military is, or war in general, is a huge way that. That medicine advances, not to mention the epidemics that come. You know, my grandmother was from what's today Moldova, what was then Romania. She got typhus during the, during World War II. So there's typhus outbreaks, there's cholera outbreaks, you know, all these, even infectious disease things can advance in war, which you wouldn't expect. You expect sort of trauma to be the sort of main problem, but actually infection is a huge problem throughout history and war. So we can learn a lot. It's this kind of horrific natural experiment in, in medical care.

• 1:51:48Lex Fridman?

  Yeah. And I've recently been reading about some of the horrific medical experiments performed by Nazi scientists, Nazi Germany. It's, I'll talk about it another time perhaps, but nothing reveals the honesty of human biology like war. Just to stay on your wild journeys for a little bit longer, you have a tweet about Shackleton saying, here's a photo of Shackleton's medical kit from his storied expedition to Antarctica in the 1910s. Some paragoric for pain, some laxative. Only the essentials. Would you put laxative under the essentials?

• 1:52:31Lex Fridman?

  Anyway, sorry to interrupt. When I worked as a ship doctor in Antarctica in 2018, I had a huge cabinet full of meds and even EKG machine. So if you can comment sort of on that contrast, first of all, your own journey, how harsh was it? How difficult was it? And given that context, can you think about how hard Shackleton's journey was?

• 1:53:00Speaker 01

  I think the difference is unimaginably stark. One thing I do want to point out is that the use of laxatives early in the 20th century and before that, it was, they were used for a surprising number of ailments where they probably did not help at all. But I think that was a holdover from sort of the old theory of medicine, the humoral theory where you have to balance the fluids in the body. And so causing people to vomit, causing them to have diarrhea or purposely taking blood out of them in bloodletting was a big part. And I think that crazy use of laxatives was maybe a holdover from that time. But that being said, they were probably not eating very high fiber food on that expedition. So perhaps laxatives could have been helpful.

• 1:53:44Speaker 01

  You know, there's a lot of seal, penguin and seal meat being eaten, which is not super high in fiber. So I don't want to discount the importance of laxatives in that setting.

• 1:53:54Lex Fridman?

  But that wouldn't be the essential thing. If you're thinking, if you're thinking of a tiny kit that has only the essentials. I mean, pain, yes, laxatives, I don't know, maybe not.

• 1:54:06Speaker 01

  I think the medical kit possibilities were much narrower back then. You know, this was before antibiotics, before, I think germ theory might have been, you know, it was known, but there wasn't much to do about it. So the availability of medicines, I mean, that's something that exploded over the course of the 20th century. So what I can put in a backpack today filled with modern medications, whether injectable or to be taken orally is, you know, just many orders of magnitude greater than what they had back then. So when I, I mean, when I went, my expedition was nothing like Shackleton's. I was on a huge cruise ship with 160 Japanese passengers who came with their own translators.

• 1:54:48Speaker 01

  And as I said, I had a cabinets, not just one cabinet, many cabinets full of medications, both injectable, some patches, some pills. I was very impressed actually with what was available there. And I didn't have to use a lot of it, thankfully, though I did use some of it for people. But, and I slept and, you know, I had got free room and board on the ship. So every southern summer cruise ships go take people to Antarctica, the southern Atlantic Islands, like the Falklands and other, other parts of the South Pacific. And then in the northern summer, the same kind of cruise ship explosion happens, you know,

• 1:55:28Speaker 01

  going to Greenland and Iceland and Svalbard and Franz Joseph Land and other parts of the North Alaska. So, and every ship needs a doctor. So it's a great opportunity. They want specifically ER doctors, you know, to deal with emergencies. But you're really working in the middle of nowhere and all you have is the medications there on the ship and supplies and your knowledge and experience. And so it's it's a very different experience than working in a high tech, modern hospital with every bit of technology and every subspecialist consultant available. But I sort of like that challenge. I mean, I like going to the ends of the earth. It's beautiful. It's exciting. It's fascinating. Practicing medicine in those settings is extra challenging and

• 1:56:10Speaker 01

  really makes you hone some of your skills, which is part of the reason that I sought sought them out.

• 1:56:16Lex Fridman?

  Do you see echoes of some of that same effort? I've gotten a chance to interact with astronauts and those kinds of folks working on space missions. Do you see some of those same echoes of challenging efforts going out into space and maybe landing on Mars and maybe beginning to build a small colony on Mars?

• 1:56:36Speaker 01

  Yeah, I think the healthcare that is needed will be a big part of that. You know, obviously, we're probably going to send overall quite healthy people. But there's a lot of medical decisions to make about what should be brought, what should be expected. You know, to some extent, a lot I've had a lot of doctors say, oh, my goodness, I can't believe you work in the middle of nowhere. What do you do if someone, you know, gets a brain bleed, like falls, hits their head, needs a neurosurgeon? I mean, the obvious answer is they die. You know, when things, when you're in the middle of Antarctica, things kill you that wouldn't if you're inside a university hospital that's fully equipped to help with every problem that arises. Mars takes that to a crazy extreme, obviously. I know that even going to Antarctica, different countries have had different strategies.

• 1:57:18Speaker 01

  I believe it was Australia used to kind of just in anticipation, remove people's gallbladders just so that it wouldn't get inflamed because that is a very common medical emergency. So they would just remove it beforehand, even though it was not diseased at all, just so that while they're stuck in Antarctica over the winter, for instance, that wouldn't be a problem. You know, there's many other issues that can arise. But so those are some decisions to make. Maybe the people who go into Mars should have their appendix removed, their gallbladder removed. Maybe they should have a cardiac cath to see if they have coronary artery disease, just to know their chances of getting a heart attack there, though it's not always predictive. You know, it's hard to predict who's going to get a heart attack. But maybe with all the data around today, we'll get, you know, better at predicting.

• 1:58:01Speaker 01

  But that will be a huge part. You know, we can't have people, the few people, few pioneers in a Mars colony dying of heart attacks and things like that.

• 1:58:07Lex Fridman?

  Anticipate stuff. Would you go? You've gone to some harsh conditions to be a doctor. Would you go to Mars to be a doctor?

• 1:58:15Speaker 01

  Um, it would definitely be amazing. I think because I have a wife and two small children, probably not in the cards for me at this point, but.

• 1:58:24Lex Fridman?

  You humans with your human attachments.

• 1:58:27Speaker 01

  Sex and death.

• 1:58:30Lex Fridman?

  If you just put more priority on the death than the sex, I think we would be uh better off. No.

• 1:58:38Speaker 01

  I would love to go to Mars. And actually, you know, I practice high altitude medicine in Nepal. Space medicine is sort of an extension of that. You know, the air is just much thinner, like nonexistent. You know, as you go higher in the mountains, the things that happen to human physiology are very bizarre and strange and still not well explained by science. And in space, it's just like a crazy extension of high altitude.

• 1:59:01Lex Fridman?

  If I could just return to the, we didn't really, I think we mentioned a little bit about the food you had. Just if we can high level say, what is the greatest meal you've ever had? So your last meal, let's go. If one more meal, I get to murder you after this. This is your last day. We get to spend it together. Where in the world would you go? What would you eat?

• 1:59:26Speaker 01

  I would say the most delicious thing is bone marrow. And I would love a full meal of bone marrow for my last, last dish. I did on my birthday in 2002, ate a kilogram and a half of crab meat in Kamchatka, and that was also amazingly delicious. The king crab they have there is incredible. But I would go with bone marrow, which is, I think, just one of the most delicious foods. And it's sort of this weird body part. You know, it's basically all your stem cells, not all of them, but the stem cells that produce all your blood cells. So they are spitting out billions of white blood cells, red blood cells and platelets every day. And there's a bunch of fat in there as well. Just one of the places the body stores fat.

• 2:00:08Speaker 01

  And so you basically add heat and that's all you need. It's like the perfect food. You add heat, the fat for frying the stem cells is already there. There's a naturally a bone vessel to contain it all. Probably add some flavor to. It's like the perfect food.

• 2:00:23Lex Fridman?

  What, does it matter which, which, uh, which animal?

• 2:00:27Speaker 01

  I prefer a larger animal, just so there's more of it.

• 2:00:30Lex Fridman?

  I actually like, well, that's true. I actually really like sort of bone marrow from like chicken bones.

• 2:00:35Speaker 01

  Right, just sucking it out of the bone. Yes, I'm I'm known for leaving absolutely nothing edible on the plate, except bone itself.

• 2:00:43Lex Fridman?

  There's one other human I know that loves bone marrow as much as you do, and that's Joe Rogan. So go, it's unnatural how much that man loves bone marrow.

• 2:00:56Speaker 01

  I understand why.

• 2:00:56Lex Fridman?

  I love the steak part. The bone marrow, like, you know what, let me, um, let me argue with you because, I don't know.

• 2:01:05Lex Fridman?

  It could be an acquired taste, but there's just too much, it's like too much with too little work for it. Like, it's as if you gave me lobster meat without the lobster, having to clean the lobster. And I just feel like I'm spoiling myself. So it's very fatty. It's, I don't know, maybe I want to work for something that tastes like that.

• 2:01:30Speaker 01

  Well, if you start from the whole animal, you do have to work to get at it, right? A lot of animals have the teeth and the jaw muscles to chomp through bone. We do not. So, um, you know, when you buy it from the store, it's already sawed up. But I've definitely gotten marrow out of deer bones, you know, with a hatchet. Just chop off, chop off the fat end and start spooning it out.

• 2:01:51Lex Fridman?

  Or maybe I'll revisit it. That's fascinating. And where, where would you eat it? Where, in which place of the world? Is there something about who cooks it, who you eat it with?

• 2:02:05Lex Fridman?

  You're not allowed to pick your family.

• 2:02:06Speaker 01

  Right.

• 2:02:11Lex Fridman?

  So like, which place in the world, rural or in the city, those kinds of things? You've been to so many fascinating places.

• 2:02:20Speaker 01

  I would say Antarctica, I would say, is one of the most picturesque places I've ever been. I really did not, I didn't know how mountainous it was. And I guess I knew there'd be the ice, but just, I didn't know how much ice it was. You know, it's ice and mountains, just overwhelming. I just, you know, as, as kind of overwhelming bone marrow might seem to you, sort of that feast for your eyes.

• 2:02:44Speaker 01

  And just ice in general is amazing, like the icebergs floating around Antarctica is just astounding. Like, the different shapes, the sizes are incredible. There's actually, I believe it's US Navy website that tracks the largest icebergs. And you can read about each of them and how big they are and just the formations you see similar up near Greenland, though I have not been to Greenland. Just ice in general is just amazing. So I could just look at its different forms while eating bone marrow forever, until you kill me, that is.

• 2:03:13Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, and afterwards we go, it's back to the death, the death and sex. I, what is it about the ice? Is it sort of the enormity of nature? It just reminds you that it's going to be there before you and after? And then you get to partake in the eating of the, the thing you need for maintaining of your biological, temporary biological organism?

• 2:03:39Speaker 01

  Yeah, I think it's a few things. One is just the shapes that you see, you know, the wave action, just eating away at these pieces of ice. You get these arches and just these shapes. I mean, it's just like

• 2:03:51Lex Fridman?

  Geometry.

• 2:03:51Speaker 01

  The geometry alone is amazing. I studied math as an undergrad and I've always appreciated geometry. And just the shapes alone are just, look like brilliant works of modernist art. And just, obviously, no two are ever the same. Not to mention, a lot of them are this unearthly blue color that is just really startling and fascinating. The same color of glaciers, you know, in various parts of the world. That blue color is just really amazing. And I also just love how it's sort of this constant shedding from our Antarctic continent, from Greenland, you know, it's this constant process of snow falling inland and pushing the glaciers further out to sea and then breaking loose. I mean, obviously, it seems

• 2:04:33Speaker 01

  to be happening faster these days, but it's sort of this constant shedding and sort of, I always like thinking about how the body has something similar, you know, we're constantly shedding and renewing and rebuilding everything. And so ice is sort of this constant similar process.

• 2:04:51Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, I did not know you were a math undergrad. So that, I mean, you're just keep getting more fascinating. Can you maybe take a small step into that direction? What do you find beautiful about mathematics? Why did you journey into that part of the world for a time?

• 2:05:10Speaker 01

  I liked math. I especially liked, so college math, I did some calculus in high school. When I got to college math, I was amazed that there were no more numbers, you know, the digits disappeared. It was just variables, concepts, you know, there was almost no more numbers at all. It was like this totally abstract, you know, kind of way of thinking, but that sort of reflects the natural world and teaches you about the natural world, though it's sort of this perfect, you know, platonic ideal, perhaps, of the natural world that can still sort of help explain what happens in the natural world. But just these concepts are so abstract from like life and from, you know, the natural world. And I was actually getting interested in the natural world at the same time when

• 2:05:55Speaker 01

  I was in, at NYU studying math, you know, I took a tour of Central Park that was pointing, the guy, Steve Brill, was pointing out these wild edible plants. And I was learning to identify the first plants and knowing what's edible, what's not. That was totally fascinating and sort of this kind of thing that I felt like was connecting me to nature. And it was balanced with this utterly abstract science, you know, or utterly abstract lessons I was getting in math class, where I was thinking through series, you know, as we approach infinity, what happens to these equations and concepts of like rings and abstract algebra? I don't know. It was just this dichotomy that I enjoyed both aspects of.

• 2:06:34Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, the concepts, but so, so different, this kind of logical.

• 2:06:43Lex Fridman?

  Rigorous view of the world and the world of biology. Why the big? How did that feel to take the leap into the biological, the mushy mess of the human body from the mathematical, which is all very clean?

• 2:06:59Speaker 01

  Right, it does. It does feel like a big step. I think there's more connection than you think. You know, we talked about symmetry of the body earlier. That is a real thing. You know, fluid dynamics of how our various bodily fluids flow and what makes them not flow as well and what makes them flow better. And, you know, all these different aspects of science go into the body. You know, everything from hard bone to softer kind of flesh to liquids of various consistencies. You know, a lot of science and math does teach you about kind of how the body works, how it can work better, what happens in sort of disease states.

• 2:07:40Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, I suppose there's a connection. There's also kind of a sort of computational biologist, this computational equivalence of each of the disciplines, which are becoming more and more fascinating. All the work that DeepMind is doing and the work of genetics, all that kind of stuff, simulating different parts of the body to try to gain an intuition, understanding of it. That to me is super fascinating, but sometimes it does feel like an oversimplification of the way the body really does it. Because the body is an incredibly weird, complex system. And it finds a way. The adaptability, the resilience, the redundancy that's built in. It's weird.

• 2:08:25Lex Fridman?

  It's incredibly powerful. And so unlike the kind of computer-based systems that we build, at least we engineer in the software engineering world, which kind of starts to make you think, how can we engineer computer systems in a different way that make them more resilient in the real world? That's sort of the robotics question.

• 2:08:48Lex Fridman?

  What do you think about that? What does it take to build a humanoid robot or robots that are as resilient as the human body? How difficult do you think is that problem? Having studied the human body, how hard is the engineering problem of building systems like that guy over there, the legged guy that is as resilient as the human body to the harsh conditions of the real world?

• 2:09:14Speaker 01

  I think it's very hard and we definitely haven't gotten there yet. I think we could probably learn lessons from people who are trying to grow artificial organs in the lab to eventually transplant into people, which would solve the huge problem of needing to get those organs from others and the rejection of putting a foreign material inside your body. Your immune system tends not to like that. You know, that has advanced a lot recently. I think, I think some advances actually have been where, you know, we pay a lot of attention to stem cells, stem cells, stem cells. We can grow whatever we want out of stem cells. But now there's sort of a recognition that the, what we call the extracellular matrix, which is sort of the, you know, foundation of the body, the thing that

• 2:09:55Speaker 01

  holds all the cells into their proper shape and keeps them where they should be. That is actually crucial and there's probably a lot of signaling that goes on. Like you stick a stem cell on the right extracellular matrix, it will turn into the kind of cell that you want and take the right shape and position and start functioning. I think that's been a huge, huge advance, knowing that it's not just these, you know, celebrity stem cells that are the answer. It's this kind of part in the background, this sort of just like laying the foundation, the system that you put these cells onto. And we're not there yet, but there's definitely a lot happening, a lot of research happening and I think there'll be some advances probably soon.

• 2:10:34Lex Fridman?

  So now on the topic of interaction of computational systems with biology. So if you look at a company like Neuralink or the, the whole effort of brain-computer interfaces, now there's a neurosurgery component there. We have to connect electrical systems.

• 2:10:56Lex Fridman?

  With biological systems. So just even the implanting is difficult. Then the communication is difficult. But what would you say from what you know about the brain, what you know about the human body and all the beautiful mess that's there? How difficult is the effort of Neuralink? Do you think it's feasible?

• 2:11:16Speaker 01

  I think it's definitely feasible. I think that we need to probably know more than we do and know how to connect it in all these ways. I think some advances, for instance, much less sexy, but really already impacting medical care is something called deep brain stimulation, which is done for Parkinson's disease and others where neurosurgeons implant this device that's electrically stimulates the part of the brain that is not functioning in Parkinson's disease. It's quite dramatic how effective it works. And I remember as a med student, watching a neurologist literally like turn the electricity up on this handheld thing and you could see the person's Parkinson's tremor go away and you could see them start to walk in a more steady fashion.

• 2:12:01Speaker 01

  And I know there's studies, there's actually studies or there may be studies in the future studying the same deep brain stimulation for everything from eating disorders to severe OCD, like severe OCD, like paralyzing OCD, not just like I want to wash my hands three times. And so I think the, you know, the potential is there, but I guess connecting the brain in a microscopic way and sort of a multifaceted way, you know, there needs to be sort of a million connections or some very high number of connections for them to work fluidly. As far as I know, I'm not an expert in the area.

• 2:12:37Lex Fridman?

  First of all, I believe and I trust in the adaptability of the biological system to whatever crazy stuff you try to shove in there. So it's going to potentially reject things, but it's also going to, if it doesn't reject things, adapt. And if we can create computational systems that also adapt, AI systems that adapt and can kind of, both of them reach towards each other and figure stuff out. But actually, our current AI systems are not very adaptable to the, like in the wild way that biology is adaptable, like adaptable to anything. And if we can build AI systems like that, I feel like there's some interesting things you could do. But of course, there's ethics and there's real human lives at stake.

• 2:13:24Lex Fridman?

  And there you can't quite experiment. You have to have things that work. And maybe simulation can help, but reality is it's a it's a dangerous playground to play on.

• 2:13:38Speaker 01

  It is messy.

• 2:13:40Lex Fridman?

  You tweeted that quote, if you look back from far enough into the future, every doctor today will look like a total quack.

• 2:13:51Lex Fridman?

  First of all, that's humbling to think about. Like, we don't know what we're doing in the great. Like, there's been so much progress that we kind of have this confidence that we figured it all out. If you look at history and you read how people thought, I mean, there's so many moments in history where people really thought that they figured it all out. It's almost like there's nothing else left to do at every stage in history. And and then you realize, no, progress often happens like exponentially. And every moment you continue to think you figured it all out. But if you're being honest, if you're being humble, then you realize we're just shrouded in mystery. So what do we make of this?

• 2:14:36Lex Fridman?

  Like, how should we feel that? How should you feel as a doctor? How should we feel as scientific explorers of the human body? The fact that we're probably going to be wrong about everything we currently know.

• 2:14:49Speaker 01

  Right, there's a saying, actually, by the time you finish med school, half of what you learned is wrong, which is quite illustrative and becoming more true as time goes on. You know, so much medical research going on, so much learning going on. It's really wonderful in a way. But in some ways, we still learn these concepts, you know, from the past. And I know when you take a test as a medical student, sometimes you know, they want to ask you, they want you to give the old answer, but you know, there's a new answer because of recent science. But you know, to give the old answer, that's now incorrect to get the question right on the test. That happens actually quite a bit because things change so quickly. Yet, you know, when I look back at doctors from centuries past, I mean, it's absurd what they were doing to their patients.

• 2:15:34Speaker 01

  I mean, for probably for most of human history, they were doing more harm than good. You know, they're draining people of their blood. That was, you know, bloodletting was a huge part of of medical care. You know, George Washington died of a paratonsillar abscess, an abscess right next to the tonsil, which has the great name of Quincy, and they bled him to death. You know, I mean, kind of adding insult to injury. Doctors are a menace and do a lot of harm. I mean, hopefully not intentionally. You know, even medical errors are still a huge problem, cause of death and morbidity. So we do a lot of things that are not great. But, you know, our knowledge, yeah, it's, it's very imperfect at this point. I do have some confidence.

• 2:16:16Speaker 01

  You know, I guess, perfect scientific studies that try to get at the reality of the universe are essential. Because when I think of why a certain medication works for a certain condition, it might make perfect sense in my head, knowing the biology, the biochemistry, the anatomy. It makes perfect sense, it must work. I gave it to the patient, they got better, and that's happened 20 times in the last year. But it's, you know, I'm wrong. Like, when you actually do a study, it actually doesn't help. Maybe it hurts. And that's really, I think, the way we explain medications working in our minds is often wrong, when you end up finally doing the, the study. And some of the most interesting experiments involve what we call sham surgery.

• 2:17:00Speaker 01

  So for instance, people who injure their knee, you know, arthroscopy, where an orthopedic surgeon goes in there with a scope, gets bits of bone out, shaves down the cartilage, you know, cleans things up, and it helps some people. But they, they actually did some studies where one group of people got the true arthroscopy and others just got sham surgery, where they put them to sleep, made little cuts in the skin so that they woke up with scars. And then it turned out that it's not clear arthroscopy is actually helping. And the same, there was a recent huge study of doing, putting a stent in someone's coronary arteries if they have stable chest pain. Not like, I'm having a heart attack, you need a stent, like, right then. But, you know, kind of chronic coronary artery disease, where every time I run up

• 2:17:43Speaker 01

  the stairs, I get chest pain, and then when I rest, it goes away. Like, obviously, you put a stent, you increase blood flow to the heart. Like, how could that not work? But then, when they did the sham catheterization, it actually looks like it might not actually help better than the sham. So I think those placebo-controlled studies are essential. I mean, it is shocking, and this has been driven home during the last two years, how hard it is to figure out what the hell's going on in the universe, and especially with our bodies. Like, it is really hard to get at the truth. And what you think makes sense, like, often turns out, I mean, the history of modern medicine is littered with examples where it made perfect sense, and it seemed to help some patients. And it turns out, it's not doing anything, or it's harmful.

• 2:18:25Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, there's all kinds of narratives swimming around. We convince ourselves as this human civilization that something is true. There's propaganda machines, there's just self-delusion. There's centralized communities. Like, there's a scientific community that believes a certain thing. There's the conspiracy theories that believe a certain thing. Sometimes the scientific community writes, sometimes the conspiracy theorists are right. Throughout human history, I mean. And we now think the scientific community, well, now the science has really figured it out. We're way smarter than we were in the past. And then there's these, like, interesting studies that I've seen. I think Roman Hansen mentioned it to me,

• 2:19:07Lex Fridman?

  that if you look at the entirety of medication, like, the effect of medication on human health, if you do those kinds of broad studies, does it actually help? Like, does quality of life, lifespan, certain measures of the well-being, does, if you, and you look at human society as a whole, does taking medication or not actually help? And those studies find there's no positive or negative effect with medication. And that's a very, kind of, interesting perspective. I mean, you could probably argue, you know, a lot of ways. But the point is, because you can bring up...

• 2:19:51Lex Fridman?

  Literally a billion cases where medication had significant positive impact on a particular patient, but you have to kind of zoom out and honestly look at the positive effects of medicine, of lifestyle choices, diet choices, of exercise or not, you know, maybe we'll find eventually that exercise is actually bad for you. Maybe like there's all kinds of things that we're going to, I feel like we're going to figure out. One of the things I think we're going to figure out, everything I've learned about my body is that aside from it being adaptable, there's a lot of very unique parameters that are opaque to me that I'm measuring through this feedback mechanism by trying stuff and

• 2:20:36Lex Fridman?

  learning about it. And one of the things we might learn is that medicine cannot be done without collecting a huge amount of data about each individual human. So like it's absurd to be like if I show up and see a doctor, it's absurd for that doctor to have just a couple of minutes with me, like with just like looking at basic symptoms, looking at such like crappy data, like first of all, no long-term data, no longitude, no data, no historical data, no detailed analysis of all the possible things,

• 2:21:20Lex Fridman?

  not just the related to your symptoms, but related to other things that you're not complaining about, just giving you a full picture of the data and then using AI to help the human doctor highlight the things that you should perhaps pay extra attention to. I think we'll look back at this time as ridiculous that doctors were expected to help anybody whatsoever without having the data, without having a huge amount of data about the human body. Like you're, you have to do so much with so little data. It's very 19th century. It's very 19th century. So it relies on the brilliance of doctors and of course, the intuition, the instinct you build up over time. Right. And that's quite powerful. The human brain is pretty, pretty damn good for using experience to teach you how to

• 2:22:05Lex Fridman?

  make good decisions, but still it's, it's, uh, it's, you might as well be bloodletting.

• 2:22:12Lex Fridman?

  Like, it's humbling to think about that. It's humbling.

• 2:22:17Speaker 01

  It is humbling and it's important. I think doctors sometimes lose that humble perspective on what they do. And I think it's very important because as I said, you know, medical history is just, medical dogma has been tossed into the trash bin so many times. Something doctors were sure of was the case is not. And it's important to, to be cognizant of that.

• 2:22:41Lex Fridman?

  You tweeted about somebody that had a big impact just by reading about him on my life as well. I still think about him. Rest in peace, Dr. Paul Farmer, a big inspiration to me. His medical career was a testament to what one person can do to improve the world. So who was Paul Farmer? And what made him a great doctor and a great man? And somebody who was an inspiration to you?

• 2:23:10Speaker 01

  So Paul Farmer was a kind of pioneer of global health. He started Partners in Health, which is this kind of an international health organization that operates originally in Haiti, also Rwanda and elsewhere. And I think he was just so a zealot for getting healthcare to some of the poorest people in the world. And he, I remember reading some of his books and a book about him by Tracy Kidder. That's really great. Mountains Beyond Mountains, about how even when he was a medical student, he was flying back and forth to Haiti in between exams and just with this really intense focus and interest in, in getting healthcare to where it's, where it's not.

• 2:23:53Speaker 01

  And I think traveling around the world, especially to poorer places like India, Calcutta, Nepal, you really see how unevenly the benefits of modern medicine are spread over the surface of the earth. Not only if you're, because if you're in Antarctica and have a heart attack, you're in serious trouble, but you know, just medications that cost pennies a day can help people. You know, a lot of children in India under five die of diarrhea. And all they need is oral rehydration solutions to to stay hydrated. You know, most of them can't afford IV fluids, for instance, to get admitted to the hospital. And really dehydration just kills hundreds of thousands of kids throughout the world.

• 2:24:33Speaker 01

  Not to mention bacterial pneumonia also is a major cause of death in children under five. And many of them, not all, would be saved by amoxicillin, which is just pennies. And for me, you know, I took a had a path and I wanted to have a career in global health. And I started traveling abroad to India and elsewhere when I was a medical student and I continued doing that. Paul Farmer was sort of one of the first to kind of open everyone's eyes, I think, about the good you can do with just money that we would, you know, change that we would throw away. Just, you know, put in a person, forget it, or wherever we accumulate change these days. So that's very eye opening. And while medical science advances and that's good, you know, we shouldn't forget that 100 year old

• 2:25:18Speaker 01

  treatments could save lives in parts of the world where they're just not available.

• 2:25:22Lex Fridman?

  People should definitely read Mountains Beyond Mountains. Just for me, at least, sort of a person from outside all of it. It was the first person to make me realize how difficult and the amount of humanity that's involved in being a doctor. So it's not some kind of cold economics based argument about where to send treatments and so on. That is there too. Like you said, basic treatments can help hundreds of thousands, millions of people in many parts of the world. But it's also

• 2:26:00Lex Fridman?

  when you have a patient in front of you, there's some aspect of you that's willing to to give a lot of your time, a lot of your money, a lot of your effort to saving them, even though it doesn't make any sense. It's irrational in some sense, but it's also human. And that's the struggle of every doctor, like when you have to choose how to allocate your time, how to allocate your mental energy.

• 2:26:25Speaker 01

  Right.

• 2:26:25Lex Fridman?

  It's a tough, it's a tough choice that a doctor has to make. And it's a human choice. It's not some kind of cold game theoretic choice. It's also a human choice and it can be irrational in some sense.

• 2:26:38Speaker 01

  Right, people are asking you for help. That's basically what every patient interaction is. Someone's asking you for help. So your inclination is to help them. And even if it means going above and beyond, you know, I mean, a lot of factors affect how compassionate a doctor might be on any given day or, you know, point in their career, their own stress and burnout, et cetera. But it's someone asking you for help and so you do what you can to help them.

• 2:27:05Lex Fridman?

  You've done quite a lot of things in your life. It's been an interesting journey. And of course, there's a lot of story yet to be written. But what advice would you give to young people today in high school? Maybe undergrad, college, starting out on that journey? Maybe trying to pick majors, trying to pick jobs, careers, dreams and goals that can pursue. What advice would you give them to have a career they can be proud of or to even have a life they can be proud of?

• 2:27:40Speaker 01

  Well, I think having passion, which isn't always a voluntary thing, you know, you just have it or you don't perhaps, but becoming passionate about something and following it, you know, wherever it takes you, I think is really important. You know, when I finished college and sort of went to Russia for the first time, that was in some ways, the beginning of my whole career and passions in my life. And I didn't know what I was going for, what was going to happen, what kind of career would turn into, what kind of job would it help me get when I got back? I wasn't thinking about any of that. I'm very fortunate I got that opportunity. I'm very fortunate to, you know, be able to go and see those places and have my mind opened. And I think that really just the fuel from that passion that was created during that

• 2:28:24Speaker 01

  time is still 20 years later going strong. You know, I'm partial to healthcare. I love being a doctor. I think it's the perfect combination of kind of intellectual problem solving, being a detective while also working with your hands, you know, when you do procedures, especially in the ER, it's sort of the perfect combination. I'm not a surgeon, but I do use my hands quite a bit, whether, you know, for a variety of reasons. And so I always loved working with my hands. I loved crafts, especially prehistoric crafts before medical school. And I just love kind of problem solving, getting clues, figuring out what's going on, you know, following your nose, using your instincts, your knowledge, and also just keen observation of the patient, you know,

• 2:29:09Speaker 01

  after seeing patient after patient, hundreds of patients, maybe thousands over years, you do get this sort of innate kind of sense, this gestalt about what might be going on. And, you know, it's not always a numbers thing. That's the thing. There's always, there's gestalt is actually a big part of medicine, you know, you often in ERs or in hospitals hear a nurse or doctor say something like, this patient just doesn't look good. And it's sort of, you can't point to a number, a value, a level in their blood, you know, a test, but something about them. And I, a lot of that, I think, has to do with the color of their skin, believe it or not, which can change in certain disease states.

• 2:29:47Speaker 01

  But I think that it's just, medicine combines this observation, the skills, the knowledge, it's art and science, it's human, and it's robotic, you know, algorithmic at the same time. And I think it just, yeah, combines kind of all my passions all in one. And I would, you know, if anyone's going into healthcare, I'd strongly encourage them to do so, but I'm very biased.

• 2:30:10Lex Fridman?

  So with that early passion, whatever that little flame was that brought you to Russia, were you able to vocalize it? Or was it just something like a gut that's pulled you towards some exploration of the unknown or something like this?

• 2:30:27Speaker 01

  I think it was a combination of things. One was just going to a different place that was different from where I grew up, you know, the suburbs, you know, when you're in high school, you hate them. Later on, they don't seem so bad. But, you know, I just wanted to get, I mean, I'm very fortunate how I was raised and never wanted for anything that wasn't rich. But just to get out and see a different place, a different people with a different culture and history and language and literature and to see different climates and geographies and ecosystems. I just wanted to see something different. And that- I guess that's what I've sought after ever since. So just that was just so fascinating. Like my trip to Kamchatka in 2003, where I was there for four months and I didn't speak

• 2:31:09Speaker 01

  English for, I think, two months out of it. And just, I remember lying on the floor, some wooden floor in a hunter's cabin in the middle of northern Kamchatka, just being like, what am I doing here? This is, I'm just so grateful for like the experiences I was having, what I was seeing and realizing and learning. It was just, I was so grateful, even though I was lying on this hard, uncomfortable floor. It's just like, this is so amazing. And that, I don't think I'll ever have another travel as meaningful and life-changing as that particular trip to Kamchatka was. Though I'm still striving after it. You know, you never replicate that first high, but you always try. So I just think that seeing something different is kind of the game.

• 2:31:50Lex Fridman?

  And there wasn't really a plan. Cause I got a chance to talk to the CEO of Qualcomm recently, and he, his advice is always have a plan. And it sounds like you're saying,

• 2:32:06Speaker 01

  Don't have a

• 2:32:06Lex Fridman?

  Don't have a plan. Don't need to have a plan. Just listen to your gut, your passion, and follow that and see, see where that takes you. Cause it's telling you something.

• 2:32:17Speaker 01

  Yeah, I think, you know, I guess the plan could be specific or could be as general as, I just wanna go far away and see something very different. That's my plan. And I did

• 2:32:27Lex Fridman?

  That's one line.

• 2:32:28Speaker 01

  Just followed my nose from one thing to the next, just being interested, following my passion. And again, very fortunate I could do that.

• 2:32:36Lex Fridman?

  Are there places in the world you're kind of thinking about that your life might take you at some point to be a doctor there for a time, to explore for a time that you haven't yet?

• 2:32:52Speaker 01

  You know, I have some colleagues who do kind of global health work in various countries in Africa and Central and South America. I would really love to go to some of those places, not just for a short trip, but hopefully for an extended period of time with sort of the healthcare being the ticket in, but then maybe even bringing my children or just, you know, I guess at this point, some of the travel I dream about is sort of replicating what I did and showing it to my kids in a way. But there's still a lot I haven't seen and would love to see as well. But I think those opportunities sort of lend themselves well, you know, as a doctor with kind of the ability to go there and sort of help, but help patients, but also teach

• 2:33:34Speaker 01

  medical students and residents. Teaching is actually a huge part of being a doctor that's underappreciated, but that's actually part of the fun of being a doctor is that you're also a teacher. Of course, the word doctor means teacher, but it's come to mean something else. But, you know, I, in some of my jobs, I'm working alongside medical students and residents and I'm giving them my knowledge, my wisdom, sharing with them stories. And so that's a very satisfying part of the job.

• 2:34:03Lex Fridman?

  If we could take a brief step into a dark place together for a time, is there, what is a dark place you've gone in your mind in your life? What would be the darkest place you've ever gone for a time, for a moment? And how did you survive? How did you overcome it?

• 2:34:31Speaker 01

  That's a very good question. I would say I haven't had as dark moments as many of the people who I care for in the emergency room. I'm fortunate in that way. I've had a pretty, you know, enjoyable, satisfying life. You know, I think everybody has dark moments though, including me. One of the most shocking things, I feel like, Becoming an adult, my two big realizations have been, one, no one knows what they're doing, and two, suicide is incredibly common, like in all humans and all societies. That I just find shocking. I mean, I've never seriously contemplated myself, but I wouldn't say it hasn't crossed my mind during

• 2:35:15Speaker 01

  some more stressful times of life.

• 2:35:20Speaker 01

  I think it crosses everyone's mind and it's sort of as a kid, I found that I never would have guessed how common suicide is.

• 2:35:27Lex Fridman?

  It's an important question to sort of the, the Camus question, like, why live? Why? Why? It's like life, especially when you're struggling, especially when life is shit. Like, why am I doing any of this? And then on top of that chemistry of your brain, it could be as simple as diet and nutrition and aforementioned exercise and things like this that affect the chemistry such that you're more predisposed to go to the places of asking the question, why? And maybe struggling to find a good answer. Because it's actually a question with no good answer,

• 2:36:12Lex Fridman?

  except something in your chemistry says, well, I kind of like it. But there's no good intellectual answer. And especially if day to day it's pain. You get to see these stories of, you know, Robin Williams,

• 2:36:29Lex Fridman?

  these people that are on top of the world from an external perspective, but from an internal perspective, it's struggle. Every day is pain, feels hopeless. And yeah, that's, that's a question we all have to struggle with or learn how to ignore. Maybe because if you ask the question too much, you're not gonna, you're not going to find a good answer. That's a choice you make. I personally think you should ask that question a lot.

• 2:37:00Lex Fridman?

  But maybe because I have the luxury of the chemistry I have where I'm not in danger of seriously contemplating suicide. But why live is an important question to answer constantly and struggle to answer that constantly.

• 2:37:16Lex Fridman?

  But people, I am, I've gotten, I've been extremely fortunate to meet people over the past couple of years that are really struggling. And

• 2:37:30Lex Fridman?

  you have probably met

• 2:37:33Lex Fridman?

  people who are really struggling, like orders of magnitude more people who are really struggling. Some of it is psychological, a lot of it is biological. And man, life, life is a motherfucker. It's pretty tough.

• 2:37:48Speaker 01

  Very true. I do think also past trauma is a, plays a big role there, like we talked about, you know, war wounds and PTSD and a lot of people grew up, I mean, with just horrific childhoods. They're abused in one way or another. And I think a lot of people who have, not, not a, I'm not saying a majority, but a lot of people, for instance, who I see in the ER, uh, coming in for threatening suicide are actually trying and failing and being brought to the ER. You know, a lot of them just have really traumatic experiences, um, you know, saw their parent commit suicide, uh, were abused, you know, these leave scars in the, in the human brain and mind. And a lot of the, their subsequent lives of whether it's substance abuse,

• 2:38:32Speaker 01

  alcoholism, et cetera, is almost trying to escape from their own memories. And it's sort of such this overwhelming, um, battle sometimes, like sometimes people get ruined, it seems, and just can't be fixed. You know what I mean? Yes, you can improve diet and health and your life choices and seek out your passion and exercise and those definitely will help. But sometimes just like, you know, you bear the scars of the past and there's no getting rid of them.

• 2:38:58Lex Fridman?

  Yeah, I think it's possible to live with them.

• 2:39:03Speaker 01

  I think so too.

• 2:39:03Lex Fridman?

  The struggle.

• 2:39:04Speaker 01

  I would never say give up, you know?

• 2:39:06Lex Fridman?

  Keep fighting.

• 2:39:08Speaker 01

  It is a constant, it can be a constant battle for some people.

• 2:39:11Lex Fridman?

  I know it can be, and I've talked to many of those folks. I know it can feel hopeless, but keep up the good fight.

• 2:39:19Speaker 01

  Hopelessness.

• 2:39:19Lex Fridman?

  Keep up the good fight.

• 2:39:20Speaker 01

  Hopelessness is kind of one of the big suicide risk factors that you sort of ask about as a, as a doctor, you know, do you feel hopeless? And that's sort of a, can be a harbinger.

• 2:39:31Lex Fridman?

  I have quite a few dark moments. So if you, if you, if you're listening and you're struggling, we're in this together, brother and sister. Keep up the good fight.

• 2:39:45Speaker 01

  Life is a motherfucker, as you said. It's really harder. I think as a kid, you know, in a joy free childhood, you don't realize like, I'm obviously, there's a ton you don't realize about life. But then when you get to be an adult, you realize just how complex and hard it is. Is it this hard for adult animals? I don't know. I don't think it is.

• 2:40:07Lex Fridman?

  So having seen

• 2:40:10Lex Fridman?

  the honesty of biology before you, do you think about your own death?

• 2:40:17Lex Fridman?

  Do you contemplate death? Are you afraid of your own death? How do you make sense of it?

• 2:40:24Speaker 01

  I've definitely thought about it, especially maybe while doing certain risky things. Ice climbing and others where every time I look down, I thought about my own death. But I think, you know, I think having kids changes the equation for sure.

• 2:40:41Speaker 01

  Should change the equation perhaps. So I think a lot of now, when I think about what will happen when I die, you know, there's a lot of worrying about what will happen to the people I care for, you know, you think about things like insurance policy, like life insurance and, you know, disability insurance, that's not related to death, but more just injuries. And that's part of the weight, I guess, that, you know, you feel as an adult that I think grows rapidly when you have kids, though, though not only, you know, there's other people you can care for, your own parents and loved ones, like a lot of people depend on individuals. And so you think about what will happen to the other people when you die.

• 2:41:22Lex Fridman?

  But also to push back, that weight might be something you've convinced yourself to think about. It's an important way to think about. But you focus on that way to escape the other weight, which is that's one point.

• 2:41:43Lex Fridman?

  This consciousness just comes to an end. And it's hard to make sense of that. We kind of delude ourselves in thinking, okay, it just, yeah, it ends. That's a natural way of things and so on. That makes sense. So we're good. Okay, that's the way, that's the way of life. But like, I don't think it's cognitively easy to just realize how terrifying that is. We love life so much that's

• 2:42:11Lex Fridman?

  The end of it, it just um.

• 2:42:16Lex Fridman?

  It's something that makes no sense. And if you linger on that thought, I think it's a painful, it's a painful, I would say even terrifying thought, not scared of like, in a way that's almost like philosophically terrifying. Like, it just reminds you, maybe humbles you that you don't know any of the, anything about anything.

• 2:42:38Lex Fridman?

  But one of the things we do as humans really well is we, especially with kids, you realize, okay, we start caring for others in the community, in the family and so on, and that distracts us. Because then we can at least focus on other people's problems and not deal with our own.

• 2:42:57Speaker 01

  When I was a medical student, I was particularly fascinated with kind of what actually happens as people die, like in the last minute, seconds of life. It's sort of surprising sometimes, like what actually kills people, you know, like you can get, let's say, a bad head injury and, you know, what kills you? Sometimes it's just your consciousness decreases and you become kind of comatose. You aspirate, your oxygen plummets and you get cardiac arrest, you know, that kind of sequence of events. Or, you know, a heroin overdose, let's say you stop breathing, similarly, your oxygen goes down, then you get a cardiac arrest. So I was, I was really fascinated with what actually happens, what makes people die. And it was sort of a morbid fascination, obviously, like most of med school is.

• 2:43:42Speaker 01

  And I had many instances where I've had patients pass. And as a medical student, I was sort of, sort of learning what's actually happening, watching it happen and, you know, not always being able to prevent it. It was sort of a scientific exploration. Then the patient's family comes in and are just devastated. And then it's like. Rips you out of the scientific perspective and you just realize how horrible death is. But the person's fine, you know, it's the family, I guess. And that's why it's always, I guess, that pointed out just how what people leave behind is often kind of the horribleness of death, like just becoming unconscious and staying that way. It doesn't seem, I guess, to me personally, so bad. Sort of like going to sleep, not waking up, not counting the pain and stuff that precedes it.

• 2:44:27Lex Fridman?

  So the actual pain, the actual suffering is often felt by the people who love the person who died.

• 2:44:33Speaker 01

  Right.

• 2:44:33Lex Fridman?

  So both financial pain, psychological pain, for years, missing them, all those kinds of things.

• 2:44:41Speaker 01

  Right, never forgetting the anniversary of their death, you know, just having flashbacks or something reminding you. That sort of brought home to me sort of what death means. And it was more about what people leave behind than what happens to them specifically.

• 2:44:56Lex Fridman?

  See, I like those concerns because I feel like I can do a lot about those. Those make sense to me. Then just be, if you're a father, just be a good father.

• 2:45:08Lex Fridman?

  If you're, sort of, you mentioned sort of insurance. Yeah, there's like financial stuff to take care of. What I don't know what to do with is the philosophical existential crisis of the fact that this fricking thing ends. It doesn't, I don't know how to deal with the mystery that's beyond death. Why are we here? Why are we born at all? What is consciousness? And you just look at yourself, what is this? Why do I have the capacity to suffer?

• 2:45:40Lex Fridman?

  Why, why? All these kinds of why questions that don't have answers. Speaking of which, let me ask you a why question.

• 2:45:47Lex Fridman?

  The biggest ridiculous one. What do you think is the meaning of life?

• 2:45:52Lex Fridman?

  Having, with this book, studied the incredible, beautiful biology of life, the components, the engineering components that make up this human body. But when you look at the entirety of it. What is, why? Why are we here?

• 2:46:10Speaker 01

  Sometimes, probably more often than not, feel like the question of why is a trick of the human brain. And outside of our thoughts, there is no why. Why is not something that's in the universe? It's just this trick happening inside our brain.

• 2:46:26Lex Fridman?

  So why, why is a game that the human brain plays on itself? And then the reality of life doesn't have whys?

• 2:46:35Speaker 01

  I do wonder if asking why is sort of an evolutionary adaptation, like, um, why, you know, maybe hunting, gathering, why does this plant grow there and not there? Why do I see the same deer tracks and by the same tree every three days? Why, you know, why is this? Why is that?

• 2:46:54Speaker 01

  Why does this plant make me vomit and that plant doesn't? I guess those whys are very practical and oriented towards survival. But then obviously, you know, we not only use why, you know, we use it to maybe hunt better, gather better, survive better. But then we sort of extrapolate it into these unanswerable questions, you know, about why, like, why does life exist?

• 2:47:18Lex Fridman?

  And it's possible that they're not unanswerable in the long arc of science and history. It's, we're just striving for the really difficult questions. Right now, we're just don't know much about anything. And so we're striving. But there, there's long, so most of human history, you were asking why questions for which we now have very precise answers, including with biology and physics and all those kinds of things. And maybe the why is this cutting edge of science of the explorer, of the curiosity of the human mind. Like man's search for meaning is the sort of the ultimate driver of the why.

• 2:47:58Lex Fridman?

  And it's almost like, it could be an evolutionary adaptation of asking exceptionally hard why questions that will never get answered. Like, so you should always have, like, it's like a queue. It's a, it's a stack of questions, why questions? And that thing should never come to the bottom. Should always be striving. And that's, that's useful for humans to come up with better and better ways of survival. And maybe from, in a bigger perspective, for the universe to figure out something about itself. And it's just humans, just a useful tool for that. Or life on earth as a useful tool for that. Well, John, this, you're, you're, uh,

• 2:48:42Lex Fridman?

  for people who should know, you're from Philadelphia. I'm from Philadelphia, so it's an, it's an honor that you would travel all this way from a place I love to the new place I love. And that you would write this really incredible book that celebrates the human body in the most honest of ways. And thank you for everything you do, for being a great educator, for being a great doctor, for being a great person and for spending your really valuable time with me today. Thank you, John. Thanks for having me, Lex. Thanks for listening to this conversation with Jonathan Reisman. To support this podcast, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now let me leave you with some words from Paul Farmer, a doctor who has inspired both Jonathan and me with the way he practiced medicine and the way he lived his life.

• 2:49:26Lex Fridman?

  The idea that some lives matter less is the root of all that is wrong with the world. Thank you for listening and hope to see you next time.