Pod Insights The Big Picture The 25 Best Movies of the Century: No. 25 - ‘Michael Clayton’ About this episode Sean and Amanda kick off their year-long project of listing the 25 best movies of the 21st century so far with a discussion of Tony Gilroy’s ‘Michael Clayton,’ the 2007 legal thriller starring George Clooney and featuring one of the best scripts of the century. They talk about how tightly wound the movie is, some sliding doors in its production, and what it means for the list to start with such a beloved movie for both Sean and Amanda.
Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins
Senior Producer: Bobby Wagner
Video Producer: Jack Sanders
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This is Bill Simmons and I want to tell you about my movie podcast, The Rewatchables, where each week I'm joined by ringer movie lovers, Chris Ryan, Sean Finacy, Van Lathan, Kyle Brandt, Matt Le Ruben. We have a whole bunch of people on. We talk about movies we can't stop rewatching. And now you can watch us cover these movies on video in the Spotify app. We have covered over 350 movies, including Heat, Goodfellas, Boogie Nights, Pulp Fiction. We have some real heavy hitters coming up here in 2025. Make sure to follow us on Spotify, where you can watch every new episode right now. Just head to The Rewatchables on Spotify, now on video.
0:38 Speaker 01 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network, and no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month, or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
1:08 Speaker 02 Coca-Cola. For the big, for the small, the short, and the tall. Peacemakers, risk-takers. For the optimists, pessimists. For long-distance love. For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you.
1:45 Sean Fennessey? I'm Sean Finacy. I'm Amanda Dobbins. And this is 25 for 25, a big-picture conversation special about Michael Clayton. That's right, we are kicking off our year-long project, counting down the 25 best slash our favorite films of the century so far. We're doing it with a bag man today. We're doing it about Michael Clayton. We have to talk about 25 for 25 before we dig into this movie for this mini-episode, this semi-bimonthly episode. How often are we gonna be doing these?
2:17 Amanda Dobbins? Well, you're the one who made the spreadsheet.
2:19 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
2:19 Amanda Dobbins? But it seems like every other week.
2:22 Sean Fennessey? More or less.
2:23 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:23 Sean Fennessey? More or less, maybe twice a month, sometimes three times a month.
2:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, sometimes we'll cluster because, you know, there are movie events, personal events. But yeah, we'll be throughout the year because we have 25 films plus a couple of bonus episodes. One are, um, one of which might be in the can already.
2:41 Sean Fennessey? Yes, a selection committee.
2:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
2:43 Sean Fennessey? Sort of the Selection Sunday style, it's March Madness.
2:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
2:46 Sean Fennessey? It's just starting now. We had our own version of it last week.
2:49 Amanda Dobbins? So, and they will be rolling out until December.
2:52 Sean Fennessey? So 25 for 25, what is it? I've already sort of explained what it is, right? It's a collaboration. You and I came together, meeting of the minds. What are the best movies that we can agree on that represent our taste? What the century in cinema is so far? Where things are going, where they were? What else? What does this constitute?
3:12 Amanda Dobbins? It is the big pictures, 25 most important movies of the century so far. And so if you've been following along with the show, you understand some of the, uh, the implications, the, the preferences that are implied in that. But we probably should lay them out a little bit so people don't yell at us like deeply. We have some rules.
3:36 Sean Fennessey? We do.
3:37 Amanda Dobbins? The first rule is that there's one film per director.
3:40 Sean Fennessey? Correct.
3:42 Amanda Dobbins? So, you know, we don't have five Tarantinos, we don't have five Finchers. Like you and I could have done that, but that is a very boring list. So one film per director, your blood pressure is already rising.
3:54 Sean Fennessey? Well, I did, that was a very hard thing to accomplish. And we've still said that there's an outside chance that we could make some changes, even though in theory our list is locked right now.
4:04 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, we're not going to change that rule.
4:07 Sean Fennessey? No, no.
4:08 Amanda Dobbins? But we can make substitutions. Um, we cannot.
4:13 Amanda Dobbins? Undo the ranking after it's been announced.
4:16 Sean Fennessey? Correct.
4:17 Amanda Dobbins? So.
4:17 Sean Fennessey? Once an episode's out.
4:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
4:19 Sean Fennessey? The list is locked.
4:20 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
4:20 Sean Fennessey? To that point.
4:21 Amanda Dobbins? But, but with the things that are not announced, we can still be editing.
4:26 Sean Fennessey? How much last minute swapping do you think will happen in the top 10? Zero?
4:31 Amanda Dobbins? I think zero, but those 10 have to be in the top 10. It's like, we can't cut one of those. So then we've.
4:36 Sean Fennessey? I don't know. I don't know. What if we do?
4:39 Amanda Dobbins? I, I think I, I'm already really angry. We can't.
4:43 Sean Fennessey? I don't know.
4:43 Amanda Dobbins? 10 through 20 is probably where things are gonna get a little, a little crazy.
4:48 Sean Fennessey? We shall see. I don't know. I know you really fought for King Richard. You felt like Will Smith's performance in that film is really important. You had it at number nine right now. So we might have to make a change there. Um, there's not a ton of other rules. The films need to be released starting January 1st, 2000, in the domestically, in the United States. All the way up until ongoing. This is a, a current project.
5:11 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
5:11 Sean Fennessey? So if a film hits, when a Minecraft movie comes out in two weeks and we witness greatness, we may decide, sorry, film like Michael Clayton, but not Michael Clayton, because it's already locked in.
5:22 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
5:23 Sean Fennessey? You have to go sit down for Jared Hess's a Minecraft movie, right?
5:27 Amanda Dobbins? I think that is definitely likely.
5:29 Sean Fennessey? What, is there anything you've got your sights on that's coming out later this year that you think could supplant something we've already selected? You don't have to say what it would supplant.
5:36 Amanda Dobbins? Not yet, which is kind of depressing. Um, but.
5:42 Sean Fennessey? Tough sledding so far in 2025.
5:44 Amanda Dobbins? But, you know, it's, it's early. We tend to be surprised at this point by things that come out of especially Cannes, even though we're not going for some reason. And so, and there are also, there are a few directors who have films this year.
6:04 Amanda Dobbins? That still deserve a chance, a slot on our list. So I wonder whether the reevaluation means that we can shuffle things around.
6:14 Sean Fennessey? You're referring, of course, to Barry Levinson, who's Alto Nights is coming shortly.
6:17 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
6:19 Sean Fennessey? I think that that's more or less it, right? I mean, why are we doing this? Because 25 is a nice round number. It's fun to do a project. But also, you know, we've been doing the show for eight years. It's been a long time.
6:31 Amanda Dobbins? That's true. I think it's important to highlight that like this, this is from us, from you and me and from the show. And and to honor kind of the the show and what we've been doing the last eight years. So it's very Hollywood focused.
6:43 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
6:44 Amanda Dobbins? You know, I was like, people are gonna.
6:46 Sean Fennessey? Not not strictly.
6:48 Amanda Dobbins? It's not strictly, but we are two children of the 90s who have always been obsessed with Hollywood and grew up reading Entertainment Weekly, unlike movie stars. And, um, you know, we do see things more widely, you especially. But like, are there gonna be as many? Is it is this representative of the entirety of like world cinema and all its many languages and also genres? No, it is not. Like, it's it's just not. It is it is it is personal to us. And so we are not trying to be definitive. We are not trying to be representative. We understand that there are both blind spots and just things we love.
7:32 Amanda Dobbins? And we really did lean into things that we love. So that is, that's how you make a list.
7:38 Amanda Dobbins? But I just, I need people to repeat that to themselves over and over again. And to themselves, don't share it with me.
7:45 Sean Fennessey? I think there's no making anyone happy when embarking on a project like this, except for ourselves. And we're happy with where we landed, sort of. I'm still kind of angrier.
7:54 Amanda Dobbins? There's time, there's a whole year.
7:55 Sean Fennessey? There is. I'm I have no complaints whatsoever about number 25.
7:59 Amanda Dobbins? Well, except for, is it gonna offend people that it's number 25?
8:03 Sean Fennessey? Well, it might even offend me, having just revisited the film.
8:07 Amanda Dobbins? You and I, we saw each other this weekend. And the last week in movie going has, there have been some bright spots, but it's mostly been a slog.
8:16 Sean Fennessey? A little tough.
8:16 Amanda Dobbins? And we were kinda, you know, stomping through the not fun stuff. And we, we shared that we were both saving Michael Clayton as a treat to watch on Sunday night as like the, the reward for all of this stuff. And so I did also then go home watching and I was like, 25, really? Like only, are we sure? I, I found myself being like emotional by getting emotional about how, how good this film is and how much I love it.
8:41 Sean Fennessey? I agree with you. It just goes down like a cold glass of lemonade. It is a very manageable, tight, beautifully executed thing. Uh, let me give some details. I'll try to give as much detail at the top before we begin a conversation.
8:57 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
8:58 Sean Fennessey? This will be a, you know, kind of a brief conversation for every movie that we do. We're not attempting to do a rewatchables episode here. It is more sort of an acknowledgement of why this movie works for us and why it belongs on this list relative to what movies have been for the past 25 or so years. So, Michael Clayton comes out October 5th, 2007, in a fall in which many other great films come out, including A Country for Old Men, There Will Be Blood, handful of others that are beloved, Zodiac. Written and directed by Tony Gilroy, who to this point has been a widely acclaimed screenwriter and also script fixer, a ghostwriter, somebody who comes in and helps people solve problems in their screenplays, has gone on to obviously incredible success, directed a couple more movies, is now probably best known as the creator of Andor,
9:42 Sean Fennessey? the Star Wars series, which is like the only good Star Wars thing that has come out since The Last Jedi, probably.
9:49 Sean Fennessey? Stars George Clooney, Tom Wilkinson, Tilda Swinton, an Academy Award winning performance, Sidney Pollack as well, a number of other great character actors strewn throughout the cast. Shot by the great Robert Elswit, shot a lot of PTA movies, one of the most gifted cinematographers of his time. Music by James Newton Howard. This movie made $93 million at the worldwide box office, pretty good. And it had, it got seven Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Director, Score, and Screenplay, and Best Actor for Clooney, Best Supporting Actor for Wilkinson, and Swinton's win. Why did this movie make the list?
10:23 Amanda Dobbins? It ticks several sweet spots for us, including, and you were setting this up when you were talking about Tony Gilroy.
10:31 Amanda Dobbins? We, we really like a writer's movie. We like people talking in rooms and talking really well. And this is one of the great screenwriters, just absolutely like seeing God. It is so perfectly plotted, just the ideas and, and structured. The dialogue is just like, you know, don't piss off a motivated stripper, really, really important stuff. And it is, it is sort of just a series of people, mostly men, talking in rooms or in alleys.
11:07 Amanda Dobbins? But with such artistry and cynicism and just execution is spot on. So that really speaks to us. And I feel like we had a lot of writers, writers who didn't quite make the, the list. So in some ways that can stand for this. The other thing is that it's, it's like a movie star finally finding his moment in George Clooney, who is one of the signature stars of our generation, but maybe not always the signature actor and definitely not the signature director. And this is his lights out moment. This is it.
11:49 Sean Fennessey? So I think in terms of Clooney, it's interesting because this comes in the aftermath of him winning an Academy Award for Siriana. And yet this is the unusual circumstance in which like someone got their Oscar too soon, rather than too late. Because this to me, with maybe the exception of Danny Ocean, is his signature role. This is the, this is the best, is it the best movie he's been associated with? Maybe Out of Sight is in that conversation. Maybe the Ocean's movies are in that conversation.
12:21 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but also what he's doing in this movie. Is like playing against everything that he's doing, certainly in the Ocean's movie, even in Out of Sight to a degree, though there's more in common with Out of Sight, like the kind of down on your luck. But there's not an ounce of charm in this film. There is charisma.
12:41 Sean Fennessey? Mm hmm.
12:42 Amanda Dobbins? But like-
12:43 Sean Fennessey? He can't help but be magnetic.
12:45 Amanda Dobbins? Yes, but I think, I don't think he smiles in this movie. Like maybe like a rueful smile that I don't really think counts, but sort of, you know, the George Clooney on the side of a tequila truck, which like, you know, knock it, but that is a big part of his persona.
13:02 Sean Fennessey? Totally.
13:03 Amanda Dobbins? Is nowhere to be found. And so that he, that he manages to, to pull something off and hold your attention without that sort of signature charm is what makes it so exciting.
13:14 Sean Fennessey? I think this is a very soulful performance from an actor who isn't always soulful, who I think was often accused of a little bit of smarm in the early stages of his stardom and who had a hard time kind of finding the right parts to break through. Should I be an action star? Should I be a genre guy? How do I get over the Doug Ross ER anxiety? I think the thing that is cool about this part for him in particular is Clooney usually plays guys who have great luck, like good fortune. That's something that he kind of finds himself in, which is somehow antithetical to great acting in a lot of ways.
13:50 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
13:50 Sean Fennessey? You know, like the fortunate soul is not somebody that, it's harder to root for that person. Obviously, he's a very handsome guy. He's got this incredible charm. In this movie, he kind of does have everything else. He's incredibly intelligent. He's accomplished in his career. He has a family. He has, he doesn't have exactly what he wants, but he has on paper the things that you would think you would want, but in the way that he has all of them, they're all without luck. His marriage is broken. His brother is an addict and has helped ruin his business. He's never really been able to transcend this skill that he has, this undeniable skill, the bagman skill, the fixer skill, which his superiors identify as making him a one of one.
14:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
14:32 Sean Fennessey? But he knows, kind of dooms him to a sort of grungy irrelevance in the wider world of lawyers. And so it's, it is sort of against type for Clooney.
14:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
14:44 Sean Fennessey? It's not really where he usually lives and yet- There are a few moments in the movie where, for example, he plays in an underground poker game.
14:53 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
14:53 Sean Fennessey? Which we see twice in the film. Starts, the film starts with a sort of flash forward and it cuts backward.
14:58 Amanda Dobbins? Which famously you don't really like, except for this, which is perfect.
15:01 Sean Fennessey? This isn't, this movie didn't invent it.
15:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
15:03 Sean Fennessey? But it did it in the way that is appropriate to me, which is that it shows you an event early in the movie, which is the explosion of his car.
15:09 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
15:09 Sean Fennessey? And gets you really thinking about what could happen and where we are in the story.
15:13 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
15:13 Sean Fennessey? I don't like it when it shows you something that doesn't really matter that much to the story. Anyhow, the poker game, for example, is like a place where if you saw a guy like George Clooney in a poker game like that, you'd be like, what the fuck is going on here? Like, why is there a guy this handsome, this clean cut, this suited? But we buy it in part because of the atmosphere that Gilroy creates. Characterization, plotting, and dialogue are all superlative in the movie.
15:37 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
15:38 Sean Fennessey? And so the vibe of the movie is sort of unmatched, I think, for your post Sidney Lumet, Sidney Lumet-esque character study about a guy in New York trying to solve problems. So, easy movie to love.
15:53 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
15:53 Sean Fennessey? In addition to that, I think one other reason why it's here is that it has become a meme movie in a lot of ways.
16:01 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
16:02 Sean Fennessey? You know, I've got my Michael Clayton hat here. The signs that go outside of people's homes.
16:08 Amanda Dobbins? It's like, it's like a grown-up cult classic.
16:11 Sean Fennessey? Yes, well put.
16:13 Amanda Dobbins? And that sounds silly because, as you enumerated at the beginning of the podcast, it was nominated for seven Academy Awards. It was not underappreciated in its time, but also it came out the same year as There Will Be Blood and No Country For Old Men. And, you know, two other movies about
16:38 Amanda Dobbins? American men operating in, you know, a capital, in a society, we live in a society. But...
16:48 Amanda Dobbins? Operating in the rot of America. And so it has always, even though it's in no way an underdog movie, like, it has always felt a little underappreciated. Or like, you're like in on something if you like it. Hence the yard signs, you know, in this house. We believe that Michael Clayton is an underappreciated. Like, is it underappreciated? I don't know. But it is sort of, you know, there, it's, it's kind of like a, like a code word or something. Like, you know, if you, you know, say to people like, I am Shiva, the god of death. Like, you either know that and you know what the person is referencing or you don't.
17:26 Sean Fennessey? I think it is probably the number one example of a movie from this century that we can point to and say, why don't they make them like this anymore?
17:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
17:36 Sean Fennessey? Because if you want to compare the other movies from that year, for example, like There Will Be Blood or No Country For Old Men, those are in many ways kind of forever movies and very difficult to pull off and very difficult to conceptualize. I don't want to take away from what Tony Gilroy put into this movie because he made a Swiss watch, but it's much smaller, much more grounded.
17:53 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
17:53 Sean Fennessey? Much more achievable on its face than those big, big movies. And so this feels like if we can't have one as good as Michael Clayton, maybe three that are three quarters as good as Michael Clayton.
18:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
18:05 Sean Fennessey? Something that we had gotten used to in the 90s and in the 80s and in the 70s. Like, there, there's a long history of movies like this. And so it is something that I think is very easy to point to and say, this was the last time this kind of thing was great. And I like adult cult classic, grownups cult classic. That's a great way of framing it.
18:22 Amanda Dobbins? All of that is true. I, I think if you got one movie half as good as this, you would feel really good because again, I think we're underestimating how art it is to do what this movie does well, well, like, is there, is there a doubt, a false note in this movie? Like, is there a moment where you're like, nah, I'm not completely locked in? You aren't doing this exactly right? Is there a bad line of dialogue? Like, is there a bad performance? You texted me and you said every single supporting actor is absolutely lights out. I, last night, was thinking to myself, is this the greatest thing that Sidney Pollack ever did? Like, across all films made, produced, like, everything?
19:07 Sean Fennessey? It's a great question. I was watching a Sidney Pollack scene when I texted you. Obviously, Tom Wilkinson and Tilda Swinton have big, showy supporting parts. They have, like, old-school Hollywood supporting star parts.
19:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
19:18 Sean Fennessey? They both got nominated. We understand why they're so great. To me, the magic of the movie is Sidney Pollack, Michael O'Keefe, Ken Howard, Merritt Weaver, Dennis O'Hare, these people who pop up, who are theater veterans, who show up in movies for one minute or three minutes at a time. Pollack, of course, a filmmaker, who, I think to our generation specifically, emerged more strongly as an elite character actor than as the guy who made Out of Africa.
19:47 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
19:47 Sean Fennessey? You know what I mean? Like, he had-
19:48 Amanda Dobbins? Or like Three Days of the Condor, or, you know, The Way We Were.
19:51 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, Tootsie, a number of incredible movies in his career, but he's this guy. He's the guy from Eyes Wide Shut. You know, in this movie, he plays Clayton's boss, a partner at the law firm, somebody who is overseeing, in the case of this story, the, um, a civil case against a U-North, which is a kind of Monsanto-esque-
20:13 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
20:13 Sean Fennessey? -factory-farming agribusiness. And it turns out that their weed killer has been killing people in the middle of the country where it's being used most often, and so there's this civil action against them. And he's trying, the Pollack character's really interesting because he's not a villain. The movie, it has hitmen, they're not really the villains either.
20:35 Amanda Dobbins? No.
20:35 Sean Fennessey? It has a CEO. He's not even really the villain. We know his business is very unethical, and we, we understand that, like, this movie does have a kind of an ethical point of view.
20:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
20:44 Sean Fennessey? But the villain is another lawyer. A general counsel for a big company who goes to extremes.
20:50 Amanda Dobbins? Well, yeah, but even she is sort of the, I mean, she is the villain. But she is played by Tilda Swinton with
21:01 Amanda Dobbins? a tremendous amount of sadness and weakness. Weakness is really, and she's like a pathetic person, like laying out her pantyhose, like literally.
21:13 Sean Fennessey? Very physical performance from her in many ways.
21:15 Amanda Dobbins? And again, another really, really playing against type. Tilda Swinton manages to look ordinary in this movie, which
21:25 Sean Fennessey? She's gained weight.
21:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
21:26 Sean Fennessey? She's very sweaty.
21:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I couldn't actually tell whether she gained weight or was was wearing padding. But they do, you know, make a point of shooting her in unflattering corporate clothing. And and much of her characterization is the is the character preparing both physically and, you know, performatively for whatever speech she is going to put out into the world.
21:51 Amanda Dobbins? Which is, says a lot with a little. But yeah, so she is the villain, but Swinton plays it. And I would even say the character is written like, there's not, what are you going to do? Like, it's sort of, she's inherited these problems. Someone else has made the decisions for her. She doesn't really, she's not doing anything with conviction. That last line, you know, there's a, there's a great confrontation. And the way she screams, you want the money? It's just like someone so out of their depth the whole time. So she is the villain, but like the system, the larger world is is really the villain.
22:31 Amanda Dobbins? And everybody is, everybody, including Michael Clayton, is playing their part and like has some guilt in them and is, you know, and who within the film.
22:45 Amanda Dobbins? Feels guilt about that.
22:46 Sean Fennessey? Mm hmm.
22:47 Amanda Dobbins? And how much is sort of the closest that you get to heroes and villains?
22:53 Sean Fennessey? It is very gray. I wrote down it's a noir with no sex or crime. An imperfect hero who lives in the shadows. It's also a melodrama without any love. Michael Clayton does not have a love interest.
23:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
23:05 Sean Fennessey? He's divorced. They don't introduce anyone in a kind of baggy side story to say, oh, well, he's living for something. He does have a son, but even the way that Clooney interacts with the young actor who plays his son, there is a kind of like harshness, a flatness. He has one moment where he really, you know, kind of semi inspires him by telling him what he is not. But they don't try to force you to love this character in any way, which I think is very admirable. And the sort of thing that in most movies kind of gets noted to death, like, we need to have a moment where we're really rooting for him.
23:39 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
23:40 Sean Fennessey? And even in the moment that they give us to root for him, where we have this triumphant, like, yes, he won.
23:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
23:45 Sean Fennessey? At the very end of the movie, the camera just trails him all the way to his cab and him kind of considering, reflecting, thinking about
23:55 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
23:55 Sean Fennessey? what he's lost, who he is in this world, how he's spent his life, how he's gotten himself entangled in all of these gross problems of the world.
24:06 Speaker 01 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
24:36 Speaker 02 Coca-Cola. For the big, for the small, the short and the tall. Peacemakers, risk takers. For the optimists, pessimists. For long distance love. For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you.
25:06 Speaker 05 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
25:18 Speaker 06 Pricing participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
25:22 Sean Fennessey? It's also kind of a Samurai movie.
25:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, you put, I, this was a good observation.
25:26 Sean Fennessey? You know, a man alone, he's got his own code. He lives within a system that he has to abide by, but until he decides to break their rules to abide by his own rules. You can really see Gilroy using that framework or like, like a knight's tale kind of framework here too. Very classical kind of writing and, and, and, uh, screen imagination that's going into it. That I think just like makes me feel, uh, very seen. You know, these are like the kind of movies that I really, really like, but it doesn't do it in any kind of showy way. Like the filmmaking style is very simple and clean. You know, it's very intimate. We're really on top of the characters a lot of time. Like you said, it's mostly shot in rooms, a lot of singles going to guys' faces.
26:10 Sean Fennessey? There's that moment when Sidney Pollack's character and Michael Akew's character and, uh, Michael Clayton are talking about his new contract and the $80,000 bonus. It's like very tense, very funny.
26:21 Amanda Dobbins? He's an asshole. Yeah, oh, it's so good.
26:23 Sean Fennessey? I love that scene. It's like, there's nothing, you don't have to see that on the big screen to get it, which is maybe a little different from a lot of the movies that we'll pick here today where a lot of them will be grand cinematic achievements.
26:35 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
26:35 Sean Fennessey? This is like, this would have been jammed into a TV show now and it would have fucking sucked.
26:40 Amanda Dobbins? True, for a number of reasons, including it wouldn't have, you know, it wouldn't be like built within an inch of its life. And I mean that in a perfect way, like not a wasted moment. Everyone says the exact right thing in like, not a bad line delivery, not perfect, but...
26:58 Amanda Dobbins? This, if you turned this into some like grand, you know, camera like exercise, it would take away from what it actually is, which is people saying truths and not quite truths to each other in like exciting but depressing ways. There is like, there is like, there is a grittiness and a like a actual literal grayness in, in palette to the film that is intentional and I think communicates kind of the, the darkness and the, there's, you know, one great, like what I call the working girl shot of like Clooney
27:38 Amanda Dobbins? alone in one tiny box in a, in an office building where you can see all the other office buildings. So it, there is visual consideration. It's just like not getting in the way.
27:50 Sean Fennessey? No, totally. You're totally right, though. The way that a lot of the film takes place at night when it isn't at night, it's, there are no sunny days here. It's all overcast. It's a certain time of the year. That's all intentional. Um, he's always in a black suit, never really in anything else. Uh, I think the film's legacy, in addition to the meme stuff is fascinating to, because Tom Wilkinson's performance is a big part of the legacy because the other significant meme is the, is the bad ads.
28:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
28:19 Sean Fennessey? And I think this is an interesting, complicated portrayal of mental health at a time when maybe we didn't talk about it in the same way that we do now, where, you know, Michael characterizes him as a manic depressive, the Arthur character, who is this wizardly lawyer who's been a trial lawyer for many years at this very Tony firm and is hugely relied upon to power through these big cases for the firm, but is also not well and medicated and.
28:50 Sean Fennessey? Becomes, has a kind of spiritual breaking point with this case. Falls in love with a participant in the case, a young woman who's testifying, portrayed by Merritt Weaver. We see on video him having a kind of breakdown where he strips his clothes off, professes his love to her.
29:07 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
29:07 Sean Fennessey? We later see him at other times giving these kind of whirling dervish speeches. He's got this incredibly active mind.
29:13 Amanda Dobbins? The, I mean, the movie opens with just voiceover of one of his, you know, great monologues that is also clearly an episode of sorts.
29:25 Amanda Dobbins? And just set to really beautifully shot chilling portraits of corporate conference rooms. So, and people walking down, down halls.
29:35 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. Does it remind you of anything?
29:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, no, not at all.
29:40 Sean Fennessey? And the baguette moment, the meeting.
29:45 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
29:46 Sean Fennessey? You know, it's, it's a very funny thing to post on social media, but it's a very sad and hard and difficult scene because, you know, Arthur clearly a mentor to Michael Clayton.
29:55 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
29:55 Sean Fennessey? I had not really clocked this previously, but there's a moment when we're in Michael's office and the camera pans to a photo on his desk and it's Arthur and his son together. And you realize that these are really like, these people mean a lot to each other, you know?
30:10 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that scene when the, and I mean, this is just like perfect. This is why Gilroy is one of the great screenwriters, but the, this son is really into this like Game of Thrones-esque book.
30:21 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
30:22 Amanda Dobbins? That he keeps trying to.
30:22 Sean Fennessey? Realm quest?
30:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, that he keeps trying to get his dad to read, but instead Arthur and the son end up on the phone and the son is explaining this idea, like the, the ideas of this fantasy world to this person who is clearly going through like a real mental episode, but also like the themes are speaking to him. And it's, but they also have like some sort of emotional connection. It's, it's, it's pretty devastating.
30:52 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. And Wilkinson is amazing in this movie. We shouldn't not have fun at the expense of the character, but the character is like, is really a tragic figure.
31:00 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
31:00 Sean Fennessey? And someone who in theory, I think stands in for people who. Are truth tellers, you know, and even though he's got this 30 year record of defending big corporations, ultimately, he has this moment of realization as he gets clear of, you know, what his medication, I guess. And I was trying to locate like what the movie is really trying to say about that. Like, is it trying to say that if you are in this line of work, you need to delude yourself to kind of continue on and doing that kind of work? Is it actually his break is problematic and, you know, dangerous? And so he is just this sort of like Shakespearean fall from grace type? Like, the movie is a little ambiguous about that.
31:40 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, intentionally. I don't think it's trying to give you an answer one way or the other of this is how you should feel about, I, I, I think now bipolar is the, is the, is the term for, but you know, again, it was 2007. So I'm, I'm not up on my, on my psych book. Anyway, it, it, it is about, I, I think the tragedy is the point. And I think that it's a series of characters who are all confronted both with limitations or setbacks and also the opportunity to, to do something like more right or less right?
32:24 Amanda Dobbins? And how are they each negotiating it in their own way? And his is like a, just like a deep tragedy. And even that scene, I mean, like, is holding the, the baguettes, again, when this movie has visual flourishes, it has visual flourishes, like all time. But that scene itself, the two, the two actors just going at each other, as Zach said last night when we were watching, like, top five movie scenes of the, it is heartbreaking, it is incisive, it is, I'm not the enemy. Well, then who are you? You know? And it turns, even for that character in a way that is a little scary and definitely sad. So, I don't know. I think the ambiguity is the point.
33:08 Sean Fennessey? The other thing that I wanted to note about the movie is, like a lot of Gilroy's work. It's very interested in the kind of the intersection of big power and working class people. And Michael Clayton, whenever we get sucked out of the world of the law firm, he basically gets sucked into his family. So he's got this brother who's struggling with addiction, who caused the flame out of his restaurant. He's got a brother-in-law who's a cop. He's got a sister-in-law, I think they're in Jersey, house in Jersey, or maybe it's in upstate New York, I can't recall where they are. And he's the son of a cop, too. And when he's around his family, everybody calls him Mickey.
33:44 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
33:45 Sean Fennessey? And when he's in the office, everybody calls him Michael. There's very small choices.
33:48 Amanda Dobbins? Is it not Long Island? It's not like Queens toward Long Island? Because I think at some point, because his detective brother ends up helping him out in a couple places, and they say, I knew your brother out in the...
34:02 Sean Fennessey? It might have just missed it. It might even be Long Island. Let's just say it's very familiar terrain as I watch the movie.
34:08 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, yeah.
34:09 Sean Fennessey? These are very familiar kinds of guys. But I like this kind of, this world and that world. And, you know, Michael, in theory, being the one who got out and got away from the working class lifestyle, but is in fact more in the shit than anybody who sees the worst possible things. You know, the famous sequence early in the film when he's summoned to Dennis O'Hare's home where he and Julie, he's just struck a man in the street while driving. There's a great sequence for a variety of reasons. I love it. Julie White, narrating a line of dialogue, crushing as, you know, his very disturbed ex-wife. What is it she's telling us? Was he out having an affair with someone? Was he drinking and driving? Was he just ignoring her and she had told him not to drive that way for many years?
34:53 Amanda Dobbins? Right. Is she just pissed off because she understands what's coming even as he's sitting there screaming, what are you gonna do?
35:00 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
35:01 Amanda Dobbins? How are you gonna fix it?
35:02 Sean Fennessey? Yes. Gilroy doesn't give the words to that scene.
35:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:06 Sean Fennessey? But you can draw your own conclusions and it works so well. And Dennis O'Hare also...
35:11 Sean Fennessey? I think Gilroy writes a very good angry dialogue.
35:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:13 Sean Fennessey? And
35:14 Amanda Dobbins? I don't like where this is going.
35:17 Sean Fennessey? Um, and he's wonderful. And Clayton, you see that it's a guy who not just is a fixer, but a fixer who's fixed a lot.
35:24 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:24 Sean Fennessey? And is sort of exasperated by people like this.
35:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:27 Sean Fennessey? And sick of his line of work at this point in his life. So like all of this great stuff, this is characterization. All this stuff is communicated so cleanly and so quickly at the very beginning of the movie.
35:37 Amanda Dobbins? Right. And culminating in the immortal line, I'm not a miracle worker. I'm a janitor.
35:41 Sean Fennessey? I'm a janitor. Um, this movie has one of the great if, what ifs in modern movie history.
35:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
35:47 Sean Fennessey? In 2012, Denzel Washington told GQ magazine that he was offered the part of Michael Clayton and that he turned it down because he was nervous to work with a first time filmmaker in Gilroy, even though Gilroy had written, I think, 10 or 12 scripts by this point. Um, what do you think the movie is with Denzel?
36:06 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, it's, it's silly to say that it doesn't work as well because Denzel is one of our great living actors. And you do think of charm and charisma with Denzel times 1,000. Like, you know, as you, as you do with Clooney. So you know that Denzel could pare it back. But by 2007 even, he's one too awesome. Like he is Denzel, you know? So do you have Denzel? Like, are you, are you bringing your Denzel associations to the, the role? And you were sort of to Clooney, but Clooney isn't as
36:50 Amanda Dobbins? he's not Denzel in, in every way.
36:52 Sean Fennessey? It's funny because the thunderous stuff, you know, he can do really well. Let's just take a look at what Denzel was doing in 2007.
36:58 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, but like the thunderous stuff, Clooney, Clooney raises his voice and Clooney is like, is, is fighting back butt from a place of
37:09 Amanda Dobbins? Just again of weakness, you know, like these are people who don't have it all together.
37:17 Amanda Dobbins? And when Denzel like brings the thunder, you don't, you know, no one, no one can match him.
37:24 Sean Fennessey? Right, right. You need somebody who is a little bit more recessed. In 2007, Denzel Washington made American Gangster, and he also directed and starred in The Great Debaters. So this was a very big year for him.
37:36 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
37:36 Sean Fennessey? But neither of those movies did what Michael Clayton did. We won't do a lot of what ifs on this show. That's really more the terrain of the rewatchables, but that one is so famous and so fascinating. Closing thoughts?
37:50 Amanda Dobbins? How are you feeling about this at 25?
37:52 Sean Fennessey? Not great. I hope that-
37:53 Amanda Dobbins? You want to explain to people why it's 25?
37:57 Sean Fennessey? Uh, well, one of the reasons was I wanted to start with a banger.
37:59 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, exactly. That's, I mean, that's like, that's, it's what's important to me is like, sometimes you gotta start, when you're making a list, really when you're doing anything. It's just like a tip for, I don't know, event planning, list making, life work in general. Bring the people in.
38:18 Sean Fennessey? This is a tasty amuse-bouche for 25 for 25. I think that there is something in the competence, competency porn of the movie that is very satisfying. The movie's runtime is one hour and 59, 59 minutes and 55 seconds. It's almost like it is intentionally a shade under two hours to show you, look what I can do in this time. A lot of the movies, we'll talk about it a lot longer than this movie. And that's okay. I love a long movie.
38:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
38:46 Sean Fennessey? But this is representative of a very specific kind of Hollywood stratagem that is no longer really present anywhere and that I miss dearly.
38:57 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
38:57 Sean Fennessey? I'd always rooted for Clooney. I always liked Clooney. I always felt like he made really weird choices with the one or two exceptions all the way up until this point. This is the time to me, not Sirianni, not even Ocean's Eleven, because he's really, you know, he's got Brad Pitt and Julia Roberts, and he's kind of leaning on a lot of people in those movies, even though he's great.
39:14 Amanda Dobbins? He's working with them.
39:15 Sean Fennessey? He's working with them. He's, he's, he's a great screen presence. This is a great screen performance.
39:21 Amanda Dobbins? Agree.
39:22 Sean Fennessey? And I think this is a wonderful movie. Will we regret? This place, do you think you'll regret it?
39:28 Amanda Dobbins? I do think that we will, we will get people interested with this. And that's, and that's the point.
39:33 Sean Fennessey? Mission accomplished.
39:34 Amanda Dobbins? And yeah, and also, listen, like, we love this movie and are kind of mad at ourselves, but this is the game.
39:40 Sean Fennessey? This is the game. I believe we'll be back next week with number 24.
39:43 Amanda Dobbins? Oh, exciting.
39:44 Sean Fennessey? So we need to record that soon. Thanks to our producer Bobby Wagner and our video producer Jack Sanders. We'll be back later this week on this pod with a new draft, 1982, with a special guest who I won't announce.
39:58 Amanda Dobbins? Oh.
39:58 Sean Fennessey? We'll see you then.
40:12 Speaker 02 Coca-Cola. For the big, for the small, the short, and the tall. Peacemakers, risk takers. For the optimists, pessimists. For long distance love. For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you.
40:42 Speaker 05 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
40:54 Speaker 06 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
Previous ‘The Electric State’ Is a Netflix Nightmare. Plus, 10 (Better) Movies We Missed. Next The 1982 Movie Draft Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated