Pod Insights Crime Weekly S3 Ep350: Murder on the Eve of Halloween | The Killing of Dr. Jablin (Part 1) About this episode Just after sunrise on October 30, 2004, police in a Richmond, Virginia suburb responded after a neighbor walking his dogs discovered the body of 52-year-old University of Richmond professor Dr. Fred Jablin lying in his driveway. He’d been shot multiple times as he went outside to grab his newspaper, something he did every morning. Inside the house, officers found his three children - still asleep, unaware of what had happened just beyond their front door. As police began to search the neighborhood for clues, one name surfaced again and again: Fred’s ex-wife, Piper Rountree. Their marriage had been volatile, their divorce bitter, and their custody battle filled with accusations that seemed to have no end. When detectives started tracing Piper’s movements before and after the shooting, they uncovered a series of bizarre and calculated choices - each one more unhinged than the last. And soon, it became clear that the story of Fred Jablin’s murder wasn’t just about one act of violence - it was about everything that led to it. Try our coffee!! - www. CriminalCoffeeCo.comBecome a Patreon member -- > ソ https://www.patreon.com/CrimeWeeklyShop for your Crime Weekly gear here --> ソ https://crimeweeklypodcast.com/shopYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/c/CrimeWeeklyPodcastWebsite: CrimeWeeklyPodcast.comInstagram: @CrimeWeeklyPodTwitter: @CrimeWeeklyPodFacebook: @CrimeWeeklyPodADS:1. https://www. LittleSpoon.com/CrimeWeekly50 - Use code CRIMEWEEKLY50 for 50% off your first online order!2. https://www. FactorMeals.com/CrimeWeekly50Off - Use code CRIMEWEEKLY50OFF for 50% off your first box and FREE breakfast for a year!3. https://www. RocketMoney.com/CrimeWeekly - Cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals today!4.https://www. PDSDebt.com/CrimeWeekly - Get your FREE debt assessment and find the best option for you today!5. https://www. HelixSleep.com/CrimeWeekly - Get 25% off sitewide! Select our podcast after you check out to let them know we sent you!
Transcript 12,194 words · 2 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:12 Stephanie Harlowe? Just after sunrise on October 30th, 2004, police in a Richmond, Virginia suburb responded after a neighbor walking his dogs discovered the body of 52-year-old University of Richmond professor Dr. Fred Jablin laying in his driveway. He'd been shot multiple times as he went outside to grab his newspaper, which is something he did every morning. Inside the house, officers found his three children still asleep, unaware of what had happened just beyond their front door. As police began to search the neighborhood for clues, one name surfaced again and again: Fred's ex-wife, Piper Rountree. Their marriage had been volatile, their divorce bitter, and their custody battle filled with accusations that seemed to have no end.
0:55 Stephanie Harlowe? When detectives started tracing Piper's movements before and after the shooting, they uncovered a series of bizarre and calculated choices, each one more unhinged than the last. And soon it became clear that the story of Fred Jablin's murder wasn't just about one act of violence. It was about everything that led to it.
1:24 Stephanie Harlowe? Okay, so we're covering this case because it happened the day before Halloween. We are in the Halloween time. And because the victim, Fred, he loved Halloween. He was the guy who went all out with decorations, parties, the whole nine. And that contrast, like the joy of the season against the reality of what happened in his driveway on the eve of his favorite time of year, it makes the story hit harder right now. So that's why we're talking about this. It's a, you know, kind of timely. Case, and there's a lot of stuff that happened in this case that also gives it that sort of Halloween, like what's hiding beneath the mask vibe. So in order to understand what happened to the end, we have to go back to the beginning.
2:08 Derrick Levasseur? As we always do.
2:09 Stephanie Harlowe? As we do. And Frederick Mark Jablin was born on July 23rd, 1952, in Queens, New York, to his parents Irving and Mildred Jablin. His father was an accountant and his mother worked as a bookkeeper. Together, they raised Fred and his older brother Mike in the community of Floral Park. Fred was known to be extremely smart and curious, unassuming, and slight in build, but he had a sharp sense of humor and a contagious love of life that made people feel instantly at ease around him. Fred earned his PhD in organizational communication from Purdue University in 1977 and quickly established himself as an expert in the emerging field. His research was innovative and influential, and he went on to win multiple awards for his work. Eventually, he joined the faculty
2:54 Stephanie Harlowe? at the University of Texas at Austin, where he built a career that was as impactful as it was fulfilling. Fred genuinely loved being a teacher and never turned down a moment to meet with students and discuss research projects. He also happily gave out his home number to anyone who needed help outside of class. So it's no surprise that students loved Fred and often named his class as their favorite. One student later said, quote, "He's one of the most enjoyable, knowledgeable, and engaging professors," end quote. As Fred settled into his career, he bought a home in South Austin near the Stevenson Nature Preserve. He was thrilled to finally have a place of his own, not just because it was his space, but because he could go all out for Halloween, his favorite holiday. For
3:36 Stephanie Harlowe? Fred, Halloween was a time when you could be someone else for a night, and he believed in doing it right. Every year, he decorated his yard with carved pumpkins, spiders, and cobwebs, and hosted a party that soon became a neighborhood tradition. In the fall of 1981, when Fred was 29, his friend and colleague John introduced him to one of his students, a 21-year-old senior named Piper Rountree. The very next day, John mentioned to Piper that he and Fred were going to an event, and Piper asked if she could join them. John said yes, but when he couldn't make it, he asked Fred to still meet her. They both went as planned, and it wasn't long before they realized there was a real connection there. Piper Ann Rountree was born on January 6, 1960, in Japan, where her father, Dr.
4:21 Stephanie Harlowe? William Rountree, was stationed as a surgeon in the Air Force. Her mother, Betty, stayed home with their five children, and Piper was the youngest. So she was close to her whole family, but she shared an especially close bond with her sister Tina, who was eight years older than her. They were so close that they referred to each other as soul sisters. After their father retired, the family settled in Texas, near the Mexico border, where Piper quickly found her place. She was bright and ambitious and involved in nearly everything in high school, from the National Honor Society to tennis and choir. She graduated in 1978 and left that same fall for the University of Texas at Austin, where she majored in speech and German. Despite being very ambitious in her studies, Piper was also known to be spontaneous and
5:04 Stephanie Harlowe? free spirited, the opposite of Fred, but not in a bad way. Fred's friend John told Katherine Casey, author of "Die, My Love," that they each, "found something in the other that they lacked." Piper brought lightness and warmth into Fred's structured life, and Fred gave her a sense of stability and care. He supported her financially and emotionally, and he catered to her every move. It was the kind of attention that Piper loved, and it became the foundation of their relationship. So within just a few months of meeting, Piper moved in with Fred. She continued her studies at the University of Texas, and in the spring of 1982, she graduated with bachelor's degrees in both communication and German. Not long after, she was awarded a year-long scholarship to study abroad in Germany.
5:49 Stephanie Harlowe? It should have been a dream opportunity, and in many ways it was. But while she was there, Piper started having an affair with another man. Fred found out, and he was obviously devastated, but instead of ending the relationship, he flew to Germany and tried to, I guess, reason with Piper. He begged her to reconsider, and she agreed to continue dating him. And when her scholarship ended in the spring of 1983, she moved back in with him in Austin. That fall, Piper started law school in San Antonio, about an hour and a half away from Austin. She moved there, maintaining a long-distance relationship with Fred, who was actually paying for her tuition. So... Fred has been financially and emotionally taking care of Piper since the beginning of their
6:34 Stephanie Harlowe? relationship. She goes to Germany, has an affair.
6:38 Derrick Levasseur? Cheats on him.
6:38 Stephanie Harlowe? Cheats on him, has an affair. He goes to Germany in, you know, a grand romantic gesture like, you're this important to me. I'm flying to a different country. I love you. You know, pick me, basically. Choose me, pick me. Yep. She says yes. She comes back to Texas, starts living with him again. Now she's, she's going to school in San Antonio. She's doing law school there, which by the way, no tuition to college is cheap, but law school tuition, definitely not.
7:07 Derrick Levasseur? Nope.
7:07 Stephanie Harlowe? Fred's paying for that after the affair, after he had to beg her to choose him. He's paying for that still, right? So.
7:16 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, he's better than me. I would have been.
7:18 Stephanie Harlowe? I don't know if it's better or just more naive.
7:20 Derrick Levasseur? I'm more, more forgiving. I'll say that because that would have been it. See ya.
7:25 Stephanie Harlowe? I know. Right? I mean.
7:27 Derrick Levasseur? That would have been it.
7:28 Stephanie Harlowe? I know. And listen, there's, I'm not trying to judge anybody here. There have been many stories, many cases where, you know, you're in a relationship, one or both partners has, you know, an affair on the side. And then because of that affair and because of the way things goes, they're like, hey, we were meant to be together. We've realized, this made me realize that it's you I want. And they go on to live very happy lives. I don't think that's the case in this, this story. So.
7:58 Derrick Levasseur? No, it was one sided.
7:59 Stephanie Harlowe? Very, very one sided.
8:00 Derrick Levasseur? It was one person committing themselves completely, providing financial and emotional support and the other person betraying that trust.
8:08 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah. And the way that it's kind of, the way it kind of seems is it's like, well, Fred brought structure and stability and safety to Piper, paid for everything for her, made sure she was always emotionally supported, financially supported. Piper was fun, you know? Piper brought fun to Fred's life. It's like, that's the kind of fun I don't need personally, but.
8:28 Derrick Levasseur? Got them on his toes.
8:29 Stephanie Harlowe? Kept him on his toes. That's for sure. He had a very regimented, you know, controlled life, everything in its place. And suddenly she came in like a hurricane and brought some fun.
8:41 Derrick Levasseur? Which is so interesting because that is the case a lot of times where someone who is successful has all their stuff together. It's like you know it's not good for you, but you just can't get enough of it.
8:52 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
8:52 Derrick Levasseur? And that that it kind of excites you almost.
8:55 Stephanie Harlowe? Because everything else in your life makes sense and and has this like very, you know, monotone quality to it, which is great, but then at the same time.
9:03 Derrick Levasseur? It's also the thrill of the chase too, like you want what you can't have type thing. I don't know, man. I don't know. It's like humans, man. We're all messed up.
9:10 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, you're like, oh, this little this little lightning burst came into my life and suddenly I'm electrified. But what I think that people don't understand is that that's really anxiety that you're feeling this excitement to be around somebody or something that destabilizes you and kind of makes you it's it's dopamine because it's something different, something unique, but it's also a level of anxiety. Like, don't tell me that Fred, after he found out she went to Germany and was cheating on him, that that there was an anxiety forever in him after that constant worry.
9:38 Derrick Levasseur? But it's kind of like also, I don't know, we have a large majority of the people who watch the show are women. So I ask all of you, like, what what is it the whole like, oh, I like the bad boy. I know there's easier people to be with that are, you know, trustworthy and safe, but I like the bad boy. How many times have I heard that?
9:59 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
10:00 Derrick Levasseur? Sorry, I just like the bad boy. So what is it?
10:02 Stephanie Harlowe? I don't think it's the bad boy. I think it's the destabilization that that they bring to your life. You know, you know how everything's gonna go. You can look like somebody like Fred would have been able to look at the next 10, 20 years of his life and know exactly where he was going to be working, where he was going to be living, what he was going to do on Halloween every year, where everything in his house was, where everything in his office was. And then suddenly Piper pops in, you know, like I said, a tornado of chaos. And he's like, huh, well, this is different. You know, this is different. I like this.
10:31 Derrick Levasseur? Laying down in the comments, let us know. Are you team safety blanket or are you team? Bad boy. I want to know. I want to know where our audience is. I want to, I want to get inside your heads. What are we dealing with?
10:41 Stephanie Harlowe? Well, there's, that's, that's a, that's a hard one. There's a lot of reasons for that. I think a lot of it comes from childhood too. I think sometimes people search for something that, that feels familiar to them, but familiar isn't always good, right?
10:53 Derrick Levasseur? Yep.
10:54 Stephanie Harlowe? So that October, the two got married. So even after all of this, he's paying for her college and he's asking her to spend the rest of their lives together. And Piper later called it a whim, saying Fred suggested they marry that weekend and she simply agreed. After the wedding, Fred stayed in Austin, more devoted to Piper than ever, because she's his wife now. But things soon began to unravel. Piper started revealing sides of herself that Fred hadn't seen before. We're going to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
11:27 Stephanie Harlowe? All right. So we're back and Fred and Piper, they get married on a whim, she says. And then, once they're married, as is the case a lot of the time, by the way, once, you want somebody who's hiding things and wearing a mask, once they sort of see now you're locked in legally, or otherwise, they'll sort of start showing you little bits of themselves here and there, because it's hard to wear a mask for an extended period of time. So Fred learns that Piper's been struggling with bulimia and that she's taking this stimulant. It's called fentermine and it's a stimulant medication used for short-term weight loss in adults who are obese or overweight with health risks. It's meant to be used in a
12:12 Stephanie Harlowe? healthy way, like the doctor's like, you should be exercising and eating well while you're taking this. But it's definitely still a controlled substance. It works by basically stimulating the central nervous system and affecting brain neurotransmitters to decrease appetite, increase heart rate and boost energy. It's also important to know that this medication is intended to be used for short-term use. You're not supposed to use it for a long time. It's typically prescribed for a limited period, 12 weeks or less. And yeah, it can have some pretty bad side effects, like most stimulants can. So she's got issues with
12:53 Stephanie Harlowe? bulimia. She's taking this stimulant medication and according to Fred and other people, she had a pretty big temper. So on top of all of those issues, Piper also stopped doing well in school, which was something new for her. Realizing something was wrong, Fred made a major sacrifice. He put his house in Austin up for rent and moved to San Antonio so he could be there for Piper and he could support her as she continued through law school. You know, and remember, he loved this house. This was his house, his first house that he had on his own. He decked it out for Halloween. He knows all the neighbors. They love him. He's got a great community there. She's just going to school in San Antonio. It's not even her permanent place of residence. And he puts his house up for rent, allows strangers to live in his house.
13:37 Stephanie Harlowe? So he can go to San Antonio and make sure that Piper makes it through law school, right? Because she's kind of slipping here. Her grades are slipping. She's not doing as well. And he's like, hey, I'm her emotional support system. I'm the one who should be there cheering her on, you know, making sure she's accountable. So I'm going to do that. And for two years, Fred made a three-hour round trip commute every day, driving back and forth between his job and their new home in San Antonio.
14:05 Derrick Levasseur? That's love, man. That's love.
14:07 Stephanie Harlowe? Well, his sacrifice worked. And in the spring of 1986, Piper graduated and the couple returned to Austin. Eventually, she landed a position as a prosecutor with the Hayes County District Attorney's Office. And this should have been a great job for Piper. She would have gotten good benefits. She'd have room to grow, a lot of opportunity to learn because she's in the DA's office. So you're going to be able to see all sorts of different types of cases. You're going to be able to see prosecutors at work, defense attorneys at work. You're going to have great mentors and things like that. But we don't know why, within a year, she'd been fired. Like I said, it's unclear what led to her termination.
14:43 Derrick Levasseur? Shocker. Based on just the little bit you've described about Piper so far, she, I'm sorry, didn't come off as a go-getter. It seemed like basically...
14:53 Stephanie Harlowe? Like, maybe not like somebody who's good with commitment.
14:56 Derrick Levasseur? It seemed like Fred got the law degree.
14:58 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
14:58 Derrick Levasseur? If I'm being honest. I'm not trying to discredit her, but it feels like... Fred was a big reason, a big force behind her even finishing.
15:06 Stephanie Harlowe? Her sticking with their relationship, her sticking with getting her law degree, her sticking with anything was sort of Fred persuading her to.
15:13 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if Fred was a part-time attorney because he probably was doing a lot of her schoolwork with her to help her out. I'm sure he was studying, just based on what you're describing, this guy was probably going above and beyond just to make sure she passed.
15:27 Stephanie Harlowe? It was probably exhausting on top of all of his other stuff, right?
15:29 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, yeah. But, but her being on her own, not having him there to hold her hand.
15:34 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, he can't go to work with her and be like, Piper, answer your emails now.
15:38 Derrick Levasseur? And then what happens?
15:39 Stephanie Harlowe? She's done within a year.
15:40 Derrick Levasseur? She's, yup.
15:41 Stephanie Harlowe? And I mean, this, this was pretty par for the course, actually, because Piper had had issues at work throughout the late eighties and into the early nineties. She struggled to hold down a job. She bounced from one job to another and most of them lasted only a year or so before she was let go. Now, during that time period, she and Fred welcomed two children into the world, a daughter named Jocelyn and a son named Paxton. After Paxton's birth, Piper was diagnosed with postpartum depression. She then made a rash decision, withdrawing money from her retirement account and combining it with fourteen hundred dollars of Fred's money to pay for breast implant surgery. Something Fred didn't want her to do as he knew that there were health risks. Plus, she was actively breastfeeding at this time, but Piper didn't listen to his concerns.
16:26 Stephanie Harlowe? She got the surgery and the decision caused tension between them. So this, and I'm sure other things led to Piper and Fred starting to go to marriage counseling. Now, usually you would see, or I don't know usually, but at least in the past, you'd see women getting breast implants and their boyfriends or husbands are like, yeah, yeah, do that. I want you to do it, you know? That's great, but Fred.
16:50 Derrick Levasseur? Listen, I'm all for it when people want to go out there and do it.
16:53 Stephanie Harlowe? They want to do it, they want to do it.
16:53 Derrick Levasseur? Who am I to stop you?
16:54 Stephanie Harlowe? But Fred's like, hey, I don't really want that because I don't need you to look any different. And also there are health issues and also we have two young children who you're still feeding from your body. And this is going to complicate things, like not forever, but at least in the short term, while you're recovering from that. I don't think breastfeeding is something. You're going to be able to do and it really seemed like and this is the kind of the imprint I'm getting from Piper and Fred. She was very selfish. And he initially perceived that as she's fun. She's she's like all over the place, man. What a what a great, what a great girl. I'm just here like her, like her very, you know,
17:35 Stephanie Harlowe? strong stage for her to dance and perform on. But now that they have kids involved, Fred's like, hey, I would really like to see you put our children first. I would really like to see you put someone first for once. And if you weren't going to do it with me, why can't you do it with our kids?
17:49 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, no, I on one hand, I agree with Fred in the sense of like, hey, listen, you're breastfeeding right now. It's been proven apparently that that's better for the children. Would you mind waiting? Would you mind waiting until they're at least done? But as far as him saying, you know, I don't want you to get breast implants because I don't think you need them. Well, it's not for you, Fred.
18:09 Stephanie Harlowe? He didn't say he didn't think she needed it. He said that there's health, like health complications, potentially, things like that.
18:15 Derrick Levasseur? Same thing. No, I mean, ultimately, if she feels insecure about something, she wants them done. She should be allowed to do it. And Fred, by the way, you signed up for the marriage. What's yours is hers. So it's not technically your money anymore. It's her money as well. So I think there's a it's not as clear cut on this part. I haven't liked a lot of what you've said about Piper leading up to this point. So this is the one thing I'll say where it seems like Fred potentially felt like, hey, because I'm the main provider and I'm doing these things, I should have say over what you're doing with your body. I don't if that was the case, I disagree.
18:50 Stephanie Harlowe? Maybe not say with what you're doing with your body, maybe say with what you're doing with your money. Because what do you what do you think about her draining her retirement account? I kind of
18:59 Derrick Levasseur? No, I don't. I don't agree with it. But this is all I know what we're talking about tonight, right? But we the reason I think we do what we do and why people come back is because we're honest. Like, it's hard to feel guilty for Fred about this. Because Fred seems like a very intelligent guy. And he saw the warning signs. We talked about going overseas. He really has nobody to blame but himself for being in this situation. There's no way that he saw these these signs and didn't realize.
19:29 Stephanie Harlowe? This is a selfish person who does what she wants.
19:32 Derrick Levasseur? What he was getting himself into. So, you know, when you're selling or renting out your house, traveling three hours and she's just letting you do it, not pushing back, being like, no, I'm an adult. I should be able to do this on my own. You shouldn't have to sacrifice your well-being and your sleep every day to appease me. Maybe don't marry her. Maybe don't have two children with her. Now, you made your bed, you gotta sleep in it. That happens to a lot of people, but they don't end up dead. So, that's the difference here.
20:00 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I think it was a lot more fun for Fred when it was just the two of them.
20:03 Derrick Levasseur? Agreed.
20:04 Stephanie Harlowe? But then you now have, hey, she got a law degree, a great expense to you, both your time, your money, and now you have children together. So, it's like, okay, she didn't do well in the law field, but now she's the mother to my children. And you would hope that this person would grow up a little bit, but that doesn't happen. And so she's now being financially irresponsible, draining her retirement funds. Because I believe, yeah, do whatever you want to your body, but it's irresponsible when you have a family to provide for and you have a future to save for, and you're draining your retirement fund to get breast implants. It's showing like, yeah, you're not, you're not making super good decisions.
20:40 Derrick Levasseur? But it wasn't like she was putting on a mask beforehand.
20:43 Stephanie Harlowe? Not really, like somewhat, but not to that extent.
20:45 Derrick Levasseur? No, no. Based on what you've described and what you've said tonight, it seems like the signs were there.
20:50 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, absolutely. And I think he's seeing that now. Like I said, it's all fun and games when it's just the two of you, but now you have children involved and this person who used to be this, you know, streak of lightning is now kind of setting everything on fire and it's not great. So, they go to counseling and eventually Piper tried to return to the workforce by opening her own practice, but it didn't go as planned. She decided she wanted to stay home with the children instead. So Fred took on consulting work to make that possible. So, he's working his job at the university and now he's taking on another side job doing consulting. And it wasn't something that he wanted to do, but he did it anyway so that Piper could have what she wanted. And I think there was a part of him who was, that was like, she's probably better off at home.
21:32 Stephanie Harlowe? Like clearly she can't go out into the world and take the initiative to buckle down and make something out of herself alone independently. So I'm gonna have to continue taking care of her. Even then, though, this stay at home mom thing didn't last long because Piper started complaining that Fred wasn't home enough and she was unhappy with that. So in 1994 Fred accepted a higher paying position at the University of Richmond's New Jepson School and the family moved into a house at 1515 Hearth Glow Lane located in a quiet middle-class suburb. The following year Piper gave birth to their third and final child, a daughter named Callie. She again suffered from postpartum depression
22:17 Stephanie Harlowe? and she began drinking heavily, eventually becoming known in the neighborhood for always having wine in her hand. Ugh, that's not what you want to be known for. So neighbors found Piper to be unpredictable. Sometimes she was fully engaged, playing with the kids and planning activities and other times she'd be shut down completely, staying in bed for hours while her very young children fended for themselves. Fred grew so concerned with this behavior that he hired nannies, but Piper always fired them. She, however, remembered things differently. She later claimed, quote, "I was dedicated to the children, doing everything that I could for them. I cooked everything, I mean absolutely from scratch. I canned, went berry hunting. My neighbor referred to me as the Martha Stewart of motherhood."
22:59 Stephanie Harlowe? End quote. Which is like, yo, why are you putting all this pressure on yourself? Okay? Why? You don't have to make everything from scratch. You don't have to be in the kitchen rolling out bread in the flour from scratch. You don't have to be canning. We have grocery stores. You've got three kids.
23:16 Derrick Levasseur? We have Wild Grain.
23:17 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, we got Wild Grain. You've got three young kids. That's a, three full-time jobs, all on its own.
23:24 Derrick Levasseur? Are you projecting right now? Are you kinda like speaking?
23:27 Stephanie Harlowe? Because it's cra- I don't, when people do this, when mothers do this and they're like, oh my god, I'm so exhausted. I got up at five to do a sourdough starter so that my family could have fresh sourdough bread for dinner and then I made soup from scratch and I did this and I'm just so tired and they start to get resentful. But it's like, you're kind of bringing this on yourself. Do those things later.
23:50 Derrick Levasseur? Stephanie's over here providing Lunchables in the morning.
23:53 Stephanie Harlowe? Right. Do those things later in life. When your kids are a little older, when they're in school and you've got all day by yourself to play music and make your sourdough bread and can your- Blueberries, whatever. You don't have to put all of that on yourself.
24:06 Derrick Levasseur? No fresh sourdough bread in the morning?
24:08 Stephanie Harlowe? Now they get it, but not then when they were babies, absolute. I could barely shower.
24:13 Derrick Levasseur? I'm gonna ask them, I'll be like, when's the last time your mom made you a bread?
24:16 Stephanie Harlowe? I have a bread maker, so it's not hard to do.
24:18 Derrick Levasseur? When's the last time you made a bread?
24:20 Stephanie Harlowe? I don't know, two weeks ago. I love bread.
24:22 Derrick Levasseur? Did you really? Okay, that's, that's more recent than I ever.
24:25 Stephanie Harlowe? Also, to be fair, it's not hard.
24:26 Derrick Levasseur? I don't know what a bread maker is.
24:27 Stephanie Harlowe? It's just like a machine. It's like an appliance and you put everything in there and then it like raises it for you. Yeah, it does everything for you. It's amazing.
24:34 Derrick Levasseur? Okay.
24:35 Stephanie Harlowe? But, but like, when they were kids, when they were babies, man, I couldn't even shower. I didn't even know my own name half the time. And she's suffering from postpartum depression, right? After the birth of her first two kids and her, her third and final daughter. So like your mental health has to be more important than.
24:51 Derrick Levasseur? Not only for you, but for your kids.
24:52 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, within thinking.
24:53 Derrick Levasseur? I mean, crazy.
24:54 Stephanie Harlowe? And, and whose perspective is this, right? So on one hand, we got people being like, yo, this, this chick was out there. She's always got a glass of wine in her hand. And she's kind of like, sometimes a good mother, but sometimes she's completely disassociated. And Piper's like, no, I was amazing. My, my neighbor called me the Martha Stewart of motherhood. I was canning my own stuff and hanging my clothes on, on clotheslines and stuff. So who knows what's true? Maybe it was both true. Maybe when Piper was on, she was on 110%. And then when, when she got burnt out, she's in bed for days because of course, yeah, you're doing a lot. You're taking on a lot. Especially because Fred's not home that often, because now he's working at the college and he's, you know, trying to take side jobs. You guys are going to counseling.
25:38 Stephanie Harlowe? Very stressful, very stressful. I'm getting anxious thinking about this. It's, it's very stressful. So let's take a quick break and we will come right back.
25:50 Stephanie Harlowe? By 1996, the couple returned to counseling. Piper said she felt unappreciated and ignored and accused her husband Fred of keeping her on a financial leash. Which I think you kind of need that, Piper. I think you kind of needed a financial leash, but she wanted control of the money. So Fred handed it over, right? Hoping that this would help, but it didn't. Because over the course of the next three years, Piper secretly ran up $32,000 in debt.
26:18 Stephanie Harlowe? And you know, we talked about wild grain in this episode and now we're going to talk about PDS that because that's what Piper and Fred could have really used after.
26:26 Derrick Levasseur? This was not planned.
26:27 Stephanie Harlowe? No, this is what they really could have used after her.
26:30 Derrick Levasseur? Maybe some rocket money.
26:31 Stephanie Harlowe? Three year shopping spree. Yeah. So then in early 1999, Piper began seeing a psychiatrist, Dr. Steven Welton. During her sessions, she painted Fred as a cruel husband while also admitting to cheating on him occasionally, something Fred didn't know anything about. He knew about the affair in Germany before they were married. He didn't know that stuff like that was still going on. So Dr. Welton ended up diagnosing Piper with a possible mood disorder and prescribed Adderall, later adding medication for depression and anxiety. Now around this time Fred found out about the $32,000 Piper had racked up and he told her she needed to find a job and to help pay the debt back. So Piper took over an
27:12 Stephanie Harlowe? office from an attorney preparing to retire. But there was just one little problem. She wasn't licensed to practice law in Virginia. Someone found out and a complaint was made to the bar association. They told Piper she needed to pass the bar in Virginia. So Fred paid $3,000 for a review course and hired help for the kids so that Piper could focus on that. But what she didn't do, Piper, she didn't end up studying. She didn't end up focusing on that while she had help with the kids. She ended up failing. So she fell into another depression and blamed everything and everyone but herself. She also started criticizing Fred for every little thing, including planning a family trip to Disney World. Not because they didn't have money for a trip, but because she
27:53 Stephanie Harlowe? considered Disney to be quote commonplace, end quote. It wasn't good enough for Piper. Disney wasn't good enough for Piper. That was where the commoners and the peasants go, not Piper. So.
28:06 Derrick Levasseur? Well, she just became an enemy of mine.
28:08 Stephanie Harlowe? Right. I love Disney World and Universal Studios.
28:10 Derrick Levasseur? Who doesn't love Disney?
28:11 Stephanie Harlowe? I love it.
28:12 Derrick Levasseur? Going back in a couple of weeks, you just got back.
28:13 Stephanie Harlowe? Got back from Universal, yeah.
28:15 Derrick Levasseur? I'm going to Disney end of this month and I'm excited. So Piper.
28:19 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, Piper.
28:20 Derrick Levasseur? We're no longer friends.
28:21 Stephanie Harlowe? We don't, we aren't defending you anymore.
28:23 Derrick Levasseur? I wasn't upset with you until you started bashing Disney.
28:26 Stephanie Harlowe? So I, yeah, I find that to be, and I get it, like amusement parks, stuff like that. It can be like a lot. It's very overstimulating. There's a lot happening, but to refer.
28:36 Derrick Levasseur? Has Piper seen the ticket prices? It's no longer for the middle-class people.
28:41 Stephanie Harlowe? I know. People are like getting second mortgages on their homes to go to Disney.
28:46 Derrick Levasseur? They're pricing us out.
28:47 Stephanie Harlowe? I see people going to Disney every year and I'm like, how are you doing this?
28:50 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, no, it's crazy.
28:51 Stephanie Harlowe? How much debt do you have? So, yeah, Piper found it to be for the commoners, even though thirty-two thousand in debt was just absolutely royalty-level kind of lifestyle. So that spring, Fred joined Piper in couples' therapy sessions with her psychiatrist, Dr. Welton, who later said he realized Fred was nothing like the man Piper had described. Fred seemed concerned about Piper and wanted to help her however and wherever he could. But by 2000, things had only worsened. Neighbors said that Piper's mood darkened and she was home less often, even though she was supposed to be taking care of the children. That fall, Piper continued spiraling. After spending Thanksgiving in Texas with her sister Tina, Piper told a friend she was moving there with her children. She said they'd be happier without Fred.
29:36 Stephanie Harlowe? She then told the kids they were moving, and this was news to Fred, who obviously had no idea about Piper's plans. He begged her to go back to counseling and said he was worried about what she might do. In December, the family was finally set to take their long-planned Disney trip. But on the day before they were supposed to leave, Fred woke up and Piper and Callie were missing, so Callie's the youngest daughter. He had no idea that during the night Piper packed a suitcase for herself and Callie. She called a limo to take them to the airport, and she flew to Houston where her sister Tina lived. When they got there, Piper told Tina that on the night before, Fred had ripped her clothes off, called her an embarrassment, and drugged her. And Tina obviously believed every word that her sister told her. Remember, they were very close since childhood.
30:22 Stephanie Harlowe? They called themselves soul sisters. They were ride or die. And Tina was eight years older than Piper, so obviously she's gonna feel a protective instinct towards her younger sister, who she's very close to. Now Fred soon figured out where Piper and Callie were, but instead of going to Houston, he took the two older kids to Disney as planned. I'm sure at this point, he was just fed up with the shenanigans. He'd been planning the trip for over a year. The kids were very excited about it. Obviously, they'd been telling them about it, hyping them up. He wasn't going to ruin that for them, even though Piper had tried to ruin it for them all. So after a week at Disney, Fred brought the kids to Houston to meet Piper and he asked what it would take to get her to come home. She said she wanted to move back to Texas
31:03 Stephanie Harlowe? to be closer to her family. So Fred agreed. He agreed to look for a teaching job in Texas and a few days later, all of them, the whole family, including Piper and Kelly, flew back to Virginia. And unlike Piper, when she said she was going to do something, Fred kept his promise and he applied for his old position at UT, but there weren't any spots available, so he kept searching for a job. Meanwhile, Piper stole Fred's MasterCard and secretly ordered a new Citibank card in his name. So within a month, she charged nearly $20,000 between cash advances and purchases. Then in early January of 2001, Piper moved out of the family home and into the home of her friend Lonnie, who was going through a divorce.
31:47 Stephanie Harlowe? Days later, Piper went back to the Jablin home to see the kids. While there, she called the police and accused Fred of pushing her into a wall during an argument. Officers arrived and Fred explained that the fight they'd had, it had only been verbal, which all of the children backed up. Piper told police that Fred was really abusive and she urged them to ask her friend Mel. But when officers contacted Piper's friend Mel, Mel said as far as she knew, Fred was not abusive.
32:16 Derrick Levasseur? Well, that backfired.
32:17 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I'm starting, I'm wondering like, Piper mentally doesn't seem okay, right?
32:22 Derrick Levasseur? There is a small part of me that always wonders if there is some truth to it. Maybe this is an exaggeration, but as you mentioned, and I was looking to see if you did, the kids backed up his account, then you even have friends of hers saying, yeah, no, no signs that he's abusive. Because usually there's at least a little truth, but also there have been cases when it's a flat out lie and just from what you're describing, that appears to be the case here.
32:46 Stephanie Harlowe? And it's almost like, did Piper know she was lying? Or did she truly believe these things were happening? Like, she wasn't mentally okay? Because why would you tell the police, go check with Mel? Knowing that Mel was gonna be like, I don't know, like I, I love my friend, but I can't, you know, I can't tell you something that didn't happen.
33:04 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, I do think it's fair to say at this point that what you just mentioned, clearly Piper was not mentally okay. I don't know what condition she actually had, but it was, it was something she should have been treated for and probably why Fred was urging her to go back to therapy, to speak with a professional because he could see there was something, some, there was something deeper going on here that she wasn't being treated for, properly at least.
33:30 Stephanie Harlowe? I mean, just the, um, the lack of impulse control, right? The cheating, the spending, making decisions very quickly without thinking them through. Yes, can somebody just be an asshole and, and do horrible things and cheat and spend money, but the, the way that it's happening, where she keeps getting caught and she keeps going to therapy and she keeps saying like, yeah, I know this isn't right. I'll make it right. And then she does it all over again. It seems like she doesn't have control over it.
33:55 Derrick Levasseur? Definitely doesn't have control of it. Couple that with the fact that she just doesn't respect Fred.
34:00 Stephanie Harlowe? Oh, clearly.
34:01 Derrick Levasseur? I mean, she hasn't respected him from the beginning and that has not changed. She has done things when he's asked, but only because he incentivized her to do it by giving her something she wanted. It's the only reason and it would only result in them being back together when Fred would make concessions, when Fred would make sacrifices.
34:24 Stephanie Harlowe? Fred had to meet her more than halfway.
34:25 Derrick Levasseur? It wasn't like there was some type of compromise, right? It was more about, hey, Fred, you come over and do everything I ask and then maybe I'll give you what you want, which is just to be together.
34:36 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, which is just to have me do what I'm supposed to be doing.
34:39 Derrick Levasseur? Exactly.
34:40 Stephanie Harlowe? I mean, when you look at the fact that she had postpartum depression and you could say, well, clearly this is a, uh, an issue with her mental health, but usually postpartum depression does not. Include these impulsive behaviors. At least alone, it doesn't include these chronic impulsive behaviors. If you're
35:00 Derrick Levasseur? And there were signs before the children.
35:01 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, because if you're talking about reckless spending, cheating, thrill seeking, frequent mood swings, unstable self-image.
35:07 Derrick Levasseur? I, I don't think the guy that Fred found out about in Germany was the first or the last.
35:11 Stephanie Harlowe? Oh, no, no, no.
35:12 Derrick Levasseur? But I'm saying before children, I'm think, I think that's the one he found out about, but there was much more going on that he wasn't aware of.
35:18 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, this sounds also like she maybe had been struggling with something bipolar for quite a long time.
35:23 Derrick Levasseur? I do got to say one thing because by now everyone knows the format of the show. And you're talking a lot about Piper and she's not coming off well. And I'm wondering how she's going to tie into all this because right now, you know, we're two thirds into the script and I'm like, okay. So Piper's responsible for it, but I, I don't want to go too far there because you could throw a curve ball at me. So I'm just letting everyone know as I'm digesting this story for the first time, I've never heard of it before. I am wondering where Stephanie's taking us because she's painting a picture of Piper that's not a good one. So I'm interested to see how this one plays out.
36:02 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I'm painting a picture of Piper, but also I think, you know, Fred's life up until the point where his life was taken from him. This is what he's dealing with. This is his experience on a regular basis. Not a great life. Like, I'm sure he was wishing to go back to his quiet house where, you know, he could have neighborhood Halloween parties and then stick to himself other times of the year. But listen, Piper's claiming that Fred's abusive. We don't know if she actually believed this or if she was lying about him. Either way, there was no evidence of it. Nobody could back it up. And Piper went back to her friend Lonnie's house, which remember Lonnie's going through divorce at that time. Later that month, Fred emailed Piper saying, you know, I still care about you. I still want to make things work.
36:44 Stephanie Harlowe? But she didn't care. And two weeks later, police were called to the Jablin house again after Piper showed up in a manic state. But this time it was Fred who called. He told dispatch, quote, "My wife's acting strange and she's trying to take my kids away," end quote. When police officers arrived, Piper was agitated and claimed Fred had locked the children in a bedroom. She also said she wanted to leave, but he wouldn't let her. Fred told them that wasn't true and officers suggested they stay apart for the night and talk things over in the morning. Well, thanks, thanks, officers. This is such a Gabby Petito situation, like, you know. Just take the night, guys. I know you've been dealing with this for years, but take the night. Tomorrow, in the light of day, you could talk about it more civilly. That's not gonna happen.
37:25 Stephanie Harlowe? Less than a week later, Piper checked into a hotel with the kids. Over the next few days, she continuously called friends and said she thought police were coming for her. She then went to the courthouse and filed for a restraining order claiming Fred had been physically abusive. Hours later, he was arrested on campus at his job, which was incredibly surprising and also embarrassing for him. After his release, he moved into a motel while Piper stayed in the house with the kids. Thankfully, he was able to keep his job. His colleagues seemed to understand what was happening, and he was even offered a job as acting dean of the Jepson School, which he accepted.
38:00 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, it looks like it didn't hurt him too much.
38:02 Stephanie Harlowe? I mean, it was, but he was able to, you know, keep it together still.
38:06 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, you're right. Didn't hurt him too much, but obviously optics not great. And you sure, I'm sure you have rumblings within the university, people wondering if this is true, and this guy is some type of monster that they're just unaware of. What is your thought at this point? Do you, because I mentioned it a couple of minutes ago, is there, in your opinion, and again, it's just an opinion, we don't know, well, we'll never know, any validity to what she's alleging? Could, could there be somewhere in the middle, or maybe not even in the middle, but just a foundation where she's exaggerating what's happening? And maybe Fred is slightly abusive in certain ways where he's like grabbing her or pushing her, not, not beating her, but doing things where she's taking that and running with it?
38:47 Stephanie Harlowe? No, absolutely not. From what I've seen, whatever you searched, there's no evidence of that. And I think that's why I keep saying, like, either she's mentally going through some kind of break from reality where she genuinely thinks this stuff happened, or she's just maliciously lying. Those are the only two options at this point. And I will say, I mean, like, it's not even the fact that, oh, Fred was holding it together and he didn't have huge impacts at work. It's good that he didn't have huge impacts at work. But he's holding it all together and making sure that his career, which is the only thing that financially provides for his entire family at this point, his career is not affected. And the amount of mental anguish that he was going through, while still making sure that it didn't leak over or touch his career.
39:31 Stephanie Harlowe? And he's kind of like trying to hold that up all by himself, while also with the other hand, trying to make sure everything's okay with Piper. And she's taking the kids here and she's taking the kids there. And it just had to be exhausting. So I know very, it's so hard when you're trying to keep everything together publicly, when privately, things are just absolutely in chaos. And you have somebody who's actively trying to like throw grenades in your path every time you step forward. But he still was, for the most part, holding it all together because he knew, not just that his career was important to him, because it was, but I'm the one who takes care of these kids.
40:09 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, he's the breadwinner.
40:09 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I'm the one who pays the mortgage on the house I don't even live in right now.
40:13 Derrick Levasseur? Right.
40:14 Stephanie Harlowe? And if not for me, if I lose my job or something happens or I slip at all, it's not just going to hurt me, it hurts my children.
40:21 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah. Speaking of the children, how old were Jocelyn and Paxton around the time when this was all occurring? I know Callie was very young.
40:28 Stephanie Harlowe? So it would have been during the early 1990s they were born. So they were probably like 10, 11, 12 at this time.
40:36 Derrick Levasseur? Okay, so they're old enough to be able to speak.
40:39 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah.
40:40 Derrick Levasseur? And know what's going on around them.
40:42 Stephanie Harlowe? All right, we're going to take a quick break and then we'll be right back.
40:49 Stephanie Harlowe? Okay, we're back. So Fred filed for an emergency custody hearing, telling the court that the children weren't safe with Piper. The judge agreed and gave him temporary physical custody and lifted the restraining order. Fred moved back into the house and soon after, Piper filed another false abuse report and stole a bunch of Fred's stuff from the family home. Still, Fred begged her to come home for the kids, but she refused. So he filed for divorce on grounds of desertion. Piper then filed for her own divorce claiming Fred was verbally and physically abusive. She asked for joint physical custody, which was denied. However, Fred was ordered to pay Piper over $1,000 a month in alimony and child support. At this point, Fred had been and was raising his children almost entirely on his own. Even with the demands of serving as acting dean, he made time for every part of their
41:34 Stephanie Harlowe? lives. He attended their games, scout meetings, and dance classes. He even volunteered as a class parent, always signing up when help was needed. He was so involved with his children's lives that at one point, he was named the professor most likely to run out of class to talk to his kids on his cellphone. I don't know how he did it. I don't know how he did it. That's hard, having like a time, a time demanding career and also still being able to be there for everything for your children and volunteer for their classes and stuff. A lot of respect there. So as Fred adjusted to being a single parent, he and Piper continued sharing joint custody, but this was difficult for Fred. He worried constantly when the children were with her. She was careless and impulsive, once letting them cross a four-lane road alone and another
42:19 Stephanie Harlowe? time taking them on a boat without life jackets. Piper was also having an affair with her daughter's married doctor, and she'd even brought her children along on their dates. It was a deep betrayal and made Fred even more uneasy about her influence. Fred began to fear for his own safety as well. After two false abuse claims, he didn't know what Piper might do next. He installed a security system and taught the kids what to do if she tried to take them without permission. His fears were justified. She kept breaking into the house, stealing from him. She even filed another false assault report. All of this led Fred to file for full custody. And in September of 2001, the judge ruled that Fred would have physical custody while
43:01 Stephanie Harlowe? both he and Piper retained temporary joint custody. A psychiatrist was ordered to evaluate them to determine who was the best fit to raise the children. So by January 2002, the psychiatric evaluations were complete. One doctor said Piper likely had substance abuse issues, ADHD, bipolar disorder, and dissociative disorder. He described her as hyperemotional with impaired judgment. About Fred, he wrote that he, quote, "relied on tact and diplomacy," end quote. Another psychiatrist believed Piper had ADHD and an adjustment disorder, noting it would take long-term therapy to manage. He said Fred sometimes saw himself as blameless and could overreact under stress,
43:45 Stephanie Harlowe? but nothing in Fred's report was damaging. So based on those findings, the court gave Fred permanent physical custody while maintaining joint custody. Piper was furious and told everyone who would listen that Fred only won custody because he manipulated the judge with his expertise in communication. And this is kind of ridiculous because, yes, the judge makes the ultimate decision, but the judge makes the decision based on so many factors, including the reports of the psychiatrists, right? Who talked to Piper and who-
44:15 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, there's multiple experts involved here. It's not just the judge. The judge is going off the opinion of the experts.
44:20 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, the judge isn't like, "Hey, hey Fred, I like the way you talk. You get your kids." It's not, it's not that way. It doesn't work that way.
44:28 Derrick Levasseur? No, the writing's on the wall here. They can see. I'm sure everyone brought stuff to the table. And the judge, in most cases, can use common sense, especially after speaking with the experts who are evaluating-
44:39 Stephanie Harlowe? Evaluating the whole situation, yeah.
44:41 Derrick Levasseur? And Piper.
44:41 Stephanie Harlowe? And the kids, honestly. And I'm sure the kids were talked to as well. So at this point, Piper is just irrationally angry, and she vowed to destroy Fred. She had her sister Tina, a nurse practitioner, type up a 42-page document titled "Jablin Psychological Profile." And to make it-
44:58 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, there's no bias there.
44:59 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, well, I think they were trying to like, plant it as if it was an official document.
45:04 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, my God.
45:05 Stephanie Harlowe? And so to make it look official-
45:06 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, my God, where are we going?
45:07 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, exactly. To make it look official, Tina listed fake credentials and then filled that report with lies. So this report said that Fred had violent outbursts, smoked pot with his students, physically and sexually assaulted Piper. Tina wrote that Fred had physically abused the children as well and wrote that the children were at high risk for psychological abuse. So when I'm first reading this part, when, you know, I'm looking through this case- I'm like, what's the purpose of this? Right? Like, where is this report going? The decision's already been made by the judge. And even if it wasn't, if you tried to submit this report, it would quickly be sussed out as being fake.
45:44 Derrick Levasseur? Fake, yeah.
45:45 Stephanie Harlowe? Where, what were you doing with this report? What was the plan here? Well, they did have a plan because Piper, in a horrible action, emailed this fake document to Fred's colleagues, members of the PTA for her children's school, the children's scout leaders.
46:01 Derrick Levasseur? What a scumbag.
46:02 Stephanie Harlowe? The children's scout leaders, anyone that knew Fred. What a scumbag. Unbelievable.
46:07 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah.
46:08 Stephanie Harlowe? Ugh, gross. So in one move, she involved the community in their family drama. And even though it was all fabricated, it was obviously devastating to Fred's reputation. Once stuff gets out there, the general public doesn't have time or, or energy to consider the, you know, gray areas or to actually get to the truth. They're just like, wow, this report looks legit. Or-
46:31 Derrick Levasseur? Well, they're also not privy to the other side to it, right?
46:34 Stephanie Harlowe? No, of course not.
46:35 Derrick Levasseur? Fred's not out there airing out all of Piper's dirty laundry. So they're only getting one side. And I'm a perfect example of how that works because I'm sitting here asking you, hey, do you think there's any truth, any validity to what Piper has alleged? And you're like, no. But the truth is like-
46:50 Stephanie Harlowe? Because you want to give, you want to, if someone's claiming to be a victim, you want to give them the benefit of the doubt.
46:54 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, of course. So without a doubt, there's going to be people in that neighborhood, that PTA or part of his colleagues who are going to say, man, Fred's an asshole.
47:02 Stephanie Harlowe? Especially if, if somebody maybe has previous history with domestic violence or has been the victim of domestic violence, they're going to automatically sort of mentally side with Piper against it because they don't have the full situation. But I have found the first person in a, in an issue like this, the first person to take it public and try to like rally troops to their side is usually the one who's causing the drama and who's causing the problems. And that's why they're trying to, to get ahead of it. They're trying to get out ahead of it. Obviously Fred's got to do some sort of damage control, but he had to personally contact colleagues to deny it. He even withdrew his name from consideration for a full-time dean position. Piper had sabotaged his personal life for years, and
47:45 Stephanie Harlowe? now she was doing it to his career. Fred filed an emergency motion to limit her visitation with the children while Piper responded by asking for more alimony, saying she couldn't keep a job. The judge sided with Fred and limited Piper's visits to two weekends a month. He no longer owed Piper child support, though he was still required to pay alimony for the time being. So, after the ruling, Piper moved to Houston to live with her sister Tina, who, by the way, is no better for going along with this. It's like, I get it that you want to believe your sister, but when you're typing up an official report, as a nurse practitioner, you have a legitimate, respected career and position. You're a medical professional, and you're typing up a report.
48:30 Stephanie Harlowe? Even if you thought everything Piper said in that report was real, you're making fake credentials so you know that there's something that's not super quite right about this, and you're going along with it to destroy the father of your niece's nephew. Like, do you understand what's happening here? This isn't good.
48:46 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, no, it's not, it's not serving anybody well. And here's the thing, you can, you can acknowledge that as her sister, she wants to believe her, that's okay. I'm, I'm okay with that portion of it, but to enable her by creating this fictitious document and disseminating it the way you did, that's where it was your job to step in and go, "Hey, Piper, I love you, I support you, I believe you, but this is not the way. This is not the way to do it." And, and she didn't help the situation at all.
49:15 Stephanie Harlowe? If the truth's on your side, just go to court, present your real evidence, and, you know, the chips fall where they fall.
49:23 Derrick Levasseur? If you have to falsify a document, that's not a good sign to indicate that what you're saying is true.
49:28 Stephanie Harlowe? Exactly, exactly. So, now Piper is living with Tina, and they spent all their time together talking about how much they hated Fred, feeding off each other until Piper's anger turned into obsession. She blamed him for everything wrong in her life, even though he had spent years trying to help her. Things only got worse when a judge ruled that Fred no longer had to pay the alimony since he was already covering the $70,000 debt that Piper had built up. So the cherry on top was that Piper was ordered to pay Fred nearly $900 a month in child support. And this isn't good, right? Because Piper can't hold a job. So now for once in her life, she's being asked not even to pay back the $70,000 in debt she racked up that her
50:11 Stephanie Harlowe? husband, because he's married to her, is legally and financially responsible for as well. Now, she's got to pay him $900 a month for child support, and she can't keep a job, and she's never in her life had to be responsible for anyone or anything, not even herself. So she completely ignored that court order, even though at this point, she was working as a guardian ad litem, which is the most, I think, just ironic part of this, because that is an attorney assigned to protect children's best interest in custody cases. So when you go through custody cases, your children will be assigned maybe one, maybe two, depending they may give a different one to each child, but they'll be assigned a guardian ad litem, and this person who's a lawyer will come and talk to the children, interview them more
50:55 Stephanie Harlowe? than once, and then they'll go to the court during the custody battle and say, this is, I'm here to protect the kids' interests. I don't care what mom says, I don't care what dad says. This is what the kids are saying, and based on the many interviews I've had and the consistency of their statements, this is what I believe to be true. That's their job. And you've got somebody who's absolutely a banana nut sundae with extra nuts, being a guardian ad litem for children.
51:19 Derrick Levasseur? Hey, let's, let's keep the sundaes out of this, all right? What'd they do to you?
51:23 Stephanie Harlowe? Well, they got extra nuts.
51:25 Derrick Levasseur? Who doesn't love a good sundae with extra nuts?
51:26 Stephanie Harlowe? I do, but not to represent my child in court.
51:29 Derrick Levasseur? No, caramel? Oh, I'm definitely getting a sundae after we're done recording now.
51:34 Stephanie Harlowe? No, bananas, hot fudge. What's caramel?
51:38 Derrick Levasseur? Whoa, are you saying hot fudge over caramel?
51:41 Stephanie Harlowe? Hot fudge over caramel all day, every day.
51:43 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, my word, we're not friends anymore.
51:45 Stephanie Harlowe? Caramel?
51:47 Derrick Levasseur? Everyone in the comments right now, caramel or hot fudge?
51:49 Stephanie Harlowe? This isn't an apple.
51:50 Derrick Levasseur? This is real deep questions we're asking here.
51:52 Stephanie Harlowe? This is a banana split sundae.
51:54 Derrick Levasseur? A banana split sundae?
51:56 Stephanie Harlowe? Yes, that's what they're called, banana split sundaes, with extra nuts.
51:59 Derrick Levasseur? That doesn't sound like you're saying it right.
52:01 Stephanie Harlowe? Yes, banana split.
52:02 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, banana split sundae.
52:05 Stephanie Harlowe? I've ordered enough of them in my life to know that's accurate and you know what? They've all come with hot, hot chocolate, chocolate.
52:11 Derrick Levasseur? Hot chocolate.
52:12 Stephanie Harlowe? What is it called? Hot chocolate, hot fudge, which is chocolate.
52:15 Derrick Levasseur? That stuff that you, yeah.
52:15 Stephanie Harlowe? That stuff I love. All right.
52:17 Derrick Levasseur? Caramel.
52:17 Stephanie Harlowe? So now, eh. So to market her services as a guardian, Piper created the weirdest business card I have ever seen.
52:27 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, my God, I got a link here. Am I supposed to open this?
52:29 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, let's look at this.
52:30 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, God.
52:32 Stephanie Harlowe? What?
52:34 Derrick Levasseur? What?
52:34 Stephanie Harlowe? This is her business card.
52:36 Derrick Levasseur? All right, so listen, if you're on audio, we're gonna describe this to you as best as we can. But you really gotta go over to YouTube and look at it yourself, but it's definitely a really bad Photoshop job. It looks like it could be some type of biblical flyer.
52:53 Stephanie Harlowe? So it's like an angel holding the scales of justice on one side.
52:58 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, but it's not like.
52:59 Stephanie Harlowe? It's not the real scale, yeah. It looks like very like Gothic, like something you'd see in a medieval church.
53:05 Derrick Levasseur? What's that movie with Tom Hanks?
53:06 Stephanie Harlowe? Which one?
53:07 Derrick Levasseur? Where he's like trying to figure out the mystery. Thank you.
53:10 Stephanie Harlowe? It's very Da Vinci Code coded.
53:12 Derrick Levasseur? Am I, did I nail it?
53:13 Stephanie Harlowe? Absolutely. And then there's a picture of her, like, kind of like her arms crossed and her back to, you know, something. And then above her, it says, if you feel you don't have the right or are convinced that you are not deserving, then we must talk, or we need to talk, we need to talk.
53:32 Derrick Levasseur? Then we need to talk.
53:35 Stephanie Harlowe? I don't know.
53:36 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, and the photo, the photo's not terrible. The photo's okay, everything else around it, and she has like a.
53:41 Stephanie Harlowe? I mean, it's kind of weird. She's intensely looking into the camera, like, I am the angel of justice.
53:47 Derrick Levasseur? The angel of justice, but it looks like it's like a Saint Michael behind her, because he's, he or she is holding a sword. I don't know, man. She, she, this was not well thought out, but everything you have talked about tonight and the woman that you have described to us.
54:02 Stephanie Harlowe? This adds up.
54:03 Derrick Levasseur? Flyer just tracks.
54:05 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, it does.
54:06 Derrick Levasseur? I'm, I see it and I'm surprised, but at the same time, I'm like, oh, yeah, okay, that makes sense.
54:10 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I mean.
54:10 Derrick Levasseur? I got it. I got it.
54:11 Stephanie Harlowe? This is very Piper. That's so Piper.
54:14 Derrick Levasseur? It looks like a crappy cover to a DVD that was made by some student.
54:21 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, for their, for their like thesis about how the Egyptian pyramids were built by aliens.
54:27 Derrick Levasseur? Yeah, well, but again, it tracks. I'm with it. All right. I need a break. Let's take our last one. We're gonna be back. We'll wrap this episode up.
54:39 Stephanie Harlowe? All right, we're back. So Piper's just, I don't know what the hell she's doing. She's living with her sister. They're getting each other all riled up. You know, I can imagine it every night. They're just coming home, pouring the wine and like making, you know, voodoo dolls that look like Fred. And then she's being, you know, working as a guardian at a light of for other children who are going through custody issues in their families and that's the scariest part of this, I will say, the absolute scariest part of this, that that that was allowed to happen. Considering what she was going through, I don't think that that was the best job for her and there should have been some checks and balances. Because she's going to obviously, even if she's not an insane person, which I believe she is. She's gonna have a bias at this point, right? She's possibly gonna have a bias towards the mother, even if that's not
55:23 Stephanie Harlowe? the correct decision to make. So I just don't think she should have been allowed to do this and work in this capacity. During her own divorce and custody battle. That's just my opinion. Are you like with me on that?
55:34 Derrick Levasseur? I mean, listen, I'm with you, but at the same time. I understand why it's allowed legally, it's okay, but yeah, knowing her, not everyone knows her like you're describing her to us. They're only seeing the end product, although that flyer should have scared everybody.
55:49 Stephanie Harlowe? Yeah, I wonder how many calls she got.
55:51 Derrick Levasseur? Probably a lot because it's so polarizing that you'd be like, I gotta call.
55:54 Stephanie Harlowe? This lady. Yeah. So even after everything she had put him through, Fred was still nice to Piper. He emailed her updates about the kids, sent photos and tried to keep things civil because he's probably hoping, hey, I do think my wife or my ex-wife has a mental illness, but eventually I would like her to get help. I would like her to have therapy and maybe take medication and she'll get better and then she can be there for our children again, even if we don't reunite, she can be there for our children again. But at times, Piper appeared polite in return, though she still refused to pay child support. Meanwhile, her job as a guardian, surprise, surprise, it was unraveling. She'd been taking client deposits without telling her employer, and when he found out, she was let go.
56:36 Derrick Levasseur? Well, no more need for that flyer.
56:37 Stephanie Harlowe? So then, in 2002, after 19 years of marriage, Piper and Fred had their final court hearing for their divorce and child custody battle. In the end, the judge ordered Piper to repay more than $8,000 in back child support and return Fred's mother's jewelry that she stole. It seemed like a major loss for Piper, but it wasn't really, because she was also awarded 20% of Fred's retirement, which was around $70,000. And for a while after this ruling, things were quiet. It seemed like the money had pacified Piper, and the drama was at a low point, at least in Piper standards. Fred was starting to feel like he could breathe again. By October of 2004, Fred was happier than he'd been in years. He was dating a woman named Charlene, and things were serious enough that he introduced her to the kids.
57:22 Stephanie Harlowe? It was also his favorite season, Halloween. Together, he and his kids decorated the yard and made plans to spend Halloween Day at a pumpkin patch. On Friday, October 29th, Fred spoke to his girlfriend, Charlene, and mentioned emailing Piper to let her know that he was going to let the kids visit her for Thanksgiving. This was a big step for Fred, but it seemed like the right one. Things with Piper had been calm and okay recently, and the kids deserved to see their mom. Now, the next morning, Fred followed his normal routine, getting up around 6:00 a.m. and putting on some coffee. Just after 6:35, while it was still dark, he stepped outside in his slippers to get the newspaper at the end of his driveway. Just then, someone emerged from the shadows near the garage and shot him multiple times in the back with a .38 revolver.
58:07 Stephanie Harlowe? Fred collapsed, landing on the edge of the driveway between his Ford Explorer and a basketball hoop. His neighbor, Bob, who had heard the gunfire and called 911, was unsure where the shots had come from, but was certain that they were close. Police arrived and searched the area but found nothing. At around 7:30, Bob and his wife Doreen took their dogs for a walk and noticed something in Fred's driveway. When Bob looked closer, he realized it was Fred Jablin. He immediately told Doreen to call the police. When paramedics arrived, they tried to revive Fred with CPR and heart-stimulating drugs, but it was too late. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Officers then learned that Fred's three children were likely inside the house, so SWAT was called in as a precaution.
58:47 Stephanie Harlowe? When they entered, they found Jocelyn, Callie, and Paxton, sleepy but unharmed, and quickly escorted them outside away from their father's body. With the kids safe, officers canvassed the neighborhood, hoping to identify any obvious suspects, and it didn't take long before they had a name to look into: Piper Rountree. Neighbors talked about the years of turmoil she'd caused, and the more officers heard, the clearer it became that she was their most likely suspect. I wonder if they saw that business card, because that would have locked it in for me.
59:16 Derrick Levasseur? Oh, yeah. They'd have been like, "We got him."
59:18 Stephanie Harlowe? "Let's find her." So they began tracing her movements before and after the shooting. And what they uncovered was strange, once again, even for Piper. But all of that's gonna have to wait for part two. So, this is part one, we have part two, and that's gonna be the end. We're not gonna have multiple parts that we're not gonna tell you about. Part two.
59:37 Derrick Levasseur? I wish we were recording it right now, because it just seems so clear-cut. So I really wanna know more. But either way, it's important to cover this case, because I've never heard about it before. I think a lot of our listeners and viewers probably haven't either, so, good case. I'm hooked. I want part two. I'm ready for it. A couple housecleaning things, I didn't mention them at the beginning. I mentioned on Crime Weekly News, the Criminal Coffee merch, the Halloween hoodie, is in. I do apologize, we sold out in one day. That's on me. I only ordered like 300 pieces, 400 pieces, and they went super fast. So I just ordered another bulk of them. They should be in this week. If you really want one, because we've had a lot of people reach out, go over to CriminalCoffeeCo.com,
1:00:21 Derrick Levasseur? go to the sweatshirt, click on it, and then where you click to purchase it, it says "Notify Me When In Stock." So as soon as we update the stock, you're gonna get notified and you can grab it, because they're gonna go fast. I didn't order a ton, we don't wanna do them after Halloween month, so... Again, thank you for all the support. We truly appreciate it. We're glad you love them. And I do apologize for not ordering correctly, but it's so hard. Some go super fast. Yeah, we didn't know. The Valentine's Day hoodies, we sold like over a thousand. And then the St. Patty's hoodies, we only sold like 300. I told you these ones are gonna fly. As soon as I saw the design. They're pretty great. Ashley knocked it out of the park. It's great. And also, something I'm gonna try for episodes going forward, it'll be on the screen to the right or left of us, or it might be over
1:01:05 Derrick Levasseur? the whole screen. A lot of you reach out and say, hey, what was the ad that you covered in this episode? We didn't know what it was. What was the product? Can you put it up there? We're gonna put up an image right now, a graphic, where you'll see all the ads for the episode and their, and their contact info. If you're someone who's watching on YouTube, that's something we're gonna start doing as well. So that's on the screen here. Probably won't mention it in future episodes. It'll just be up there at the end of each episode. As always, guys, we appreciate you being here. All the love and support. We couldn't do it without you. We're gonna keep it rolling. Lot more to come. Some few surprises that we're coming down the road for sure. Stephanie and I have some great plans, and we can't wait to share them with all of you. We hope everyone's happy, having a good holiday season, and we will see you next week. But until then, what am I gonna say? Stephanie?
1:01:49 Derrick Levasseur? Stay safe out there. Stay safe out there. We'll see you next week.
Previous S3 Ep349: Justice for A’Marie Jones | Cleveland Case Raises Outcry Next S3 Ep351: Austin’s Yogurt Shop Murders | 34 Years Later - New Break In the Case! Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated