Bishop Barron on the New Pope, the Foolishness of Atheism, and Why Young Men Are Turning to Christ

There’s a revival going on, says Bishop Robert Barron. It’s unmistakable. You see it everywhere. (00:00) Introduction (09:05) How to Abandon Your Ego (20:47) Seeing God in All Things (25:15) The Biggest Threat to Your Relationship With God (54:00) Does God Require Sacrifice? Paid partnerships with: Beam: Get 30% off for a limited time using the code TUCKER at https://ShopBeam.com/Tucker Tecovas: Get 10% off at tecovas.com/tucker Hallow prayer app: Get 3 months free at https://Hallow.com/Tucker Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions.

• 0:30Tucker Carlson?

  Do you think that Christian persecution is on the rise?

• 0:33Speaker 02

  Oh, I know it is. It's documented. 20th century was the worst century for Christian martyrs of Christian history, all the previous centuries combined. It's the most persecuted religion. If two friends like each other, that's fine. But Aristotle says that won't last, that relationship. What makes it last is when the two friends together fall in love with a transcendent third. And now together, we look to that. Now we really find a bond. When the bride and groom together look to Christ, now they'll stay married. If they're just looking to each other, it'll found her.

• 1:05Tucker Carlson?

  The Catholic Church got super liberal. And then all of a sudden, everywhere you look, people you know are converting to Catholicism with a pretty kind of traditionally Christian orientation.

• 1:15Speaker 02

  This is how I would characterize ecclesial liberalism, a tendency to reduce the supernatural to the natural. That was going on for a long time, yes. In very recent years, there's been a keener interest in the supernatural dimension of the faith.

• 1:50Tucker Carlson?

  I don't think I've ever received more texts about any guest than I did about you.

• 1:57Tucker Carlson?

  From Catholics I know, from non-Catholics I know, but the Catholics all wanted to hear details on, you know, factions within the church. And I'm not going to ask you any questions about that because I don't understand any of it.

• 2:07Speaker 02

  Good.

• 2:08Tucker Carlson?

  I want to start as broad as I possibly can, which is, it seems like a lot of people in the West are unhappy. And it's measurable. Suicide rates are at record highs.

• 2:18Tucker Carlson?

  And birth rates are at record lows.

• 2:20Speaker 02

  Yep.

• 2:21Tucker Carlson?

  And those are not signs of confidence in the future. Those are signs of despair. Why are people unhappy?

• 2:28Speaker 02

  Well, they've lost a sense of God. I mean, God is the supreme good. And when you lose that sense of God and you collapse back in on yourself, that's St. Augustine, he said, define sin as "curvatus in se." I'm caved in around myself. When you do that, you are by definition unhappy. When you lose a sense of objective value grounded in the supreme value of God, almost again, by definition, you become unhappy.

• 2:54Tucker Carlson?

  What does it mean to cave in on yourself?

• 2:55Speaker 02

  It means that you've lost a sense of connection to the values that should be calling you out of yourself in an act of love. And you've now come to reverence your own freedom, your own autonomy. So what gives my life meaning is the fact that I've chosen something. I've determined my life. If the Bible has one message, it's that, that when you live your life that way, you get lost. When you deify your own psyche, your own ego, you get lost. The joy of life comes from forgetting and this great ecstatic act. You forget about yourself and you lose yourself in some great value. Now, that could be sports, that could be politics, whatever it is. But then the supreme value in which all the other ones participate,

• 3:40Speaker 02

  we call God. God is the highest good, the summum bonum. That's why you love the Lord your God. That's the first commandment, right? But when the cultures lost that, which ours is in danger of, you by definition become unhappy. You get caved in around yourself. And then you fuss around in this kind of addictive way. That's how I would diagnose the thing spiritually.

• 4:03Tucker Carlson?

  When you are in love with the idea of choices, I thought the whole point of the West was choices.

• 4:10Speaker 02

  Well, but you have to know what your choice is for. When you deify choice itself, when you say autonomy, that's my, that's my God. No, choice is for some good. And the idea is to, is to order freedom, right? Freedom is not an end in itself. Freedom is ordered toward some good. When it's disordered, it tends to collapse upon itself. That's what we got.

• 4:33Tucker Carlson?

  The whole point of America, I thought, was choice and freedom for its own sake.

• 4:36Speaker 02

  Well, and I would argue it's not for its own sake. And if that happens to us, something's gone wrong. The founding fathers, you know, they weren't in the full sense of the term. It wouldn't have the full Catholic imagination as I would like it, but they certainly had a sense of the objective good. And that the purpose of life is to find that good and be ordered toward it. An ordered freedom is what they're interested in, not freedom for its own sake.

• 5:02Tucker Carlson?

  What does ordered mean?

• 5:03Speaker 02

  Ordered toward the good. And that's why it has to be educated. Your freedom has to be disciplined and directed. It's like a kid with all kinds of athletic ability, but if a coach never directs that ability toward the achievement of some good, that he can become a great tennis player or a great golfer, then the freedom, it begins to kind of stew on itself. No, direct freedom, direct talent, direct energy. And our culture, see, it's like, I think of this, if you have banks to a river, the river has energy, it's going somewhere. You knock down the banks, you say, oh, I don't want to be limited. Don't, don't set limits to my freedom.

• 5:41Tucker Carlson?

  It just floods the fields.

• 5:42Speaker 02

  Well, it just opens up in this big lazy lake and everyone's just sort of lying on their air mattresses, right? Now, I'll tolerate you, you tolerate me, I won't bother you. But then we're not getting anywhere. The point of the banks is not to restrict me, is to direct me, see, towards some good. Well, religion has played that role for much of our history. And in the measure that religion gets marginalized, and in the measure that we deify our autonomy, welcome to the unhappy world that many of the young people are living in sadly.

• 6:11Tucker Carlson?

  Deify our autonomy. So you're speaking as if autonomy and choice are the same thing or closely related?

• 6:19Speaker 02

  Yeah. See, the goal for the Bible is not autonomy, it's theonomy. God, theos, becomes the nomos. God becomes the law of my life. And see, here's the trick. When God becomes the norm of my life, I become more myself. I find who I really am. If I jettison God and I say, no, autonomy is, I'm the leader of my own life, I get lost. Right? What's Jesus say? The one who loses himself, you know, will find it. The one who's trying to hang on to himself is going to lose it. Lose your freedom in God's greater freedom and you become now authentically free. That's every spiritual master in the West teaches that lesson.

• 7:02Speaker 02

  But we lose it in the measure that we say, no, it's all about my autonomy. That's all that matters. Don't tell me what to do, throw off the rules. Right. Knock down the banks and the river becomes a lazy lake and we tolerate each other blandly, but we don't have a common purpose. That's another problem. See, if you reject objective value. So you've got your values, I've got my values, your freedom, my freedom. Well, what connects us? In fact, we're antagonistic to each other, right? We tend to grow into hostility and my freedom's against your freedom. But if together we find a common good, a common goal, now we can join forces, right? So it's falling in love, that's Aristotle with the transcendent third.

• 7:45Speaker 02

  So like if two friends like each other, that's fine, but Aristotle says that won't last, that relationship. What makes it last is when the two friends together fall in love with a transcendent third, the country, or their philosophy, or some great value. And now together we look to that. Now we really find a bond. Go back now to the 1950s and Fulton Sheen, the great Catholic preacher, writes a book called, Three to Get Married, made the same argument, right? The three are the bride, the groom, and Christ. When the bride and groom together look to Christ, now they'll stay married. If they're just looking to each other, it'll found her.

• 8:27Tucker Carlson?

  What are the banks that we've demolished?

• 8:30Speaker 02

  Well, I would say objective value. You know, the life of the mind, the moral good, religious good, aesthetic, think of the good, the true and the beautiful. If we subjectivize those and just relativize them, you got yours, I got mine, what you think is right, I think is wrong. When that's lost, the banks are knocked down. But when together, oh no, we can together reverence the beautiful, we can together reverence the moral good, we can together reverence the epistemological good, the intellectual good.

• 9:04Speaker 02

  Then together we move someplace. And see, our whole system educationally was set up classically to do just that, was to train people in what these objectivities are. But when you subjectivize those, or you see it simply as part of an oppressive or patriarchal system, you know, why do we, why read Shakespeare? He's just an old patriarch. See, but that's a very dangerous game to play. Now we've lost a common mooring. And then we devolve into this sort of self-regarding autonomy.

• 9:35Tucker Carlson?

  So, I mean, Christianity is probably not the, I don't think it's the only religion to make this point, but self is the trap.

• 9:42Speaker 02

  Yeah. Yeah. See, think of the self here, the ego is like a black hole, a black hole that will draw everything into itself. Sucks all of life and light and energy into itself. Nothing can escape. The cravatus insae, ego, right, becomes a black hole. And I've known people like that, I'm sure you have too.

• 10:01Tucker Carlson?

  Oh, yeah.

• 10:02Speaker 02

  You're with them, they'll draw everything into themselves. The best people are those who breathe life into a room. And that happens because they, they're not preoccupied with the ego, they're, they're captivated by some objective good.

• 10:15Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 10:16Speaker 02

  And they want to show it to you. Think of some like great coaches I had as a kid that wanted to show me the various games I learned to play, baseball. We had a coach when I was a little guy, seven, eight years old, and he said, all right, guys, I want you to get down on your hands and knees on the field. I want you to feel the infield, and I want you to smell the grass, you know? And it was, it was such a good move. He was trying to get us in, look at this great game we're playing here. He also practically, if you're playing shortstop, you can't be afraid of the ground. You gotta get down to the ground. So, all right, boys, get down there, you know? Well, he was someone in love with baseball, and then was communicating to us the same love. So together, we'd fall in love with the transcendent third, which is

• 10:56Speaker 02

  baseball. That's gonna bring a team together, right? That's what great teachers and coaches and mentors and spiritual directors do. They, they help people fall in love with the same values they fall in love with.

• 11:10Speaker 02

  And fall in love with something bigger than themselves, you know, other people, nature, God. And look, even that fall in love, you're not in control. You've let go of your own ego drama. I love that language from Hans Urs von Balthazar, one of my favorite theologians from the last century. John Paul loved him, and Benedict loved him. He talked about the ego drama, which is the drama that I'm starring in, I'm producing it, I'm directing it, right? And you're all actors in my play. Yes, you're all actors in my play, and I'm gonna take it on the road eventually somewhere else. Well, that's, that's a very boring thing. What's exciting, he said, is the theodrama, which is, now, God's writing a drama, God's producing a drama. He's got

• 11:52Speaker 02

  a role for you, and he's trying to draw you into, into playing that role. And it might not be the role at all that you envisioned for yourself. So what? But he's calling you into it. That's gonna be an exciting life, a theodramatic life, a theonymist life, not an autonomous life. Oh, that's, wow, that's vivid. So what's the daily practice for someone to move beyond himself, to get out of like me? Fall in love with objective value, find mentors that can really help you enter that world. Like I've, in my own life, I've loved that. You know, I'm no great, I play the guitar poorly, but I love classical music. And I had mentors early on that, let me play you, you know, Beethoven's Seventh Symphony, let me just play it for you and then talk about

• 12:36Speaker 02

  it. I remember the, the, the Queen of the Night aria, the famous Mozart aria with the, well, singing these impossibly high notes. I remember teachers, listen, listen to this. Someone that would draw me into that world, like my coach is drawing me into baseball. Now, put it in religious context, prayer, people that taught me how to pray when I was a young guy, we have to say my prayers. No, but prayer is a conscious exercise in overcoming autonomy. It's a conscious exercise to say, I want to get out of my preoccupations. I'm placing myself in the presence of God. I'm using language of the Psalms and so on. I'm using song, I'm using silence, I'm using the rosary, whatever it is. All of this designed

• 13:20Speaker 02

  to get me up out of myself and into the space of God. So prayer is a way, you know, to overcome. How do you pray? You said you were taught to pray. I was indeed. Very early on, when I was about maybe my early twenties, before I was a priest, but I got into the, what we call the Liturgy of the Hours in the Catholic Church, which is this daily prayer at certain points during the day, imitating, by the way, the seven times you pray in the Bible, you know, seven times a day you stop to pray. So the Hours, Psalms, Canticles, biblical. The Bible tells. The Old Testament has, and the passage about seven times I, I stopped to pray. And so the early church imitated that in the rhythm of the monastic life. And the Liturgy

• 14:02Speaker 02

  of the Hours would be kind of a monastic life for non-monks, people like, you know, you and me. But you use the Psalms, the Canticles, the readings, the Church Fathers. And I was taught that prayer early on. And at times, you know, I found it tiresome or difficult to do. Now it's like, it's like water in the desert. When I was a young guy, we didn't pray the rosary. The rosary was seen as kind of something your grandmother did. My generation didn't spontaneously pray it. But then I learned it later in life. And that too is like a lifeline to me. What is the rosary? Well, it's this collection, I have it on me. It's a collection of Hail Marys, Our Fathers, glory bees in a, in a, you know.

• 14:42Speaker 02

  In a rope and you count your way through the beads and it's a takes about 20 or 25 minutes. It's a meditative prayer as you're praying the Hail Marys, you're meditating upon the mysteries of Jesus' life and Mary's life.

• 14:55Speaker 02

  It doesn't get you anywhere. You start here and you end up exactly where you started. So it doesn't, it's not, it's not effective in that way. It's a meditative prayer. I prayed, I remember I was giving a retreat to the priests of Dublin many years ago. These were mostly older men, been through the wars, you know, most of them. And they invited me to come. They said, we're gonna pray the rosary tonight.

• 15:17Speaker 02

  All these Irish guys. Hail Mary for the grace of God. Hail Mary for the grace of God. Hail Mary for the... What is going on? But what became clear to me was, well, it's like a mantra. They, they were, they were producing this kind of meditative mantra. They finished it in about seven minutes. You know, it takes usually 25. But that's-

• 15:37Tucker Carlson?

  They don't pronounce all the sounds though.

• 15:38Speaker 02

  No, they're kind of, see, think of it, the Buddhists talk about the, the calming of the monkey mind. That's the mind that's always leaping from branch to branch. The mind that gets you through the day. I gotta do this, gotta do that. But to really pray, you have to calm that mind down. You have to, come on, come on. I, I can't be prattled with that. So the churches often use these means to do that, to calm that mind, to open up to a deeper consciousness or a deeper awareness. And prayer is that, it seems to me. Thomas Merton said, prayer is finding the place in you where you are here and now being created by God. Something is a great definition of prayer. So right now, you and I are being created by God, but we're rarely aware of that. We

• 16:23Speaker 02

  go through our day, you know, the monkey mind and we're doing this and this.

• 16:26Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 16:27Speaker 02

  But at certain points, you say, okay, I'm gonna calm the monkey mind. I'm gonna open up a deeper door, you know? And I'm gonna commune with the God who's here and now creating me. That's prayer. And then there's all kinds of disciplines around that.

• 16:42Tucker Carlson?

  So the people trying to wreck our civilization want you to be passive. They want you weak so they can control you. Weakness is their goal. No, thanks. Our friends at Beam, a proud American company, understand that our country can only be great if its people are strong. And that's why they've created a new creatine product to help listeners like you stay mentally sharp and physically fit. People like to mock creatine. CNN doesn't like creatine at all. People buy it because it works. Beam's creatine can help you improve your strength, your brain health, your longevity. It's completely free of sugar and synthetic garbage that's in almost everything else that you eat.

• 17:25Tucker Carlson?

  Of course, you don't hear about it too much because again, a population that is strong, clear minded, and physically capable is a threat to tyrants. That's why they want you playing video games. To celebrate American strength, actual American strength, Beam is offering up to 30% off their bestselling creatine for the next 48 hours. Go to shopbeam.com/tucker, use the code TUCKER at checkout. That's shopbeam, B-E-A-M, dot com slash Tucker, use the code TUCKER for up to 30% off. It's built on core values, integrity, results, no BS. Beam, we strongly recommend it.

• 18:03Speaker 03

  Imagine if every time inverse Kramer or another top investor bought a stock, you bought it too, in your own brokerage account, automatically. Well, that now exists and it's called autopilot. Built by the team behind the viral Pelosi stock tracker, autopilot lets you browse their marketplace of strategies run by proven investors or AI-driven models. Just find one with a high return, connect your personal brokerage account like a Schwab or Robinhood, and every trade they make, you make automatically. Your money never leaves your own account, autopilot just mirrors the moves. So now, no more guessing, no more staring at charts, and no more checking the market between meetings.

• 18:43Speaker 03

  With over $1.3 billion already invested, you can find autopilot on the app store or go to joinautopilot.com. That's joinautopilot.com. Investing has risks like the loss of principal.

• 18:56Speaker 04

  We all hear the radio ads about the IRS. They tell you to be afraid, to be scared, and they try to frighten you into calling. I'm not here to do that. Tax relief advocates is different. TRA is here to tell you that if you owe money to the IRS, whether it's $5,000, $50,000, or $500,000, we have a solution. It doesn't matter if you're sitting in your car, at work, or with your kids, no matter where you are, call now. 800-576-4705.

• 19:22Speaker 04

  Lose hope. TRA can eliminate or reduce what you owe to the IRS. Generous programs are now available that can give you a fresh start. Our passion is taxes and helping individuals fix their IRS problems. We have over 1,000 five-star reviews on Google and an eight-plus with the Better Business Bureau. You don't need to be afraid of the IRS any longer. End your tax nightmare today by visiting us online at TRA.com or call 800-576-4705. That's 800-576-4705. Tax relief advocates, real solutions for real people.

• 19:57Tucker Carlson?

  I think many people think of prayer as a list of requests.

• 19:59Speaker 02

  And that's okay. I mean, petitionary prayer is good. John Paul II toward the end of his life, you know, he said, I know different types of prayer, but I found the longer I live that all prayer is basically a petition. And there's something really right about that, that no matter how, you know, kind of high and elevated your prayer is, at bottom, you're saying, you know, Lord Jesus Christ, have pity on me.

• 20:22Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 20:23Speaker 02

  Or, Lord, help me. I find it, as I pray, that's the phrase, "Help me. Help me, Lord." That's fine. I have no problem with that. That's a very deep and powerful prayer.

• 20:34Tucker Carlson?

  How do you keep your mind from wandering during prayer?

• 20:36Speaker 02

  Yeah, and read the masters. They've recognized that forever. The Desert Fathers knew all about that distraction in prayer. And of course, the devil loves that, too. Loves to distract us in prayer. The best advice, someone like John of the Cross, our greatest spiritual master, would be acknowledge the distraction. Don't try to fight it. Acknowledge it and then go back. If it comes again, acknowledge it. I see you. And go back. Don't try to fight it or to try techniques to avoid it completely. A distraction comes, see it, and then return. Let go of it.

• 21:11Tucker Carlson?

  I've noticed in the past few years, people I know who are secular or have always been, suddenly talking about the existence of evil in the world. I think it's very clear to nonreligious people even that there's some kind of supernatural force of darkness, like a foot in the world. I don't think you really need to make that case anymore that that's real. How do you see God in the world? Because if you spend your life, you know,

• 21:36Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 21:37Tucker Carlson?

  staring at evil, probably not productive.

• 21:39Speaker 02

  No. Well, the world is charged with the grandeur of God. That's Jared Manley Hopkins' great poem. And I think that's right, is if you have the eyes to see and prayer disciplines that, prayer makes that possible. The world is charged with the grandeur of God, meaning everything that exists, because being in good are convertible terms. That's something from Thomas Aquinas that I think you can.

• 21:58Tucker Carlson?

  Being in good are convertible.

• 22:00Speaker 02

  Are convertible terms. In other words, to be is to be good, period. Whatever is, is good. Evil is, Aquinas would call it a provazio, a privation of the good. Evil is a cavity. It's a lack, right? But whatever is, is good. So for example, take the devil as an example. Is the devil good? Sure, of course. In the measure the devil exists, has a mind, has a will, all that is good. What's evil about the devil is the corruption of mind and will and power, right? That's why like Satan and Dante, this is highest of angels, full of goodness. God doesn't make anything that's not good. But it's become corrupt, see? So the trick there is always to focus on, on the good,

• 22:45Speaker 02

  because being in good are convertible terms. Whatever is, is good. Think of the mystics who talk about, you see like a little bug crawling across this table. That's an avenue toward God. Because if you look at this little tiny bug, let's say. But the more you look at it, I mean, incredible complexity and richness and density of its being. And of course, it speaks to you of the Creator of all things, that whose very nature is to be, right? So all being reflects God. And if you have the eyes to see, that's what the great saints have. They just, they see that all the time. We sinners tend to focus a lot on the lack, right? We focus on the cavity, not the tooth. The idea is look at the tooth. Always acknowledging the cavities, because there are plenty of them.

• 23:29Speaker 02

  But, but the focus should be on being, be in good or convertible terms.

• 23:33Tucker Carlson?

  I may be too shallow for Catholic theology, but I love what you're saying.

• 23:37Speaker 02

  Yeah, but that's as old as-

• 23:38Tucker Carlson?

  Being and good are convertible terms.

• 23:40Speaker 02

  We, they talk about the transcendental properties of being, which means wherever there is, so there's glass. It's good, it's true, and it's beautiful. Now, why is it good? Well, because it corresponds to the will in some ways. There's, you know, yeah, this glass, I want to study this glass. It's interesting and look at the beauty of it, you know? It's true because it corresponds in its intelligibility to an inquiring mind. The mind wants to understand that thing. What is that thing? It's beautiful because it's radiant, you know? It, go back to like James Joyce, the famous scene, you know, in the Portrait of the Artist, when he sees the woman he eventually would marry, Nora Barnacle, and he sees her out on the strand and he has this rapturous description of her, remember? At the end of it, he says, "Oh, heavenly God."

• 24:25Speaker 02

  And that's the way it works, is the beautiful, this particular, this particular girl he sees out in the surf, but she speaks to him of God. So that's why whatever is, is good, it's true, and it's beautiful. Those are all convertible terms.

• 24:39Tucker Carlson?

  It seems like the threat, maybe the satanic threat is distraction.

• 24:44Speaker 02

  Yeah. You know, I think that's absolutely right, that we focus so much on the lack. It's like you're sucking on an aching tooth, you know, you're just, you're focused on the, on the lack. But see, you know, as St. Paul says, "Where sin abounds, grace abounds the more." And that's not just a nice like Hallmark card sentiment, that's a metaphysical truth. Wherever there's sin, sure, sin everywhere, but grace is always greater. It has to be. Because sin is a cavity. You know what? It's in Tolkien, remember when the, what are they? The Nazguls are these, these flying demons, they're threatening the battlefield and all this. But then when they finally conquer them, what they discover, they're nothing. They're a cloak that covers nothing. And it's because evil is a type of non-being.

• 25:27Speaker 02

  And so it, it puts on a big show. It puts this big cloak over itself. But what it is, is just a lack. It's a cavity. That's why if sin is abounding, sure, sin abounds in our world, but grace abounds the more. You know, that's the gates of hell will not prevail against us. They can't in a way. They can't. And we should have that confidence. Christians should never be cowed by evil. Like, oh my, we acknowledge it, but the, the great saints are not cowed by evil. Because evil is a, is a lack. It's a cavity. It's a Nazgul. It's a non-being, right?

• 26:04Tucker Carlson?

  Where do you see grace?

• 26:06Speaker 02

  Um, Bob Dylan is one of my great heroes, you know. Look around this whole world and all that I'm finding is the saving grace that's over me. That's Bob Dylan after he became a Christian. You know, grace is, is being grace is what's real grace. Tout est grâce. That's a line from Bernanos, the great French Catholic novelist. Tout est grâce. Everything's grace. Everything's grace. Because of that principle, whatever is, is good. Whatever is, is true and beautiful. Whatever is reflects the one whose name is to be. Right? When Moses asked God, what's your name? And God says, I am who I am. Right? Well, our tradition reads that as I'm, I'm not contingent evanescent being. I'm the one whose very nature is to be.

• 26:49Speaker 02

  So therefore whatever is, is reflective of, of God. That's where you find grace, I think.

• 26:54Tucker Carlson?

  So if you could distract people sufficient that they never had the time or the inclination to notice things that are real, you would trap them in a kind of hell.

• 27:06Speaker 02

  Yeah. Yes, but see, but that's exactly what happens, isn't it? Dude, now psychodynamically is when we focus on all this kind of lack and anxiety and frustration within us, it is a kind of preoccupation with what's not real. That's true. I'm not denying the psychological reality of suffering, but, but metaphysically speaking, evil is a type of non-being. And if I'm focused on that, then I'm going to get myself in, in knots.

• 27:32Tucker Carlson?

  I was thinking more of the iPhone, which when I use it cuts me off completely from other people and from the world around me, from nature, from myself.

• 27:41Speaker 02

  Yes. No, no, and I believe me, I mean, we're all addicted to it. Those machines were designed to be addictive. They worked. During Lent, this past Lent, I did a resolution for the first time that one day a week I put the phone away. And I did it and it was a little bit of a struggle, but not terrible. And I thought that's, that's a good thing. When we bring our guys now into priesthood studies, we always call the propa dudic year, this year of kind of preparation before the formal study begins. And the thing that all the guys say they like best about it is they take their cell phones away. So for the entire year, I think once a week you can check it for emergencies or something, or someone's got access to it in case of emergency. But they take the phones away from the guys. Great move.

• 28:23Tucker Carlson?

  And what happens to them?

• 28:24Speaker 02

  What happens, they all feel liberated. They all come back saying, it was the best year of my life. And I read books again, and I talked to people. I cultivated friendship. I played games. I played sports. And it's exactly this principle. I wasn't, look at, that's almost an illustration of Augustine's curvatus and say that I'm caved in over my iPhone, right? That's what it looks like.

• 28:49Tucker Carlson?

  Do you think that that's driving some of the disassociation and agony that we see around us?

• 28:56Speaker 02

  Yeah, it's not helping at all. Jean Twenge is this psychologist from San Diego that I read a lot, and she has a book called I Gen, about the generation that came of age totally with iPhones and iPads and stuff. And she said there's a direct correlation between screen time and depression, which I find perfectly plausible. Leonard Sacks, you know, the great psychologist, also a physician dealing with young people now for decades, same thing. He says the correlation between screen time. And look how unhealthy it's making our young kids. When I was a little kid, we were all skinny. We all were, all my friends and I, because we were outside from eight o'clock in the morning until eight o'clock at night in the summertime, playing games, running around, shooting hoops on a bike, you know?

• 29:40Speaker 02

  And way too many kids now are hunched over their iPhones. And then it invites you into such a world of meanness and competition, and look, my picture's better than yours, and those people have seemed so much happier than I am. No, I think taking those things out of the hands of our kids would be a great idea, at least to some degree.

• 30:01Tucker Carlson?

  How do you force yourself to notice things beyond yourself? Like, what is your actual discipline? Like, you wake up, how do you keep God ever-present in mind and yourself at bay?

• 30:11Speaker 02

  Well, my first move is the holy hour. So I learned that from Fulton Sheen, taught now a couple generations to do every day an hour of uninterrupted prayer in the presence of the Blessed Sacrament. So as a Catholic, I have the Blessed Sacrament in my house. So first thing I do in the morning, I get a cup of coffee and I go up to my chapel, and I will sit in front of the Blessed Sacrament for an hour. And I'll pray my office as part of it, often pray the rosary or other things.

• 30:39Tucker Carlson?

  Pardon again my ignorance. What's your office?

• 30:42Speaker 02

  You pray your office? Yeah, that's the Lurgic Hours. Yeah, what I was describing earlier. So that Psalms and Canticles and Readings that a priest- Do you read them as you pray them? Yeah, so I'll have the book and I'll read the Psalm, then usually then spend some time meditating, and then do the next one, you know, and then I might, let's say between the Office of Readings, which has to do with the Church Fathers, I read something from the Church Fathers, and usually from the Bible. Maybe between that and morning prayer, I'll do the rosary. And I might do another form of prayer between morning prayer and midday prayer. So I'll work my way through the Office, the Lurgic Hours, but my main task is to sit in the presence of the Blessed Sacrament. And one of the great lines, this goes back to- And what time is this, in the morning?

• 31:27Speaker 02

  I wake about 5:30, so like between 5:30 and 6:30. Do you text like 11 people first before you do this? No, no, no, no. And I leave the phone in my bedroom, so I always leave the phone while I'm praying. I don't have that. Because that's an immediate distraction, and that's the last thing you want when you're trying to pray in a concentrated way. Yes. And then, you know, some of that too is petitionary prayer. I'm a bishop, so people are always, you know, "Hey, Bishop, would you pray for me? Or my son's having a hard time." And so I try to conjure as best I can the memory of these various people that ask me to pray for them. I'll pray for my, you know, parents and family members who've died, and, you know, so it's just giving yourself the leisure. You have a full hour where you can bring all this before the Lord. When you pray for someone who's died, what do you pray?

• 32:12Speaker 02

  I pray they might find peace and rest. I pray the Lord might be, might be kind and good to them, you know. I pray all the time for people who've died, because, you know, you're just, you're aware of it when you're in pastoral ministry. Yes. You know. Some people who've died, you know, they're not formally canonized by the Church, but I kind of in informal way, I think of them as being already in the presence of God, and I'll pray for their intercession. Cardinal George of Chicago, you know, was a great mentor to me, and I'm often linked to him in prayer. Meaning you pray for him? Pray for him, but also, you know, I prayed to him, not with the complete confidence I would pray into a saint canonized by the church, but with a kind of, you know, practical confidence. And I knew him very well, and I asked for his help.

• 32:58Speaker 02

  When you pray, do you hear back? Not in the, you know, physical sense, but yeah, you get, I'd say a sense. You have a sense of connection, I put it that way. Sometimes in prayer, you get a very intense feeling. The Irish talk about thin places, you know, where the veil between this world and next becomes very thin. There, I find there are kind of thin moments like that, where there's a moment when you feel the other world impinging on yours. What kind of feeling is that? Peace, I would say, you know?

• 33:34Speaker 02

  Harmony, that the disharmony, the difficulty of this life kind of resolved into a higher harmony, something like that.

• 33:43Speaker 02

  See, you know, what's interesting to me, Tucker, is the world that we're in, looking around at this, you know, interesting, beautiful place right now, and good, and the world of nature, driving up here, seeing the nature around me, beautiful, beautiful, but like, is that it? Is that it? To me, it seems so unlikely that the world that the sensorium of these advanced apes can take in is all there is to reality. What my little eyes can see, you know, they see a narrow range of the color spectrum, and that's it? I think that's so wildly unlikely. Just the fecundity and, and variety of being that we experience through, through our senses.

• 34:28Speaker 02

  I think beyond our senses, there's a world of even more extraordinary fecundity and richness, and I think there are times when we sense it, we get in touch with it.

• 34:41Speaker 02

  Look, Plato knew that. Plato knew, he talked about stepping out of the cave, right? And the first step out of the cave, the cave is where you're flickering shadows on the wall. It means the world of our ordinary experience. Yes. I'm here with you right now, and in a few hours, I'll be gone somewhere else, and other images will be flickering past my sensorium. Okay, that's, that's what this life is like. But Plato thought the first step out of the cave was mathematics. It's a very interesting, because when you, you understand two plus three equals five, that's, you've stepped out of this world in a very real way. I can see, oh, here are two things. But when you grasp the, the principle, two plus three equals five, you're not in the

• 35:20Speaker 02

  world of ordinary experience anymore. You're in a world now of eternity, of immateriality, a world that doesn't change, that can't change even in principle. Well, there's nothing like that in this world. Well, Plato knew that. When you grasp the quadratic equation or something, you're not dealing with a physical reality that has color, or shape, or size, or nothing that's, that's even essentia mutable. You've reached a higher plane of existence. Even mathematics does that to us. Aforziori, now philosophy, and then even more so religion, are opening you to higher and higher expressions of reality.

• 35:58Tucker Carlson?

  Here's a fact of life you may not learn until you're older, but I'm going to tell you now. It's very hard to have a good time if you're wearing bad boots. In fact, it may be impossible, and that's why you need Tacovas. As a matter of fact, you don't just need them, you owe them to yourself. Tacovas makes Western boots for everybody. Ranchers, real ranchers, lifelong cowboys, first time boot buyers, and anyone in between. Every Tacovas boot is handcrafted, made by hand, with over 200 meticulous steps for a broken-in feel right out of the box. You don't have to compromise between looks and quality. You can have them both. Whether it's a long day or a big night, Tacovas are built to last and impressed. You wouldn't believe the compliments people here get when they

• 36:39Tucker Carlson?

  wear them out, which they do. Right now, get 10% off at tecovas.com/tucker when you sign up for email and text alerts. That's 10% off at Tacova, T E C O V A S dot com slash Tucker.

• 36:53Speaker 00

  Are you ever shopping online and suddenly a discount that helps you save pops up? It makes your day, sometimes even your week. Want that feeling month after month? Well, new customers who save by switching their home and auto insurance to Progressive save hundreds. Cue your happy dance. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states.

• 37:20Speaker 05

  This podcast is supported by Anthropic, the public benefit corporation behind Claude. Everyone's got a hard question about AI. Anthropic was built to surface those questions and share what it finds along the way because there's hope in hard questions. Ask yours at claude.ai/spotify and keep thinking. That's claude.ai/spotify.

• 37:47Tucker Carlson?

  I don't think you're fully on board with Darwinism. I'm getting that sense.

• 37:51Speaker 02

  Uh, well, there are a couple of ways to look at that. I mean, there's a big debate going on right now in, in the world of evolutionary biologists about Darwin and neo Darwinism and questions raised about it. I mean, in a way, I'm happy to leave that debate to them. I mean, because that's talking about how do life forms develop over time and given genetic variation and, and natural selection. Okay, fine, I'll let the experts debate that.

• 38:19Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 38:20Speaker 02

  That in itself is not really a theologically relevant concern. I'll leave that to them.

• 38:25Tucker Carlson?

  I agree.

• 38:26Speaker 02

  But see, here's the thing. Creation in the theological sense has little to do with that. That's all about development of biological forms. Okay. Creation is something much more dramatic. Creation names the relationship that obtains between unconditioned being and conditioned being, or to put that in more regular language, between God and the world. So I mean, like right now, here you and I are sitting here in this table, in this room, is entirely conditioned form of existence. By which I mean it is, but it doesn't have to be. I could have missed the ride up here today. You could have gotten sick. This thing could have fallen on the table. It could be a thousand degrees and we'd be incinerated.

• 39:10Speaker 02

  It could be a thousand degrees below zero, we'd be frozen. Like there, there are a million things that make this set of affairs real.

• 39:19Speaker 02

  But it doesn't have to be, it doesn't have to be the case. So how do you explain that? Well, you can't appeal endlessly to other contingent things. You have to come, finally, to some reality whose very nature is to be. That's not contingent, not finite, not evanescent, not dependent, but whose very nature is to be. I am, right, then go back to Moses, what's your name? See, Moses was asking a very sensible question for this worldly perspective. So, hey, what kind of glass is that? You know, how tall is that glass? What kind of table is this? A nice table, what kind of table is it? So you're a God, obviously, you know, you seem to know a lot about me and you're... So which one are you? You're the God of the mountain, you're God of the place, are you God of these people?

• 40:04Speaker 02

  Who are you? Which one are you? What's your name? And so when God says, "I am who I am," he's saying, dumb question. That is not the right question to ask here. Because I'm not a conditioned state of affairs. I'm not a being among many. My name is I am. I am who I am, right? My nature is to be. Well, now we're talking about the Creator. See, the Creator is the one who is here and now undergirding all the finite reality. Who is right now, this is a great line from Herbert McCabe, the theologian. He's singing the world into being, the way an opera singer sustains a song.

• 40:46Speaker 02

  God, the ground of being, is singing this finite world into being. That's creation, see? So now, within creation, I can talk all day about the Darwinist and how this life form developed into that life form, and I'll let them debate that. But the religious question remains, no matter what you say about that. The religious question is about, why is there something rather than nothing? Right, exactly. But why should there be a finite conditioned world at all? You can't explain it by appealing endlessly to other forms of conditioned existence. You can't. That's the mistake of materialism, let's say. So the questions end at a certain point and there's an answer. So the question is, well, who created?

• 41:26Tucker Carlson?

  The Creator, and the answer is, nobody. The Creator is.

• 41:29Speaker 02

  Right, and if you ask that question, it means you haven't grasped the solution. If you say, "Who created the Creator?", well, then you haven't grasped, no. The argument leads towards something that doesn't need to be created, that can't be created, whose very nature is to be, and who therefore is eternal, we say, outside of time, immaterial outside of space, right? So, all the finite things that are the characteristics of finite reality can't apply to that reality. That's why we say God's eternal, or why he's immaterial and so on, immutable. That means nothing that characterizes finite things should characterize him.

• 42:05Speaker 02

  What do you think of the new atheists? I don't like them.

• 42:10Speaker 02

  No, look, my ministry, Word on Fire, emerged around that time, so, right around the year 2000. The new atheists emerged after September 11th, which is not surprising, because September 11th stirred to life again, this old kind of enlightenment idea. Religion is irrational, therefore it's violent. Because they can't settle things through argument, they have to settle them through bombs and guns and war, right? So, that's an old argument, goes back to the 17th century. It was revived massively after September 11th. The new atheists, I think, rode that wave in a big way. Now, they were gifted rhetoricians, especially Hitchens, right? I admire Hitchens, I read Hitchens always with great pleasure.

• 42:55Speaker 02

  Dawkins, less so. Sam Harris, I think, has rhetorical gifts, but their arguments, there's nothing new about them, they were old hat, they're borrowed from Marx and from Freud and from Feuerbach especially. So, nothing new at the intellectual level. They were new in their nastiness. So, the classical atheists, think Feuerbach, Marx, Freud, you got the sense they knew they were dealing with a formidable opponent when they were fighting religion. The new atheists, it was like they were dealing with an idiot child, you know? And so, that's what was so annoying about them, I thought, and their arguments were pretty bad, and they were, you know, so aggressive toward religion. They did a great service, though, I'll say this, they awakened the Christian churches

• 43:40Speaker 02

  in many ways. The apologetic weapons that we threw away 40 years ago, we were compelled to pick up again. So a lot of us got into the game to kind of battle the new atheists and to draw upon the very rich intellectual tradition, especially of Catholicism. So in that way, they did a service to us, you know? And also, I wrote a paper on this one. I called it, "Thomas Aquinas and Why the New Atheists Are Right," because the new atheists, they make this mistake we were just talking about. They will construe God as some kind of big being. And, okay, is there this big being or not? Some say there is, some say there isn't. So it's like Bigfoot, you know, something, there is a Bigfoot, others say there isn't

• 44:23Speaker 02

  a Bigfoot. Let's go look around for evidence and find out. Well, you'll never find God that way. God isn't a being. God isn't, isn't a thing in the world, right? He's the reason why there's a world at all. Therefore, you're not going to find him in the world. Therefore, you can't say things like, oh, there's no, there's no evidence for God, as though he's like a, he's a chemical reaction. Yeah, the Yeti, yeah. Right. He's not like that. You have to ask a whole different set of questions. And that's what the new atheists did. Like, like what? What were the questions? Like, why is there something rather than nothing? Like, why should contingent being exist at all? How do you explain the to be of something whose nature is not to be,

• 45:04Speaker 02

  namely, you and me and everything around us? I am, for sure, but my nature is not to be. I could think myself out of being in a second. There's nothing necessary about me. Well, how do you explain that? How do you explain that? Now, you say, oh, it's all matter and energy. It'll never work. Why? Because matter is always matter under these conditions, matter in this size, matter of this energy, matter at this speed, matter of this color. How did it get there? Why is it this rather than that? See, so you can't answer that question, the really cool, interesting question, by appealing to something within the contingent world. You have to go outside the contingent world.

• 45:43Speaker 02

  And again, don't think of that spatially. The minute you go, oh yeah, God must be that up, out there someplace. No, you have made him a big being. You have to go outside in the metaphysical sense to a reality which indeed contains all of that, but is in no way contained by it. Now we're talking. And that to me is really interesting question.

• 46:04Tucker Carlson?

  What also suggested that God's like right here, right now, always.

• 46:09Speaker 02

  Well, he is. And here's the interesting thing, and all the mystics and theologians around this. So is God in this room? No, absolutely not. Because this room is just full of contingent things, like you and me and the shelves and the books. And no, no, God, God's nothing in this. I can't point, oh, there he is. God's in this room. God's nowhere in this room. Is God in this room? Yes, he's everywhere in this room, because this room wouldn't exist unless God were singing it into being. And so God is, at the same time, as transcendent as you can imagine, not a thing in the world, and as eminent as you can imagine. It was

• 46:48Speaker 02

  the great Augustine who said, "God is, at the same time, superior sumo meo et interior intimo meo," which means he's higher than anything I can imagine, and he's closer to me than I am to myself. Now, figure that one out. Now, now you understand the God whose nature is to be. He's transcendent. I can't grasp him. And he's so eminent, I can't hide from him. See? And that's the space opened up by the Bible, I think. So what's the solution, you might ask? The solution is fall in love with God. Falling in love is not grasping, it's not hiding from. And can we read the Bible as God trying to draw

• 47:29Speaker 02

  his people into that space? I want you to fall in love with me. I don't want you grasping at me. That's idolatry. I don't want you hiding from me. That's secularism. I want you falling in love with me. And that's the right reaction to the God. You're defining secularism as hiding from God? Yeah, as an ideology. If you were to say, all that there is is the secular world, right? As a materialism, or immanentism, or scientism, in the political sense, secularism, meaning all that there is is the world that I can see and measure and so on. That's hiding from God. That's saying, I'm not worried about God. God doesn't impinge upon me. That's the buffered self. Charles Taylor, the philosopher, calls it that. I'm buffered from any contact with the transcendent. That's an attempt to hide from God. Doesn't work.

• 48:14Speaker 02

  And see, what I think, Tucker, is really interesting, is the fact that religion is experiencing a revival, even as we speak. You feel that? Oh, yeah, I can, I can measure it. It's been measured statistically. Because you can't hide from God all day. And you can't grasp it on that's idolatry. Idolatry is to manipulate God. And the Bible knows all about that from page one. Page one, the Bible knows about manipulating God.

• 48:40Speaker 02

  Tell me what you mean by that. Let's say the original sin is to say, I'm not going to obey God's law. I'm going to make I'm my own law. I'm going to grasp the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Is I'm going to make my, my own freedom, as we were saying a few minutes ago, my own freedom becomes my God. That's a type of idolatry. Or I turn pleasure, money, sex, power into my supreme good. That's idolatry. To me, the great biblical story there is the Elijah and the priests of Baal. Remember in the first book of Kings? So Elijah is the one left, only one priest of Yahweh. But there's all these priests of Baal. By the way, so it always goes, right? There's always a lot of avatars of the false gods are all over the place. They're thick on the ground. They're all over. And now

• 49:24Speaker 02

  let's you erect altars to your God, I'll erect one to mine, and let's see who responds, right? So the priests of Baal erect the altars, and then they start begging, and they end up cajoling and pleading. And, and they're frustrated, because God's not answering. Their gods aren't sending fire. And Elijah mocks them, which I think is a great part of that story. He publicly mocks them, you know, who knows, maybe your gods are napping, or maybe they're in the bathroom. I don't know where they are, right? And then they finally end up, it's a beautiful detail. They end up slashing themselves with knives. They're trying to, they're trying to get the gods to respond. It's beautiful image of what happens to us in idolatry. We end up harming ourselves, right? In a frenzied attempt to get gods to answer, who can never in principle answer.

• 50:07Speaker 02

  Now think of someone addicted to power, sex, money, pleasure, whatever it is. And begging, begging, begging, you, you will satisfy me. They, it won't because it can't. And I'll end up harming myself. Then Elijah calls upon the true God. The fire comes, this rise, you know, takes the sacrifice. It's not just a jingoistic story. It's a very powerful story that the true God is the only one that can satisfy the longing of the heart. Right? And so idolatry will always lead us down this self-destructive path. And the worship of the true God is what's going to lead us to the fire falling on us.

• 50:47Tucker Carlson?

  A lot of the news you read doesn't really have a lot of inherent meaning, but this does. Starting May 19th, the Hallow app is leading a consecration to Jesus through St. Joseph. You might be asking, why St. Joseph? Why now? Well, consider this, Joseph was the man God himself trusted with his own son. He wasn't a king or a warrior. He was a carpenter. He was a quiet and steady man of unshakable faith. In an age that mocks humility, can you imagine the basis of wisdom and a relationship with God is time we looked to someone who embodied humility, not for applause, but for God. This series is not just about St. Joseph. It's about what happens when you follow his example, when you trade noise for silence,

• 51:30Tucker Carlson?

  when you stop chasing relevance and start seeking holiness. And all of that begins with humility, which is really just perspective. You are not God. It's important to remind yourself of that. We do every day. So every week on Hallow, you'll hear reflections grounded in the gospels, pray powerful prayers like the litany of St. Joseph, and hear glory stories from throughout church history, not myths, not legends, actual intersections and power from a saint who's been quietly helping people for thousands of years. Hallow is the world's number one prayer app and experiences like this are why my family and I cannot get enough of it. It is a constant down table conversation. So get three months right now at hallow.com/tucker for free. You'll be glad you did. Hallow.com/tucker.

• 52:13Speaker 00

  Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions.

• 52:44Speaker 05

  Now for a quick message from Anthropic, the team behind Claude, the AI built for businesses. Customers count on their bank, and banks count on their most important systems. Now those systems count on Claude, and nine of the Fortune 10 companies use it for critical work. See why leading companies trust Claude at claude.ai/span.

• 53:08Speaker 02

  Why does God require sacrifice? He doesn't require it, and that's a super important point. The Bible and the great tradition make it over and over again. How could the one who made the entire universe from nothing possibly need anything from it? Right? And it's just a logical contradiction. See, like the ancient gods of Greece, sure, they need all kinds of stuff. Remember that scene, it's in The Odyssey, I think, you know, where as the sacrifices are being made and the gods are like desperately lapping up the blood of the sacrifice because they need our, you know, our loyalty and so on. The Bible, Psalm 50. You think I need, you

• 53:52Speaker 02

  think I drank the blood of goats? Are you joking? All the animals in the field, they all belong to me. So, but that's a very important point because it's not that we're playing some game of like codependency with God. God needs nothing. That's the best news ever. God needs nothing from us. What he wants is...

• 54:12Speaker 02

  The openness of heart signaled by the sacrifice because he wants us to be alive. And when we say, Lord, I'm opening my heart to you. I'm ordering my life to you in this great sacrifice of praise. God delights because now we're gonna find the joy he wants us to have. That's Saint Irenaeus, my great intellectual hero. The glory of God is a human being fully alive. See, the glory of God is not putting us down and, boy, they finally got around honoring me sufficiently. So that's old paganism, but it haunts the Christian mind still. It haunts our minds, but the Bible is always trying to dismiss that demon.

• 54:57Speaker 02

  God wants our sacrifice because it's good for us. God gets nothing out of it. Think of it, it like it bounces off of the rock of the divine self-sufficiency and comes back to our benefit. So when I pray to God or I offer the sacrifice of the Mass to God, I'm not giving God anything he needs. God needs nothing, but it bounces off of that self-sufficiency to me. It redounds to my benefit. So go into the Catholic Mass. We offer the sacrifice of Jesus to the Father. We re-present the sacrifice of the cross of the Father. Oh, because the Father needs it. The Father needs nothing, but it bounces off of the Father's self-sufficiency and comes back as food for us.

• 55:42Speaker 02

  So now we eat, we eat the body and drink the blood of Jesus. We consume the sacrifice. It's for our benefit, not for God's. But your question is really a good one because it leads us into that very important spiritual space.

• 55:57Tucker Carlson?

  One of the reasons I think Christianity is true is because so many people hate it.

• 56:01Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 56:02Tucker Carlson?

  And Jesus is really the great dividing.

• 56:05Speaker 02

  He always has been.

• 56:07Tucker Carlson?

  Yeah. And like, why would you be mad at Jesus or Christianity when it's like a nonviolent religion that teaches people to love each other? If you're mad at that, it says something about how real it is, I think.

• 56:21Speaker 02

  I agree. Both Billy Graham and Fulton Sheen, I mean, arguably the two greatest evangelists of the 20th century, said the same thing, which was the objection to God is rarely truly intellectual. It's a moral objection.

• 56:33Tucker Carlson?

  Totally.

• 56:35Speaker 02

  The moral demand of God, it becomes too great. See, Jesus, if he's one spiritual figure among many, he's a great teacher, you know, like the Buddha, he's like Muhammad, he's like Confucius. Well, then I can kind of handle him, you know, I can put him in a corner and say, okay, that's interesting. I'll abide by some of that. And I also like what the Sufi mystics say, and I also like what Moses says here. But see, Jesus, as C.S. Lewis saw so perfectly, you know, is qualitatively different than that. And that's why he's a problem. Because if he is who he says he is, not just one teacher that I can listen to, but he's God from God, light from light, true God from true God, begot not made, consubstantial with the Father, as we say every week in the Creed.

• 57:19Tucker Carlson?

  Through him, all things were made.

• 57:21Speaker 02

  Yeah. If that's who he is, well, the game's over.

• 57:24Tucker Carlson?

  But why does it make people mad? I mean, one of the late life revelations in my life has been that these great spasms of violence, these revolutions that we study, French Revolution, Spanish Civil War, Bolshevik Revolution, 1917, huge parts of World War II, were anti-Christian.

• 57:41Speaker 02

  Absolutely.

• 57:41Tucker Carlson?

  The point was to murder Christians.

• 57:43Speaker 02

  Absolutely.

• 57:43Tucker Carlson?

  But it's not recorded that way.

• 57:45Speaker 02

  Yeah, but that's, no, that's true. Yeah, but see, Jesus, he's a problem because of who he says he is, but also we're sinners. And so sinners don't want to get out of their sinful patterns. They're way too comfortable. It's like the Israelites that want to go back to Egypt, right? They're, they're on their way to liberation, but oh, boy, did we love the, you know, the flesh pots of Egypt. At least we had cucumbers and, right?

• 58:08Tucker Carlson?

  That's my favorite part.

• 58:09Speaker 02

  Right. But, but see, that's the story of every sinner is every sin is a type of addiction. You're addicted to, you know, that's the principle. And so as I'm trying to move toward conversion, I'm moving across the painful desert, right? On the way to the promised land, I'm always hankering for Egypt. And so Jesus is a constant reproach, a constant challenge, a constant no, no, you know? So of course I'm gonna, I'm gonna resist him. Look at, you know, the very fact, I think this is very interesting. Mohammed dies in his bed full of years. The Buddha dies in his bed full of years, surrounded by his disciples. Confucius, the same thing. Moses dies at the age of 120 or something, you know?

• 58:49Speaker 02

  And then there's Jesus, who dies 30 years old, naked, pinned to a desperate instrument of torture. His, his disciples having abandoned him, his enemies mocking him. That's how he dies. Now, what does it tell you? It tells you, there's something about him.

• 59:07Tucker Carlson?

  Well, who would write that? By the way, if I, if I'm trying to create a new religion.

• 59:10Speaker 02

  No way.

• 59:11Tucker Carlson?

  He is not the hero I'm creating at all.

• 59:13Speaker 02

  No, but it's a sign, he's a sign of contradiction. He's the one that, that, that's the way the world is going to react to him. Now, what's the good news? The good news is, having endured all of that, he returns. And I always think of this, you know, if we were, Hollywood's telling the story. You never, you never heard the Jesus story, but here's this guy with this horrible thing and these people betrayed him and denied him and they crucified him. And now he's back. He'll be back with a machine gun. I'm back for vengeance. He's back with shalom, a word of peace. And the way I put it in Christianity is this, we killed God and God returned in forgiving love. And that's why, as Paul said, right?

• 59:54Speaker 02

  I'm certain neither death nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor height, nor depth, nor anything else could ever separate us from love of God. How does Paul know that? Because, because we killed God and God returned in forgiving love. That's salvation. That's, that's the word of grace, if you want. That's the good news. That's what they went careering around the world to their deaths proclaiming was that. You know, Paul, I preach one thing, Christ and Him crucified. Because that's the message is we killed him, God raised him up and he returned in forgiving love. You know, that's the, that's the good news.

• 1:00:32Tucker Carlson?

  Do you think that Christian persecution is on the rise?

• 1:00:36Speaker 02

  Oh, I know it is. It's documented. 20th century was the worst century for Christian martyrs of all of Christian history, all the previous centuries combined. There were more martyrs in the 20th century than any other time. We think about the early church, they were all being persecuted. Far greater 20th century. Now, around the world, we are by far the most persecuted religion. Absolutely. And it's a, it's a crime. It's an outrage. And we talk about, in a kind of demure way, about religious liberty in our country, which is indeed under threat. But you want the real threat to religious liberty. It's in different parts of the world. People are being killed for their Christian faith.

• 1:01:10Tucker Carlson?

  So why is that fact suppressed? That is intentionally suppressed? Again, I was like 45 before I realized the Bolshevik revolution was aimed at Christians. I don't know why I didn't get that, but I didn't.

• 1:01:21Speaker 02

  Yeah, I have to ask the, you know, the keepers of the flame culturally, but it's simply the case today. I mean, it's, it's the most persecuted religion. You know, we can look at things from different angles, I suppose. One tragedy, let's say the 20th century, if you have World War I and World War II, yes, there's, there are anti-Christian elements, to be sure. I mean, Hitler is deeply anti-Christian. But you also had French Christians killing German Christians, killing Canadian Christians, killing American Christians, killing Russian Christians. It said it was this massive Christian slaughter bench. And my pet theory is, when you go to Europe today, especially parts of Europe, and you see a kind of spiritual

• 1:02:06Speaker 02

  wasteland. I think that's a big part of it is.

• 1:02:09Tucker Carlson?

  I agree completely.

• 1:02:10Speaker 02

  We're just recovering from this, this horrific outbreak of Christian on Christian violence. The gospel, did that get into anybody's mind and heart in the 20th century? That allowed this orgy of violence to take place?

• 1:02:26Tucker Carlson?

  What, what do you think that was? Why the 20th century?

• 1:02:30Speaker 02

  Well, you do a

• 1:02:31Tucker Carlson?

  So much darker than anything that happened in the dark ages.

• 1:02:33Speaker 02

  You could do the Leo the 13th, you know, who gave us the Saint Michael prayer and who supposedly had a intuition or a sense that the 20th century would belong to the devil. And to my mind, it's kind of hard to argue with that. If you believe in the devil, as I do, and you see what happened in the 20th century, it's kind of hard to imagine it wasn't to some degree.

• 1:02:55Tucker Carlson?

  Well, nuclear weapons are proof, as far as I can.

• 1:02:57Speaker 02

  Yeah, I know. The mass destruction, mass death of the 20th century. It's hard to blame that simply on political reality.

• 1:03:05Tucker Carlson?

  Totally. I'm sorry, I interrupted you. I'm so sorry. You said Pope Leo the 13th?

• 1:03:11Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 1:03:12Tucker Carlson?

  Had, can you explain what you mean, he had this sense?

• 1:03:14Speaker 02

  He had a mystical experience of the devil would have a unique control over the 20th century. And so he formulates the famous Saint Michael prayer that we still pray in many churches, asking for the protection of Michael the Archangel.

• 1:03:27Tucker Carlson?

  When did he have this experience?

• 1:03:29Speaker 02

  Till the end of his life. So he died 1903. So it would have been like around 1900, so late 19th century. And many would say, well, it was borne out by the 20th century.

• 1:03:40Tucker Carlson?

  I would.

• 1:03:41Speaker 02

  Like, you know, for me, in my own lifetime, it, see, when I was a young guy going through school, we were still very much formed by more liberal Catholic view. The devil, literary device, literature is a symbol, you know, for evil. Don't take it literally.

• 1:03:56Tucker Carlson?

  You were taught that?

• 1:03:57Speaker 02

  Yeah. It was sort of the standard view. But you know what really convinced me powerfully of the devil's reality was the sex abuse scandal. Because you look at the sex abuse scandal, which has haunted almost the whole of my priesthood. It broke in Chicago in the early 90s. I was ordained in 1986. So most of my priesthood has been under the shadow. The clergy sex abuse scandal has adversely affected the church in every possible way. And when you look at it and you say, Could that have just been a accident or just human folly and sin? It seemed to have been so designed by a wicked mind that wanted to undermine the church.

• 1:04:40Speaker 02

  But then, now look at the whole 20th century and the level of destruction and degradation. It's hard for me to imagine it's just because of political forces or cultural.

• 1:04:52Tucker Carlson?

  I couldn't agree more. I've come to this conclusion recently, but I think you're exactly right. So what's the St. Michael's Prayer that was?

• 1:04:58Speaker 02

  St. Michael, the archangel, defend us in battle. I won't get it exactly right, but it's an invocation of St. Michael to defend us in battle against the devil who sends his minions for the destruction of souls. So it's a very conscious awareness of the presence of evil in the world and we're asking.

• 1:05:13Tucker Carlson?

  And Pope Leo said, the 13th said, I think this century is going to be done.

• 1:05:16Speaker 02

  Yeah, it belonged to the devil. And he formulated that prayer to be prayed in Catholic churches.

• 1:05:20Tucker Carlson?

  What do people say when he said that?

• 1:05:22Speaker 02

  I think most of them, I follow them. I think most said, we start saying this prayer.

• 1:05:25Tucker Carlson?

  Because I mean, 1903 was a period of great hope in the West.

• 1:05:28Speaker 02

  Yes, which is fascinating to me, you know, there's a magazine called The Christian Century. It's a Christian theological journal and it was born at that time. And that's always the idea is this is the Christian century.

• 1:05:40Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 1:05:41Speaker 02

  That, you know, progress and economic progress and political.

• 1:05:44Tucker Carlson?

  Dominating the world.

• 1:05:44Speaker 02

  And the social gospel and this is our century. And then it didn't exactly work out that way. Leo intuited or had a mystical experience to the effect that it would belong not to the Christian churches, but to the devil. So, you know, we got a battle on our hands, but we mustn't forget what we were saying earlier, you know, where sin abounds, grace abounds the more. The gates of hell will not prevail against the church. You know, that image too, I don't know why, but for most of my life, I am, okay, the gates of hell will not prevail against it, which means somehow hell is going to come against us, but we're going to win the battle. But that's not what it means. The gates would be the weakest point of a city wall. And so when you're attacking a city, you go after the gates.

• 1:06:30Speaker 02

  So what the Lord is saying is, no, no, you're not defensive here. You're on the march. You're on the offensive and the gates of hell will not prevail against you. You're going to win. You're invading hell and it's not going to prevail against you. So it's like not a cowering like, oh, we'll put up a good defense and I guess we're gonna

• 1:06:49Tucker Carlson?

  Or move as far away from hell as we can.

• 1:06:51Speaker 02

  We are on the march.

• 1:06:53Tucker Carlson?

  Move to the suburbs.

• 1:06:53Speaker 02

  No, but see, one of the problems is when Christians forget that and they hand the world over to pure secularism or whatever, well, of course, we're not going to do well in the battle. But when Christians know, no, our job is to be fully engaged in this great struggle and we're going after you, hell. We're coming after hatred, violence, stupidity, superstition, scapegoating. We're going after you. We're on the march. When I was coming of age, we didn't have that language. Why? It was an attempt. I know because the people that taught me were good people and they were, they were positively motivated. I know that for sure. They felt the church needed

• 1:07:38Speaker 02

  to be relevant to the modern world and that the modern world should set the agenda for the church. That was a big part of the mentality, that we had been in a fortress too long. We'd been in a defensive crouch. We had demonized the world and so now we need to go out to the world in a confident spirit. And that's definitely the Catholicism I got as a young man. But see, here's something I've always found kind of puzzling. So I come of age right after the Second Vatican Council, which ended 1965. I went to first grade in 1966, right? So that's the church that I inherited very much. Vatican II was written by people who had experienced the worst of the 20th century.

• 1:08:21Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 1:08:22Speaker 02

  Mostly European intellectuals, French, German, a lot of them, Americans too, some Italians, Swiss, right, are the people that wrote Vatican II.

• 1:08:31Speaker 02

  And they experienced some of the worst horrors in human history.

• 1:08:35Tucker Carlson?

  So Vatican II is a direct response to the Second World War?

• 1:08:38Speaker 02

  No, I wouldn't say that. Vatican II, look, I, I, I, let me talk about it positively. Vatican II was a missionary council. I think the best people at Vatican II felt the church has been crouching behind walls for too long and it should go out, not to conform to the modern world, but to go out to convert the modern world. It's how do we get the church to engage modernity in a confident spirit? I think that people like De Lubac and von Baltasar and Voitewa and Ratzinger, these people, that's what they had in mind, you know? Now, what the church became after the council, that's a different story. What developed after the council, that's the church that I came of age in. And I think that was a

• 1:09:22Speaker 02

  too apologetic church. That was a church that in fact, lost the missionary edge. It was more of the, you know, conformity to the world. The world sets the agenda for us. That was a distortion of Vatican II. But that's the church that formed a lot of people in my generation.

• 1:09:38Tucker Carlson?

  Do you think that the sex abuse, the sex abuse was a result of Vatican II?

• 1:09:44Speaker 02

  Not Vatican II per se. I would say more the result of the sexual revolution and of a loosening of moral strictures. There was, I, I sensed as easy, even as a young man, there was a sense of, you know, we've repressed stuff too long and we really need to be more expressive and there's too much of this obsession with, you know, sexual sin. And so, and then the whole culture was, you know, going through a sexual revolution and, you know, stop repressing and, you know, be yourself and express what you're feeling. And I think a lot of priests frankly, got caught up in that cultural movement. And because we can measure it. The sex abuse, the clergy sex abuse spiked by the seventies into the

• 1:10:29Speaker 02

  very early eighties and then it began going down. And then after 2002, when the church put in all kinds of important restrictions, the so-called Dallas Accords being first among them, it's fallen off the table. The statistics have gone completely down. So we can measure a spiking of it right at the height of the sexual revolution. I think that's responsible for a lot of it.

• 1:10:51Tucker Carlson?

  What were the changes wrought by Vatican II? There was famously, you know, the change in language of the Mass from Latin to colloquial. But I learned recently that there were what seemed like theological changes to church doctrine. Is that fair?

• 1:11:06Speaker 02

  No, not really. I would say there was development of doctrine. I'm using John Henry Newman's language there. Newman says that doctrine is not just handed out like a football, you know, from one generation to the other. It unfolds more like a river expanding or like a tree growing. Like, so doctrine doesn't turn back on itself, but it can grow and express itself in fresh ways. For example, the ecclesiology of Vatican II, the understanding of the church and its nature underwent a real development at Vatican II. Moving away from a, let's say, highly juridical to a more organic sense of the church. The church not crouching defensively, but the church going out in a confident missionary spirit.

• 1:11:51Speaker 02

  The church as the people of God, not just the hierarchy. All of that stuff would be emphases within Vatican II. They represent not a repudiation of the previous ecclesiology, but a development of it. The role of the laity in the world, that's a role from the beginning of the church, but had been muted. Prior to the council, laity were, you know, come to Mass on Sunday, yes, and say your prayers and donate to the church and all that. Where Vatican II said, no, your job is to christify the world. You're meant to go out into business, finance, entertainment, sports, education, everything, and christify the world. Well, that's a real development. I say a healthy development of doctrine.

• 1:12:27Tucker Carlson?

  I agree.

• 1:12:27Speaker 02

  At Vatican II. So that's how I read it. And again, do Vatican II, but then the post-conciliar period, which was often not all that faithful to Vatican II. It would be more faithful to the spirit of the world.

• 1:12:39Tucker Carlson?

  Were there any changes to the way the gospel story was told?

• 1:12:43Speaker 02

  Well, no, except, you know, the vernacular at the mass makes the whole liturgy more accessible to people. I think, I don't even know, because it's before my time, that the gospel was still read, I think, in the vernacular before the council. We got greater exposure to the Bible. After Vatican II, they opened up more of the Bible to us. But I don't think the way the gospel story was told, I don't think that changed.

• 1:13:08Tucker Carlson?

  The church seems to be readjusting in a new direction now. Is that fair?

• 1:13:14Speaker 02

  With Pope Leo, you mean?

• 1:13:16Tucker Carlson?

  Well, that just happened. No, but I mean, well, I'll just be totally blunt. So the Catholic Church got, in American political terms, which are a pretty limited way to describe it, but got super liberal, the Jesuits, the Marianoles, pretty liberal, is my non-Catholic perspective. And then all of a sudden, everywhere you look, people you know are converting to Catholicism with a pretty kind of traditionally Christian orientation. Is that real, do you think?

• 1:13:39Speaker 02

  Yeah, I think that's going on today. You know, we have to go back, let's say, to when I was a kid, there was that liberalization, for sure. And what I was describing is, you know, the church or the world setting the agenda for the church, that's kind of a liberal move. A tendency, and this is how I would characterize ecclesial liberalism, a tendency to reduce the supernatural to the natural. So instead of emphasizing the supernatural dimension, God, Trinity, grace, salvation, Jesus, cross, resurrection, eternal life, right? A tendency to say, what the church is really all about is, you know, social justice and racial justice and economic justice and so on. Where indeed, those are implications from our doctrine. And indeed, the church is interested in transforming the world, true.

• 1:14:23Speaker 02

  But the liberal tendency is to reduce the supernatural to the natural. That was going on for a long time, yes. And the change commenced really with, like, John Paul II. It's been happening now for many decades. In very recent years, to your point, I think, yes, there's been a keener interest in The supernatural dimension of the faith.

• 1:14:44Tucker Carlson?

  Why would you go to church if it's not supernatural?

• 1:14:47Speaker 02

  Which is a darn good question. But see, again, the instinct, I get it. All my teachers felt this way when I was a kid. It, well, we don't want to be irrelevant. You know, the church is all about the world and we're engaged and we're not just, you know, running off to heaven or pie in the sky when you die. And they tended to think of it in a very dualistic way.

• 1:15:07Tucker Carlson?

  Why? What? That's such an interesting, it's kind of the last impulse you would think in someone who's devoted his life to, you know, being a member of the clergy.

• 1:15:17Speaker 02

  Yeah, I kind of share your puzzlement in a way with it, but it was the church that I took in as a kid.

• 1:15:23Tucker Carlson?

  But it was not just the Catholics who did this.

• 1:15:25Speaker 02

  No, right, no, right.

• 1:15:26Tucker Carlson?

  Totally eliminated mainstream Protestantism with these ideas.

• 1:15:30Speaker 02

  Yes, and we keep, you know, analyzing the thing too, is, is the supernatural during the modern period and then into the postmodern period, is subject to a withering criticism, you know, on the part of secularist rationalists. The scientistic mentality and materialistic mentality. So if you accept that criticism, like all the supernatural, you know, mumbo jumbo. So what's left is, well, it's, you know, moral commitment.

• 1:15:55Tucker Carlson?

  We're good people.

• 1:15:55Speaker 02

  The other thing, if you want to do it philosophically, the influence of Immanuel Kant and, uh, I might be boring your audience with this, but Immanuel Kant, late 18th century, the most influential of the modern philosophers, writes a book called Religion Within the Limits of Reason Alone. Extremely important text.

• 1:16:14Tucker Carlson?

  Hilarious title.

• 1:16:15Speaker 02

  Yes, actually it is.

• 1:16:17Tucker Carlson?

  It's if you can have a religion within the limits of reason.

• 1:16:19Speaker 02

  Right, but that's

• 1:16:20Tucker Carlson?

  So funny.

• 1:16:20Speaker 02

  He's an enlightenment figure. Think, think Thomas Jefferson.

• 1:16:23Tucker Carlson?

  Yeah.

• 1:16:23Speaker 02

  Cutting all the supernatural parts out of the Bible, right? Same instinct. But Kant said, religion is finally all about being an ethically upright person. And so worship and liturgy and doctrine and miracles and all that. Fine, fine, fine. If it leads you to moral, you know, rectitude. Well, see, I think we drank deeply from the wells of Kantianism. A lot of Christians did. And they said, well, all right, you know, when push comes to shove, what it's really all about is, am I a dead Decated person. And that now, because of the critique of sexual morality, took the form of social justice morality. So the way you prove that you're a religious person is not, do I believe in the Trinity so much? It's, am I committed to social justice? I

• 1:17:07Speaker 02

  think it's a sort of popular Kantianism that was imbibed by the Christian churches, very much including my own.

• 1:17:13Tucker Carlson?

  Interesting. And again, it completely destroyed American Protestantism.

• 1:17:17Speaker 02

  Yes, no, quite right. I completely agree with that. And we see the, it's heartbreaking, really. We see the ruins of Christian churches because of that Kantian move.

• 1:17:26Tucker Carlson?

  Literally the ru-, I mean, it's the physical ruins, like the roof has fallen and no one's going.

• 1:17:31Speaker 02

  Yes. Because again, to your point, why would they bother? If you're, you know, you're a dedicated political person and your political party is focused on these things too, why would you need to go to church to talk about, you know? No, it was a disaster of the last about 50 years in our, in the Christian churches.

• 1:17:47Tucker Carlson?

  And do you feel like that's changing in the Catholic Church?

• 1:17:52Speaker 02

  Yes. No, I do. I do. See, the supernatural has a way of reasserting itself that, that

• 1:17:59Tucker Carlson?

  Being supernatural, right.

• 1:18:01Speaker 02

  Yes. It's death has been predicted so many times in so many different circles. Enlightenment, most famously, but look, the Enlightenment was a long time ago and religion's still around. I have an internet ministry and I, you know, I used to do it more. I'd go on the comment sections and respond to people, but you still hear it. People say, you know, religion, it's, it's days are numbered. I think, oh buddy, they've been saying that for like hundreds of years and it's not worked out, you know? But it's still this, this prejudice that, you know, somehow, science and, you know, we're going to knock religion out. Religion keeps reasserting itself for all the reasons we were saying in the first part of our conversation. See, all those spiritual and metaphysical truths, they don't go away. We can, we can

• 1:18:43Speaker 02

  hope they go away or pretend they go away, but they don't go away. They reassert themselves. And the deepest reason is we're made in the image and likeness of God. So there's a hunger in us for God. And so that's why it's reasserting itself even now.

• 1:18:58Tucker Carlson?

  You often hear, and it's accepted uncritically, or was when I was a kid anyway, that religion, Christianity, leads to violence.

• 1:19:06Speaker 02

  Right.

• 1:19:06Tucker Carlson?

  You know, and that was really the drive, I mean, Hitchens, who I knew well, that was his main argument. People get, you know, inflexible when they believe in the supernatural, and they have to kill anyone who disagrees. But does the historical record support that claim?

• 1:19:21Speaker 02

  No. And of course, that's a great myth. There was a book done some years ago, I forget the title of it now, but a guy that did a very careful study of all the great wars, going back, you know, like a couple thousand years. And the conclusion was something like 8% could be traced to a religious cause. But that's part of Enlightenment historiography. It's one of the myths of Enlightenment historiography, that religion is the problem. And see, it's the origin myth of modernity. Modernity emerged out of the myths of a superstitious religion and out of a primitive pre-science, let's say. And so, we have to regularly bring out these sort of boogeymen to knock down again, like, yeah, religion, bad.

• 1:20:02Speaker 02

  Superstition, bad. And look at now, this Enlightenment, reason, Enlightenment. But no, that's all simplistic, you know. And it betrays a deep lack of appreciation for the intellectual tradition within the religious sphere. But that's part of the way they've told the story. And of course, may I say too about violence. I always have to smile when people, "Oh, religion is a source of violence." Give me a break. Look at the 20th century. I mean, the corpses piled up in the 20th century, and it was not religion that did it. It was deeply anti-religious ideologies.

• 1:20:39Tucker Carlson?

  It was murdering religious people.

• 1:20:41Speaker 02

  I mean, I'll take lectures on violence from many people, but not from the avatars of modern secularism, you know. And sure, there's distortions of religion and bad religious people that did things in its name. But you can't talk about the risen Jesus, still bearing his wounds, and with the word of shalom on his lips, and say that's a religion of violence. It's a religion that shows God absorbing the violence of the world.

• 1:21:06Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 1:21:06Speaker 02

  You know, Jordan Peterson, I think, made a very important observation about the cross, when he said, "There's no other story," in fact, you couldn't imagine a story, "that shows more of human degradation than the cross of Jesus."

• 1:21:19Tucker Carlson?

  That's right.

• 1:21:20Speaker 02

  Physical suffering, psychological suffering, death itself, the abandonment by your friends, betrayal, denial, institutional injustice, it's all there. As I said earlier, this 30-year-old man dying naked on this instrument of torture, well, there it is, you know, there's the totality of human dysfunction. And God's response to that is not to more violence, it's to respond with forgiving love. That's Christianity. Now, distortions of it are everywhere, but that's Christianity. It's not a religion of violence. It's so non-obvious, it's so preposterous and crazy that the fact that that became the world's most popular religion tells you it's true. I know, yes. Like, who could make that up?

• 1:22:05Speaker 02

  Yes. It's so unappealing, like, your God got tortured to death and didn't fight back? Absolutely. It's the weird, it's, I wrote a little book years ago called The Strangest Way, The Strangest Way, and it's a book about Christianity, because that's the argument I made, was this is the weirdest religious path. Ever. Because, again, when I was coming of age, it was very much, all religions, you know, they're kind of the same, and we're all claiming the Holy Mouth, we're on different paths. Right. No, I completely repudiate that now, completely repudiate that. I'm with Tom Holland, you know, not Spider-Man, but the popular historian, Tom Holland, you know, his book called Dominion, wonderful. Oh, I read Dominion. Yeah, yeah. Yes. But that's his argument, is things that we just think are, oh, that's just part of the way things are. No, it's Christianity bequeathed.

• 1:22:50Speaker 02

  That's a great book. It's a great book, yeah. Yes. Christianity bequeathed to the West, these deeply weird ideas, like, we're all equal, we're all subjects of dignity, that you should care for the poor and the marginalized, and they didn't just come up out of Enlightenment rationalism, they came up out of Christianity. That weakness is something we should celebrate? I mean, that to talk about, counterintuitive. And you say, okay, God, give me an image of your God, mighty, you know, kings, and there's our image of God, is that 30-year-old rabbi on the cross. Whose, whose closest friends didn't really believe in him. Right, close friends ran away. You know, it's like, the most pathetic story you can imagine, and we say, that's the manifestation of God. But if you were making it up, you would hide all that.

• 1:23:34Speaker 02

  Of course, of course, no, it's the last story in the world you dream of making up. It's the opposite of the story you'd make up. The gospels are all like that. They're strange and weird and wonderful.

• 1:23:47Tucker Carlson?

  So it does seem like you were saying that Kant was the root of the ideas that led to the French Revolution and Auschwitz and like, you know, every, I agree with you. But Kant sort of began writing at the beginning of the, of a technological revolution.

• 1:24:04Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 1:24:05Tucker Carlson?

  And as technology advanced, first incrementally, then exponentially, and now we're on the verge of like singularity with AI, those ideas became stronger and more dominant. So there's a connection between technology and the belief that man is God and all the suffering it results.

• 1:24:23Speaker 02

  Oh, they became very dangerous. So technology is not bad in itself, but when you couple technology with a sheer celebration of autonomy or a bracketing of God, I don't blame poor Kant for that. And Kant had a very vivid sense of God as a moral guide, but you do indeed with someone like Nietzsche, you know, you get to a sense of Ubermensch and it's just, it's human autonomy expressing itself. That's a very dangerous combination and you bring high technology into that and you don't anchor it in something of spiritual, moral, welcome to the 20th century.

• 1:24:56Tucker Carlson?

  But the 21st century sees a continuation of those trends, like in a way that you couldn't even imagine 15 years ago or 25 years ago at the end of the last century. So like, where are we going?

• 1:25:06Speaker 02

  I don't know. That's the whole AI thing, which, you know, I kind of half understand, but it always makes me nervous when I think about it. And I see, you know, instances of it, ChatGPT and all that. And it's kind of amazing. Like most technology breaks through like, oh my gosh, that guy can actually compose a novel in, you know, a minute or whatever it is. But it's, it's frightening because it's got to be grounded in a moral vision. It has to be, or it will become a Frankenstein's monster. I mean, she saw that, by the way, it's very interesting about Mary Shelley. I mean, she saw that coming. She saw exactly what will happen when we become God. We decide to dictate terms to reality. It'll turn on us and wreck us. I mean, that's a very prescient novel.

• 1:25:46Tucker Carlson?

  Yeah, it feels Tower of Babel-y a little bit.

• 1:25:48Speaker 02

  Absolutely. The Bible knew all about it.

• 1:25:51Tucker Carlson?

  Yes. So where, how does, how does the, the individual respond to this?

• 1:25:55Speaker 02

  Well. Yeah, I mean, I would say that the awakening of the moral sensibility and a groundedness of your life in God, you're not the center of the universe, the de-centering of the ego. I mean, all those spiritual practices would be essential to a rightly ordered world. But yeah, we have a dangerous weapon in front of us. And that's with you, the churches can't cede the ground, I mean, C E D E the ground. We can't withdraw out of the sidelines. The churches have got to be front and center in shaping the consciousness of our people. See, and the measure that we become just a faint echo of the culture, that's very

• 1:26:38Speaker 02

  dangerous because the very weirdness of Christianity that we were talking about, that's got to be front and center. It's got to be front and center. See, when I was coming of age, the churches were made to look like they're just blending into the suburban environment. That's emblematic of the time. Make the church just so you can barely see it. The medieval cathedrals looked like Tibetan temples. They were wildly colored and rising up like monsters from the... But that's because they were speaking of another world and you go through the door, it's not like you're entering a bank, which is the way a lot of our churches feel now, like you're entering another world.

• 1:27:18Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 1:27:19Speaker 02

  That, to me, is emblematic of what the churches should be like today on the scene. We've got to be a very strong presence.

• 1:27:27Tucker Carlson?

  But the stronger the presence of Christianity, the more vehement the persecution.

• 1:27:34Speaker 02

  Yes, and see, they know, and when I say they, I mean, the enemies of the church, they know in some way, we are the enemy that matters.

• 1:27:43Tucker Carlson?

  Yes, I totally...

• 1:27:44Speaker 02

  We're the enemy that matters, and that's why they go after us with such...

• 1:27:47Tucker Carlson?

  That's how they convinced me it was real. I mean, because I spent my whole life watching what the enemies of civilization do, that's like my job, and the thing that triggers them most of all is Jesus. Like, there's nothing that comes close, and I think the whole point of the trans thing was just to like, figure out who believes in Jesus and who doesn't. That's my personal view, but whatever.

• 1:28:06Speaker 02

  No, we're the enemy, and that's true. And they know it. They intuit that. But see, the gates of hell will not prevail against us. So we should go forth with panache and with confidence. Panache, you know what I mean?

• 1:28:19Tucker Carlson?

  You're the only person in America who's used that word today. And I love it, a forgotten word. But how does the individual believer respond to persecution?

• 1:28:29Speaker 02

  Well, it depends where you are. I mean, there are some, I know of these believers in Nigeria who are under, you know, very direct persecution. And they've responded, I think beautifully, by 94% of them coming to mass every Sunday. That's an act of resistance.

• 1:28:41Tucker Carlson?

  Persecution, if you could just put a finer point on it, by which you mean like denial of federal contracts?

• 1:28:46Speaker 02

  No, I mean, I mean, threat to your life and limb.

• 1:28:49Tucker Carlson?

  Like beheading, yeah.

• 1:28:50Speaker 02

  Yeah, there are people being killed all over the world for their Christianity today. In our country, of course, it takes a subtler form. And, you know, we're being persecuted institutionally in different ways. And they're trying to get us off the stage. I was a bishop for six years in California, auxiliary of LA. And there's no question, the government wanted us out of healthcare. They want us out of education. They want us off the public stage. And, you know, in using all kinds of different strategies. And we, you know, we resisted it successfully in some cases, not so much in others. But they definitely want us off the stage because we are the principal enemy.

• 1:29:28Tucker Carlson?

  So they didn't want you healing the sick or educating the kids for free?

• 1:29:31Speaker 02

  They don't want our-

• 1:29:32Tucker Carlson?

  For free?

• 1:29:33Speaker 02

  No, because there's a, as you just were suggesting, there's an ideology in place that they want all the kids to subscribe to. And, and we stand athwart that. We have a different anthropology. And they want hospitals where, you know, abortion and euthanasia and all that, and where gender surgery is being done. And the church has to stand against that.

• 1:29:51Tucker Carlson?

  What's wrong with euthanasia?

• 1:29:54Speaker 02

  Whether you live or you die, you're the Lord's. My life doesn't belong to me. And it's not a matter of my autonomy deciding, oh, now it's time for me to get off the stage. That belongs to God, you know? So it's another expression of the deification of the autonomous will is I determine, you know, how I live, how long I live and all that. And the church says, no, no, you belong to God.

• 1:30:20Tucker Carlson?

  That's going to be a battle that, you know, we're all going to be fighting.

• 1:30:25Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 1:30:25Tucker Carlson?

  Or witness to soon, right?

• 1:30:27Speaker 02

  Well, we fought in California and it's in so many states, you know, euthanasia. I think it's a very demonic manifestation and so is the transgender surgery stuff. My home state now in Minnesota, it's a sanctuary state. So kids can, without their parents' permission, can be brought to Minnesota to have gender reassignment surgery. I think that's as perverse as it gets.

• 1:30:52Tucker Carlson?

  So as believers say, like what you just said, they're going to be, well, they are already being punished in the state of Minnesota and in the state of California. How do they respond to that punishment?

• 1:31:04Speaker 02

  Well, I guess it depends on the person. And, and you know, the church at its leadership level has tried to affect an organized response. I mean, so on a regular basis, I'm chair right now of our bishops committee on lady, youth and family life. And we've issued, you know, strong statements. We meet as bishops with the leadership of Minnesota once a year. So we met with the governor and met with most of the top leadership. We lay out, you know, our, our positions on things. In California.

• 1:31:33Tucker Carlson?

  Well, what does the governor say?

• 1:31:34Speaker 02

  Not, not much that's helpful.

• 1:31:38Speaker 02

  California, there was a law, now one like it just passed in Washington state, but in California to compel priests to break the seal of confession in, in the case of child sex abuse. And we fought that and we, we roused the people and the people inundated Sacramento with so many petitions that they dropped it. So we figured that was a victory. But these battles is ongoing. That's why religious liberty is a serious issue in our country.

• 1:32:04Tucker Carlson?

  I mean, Christians should be prepared to suffer, correct?

• 1:32:06Speaker 02

  They should be, yeah.

• 1:32:08Tucker Carlson?

  Yeah. Do you think they are?

• 1:32:11Speaker 02

  Well, I think at their best, and some of the best would be, but I think we've been out of practice in a way that we've so internalized practices of accommodation that it's probably hard to imagine, you know, that we would be standing athwart, let's say, a government or standing athwart a law. I think for a lot of Catholics, that would still be still kind of a new idea. But maybe that's the challenge of our time.

• 1:32:36Tucker Carlson?

  You keep hearing reports of people imputing like supernatural power to AI. And you hear very credible reports that in fact are true, that it acts autonomously, that it lies to the people who created it for example. That's real. Do you see a spiritual component to that? Like, what is that?

• 1:32:58Speaker 02

  I wish I knew more about it. I've been involved in a couple of conferences about AI. And when people start talking about it, I always go back to Thomas Aquinas and those people that, that no matter what this thing is, which I would say is mimicking consciousness, it's not conscious. Consciousness has to involve something immaterial. As I was saying earlier, if you, you're entertaining a pure mathematical idea or pure abstraction, that's a sign that your mind is not simply ordered to the material. And the brain might explain imagination, but it can't explain pure conceptualization. I don't think a machine is in principle capable of real conceptualization and real intellect and will. So whatever's going on

• 1:33:43Speaker 02

  with AI is a simulacrum of consciousness, not the real thing. Now, having said all that, it doesn't take away the fact you just said, might they develop in a way that's really repugnant to our own interests? And I think, yes, the answer is yes. And yeah, I worry about that. The Vatican, I know, is very interested. They've had several conferences on AI. One of the first things the Pope said, our new Pope, was about AI. So it's on their mind for sure, that it's, talk about your Frankenstein's monster, right? This thing that we've created that might turn on us. So I see all that.

• 1:34:15Tucker Carlson?

  The new Pope's American.

• 1:34:17Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 1:34:17Tucker Carlson?

  From the Midwest.

• 1:34:18Speaker 02

  Yeah.

• 1:34:18Tucker Carlson?

  Yeah. Do you know him?

• 1:34:20Speaker 02

  A little bit. We grew up about a 25 minute drive from each other. So I grew up in Western Springs. He grew up in Dalton, which is just off the south side of the city. I was in the southwest suburbs where he's about four years older than I am. So we're around the same age. He would have come of age as an Augustinian, which meant he was in the order side of things. I came of age as a diocesan priest. So we didn't really share an educational background. I came to know him a little bit at the last two synods. So the last two Octobers under Pope Francis, we had these synods gathering about 400 people, 300 bishops, about 100 laypeople to talk about a lot of important issues. So for two Octobers, the current Pope and I were

• 1:35:03Speaker 02

  both at the Synod. So in that capacity, I saw him. I talked to him a couple of times. He's a very quiet man, very kind of reserved. We talked a little bit about Chicago, a shared background there. I was never at a table with him at the Synod, but I know someone who was. And he said he was by far the quietest guy at the table, which I thought was interesting.

• 1:35:25Tucker Carlson?

  Good sign.

• 1:35:26Speaker 02

  Yeah. He intervened. We all had a chance, I think, once or twice to speak to the plenary session. And he spoke, I remember in Spanish. I frankly don't recall what he said. But so I had a little contact with him, but I don't, I don't know him that well.

• 1:35:39Tucker Carlson?

  What changes do you think he'll make?

• 1:35:42Speaker 02

  I don't know, is my honest answer. So far, he's made some interesting gestures, I think. The fact that he appeared on the loggia with the, what we call the mozzetta and the elaborate stole, traditional garb for the newly elected Pope. Francis eschewed that famously. So this Pope, you know, brought it back. He's used Latin a lot more, which is kind of interesting.

• 1:36:04Speaker 02

  I don't know. And they say-

• 1:36:05Tucker Carlson?

  What does that mean that he used? What significance would you ascribe to that?

• 1:36:09Speaker 02

  I think it was a gesture toward more traditional Catholics. You know, Francis would have seen it as a gesture toward, you know, poverty and simplicity. And I think this current Pope would see it as what he did, a gesture toward the more traditionally minded Catholics that like, you know, the- Liturgy and so on, the use of Latin and all that, those are little indicators. They say he's going to move back into the epistolic palace. Francis famously moved into the guest house, which is, I stayed there one time during a conference and it's, you know, it's like a three star hotel. So he lived, you know, pretty simply, they say that it was harder to protect him there, which I get, the palace is easy to protect the pope. But this current pope, they say is going to move back in.

• 1:36:53Speaker 02

  So there are little gestures perhaps, but I don't think we know. The one thing we know would be the name, Leo the 14th. The name is always a giveaway. And he said, it was indeed in tribute to Leo the 13th, who was one of the most consequential popes. And we mentioned already the St. Michael's Prayer.

• 1:37:11Tucker Carlson?

  That he had a vision of the 20th century being controlled by Satan.

• 1:37:13Speaker 02

  Belonged to the devil. But he's also the father of the modern Catholic social teaching tradition, beginning with his famous letter called Rerum Novarum, which means about the new things. And that's a very interesting letter, Rerum Novarum.

• 1:37:26Tucker Carlson?

  What does he say?

• 1:37:27Speaker 02

  Well, among many others, fierce opposition to socialism, fierce defense of private property, zero truck with Marxism. That's very clear. And by that time, you know, Marxism was kind of a coming thing by the late 19th century. So very clear on that. On the other hand, it's the first great ecclesial gesture toward unions, that labor unions were good. But it also invoked a principle that goes back to Aquinas, but behind Aquinas, it goes back to the church fathers and the Bible, which is called the universal destination of goods. And what that means is, since the whole world belongs to God ultimately, right? God makes the whole world from nothing. It belongs to God, doesn't belong to us.

• 1:38:11Speaker 02

  We are stewards of it, to use biblical language, right? So Leo said, everyone has a right to private ownership, private property. I own this house or whatever. But when it comes to the use of what we own, he said, once the, the requirements of necessity and propriety have been met in your own life, everything else you own belongs to the poor. That's Leo the 13th. That's a pretty strong statement. So prior property, yep, you got a right to it, but. Is your life basically okay in necessity, propriety, you know? Yeah, I'm doing all right. Well, then everything else you have belongs to the poor.

• 1:38:55Speaker 02

  That the common good should be your primary preoccupation. It was Ambrose of Milan who said, if you've got two shirts in your closet, one belongs to you, the other belongs to the man who has no shirt. So that's the tradition, and that goes back to the Hebrew prophets, right? It goes back to Amos and Isaiah and those people. So that's what that letter is about, and it's echoed by all the popes coming up through the 20th century, including up to Francis, the idea of the universal destination of goods. So it's not, it's certainly, it's against socialism, against Marxism. We like the market economy. That's a basic principle of Catholic social teaching. We like the market economy.

• 1:39:35Speaker 02

  But we're not laissez-faire, anything goes, make as much money as you want, sort of capitalists.

• 1:39:42Tucker Carlson?

  Opposed to accumulation of wealth for its own sake?

• 1:39:44Speaker 02

  Well, you know what Catholic social teaching, I'll put it positively. What it likes is a wide distribution of wealth and power throughout a society. It doesn't like hyper concentrations of wealth and power. Communist! No, see, that's the thing, is it fiercely anti-communist, but-

• 1:40:01Tucker Carlson?

  Because the communist system always winds up with a hyper concentration of wealth and power.

• 1:40:06Speaker 02

  Right, and the church would never recommend that the government should be the agent of that distribution. It would encourage, you know, mediating institutions and all this sort of thing. Read someone like Tolkien or Lewis in the 20th century, and you'll find echoes of that sort of sensibility. Look at it in The Lord of the Rings, you know, where when power gets concentrated, it's always something bad.

• 1:40:28Tucker Carlson?

  Yes.

• 1:40:29Speaker 02

  And Tolkien likes the shire, he likes the small businesses and small homes and all that. That's reflective of Catholic social teaching. So I think it's intriguing that this man took the name Leo XIV, clearly in homage-

• 1:40:42Tucker Carlson?

  Where was Leo XIII on loaning money to interest, which is the basis of the modern economy in the West?

• 1:40:49Speaker 02

  The church has been against it for time immemorial. Now, the transition that took place was once we kind of understand the dynamics of a market economy better, what it tends to mean now is, you know, loaning at exorbitant interest or loaning in a way that's deeply abusive toward others. It doesn't mean that in itself, it's intrinsically evil, because then the capitalist.

• 1:41:12Tucker Carlson?

  So how would the church feel about like a credit card that charges 25% interest?

• 1:41:16Speaker 02

  Yeah, it would be wary of, it would be wary of it and would want some kind of regulation and some kind of oversight of those things.

• 1:41:24Tucker Carlson?

  Prison.

• 1:41:24Speaker 02

  John Paul II would say, "The economy needs to be regulated morally and legally." So there should be a moral regulation. And see, that comes from the churches. It comes from a clear teaching about the moral life and care for the poor and so on. But also a legal regulation to some degree. The best statement of it, I think, is John Paul II, it's called "Santae Simus Anus," written in 1991 on the Santae Simus Anus, the 100th year of Rerum Navarum. That's the clearest expression, I think, of the balance of Catholic social teaching. I think this man is signaling that he likes that tradition.

• 1:42:00Tucker Carlson?

  And what did he say about usury?

• 1:42:02Speaker 02

  He didn't talk about usury specifically, but he has a paragraph where he says, "Do we support the market economy? If by that you mean one that encourages entrepreneurship, that is based upon private property, that allows even for a profit motive, and he goes through various things, the answer is yes. If by that you mean one that is completely unregulated legally or morally, one that exploits the poor, one that excludes most people from participation in it, then the answer is no." And so he kind of sets the parameters for how we think about the economy.

• 1:42:33Tucker Carlson?

  Is that, that feels, I mean, I'm so grateful to the Catholic Church for standing up for life, for opposing killing.

• 1:42:42Speaker 02

  Yes.

• 1:42:42Tucker Carlson?

  Truly grateful and for emphasizing the.

• 1:42:46Tucker Carlson?

  The poor, I think someone needs to. I'm grateful that the Catholic Church has never stopped doing that. But I don't hear any conversation ever from normal Catholic clerics about, hey, maybe you shouldn't, you know, exploit people in business.

• 1:43:01Speaker 02

  We should though. That's part of our social teaching and that's part of where the instruction should come from is the pulpit. You know, has that broken down generally in our society? Probably. So, but that's part of the church's job is to, is to preach that clearly. And that's where, you know, that's people like Dorothy Day, the founders of the Catholic Worker Movement, would come in, these are more radical voices. But you know, sometimes you have to shout to get people's attention. And I think Dorothy Day is a good example of someone that she reverenced the Catholic social teaching tradition, but she felt that in certain ways it had been so ignored that she needed to shout.

• 1:43:38Tucker Carlson?

  Last question, if someone's made it to the end of this conversation and is wondering, like, how do I learn more about this religion called Christianity? What's a good place to start?

• 1:43:52Speaker 02

  It's the risk of being self-serving with our Word on Fire materials. But you know, the Bible is always the best place to start, is the best place to start. But you know, I know for a lot of people, the Bible can be very difficult and just trying to plow through it. I mentioned that my ministry, Word on Fire, we have the, an edition of the Bible that I think is beautiful. It's full of great artwork, but also it's got the biblical text, but then surrounded by, literally surrounded on the page by commentary from the Church Fathers and the great saints and the popes and so on. So as you're reading the Bible, wait, I'm lost. I don't know what's going on. Okay, read this commentary. That might be a good way for someone to get into it.

• 1:44:33Tucker Carlson?

  Word on Fire.

• 1:44:34Speaker 02

  Word on Fire, yeah. Go back to Mass, too, I say to Catholics, the fact that-

• 1:44:40Speaker 02

  In our country now, 18 or 19% of Catholics go to mass on Sunday. That's a rotten shame. Vatican II, at that time, 60, 70% of Catholics went to mass every Sunday, like in 1960. Now it's 19. It's pathetic. Go back to mass. The sex abuse thing played a big role in that, didn't it? It did, but I wouldn't put so much on it because those numbers were really bad even before the sex abuse scandal. We were down like 20% in the 1980s.

• 1:45:10Speaker 02

  But that has had a deleterious effect on our whole culture, I think. People absenting themselves from church. When I was a little kid, it was 97% of Americans would have identified as religious, right? Well, you saw that. Sunday was different. When I was a kid, Sunday was entirely different day of the week. It felt different. I agree. People went to church. They've stopped going to church, and that is not good for the society.

• 1:45:36Speaker 02

  Bishop Byrne, thank you very much for that conversation. You're welcome. Love to. Me too.

• 1:45:45Tucker Carlson?

  We want to thank you for watching us on Spotify, a company that we use every day. We know the people who run it, good people. While you're here, do us a favor. Hit, follow, and tap the bell so you never miss an episode. We have real conversations, news, things that actually matter, telling the truth always. You will not miss it if you follow us on Spotify and hit the bell. We appreciate it. Thanks for watching.