Skip to content

The Psychology of Cheaters (According To A Divorce Lawyer) | James Sexton

BigDeal

Hosted by Codie Sanchez

1h 31m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this episode, divorce attorney James Sexton joins host Codie Sanchez to examine the psychology of failing relationships, why marriages break down so slowly, and what couples can do to reverse the drift. Sexton argues that most divorces are not caused by sudden catastrophes, but by a gradual accumulation of apathy, poor communication, and a lack of daily attention. Drawing on decades of trial experience, he explains how framing conversations with curiosity rather than defensiveness can transform interactions, and why treating a partner with everyday maintenance is essential. They discuss how having children often triggers disconnection, how men and women experience cheating differently, and why the best negotiations and relationships rely on subtle, humble connection rather than performative conflict.

  • Treating your partner with everyday attention and small gestures is a 100 percent return on investment to reverse a fading connection. 6:16
  • When couples stop listening attentively and resort to tone-of-voice contempt, it serves as an early auditory sign of a relationship in trouble. 1:45
  • Before reacting defensively to your partner's complaints, practice stepping into their perspective and inquiring about their actual experience. 28:07
  • Anticipate your partner's strongest criticisms by owning your flaws upfront, much like a lawyer using the eight-mile strategy in court. 1:03:55

Chapters

  1. 0:02
    Podcast Intro and Sponsor Announcement

    The episode opens with a brief sponsor message followed by the host introducing the topic and guest.

  2. 1:07
    Defining Marriage Success and Failure

    The host and guest discuss the high failure rate of marriages and what constitutes a successful partnership.

  3. 6:00
    Daily Acts of Love and Attention

    They emphasize small, intentional gestures that reinforce affection and prevent relationship decay.

  4. 15:40
    Social Media’s Impact on Relationships

    The hosts explore how online portrayals can distort expectations and affect marital satisfaction.

  5. 29:59
    Communication and Defensive Dynamics

    They examine how defensive communication styles harm intimacy and offer strategies for healthier dialogue.

  6. 36:21
    Cheating: Gender Perspectives and Cultural Norms

    The discussion shifts to how men and women experience infidelity differently and the societal pressures surrounding it.

  7. 43:58
    Intro and Podcast Hook

    The episode opens with the host introducing the topic and setting the stage for a deep dive into infidelity and relationship dynamics.

  8. 45:15
    Personal Story: Father‑Son Conflict

    A narrative about a tense father‑son conversation highlights the importance of listening and avoiding comparisons to idealized figures.

  9. 49:18
    Critique of Social Media and Gender Narratives

    The speaker reflects on a viral reel about gender expectations, criticizing the oversimplified and offensive comments it sparked.

  10. 59:30
    Legal Persuasion Techniques Applied to Relationships

    Drawing parallels between courtroom cross‑examination and everyday communication, the speaker explains how framing questions shapes outcomes.

  11. 1:13:17
    The Power of Listening and Empathy

    The conversation turns to the value of truly hearing a partner’s concerns without immediately offering solutions, fostering deeper connection.

  12. 1:17:27
    Reevaluating Marriage and Love

    The speaker discusses the high failure rate of marriage, challenges conventional beliefs about love, and emphasizes personal growth through relationships.

Highlights

Quotes

  • “this person helped me become the most authentic version of who I am.”
    Unnamed speaker · 14:46
  • “The feeling of it is a different thing, too.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:31
  • “Another 10 to 20% either separate but never file for divorce, go out for milk and never come back, or they just sort of unhappily stay together and under surveys basically say,”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:42
  • “is just start treating our partner with love and attention and connection.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:29
  • “send your girlfriend, wife, a text that says, 'You know, I had such fun hanging out with you last night.'”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:33
  • “I mean, a massive number, a massive, I would, I would be speculating because it's hard to measure those things.”
    Unnamed speaker · 43:58
  • “Like, we lie to our partners all the time, but it's mostly because we're lying to ourselves.”
    Unnamed speaker · 44:55
  • “If you compare a woman in your life someday, if you compare your wife someday to your imaginary perfect wife, she is going to disappoint the shit out of you.”
    Unnamed speaker · 47:00
  • “I think that's the part in relationship, like the algorithm has taken away our proclivity towards doing that. It has in fact encouraged the opposite.”
    Unnamed speaker · 47:30
  • “I genuinely believe that when I look back on my life, it's those moments of connection with another person, like, that I will remember.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:19:26
  • Michelob Ultra 0:02–0:28
  • SoFi 21:30–22:09
  • Owner Be Owned 42:53–43:52
  • Michelob Ultra 1:01:26–1:01:53
  • Lululemon 1:31:11–1:31:38

About this episode

Thanks to SoFi for sponsoring this episode! Looking for funding to help grow your business? Get started at SoFi.com/Codie. #SoFiPartner #ad My new book, Own Or Be Owned, is all about building a business so good it doesn't need you. I broke it into the 12 Profit Levers… The 12 levers I've seen determine whether you print cash or hate your life. Check it out: https://contrarianthinking.biz/bigdeal-sexton -cs You've been telling yourself the same story. That you need to work harder on your marriage. That you need to read more books, take more courses, find the perfect framework. Here's the truth: the only thing between you and the relationship you want is believing you need something you don't already have. James Sexton is one of the world's most famous divorce attorneys who has represented clients in more than a thousand divorces. He's seen every way a marriage can fail and every pattern that predicts it. In this episode, he breaks down the exact signs that a relationship is ending, why disconnection happens so slowly you don't even notice, and the simple daily habits that separate couples who last from couples who don't. In this episode, you'll learn: The sound of a dying marriage: why the tone of voice that says whatever or what reveals more than any argument ever could, and how contempt kills connection faster than cheating Why babies don't cause divorce but disconnection does, and how the mental load of parenting makes couples forget that their love built the baby in the first place The menu framework: how offering your partner options instead of expecting them to read your mind creates safety, and why asking do you need space or do you need to talk right now changes everything Why men ask did you have sex with him and women ask do you love her, and what that reveals about how men and women experience betrayal completely differently The eight mile strategy: how getting ahead of your own weaknesses in a relationship disarms defensiveness, and why showing your partner your flaws is the only way they can truly love you ___________ (00:00:00) Introduction: The Sound of a Marriage About to End (00:01:33) The What Huh Whatever: How Contempt Kills Connection (00:04:46) The Story Retelling Test: When Your Partner Becomes Boring (00:05:57) The Spiral of Apathy: How Disconnection Happens Slowly Then All at Once (00:07:16) The Text Message Strategy: 30 Seconds That Could Save Your Marriage (00:10:15) The Eight Billion People Problem: Why Your Partner Is Your Favorite Person (00:11:50) The Evidence Test: Cross-Examining Your Own Relationship (00:15:24) Social Media and the Performative Self: Hashtag Blessed While Negotiating Divorce (00:18:06) The Manual We Never Got: Why No One Teaches Us How to Love (00:22:38) Babies and Disconnection: The Crisis That Pulls Couples Apart (00:24:56) You Can't Pretend You Meant to Get Divorced: The Humility of Failure (00:27:29) Men and Women Get Each Other Wrong: The Defensiveness Trap (00:30:10) Creating Safe Space: Why Men Don't Tell You What You Don't Want to Hear (00:34:46) Love Is Not Permanently Gifted, It's Loaned: The Fragility of Connection (00:36:59) Cheating and Infidelity: The 70 Percent Reality (00:39:56) Did You Have Sex With Him: How Men and Women Experience Betrayal Differently (00:42:35) The Economy of Monogamy: What We Owe Each Other in a Committed Relationship (00:47:32) The Imaginary Perfect Partner: Comparing Real People to Fantasy (00:59:19) The Shaving Story: How You Ask the Question Dictates the Answer (01:03:46) The Eight Mile Strategy: Owning Your Weaknesses Before They're Used Against You (01:06:13) The Persuasion Principle: Great Advocacy Doesn't Look Like Advocacy (01:10:57) A Good Lawyer Knows the Law, A Great Lawyer Knows the Judge (01:14:27) The Menu Framework: Listening, Fixing, or Distraction (01:17:48) Does Marriage Still Work: The 70 Percent Failure Rate Question (01:19:45) Chapters in a Long Book: Reframing Divorce as Part of Your Story, Not Failure (01:26:09) The Vulnerability Invitation: Showing Your Weaknesses So You Can Feel Real Love ___________ MORE FROM BIGDEAL 🎥 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@podcastbigdeal 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bigdeal.podcast 📽️ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@big.deal.pod MORE FROM CODIE SANCHEZ 🎥 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@codiesanchezct 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/codiesanchez 📽️ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@realcodiesanchez OTHER THINGS WE DO 🌐 Our community: https://contrarianthinking.typeform.com/to/WBztXXID 📰 Free newsletter: https://contrarianthinking.biz/3XWLlZp 📚 Biz buying course: https://contrarianthinking.biz/3NhjGgN 🏠 Resibrands: https://resibrands.com/ 💰 CT Capital: https://contrarianthinking.biz/4eRyGOk 🏦 Main St Hold Co: https://contrarianthinking.biz/3YfGa8u Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:31:54

18,945 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Instagram
  • Eight Mile
  • courthouse
  • Manhattan
  • TikTok
  • Brazilian Jiu Jitsu
  • NBA
  • Contrarian Boardroom
  • Step Brothers
  • Destiny's Child

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated