Four Practical Ways to Live Like a Stoic with Ryan Holiday

Many people think Stoicism is about suppressing emotions or accepting suffering with a stiff upper lip. But it’s really about learning to live well, to find peace, courage, and happiness in a chaotic world. In this episode of Office Hours, I sit down with my friend Ryan Holiday https://ryanholiday.net/, bestselling author and modern Stoic who has written several books about Stoicism, including his latest, Wisdom Takes Work https://www.amazon.com/Wisdom-Takes-Work-Repeat-Virtues/dp/0593191730. Together, we explore how ancient wisdom can help us live better today and why doing the right thing, even when it’s hard, leads to greater happiness. We talk about how to stay centered in a world that constantly tests our integrity and attention, and what it means to live with temperance and purpose. Stoicism reminds us that we can’t always control what happens, but we can control how we respond, and that choice shapes the life we build. — Where to find Ryan Holiday: • Website: https://ryanholiday.net • YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYmBIKsrzIjdHRuqs2I8nHA • X: https://x.com/RyanHoliday • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ryanholiday • Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ryanholiday • Podcast: https://dailystoic.com/podcast Where to find Arthur Brooks: • Website: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://arthurbrooks.com/⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://arthurbrooks.com/ • Newsletter: ⁠⁠⁠https://www.arthurbrooks.com/newsletter⁠⁠⁠ https://www.arthurbrooks.com/newsletter • X: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://x.com/arthurbrooks⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://x.com/arthurbrooks • Instagram: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.instagram.com/arthurcbrooks/⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.instagram.com/arthurcbrooks/ • Facebook: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/ArthurBrooks/⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.facebook.com/ArthurBrooks/ • YouTube: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGuyFRjJQFGCKzfHTBvWM6A⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGuyFRjJQFGCKzfHTBvWM6A • LinkedIn: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/arthur-c-brooks/⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.linkedin.com/in/arthur-c-brooks/ • Email: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠[email protected]⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ mailto:[email protected] — Timestamps: (00:00) Intro (05:01) How Ryan Holiday got into Stoicism (10:04) Ryan’s definition of Stoicism (13:53) Who Cicero was, his Stoic leanings, and differences from the Stoics (21:05) Seneca’s death (22:19) The three principles of Stoicism (25:40) Modern people who demonstrated Stoic principles (34:44) Stoicism’s work: finding a way to feel happy and grateful in spite of hardships (43:30) Ryan’s advice to young Stoics (47:35) A case for making your own meaning (49:02) How to stay in control when everything competes for your attention (52:13) Where the Stoics fell short (57:10) The Four Idols game (1:04:35) Wrap up: Four ways to practice Stoicism — Referenced: • How to Build a Life: https://www.theatlantic.com/projects/how-build-life/ • The Happiness Files: Insights on Work and Life: https://www.amazon.com/Happiness-Files-Insights-Arthur-Brooks/dp/B0F4MFQ6VN • Ryan Holiday’s website: https://ryanholiday.net/ • Wisdom Takes Work: Learn. Apply. Repeat.: https://www.amazon.com/Wisdom-Takes-Work-Repeat-Virtues/dp/0593191730 • Robert Greene’s website: https://powerseductionandwar.com • The Stoics: The Philosophy of Seneca, Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius: https://www.amazon.com/Stoics-Philosophy-Seneca-Epictetus-Aurelius/dp/1398849103 • Meditations: https://www.amazon.com/Meditations-New-Translation-Marcus-Aurelius/dp/0812968255 • ... References continued at: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.arthurbrooks.com/office-hours⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.arthurbrooks.com/office-hours⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://www.theatlantic.com/projects/how-build-life/ — Production and marketing by ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://penname.co/⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ https://penname.co/⁠.

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:00Speaker 00

  At REI Co-op, we don't just sell outdoor gifts. We use them, test them, trust them. So we know what to give this season. For joy rides, campfire cheers, and peak views. We know what to give the people you love who love to get out there. Because we're out there too. Just stop in and ask a green vest, like me. For the best gifts out there. Shop in-store or at REI.com.

• 0:31Speaker 01

  This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.

• 0:59Arthur Brooks?

  I love the Stoic philosophy and the way that we can implement it in ordinary, modern life. Last I looked, you'd sold 10 million books on Stoicism. But how does the world's leading proponent of Stoicism today describe it?

• 1:10Speaker 03

  You don't control the world around you, but you control how you respond to it. Stoicism is not necessarily leaping on the floor. It is living within or beneath one's means. There's a line in Meditations, a remark to us that says, "Convince yourself that all of this is a gift from the gods and that things are good and they always will be." Your job here is to not despair, to not take it personally, to not give up, to not quit, but to do the very real mental and spiritual work that allows you to find something to be grateful for, even in the midst of a plague, even in the midst of a political disaster, even in the midst of a funeral for someone that you love.

• 2:02Arthur Brooks?

  Hey everybody. Welcome to Office Hours. I'm Arthur Brooks. I'm a behavioral scientist dedicated to lifting people up and bringing them together in bonds of happiness and love. And this is a show by doing just that. I look at behavioral science and neuroscience in a way that you can use these ideas. And sometimes I look at philosophy as well. This is really important because philosophy in the study of happiness is the big questions. Behavioral science gives us a lot of data about it. Neuroscience gives us the mechanisms of action. And then, of course, we need to talk about how we practically can live these ideas in our lives to live happier lives. Today is one of those questions shows, looking at philosophy. Specifically, I want to look at Stoicism, a massively popular ancient philosophy that

• 2:46Arthur Brooks?

  has made a relatively recent comeback, particularly among young people, looking for a way of living that's not just comfortable, but meaningful. And my guest today is one of the world's leading proponents of Stoic philosophy, Ryan Holiday. Ryan has written many books about Stoicism. He's sold more than 10 million books, as a matter of fact. And, and part of the reason for that is because it's just so compelling, what he's writing. These ideas are so fresh and so new. They provide an outline on how you can live a better life. He's also a beautiful writer and just an incredibly interesting guy. You're going to like this episode a lot. You're going to watch it until the very end when we play the game, What's My Idol? Which, if you'll remember, if you've been watching, I also played that with Rainn Wilson. He knows Rainn Wilson as well. And, and I hope you're playing that game at home.

• 3:31Arthur Brooks?

  You'll see how, how Ryan plays it. You'll see that he has idols, just like everybody else, notwithstanding the fact that he's talking about Stoic philosophy. Now, what we're going to talk about in this episode is going to be really practical, but I want to kind of lay it out, what you're going to hear. You're going to first start by hearing what Stoic philosophy is. And you're going to learn the three big principles of Stoic philosophy. These are the big ideas that all of the writers, from Seneca to Epictetus to Marcus Aurelius to, to Cicero, what were they writing about? What were the main principles that they were trying to get across? These are really hard ideas to live by, but they're bracing ideals. As soon as you hear these things, it'll be like a, a tall glass of cold water on a summer's day. You say, yes, I want that. But you're going to learn very quickly.

• 4:16Arthur Brooks?

  The second big idea is that Stoicism isn't, isn't something that you can attain. It's an ideal to approach. And so when we talk about who were the great Stoics, you'll also find out that they weren't necessarily great Stoics in their lives. So Stoicism is not a state. It's a, it's a path. The third is that Stoicism is really all about self-governance. Self-governance is, is governing yourself as opposed to being governed by the world. And this is one of the reasons that young people today find it so incredibly attractive. So many young people today, they, they tell me, I feel like I'm being managed. I feel like I'm, you know, I'm in this simulation and, and you know, things are coming at me all the time and I'm just kind of consuming them.

• 4:59Arthur Brooks?

  And, you know, I'm managed by emotions. I'm managed, you know, by the world. I'm managed by my addictions and by my appetites. And I want to be in charge. Of course you do. You want to be a self-governing individual and that's part of the Stoic ideal. That's where the fourth part of the conversation, which is the wide-ranging conversation. That's really, really where it comes around because Ryan, together we set up this Stoic self-governance protocol. Here are the four things to do. Here are the four things to, to seek and four ways to get those things. You're going to find how to manage your emotions, discipline your will, lower your self-focus and extinguish your addictions. Those are the four things to make you a more Stoic and therefore a more,

• 5:44Arthur Brooks?

  a happier person, living a good life under your own circumstances where you're in charge and nobody and no device is in charge of you. You're going to find out the ways to do that. So stay tuned. This is going to be a real practical episode and, and one I think you're really going to enjoy. This is my interview with Ryan Holiday. Ryan Holiday, welcome to Office Hours. Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm delighted. And this is a, a new podcast and I've been on your podcast a bunch of times and, and we've done stuff together in the past, which I've always really loved. And I thought, People listening to Office Hours need to hear from Ryan Holiday because everybody needs a little more Stoicism in their life.

• 6:17Speaker 03

  Well, I'm a college dropout, so I didn't get to do a lot of office hours. But as a concept, it's always been, like, whenever I go back to colleges, and I'm talking to college kids, I go, I don't think you understand how insane the concept of office hours is to everyone else in the real world. Like, these professors, which as, you know, expert witnesses in court cases, charge tens of thousands of dollars an hour in some cases, or in other cases, you know, speak for tens of thousands of dollars, or consult to, you know, some of the biggest, most important people in the world, they are sitting in their office mandated to have a certain number

• 7:01Speaker 03

  of hours that anyone can come talk to them, and they mostly just sit there and wonder why nobody comes.

• 7:09Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, no, mine are on Zoom and they're booked up in 15-minute increments.

• 7:15Speaker 03

  Yeah.

• 7:15Arthur Brooks?

  So their appointments is kind of what it comes down to. And generally speaking, since I teach happiness, they want to talk about their lives. And so it becomes clinical work, effectively.

• 7:24Arthur Brooks?

  And I'm not a clinician, so there you go. I'm a huge fan of your stuff, as you know. I love the Stoic philosophy and the way that it actually is, and we can implement it in ordinary, modern life. And you're the leading exponent on bringing Stoicism to literally millions and millions of people. Last I looked, you'd sold 10 million books on Stoicism. 10 million. That's a nice round number. I like it.

• 7:45Speaker 03

  Yeah.

• 7:46Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, and you didn't sell them all through your own bookstore in Bastrop. I mean, this is stuff that I see.

• 7:51Speaker 03

  I wish.

• 7:52Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, I know. That would be double dipping, man. That's not fair. You write books on Stoicism and sell them yourself and charge twice. I'd love for you to tell me kind of the backstory and how you got interested in Stoicism, how you started to become a modern Stoic philosopher yourself. How did that come about? How did a normal guy, working for Robert Greene, the author of all things, wind up becoming a philosopher? Tell me that, and then we'll talk about your new book.

• 8:18Speaker 03

  I don't know if I would call myself a philosopher so much as someone who writes about philosophy. I guess I think the title, someone else has probably got to give you the title. So I'll, I'll take it. But I was in college. I was actually, I remember I was taking a class on Aristotle. He's Aristotle and the meaning of life. And it was fascinating and interesting, you know, mostly over my head. And I remember I was at a conference, I was writing for a college newspaper and I was at a conference. And I went up to one of the speakers afterwards and I said, you know, I love to read. Are you reading anything interesting? What might you recommend? And the person recommended a biography of Theodore Roosevelt and the Stoics. And I remember grabbing the Stoics on Amazon.

• 9:02Speaker 03

  The movie Gladiator was still relatively new at this point. So I'd heard of, I'd at least heard the name Marcus Aurelius, like that rang some bells. And I remember Meditations came to my college apartment and it was nothing like Aristotle. Like it's in these short kind of clipped sentences. He's saying what he means and he's not talking so much about the meaning of life as he is talking about the practical problems of life. Right? There's a passage that I remember hitting me as a, as a 19 year old in, in the opening of book five of Meditations, where he has this extended riff on why he has to get out of bed early in the morning, even though he doesn't want to.

• 9:43Arthur Brooks?

  The covers are so nice.

• 9:45Speaker 03

  Yes. Yeah, he says, but it's nicer here. And he says, so you're made to feel nice to huddle under the covers and stay warm? And so there was just something about hearing the most powerful person in the world write these notes to themselves in the way that today someone might write something on a sticky note and put it on their bathroom mirror. And, and, and the idea that, that, that this was based on an ancient philosophical tradition. I mean, it just, it just lit me up. And I went down this rabbit hole and I started writing about it on, I had a blog. And it certainly was not my plan or my intention, nor could I have imagined that this is where I would end up. My, my first two books were about marketing.

• 10:26Speaker 03

  And I remember I went to my publisher afterwards and I said, you know, for my next book, I'd like to write about an obscure. School of ancient philosophy and they were, you know, less than excited. And so, you know, it kind of, it was something that kind of just happened. But to me, it all stems back from this kind of moment of discovery and excitement. When, when you find, you know, whatever, I think anyone that's had a religious or a philosophical experience knows, when you, when you find the thing that was written thousands of years ago, that feels like it was made exactly for you in that moment. That's a magical thing.

• 11:01Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. So sum up Stoicism for people who don't, I mean, most of people, I guess, I suspect that most people who are watching Office Hours know something about it. But how does the, the world's leading proponent of Stoicism today describe it?

• 11:13Speaker 03

  Well, not what people think Stoicism is, which is, you know, has no emotions, has no feeling, you know, invulnerable, robotic, whatever. I, I like to tell people that my definition of Stoicism is a Stoic believes you, you don't control the world around you, but you control how you respond to it. And so Stoicism is this, this way of responding or this framework for responding that's built around the cardinal virtues of courage, self-discipline, justice and wisdom. And the idea, and this is, my first book on Stoicism was called The Obstacle is the Way. It's based on, I think, the essence of Stoic philosophy being that every situation you're in is an opportunity for virtue.

• 11:57Speaker 03

  So the more trying, the more difficult, the more painful, the more whatever that situation happens to be for you, the more it calls from us, one or all of those four virtues. And I think Stoicism, fittingly for people who don't know, Stoicism is a, is a philosophy that comes in about the fourth century B.C. When, when a merchant named Zeno suffers a shipwreck. So he loses everything. He was this successful merchant. And, and it's, it's in the rebuilding of his life after this disaster that he's introduced to philosophy. I think it's fitting that Stoicism, which is a philosophy of resilience and responding

• 12:38Speaker 03

  to what happens to you in life, comes from a guy doing precisely that.

• 12:43Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. And this is the guy, he, I think he lost a whole boatload, literally a boatload of purple cloth, right? Isn't that what he was?

• 12:50Speaker 03

  Yes, purple dye.

• 12:51Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, purple dye, because that, because, you know, purple dye was unbelievably expensive and that was his life's. Work and all of his savings and all of it was gone. And you say, well, what does that mean? So this actually leads to something you've written about an awful lot, which is central to Stoicism and which is utterly opposed to the modern complex surrounding mental health in young people, which is that if you're suffering means something's wrong with you. And that's completely mistaken. Pain is not evidence that something's wrong. Pain is evidence that you're alive and it's not to be eliminated, but to be understood and as an incitement to growth. Is that, is that fair? I mean, I've heard you say this a hundred times, but that's right, isn't it?

• 13:29Speaker 03

  Yeah. Yeah, Zeno's joke was that he made a great fortune when he suffered a shipwreck because it introduced him to philosophy. But you could also say it introduces him to himself.

• 13:39Arthur Brooks?

  Right.

• 13:40Speaker 03

  Right? It's the thing that challenges him, that requires him to grow, that requires him to change. And so, yeah, you can choose, this is the idea in Stoicism, that you could, you don't choose the situation, but you choose the story you tell yourself about it. So you can suffer the shipwreck metaphorically or otherwise and say, I've been singled out. I've been mistreated by fate or fortune or God. A tragedy has befallen me. I will, I can never recover. This is awful. Or you can say, this is a chance for me to start over.

• 14:12Arthur Brooks?

  Right.

• 14:12Speaker 03

  This is exciting. This is an adventure. This is a chance for me to do something that I wouldn't have ordinarily done. And so Stoicism is really that choice. So it's interesting that people think Stoicism is passivity or resignation, but it's really only passivity or resignation in that one singular moment as to whether you're going to argue about whether something has happened or not. Right? So yes, it is, it is accepting that it is a shipwreck. That is a done deal. But, but where one is not passive is in what one does next.

• 14:50Arthur Brooks?

  So you're writing books about this so that people can use these ideas today. You're not using these ideas so people understand purple dye and Zeno, as interesting as that actually is. So let's talk about actually using some of these ideas today. So as I understand it. Your description of Stoicism, which seems very robust and certainly in accord with my reading of Marcus Aurelius and Seneca and Epictetus and Cicero, and I mean Cicero's a Stoic, right? Do we call him a Stoic?

• 15:18Speaker 03

  I don't think he calls himself a Stoic, but Cicero is the means by which we know most of what the Stoics said. He clearly was intellectually and academically fascinated with the Stoics and he knew many of them. Obviously, he's several hundred years later after Zeno, but he wrote beautifully about Stoicism and did try to apply it as best he could. So I kind of see him as this like, he's a fellow traveler. I think his personal philosophical beliefs are a bit more eclectic and he has some Epicurean tendencies, to put it mildly.

• 15:54Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah.

• 15:55Speaker 03

  But as far as...

• 15:58Arthur Brooks?

  Explain that for a second. Explain the Epicurean tendencies, in case nobody's getting the reference. Epicurus and Epictetus were the opposing camp.

• 16:05Speaker 03

  Yes, sure.

• 16:05Arthur Brooks?

  Epictetus was a Stoic. Control yourself. And Epicurus said, "Let's go feel good, man."

• 16:11Speaker 03

  Yes. And to be fair, I am doing to the Epicureans what others do to the Stoics there.

• 16:17Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah.

• 16:18Speaker 03

  So in the ancient world, two of the rival philosophical schools are the Stoics and the Epicureans. And the Epicureans, people think that means hedonists, pleasure seekers. I take it, to me, I say the difference is that the Stoic is in the arena, literally and figuratively, active in life, meeting challenges, involved, professionally engaged, perhaps even ambitious. And the Epicurean says, "Look, none of this really matters. Let's drop out, tune in. Let's just study philosophy and sort of tend to our own intellectual

• 16:55Speaker 03

  and spiritual nourishment." And so there's nothing exactly wrong with that, except we live in the world that the Stoics made, not the world that the Epicureans made.

• 17:09Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah.

• 17:09Speaker 03

  Because the Epicureans didn't think you needed to make anything.

• 17:12Arthur Brooks?

  Well, not to mention the fact that Christianity is more Stoic than Epicurean. And you know, that Christendom actually brought Stoic thinking forward through the centuries. And you know, through St. Thomas Aquinas, et cetera, et cetera. There's a lot more Stoicism in that than there. There's, there's no Epicureanism in that, to be sure. But they do get this wrong because Epicurus, he had a cult and he had a community around him. And there was nothing morally untoward that was going on. There was not like hedonistic sexual activity or bacchanalian activity. On the contrary, they were, they were, they were pretty prim and proper. What they were doing was hanging out, not arguing with each other angrily, but rather having very deep philosophical discussions and trying not to, not trying not to be uncomfortable is what it comes down to, right?

• 17:56Speaker 03

  Yeah. And, and so when I said Cicero was Epicurean, what I, what I really meant to say is that, that he was, he was a very wealthy, very powerful, very, um, he was a lover of the high and the fine life. Um, and, and I think the, the austerity of Stoicism is, is emphasized by some of the thinkers more than others. I think Cicero would certainly preach the austere life and then retreat to his mansion.

• 18:25Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. It was, and there's a lot of people like that today. I'm, I'm sure there are a lot of people who get major epiphanies from reading, you know, your books and then retreat to playing video games and smoking weed, right?

• 18:38Speaker 03

  Well, look, I, I live in a nice house. I, I, I think to me Stoicism is not necessarily living, uh, sleeping on the floor. It is living within or beneath one's means. And I, I think if you can get to a place, and perhaps Cicero was, and so I'm being unfair here. If you can be, uh, if you can live in a place where you don't need it, where you'd be all right if it went away, then it's fine to have. Uh, that, you know, it's funny, we have this word indifference. Um, and, and that's what people often associate the Stoics with. But actually the Stoics tended to use the word indifference, like E N T S, not E N C E. And so by indifference, they meant that these things didn't matter.

• 19:21Speaker 03

  So, uh, like Seneca talks about how, he goes, look, it's Better to be tall than short. Like, if someone gave you a choice, you would rather be tall than short. But because you don't get a choice, it's something, it is an indifferent. But he said there are also what he calls these preferred indifference. And so the idea is, if you can afford a nice car, why would you deliberately drive a beater? Now, there might be a philosophical reason. You go, hey, I don't want to care about something that doesn't matter. Or the other says, hey, look, I like having cruise control and self-driving, so I don't have to spend so much brain power on a thing that doesn't matter. So it's interesting how timeless some of these philosophical debates can get.

• 20:06Speaker 03

  But in the ancient world, the idea was, you know, one was austere to a point, and one was trying to cultivate an indifference to things that didn't really matter.

• 20:19Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, and so the Buddhists would talk about this in terms of intention without attachment. So you have an intention towards certain things. You have goals in life, you have preferences, but you're unattached to the attainment of those goals. You're unattached to arriving at the destination of your dreams, is what it comes down to. And the truth of the matter is, that's unbelievably behaviorally robust. There's a ton of modern research that shows that you need intention to make progress in life and to find meaning in life, but you need non-attachment, or you'll fall prey to the arrival fallacy. And that's one of the greatest tyrannies toward happiness of all time, something both you and I have written about. And so the Stoics, it seems to me, that those who are the, talking about the indifferent as opposed to the indifference, are getting it just right.

• 21:01Arthur Brooks?

  That's in accord with most other really good philosophies. It's interesting, you know, we're talking about Cicero, and, you know, he did his best. The very last couple of sentences that he pronounced were the most Stoic things ever, weren't they?

• 21:16Speaker 03

  Of course. Yes. And you know, there's a great tradition with this and the Stoics that the whole idea Cicero said of philosophy is to learn how to die, right? So you can get basically everything else wrong. You can screw up, but if you can die well, if you can die according to your principles, that's sort of the ultimate statement. And Cicero's, I believe, final words as he meets the end at the hands of Octavian's goons on a dusty road outside Rome is, what is it? There's nothing proper.

• 21:51Arthur Brooks?

  There's nothing proper. There's nothing proper about what you're about to do, Centurion, but do try to do it properly.

• 21:56Speaker 03

  Yes. And Seneca, you know, is a similar figure to Cicero in that he's politically ambitious. He's wealthy. He's morally compromised in the way that the political life at the elite level can compromise a person. And yet he's also writing beautifully about austere and sort of virtuous philosophy. And at the end Nero sends his goons to kill Seneca. And Seneca is basically saying, as a playwright, he knew this. He knew that the audience will forgive a bad play if it's brought to a close, right? If the final act is good.

• 22:37Speaker 03

  And Seneca, you know, forced to commit suicide, does so sort of bravely without tears. He delivers a couple of badass one-liners, you know, pours out some of the hemlock as an offering to the gods and sort of bequeaths to his friends, his example. And that was the idea. So I think it's easy, it's easy to judge the life of a person you don't know in scenarios you've never been in. And it's also hard to argue that, you know, in the scariest moment of their life, they were pretty badass.

• 23:15Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. Let me, based on that, sum up the three principles of Stoicism as you see them for our lives. And then let's talk about modern Stoics and people that are great examples of this today, and then how we can be more like that, because that's really what you're getting at. Because you know, your work is about how we can live better lives, have more eudaimonia, have a better lives well-lived. Through this ancient philosophy and bringing it to life today. So number one, principle number one of Stoicism from Ryan Holiday. Manage yourself, not the outside world.

• 23:44Speaker 03

  Yeah.

• 23:45Arthur Brooks?

  Because you can't manage the outside world and the only thing you can manage is yourself. So pay attention to the one thing that you can manage, which is yourself and your feelings and your actions and your behaviors and not the outside world. That's number one. Okay?

• 23:58Speaker 03

  Yeah, and that's the greatest empire, the Stoic said, right? Command over oneself and they didn't, they didn't say this like the Epicureans, you know, in their garden, just sort of judging these people in power. They were like, hey, look, I command this great army. I'm in charge of this province. I am the head of this business empire. Or is it the head of me? You know, who's, who's actually in charge here? And, and that that's what they held up as, as the truly impressive thing. Not what you were in charge of, but what was in charge of you? And was that you?

• 24:31Arthur Brooks?

  That's important and we're going to go back to that for sure. Second, everything is an opportunity, including suffering.

• 24:38Arthur Brooks?

  That's the second big principle, right?

• 24:40Speaker 03

  Yes, that's the obstacle is the way that it, that it's calling from you something that perhaps would not be possible in ordinary circumstances that you wouldn't be able to bring out of yourself.

• 24:51Arthur Brooks?

  And so therefore, by extension, if your life philosophy is trying to eliminate suffering, you're eliminating opportunities from your life and that's a bad way to live.

• 25:00Speaker 03

  Yeah, and you look back on your life, I would argue that most of the things we're most proud of came out of situations that we didn't choose. And most of the things that we thought were unalloyedly negative are in fact, you know, filled with all sorts of silver linings.

• 25:20Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, for sure. That's certainly the case in my life and yours and anybody who's thinking about it seriously. And last but not least, if you have to choose, choose virtue over comfort.

• 25:30Speaker 00

  At REI Co-op, we don't just sell outdoor gifts. We use them, test them, trust them. So we know what to give this season for joy rides, campfire cheers and peak views.

• 25:47Speaker 00

  We know what to give the people you love who love to get out there because we're out there too. Just stop in and ask a green vest like me for the best gifts out there. Shop in store or at REI.com.

• 26:01Speaker 01

  This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you, so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.

• 26:31Speaker 03

  Yeah, yeah. Just that you do the right thing, Marx really says at one point in Meditations, he says, "The rest doesn't matter." You know, and the idea of, like, again, you control the choice that you make. You don't necessarily control whether it's going to be well received. You don't control whether you're going to get a thank you. You don't control, like, I think one of the... The idea of karma is beautiful. One of the things I think it does for people is it makes them think the universe and the world is fair and that this is an exchange of value. "I'll be good, so you'll be good to me." Right? "I'll do the right thing, you do the right thing. I work hard, I'll get ahead." I think the Stoics lived in a much more capricious world,

• 27:16Speaker 03

  a much crueler world. And so they understood that you could be a good person and it might not work out for you, in one sense. But in the other sense, it was the only way to be.

• 27:30Arthur Brooks?

  Mm-hmm, indeed. And, and, you know, that leads me to the next question that I have. Because in your books, which everybody should read, if you haven't read Ryan's books, read them. You don't just talk about these ancients. You don't talk about Cicero, a highly imperfect kind of character.

• 27:44Speaker 03

  Sure.

• 27:45Arthur Brooks?

  You talk about modern figures as well, and that's what makes it really interesting. And so before we talk about how we can be Stoics, give me an example of somebody in relatively modern life, perhaps dead, maybe, you know, maybe it's General Montgomery, maybe it's Abraham Lincoln, maybe it's Martin Luther King, I don't know, who is a modern Stoic, as clear as you can see that applying.

• 28:09Speaker 03

  Well, one of the things I try to do in my books is I try to take Stoic ideas and then illustrate them with stories from literature and culture and sports and business, military history. I'm not saying that John D. Rockefeller is a Stoic. I'm saying it was Stoic the way he was able to keep his mind clear in the midst of multiple financial crises, right? I'm not saying that Cicero is a Stoic. I'm saying he said something good about Stoicism here that's worth learning from, right? So what I try to do is illustrate these ideas in little slices because I think we all know, none of us are perfect. And there are moments

• 28:54Speaker 03

  where we might rise to the ideas or to the occasion, and then there's other moments where we fall short. So what I'm always trying to do is just take very specific Stoic ideas or philosophical ideas and then illustrate them. So I've been doing this series on the cardinal virtues. And so there's a bunch of different characters. So I'm talking about, you know, de Gaulle as an example of courage, but he might also be a cautionary example in a chapter that I'm talking about, you know, managing one's ego in the discipline book. And, you know, he might be a profoundly inspiring figure as we're talking about fighting

• 29:35Speaker 03

  for France. And then as I'm talking in the justice book, you know, his relationship to the larger French empire, you know, could be a cautionary example. So my theory is never, oh, this is a modern Stoic. This person is worthy of being on the Mount Rushmore of Stoics alongside Marcus and Epictetus and Seneca. I'm just saying, in this moment, they have a chance to teach us something about what the Stoics were trying to call us to be.

• 30:08Arthur Brooks?

  Can you think of a figure, however, that that at least approaches the Stoic ideal as much as or better than anyone else that you can think of?

• 30:15Speaker 03

  Well, I do think if we're talking about these cardinal virtues, Lincoln is about as close as you can get as an embodiment of all of them. And I tell this story, there's this fascinating story about Tolstoy. Towards the end of his life, he's in this remote mountain camp in the Caucasus Mountains. And he's telling them, you know, they asked him to tell him stories about the great men of history. And towards the end, they go, you know, you told us about George Washington and Napoleon and this person and that person, they said, but you haven't told us about the greatest man of all. And he goes, who could that be? And the chief, the chief of this tribe says, you know, you know, the man with words like thunder and deeds like the rock. And now Tolstoy is really, you know, who did I miss? And then the guy goes, Abraham Lincoln.

• 31:00Speaker 03

  And Tolstoy is just amazed. How could, how could the story of Lincoln made its way all the way here? And what he realizes, he goes, you know, now that I think about it, Abraham Lincoln actually is perhaps the greatest man in history, the one that that all nations should be proud because his accomplishments weren't for himself, right? He's a great military theorist and conqueror, but, but it's, it's, you know, it's to free a group of people rather than enslave them. You know, his education wasn't to impress other people. It was to claw it's himself and his family out of poverty. That there was this sort of moral center, that Lincoln was as ambitious as any of those

• 31:44Speaker 03

  other great men, but his ambition had a kind of a moral center to it. Like, you know, I think it's interesting, I talk about this in the wisdom book. Abraham Lincoln was known as Honest Abe, and he got that reputation as a lawyer, right? Like, that's, that's not where, where you would, and his, his, his line was, if you can't be an honest lawyer, try to be an honest man in some other profession, right? And so, so I think, I think it's, it's rare that you see the complete package in that way. And I think that's probably why. There's been more books written about Abraham Lincoln than just about any other person to ever live because we see in a essentially a modern figure, an ambitious,

• 32:29Speaker 03

  a self-taught political figure as opposed to some, you know, person who lived 3,000 years ago. We see all the, all the potential pitfalls that have disrupted many of our leaders and, and we see him somehow expertly and selflessly navigate them. So I would put him up there. Certainly. We don't know if he ever read the Stoics, unfortunately. But, but, but he's about as close as you can get to the ideal in the real world.

• 33:03Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. In the 1830s and 1840s, when he would have been a student and young adult, I don't think the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius was in common circulation yet, right?

• 33:11Speaker 03

  No, no. And in fact, George Long, the British classicist who, who came to work at the University of Virginia, who, who popularized Marcus Aurelius was a sort of a Southern sympathizer. And, and he famously complains in his edition of Meditations that, that he's a, he's a Southerner at heart and he doesn't like all these Yankee entrepreneurs who are, who are publishing the edition of his book. So, yeah, we don't, we don't know. He was steeped in the ancients, but, but no overt mentions of the Stoics from him. There is a funny joke that you would like, not, not everyone's going to appreciate the

• 33:53Speaker 03

  obscurity of this, but in a campaign biography, when he announces his run, one of his friends writes that, you know, he's this self-taught reader who loves the works of Plutarch and Lincoln reads this and, and he has to admit that he's never read Plutarch. So instead of having them correct the, the campaign biography, he goes and he gets the editions of Plutarch.

• 34:16Arthur Brooks?

  He reads Plutarch.

• 34:17Speaker 03

  Which he reads and then he says, not only have I now literally read them, but, but I am a fan and has changed my life. And so, you know, he, I, my favorite scene of Lincoln, and I'm nerding out here. But but he becomes president and then the civil war breaks out. And so he calls to the Library of Congress to have them send him every book on war that they can find. Because he has to, um, he has to figure it out. He was self taught, not just as a kid, but he was this lifelong learner. Which I think is is what the idea, the virtue of wisdom is really about.

• 34:50Arthur Brooks?

  And no doubt, an imperfect man. I mean, a lot of the biographies about, you know, Joshua Wolfshank's book on his suffering, et cetera, et cetera. Talking about the imperfections, but but he did follow these three basic Stoic maxims of manage yourself. See suffering as an opportunity and choose virtue over comfort. Specifically fortitude, prudence, just in a justice and wisdom, which he hippified, which would made him arguably the greatest president in the history of the United States. One might say it was his, I guess, Stoic tendencies. If he wasn't a Stoic that actually made him who he was.

• 35:23Speaker 03

  Yeah, and look, Lincoln wouldn't have been Lincoln without the fiery trial of the Civil War. Right? Like, uh, he would have almost certainly wanted to have been president in any other time. And perhaps he would have been a mediocre president if that were the case. He was certainly underwhelming as a congressman. He needed the moment and the moment needed him, which is, I think, something that's uniquely true about great leaders. And, you know, Marcus Aurelius, 20 years of peace and prosperity, uh, Hadrian and then Antoninus. And then basically Marcus becomes emperor and and it's one disaster after another. All external things, nothing he caused, but there's a famine, which leads to a plague. Well, there's a flood, which leads to a famine, which leads to a plague, which leads to a civil war.

• 36:08Speaker 03

  And so without these disasters, you know, perhaps he's a much more philosophical king. But he has to be philosophical in another sense, right? And he has to guide the country through one disaster after another. So you would rather it go a way different than it did, but nobody asked, right? You didn't get a choice. And I think Stoicism is the decision to make the make what you can of the hand you've been dealt.

• 36:36Arthur Brooks?

  That's interesting. That's a good summary of exactly the three points that you made earlier. Why is that? It's weird, you know, one of the things that I teach my students is the most shocking thing about happiness is that Mother Nature doesn't care if you're happy. Mother Nature really only wants you to survive and pass on your genes. And, and, and so you're going to live, you're going to sit on the couch in a comfy blanket, eating Haagen Dazs and watching Netflix as opposed to going down to the gym, left to your devices, because Mother Nature wants you to feel more comfortable at this particular moment, but it's the wrong thing to do. And it seems to me that this maxim of Mother Nature not caring about your happiness lies behind a lot of the truths of Stoicism and why Stoicism is so hard, right? And yet, it's so unbelievably beguiling.

• 37:21Arthur Brooks?

  You've sold 10 million books about Stoicism, which is a philosophy that says, suck it up, buttercup.

• 37:28Speaker 03

  You know, it's, it's funny, I was, I was just giving a talk about Stoicism and happiness. And I was, I was saying that, you know, riffing on that line of, about Sisyphus, that I was, I was sort of going through all the things that went wrong for Marcus Aurelius, right? All the disasters we just talked about, plus he buries six children. His wife may have been repeatedly unfaithful. He has health issues. It's, it's, it is not a, a good go of it. And I said, and yet, if we are to, to understand what Stoicism is about, I think we should imagine Marcus Aurelius happy. Now, not happy because everything was going the way that he wanted it to go, and because

• 38:11Speaker 03

  it was fun and nice and peaceful all the time. It's that the idea for the Stoics was, can you be happy even in all of this, right? I think Cicero talked about, you know, the real test of happiness was, could you be happy while you're being tortured to death on the rack, right? Like, the idea, if happiness was, was only the result of all of your conditions and preferences being met, it was going to be a particularly fragile thing. Now, if happiness is something that you can get despite all of those things, it might be something worthwhile. And so I, I think there's a line in Meditations where Marcus Aurelius says, convince yourself

• 38:55Speaker 03

  that all of this is a gift from the gods, and that things are good, and they always will be. And I think that word convince your, that phrase convince yourself is, in a sense, the definition of Stoic philosophy, right? He's saying that your job here is to not despair, to not take it personally, to not give up, to not quit, but to do the very real mental and spiritual work that allows you to find something to be grateful for, even in the midst of a plague, even in the midst of a political disaster, even in the midst of a funeral for someone that you love.

• 39:40Speaker 03

  Can you do the work to find the gratitude and the satisfaction and the meaning? It's easy to be grateful when you're looking out over your healthy children in your mansion. It's easy to think that the world is wonderful as you're staring out over the Grand Canyon. It's harder to do it when the Spirit Airlines flight you're on is six hours delayed, or you have a terrible case of food poisoning, or you just got terrible news from the doctor. But to me, the real work of Stoic philosophy is finding a way to feel happy and grateful

• 40:22Speaker 03

  and content and peaceful in a world that's very much not necessarily conducive to those things.

• 40:28Arthur Brooks?

  Right, and this is entirely consistent with the proper definition of happiness. The misunderstanding of happiness is that it's a feeling, it's the feeling you get when you're doing the things that you enjoy. You can't put it into words, but you know it when you feel it. And that's wrong, because feelings are, at best, evidence of happiness, like the smell of the turkey is evidence of your Thanksgiving dinner. Happiness, as we understand it in the world of behavioral science, is a combination of enjoyment, satisfaction, and meaning. And there's a lot of suffering in going from pleasure to enjoyment and deferring your gratification so you can experience true satisfaction. And most importantly, finding the meaning of your life, that's full of suffering. That's just absolutely full of suffering. And so the proper definition of happiness is inherently stoic, right?

• 41:12Speaker 03

  Yes, and that also that happiness is work, right? That happiness isn't getting all the things you want handed to you, but that it's actually work that you have to do. Mental, spiritual work to orient yourself right, to understand what's happening right. That, yeah, if it was just a feeling that creeped in, what would it really be worth?

• 41:37Arthur Brooks?

  Right, right, exactly. It's feelings are largely unearned because they're a product of the limbic system. And what I teach my MBA students at Harvard is the most important thing that I teach them is emotional self-management through the process of metacognition, which is choosing to manage yourself with your prefrontal cortex as opposed to be managed by your limbic system, which is your emotional console. And there are all kinds of techniques for doing that, but they all talk about bearing up under unpleasant feelings through understanding, through self-management, through convincing yourself, like you just said, using everything from Vipassana meditation to journaling to prayers of petition. But one way or another, it's such that you're managing your feelings and they're not managing you.

• 42:22Arthur Brooks?

  I mean, that's fundamentally a stoic exercise, isn't it?

• 42:24Speaker 03

  No, that's the definition of Stoicism. I think people think that, and that's because of what the word stoic means, they think stoic means has no emotions, right? I think Stoicism is having the emotion and then not being ruled by it. So there's so many things that piss me off, but do I try to go through my life in a state of being pissed off, right? There's things that I'm afraid of, but I try to go through my life not ruled by fear. There's things that I desire, there's things that I yearn for, there's ambitions that I have, but I try to make sure that I...

• 43:04Speaker 03

  I have those things as opposed to those things have me, right? I have a career. My career does not have me. And so what is that kind of line between feeling the emotion, feeling the pull, feeling the attraction, whatever it is? And then to me, the Stoicism is the process of processing them. There's a, there was a Stoic named Athenodorus, who was the advisor to Octavian, the one who put Cicero to death. And he said, you know, before, he writes in this, this essay that, you know, before you do anything, you should count all 24 letters of the alphabet.

• 43:45Speaker 03

  Now, there, there was two fewer letters in the ancient Latin alphabet than we have today. But his point was, you have the feeling, you're upset, somebody did something, somebody said something, you want to do something. And then, you know, can you pause? And to me, Stoicism is that pause and reflection before the action.

• 44:05Arthur Brooks?

  That's metacognition, right there. That's what that is. That's exactly what we're talking about.

• 44:10Speaker 03

  So that might appear to someone who doesn't know you very well as not having had the emotion at all, right? But, but the idea that Seneca, the playwright, didn't have pangs of jealousy when he saw some other playwright succeed, or that it didn't hurt his feelings when a critic said something negative about him, or that he, that he didn't feel sad when he, you know, lost somebody he loved. That, of course, he's a human being. He actually says, no amount of philosophy takes away natural feeling. But you can train yourself to not go around, you know, acting impulsively, right? And I think that, that's the difference.

• 44:53Arthur Brooks?

  And to govern yourself and not be governed by, by these negative. Or, or by the way, the real Stoic master also is not governed by his positive feelings.

• 45:02Speaker 03

  Yes, yes.

• 45:02Arthur Brooks?

  Which is really important. I mean, of course, we'd like to overlook that. I just want to govern my negative feelings, but I don't want to let my positive feelings in a range and roam freely. And you don't get that.

• 45:13Speaker 03

  No, to me, it's the even keel, right? That's where we're trying to get to. Some kind of center.

• 45:18Arthur Brooks?

  Some sort of a center while we're still experiencing the emotions, because that's part of human life. Tell me, as you're traveling around the country a lot, you're talking to college students, so am I. What are the protocols of modern Stoicism that you're advising for young people today? What should they start doing today to live in a more Stoic fashion?

• 45:36Speaker 03

  Well, I think Stoicism is inseparable as a practice from journaling, right? Much of the work we have from Marcus Aurelius is him writing to himself. So it is this process of self-examination. And Seneca called this the evening review. He said he'd wait for his wife to go to sleep, and he would sit down and he would put himself up for a review. He said, "I would let nothing pass by." You know, he'd look at what he did well, what he could have done better, and he'd write this down. And so I think the process of thinking about what you think, thinking about yourself, is not just philosophical, but it's also deeply calming and reassuring. And it cultivates a kind of self-awareness

• 46:19Speaker 03

  and self-knowledge that I think is inseparable from enlightenment and wisdom. It's the main thing I would give people. I think I give a bunch more practical ones. I think, look, there's a reason Marcus Aurelius is talking about waking up early. He's talking about starting the day off in charge, doing something that you don't want to do, right? And building a practice where you go, "Hey, I'm a person who does hard things. I decide what my day is built around. I am asserting that I don't think my job is to lay here under the covers and be warm." Right? So the Stoics have all sorts of adversity that they seek out, they cultivate. There's a physical practice to Stoicism

• 47:02Speaker 03

  that I think is a big part of it.

• 47:07Speaker 03

  So, and look, I think for a lot of young men, this is why it is a more attractive philosophy than some of the more ethereal or cerebral forms of philosophy. It's like Stoicism is a thing you do, right? Not a thing you read about and then debate in salons.

• 47:25Arthur Brooks?

  It's a practice. It's a set of practices. And we're working through those practices right now. So number one was... Manage your emotions by journaling. The second was discipline the will by getting up early. So now you've got your emotions under control and you've got your will bent to your, your, your, your goals as a person as opposed to roaming all over the place. What's the, what's the next thing that a young Stoic needs to do?

• 47:47Speaker 03

  Well, look, I, I think what I have loved about the Stoics is that, again, opposed to the Epicureans, is that they were involved, right? Involved in running the country, involved in their community, involved in public life. There was this component of justice. So I would say, what is your contribution to society? Where are you making the world a better place, right? And what is a practice or an activity that you regularly do that connects you with other people that leaves this place better than you found it? And that could be running for office on one end and it could be picking up trash, you know, that you see on the street. In Meditations of Marcus Aurelius, he says, you know, you want to have good fortune.

• 48:32Speaker 03

  He says, good fortune is good character, good intentions and good deeds. And so what, what are you doing that is contributing to this world that you, you might reasonably see as dark and dysfunctional? What are you doing to make it not that way?

• 48:50Arthur Brooks?

  Now, that of course is entirely consistent with the Jamesian, the William James philosophy of the I self versus the me self. When you act in a publicly virtuous way, you've transcended yourself laterally to other people in much the same way that when you, when you worship God, you transcend yourself vertically. And both work in much the same way with respect to how it improves you and improves your life. That's what leads to a good life well-lived is not focusing on yourself, right? Self-focus is lethal. And the best way for you to not focus on yourself is to focus on others and make their lives better. Is that the point?

• 49:26Speaker 03

  Yes, and then I think that pulls us back to the idea of happiness. There are many people much wealthier than you. There are many people much more accomplished than you, much more famous than you. And chances are, many of them are not happier than you. Conversely, though, there are people that have all sorts of jobs that seem exhausting and demoralizing, that are poorly paid. But those people take a lot of meaning and purpose from those professions because it feels like they are contributing to the world. Right? And those people are probably happier than you.

• 50:04Arthur Brooks?

  Oh, yeah.

• 50:05Speaker 03

  So what are the choices or decisions you're making as far as how you're orienting your life? Like, look, I said, I wrote two bestselling marketing books before I wrote this book about Stoic philosophy. The Obstacle is the Way could have sold 15 copies, and it would have been a profoundly important and meaningful thing to me. Part of the reason I didn't want to do those, I said, I don't want to do this for the rest of my life, just go around and tell people how they can sell more of their shit to other people. That's not lighting me up. That's not what I was actually put here to do. And what is the net positive contribution of that? It is very little.

• 50:50Speaker 03

  And so deciding to find something and to dedicate yourself to something that gives you meaning and purpose, that's where the happiness comes from.

• 50:59Arthur Brooks?

  The last area I want to ask you about, for the modern would-be Stoic, or somebody who's actually tending towards Stoicism, who's going toward the Stoic ideal, a young person today that you're talking to, that we're talking to right now. Tell me about device use in the Stoic mold.

• 51:14Speaker 03

  Anything that you have that has power over you is something the Stoics would look at suspiciously. Right? And so if the first thing that you do when you wake up in the morning is grab that device, that's a bad sign. And so to me, I don't think the Stoics would have been these Luddites who reject all technology, but they would try to set up boundaries and rules and habits that, you know, sort of are asserting who's in charge. So like, I have social media. It's a powerful tool for reaching my audience, but it's not something that I have direct

• 51:55Speaker 03

  access to. Right? It's not on my device. It's on a device at the office that we use, or it's on my wife's phone if I have to check a message or something. I'm not sleeping with my phone next to my bed. It's in the other room. Right? I read physical books, so I have a lot of time where I'm not staring at my screen. Right? So I think the Stoics would ask, you know, hey, do I have the phone or does the phone have me? We've been using that sort of that, that, that expression quite a bit, but I, to me, that's the test. Who's in charge here? Is it, is it Apple or is it me? Is it Twitter or is it me?

• 52:31Arthur Brooks?

  And, and by the way, the, the same principle applies as you would read the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius or anything by Epictetus. They don't write about the iPhone, but they do write about not being dominated by any other addictive substance or behavior because it's the same principle. Right? Do not be dominated by strong drink. You know, it's and the idea of gambling or alcohol use or drugs or in modern times, internet use or highly glycemic carbohydrates or pornography or anything that captures your brain and makes your life worse. That's the same principle as excessive device use. Right?

• 53:03Speaker 03

  I think that's right, and I do think what I think is powerful about the Stoics is this idea of temperance, right, or moderation. It's a tricky concept, but it's an important one. And to go to your point about drinking, often the image for the idea of temperance was a man watering down his wine, right? Wine was very strong in the ancient world. And so he's not refusing to partake, but he is diluting the strength of what he would ordinarily have partaken in. And so that's what I'm, I'm not walking around without a phone. Even people go, I have a flip phone. It's like, maybe that works for you, but I have a terrible sense of direction and I

• 53:47Speaker 03

  don't want to get lost all the time, right? Also, by having my phone, it allows me to do a little work here and there and not have to sit at my desk all day, right? I can take a walk and listen to music, or, you know, I can do my phone calls on the mo, I can do stuff. So I use it, but I try to make sure that I am using it and not the other way around.

• 54:10Arthur Brooks?

  That's great, that's great. What did the Stoics get wrong?

• 54:13Speaker 03

  Ooh, well, I do think they get all the things wrong that the ancients got wrong about, you know, sort of equal rights and equality and, you know, slavery and violence, you know? We are lucky that we don't live in the world of the Roman empires because unless you were the elite of the elites, it was an empire built on exploitation and force, right? It's good that we live in the modern world in that sense. So obviously, they didn't question most of those assumptions. Every once in a while, they did, but not always. I also think the Stoics, because this partly explains that, they were a bit more predeterministic than I think they needed to be, right?

• 54:57Speaker 03

  So this idea that some things are in your control and some things are not in your control. Okay, well, what do we decide is in our control or not in our control, right? So sure, slavery or colonialism, these are things that have existed for countless centuries. But then someone like Gandhi comes along, or Abraham Lincoln, or Martin Luther King comes along and says, Well, what if I did something about that? Right? Thomas Clarkson comes along and says, well, what if I change that? So, so I do think that the Stoics were often a bit too lowercase c conservative in the sense that they, they, they respected or venerated tradition

• 55:41Speaker 03

  that, that, that actually was in their control to change. And we would not want to live in a world where everyone accepted everything as outside of their control because, because what that neglects is our ability to come together collectively and solve complex problems. That's, that's what politics in its best form is about. That's what government should be, us solving difficult problems and making the world better for each of us to live in. So I, I think the Stoics get some of that wrong.

• 56:13Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. So in a way, you're saying that what Marcus Aurelius got wrong is he didn't live in 2025, which is hardly his fault.

• 56:19Speaker 03

  But, but also, uh, the way we got from, you know, 150 AD to 2025 was, you know, that famous line about, um, you know, the reasonable man adapts himself to the world. The, the unreasonable man adapts the world to himself. Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man. There, there is something a little delusional about one's belief in changing the world or making a dent in the universe that we need also. And, and I don't want people to think that the Stoics were that. And I, and look, I think we can square this circle pretty easily because the founding fathers are, are both the cautionary example and the inspiring example of this.

• 57:03Speaker 03

  All of them are steeped in Stoic philosophy. And what do they do? They create a new nation from nothing. And that is a politically revolutionary act. And so Stoicism is not incongruent with that. Although I did a daily Stoic email not that long ago about this letter where, um, where George Washington, for instance, this goes to my point, George Washington is going like, you know, I really hope someone does something about this slavery thing, you know? And, and it's like, It's like, there was not a better person on earth than you in this moment to do something about that. And so, you know, I think his lowercase c conservatism, the conservatism of Cato,

• 57:43Speaker 03

  which he very much admired, held him back from imagining a world where certain conditions could be changed. And that he could be the one to do it.

• 57:52Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, and it's this entirely human, entirely human thing.

• 57:57Arthur Brooks?

  As we go forward through history, we find all kinds of people that did not talk about the Stoics, but we, but, but, but use Stoic philosophy in very meaningful ways. And one of them is somebody I mentioned before, which was Thomas Aquinas, the greatest of the, of the medieval theology. He was an Aristotelian, originally sort of a Neoplatonist, but, but, but introduced Aristotle's ideas to what were then modern audiences. And he's the reason we read Aristotle today and indirectly why we read a lot of Cicero today and indirectly why we know a lot of Stoicism today was vis a vis Aquinas. And Aquinas in the Summa Theologiae, he had this really interesting and very, very Stoic point, where he said that, that, that all people are beguiled by idols.

• 58:41Arthur Brooks?

  And these idols govern them, what they really want is God, but God is inconvenient. A lot of one-sided conversations and inconvenient rules. And so they go for things that seem like they have divine characteristics. Now, this is a lot like what the Stoics talk about. I mean, staying under the covers in early in the morning, it feels like it has divine characteristics, but it's just comfort, not virtue. This is Marcus's point. And he says that all, and this is a very strong behavioral science point, that, very sound point, that Thomas Aquinas makes, that there's only four kinds of idols and each of us falls prey to one more than the others. And the four idols are money, power, pleasure, and honor.

• 59:21Arthur Brooks?

  Those are the things we fall prey to. There are other things that beguile us because they capture our brain chemistry. But those are the big idols that he talks about. And when you know what your specific idol is, then you can become self-governing in a way that will set you free. And so I have a game I play with my MBAs called What's My Idol? To figure out which of those beguiles them the most so they can pay attention to it and not do the things that they will ultimately regret. Do you want to play?

• 59:47Speaker 00

  At REI Co-op, we don't just sell outdoor gifts. We use them, test them, trust them. So we know what to give this season. For joy rides, campfire cheers, and peak views. We know what to give the people you love who love to get out there. Because we're out there too. Just stop in and ask a green vest, like me. For the best gifts out there. Shop in-store or at REI.com.

• 1:00:18Speaker 01

  This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.

• 1:00:47Speaker 03

  I do, I do. And I think this is also where we have some advantages over the ancients, which is, you know, modern psychology and psychiatry gives us the ability to go, okay, what about my childhood? What about that I was taught is going to predispose me towards one direction or another, right? Basically, what did I make up as a kid is more important than it actually is.

• 1:01:11Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, yeah, that's right. So this is the second time I've done this on this kind of new show. It's your the second. The first was Rainn Wilson. So, yeah, I know he's, that was a great episode. So the four idols, and this is an exhaustive list, according to Thomas Aquinas, but very, very sound, according to modern behavioral science as well. The thing that will throw you off your game, that will make you not pay attention to your loved ones, it'll make you cut ethical corners, it'll make you do things that you ultimately become non-self-governing and thus regretful are, because they're comfortable, are money, power, pleasure, and honor, which, and, and, you know, money just means resources. Power means, it doesn't mean tyranny, it just means persuasion and the ability to have sway,

• 1:01:55Arthur Brooks?

  and which can be used for great good, obviously. Pleasure means feeling good, but also it means comfort or security. So if you're checking your stock portfolio every day, you're a pleasure freak, is what that would be. That's your idol. And then fame probably doesn't mean internet famous for most people. It means being respected and admired by the right people, maybe lots of people, or as prestige or whatever happens to be. So the way to play the game in good social science fashion is to eliminate the idols you don't have, Ryan. So the ones that you really, really don't care about, because, you know, we're, we're so funny. We're prideful about things that we're not prideful about. You know, it's a, you know, I'm so proud of this, that I don't have this, you know, idol. It's, so, so you gotta get rid of one.

• 1:02:39Arthur Brooks?

  Which one do you get rid of first? Money, power, pleasure? And that doesn't mean that you don't have it. It just means that you're the population mean.

• 1:02:46Speaker 03

  No, no, my, my, my main one is definitely not pleasure. That's not what lights, lights me up.

• 1:02:51Arthur Brooks?

  But I know that you know this because you're, you're, you're not an ascetic, but you're, you could live with some austerity in your life, right?

• 1:02:58Speaker 03

  Yeah, and, and I, I could probably eliminate, uh, power too. I'm, I'm more of an introvert solo figure. What I, I don't, that, that's not what I want. I'm not, I'm not pining for, for office or, uh, influence in, in that sense.

• 1:03:15Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, and probably I would guess, because you just eliminated power. You hate it when people have power over you, right?

• 1:03:21Speaker 03

  Definitely, yes.

• 1:03:22Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, every, see, here's the thing. People admire those who have the idol that they hold. Those who have a lot of the idol that they crave after, that they hanker for. So if you see that, that would be dictators love dictators. They admire dictators. You know, would be, you know, money freaks. They love billionaires is what it comes down to. You can tell somebody's idol by what they admire, right? And if you really, really, if you're just having aversion to really powerful people, it means power's not your idol, almost always.

• 1:03:53Speaker 03

  Well, don't you see this as an author? Uh, you meet, uh, a lot of very, very rich and successful people. And they're just like in love with what you do because they, they love books. But they also notice that, that people perceive people with creative, uh, chops or, uh, an audience or have done that hard thing. They notice that it's perceived differently or that it bats, I think, above its, uh, it's, it's class than just say, you know, having a gazillion dollars.

• 1:04:25Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah.

• 1:04:25Speaker 03

  I've noticed that it's, it's what, it's like, what do, what do, um, uh, rich people do as soon as they've made a lot of money is they pay someone to write a book for them?

• 1:04:33Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. And, you know, when, every time a, a big time CEO retires, he allows himself to be persuaded that he needs to write a book on leadership.

• 1:04:41Speaker 03

  Yes, exactly.

• 1:04:42Arthur Brooks?

  And, and I got news for you. You don't need to do that and the world is better if you don't. And you'll be a lot happier and your marriage will be better if you don't do that.

• 1:04:50Speaker 03

  When I sometimes see those people, I go like, I know why I'm here. I'm, I'm getting paid to be here. This is my job. You have a gazillion dollars and you had to come to this dumb conference because you are coveting the other, you're coveting the other thing.

• 1:05:04Arthur Brooks?

  Interesting. Okay, so we're down to, we're down to money and honor. And you got to get rid of one, but it's hot in here now because you like both, obviously, or you wouldn't, you would have eliminated them. Which is, which one do you get rid of next? Even though you like them both?

• 1:05:17Speaker 03

  I probably like money more than I like, I'd like to. Like, I wish it was less important to me. I very much admire people when I hear someone just, I just interviewed this, this guy that had turned down a $17 million MBA contract. And I thought, wow, I can't imagine doing that, you know? So I, I admire it because it seems very foreign to me, but, uh, but that's not my main thing. I mean, I wouldn't be writing books about philosophy if money was the main thing.

• 1:05:43Arthur Brooks?

  Right. And so we know that that honor will be, it's not dominating your life, but if you want to be living up to Stoic principles, that's the one to be paying attention to because that's the one that's most likely to govern you in your weak moments. That's the whole point. Right? And that's the one that will make you make decisions and say things that shouldn't have said that. I wanted the approval of people or something, right?

• 1:06:05Speaker 03

  Yeah, it's what did my parents value? What did, what did the 17 year old version of you think was the coolest thing in the world, you know? And, and I think about like, I love my parents, obviously, but when I go see them, they, they tell me about like the fancy important people that they met or bumped into or that lives down the road. And I go, oh, it probably is not a surprise that I sought out some career that would mean distinction. I didn't pick an anonymous, you know, quiet life. I went for something that would be the kind of thing that my parents would tell other people about.

• 1:06:43Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. And your mother is over the back fence to the neighbor right now. You know, you know, Ryan has a new book coming out. You know, Ryan's last book sold a million copies and they're like, I know, we know, we know.

• 1:06:55Speaker 03

  Yes, yes. Although they, they did not necessarily have the, see this all coming. I think it was a surprise. So there was a, there was a dip, right? And this actually goes to the point, right? There was the dip because having the kid who dropped out of college to, you know, do whatever, seemed like it was heading in the opposite of that direction, right? And so that probably motivated me on some deeper level also to go like, well, now I really got to prove it. So I think about this a lot.

• 1:07:22Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, yeah, me too. And it's great. That means you're thinking about your idol and, and that means you dominated and you can live in a more Stoic fashion and live a better life as a result, which is great. Let me sum up the, the four lessons for our listeners on how they can be more Stoic. Now, again, you're not going to be a Stoic. What you're going to do is you're trying to be more Stoic. Right? That's the, that's the important point because Stoicism is an ideal, not a state. Right? Okay. So here are the four things to do. Number one, manage your emotions. Best way to do that is journaling. Check?

• 1:07:53Speaker 03

  Yes.

• 1:07:54Arthur Brooks?

  Number two, discipline the will. Good way to do that is by winning the day by getting up before dawn.

• 1:08:01Speaker 03

  Yep. Treat the body rigorously, Seneca says, so it's not disobedient to the mind.

• 1:08:05Arthur Brooks?

  Great. Number three, lower your self-focus. Do that by serving others.

• 1:08:13Speaker 03

  It's the we, not the me.

• 1:08:15Arthur Brooks?

  And last but not least, extinguish your addictions, and that will probably start with your devices.

• 1:08:21Speaker 03

  I think that's right.

• 1:08:22Arthur Brooks?

  You do those four things, well, you still need to get to books. And the new book is Wisdom Takes Work. So sum that up for us.

• 1:08:29Speaker 03

  It's the fourth and the most essential of the cardinal virtues, because it's the one that informs all of the others. So it's not a book of wisdom, because to write one would be preposterous. It is a book about the methodology by which one becomes wiser, to go to the way you expressed it earlier. No one is wise, but you can become wiser than you were. That's what the book's about.

• 1:08:55Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah. All of these things are tied together. You can't be happy. You can only be happier than you were. And all of these things are ideals that you would actually approach. You'll never be a stoic. You'll just be closer to the stoic ideal. And I think that's an important way to live our lives, because life is a journey. And that journey should be an incredible adventure in making improvements in our own lives, lifting other people up and bringing them together. And in so doing, finding the best person that we can possibly be. I'm really grateful to you for the work that you're doing, because I read it and I feel like I'm a better person as a result.

• 1:09:27Speaker 03

  Well, I would say the exact same thing about your work, and it's been wonderful getting to know you.

• 1:09:33Arthur Brooks?

  Thanks. I can't wait to see you in Bastrop, Texas, a beautiful place.

• 1:09:36Speaker 03

  Yeah, in like a couple of months, right? I think you're here in December or something.

• 1:09:39Arthur Brooks?

  Yeah, I'm gonna come on your show. Can't wait.

• 1:09:40Speaker 03

  We'll do it again. All right.

• 1:09:42Arthur Brooks?

  Thanks, Ryan.

• 1:09:53Speaker 01

  This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground, or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why State Farm takes the time to get to know you so they can help personalize coverage for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there.

• 1:10:22Speaker 04

  Whenever fall comes back around, it always feels like a fresh start. This year, I've been layering in some styles from the new Lululemon Fall Drop because the weather is shifting and I find I have to be ready for the entire day and not just one part of it. Lululemon's Fall line has some really versatile transitional pieces so I can just wake up, throw on a matching set, add a jacket or a fleece, and head out, knowing that I'll feel comfortable enough to go wherever the day takes me. Check out the new fall arrivals in store and online now at lululemon.com.