Skip to content

Ep. 923: Wild Horse (Mis)Management, Dr. Randall Hunts Austria, and Fishing as a Constitutional Right

The MeatEater Podcast

Hosted by Steven Rinella

1h 56m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode covers an eclectic mix of outdoor news, hunting tales, and conservation policy updates. The guest recounts a cultural immersion trip hunting roe deer and chamois in Austria, detailing how European estates manage wildlife alongside forestry and market meat processing. The hosts also discuss the record-breaking auction of a vintage punt gun that raised over one hundred thousand dollars for land access, review proposed rollbacks to the federal roadless rule on public forest lands, and break down a landmark North Carolina lawsuit linking constitutional hunting rights to fisheries management. Finally, the team explores local regulations and public concerns regarding the growing popularity of drone-assisted shark fishing.

  • Austrian hunting quotas are strictly tied to private land ownership and professional forestry management, where game meat is processed and sold directly to the public through local butcher shops and vending machines. 15:45
  • The MeatEater team sold their restored 140-year-old punt gun at a Rock Island Auction for $117,500, setting a new world record and donating the proceeds to the land access initiative. 42:41
  • Voters in Colorado should look for Amendment 84 on their November ballots to officially codify the constitutional right to hunt and fish in the state. 1:37:01
  • A successful six-year lawsuit in North Carolina used the state constitutional right to hunt and fish to prove that state-managed fisheries failed viability standards due to poor commercial bycatch regulations. 1:39:04
  • Several states including New Jersey, Texas, and Hawaii have explicitly banned the use of drones to take or assist in the taking of wildlife, such as dropping shark baits. 1:51:44

Chapters

  1. 0:35
    Host Introduction and Episode Teaser

    Steven Rinella introduces the episode’s themes and previews upcoming segments.

  2. 2:00
    Wild Horse Management Overview

    The hosts discuss the wild horse situation in the American West and government responses.

  3. 2:32
    Pre‑Sale Ticket Confusion for Live Tour

    A humorous exchange explains the confusing pre‑pre‑sale ticket system for the MeatEater Live tour.

  4. 11:03
    Randall Hunts in Austria – Roe Deer and Chamois

    Randall recounts his nine‑day hunting trip in Austria, detailing roe deer and chamois hunting.

  5. 12:30
    Wild Game Processing and Market Practices

    They describe how hunted game is processed, sold, and used for food in Austria.

  6. 15:50
    Cultural Immersion: Guns, Beer, and Tailgates

    The hosts share experiences with traditional Austrian firearms, beer culture, and upcoming tailgate events.

  7. 48:00
    Wild Horse Management Debate

    The hosts discuss the shortcomings of the Wild Horse and Burrows Act and the loopholes that allow wild horses to be sent to slaughter.

  8. 1:04:00
    Colorado Amendment 84 and Hunting Rights

    The hosts cover the Colorado ballot initiative to codify the right to hunt and fish, the signature‑gathering process, and the broader national context of hunting rights legislation.

  9. 1:08:00
    North Carolina Fishing Rights Litigation

    The conversation turns to a lawsuit in North Carolina that used constitutional hunting and fishing rights to challenge the state’s failure to protect coastal fisheries.

  10. 1:16:25
    Legal Loophole and Government Actions

    The conversation turns to the legal loophole that lets the government sell protected wild horses cheaply and the political implications of this practice.

  11. 1:21:53
    Roadless Rule and Public Comment

    The hosts explain the history of the Roadless Rule, the recent proposal to roll it back, and the public comment process that overwhelmingly supports keeping the rule.

  12. 1:32:34
    Boundary Waters Mining Controversy

    The discussion shifts to the Minnesota executive order that blocks mining in the Boundary Waters and the broader debate over mineral withdrawals and state‑federal cooperation.

  13. 1:42:11
    Intro and Ad Reads

    The episode opens with brief introductions and a series of ad reads covering various products and services.

Highlights

  • 11:07

    Hunting Roe Deer in Austriastory

    The guest describes hunting roe deer in Austria during their mid-summer rut, using stand calling techniques similar to coyote hunting while navigating dense forest tower blinds.

  • 24:29

    Vending Machine Wild Game Meatstory

    The guest shares an amusing anecdote about purchasing wild game sausage and steaks from an automated vending machine outside an Austrian butcher shop using the company business card.

  • 41:52

    Punt Gun Auction World Recorddata

    The team announces that their antique punt gun sold at a Rock Island Auction for a record-breaking $117,500, with all proceeds benefiting the land access initiative.

  • 53:05

    Grammatical Debate on Learning Curvesinsight

    Reviewing a listener letter from writer Peter Bodo, the hosts discuss the counterintuitive linguistic rule that something easy to learn has a steep learning curve.

  • 58:55

    Finding a Lost Trail Camera via GPSstrategy

    A listener correction reveals that lost trail cameras can easily be located by checking the device info and GPS latitude and longitude coordinates within the mobile app.

  • 1:07:07

    Wild Horse Overpopulation Crisisinsight

    The host argues that the 1971 Wild Free Roaming Horses and Burros Act created an unsustainable population crisis, suggesting that restricting slaughter creates severe ecological damage to public rangelands.

  • 1:21:53

    Roadless Rule Rescission Debatedebate

    The team discusses the USDA's proposed rollback of the roadless rule across 44 million acres of national forest, debating the tension between active wildfire management and conservation.

  • 1:39:30

    Legal Rights in Fisheries Managementinsight

    The host explains how North Carolina anglers successfully sued the state by arguing that degraded coastal fisheries violated their constitutional right to harvest wildlife.

Quotes

  • “The wild horse situation is out of control in the American West.”
    Steven Rinella · 2:00
  • “I think it's definitely a two parter. Garrett this morning said maybe it's a two hour thing.”
    Unnamed speaker · 33:11
  • “I think it's going to end with a restructuring of the the commission. And just like, sorry, this is the new way we're going to try it. That's what I imagine.”
    Steven Rinella · 1:47:13
  • “In the last decade, drone fishing for sharks has become very popular on summer nights.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:53:05
  • “The last known attack in the area was May 2023. So these concerns of luring sharks closer to the shoreline are just out of precaution.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:55:33
  • Grainger 0:00–0:25
  • OnDeck 26:01–26:17
  • Lincoln 26:29–26:40
  • Tailgate Tour 39:02–39:10
  • OnDeck 49:13–49:51
  • Lincoln 49:52–50:30
  • OnDeck 1:20:03–1:20:33
  • Lincoln 1:20:34–1:21:12
  • OnDeck 1:40:05–1:40:35
  • Bet365 2:04:12–2:04:45
  • Boost Mobile 2:04:55–2:05:14
  • OxiClean 2:05:21–2:05:42

About this episode

Steven Rinella and the MeatEater Crew discuss: Fishing with drones; hunting in Austria; Tim Walz: scourge of miners; constitutional rights to hunt and fish; roadless rule; and more! Presented by Can-Am: maker of the best ATVs, SxS, and Utility Vehicles www.can-am.brp.com http://www.can-am.brp.com Connect with Steve https://www.themeateater.com/authors/steven-rinella and The MeatEater Podcast Network https://www.youtube.com/@MeatEaterPodcastNetwork Steve on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/stevenrinella and Twitter https://twitter.com/stevenrinella?lang=en MeatEater on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/meateater, Facebook https://www.facebook.com/StevenRinellaMeatEater/, Twitter https://twitter.com/MeatEaterTV?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor, and YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@MeatEaterPodcastNetwork See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
1:56:32

22,300 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • North Carolina
  • Roadless Rule
  • Colorado
  • Boundary Waters
  • 911 Nashville
  • New York Times
  • Amendment 84
  • Celtic Bank
  • National Academy of Science
  • USDA

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated